Meeting will now come to order. First, let's do roll call, so I'll start. Nadav Dahim, Chair of the Commission, present. Gerard Ponacook, Chair of the Grants Committee, present. Colin Doughery, Commissioner, present. Paige Sharp, City Staff, present. Austin Wall, Commissioner, present. Rob Shakespeare, Commissioner and part of the Public Arts Commission. Subcommittee. Sorry. Rebecca Keough, Chair of the Public Art Subcommittee, present. Gretchen Nall, Public Art Subcommittee, Commission Member, present. Betsy Stewart, Public Art Committee, present. Lynn Hooker, Commissioner, present. White Lawson, Commissioner, present. Christina Elam, City Staff, present. Okay, thank you everyone. So today I'm going to actually be moving our agenda item for public comment to the start of the meeting just so that we can get through that. So just a few notes about that. We only have 15 minutes dedicated to this portion of the agenda just because we want to make sure we can get through the rest of the agenda tonight. And if anybody from the public wants to comment, you do have three minutes only. I will be using a timer just to help me keep track of that. So please be respectful of the three minutes. And once either I or hopefully the timer goes off, you just kind of stop your comment. If we are ready for that, please, is there anyone from the public that would like to comment? Yes. I asked her a time limit, and I was told that, or I wasn't given one, and I prepared about a five minute speech. I emailed a time limit. I apologize. I think that I missed it. I developed my speech for about five minutes, and I feel like getting cut off would not be great for anyone. Well, I mean, I'm not really sure in that case. Do you know if? I have a solution. I asked four questions at the end of my speech, And I would appreciate it if you would answer those in writing. That's my request, and I will not ask them out loud during the meeting. So I'll cut my speech down to three minutes. Yeah, let's sign, as long as you stick to the three minutes. Where should I stand and how should I speak? I think if we want to, I mean, you can either just stand right there, and I think that the mics will capture your own. Whenever you're ready, you can start. OK. My name is Katherine Fords-Rossman. There's a concept in psychology about small differences. The people who trouble us most are often the people we have the most in common with. You work alongside someone for a decade. You learn how capable they are. You know they know better. Then they choose a road you cannot go down. That road violated my moral code. I was watching people become comfortable dehumanizing Jews, my people. And I couldn't reconcile that with the values that I thought we shared. On September 30th, 2025, I made what may have been a very stupid decision. I checked my heart for malice. I wrote one respectful letter and hand delivered it politely and in person to Bloomington's Assistant Director of the Arts at City Hall, asking them to consider how they were using public authority. It was protected speech, a citizen petitioning their government. I didn't organize a campaign. I didn't call for anyone's dismissal. I never have. I didn't organize a campaign. At the time, my business was thriving. I was having my best year ever. Within days, texts began circulating calling me a monster. They called my photography homophobic racist trash. One reached a performer. In the middle of a shoot, I'd spent four months preparing for a documentary project that I had been working on for 18 months. I was crestfallen. Then my clients were contacted and some were harassed. Opportunities withdrew, work disappeared, and it felt like an avalanche. I've been digging out ever since. On September 6th, I filed a complaint. The city answered in writing and said that this was a personal matter between two individuals and offered me a meeting. I did not agree to that characterization and I said so. I handed a letter to a city official in City Hall about city business. That was a petition to my government, not a personal dispute. I asked to schedule the meeting. On October 14th, the city told me all further communication must go through legal and the meeting never happened. Here's what that meant to me. I disagreed with the city's description of what happened and in response, they withdrew their willingness to hear from me or offer any additional repair. I want to believe that wasn't the intent, but that was the effect. No acknowledgement, no correction, no accounting. My business closed and I'm still paying off the debt. People have told me to let it go. It's hard to give up on something while it's still happening to you. I understand the city may be worried about liability, but I have never asked for compensation. I've asked for repair and safeguards. I think that's a generous offer. Bloomington placed Arts Inside, Economic Development and Sustainability. That tells me artists are not- Just a minute, I'm sorry. I'm willing to make my speech available online. I'll put it on my website. It's KatherineKorsRossman.com. And also, I forgot to mention, before we began public comment, I just want to also say to everyone in the room, including commissioners, this is just for public comment. We are not discussing or debating anything. OK. Is there anyone else in the public that would like to share a comment? Sure. I have about maybe a minute or two. Okay. My name is Rob Bishay. I'm a photographer in town here. I've been here since 1979. I'm a veteran of the United States Army and several other organizations. I am the chief technology officer for a company here in Blompton. I've been here since 1979. That's 47 years, I believe. Been married