WEBVTT

00:00:00.610 --> 00:00:07.959
- All right, good evening, folks. I have 5.30 on my computer. So we'll go ahead and get started. This

00:00:07.959 --> 00:00:15.456
- is the regularly scheduled meeting of the Board of Public Works for November 17, 2026. We are here in

00:00:15.456 --> 00:00:22.879
- City Council chambers at 401 North Morton Street. And we also have a Zoom link with a meeting ID and

00:00:22.879 --> 00:00:25.598
- passcode on the agenda. Oh, perfect.

00:00:26.082 --> 00:00:32.367
- So there is a meeting ID and passcode on the agenda for those attending virtually. If you are attending

00:00:32.367 --> 00:00:38.411
- virtually and you have any public comment for items not on the agenda, there will be time for that.

00:00:38.411 --> 00:00:44.575
- We just ask that you use the raised hand or the chat function on Zoom. And then if you do have public

00:00:44.575 --> 00:00:50.921
- comments on any of the items that are on the agenda, there will also be time for that during the meeting

00:00:50.921 --> 00:00:53.822
- using, again, the raised hand or chat function.

00:00:53.986 --> 00:01:00.294
- I will turn it over to Elizabeth Carone, president of the Board of Public Works. Thank you, Adam. Good

00:01:00.294 --> 00:01:06.418
- evening, everyone, and welcome to tonight's Board of Public Works meeting for November 17. First on

00:01:06.418 --> 00:01:12.849
- the agenda, we have messages from board members. Are there any messages from the board? All right. Next,

00:01:12.849 --> 00:01:19.157
- we'll move along to appeals. First, we have an appeal of a noise citation issued by Bloomington Police

00:01:19.157 --> 00:01:20.382
- to Tatum Hernandez.

00:01:20.642 --> 00:01:28.820
- Great. Adam Wason again, Public Works Director. So we have Officer Caleb Brinson here. He is the officer

00:01:28.820 --> 00:01:36.843
- that issued this noise citation, citation number 40799. And that was issued on June 20th, 2026 at 1030

00:01:36.843 --> 00:01:44.865
- or 1023 PM to Tatum Hernandez at 1313 East Matlock Drive. The basic facts of the case are that Officer

00:01:44.865 --> 00:01:49.694
- Brinson had approached the property after several complaints.

00:01:49.794 --> 00:01:56.810
- heard noise coming from the property that was outside of our noise ordinance and he did issue a ticket

00:01:56.810 --> 00:02:03.826
- notice of violation for that. The resident did ask for a warning. I think it was explained at the time

00:02:03.826 --> 00:02:08.798
- that for calls like this, the police department does not issue warnings.

00:02:09.058 --> 00:02:16.327
- But officer Branson is here for any questions you may have of him and I believe the appellant is here

00:02:16.327 --> 00:02:23.668
- Ms. Hernandez And if she would like to approach the podium and make any statements to the board you're

00:02:23.668 --> 00:02:31.294
- welcome to at this time Hi, if you could start by stating your name, please for the record Thank you, okay

00:02:31.842 --> 00:02:37.965
- Good afternoon. Thank you for the opportunity to speak regarding my appeal of the Norris ordinance citation

00:02:37.965 --> 00:02:43.918
- my roommates and I received. On the night of October 16th, our home received a noise ordinance citation.

00:02:43.918 --> 00:02:49.871
- I am asking the city to reconsider this citation because I do not believe that the situation was handled

00:02:49.871 --> 00:02:53.726
- fairly, nor were we given the opportunity to address the complaint.

00:02:54.882 --> 00:03:00.413
- My roommates and I have lived in the same house for nearly three years, and we have never received

00:03:00.413 --> 00:03:06.056
- complaints. We are also on good terms with all of our neighbors. We live relatively quiet lives, and

00:03:06.056 --> 00:03:11.866
- we're full-time students and work. Before our gathering on Friday, we reached out to our neighbors with

00:03:11.866 --> 00:03:17.509
- handwritten cards and bags of candy, asking them to contact us if the noise became too loud. We also

00:03:17.509 --> 00:03:20.414
- had someone standing outside monitoring the volume.

00:03:20.674 --> 00:03:26.859
- We genuinely do not believe the noise was excessive enough to warrant a noise ordinance citation. We

00:03:26.859 --> 00:03:33.044
- understand the importance of Bloomington's noise ordinances and we respect our neighbors. However, I

00:03:33.044 --> 00:03:39.167
- do believe enforcement should be fair and consistent. This brings me to a concern that came up when

00:03:39.167 --> 00:03:45.475
- we received the citation. Loud music is constantly heard from other houses and off-campus fraternities

00:03:45.475 --> 00:03:48.414
- during the weekdays, often late into the night.

00:03:48.706 --> 00:03:54.504
- When I was asking questions about this, the officer responded with the fact that the fraternities are

00:03:54.504 --> 00:04:00.189
- able to pay off these citations with, and I quote, daddy's money. I am not arguing against the law,

00:04:00.189 --> 00:04:05.873
- nor am I asking for it to be changed. I'm asking for fairness and consistency. I am also asking you

00:04:05.873 --> 00:04:11.785
- to reconsider this noise citation with the understanding that noise has never been an issue at our home

00:04:11.785 --> 00:04:16.958
- and that we took what we believed were the proper steps to be considered of our neighbors.

00:04:20.002 --> 00:04:28.418
- Thank you very much. All right, questions from the board? I would just like to make sure the staff report,

00:04:28.418 --> 00:04:36.441
- the noise appeal and the summary is listed as happening on June 20th, but the ticket is October 20th.

00:04:36.441 --> 00:04:44.542
- I just want to make sure that that is an October date and the appeal was received in a timely fashion.

