WEBVTT

00:00:00.130 --> 00:00:11.909
- If we can call this meeting to order, this is the special November session of the Bloomington Transportation

00:00:11.909 --> 00:00:23.147
- Commission. Will the secretary please call the roll? Copic? Here. Standifer? Here. Binder? Here. Bowen?

00:00:23.147 --> 00:00:27.902
- Here. Drumme? Sorry. Flaherty? Here. Davis?

00:00:29.858 --> 00:00:38.980
- Skorushko? Here. Stossberg? Here. That's it. Thank you. We have a quorum. I'd also like to welcome our

00:00:38.980 --> 00:00:47.837
- newest member who's here on behalf of the transit, Bloomington Transit. Good luck is all I can say.

00:00:47.837 --> 00:00:50.494
- What a first meeting for you.

00:00:51.042 --> 00:00:59.944
- Anyway, I thought that I would, so our agenda will include reports and communications and one case,

00:00:59.944 --> 00:01:09.113
- TCR 2622, adoption of College and Walnut Corridor Study and amendment to the transportation plan after

00:01:09.113 --> 00:01:18.460
- which we will adjourn. To that end, I'd like to make a very brief presentation just to ground what we're

00:01:18.460 --> 00:01:20.062
- doing in context.

00:01:23.490 --> 00:01:31.896
- waiting for the presentation to here we go. All right. So for those of you who are new to this commission

00:01:31.896 --> 00:01:40.301
- our mandate is it's not it's from more than twenty twenty five or four to guide the city's transportation

00:01:40.301 --> 00:01:48.627
- endeavors through a comprehensive framework which seeks to provide adequate and safe access to all right

00:01:48.627 --> 00:01:52.830
- of way users while prioritizing non automotive modes

00:01:52.994 --> 00:02:00.575
- and sustainability. Our mandate includes providing recommendations and guidance to the mayor and common

00:02:00.575 --> 00:02:08.156
- council in the pursuit of developing and implementing a citywide policy to eliminate all transportation

00:02:08.156 --> 00:02:15.882
- related fatalities and serious injuries to pedestrians bicyclists transit users motorists and passengers.

00:02:15.882 --> 00:02:19.454
- We also shall promote sustainable transportation

00:02:19.554 --> 00:02:26.616
- shall foster equitable access and shall promote community centric design. The commission is only 18

00:02:26.616 --> 00:02:34.172
- months old. It replaced three other commissions, the bicycle and pedestrian safety commission, the traffic

00:02:34.172 --> 00:02:36.926
- commission and the parking commission.

00:02:37.122 --> 00:02:44.387
- Uh, we were not responsible for the 2019 transportation plan, which is the subject, partially the subject

00:02:44.387 --> 00:02:51.721
- of tonight's case. We are also not responsible for the 2024 vision zero policy to eliminate all fatalities

00:02:51.721 --> 00:02:58.781
- and city streets by 2039, but we are responsible for overseeing the implementation of these documents.

00:02:58.781 --> 00:03:05.566
- Uh, what we are not doing tonight also is trying to rush a decision. Uh, while we have the option,

00:03:05.794 --> 00:03:12.903
- to make a recommendation tonight. We also have the option to continue to a future meeting. The administration

00:03:12.903 --> 00:03:19.366
- is recommending a change to the city's transportation plan. It's going to present it to us tonight.

00:03:19.366 --> 00:03:26.087
- It will then be presented to the plan commission at whatever point we have disposed of it. Then it will

00:03:26.087 --> 00:03:31.774
- eventually go to the common council. So this is the first step in a multi-step process.

00:03:32.482 --> 00:03:39.203
- We are going to hear a statement of the case by staff and report. They're going to make a presentation

00:03:39.203 --> 00:03:45.859
- We're going to have first round questions by Commissioners for staff. We will take public comment. We

00:03:45.859 --> 00:03:52.385
- will hear second round questions from the Commission the Commissioners will discuss the case if not

00:03:52.385 --> 00:03:59.041
- debate it and then we can decide on action and To that end. These are the actions available to us. We

00:03:59.041 --> 00:04:02.238
- can make a positive recommendation to forward to

00:04:02.530 --> 00:04:10.295
- bodies above us, we can make a negative negative recommendation. If one of those two does not come forward

00:04:10.295 --> 00:04:17.915
- when it comes time for us to make a motion, then a member can recommend no recommendation or to continue

00:04:17.915 --> 00:04:25.680
- to a future meeting. Our next meeting will be on December 7th or last meeting of the year in this chamber.

00:04:25.680 --> 00:04:31.486
- So with that, I hope that gives everybody context for what we're doing tonight.

00:04:31.810 --> 00:04:39.344
- And, uh, with that, I'd like to, uh, move straight to unless there's anything that any commissioner

00:04:39.344 --> 00:04:47.331
- would like to say or ask, uh, in reporting on other issues before we continue with the main item tonight.

00:04:47.331 --> 00:04:54.639
- Seeing to my left, to my right, without further ado, I believe that, uh, uh, is John Garza here?

00:04:54.639 --> 00:04:57.502
- John is here. Uh, and, uh, Lynn coin.

00:04:58.146 --> 00:05:06.717
- is here representing the planning transportation department, but the main presentation is going to be

00:05:06.717 --> 00:05:15.288
- made by Ryan Roebling. Mr. Roebling, please take it away. Okay. Thank you. Let me switch this. Sorry.

00:05:15.288 --> 00:05:21.086
- One second. Try to make that a little bit more visible to everybody.

00:05:26.370 --> 00:05:33.343
- Okay. Before us tonight is resolution TCR 2618. And before I begin, I want to clarify immediately that

00:05:33.343 --> 00:05:40.114
- this resolution, what this resolution does and what it does not do tonight's action on an amendment

00:05:40.114 --> 00:05:40.926
- to the 2020

00:05:41.186 --> 00:05:48.620
- or 2019 transportation plan to adopt the College and Walnut Corridor Study as an official planning addendum

00:05:48.620 --> 00:05:55.641
- and long-range design vision. It does not award a construction contract, it does not commit local tax

00:05:55.641 --> 00:06:02.937
- funds, and it will not trigger construction. It will also not convert the corridor to two-way operations.