for 47 years. I have kids. happy and I love this town and it's art. But here is the thing, we cannot as an art community have religion, sex, color, get in our way of life. That's not the way it is. Every single artist and every single individual that will express that artistic vision should be able to do that without fear of persecution or fear of being isolated because he or she have a point of view. I don't care what the point of view is. Whether it's a political religion or gender or whatever the case is, that should not happen. I lived in different culture and I traveled a lot, places in the world. I have never personally felt anything like this in any place. So this is just a general thing. It's not really a complaint. It's not an answering for Catherine. It's not anything else, more that we as people, as a community in Bloomington, Indiana, we need to take all this edge out. That should not have anything to do with what we do in daily life. That's it. Thank you. Do you want to do a comment or? I don't see anyone. OK. Someone? Yep. Please go for it. Go ahead. My name is Matt Hicks. I've only witnessed some of the issues that Catherine spoke to from the outside and just what I've seen on social media and that was reported through B Square Bulletin. And I would say I hope that you all take seriously the consideration that she proposes for at least some safeguards, because it seems only reasonable, at least in some small part, that there's future-looking, put some type of controls around in place to maybe prevent a reoccurrence of what happened. So I think it's just reasonable just to keep it on the mind and consider it do our best to keep emotions and maybe approach it from a rational standpoint. So that would be the only thing that I'd have to say. Thank you. Yes. Please go ahead. Can I read the rest of your letter? Oh, my goodness. What a gift. No acknowledgement, no correction, no accounting. My business closed. I'm still paying off its debt. People have told me to let it go. It's hard to give up on something while it's still happening to you. I understand the city may be worried about liability, but I've never asked for compensation. I've asked for repair and safeguards. I think that's a generous offer. Bloomington placed arts administration inside economic and sustainable development. That tells me artists aren't ornaments. We're workers, entrepreneurs, and small business owners. And the city's duty to that economy can't depend on whether its employees agree with our beliefs. I don't know why I'm nervous on your behalf. It's hard. It's so hard. It's very hard. Today I'm submitting an arts governance review, an evidence dossier, and a citizen drafted ordinance for the commission's review and referral. It would guard against ideological discrimination, retaliation, and interference with creative businesses while protecting political expression. I experienced the conflict as a sole proprietor, colliding with people who held substantially more institutional and cultural power than I did. I spent years photographing the city, promoting its artists, documenting its events. I was building something here. I had the city's back. Why didn't you have mine? I have four questions, the full text, is in the written word, in the written record, and I'm asking for a written answer to each. One, the chair of an arts commission grant committee was in a romantic relationship with the city's assistant director for the arts. That put all the city's arts funding in one household. What disclosure, recusal, and oversight applied? Two, What was said in the unprofessional Google Chat conversations tied to the termination of two city arts administrators. I'm not asking for personal details. I'm asking how they spoke about the artist they served. Three, how did my letter handle to a city official in City Hall reach third parties and become mischaracterized? Who handled it? And what records show it? When you don't know how you were attacked, you become a hypervigilant. That's why this matters. Four, Why was denying liability treated as enough with no acknowledgement, correction, or repair? Why was the meeting withdrawn? And what process addresses the harm that's still happening? I'm not asking to be rescued. I've spent this year rescuing myself. I'm committed to deescalating this and to depersonalizing this. This is about systems, not people. But I don't want to do the next part alone. I don't want to do the next part alone. I've lived in the city since I was a child. I've given it hundreds of volunteer hours. I'm offering my time to help draft responsible, reparative legislation with safeguards so the next artist who raises a concern is heard instead of burned. I'm hopeful that you'll meet with me and you'll bring me back into the fold in the computer. I'd never stop loving. Thank you. I apologize for that. I think we have some One trying to infiltrate the meeting. OK, we've had our 15 minutes. So unfortunately, we can't take any more public comment at this time. And we will move on with the yes. I feel like that's really inappropriate given what we're dealing with. I know you have an agenda to deal with, but I mean, look, we were just attacked. Yeah. Well, I mean, we set these rules from the start of the meeting. And all those people came here to speak. I totally understand, but we also have other things on the agenda and we can't just spend an hour. Right. So we've had this agenda scheduled and we have the things that we need to cover. Maybe if we have time at the end, we can return to public comment, but unfortunately right now we need to move on with the agenda. And I understand maybe that's not the answer you're looking for, but that's