00:04:58.722 --> 00:05:06.046
- was issued in October, and the appeal was received timely. Thank you. I have another question,

00:05:06.046 --> 00:05:14.450
- if you do not. Did you say the officer is? Yes, Officer Brinson is here. Brinson, would you mind approaching

00:05:14.450 --> 00:05:22.236
- the podium, please? And if you could state your name for the record. Officer Brinson, Kayla Brinson,

00:05:22.236 --> 00:05:26.014
- BPD. Thank you. We have the dispatch call sheet.

00:05:28.386 --> 00:05:34.688
- Can you tell us how many complaint calls you received about this noise complaint? I believe we had three

00:05:34.688 --> 00:05:40.690
- complaint calls before we were able to make our way to the property. OK. And the complaint? OK. The

00:05:40.690 --> 00:05:46.751
- complaint calls were what notified BPD of the excessive noise? Yes. Thank you. Does it also indicate

00:05:46.751 --> 00:05:53.113
- that there were up to a couple hundred people at the residence at the time? I think one of the complaints

00:05:53.113 --> 00:05:55.934
- said that. We didn't witness that many people.

00:05:58.402 --> 00:06:05.412
- But there were three separate complaints about the noise, if not the crowd size? Yes, ma'am. OK. And

00:06:05.412 --> 00:06:11.866
- my last question, could you just, for the record, state BPD's policy on issuing warnings for

00:06:11.866 --> 00:06:19.014
- noise complaints? So I work third shift. And our directive from our supervision is to write citations.

00:06:19.014 --> 00:06:25.955
- We don't do warnings on third shift, or else we would be chasing them all night long. OK. Thank you

00:06:25.955 --> 00:06:26.718
- very much.

00:06:29.826 --> 00:06:37.686
- All right, is there any public comment on this item? Seeing none, is there a motion? I move that we

00:06:37.686 --> 00:06:45.782
- uphold the noise citation issued by Bloomington Police to Tatum Hernandez. And I second. With a motion

00:06:45.782 --> 00:06:53.799
- and a second, I will call the roll. Cox-Duckard? Aye. Caron? Aye. Appeal is upheld. I'm sorry. Appeal

00:06:53.799 --> 00:06:57.022
- is denied. The noise citation is upheld.

00:07:00.162 --> 00:07:05.662
- Next, we have an appeal of engineering notice of violation issued to Bloomingscapes LLC.

00:07:38.594 --> 00:07:46.292
- The staff member that actually observed the violations of not having proper traffic control was Rebecca

00:07:46.292 --> 00:07:53.842
- Davis and that happened later in the day after Zach had been in communication with representatives of

00:07:53.842 --> 00:08:01.318
- Bloomingscapes. So staff is requesting denial of the appeal. We do have both Zach. We have Zach here

00:08:01.318 --> 00:08:07.166
- and Kyle here and they are happy to answer any questions you may have on this.

00:08:08.482 --> 00:08:23.398
- but asking for denial of the appeal. Thank you. Any questions from the board? I have just a question

00:08:23.398 --> 00:08:32.702
- for our staff. So was there a reason that Zach had reached out

00:08:33.218 --> 00:08:39.470
- about the, like, with the reminder, I guess. Is there a context to the reminder? Yes. Yes. So Zach Bell,

00:08:39.470 --> 00:08:45.662
- engineering, the exact reason I reached out to Bloomingscapes was to inform them of the fact that their

00:08:45.662 --> 00:08:51.675
- subcontractors have to follow the same MUTCD approved, or approved maintenance of traffic plans that

00:08:51.675 --> 00:08:57.748
- are associated with this permit. So I reached out to them first thing in the morning to let them know

00:08:57.748 --> 00:09:03.166
- that that is a requirement. And then it was observed that their subcontractor did not have

00:09:03.650 --> 00:09:12.480
- traffic control in place. And had the permit applicant not completed the maintenance of traffic plan

00:09:12.480 --> 00:09:21.485
- for the permit? No, the work that was being done was the final repairs to the street cuts. So they had

00:09:21.485 --> 00:09:30.228
- finished everything up until then, and then the subcontractor came in to complete the work. OK. And

00:09:30.228 --> 00:09:32.414
- so you had reminded them

00:09:32.514 --> 00:09:40.982
- Because you knew a different subcontractor was coming in to do the work. And it was like a courtesy

00:09:40.982 --> 00:09:49.451
- reminder that they needed to make sure to maintain the existing permit maintenance of traffic. Yes,

00:09:49.451 --> 00:09:58.173
- exactly. Ultimately, I just want people to be safe and things to go well. Thanks. Any other questions?

00:09:58.173 --> 00:10:00.798
- Do we have the appellant here?

00:10:07.490 --> 00:10:14.932
- It does not appear that the appellants are online or in person this evening. Is that a yes, additional

00:10:14.932 --> 00:10:22.230
- question? I do not have additional questions. Is there any public comment on Zoom? Again, if you are

00:10:22.230 --> 00:10:29.527
- joining the meeting on Zoom, use the chat function or raise hand. If you are in council chambers and

00:10:29.527 --> 00:10:33.790
- have comment about this item, you may approach the podium.

00:10:39.074 --> 00:10:46.596
- All right, is there a motion? I move that we uphold the engineering notice of violation issued

00:10:46.596 --> 00:10:55.226
- to Bloomingscapes LLC. And I second. I will call the roll. Cox-Deckard? Aye. Caron? Aye. Notice of violation

00:10:55.226 --> 00:11:04.094
- upheld. Next is an appeal of multiple Title VI violations issued to Grant Street addresses for Elkins property.

00:11:15.778 --> 00:11:23.774
- Good afternoon board members Taylor Brown city legal. This is regarding multiple title six violations

00:11:23.774 --> 00:11:31.691
- specifically for six point oh four point one one zero which is trash carts blocking the right of way

00:11:31.691 --> 00:11:39.765
- and six point oh six point oh two oh which is garbage deposit of garbage on the property. Tickets were

00:11:39.765 --> 00:11:43.998
- made to warnings were initially given on August 25th.