00:06:02.937 --> 00:06:10.302
- What it does is establishes a long-term plan for the 4.2 miles of College Avenue and Walnut Street so that

00:06:10.754 --> 00:06:18.362
- As roads are repaved, utilities are upgraded, and developments occur, we can slowly build towards a

00:06:18.362 --> 00:06:26.351
- safer and more economically beneficial corridor. College in Walnut encompasses nearly 32 acres of public

00:06:26.351 --> 00:06:34.188
- space running through the heart of the community. It currently has 404 meter parking spaces and 21 bus

00:06:34.188 --> 00:06:39.742
- stops. This study was formally mandated in the 2019 transportation plan.

00:06:40.002 --> 00:06:46.349
- Within that plan, a thorough technical study is called for along this corridor to solve long-standing

00:06:46.349 --> 00:06:52.571
- safety issues, modernize cross-sections, and protect the vitality of our downtown. Since the outset

00:06:52.571 --> 00:06:59.042
- of this study, we have conducted speed and volume counts, public engagement, synchro modeling, engineer

00:06:59.042 --> 00:07:00.286
- designs, et cetera.

00:07:02.690 --> 00:07:10.411
- It's important to understand how and why we have the corridor that we do today. Until 1956, College

00:07:10.411 --> 00:07:18.131
- and Walnut were traditional two-way city streets. That year, in 1959, or 1956, excuse me, the State

00:07:18.131 --> 00:07:21.374
- Highway Department redesigned the streets

00:07:21.506 --> 00:07:27.206
- of then State Road 37 enforced the one-way couplet upon Bloomington to allow for regional freight to

00:07:27.206 --> 00:07:33.189
- move through the town more easily. At that time, local business owners objected, but the state threatened

00:07:33.189 --> 00:07:39.172
- to pull funding to the city. Eventually, State Road 37, as you probably know, moved west as urban highway

00:07:39.172 --> 00:07:44.872
- corridors fell out of fashion due to traffic and safety concerns. Despite the move west, the highway

00:07:44.872 --> 00:07:49.726
- street design remained. Over the next half century, Bloomington's population grew 44%

00:07:50.082 --> 00:07:57.858
- Yet the vehicle trips on the corridor dropped by 31%. Today, we are maintaining wide multi-lane roadways

00:07:57.858 --> 00:08:05.339
- built for 1950s highway freight demands that no longer exist. So why study the corridor? That's kind

00:08:05.339 --> 00:08:13.041
- of the question at the heart of this. And the first one is to eliminate high-speed crashes, crash risk,

00:08:13.041 --> 00:08:19.262
- and create a comfortable, walkable environment. As Mr. Volin highlighted, we have a

00:08:19.490 --> 00:08:25.481
- Vision zero policy here where we're attempting to eliminate fatal and serious crashes by twenty thirty

00:08:25.481 --> 00:08:31.355
- nine on the city's roadways. And this is obviously a corridor that features city roadways. Second is

00:08:31.355 --> 00:08:37.404
- to provide environmental and public realm benefits expand tree canopy and sidewalk space to lower noise

00:08:37.404 --> 00:08:40.894
- and build noise pollution and build resilient public realm.

00:08:41.218 --> 00:08:46.964
- And finally, drive economic development and tax-based growth, rebalancing pavement to increase customer

00:08:46.964 --> 00:08:52.765
- foot traffic, help eliminate commercial vacancies, and boost property values across the corridor's block

00:08:52.765 --> 00:08:58.566
- phases. So to answer the question of why we're doing anything on College of Walnut, it's because between

00:08:58.566 --> 00:09:04.091
- 2018 and 2022, 34 individuals had their lives forever altered and three lost their lives. This is a

00:09:04.091 --> 00:09:09.726
- corridor identified as the highest priority in the city's safe streets and roads for all action plan.

00:09:10.690 --> 00:09:19.181
- And it experienced 56 injurious crashes, including six serious injuries and one fatality between 2021

00:09:19.181 --> 00:09:27.756
- and 2025. And here you can see a clip from the safety action plan. You can see that College and Walnut

00:09:27.756 --> 00:09:36.414
- are highlighted here in dark red, similar to state highways, the bypass and West and East Third Street.

00:09:36.546 --> 00:09:42.665
- You can see that the design of state highways often features higher fatality and serious injury crash

00:09:42.665 --> 00:09:48.724
- risks, and because of their lingering design from the 50s, you can see that elevated risk on College

00:09:48.724 --> 00:09:54.903
- of Walnut today. Since the 50s, College of Walnut have been designed as state highways aimed at moving

00:09:54.903 --> 00:09:58.142
- people quickly through and past the city, but despite

00:09:58.242 --> 00:10:04.589
- decades being removed from the state highway designation, they are still designed and operate as such.

00:10:04.589 --> 00:10:10.813
- This is a corridor that includes the heart of downtown, high population density centers to the north

00:10:10.813 --> 00:10:17.344
- and single family neighborhoods to the south. These are areas where people walk, bike, play, park, drive.

00:10:17.344 --> 00:10:23.630
- Yet it is designed with widths wider than I-69. It's 41 feet of lane width on both College and Walnut

00:10:23.630 --> 00:10:26.526
- at Third Street and 35 for 69 at Third Street.

00:10:27.394 --> 00:10:34.525
- You can see that from the speed data collected in 2023, that speeders are going about 10 to 20 miles

00:10:34.525 --> 00:10:41.303
- over the posted speed limit in some areas. And this is a fault of design, not reckless drivers.

00:10:41.303 --> 00:10:48.717
- All right, counts gathered during the study found that over 4,500 motorists exceed the speed limit along

00:10:48.717 --> 00:10:56.766
- the corridor every day, with 85th percentile speeds reaching 42 miles per hour in some areas. A pedestrian truck,

00:10:57.186 --> 00:11:06.447
- A pedestrian crash at 40 miles an hour has an 80% chance of being killed. At 20 miles an hour, that

00:11:06.447 --> 00:11:15.708
- pedestrian survival rate climbs to 90%. Since 1976, motor vehicle volumes along College and Wellman

00:11:15.708 --> 00:11:24.414
- have dropped between 504 vehicles a day and 5,500 vehicles per day, depending on the segment.