kind of what we have to do because we do have other things we have to address. I don't think you're addressing the most important thing, and I think that's going to cause harm. And that's totally fine for you. And I think someone else should be able to talk. Yes, I totally understand what you're saying, but we are going to have to move on with the agenda. I think you have the option to change the agenda. Yes, but there are also other things that we have to do it. It comes with consequences. And that's totally fine. And as the chair of this commission, I feel comfortable saying that I'm okay with moving on with the agenda because there are other things we have to cover. And feel free to come to other meetings to comment. You can share your opinions in other ways. I totally understand, but we are not going to be taking public comment any longer and we are going to move on with the agenda. So the next thing All right. We will be moving on. So the next thing on our agenda is approval and our correction of the minutes. So the secretary's draft of the minutes of the October meeting were sent to everyone at the commission and the copy is in your meeting packet. Are there any corrections to the minutes as distributed? Okay, so if there's no corrections, I move to approve the minutes as distributed. Can I get a second? Thank you. All in favor say yes. All those opposed say no. Okay, so the minutes are approved. So next thing on our agenda is from me. The only update I have is we have a new commissioner who's present here today, Wyatt Lawson. Please say welcome. And Wyatt, if you don't mind just sharing a quick introduction about yourself. Yeah, absolutely. Hello everyone. My name is Wyatt Lawson. New to Bloomington within the last two years. So I moved here two years ago and took a job at the Community Justice and Mediation Center. So that's what I do here in Bloomington. But I have a long history with the arts. I have a BFA in painting. My master's is in education. And I spent time at the Spoke Art Museum in Terre Haute working as their director of education and working amongst a lot of the arts organizations there. So I'm excited to do the same here in Bloomington. And I'm excited to be here. Thank you so much. We're happy to have you. So that's all I have on my. from me today, so next on the agenda we have staff reports, so you guys have a few things on there, so take it away. The first is just an update on the budget that we still have $141 remaining from all of the grant expenditures that we have made. We recently, which Gerard will talk a little bit more about in his section with regard to grants, granted out the arts operations support dollars and have completed the professional development training. and will actually request approval from the BOEA for use of their dollars for support of operation grants as well. So we are in good shape this year for all of the funding that we allocated to support grants for operations, project support, and artistic advancement, which is a pretty good investment, about $180,000. Any questions about the budget? sweet. So next I want to move on to the end of year party so every year we have our end of year holiday party and today well this year it'll be on December 9th so our next meeting will actually be will be the party and at this party we honor all of our grantees. So this year, we were able to disseminate over 100 grants through our grant program. So it'll be honoring all of our grantees, but also the things that we just did through the year through public art and other initiatives. And so it's just a great way to just reflect and celebrate. So this year would be at FAR. It was there last year. So it's going to be at FAR again this year off of South Rogers. And it'll be from 530 to 730. 537.38 at FAR on December 9th. You should have gotten your invitations. So remember to RSVP by December 2nd. Yeah. Also, the other thing I wanted to say, it was kind of also tied into the budget, but we did wrap up our professional development workshops. So they were much success. Andrea M. Sterling was the facilitator for all three. We covered topics such as, creating collaborative community burnout and conflict resolution. And so the one that was yesterday was around burnout. And so we had a consistent number of people come out each time and it was very successful. So I just wanted to relay that to you guys as well. So that's the update there. Okay, so Next is me looking at 2027. So let's talk about some of our priorities. And I know you've heard me talk about this one like 150,000 times because I'm all about public art policies and procedures. So to the uninitiated, I'm looking at you Wyatt, we have We're going to get a consultant to guide us and lead us through a public input process to develop policies and procedures for public art that would include what it means to deaccession, what's the process for deaccessioning, what's the process for accepting, who does what, role delineation. So everything is written and documented and we have something to refer to so that everybody's on the same page. And so that if I leave, then easily somebody has a resource document to refer to. And also that we are consistent, transparent, and fair across all processes. So that's what those kind of documents are really helpful for. And getting the public input to help us development is also really, really important. Another thing that I'm based upon some of the conversations that we have had, and particularly because The arts is in the economic development department. It makes sense to develop a city of Bloomington creative arts and economic development plan. Again, this would be an inclusive process where we get