00:11:44.162 --> 00:11:51.747
- of this year and those were concerning the trash carts blocking the right of way. When the hand inspector,

00:11:51.747 --> 00:11:58.907
- and she is present if you have any questions, came back on September 22nd, the trash carts continued

00:11:58.907 --> 00:12:05.995
- to block the right of way and there was also a couch that was on the property. And that is when the

00:12:05.995 --> 00:12:12.446
- first citation was issued, two citations for trash carts and a $50 citation for the couch.

00:12:12.770 --> 00:12:18.611
- And then when the inspector came back on the 30th, the trash carts were taken care of, but the couch

00:12:18.611 --> 00:12:24.162
- had not been. And that's when the second $100 violation was, the notice of violation was given.

00:12:24.162 --> 00:12:30.061
- At this time, the property has been brought into compliance, so all of the couches and everything has

00:12:30.061 --> 00:12:35.902
- been taken care of. Thank you. Is there a representative here from Elkins Property who would like to

00:12:35.902 --> 00:12:39.198
- make a statement? Would you like to approach the podium?

00:12:44.642 --> 00:12:51.326
- State your name, please. I apologize for the raspy voice, but it is what it is. You're fine. Yeah, so

00:12:51.326 --> 00:12:58.075
- you know, I think it's interesting. I listened to what counsel just said, and his first statement was,

00:12:58.075 --> 00:13:04.103
- I assume a warning notice was sent. That's the first thing. Name for the record. My name is

00:13:04.103 --> 00:13:10.590
- Sherry Hillenburg. And that's the first thing he said. In the information where I filed my appeal,

00:13:11.618 --> 00:13:21.937
- I sent multiple pieces of documentation and if you go to the civic access site for the city or hand

00:13:21.937 --> 00:13:32.256
- in or other violations when you look in there if they issue a warning there is a notice a violation

00:13:32.256 --> 00:13:34.526
- for the warning date.

00:13:34.722 --> 00:13:42.112
- Case in point, I looked at your agenda from October the 4th when Hunter Properties was here and they

00:13:42.112 --> 00:13:49.429
- were appealing multiple violations. I went back today and actually looked at those notices and what

00:13:49.429 --> 00:13:56.965
- I found was November 9th they had an entry that said warning. November 25th, I'm sorry, September 25th

00:13:56.965 --> 00:14:02.526
- they had a warning, notice of violation and it said, it was the first fine.

00:14:04.098 --> 00:14:12.441
- On October 9th, there's a third entry in access and the fine increases, and they were here appealing

00:14:12.441 --> 00:14:20.702
- those. If you go to City Access and you look at these citations on South Grant, it was entered into

00:14:20.702 --> 00:14:29.045
- the system the very day we got a fine. There was no warning ever issued. There was no August warning

00:14:29.045 --> 00:14:31.358
- issued on these properties.

00:14:31.970 --> 00:14:38.734
- I have been at Elkins Apartments since 1998 and I would tell you you could go through every file that

00:14:38.734 --> 00:14:45.365
- hand has and you will not find a time when we have ignored a notice of violation. We don't do that.

00:14:45.365 --> 00:14:51.997
- We go to our our tenants if they're violating something and we say you got to take care of this now

00:14:51.997 --> 00:14:58.760
- and if you don't we're taking care of it and we'll charge you. We don't do that. We try to follow the

00:14:58.760 --> 00:15:01.214
- rules. We try to stay in compliance.

00:15:01.762 --> 00:15:10.230
- The other thing that I noticed, and I questioned it with, I believe it's Miranda, who reached out to

00:15:10.230 --> 00:15:19.117
- hand, if you go into City Access and you look at these violations that I'm appealing, they all say closed

00:15:19.117 --> 00:15:27.501
- and resolved. And I was asking why they say closed and resolved if they're on appeal. So the answer

00:15:27.501 --> 00:15:31.358
- that I got back, which she received, was that

00:15:32.258 --> 00:15:39.195
- hand simply does that so that it's closed as far as they're concerned. But again, that's not the case

00:15:39.195 --> 00:15:46.336
- with the 100 properties that was on your agenda in October. I looked at theirs today, and they're still,

00:15:46.336 --> 00:15:53.205
- say, in progress. They're not closed because they were appealed. I'm assuming they haven't paid them

00:15:53.205 --> 00:15:59.870
- or whatever, but they're not closed yet. But mine, I'll say, closed and resolved. So when I filed

00:16:00.002 --> 00:16:06.898
- the information for the appeal. I asked the question, what triggers a notice of violation? Is it when

00:16:06.898 --> 00:16:14.065
- the inspector puts that into city access? If that triggers because it's a form letter, you know, nobody's

00:16:14.065 --> 00:16:21.232
- typing it. If that triggers the notice of violation, then the reason I'm on my third warning and a ticket

00:16:21.232 --> 00:16:28.129
- is because I didn't get a warning. I didn't get those notice of violations that because it wasn't put

00:16:28.129 --> 00:16:29.278
- into the system.

00:16:29.538 --> 00:16:36.479
- It was not put into the system in August. It was put in in September. I provided you copies of that.

00:16:36.479 --> 00:16:43.421
- It's public record. Anybody can see it if you go to City Access. So I'm here to appeal those. I have

00:16:43.421 --> 00:16:50.293
- no problem paying fines. If we made the mistake, if we overlooked it, if it's our fault, we pay the

00:16:50.293 --> 00:16:54.142
- fine. But that doesn't happen because we don't do that.