00:11:24.514 --> 00:11:31.945
- And since 1976, a number of major changes to the Bloomington's transportation system have taken place.

00:11:31.945 --> 00:11:39.233
- The first is State Road 37 moved west, like I mentioned. Second is that the bypass 30, 45, 46 bypass

00:11:39.233 --> 00:11:47.169
- opened, allowing travel for vehicles wanting to go east to move that direction. And then finally, ultimately,

00:11:47.169 --> 00:11:53.374
- I-69 opened up, removing traffic stops and any impediment to speeding motor vehicles.

00:11:55.266 --> 00:12:07.165
- And you can see, sorry about that, you can see some of those numbers here. Kind of the extreme one here

00:12:07.165 --> 00:12:19.065
- is South College Avenue, south of 9th Street, where it had 1,600, 700, 16,727 vehicles per day in 1976.

00:12:19.065 --> 00:12:23.870
- And then in 2023, we had 11,234. Finally.

00:12:24.034 --> 00:12:30.323
- The opening of I-69 in the late 20 teens further allowed traffic to the ability to bypass downtown.

00:12:30.323 --> 00:12:36.675
- These are designs that, these are drivers that never intended to be downtown. They just wanted to do

00:12:36.675 --> 00:12:42.965
- regional or long distance travel through Bloomington. They had no intention of interacting. You can

00:12:42.965 --> 00:12:49.443
- see the significant drop off in orange is 2018 numbers. And then in that bluish color is 2023 numbers.

00:12:49.443 --> 00:12:53.342
- And then the gray is 1976 numbers. And you can see that this,

00:12:53.442 --> 00:13:01.199
- pretty steep drop off in some areas, specifically north of Third Street on College. We lost about 5,000

00:13:01.199 --> 00:13:08.955
- drivers per day. All right. So what does this look like in practice? On both corridors, the peak hourly

00:13:08.955 --> 00:13:16.190
- volume was recorded. And on College south of Kirkwood, the high was 900. This is the highest for

00:13:16.290 --> 00:13:24.297
- and hourly rate for anywhere on the corridor was 931 vehicles, which is below the capacity of a one-lane,

00:13:24.297 --> 00:13:32.228
- one-way street, which is roughly 1,050 vehicles per hour, shown here in that purple color in the middle.

00:13:32.228 --> 00:13:39.933
- This means that for a majority of the day, that portion of college has three times the required space

00:13:39.933 --> 00:13:45.598
- available to it, just sitting there unoccupied, allowing vehicles to move,

00:13:46.242 --> 00:13:54.006
- to not only travel quickly, but also to weave in and out of traffic to avoid other traffic that may

00:13:54.006 --> 00:14:02.080
- slow them down. So during these peak hours, standard three-lane design, sorry, hold on. So during those

00:14:02.080 --> 00:14:09.999
- peak hours, the standard three-lane design, which is on the right here, which is one northbound lane,

00:14:09.999 --> 00:14:13.726
- one southbound lane, and then a turn lane would

00:14:14.242 --> 00:14:21.295
- reach capacity by about 70 vehicles during peak. And that's just on north. This is just on southbound

00:14:21.295 --> 00:14:28.209
- college traffic. So one lane of that three-lane design would roughly hit at its peak would be about

00:14:28.209 --> 00:14:35.123
- 70 vehicles over capacity. And that would be just for college, which the two-way design would allow

00:14:35.123 --> 00:14:40.862
- Walnut to also look like that or have an additional southbound line, I should say.

00:14:42.242 --> 00:14:49.637
- Okay so environmental concerns here is flood risk in the city of Bloomington. As you all have probably

00:14:49.637 --> 00:14:57.175
- seen and or heard there is a significant flood risk south especially south along the corridor especially

00:14:57.175 --> 00:15:04.355
- south of Second Street. You can see that in those blue dots. That is a risk that will probably grow

00:15:04.355 --> 00:15:08.734
- as time goes on. Not only environmental changes but also the

00:15:09.122 --> 00:15:18.236
- CBU's Clear Creek project sped up the efficiency of the northern stretch of Clear Creek, which will

00:15:18.236 --> 00:15:27.806
- allow the water to move quickly south and cause potentially more flooding risk until that is alleviated.

00:15:29.698 --> 00:15:36.104
- Then we have the urban heat island effect. You can see here in the reddish and orangish colors that

00:15:36.104 --> 00:15:42.703
- we have a significant heat island effect in the downtown. That is exacerbated by lack of street trees.

00:15:42.703 --> 00:15:49.109
- And the street trees, you can see them on the count on the right side here. As anyone who's been on

00:15:49.109 --> 00:15:55.643
- College and Walnut knows, there are a bunch of trees and they don't grow very old. We have to replace

00:15:55.643 --> 00:15:58.718
- them because they don't have much room to grow.

00:15:58.818 --> 00:16:05.041
- They need more room than we currently allot them. And so they don't grow very old and they stay in eye-poking

00:16:05.041 --> 00:16:10.925
- range when you walk down the corridor. All right. So economic development is the third big reason. When

00:16:10.925 --> 00:16:16.639
- business leaders ask whether changing street geometry is worth the investment, we don't have to rely

00:16:16.639 --> 00:16:22.353
- on theory or speculation. We can look at hard empirical evidence from regional benchmarks right here

00:16:22.353 --> 00:16:24.446
- in Indiana and neighboring Kentucky.

00:16:24.578 --> 00:16:31.623
- that prove modernizing streets directly drives commercial property values and private investment. First,

00:16:31.623 --> 00:16:38.936
- we can take South Bend. When they restored their major north-south downtown arterials to two-way operations,

00:16:38.936 --> 00:16:45.780
- assessed commercial property values along the corridor increased by 21% over a five-year period. That

00:16:45.780 --> 00:16:52.624
- represents real tax-based growth and increased equity for property owners along those streets. Second

00:16:52.624 --> 00:16:53.630
- is Louisville.