input from the community to help develop what's the directional that we want to go to. I want to get an outside consultant to facilitate that because that individual helped get the input and put it into actionables that is collectively informed from a number of people. So this continues to work through and address some of the things that we've been hearing and we've talked about, which is continuing to improve our processes so that they are more consistent and transparent. Anybody have any questions about either of those two priorities? How much does the consultant cost? This is not a two-way discussion. This is the commission discussion. Any questions on that? OK. From the commissioners, are there other priorities that you feel like the commission needs to concentrate on over the next year in 2027? I think you hit the highlights. Hit the highlights. OK. Any others? No? OK. All right, great. And then we want to talk about subcommittees. Yes. So with subcommittees, there has been more of a greater initiative from the city in general of re-evaluating subcommittees and boards and commissions. So this is just across the board. Mainly just because of the staff time it takes to keep a subcommittee going, and then just like legal involved and the things that we have to review. So it's just like, how can we make sure that we're intentional about subcommittees, how many we have, and then also thinking of other ways of like, maybe it's not a subcommittee, but it's maybe a working group. And working groups are more temporary and they have less people within them. And so every board and commission will be going through a review in the coming year and all their subcommittees will be evaluated if this is going to continue. And so we kind of wanted to open the discussion up here about our committees, because we have, too, the public art as well as the grants subcommittee. I don't know if you have? So one of the things I think about, I think because we have the commission tends to have some transition. People come off, people come stay for a little bit, and then we know some folks are leaving. So there's a lot of transition. And then that means that sometimes our subcommittees are really, really small. And those folks are making decisions that maybe would be, in my opinion, it's just me, better informed coming from the collective commission rather than to the small group. And that maybe tougher questions, like trying to figure out maybe changes in strategy, would be better informed by bringing other people from the community to join, like she said, the study group, like say grants, to really tackle some of the more difficult questions and then bring it back to the bigger BAC. But I would love to hear from you guys and what you think and how you'd like to continue with committee structure. And we can have that conversation now a little bit, and then we can also make decisions later It's certainly entirely up to you. We're just teeing off the conversation this evening. I have a question. How would that work for the Grants Committee, for instance? I know already we have so many grants that we have to review, and it's a pretty heavy load for the committee. I know it is, Gerard, and I know we've brought other people in. What's the best way forward for that particular committee since we have so much work to do? I'm giving this some thought and I don't want to have like a perfect solution mapped out, but I mean I think in a lot of ways dissolving the grants committee I think you know makes sense in a kind of in the ways that that that page outlines like I think there is you know I I really liked having the sort of the Most of the full commission involved in reviewing the grants just because of the amount of applications we received this year and how competitive the grant cycle was like pulling everyone in. I thought actually like made the process, you know, saw more collaborative and I think those, you know, those reviews and those decisions should be brought to the full commission. So that, in some ways, that helps lighten the load in that way. I think where it becomes complicated is in some of the thorny areas, like what are the guidelines for this coming year? How are we mapping out the cycles? How are we changing the applications and things like that? And that's a lot of deep thinking work that could be done by a committee, but I actually think that maybe having the flexibility of a task force or a working group or something like that to kind of take on those questions for the coming year and then present them, not to a committee, but to the full commission, I think that makes a certain amount of sense. But one of my concerns as chair is, yeah, there's a lot of work for the committee, a lot of work from the commissioners, but there is a lot of work for the chair, and I don't have a way of resolving that issue, because there is someone who still kind of needs to coordinate the reviews and sort of, you know, take in all the reviews and create a proposed funding package and that type of stuff. And that is still gonna have to be someone's responsibility. And probably not, I don't think it would be fair to put that to the full commission chair with all their responsibilities. So there will also need to be a grant's lead. I don't know what you would call that person, but someone doing that work. And that's, I haven't quite landed on that. But yeah, I think I'm open to, and hearing Christina's point about the sort of like the, from the city side of things, the staff work it takes to, you know, and abiding by open door policies and things like that, which are, you know, are all great, but it does create a lot of additional work for city staff and