00:16:55.490 --> 00:17:03.264
- And in this case, I don't think we ever received a notice. I'm not looking to, you know, crucify anybody

00:17:03.264 --> 00:17:10.668
- or shoot the messenger, because let's face it, August, September is a busy time for us. It's a busy

00:17:10.668 --> 00:17:18.294
- time for hand. And I get that. And things can be overlooked. I'm just asking to be treated fairly. I'm

00:17:18.294 --> 00:17:24.958
- saying we do not ignore notice of violations. We do not. And, you know, the website seeks

00:17:25.154 --> 00:17:33.604
- speaks for itself. They're not there. They were not entered until September 30th. On September 30th,

00:17:33.604 --> 00:17:42.138
- I have a $100 fine. Now the one, there's one on 346 that says September 22nd. They're both entered on

00:17:42.138 --> 00:17:50.505
- the same entry in civic access. They're both on the same entry in civic access. You can go, you can

00:17:50.505 --> 00:17:53.182
- drill down and see that. Again,

00:17:53.410 --> 00:18:00.074
- How can I take care of something of a warning if I'm not told? The first thing I saw was a $100 fine.

00:18:00.074 --> 00:18:07.000
- And the one for the lesser fine came the same day as the $100 fine. And I think unless somebody's willing

00:18:07.000 --> 00:18:13.599
- to answer that, which hand has not at this point in time, entering that information into that access

00:18:13.599 --> 00:18:20.133
- likely triggers the notice. Makes sense to me. You put the information in, and it triggers a notice

00:18:20.133 --> 00:18:22.942
- that goes out to whomever is in violation.

00:18:25.506 --> 00:18:32.779
- So, you know, I'm just asking to be treated fairly. Like I said, I have no problem if we made a mistake,

00:18:32.779 --> 00:18:39.360
- we did something wrong, we pay it, no questions asked, I wouldn't be standing here. All right.

00:18:39.360 --> 00:18:46.772
- Thank you very, very much for your statement. Thank you. Questions from the board? Yeah, I have a question

00:18:46.772 --> 00:18:53.630
- for staff. First, I think a question for Adam. I didn't think we reviewed appeals for trash cards.

00:18:55.490 --> 00:19:04.041
- for cans of the curb? Come on up to the podium, please. I can't remember a time that we've had one come

00:19:04.041 --> 00:19:12.262
- for cans of the curb, but I'll, yeah, please. Yeah, Angela Van Roy, operations manager in hand. You

00:19:12.262 --> 00:19:20.484
- are correct. That was the case. It was at one time that those cans of the curb violations had to go

00:19:20.484 --> 00:19:22.046
- straight to court.

00:19:22.178 --> 00:19:31.301
- It was repealed and code was amended within the past year, a little more than a year. Yeah. That's why

00:19:31.301 --> 00:19:40.600
- I don't recall. Did that code also have any effect on warnings? I was thinking that there was no warning

00:19:40.600 --> 00:19:48.926
- and that there was no appeal to the Board of Public Works in the past, so I'm just curious if

00:19:49.666 --> 00:19:58.416
- about the whole. For cans at the curb in particular. Yeah, for cans at the curbs. We would definitely

00:19:58.416 --> 00:20:07.337
- hear the couch issue is something that would come to us. Correct. With the enforcement procedures, it's

00:20:07.337 --> 00:20:16.258
- updated to 6.04.100 is what does the whole appeal procedure. And it specifically states in, let me find

00:20:16.258 --> 00:20:19.518
- it here, subsection C and, excuse me,

00:20:19.682 --> 00:20:27.377
- E is where it is where it states that it can be heard by appeal to the Board of Public Works. Okay.

00:20:27.377 --> 00:20:35.149
- And then is so warning is an option for warning is not required by code. Warning is usually given by

00:20:35.149 --> 00:20:43.614
- compliance officers who are trying to be good neighbors and let them know that things are need to be changed.

00:20:44.066 --> 00:20:54.385
- And then I've been trying to keep up, because I know there are several different documents. But I wanted

00:20:54.385 --> 00:21:04.310
- to just ask for clarity. The notices of violation in question that Ms. Hillenburg had mentioned that

00:21:04.310 --> 00:21:12.958
- she did not receive ahead of the fining getting to, I think it was $100, were those for

00:21:13.410 --> 00:21:22.494
- the couch, or were they for the trash carts? Is there a way for us to discern that? Thank you. So there

00:21:22.494 --> 00:21:31.316
- were two specific, and if I said I assume, I did not mean to say I assume, so I'll just correct that

00:21:31.316 --> 00:21:40.226
- for the record now. There were citations given. And in, let me see where it is here. In, just to make

00:21:40.226 --> 00:21:42.846
- sure I'm accurate, 6.06.070B.

00:21:43.010 --> 00:21:49.515
- It states, the notice of violation shall be in writing and served on one of the more responsible parties,

00:21:49.515 --> 00:21:55.774
- in this case, the property owner, by one or more of these methods, either delivery in person by first

00:21:55.774 --> 00:22:02.524
- class mail or by placement in a conspicuous place on the property. And Han does multiple of those. Compliance

00:22:02.524 --> 00:22:08.783
- Officer Chastina stated that she had, in fact, spoken with the tenants and provided those notices. If

00:22:08.783 --> 00:22:12.158
- they weren't passed along, that's unfortunate, but not

00:22:12.386 --> 00:22:21.172
- ultimately within the city's control. So I know that they were in the picture of the couches. You can

00:22:21.172 --> 00:22:29.873
- actually see in the background a little yellow notice where it's been posted to the door. And so the

00:22:29.873 --> 00:22:38.659
- couch was one of the violations that was not that the notice had been posted, but it didn't appear in

00:22:38.659 --> 00:22:40.382
- the digital portal.

00:22:40.706 --> 00:22:47.381
- And I believe it was, the appellant even stated that September 22nd those notices were inputted into

00:22:47.381 --> 00:22:54.320
- the portal. If I could ask, if someone from hand staff could explain the whole civic, I'm not sure which

00:22:54.320 --> 00:22:58.814
- system you all use, so I'll get out of my league very quickly here.