00:16:53.794 --> 00:17:01.117
- We they had a three-year study of Brook Street, which was had a two-way conversion take place Property

00:17:01.117 --> 00:17:08.796
- values along Brook Street surged 39% Me way. Meanwhile on adjacent second and third Street one-way couplets

00:17:08.796 --> 00:17:16.048
- That obviously remained one way properties experienced a point for annual depreciation over that same

00:17:16.048 --> 00:17:18.750
- period that shows a stark contrast of

00:17:19.074 --> 00:17:25.430
- two-way restoration, create a thriving economic environment, while legacy one-way design caused property

00:17:25.430 --> 00:17:31.666
- values to stagnate and decline. In the original 2010 analysis, Only Brook Street and First Street were

00:17:31.666 --> 00:17:37.780
- proposed to be converted to two-way traffic, while Second and Third Street were proposed to maintain

00:17:37.780 --> 00:17:44.197
- their one-way status, acting as a control. By March 2018, both Second and Third Street had been converted

00:17:44.197 --> 00:17:48.798
- to two-way traffic, and under-utilized properties began to spring back with

00:17:48.962 --> 00:17:56.840
- to life with retail, hotel, parking, and office space. You can see Third Street prior to 2018 reconfiguration

00:17:56.840 --> 00:18:04.288
- and then after the 2018 reconfiguration. All right. And third, we have the Indianapolis Cultural Trail.

00:18:04.288 --> 00:18:11.521
- When Indianapolis invested in active transportation and pedestrian-focused street infrastructure, it

00:18:11.521 --> 00:18:16.606
- acted as a massive economic catalyst. Property values within one block

00:18:16.706 --> 00:18:23.297
- which is 500 feet in Indianapolis. It's about 330 feet here. The trail skyrocketed by 148%, generating

00:18:23.297 --> 00:18:29.888
- over a billion dollars in new assessed property values. We also did some outreach to other neighboring

00:18:29.888 --> 00:18:36.927
- cities to find out if their two-way conversions were successful. We reached out specifically to Indianapolis,

00:18:36.927 --> 00:18:43.134
- Columbus, Ohio, and Lafayette, Indiana. All had not only seen positive results, but have or were

00:18:43.298 --> 00:18:49.591
- Actively considering additional conversions. I spoke to Michael Berger from the greater Lafayette commerce,

00:18:49.591 --> 00:18:55.593
- which is similar to our chamber And he reported that worries before the conversion had not turned into

00:18:55.593 --> 00:19:01.420
- complaints afterward with no lingering stressors in parking Deliveries or traffic flow the takeaway

00:19:01.420 --> 00:19:07.422
- here is fairly clear streets designed purely for high-speed automobile via automobile throughput drain

00:19:07.522 --> 00:19:14.190
- value from adjacent properties, whereas streets designed for moderate speeds increase storefront visibility

00:19:14.190 --> 00:19:20.364
- and support walking and biking, creating long-term wealth for businesses and property owners alike.

00:19:20.364 --> 00:19:26.229
- And we can see kind of why that is for one reason here. In transportation engineering, there's

00:19:26.229 --> 00:19:32.465
- a well-documented phenomenon known as eclipsed frontage. When a driver approaches an intersection of

00:19:32.465 --> 00:19:36.478
- a multi-lane, one-way street, visual blind spots physically hide

00:19:36.866 --> 00:19:44.695
- 25% of near 25% of near-side storefronts from their line of sight you can kind of see how that happens

00:19:44.695 --> 00:19:52.449
- anywhere that is not in the one direction you're traveling will be Difficult if not impossible to see

00:19:52.449 --> 00:19:58.302
- especially if you're a driver you will not only have the Eclipse frontage of

00:19:59.426 --> 00:20:05.973
- of a business facing the wrong direction, but you also have your A and B pillar, which are the structural

00:20:05.973 --> 00:20:09.246
- components of your window blocking additional views.

00:20:13.986 --> 00:20:20.371
- And so you can see restoring two-way travel eliminates that blind spot entirely by combining traffic

00:20:20.371 --> 00:20:26.946
- moving on both directions. Every single storefront gains 100% visual exposure to drivers and passengers

00:20:26.946 --> 00:20:33.269
- coming from north and south. Furthermore, moderating speeds from highway levels down to comfortable

00:20:33.269 --> 00:20:35.102
- 20 to 25 miles an hour gives

00:20:35.202 --> 00:20:42.559
- people in cars, the reaction time needed to actually read signage, check out Windows displays, and decide

00:20:42.559 --> 00:20:49.846
- to stop and shop. This is a pretty good example of an eclipse frontage. This is College at Sixth Street.

00:20:49.846 --> 00:20:56.995
- This is a photo from the UDO. It features Pictura Gallery, which I believe now is Bluebird Couture and

00:20:56.995 --> 00:21:03.102
- has been a handful of other things since this picture was taken in the 2018 UDO update.

00:21:07.714 --> 00:21:14.493
- Okay, so the study systematically evaluated two build alternatives against community goals. Option one

00:21:14.493 --> 00:21:21.140
- maintains the one-way operation but puts the streets on a road diet, reducing three lanes to two and

00:21:21.140 --> 00:21:28.116
- adding an urban trail on both corridors. While this improves bicycle and pedestrian facilities, it leaves

00:21:28.116 --> 00:21:34.763
- primary problems in place. Drivers will still treat two open one-lane ways as a highway and economic

00:21:34.763 --> 00:21:36.606
- vitality will still suffer.