things like that, so. Yeah, I mean, I feel like I kind of, I agree with mostly everything Gerard was saying. That's also something I've been thinking about, especially for like, I feel like we do have meetings with like about public art or the grants is more like we are spending time outside of meetings to do a lot of the work. But in terms of like public art, I think everyone on the commission has something to offer in terms of opinion and experience. And just, I think I would definitely appreciate having that conversation in this kind of group instead of siloing and you know I think we still we do have a lot of overlap as well we have those conversations here so maybe we don't need to have them two times and I think yeah having like maybe a grants lead or liaison to the Commission or and like a public arts liaison or lead to the Commission we could still have that specialized role without the requirement of having to meet you know you know everyone's then having two meetings a month and potentially more when it's grant season and it can get to be a lot for a volunteer position and also the city has to be present and available making all these things and we want to do it right. So I think it really is important to think about do we really need those extra meetings as a like a standardized monthly thing or should it be we have our leads or liaisons and then we have task force or like specific times in which we're setting up meetings for things that do need to get done outside of a larger commission, general meetings. Gretchen, what do you think? I think public arts involving everyone is good. Yeah. It's not nearly as labor intensive as the grants, because that's so hours and hours and hours of work. But I think it's a good idea. I think part of the model that we're hearing from, I believe it was legal, that if there is a gathering of a few members of the commission, that whatever the summary of what that what occurred needs to be brought to the full commission so that in seeking transparency. I would argue for, call it what you like, but something to do with public art, to thrash through some of the details, particularly when we come to making calls and getting the information right, getting the template right, getting the strategy right for how to involve the public and not involve the public. Maybe in some cases pre-filtering depending upon what we're doing and then bringing that summary to the larger commission for discerning how to move forward. I think if we all are trying to put however many hands there are here into developing the call, developing strategies, then I think it could get awfully messy. That rather this task force or subcommittee, whatever it is, has the opportunity to do some of the nitty gritty work and then presented to the larger group. I appreciate the extra effort that goes on, particularly for grants. And I like the spirit in which most of us will volunteer to join that subcommittee to help so that every application gets a couple of eyes on it and nothing is just shuffling through for expediency. I really appreciate that process as it has Develop forward, but I think the public art Subcommittee I think it has a role, but that's you know obviously for us to discuss in a larger format I definitely want to give space for commissioners if they want to share something But I also want to be mindful of time and make sure we have enough time to cover our agenda items for public art and grants but I think a couple more minutes if Any folks have anything else to add? OK. I think we can move on then. So I think that's the end of agenda item for the staff report. Thank you, city staff. Next on our agenda, we have public art with Rebecca. Can you please share updates? Yeah, so we met last week, and essentially we just discuss the closing of the DBI initiatives so there was city staff did sort of like a in general what the programs were that the DBI did over the last three years I believe yes and concluded with the Uptown mural being one of the last ones I think though and there's still some outgoing What are they? The traffic boxes that we keep hearing about. Yes, those are still outgoing. But really, it was just a presentation that you put together, Christina, about the closing of that. And then the biggest thing that we sort of talked about was the rubric for the Gateway Project. That'll be upcoming and really just sort of wanting to solicit some support here or some advice here about what we need as far as panel goes for like the panel review. I think we discussed Initially about having seven on the panel. We discussed that as like a good number. Um, not maybe six, but seven was good. Um, and a lot of those being public art staff or public art, um, subcommittee members, um, with some city, if they needed, um, a one, maybe one parks and rec, uh, person as they can be involved or not involved. Um, and we just kind of wanted to open it up here to see if, what else any other commissioners thought about it. So I know you missed the meeting. So it's okay. No, it's okay. I think last year we reviewed like, I remember it doing over Thanksgiving. It was like a hundred different submissions. It was a lot. So I was, yeah, the convention center. So I think, I think a lot of eyes on That is good, personally. I mean, it is a ton of work. But whoever is willing to do it. I think the review time is four or five weeks, I think. And then I think part of the feedback from my recollection with the Public Art Committee was also consideration about this experience base that the reviewers bring to the table so that we have folks that are evaluating artwork that have experience evaluating artwork in terms of selection