00:22:59.266 --> 00:23:05.190
- Hi Anna Killian Hansen director of housing and neighborhood development quickly just want to let you

00:23:05.190 --> 00:23:11.290
- know how civic access is being used. It is not being used to issue tickets on site like maybe a parking

00:23:11.290 --> 00:23:16.862
- ticket would be issued. So that information is entered on site. You have it instantly updated.

00:23:17.090 --> 00:23:23.783
- Our enforcement officers are currently using paper tickets. We might be the only city department using

00:23:23.783 --> 00:23:30.411
- NCR paper for our tickets. And so a copy is left at the site and then we take one back to the office.

00:23:30.411 --> 00:23:37.233
- City staff manually enter those tickets. So there is a delay period between when civic access is updated

00:23:37.233 --> 00:23:38.078
- and when the

00:23:38.146 --> 00:23:44.992
- NOV is issued So that that really should have no bearing on the timeline When we're looking in civic

00:23:44.992 --> 00:23:51.906
- access to see when something was entered The reason that we're putting it in civic access is to track

00:23:51.906 --> 00:23:58.684
- dates so that we can run reports. It's also to track fines And to allow the public to pay for their

00:23:58.684 --> 00:24:05.462
- violations online. So Unfortunately, we tried to shift to an electronic system Last year to cut our

00:24:05.462 --> 00:24:06.750
- production in half

00:24:08.194 --> 00:24:15.630
- Can I ask you a follow-up question, please? Could you explain why one or more of these violations said,

00:24:15.630 --> 00:24:22.852
- resolved in civic access when there was an appeal? That means that we've reached compliance. It does

00:24:22.852 --> 00:24:30.216
- not mean that the fees have been paid. It just means that the issue is no longer there. OK, thank you.

00:24:30.216 --> 00:24:37.438
- I have a follow-up question for legal, if I may. Yes. Can you please, what is the difference between

00:24:37.666 --> 00:24:48.359
- municipal code 6.04.100 and 6.04.110, I think. So 100 is specifically enforcement procedures. 0.110

00:24:48.359 --> 00:24:59.480
- is, and this happens occasionally, I can only speculate, I can't speak to it exactly, but when the code

00:24:59.480 --> 00:25:06.430
- is being updated and they want to insert another section without

00:25:06.626 --> 00:25:15.792
- adding and changing all of the numbers, they will insert it afterwards. So while the enforcement procedures

00:25:15.792 --> 00:25:24.533
- and how things are appealed are in 100, there's an additional requirement of removal of the containers

00:25:24.533 --> 00:25:33.359
- found at 110. Does that answer your question? Okay. And in the order shared by staff, the warnings were

00:25:33.359 --> 00:25:36.414
- in violation. This is number eight.

00:25:36.706 --> 00:25:48.438
- of the order document, fines in accordance with BMC 6.04.100 on September 22nd, and then the other,

00:25:48.438 --> 00:26:00.287
- the $50 and the $100 fines for 6.06.070. Yes. I will also just direct the board to take into account

00:26:00.287 --> 00:26:04.158
- that while civic access might be

00:26:04.674 --> 00:26:12.148
- take some time to update and things. The code specifically does not require any sort of electronic component,

00:26:12.148 --> 00:26:19.146
- simply that there is either delivery in person, first class mail, or placement in a conspicuous place.

00:26:19.146 --> 00:26:26.009
- So even if Hand had not put anything into civic access, there would be no requirement to do so under

00:26:26.009 --> 00:26:32.803
- code. It is a physical requirement that notice be made, again, either in person by first class mail

00:26:32.803 --> 00:26:34.366
- or posted to the door.

00:26:34.754 --> 00:26:45.753
- So, while civic access is convenient, not entirely required by code. All right. I hate to ask you again,

00:26:45.753 --> 00:26:56.333
- but we are addressing the violation of 6.04.110, which is removal of solid waste and recycling carts

00:26:56.333 --> 00:27:04.190
- and yard waste containers. And the fines for $15 was assessed as 6.04.110.

00:27:04.290 --> 00:27:13.584
- 0.100? 0.100 is the enforcement mechanism. Sorry, weird emphasis on the word. Is the enforcement mechanism.

00:27:13.584 --> 00:27:22.275
- So the ticket was issued under that section, because that's the process. The actual violation is for

00:27:22.275 --> 00:27:31.139
- 0.110. And that's why the 110 is on the ticket. But then the ticket was issued under 100, which is the

00:27:31.139 --> 00:27:33.118
- enforcement procedure.

00:27:33.282 --> 00:27:42.892
- Thank you very much. Other questions? I guess I have a question also. Help me understand this, Taylor.

00:27:42.892 --> 00:27:52.409
- In most of these instances, these fines are issued to the tenants of the locations. I'm having a hard

00:27:52.409 --> 00:28:02.206
- time understanding how the property owner had gotten pulled in when the fines are issued to the tenants.

00:28:02.338 --> 00:28:09.634
- Sure. So under, let me pull it up here. This may just be my confusion. Of course. 6.06.070, subsection

00:28:09.634 --> 00:28:17.072
- A, the second sentence there. For purposes of issuing a notice of violation, the following persons shall

00:28:17.072 --> 00:28:24.651
- be considered responsible parties with liability for fines and responsibility for remedy of the violation.

00:28:24.651 --> 00:28:29.822
- Persons with possessory interest in the property, that would be tenants.

00:28:29.922 --> 00:28:36.311
- property owners and or any persons who have caused the violation. So while the tenants may have also

00:28:36.311 --> 00:28:42.700
- caused the violation, the property owners would also be responsible for their tenants. Right. And in

00:28:42.700 --> 00:28:49.152
- most cases, don't we have the tenants then provide the lease and that has the name of the individuals

00:28:49.152 --> 00:28:55.794
- that are responsible? Correct. Okay. Why is this different? I'm afraid I don't understand your question.