00:21:37.410 --> 00:21:45.022
- In order to match some of the speed reduction benefits of a two-way design, the one-way design would

00:21:45.022 --> 00:21:52.559
- also feature additional features such as raised mid-block crossings in areas with higher numbers of

00:21:52.559 --> 00:22:00.170
- pedestrians. It's kind of difficult to see, but you can maybe see the bump out if my mouse will ever

00:22:00.170 --> 00:22:06.878
- come on screen. That right there is a mid-block crossing where the two bump outs kind of

00:22:07.330 --> 00:22:14.038
- encroach into the parking lot. I can't see that. Can you point to it again? Yeah. Oh, sorry. Can you

00:22:14.038 --> 00:22:20.813
- see my mouse there? No. Just describe it for what part of it. In the middle of the blocks between 4th

00:22:20.813 --> 00:22:28.052
- and Kirkwood, you can see a pretty good example on college. You can see a pretty good example of a mid-block

00:22:28.052 --> 00:22:35.358
- bump out, which is an area where the curb cuts into the parking lane, further reducing crossing distances and

00:22:35.586 --> 00:22:44.550
- allowing pedestrians to be more visibly seen. All right, thank you. Yeah. OK. And then option B would

00:22:44.550 --> 00:22:53.777
- restore the College and Walnut to their original two-way motor vehicle operations with one motor vehicle

00:22:53.777 --> 00:23:02.302
- traveling per direction. This concept includes a center turn lane in key segments along College,

00:23:02.626 --> 00:23:10.241
- and includes intersection and signal upgrades to maintain motor vehicle traffic flow and improve multimodal

00:23:10.241 --> 00:23:17.644
- safety. The concept includes a new urban trail along Walnut Street, connecting neighborhoods to downtown

00:23:17.644 --> 00:23:25.118
- from the bypass to Allen Street. An urban trail would also run along College, north of 7th to the bypass.

00:23:29.186 --> 00:23:36.265
- Okay, here is how the right-of-way would be distributed within the existing 88 feet of required right-of-way.

00:23:36.265 --> 00:23:43.345
- On both streets, there will be space for 11-foot travel lanes, eight-foot sidewalks. On college specifically,

00:23:43.345 --> 00:23:49.973
- extra space will be allowed to expand to pedestrian space, including sidewalk, cafe, dining, space for

00:23:49.973 --> 00:23:57.310
- accessible bus shelters, and green stormwater infrastructure. On Walnut, in the downtown, pull in angled parking,

00:23:57.666 --> 00:24:04.714
- Will be provided on both sides of the street. This is sorry along courthouse square Pulling angled parking

00:24:04.714 --> 00:24:11.565
- will be provided as well as a 10-foot urban trail that provides physically separated and raised Bicycle

00:24:11.565 --> 00:24:18.415
- and pedestrian traffic that's separated from motor vehicles And then at intersection curb bumpouts will

00:24:18.415 --> 00:24:20.062
- shorten street crossings

00:24:22.562 --> 00:24:29.429
- This is an example of what an urban trail kind of looks like. This is the cultural trail in Indianapolis.

00:24:29.429 --> 00:24:36.426
- This connected Fountain Square to downtown. If you're familiar with Indianapolis, this is an area, Fletcher

00:24:36.426 --> 00:24:42.904
- Place is an area that runs through this and was a gray, kind of sad, desolate, vacant area, and now

00:24:42.904 --> 00:24:49.706
- features two of the most famous restaurants in probably Indiana, in Bluebeard and Milktooth, if anyone's

00:24:49.706 --> 00:24:51.326
- familiar with those two.

00:24:53.186 --> 00:25:00.030
- All right, we had a single standard one-way urban traveling with coordinated traffic signals comfortably

00:25:00.030 --> 00:25:06.874
- carries about 1,000 vehicles an hour in an urban setting. At its busiest intersection along the corridor

00:25:06.874 --> 00:25:12.805
- of College South of Kirkwood, like I mentioned, reached 931 vehicles per hour, meaning our

00:25:12.805 --> 00:25:19.649
- busiest intersection does not reach the capacity of a single lane. Today, we are dedicating two to three

00:25:19.649 --> 00:25:21.278
- lanes in each direction.

00:25:22.114 --> 00:25:28.230
- Even though that two-way design will right-size vehicle travel lanes, our traffic engineering capacity

00:25:28.230 --> 00:25:34.228
- models show that every intersection will continue operating smoothly at a level of service A through

00:25:34.228 --> 00:25:40.166
- C. At the same time, we're proposing critical safety treatments like protected turns, truck aprons,

00:25:40.166 --> 00:25:44.382
- and leading pedestrian intervals to protect people walking and biking.

00:25:47.266 --> 00:25:52.984
- The consultant modeled every single signalized intersection along the corridor. That modeling found

00:25:52.984 --> 00:25:59.274
- that under two-way operations with signal timing and dedicated turnpockets where required, every intersection

00:25:59.274 --> 00:26:05.278
- would maintain that level of service A through C. And the two-way design during peak evening rush hours,

00:26:05.278 --> 00:26:11.281
- motor vehicles on College and Kirkwood will operate at a level of service B down from a level of service

00:26:11.281 --> 00:26:13.054
- A. It's important here to note

00:26:13.218 --> 00:26:18.933
- I'm sure transportation commission members will have heard me say this before, but just for everyone,

00:26:18.933 --> 00:26:24.591
- it's important to note that level of service uses letters similar to a grading scale, but they don't

00:26:24.591 --> 00:26:30.530
- function as a grading scale, meaning a level of service of A is not the best possible condition. Instead,

00:26:30.530 --> 00:26:36.356
- it describes how vehicles move through the intersection. In this case, level of service A means traffic

00:26:36.356 --> 00:26:40.446
- is free to flow through with low volumes and conditions for high speeds.

00:26:40.674 --> 00:26:46.286
- Level service A is expected on highways. I-69, State Road 37, those are expected to be designed at a

00:26:46.286 --> 00:26:52.510
- level of service A, not in urban areas with high numbers of conflict points, pedestrians, and turning vehicles.