process. Inclusion of park staff is dependent because they're the key stakeholder. They're the one paying for it. So to make sure that they weigh in as they feel comfortable weighing in. So we will defer to that. I noted that I will be facilitating the process, but not in any way informing it. other than vetting out who is not eligible to really be considered because, for example, they're not in any of the states that were eligible. So we will vet all those and bring to the table what you all can review that makes sense. Be respectful of your time, of course. But I think the one thing that you guys wanted to know from the rest of the BAC is like, who would you recommend to be a part of this review team? Who would be really good that brings that skill set to the table that you feel really confident in? And I think you were looking for some suggestions from names. Am I, did I get that captured correctly? Okay, great. We weren't sure if we were thinking about bringing in outside community people into the Gateway Project. Certainly outside the BAC. Right, certainly outside the BAC. We were just sort of spitballing some ideas, but who else could make up that seven panel number? So the weeks that the review will be happening are? January 4th through February 4th. So that month, so January 4th to February 4th, okay. The deadline is December 4th, so it'll take us some time. Hopefully we will get a really good number of applications. Christina has done an absolutely stellar job getting the information out across the planet. So Coda Works has advertised it and she's personally emailed all the different arts councils that are in each of the eligible states, which is Indiana and the surrounding states. Many of them have responded to her. We've seen it in statewide newsletters already, certainly the Indian Arts Commission, Illinois Arts Commission, Ohio. So really appreciate our good friends at other state agencies sharing that out broadly. We're getting applications in, but not until December 4th. I hope that we have a big stockpile to plow through because this is a really exciting public art opportunity, I think, for the community and for whomever is selected. So does anybody have any, like, suggested ideas or names or folks that you think might be good to perhaps invite or think that would be helpful to be a part of that review team? to mine right now, but I definitely think it would be helpful to have community artists or members of the art community, particularly maybe ones who do this type of work or have done projects in the past similar to this or have supported art in Bloomington. I think that would be nice to just have their insight. But also, yeah, I feel like it could be anyone from the community, really, who feels strongly about the sign in the art piece that's going to go around it. Could we think about it? Of course, absolutely. Can we bring it up the next? Well, our next meeting is the party, so did the group email? Email, and you can totally use it. Can we send it to the whole group? Of course. However you want to communicate, I'm sure everybody, and now if they don't want you to email the whole group, I know these folks, and they will say, hey, don't email the whole group. Just email me. However, the most important thing is we get to a good review team. Everybody feels good about and comfortable with, and that this is going to put us in the right direction. Marinated, I'm sure some name will come to you in the shower. That's where all great epiphanies come from. So we'll be in good shape. So do we have currently, because if we're saying seven, so how many people do we already have potentially? Like how many more folks would we need to get on board? Well, I think we've got several of the public art committee members. But I also want to make sure that we get a good balance. put together like a list. How's that sound? And you guys can ferret out what you think a good finalist would be. Maybe we can put it to a little vote, a little online vote. We have time, and I think part of it is we don't know until the application deadline. I think it would be great to have some public art artists in addition to Rob that can be Part of that selection team say like Dale Enix, but who knows if he's going to apply or not I think he would be a really good solid candidate for it Any other thoughts on that so one person from parks and rec or a couple okay Because they they may not want to be a part of that first step portfolio review and they may want to leave it into other people's hands and they may want to just look at it as an advisory capacity. So for example, if we get down to the final five folks that we will invite, maybe a couple alternates, we'll make sure that we could have engineering review the portfolios of those individuals and make sure that they have the capacity for this type of project if it goes down. Parks may evaluate and say, no, I really am concerned about these folks. And that's why having a couple alternatives would be helpful as well. We may also elect to do interviews to ensure that they're collaborative if it didn't strongly come across in the application. So there's a few ways to splice it and dice it. It just depends on what Parks wants to do in terms of their involvement. But I certainly don't want to decide for them what they're going to be doing. I want to hear from them themselves. And they've been kind of one place at another place, but so we'll see. That was all I had for the public or public art. Can I reflect back on just this is going backwards, but where we're going to review subcommittees or task forces. Can I make a comment? Yeah. From the public art, subcommittee. We are also involved or have been