00:28:55.794 --> 00:28:57.502
- Would you mind rephrasing?

00:28:57.602 --> 00:29:03.369
- Usually in these situations, we would then reach out to the property owner to say, hey, there was a

00:29:03.369 --> 00:29:09.366
- notice of violation at your property. Can you provide the lease information with the tenant information

00:29:09.366 --> 00:29:15.018
- so that we can hold the tenants accountable? Isn't that? Yes. We hold both of the tenants. Sorry.

00:29:15.018 --> 00:29:20.958
- Go ahead, Anna. Please help me. We hold both the tenants and property owners. So under that particular

00:29:20.958 --> 00:29:26.782
- section of code legally, they are all responsible for fixing that violation. OK. Please, Anna. Sure.

00:29:27.650 --> 00:29:35.605
- It attaches to the property with the owner until the landlord provides the lease. And in this case,

00:29:35.605 --> 00:29:43.878
- we have not received a copy of the lease to shift that responsibility. OK. That's where I was confused.

00:29:43.878 --> 00:29:52.072
- I got you. All right. Thank you. All right. With no more questions from the board, is there any public

00:29:52.072 --> 00:29:53.822
- comment on this item?

00:29:58.562 --> 00:30:06.362
- You are when you come on up. So, you know, in response to the lease, you're absolutely right. When we

00:30:06.362 --> 00:30:14.239
- get a warning, actually, in the last week, we got a warning of trash carts at the curb for a property.

00:30:14.239 --> 00:30:22.116
- We sent the lease over to hand and called us and said, don't send us the lease for a warning. We don't

00:30:22.116 --> 00:30:25.022
- need them. And I instructed my staff.

00:30:25.122 --> 00:30:31.768
- I don't care whether they need it or not, they can throw it away. I want a lease sent every time. But

00:30:31.768 --> 00:30:38.545
- when we get these notices, we send the leases. By the time we got the notices for the fines, the second

00:30:38.545 --> 00:30:45.386
- fine, then I said, well, we have to appeal these. I mean, at that point, it's too late to say, you know,

00:30:45.386 --> 00:30:51.902
- we've given the second fine. The other issue that I have with what's been said here tonight is that

00:30:52.418 --> 00:30:59.359
- They can tag the tenant's door and tell them, yet you hold the property owner responsible. And so if

00:30:59.359 --> 00:31:06.369
- you put a tag on our tenant's door, which we got a picture, showed they tagged it, I'm pretty sure my

00:31:06.369 --> 00:31:13.310
- tenants are not going to call me and say, hey, somebody's going to fine us for something being here.

00:31:13.310 --> 00:31:20.388
- I mean, they didn't pull the carts in to begin with, which we tell them, or whatever. So again, I just

00:31:20.388 --> 00:31:21.694
- think this is not,

00:31:21.986 --> 00:31:30.033
- We were in business beforehand existed. And so we always deal with these things. We always deal with

00:31:30.033 --> 00:31:38.079
- them. In this particular instance, we didn't get any notices until we got the fines. And you can say

00:31:38.079 --> 00:31:46.126
- what you want about access, and I can say that it's not there. But I'm telling you, your agenda last

00:31:46.126 --> 00:31:49.950
- month and Hunter Properties, it's all in there.

00:31:50.178 --> 00:31:56.505
- I've been looking at our agendas from the last couple of months. We don't have 100 property from last

00:31:56.505 --> 00:32:02.831
- month. October 4th, it was on Dorchester Drive. Because we met October 15th. I don't know that we met

00:32:02.831 --> 00:32:09.158
- on the 4th. Is it possibly maybe last year? It was continued. Maybe it didn't inform or whatever, but

00:32:09.158 --> 00:32:15.857
- it was on October 4th, and then it went to, but it was, they were all there. There's a notice of violation.

00:32:15.857 --> 00:32:19.454
- If I go look at my properties, I send an example for 606,

00:32:20.258 --> 00:32:27.552
- If I go look at my properties that have had violations in the past, the very date on that warning notice

00:32:27.552 --> 00:32:34.637
- is the very date it's in civic access every time. You could go through it, you can look over and over

00:32:34.637 --> 00:32:41.723
- and over at the examples that it's in there. And maybe they don't do it, and maybe they do, and maybe

00:32:41.723 --> 00:32:49.086
- there's some reason this one is different. But you go look at them, you look at the date on one of those,

00:32:49.890 --> 00:32:58.159
- And it is the same date on the notice that comes out in the mail. It's the same day in civic access

00:32:58.159 --> 00:33:06.760
- that the case was opened. In this case, this was not opened until September 30th when we got the fines.

00:33:06.760 --> 00:33:09.406
- Thank you very much. Thank you.

00:33:20.706 --> 00:33:28.764
- For the benefit of the public I do want to make sure that everybody understands that it's not just posting

00:33:28.764 --> 00:33:36.597
- tickets or no fees on the doors. We also mail them when we get them back to the office so we don't have

00:33:36.597 --> 00:33:42.622
- control over the mail delivery system. Thank you. All right. Is there a motion.

00:33:44.962 --> 00:33:54.916
- I move that we uphold the multiple title six violations issued to Grant Street addresses for Elkins

00:33:54.916 --> 00:34:04.870
- property. Second. With a motion and a second, I will call the roll. Cox Deckard. Aye. Corona motion

00:34:04.870 --> 00:34:09.150
- does not pass. Did not pass. Did not pass.

00:34:15.106 --> 00:34:25.249
- means it falls into a gray Neverland area because it's... Do we have city legal? Mm-hmm. Please.

00:34:25.249 --> 00:34:36.229
- Taylor Brown, city legal. So in this instance, it falls into this gray Neverland area, as Vice President

00:34:36.229 --> 00:34:42.398
- Cox Decker stated. Essentially, a board member, I believe,

00:34:42.818 --> 00:34:49.980
- I will double check my answers here, but I believe a board member of the board would have to then take

00:34:49.980 --> 00:34:56.446
- the matter back up again to be heard until then it is kind of in limbo until taken up again.