00:26:55.458 --> 00:27:00.941
- Some other logistics here we heard important feedback regarding delivery trucks parking and emergency

00:27:00.941 --> 00:27:06.423
- response during our public engagement Today delivery trucks have no dedicated space to unload So they

00:27:06.423 --> 00:27:12.014
- double park in active travel lanes creating danger dangerous sudden merges and traffic delays on walnut

00:27:12.014 --> 00:27:17.443
- Six between six and seventh is kind of the highlighted area that everybody thinks about when they're

00:27:17.443 --> 00:27:22.818
- talking about this issue There are often two delivery trucks reducing the number of available lanes

00:27:22.818 --> 00:27:23.678
- to just one and

00:27:24.386 --> 00:27:29.994
- Proposed design resolves this by creating dedicated curbside loading space adjacent to the curb These

00:27:29.994 --> 00:27:35.602
- loading zones will be designed around the businesses on each block face Meaning we can go in and talk

00:27:35.602 --> 00:27:41.266
- to those businesses to find out what their needs are So some blocks may find it necessary to have more

00:27:41.266 --> 00:27:46.654
- loading zones than others While others may prefer prefer additional on-street parking be provided

00:27:47.906 --> 00:27:54.276
- The design for college will feature a continuous center turn lane, which will allow emergency vehicles

00:27:54.276 --> 00:28:00.461
- to utilize the space, allowing first responders to maneuver around vehicles that are stopped on the

00:28:00.461 --> 00:28:01.822
- vehicle travel lanes.

00:28:02.370 --> 00:28:09.002
- Today the entire corridor features 404 meter spaces But those spaces many of those spaces see little

00:28:09.002 --> 00:28:15.634
- to not no utilization especially in the northern and southern extents outside of the downtown in The

00:28:15.634 --> 00:28:22.332
- core of downtown where parking is most utilized which is third through seventh. It has 143 spaces the

00:28:22.332 --> 00:28:27.454
- proposed two-way design the entire corridor will feature 253 meter spaces and

00:28:27.618 --> 00:28:34.530
- However, the core downtown, it will actually increase the number of parking from 143 to 144, while also

00:28:34.530 --> 00:28:41.509
- providing those dedicated loading zones. This is because slower speeds and the design of two-way streets

00:28:41.509 --> 00:28:48.222
- allow for additional rows of angled parking. So you can see here, oops, you can see here, maybe, you

00:28:48.222 --> 00:28:55.200
- can't really see here, but I promise there are lines that show pull-in angled parking along both College

00:28:55.200 --> 00:28:55.998
- and Walnut.

00:28:56.194 --> 00:29:03.911
- Between Kirkwood and six, especially that if you look at the the grander scheme You can see that additional

00:29:03.911 --> 00:29:11.342
- angled parking is provided south of Kirkwood Okay So a big question that everybody likes to think about

00:29:11.342 --> 00:29:18.773
- is how much will this cost the one-way design has in 20 $26 has a hundred and three million dollar cost

00:29:18.773 --> 00:29:24.990
- estimate and the two-way design has a hundred nine million dollar cost estimate that's

00:29:25.090 --> 00:29:32.789
- $6 million difference. And that is for total reconstruction estimates. It is not how much we're spending

00:29:32.789 --> 00:29:40.414
- on this project. This is just if you were to design or to dedicate the funding tomorrow, how much would

00:29:40.414 --> 00:29:47.967
- it cost? And that's just to give us an idea of cost benefit analysis. But it's important to know those

00:29:47.967 --> 00:29:53.246
- numbers. The consultant did a design comparison of the existing design,

00:29:53.442 --> 00:30:02.124
- one-way concept in the two-way concept versus the stated community goals at the onset, which come from

00:30:02.124 --> 00:30:11.228
- the transportation plan, the climate action plan, the comprehensive plan, and other related city documents,

00:30:11.228 --> 00:30:19.742
- as well as what we heard from feedback during our public engagement. And they compared each of those

00:30:20.546 --> 00:30:29.411
- goals against each other and so black dot here is the design contributes to outcomes that strongly conflict

00:30:29.411 --> 00:30:37.128
- with those goals. The white dot is that they just conflict. What is happening to my computer?

00:30:37.128 --> 00:30:45.501
- I'm not sure, sorry about that. The black circle with the white dot is they conflict. The blue circle

00:30:45.501 --> 00:30:48.702
- with the bluish color in the middle is

00:30:48.802 --> 00:30:56.443
- that they support our goals. And then the solid blue is that they strongly support. And you can see

00:30:56.443 --> 00:31:04.695
- the big separation between the one-way concept and the two-way concept. Both of them have big improvements.

00:31:04.695 --> 00:31:12.488
- The one-way concept is better for pedestrians and bicyclists. It features the urban trail on both. We

00:31:12.488 --> 00:31:18.142
- know that in some cases, pedestrians are safer on one-way design streets.

00:31:18.434 --> 00:31:25.486
- However, it depends on the pedestrian. So the most vulnerable, you see a lower case of safety. So that

00:31:25.486 --> 00:31:32.333
- means children and people over the age of 65 are less safe on one-way streets just due to the speed

00:31:32.333 --> 00:31:39.659
- of vehicles, oncoming vehicles. So that gets a higher score than the two-way. But you can see that there's

00:31:39.659 --> 00:31:46.026
- pretty strong negative points in the street network resilience. You can see today that we're

00:31:46.026 --> 00:31:47.806
- doing construction on the

00:31:47.906 --> 00:31:55.977
- convention center and that is at one point completely closed college. That is a design where engineering

00:31:55.977 --> 00:31:57.438
- and the consultant

00:31:57.538 --> 00:32:02.973
- Determine what vehicles would do and they found that 50% of the vehicles they weren't sure where they

00:32:02.973 --> 00:32:08.355
- would go They knew that 50% would take Rogers and or other dedicated streets But for 50% they didn't

00:32:08.355 --> 00:32:13.737
- know where they would go and that's because there is no what network resiliency You could go over to

00:32:13.737 --> 00:32:19.172
- Rogers and then if you don't do that, where do you go? You probably take Washington and that backs up

00:32:19.172 --> 00:32:24.501
- in front of two sticks or wherever so the two-way design increases the grid that we don't currently

00:32:24.501 --> 00:32:26.366
- see much of in the north-south and

00:32:26.626 --> 00:32:34.431
- other than Rogers. And then navigability is difficult on one way, especially for people who are unfamiliar

00:32:34.431 --> 00:32:41.799
- with the city. You see a lot of people with Illinois license plates turning the wrong way on college

00:32:41.799 --> 00:32:48.510
- if you hang out on a corridor long enough. Okay. I don't know what's going on. There we go.