asked to be involved with other committees in the city. I started off being part of the B, Bloomington Arts Entertainment. Betsy joined in to help with the Convention Center Art Initiative. You were part of a committee that had to do with the mural. You've had taken on the individual painting of the boxes. So we're involved in a lot of other things, too, not just showing up through our subcommittee meeting. So I just want to argue for more for that. There is the need, I think, for these specialized groups to then bring their resources back to the state. Sorry to jump in real quick. Sorry. I'm from the legal department. What were you talking about in terms of voting online for something? Did you bring that up? A poll? A poll in the committee, the BAC about selecting the review committee. Okay. That I would advise against doing online. That needs to occur in a public meeting. I would also advise sending communications to you to send out to the group, just so you can avoid accidentally doing a reply all situation. And now we've got a meeting that's in violation of the open door law. So that's my advice. Thank you. The public is leaving. One person is left. We just have a couple more things. Rebecca. So now we'll move on to Jordan for grants. Sure. I've got three things to address today. So one is sort of a an update on kind of where we are in our in our grant cycle. So I was not here at the October meeting. At that point in time the subcommittee was reviewing the operations grants which we had. Oh I think 24, 25. It was definitely one of our more competitive years for the operations grant cycle. The committee has since scored and reviewed those grants and developed a funding package. I think, I forget the exact amount, but I think we ended up funding about $50,000 in awards and... $55,000. Yeah. Yeah. A little bit different than what we did with the artistic advancement grants where we made a clear distinction to fully fund a select amount and not do partial funding. With the operations grant, we ultimately decided that it was more appropriate to offer partial funding to some organizations that And we didn't score as highly as some, so we created a tiered system in our review. People in the top tier got full funding, and then partial funding, and then slightly less partial funding. And so yeah, we put together that awards package, voted on it, and those letters have gone out, which has concluded at least the Boonton Art Commission's work on this year's, this grant cycle. And yeah, the second thing was, you know, I kind of did want to like do a little bit of a zoom out and just sort of like give a recap on the year. You know, we started the year with a very different makeup of the commissions. Since then, over the course of the year, we've had four new commissioners join. We've had new staff and staff liaisons join. We inherited what I thought was a pretty good process, but we put a lot of work into continuing to professionalize and evolve that process and despite all of you know all of those difficulties all of that transition we made it through one of our most competitive grant cycles that we've ever had and I think awarded not the most amount of funds that we've ever had but I think close to it so I want to you all a lot of gratitude for stepping in and and not just like letting the committee do that work but we you know we did that work as a commission and I really really appreciate you all stepping up and helping with that and I think we should feel really good about the work that we did this year so we can all celebrate next month so much work yeah and then the final thing I have it's a to make it a little bit more procedural. We do have a conflict of interest that we need to vote on and approve. So, and I think this is just for the grants committee currently, the way that this is gonna work. So this is just for the grants committee members to hear and vote on. And so to the grants subcommittee members, this is similar to what we had with the, I think one of our project grants. There is a city employee, Aubrey Cedar, works with Off Night Productions, which is a local theater group. And she is sort of the representative and grants writer of that group. And so she has disclosed this conflict of interest. And in that disclosure, she notes that, yeah, she is the representative of this group. She notes specifically that for this operations grant, she will not receive any compensation or any of the funds that are going. It's all going to the operations of Off Night Productions. and the artistic theatrical work that they do, that those materials have been sent to the commission and reviewed. So before we vote to approve this conflict of interest, I just wanted to see if there were any comments or concerns. Okay, great. Well, that being said, I am going to motion to vote to approve this conflict of interest. Can I get a second from a committee member? All right, all in favor of approving this conflict of interest, say yes. Any opposed, say no. Okay, thank you all. And that ends the Grants Committee Report. Next on the agenda, we have our upcoming events and important dates. We can just take a look at that. As always, we ask that if commissioners know of any art events happening. No. It is that time of the year. But we will be adding, if you do know of or hear of any upcoming events that you think would be important for commissioners to be there to represent the commission, or at least you don't kind of get to know is happening, please include that in this document, you always have the link in, I think it's in my midpoint emails, and then also, I believe, Christine always sends out. I can. Yeah. Or I always send it in the