00:35:04.482 --> 00:35:12.371
- Moving on to petitions and remonstrances, this is a time if any member of the public has a public comment

00:35:12.371 --> 00:35:19.812
- about an item that is not on tonight's agenda. Again, if there's a comment that is not on tonight's

00:35:19.812 --> 00:35:27.627
- agenda, you may approach the podium in council chambers or use the raise hand or chat functions on Zoom.

00:35:27.627 --> 00:35:31.422
- All right, let's move along to the consent agenda.

00:35:31.586 --> 00:35:41.212
- Tonight we have resolution 2026-042, ITS surplus to technology recyclers. Resolution 2026-045, ITS surplus

00:35:41.212 --> 00:35:50.658
- to Mariachi Project. Resolution 2026-053, BPD surplus November 26. 2027 Centerstone Agreement. Amendment

00:35:50.658 --> 00:35:59.294
- one to contract with DC Construction Services for lots one, three, and five for date extension.

00:36:00.034 --> 00:36:06.619
- Contract renewal with routeware for recollect software. Contract with City Glass for Fire Station 5

00:36:06.619 --> 00:36:13.402
- project. Service agreement with Watson Lawn Services for snow removal at the parking garages. Contract

00:36:13.402 --> 00:36:20.185
- with Woods Electric for fire generator installations. Service agreement with Strouser Construction for

00:36:20.185 --> 00:36:26.046
- facilities. Amendment 1 to contract with Allison Family Farms for snow removal services.

00:36:26.210 --> 00:36:32.957
- Amendment 1 to contract with Trinkle for snow removal services, agreement with Family Farm Supply, DBA,

00:36:32.957 --> 00:36:39.510
- Indiana Salt Supply for de-icing salt, agreement with Young Trucking for de-icing salt, and payroll.

00:36:39.510 --> 00:36:46.127
- Are there any items that need to be removed from the consent agenda tonight? No. All right. Any board

00:36:46.127 --> 00:36:51.966
- questions about the consent agenda? Is there any public comment about the consent agenda?

00:36:55.938 --> 00:37:03.494
- Is there a motion? I move that we approve the consent agenda for this evening's meeting on November

00:37:03.494 --> 00:37:11.201
- 17th, 2026. Second, I will call the roll. Cox-Deckard? Aye. Caron? Aye. Motion passes. Our first item

00:37:11.201 --> 00:37:19.286
- of new business tonight is the acceptance of public improvements for Hopewell East. Hello, Maria McCormick

00:37:19.286 --> 00:37:25.406
- from engineering. We are bringing to you today the subdivision of Hopewell East,

00:37:25.570 --> 00:37:33.125
- for acceptance of the public improvements, which include the streets, alleys, street trees, tree plots,

00:37:33.125 --> 00:37:40.897
- lighting, water, sanitary, sewer, and storm sewers located in the right of way of that plat. This includes

00:37:40.897 --> 00:37:48.742
- the extensions of South Madison Street and West University Street, as well as two new alleys. This includes

00:37:48.742 --> 00:37:50.558
- a new park for the city.

00:37:50.882 --> 00:37:57.265
- And we would like your approval to accept these assets into the city's inventory tonight. Thank you.

00:37:57.265 --> 00:38:03.901
- Any questions from the board? Don't have any questions. Just was going to reiterate what we talked about

00:38:03.901 --> 00:38:10.473
- yesterday at the work session that this is one of those sort of intercity transactions that's happening

00:38:10.473 --> 00:38:16.920
- because the Redevelopment Commission is basically putting these assets back to the city by way of the

00:38:16.920 --> 00:38:18.942
- Board of Public Works. Correct.

00:38:19.106 --> 00:38:25.804
- And that's why we're there. It's the same as any developer. They built out the infrastructure. We went

00:38:25.804 --> 00:38:32.372
- through the same inspection process that we would for private developer. They had to meet all of the

00:38:32.372 --> 00:38:39.070
- same requirements and go through the process of getting the public improvements accepted just like any

00:38:39.070 --> 00:38:43.102
- other developer would also wanted to add just as a caveat the

00:38:43.234 --> 00:38:52.333
- permeable pavers that are part of the roadway and sidewalks. They need to use sand on those. And that

00:38:52.333 --> 00:39:00.808
- will be included in the memo that I send out, letting everybody know that we've accepted them.

00:39:00.808 --> 00:39:08.926
- Thank you. Thanks. Is there any public comment on this item? All right. Is there a motion?

00:39:09.122 --> 00:39:16.343
- I move that we approve the acceptance of public improvements for Hopewell East. Second, I will call

00:39:16.343 --> 00:39:23.926
- the roll. Cox Deckard. Aye. Caron. Aye. Motion passes. Thank you. Next is a right of way closure request

00:39:23.926 --> 00:39:31.219
- from stratum at Indiana for the 600 block of North Morton Street. Hello, I'm Rebecca Davis from city

00:39:31.219 --> 00:39:32.158
- engineering.

00:39:32.322 --> 00:39:40.793
- Stratum and Indiana is requesting approval of a temporary wide right away closure at 277 West 11th Street

00:39:40.793 --> 00:39:48.784
- to accommodate a brick sidewalk repair. And this was prompted by a sidewalk repair request that was

00:39:48.784 --> 00:39:50.622
- sent through the city.

00:39:50.978 --> 00:39:59.289
- It includes a temporary closure of the East sidewalk of North Morton directly south of West 11th Street

00:39:59.289 --> 00:40:07.439
- as necessary to safely complete the work. The closure is proposed to occur from December 14th 2026 to

00:40:07.439 --> 00:40:08.638
- December 18th.