00:32:55.554 --> 00:33:01.115
- So I want to pause here and address the most immediate question on many people's minds, and that is,

00:33:01.115 --> 00:33:06.786
- when does this happen if this were to be adopted? And I want to be perfectly clear, two-way conversion

00:33:06.786 --> 00:33:12.347
- is not happening anytime soon. Tonight's resolution does not schedule road closures. It does not set

00:33:12.347 --> 00:33:18.018
- a start date for two-way traffic. In any long-term corridor reconstruction, changing traffic direction

00:33:18.018 --> 00:33:21.982
- is the very last step of phased implementation. It's not the beginning.

00:33:24.098 --> 00:33:29.753
- The vast majority of safety and public rail improvements within the plan, including building the urban

00:33:29.753 --> 00:33:35.298
- trail, adding pedestrian improvements, and modernizing the streetscape and stormwater infrastructure

00:33:35.298 --> 00:33:40.953
- can be constructed and operated under our existing one-way traffic pattern. Moving forward, the city's

00:33:40.953 --> 00:33:46.497
- approach, as outlined in the proposed amendment to the transportation plan, is to be incremental and

00:33:46.497 --> 00:33:47.870
- financially disciplined.

00:33:48.098 --> 00:33:54.159
- The updated corridor design will target improvements segment by segment during scheduled street resurfacing

00:33:54.159 --> 00:33:59.939
- and adjacent property redevelopment. This is the same approach that every other corridor in the city's

00:33:59.939 --> 00:34:05.775
- transportation plan is designed using. When construction happens adjacent to the right of way, the city

00:34:05.775 --> 00:34:11.555
- and developers look at the transportation plan to determine what infrastructure elements are required,

00:34:11.555 --> 00:34:16.830
- including sidewalks, tree plots, and intersection improvements. So this will be no different.

00:34:17.474 --> 00:34:23.797
- Adopting this amendment to the transportation plan allows the city to aggressively pursue competitive

00:34:23.797 --> 00:34:29.995
- grants. For example, USDOT raise grants, like peer cities have done, ensuring that we bring outside

00:34:29.995 --> 00:34:36.318
- federal dollars into Bloomington to rebuild our infrastructure. Those funds will be used to construct

00:34:36.318 --> 00:34:42.888
- those safety improvements outlined in the plan over time. So to summarize, like the entire transportation

00:34:42.888 --> 00:34:45.182
- plan, this is a 20 plus year vision.

00:34:45.506 --> 00:34:52.859
- safety upgrades come first under the streets as they currently operate and Operational conversion remains

00:34:52.859 --> 00:34:59.935
- a long-term carefully evaluated future phase Okay, as Commissioner Boland mentioned this is the first

00:34:59.935 --> 00:35:06.872
- step in multiple public engagement and boards and Commission review So we're here at Transportation

00:35:06.872 --> 00:35:08.190
- Commission tonight

00:35:08.418 --> 00:35:17.597
- of ultimately this will go to plan commission for their recommendation and finally common council for

00:35:17.597 --> 00:35:26.867
- approval or adoption. Okay with all of that being said we have criteria in the municipal code that the

00:35:26.867 --> 00:35:36.766
- transportation commission is required to find before adopting any resolution and these criteria include sorry

00:35:37.026 --> 00:35:42.705
- that it is consistent with the comprehensive plan and other applicable city goals. I listed a bunch

00:35:42.705 --> 00:35:48.554
- of applicable city goals, but I'll highlight here goal 4.2, which supports local businesses, encourage

00:35:48.554 --> 00:35:54.233
- and support local businesses, the arts and cultural events downtown, promote walking and biking and

00:35:54.233 --> 00:36:00.309
- public transit, continue to integrate all modes into the transportation network and to prioritize bicycle,

00:36:00.309 --> 00:36:03.262
- pedestrian, public transit and other non-automotive

00:36:03.362 --> 00:36:10.185
- modes to make our network equally accessible, safe, and efficient for all road users, and built environment

00:36:10.185 --> 00:36:16.692
- in Greenscape to drive increased efficiency and reduce environmental impacts on the built environment.

00:36:16.692 --> 00:36:23.262
- Next is, is it consistent with the best practices for eliminating all transportation-related fatalities

00:36:23.262 --> 00:36:30.022
- and serious injuries within the city? The study advances the city's goals of eliminating fatal and serious

00:36:30.022 --> 00:36:33.054
- injury crashes by addressing documented safety,

00:36:33.442 --> 00:36:40.525
- Concerns along two of Bloomington's highest risk corridors the proposed design applies proven safe system

00:36:40.525 --> 00:36:47.273
- strategies to reduce vehicle speeds improve intersections and provide safer separated facilities for

00:36:47.273 --> 00:36:54.022
- vulnerable road users It is it consistent with the Advancing a sustainable transportation system and

00:36:54.022 --> 00:36:57.630
- equitable access to all transportation facility users

00:36:57.762 --> 00:37:02.989
- While prioritizing on automotive modes, this study advances a sustainable, equitable, and multimodal

00:37:02.989 --> 00:37:08.319
- transportation system by reallocating roadway space to prioritize walking, biking, and public transit.

00:37:08.319 --> 00:37:13.546
- The proposed improvements will close gaps in pedestrian and bicycle networks, improve accessibility,

00:37:13.546 --> 00:37:18.462
- and provide safer, more connected transportation options for people of all ages and abilities.

00:37:20.930 --> 00:37:26.986
- Has it adequately conducted public engagement and considered community centric design tied to targeted

00:37:26.986 --> 00:37:32.983
- outcomes the studying included extensive public engagement with residents businesses and stakeholders

00:37:32.983 --> 00:37:38.862
- throughout the planning process with feedback directly informing the preferred design the resulting

00:37:38.862 --> 00:37:45.035
- concept balances safety accessibility and multimodal connectivity with businesses needs downtown parking

00:37:45.035 --> 00:37:48.798
- and loading needs and environmental improvements all considered

00:37:50.050 --> 00:37:55.958
- All right. And so with all that said, staff recommends that the transportation commission forward the

00:37:55.958 --> 00:38:01.982
- proposed amendment to the transportation plan with a positive recommendation to the city of Bloomington

00:38:01.982 --> 00:38:07.775
- plan commission and common council. And I can answer any questions. Thank you for the presentation,

00:38:07.775 --> 00:38:14.031
- Mr. Roebling. Let me just clarify that the items listed under the case in the agenda, you weren't intending

00:38:14.031 --> 00:38:19.070
- to present every document. They're simply there for us and for the public to, to read.