midpoint, but maybe if it would help to have it with the application materials, or general meeting materials, we can also include it. Does anyone know of any events happening that they want us to just quickly add in here, or would you guys prefer to Well, the McKinney Visiting Artist Series is happening. OK. And it is Friday, November 20th. Christina Mild. What did you say it was called? It's called the McKinney Visiting Artist Series. And it is on campus. She's a Czech-American interdisciplinary artist. They're from Brooklyn. I always try to go to at least a couple of those big things and just introduce myself to people on campus, like the visiting artists and people that are there. What date did you say it was? It's the 20th at 5 o'clock. And they'll have like a reception. And it's architecture and design. So it should be pretty cool. It'll be pretty fun. Yeah, should be a nice group of people. All right. I won't belabor this too much and have you watch us just type things in. But thank you for sharing Gretchen. And as always, please, please, if you do know of things happening, just take a moment to put that in. Or if you're just like, I don't have time or I'm lazy, email me. I'll do it for you. I love organizing things. OK. So next on our agenda is commissioner comments and announcements. So do any commissioners have any comments to share generally about this meeting, outside of this meeting, or things happening outside of this meeting? The floor is open for you guys. All right. So next. I'm sorry, I had something. Oh. In a fun event. Soul Tonk is happening on December 6th, Soul Tonk. So the Black House normally has an event called Honky Tonk where it's more centered around country music, but Soul Tonk is around soul music, classic soul. But this one will be holiday themed, so you will see a lot of soul, holiday themed music. And it's on December 2nd, Tuesday December 2nd, doors open at 8pm. Are you singing? I am. What time is it, Christina? Doors open at eight. What's it usually start at like eight or like? Yeah. Okay. All right. So we do have eight minutes of this meeting remaining and as promised, I will allow us to go back to public comment and allow other members of the community to comment. I can stick to three minutes again, but we will be ending this meeting at 630. You have suppressed public comment tonight. You have been long-winded on purpose and you have suppressed public comment tonight. So we've already finished the agenda and we do have eight minutes. We have eight minutes left for public comment. If people would like to comment, they are free to do so. They do have three minutes. And we will be strict with that because we want to make sure that with the time remaining, folks can actually talk. So who would like to, in the community, like to offer a comment? Feel free to raise your hand. OK, there's someone online. Martin, you can go ahead and unmute yourself if you can, and go ahead and speak. You have three minutes. Hello, this is Martin. I'm Martin Bowling. I'm a local photographer, and I'm here in support of Dr. and her concerns. And so I'd just like to say that I would like to see the condition address her four questions that she put in writing. and that you make your answers part of the public record. And that's all I had to say about that. Thank you. Any other comments from the public? I have no idea what this is all about. I'm going to read the statement that I did not read earlier. It should take me about a minute or two. OK. And this is simply say that the art community in Bloomington and Monroe County should be a place where creativity flourish free from discrimination based on political belief, religion, gender, sexual orientation, or background. Our focus should be on supporting meaningful artistic expression and the creating opportunity for all artists to present their work should be able to express their perspective without being labeled a supporter of one political party or another, and without fear of harassment, exclusion, or isolation. It is very important to understand that. I do not know the situation or what happened or what's not happened, but I know that there is a common sense that we all must follow. It's just simple as that. I'm not asking for anything. I'm just saying that this is something that you need to do. If you want to know event, the Bloomington Photographic Club opening in Convention Center, I believe, on Friday, December 4th, between 5 and 8. You guys will come to go see that too. That's all I have to say. I mean, we are meeting complication of something that should not be. Thank you for your time. And we appreciate, by the way, all the work that you do. We appreciate that. Thank you so much. Any other comments from the public? Yep. Hi, yeah. Just in regards to Catherine's concerns and what she's proposing and suggesting, I think, again, if you've got an opportunity to look at policies and procedures, Salton or amongst yourselves, I think it's an opportunity to consider what she's brought forward and you know, I mean the cyber bullying and everything we've seen going on constantly in the world. I think it's just an opportunity for you to consider that into the specs. So, thank you. Anyone else like to offer a comment? I don't see anyone else raising their hands or posting anything online. So I'm going to go ahead and move to adjoin the meeting. Can I say one more thing? I want to acknowledge that no one on the commission tonight spoke to my situation. OK. That's it. All right. So there being no further business, I move to adjoin the meeting. Can I get a second? Second. Thank you. All in favor say yes. Yes. Those opposed say no. All right, thank you, meeting adjourned.