00:40:08.802 --> 00:40:17.939
- 2026, it will be for 24 hours a day. Pedestrians will be rerouted in accordance with the approved maintenance

00:40:17.939 --> 00:40:26.910
- of traffic plan, which is to just route them, detour them over to the west sidewalk of North Morton Street.

00:40:28.194 --> 00:40:36.410
- But the petitioner shall install and maintain all required signage barricades and traffic control devices

00:40:36.410 --> 00:40:44.471
- maintain access to Adjacent properties and limit the closure to the minimum area and duration necessary

00:40:44.471 --> 00:40:52.222
- to complete the work Thank you questions from the board All right, is there public comment on this?

00:40:53.218 --> 00:41:00.545
- All right, is there a motion? I move that we approve the right-of-way closure request from Stratum,

00:41:00.545 --> 00:41:08.238
- Indiana for the 600 block of North Morton Street. Second, I will call the roll. Cox-Deckard? Aye. Caron?

00:41:08.238 --> 00:41:15.565
- Aye. Motion passes. Next is a right-of-way closure request for City of Bloomington Utilities at 308

00:41:15.565 --> 00:41:20.254
- South Madison Street. Good evening. Kyle Ball with Engineering.

00:41:20.354 --> 00:41:28.905
- City of Bloomington Utilities is requesting a street and alleyway closure for South Madison Street.

00:41:28.905 --> 00:41:37.713
- This is going to be adjacent roughly to the 308 property on South Madison in between the Beeline Trail

00:41:37.713 --> 00:41:46.350
- and South Rogers Street, just south of West Third Street. So the section of Madison right there, and

00:41:46.350 --> 00:41:49.086
- then there's a east-west alley,

00:41:49.282 --> 00:41:56.267
- In between third and Prospect Street that would be occupied. I did look back at our notes And this closure

00:41:56.267 --> 00:42:02.861
- for the actual Madison section is only going to be there a couple of days Not for the full week that

00:42:02.861 --> 00:42:08.606
- they're requesting here And then the remainder of the work would be within the alleyway

00:42:08.738 --> 00:42:15.629
- We're working with CBU to make sure that notifications go out to the affected property owners and make

00:42:15.629 --> 00:42:22.720
- sure that they're doing what they need to do to maintain the access for those affected, as well as notify

00:42:22.720 --> 00:42:29.678
- the Convention Center and the construction managers for the Bloomington Convention Center project. This

00:42:29.678 --> 00:42:36.435
- closure is being requested to take place from November 30th of this year to December 7th. Thank you.

00:42:36.435 --> 00:42:38.174
- Questions from the board?

00:42:38.946 --> 00:42:45.876
- All right. Is there any public comment on this item? No. Is there a motion? I move that we approve the

00:42:45.876 --> 00:42:52.604
- right of way closure request for city of Bloomington utilities at 308 South Madison Street. Second.

00:42:52.604 --> 00:42:59.399
- I will call the roll. Cox Decker? Aye. Caron? Aye. Motion passes. Next on the agenda, staff reports.

00:42:59.399 --> 00:43:05.118
- Good evening, folks. Adam Wason, Public Works Director. Just wanted to note that our

00:43:05.762 --> 00:43:11.352
- In coordination with our engineering department, there is some ongoing construction that's wrapping

00:43:11.352 --> 00:43:17.053
- up for this paving season that's going to be taking place this week and next and into early December.

00:43:17.053 --> 00:43:22.811
- But this is the Kirkwood, West Kirkwood, South Rogers, and Patterson Street project that's part of the

00:43:22.811 --> 00:43:25.438
- overall community crossings grant that we got.

00:43:25.538 --> 00:43:33.035
- to help fund that project. So milling and paving is starting. I noticed they were on West Kirkwood today.

00:43:33.035 --> 00:43:40.178
- We're starting with the milling. So this is West Kirkwood from Rogers out to Rose Hill Cemetery near

00:43:40.178 --> 00:43:47.674
- Adams. This is sections of Patterson between Second and Grimes. And then Patterson and Grimes from Walnut

00:43:47.674 --> 00:43:55.454
- to Third Street. So major paving and construction, milling and paving activities still going on in that area.

00:43:55.586 --> 00:44:03.078
- through the end of the month. And so just noting that for the public, it will have travel impacts. There

00:44:03.078 --> 00:44:10.355
- will be lane and road closures as they're doing that work. So I just want folks to know there will be

00:44:10.355 --> 00:44:18.061
- some travel delays in the near west side. If you can avoid those areas, that's taking place now. Otherwise,

00:44:18.061 --> 00:44:18.846
- just we're

00:44:18.978 --> 00:44:24.633
- Moving in towards towards our winter weather season so glad we got some salt approved tonight for salt

00:44:24.633 --> 00:44:30.233
- purchases. You know we're getting all of our trucks and equipment ready for any winter weather events

00:44:30.233 --> 00:44:35.779
- continuing to work these big guy football weekends as well appreciate all the coordination that took

00:44:35.779 --> 00:44:41.324
- place this last couple weeks on on those on the big guy football weekend so thanks to our friends at

00:44:41.324 --> 00:44:46.430
- the Bloomington Police Department and other law enforcement agencies really appreciate their

00:44:46.594 --> 00:44:55.203
- coordinated efforts with everything going on downtown. So that's all I have today. Thank you. Last on

00:44:55.203 --> 00:45:03.813
- the agenda is the approval of claims. Are there board questions about claims tonight? Is there public

00:45:03.813 --> 00:45:13.182
- comment about claims? No. Is there a motion? I move that we approve the claims in the amount of $5,125,500.78.

00:45:13.666 --> 00:45:20.086
- Second, I will call the roll. Cox, Decker? Aye. Caron? Aye. Motion passes. And with nothing else on

00:45:20.086 --> 00:45:22.718
- the agenda, I will call for adjournment.