00:38:19.298 --> 00:38:26.127
- Yes, and I'm happy to open up and discuss any document you have a question about. Yeah. Okay. Well,

00:38:26.127 --> 00:38:33.229
- there are a bunch of substantial documents here in support of this, but it's time now to open the floor

00:38:33.229 --> 00:38:40.126
- to questions from commissioners for TCR 2622. Let's start on my left. Is there anyone who would like

00:38:40.126 --> 00:38:47.774
- to ask questions? I hope everyone will have some. Mr. Stossberg. Mr. Robley, this design reduces road capacity.

00:38:47.938 --> 00:38:54.897
- Well, it's intended to service for decades. So how do we do those projections for what our capacity

00:38:54.897 --> 00:39:01.857
- would be in the future? And sort of what's the expected lifespan of this design of we don't want to

00:39:01.857 --> 00:39:08.816
- make a road smaller and then find that it doesn't service in 10 years? Yeah, great question. So the

00:39:08.816 --> 00:39:15.358
- consultant looked at the current day numbers rather than projected growth numbers because the

00:39:15.554 --> 00:39:21.974
- current design of the roadway and proposed design of the roadway are both so overbuilt for capacity.

00:39:21.974 --> 00:39:28.393
- We have so much ample space that would be required that you could essentially increase those numbers

00:39:28.393 --> 00:39:34.813
- back up to the 1976 numbers and you would still have capacity available. So that those are including

00:39:34.813 --> 00:39:41.360
- regional and interstate transportation users who aren't intending to be in Bloomington. So even if our

00:39:41.360 --> 00:39:43.966
- population grew by that number, we would

00:39:44.386 --> 00:39:51.817
- safely and comfortably be able to manage that number. Questions to my left. Mr. Coppock, please get

00:39:51.817 --> 00:39:59.546
- close to the mic and turn it on. You mentioned the street trees in the corridor south and South College

00:39:59.546 --> 00:40:07.051
- and in that section in there. But is the city's policy still to have the build forward with the bill

00:40:07.051 --> 00:40:14.334
- to go up against the right away? And doesn't that decrease your growth of trees in there? I mean,

00:40:15.042 --> 00:40:21.562
- There are, that's a great question, there are areas in the downtown that do require build forward buildings

00:40:21.562 --> 00:40:27.841
- that is not the entirety of the corridor, especially in that southern stretch. The downtown has special

00:40:27.841 --> 00:40:33.939
- UDO requirements that require building forward that potentially could limit the number of trees, but

00:40:33.939 --> 00:40:40.097
- street trees aren't provided on private property, they're provided in the right of way in a tree plot

00:40:40.097 --> 00:40:42.814
- that is different than the private property.

00:40:45.698 --> 00:40:52.566
- And I got another question, too. Of course, the fatalities that you noted really aren't related to speed.

00:40:52.566 --> 00:40:59.304
- I mean, from what the reports I read on those, I think you gave them to everybody else. I mean, I don't

00:40:59.304 --> 00:41:05.913
- know that this would reduce that. So I think that's kind of misleading in there. Is that a comment or

00:41:05.913 --> 00:41:12.457
- a question? That's a comment, I guess. Or maybe it's a question as to whether he thinks it's related

00:41:12.457 --> 00:41:14.142
- to speed of the vehicles.

00:41:14.306 --> 00:41:22.622
- Mr. Roebling? Yeah, so it's best practice to not focus on any individual crash and instead to take the

00:41:22.622 --> 00:41:31.099
- entire corridor. But I will say that there is at least one fatal crash that was speed related. Certainly

00:41:31.099 --> 00:41:39.173
- there was a motorcycle driving at high speeds that caused a crash. There are two others where speed

00:41:39.173 --> 00:41:41.918
- wasn't the immediate cause of the

00:41:42.050 --> 00:41:49.508
- that crash. But again, going back to the safe systems approach, we know that slower vehicles cause fewer

00:41:49.508 --> 00:41:56.682
- fatalities. One more question. When you mentioned South Bend and Louisville, I think in part of what

00:41:56.682 --> 00:42:04.282
- you said, were those areas that were underutilized in redevelopment type areas as opposed to this quarter,

00:42:04.282 --> 00:42:10.462
- which most of it's pretty well developed and established? Well, I would challenge that

00:42:10.754 --> 00:42:17.242
- The downtown is certainly well established in Bloomington. I would say that the southern stretch features

00:42:17.242 --> 00:42:23.363
- very few buildings. There's the rallies and then the post office, but few else. And then similar to

00:42:23.363 --> 00:42:29.484
- the north, there's longstanding vacancies. But Bloomington, or sorry, Louisville and South Bend, to

00:42:29.484 --> 00:42:36.094
- answer that portion of the question, both were economically depressed areas, but not completely eliminated.

00:42:36.194 --> 00:42:44.384
- area in Louisville is where the convention center was located. It was as hopping as a convention center

00:42:44.384 --> 00:42:52.888
- in a major American city can be. Let's go to some other questions. Any questions on my right? Mr. Flaherty.

00:42:52.888 --> 00:43:00.841
- Thank you for the presentation. Looking at the staff recommendation among the two options that would

00:43:00.841 --> 00:43:05.566
- broadly aim to improve safety and achieve the city's goals,

00:43:06.242 --> 00:43:12.510
- The recommendation is the two-way conversion. You mentioned that there would be a phased approach, obviously

00:43:12.510 --> 00:43:18.319
- funding contingent over many years, potentially decades. Can you tell us a little bit more about the

00:43:18.319 --> 00:43:24.185
- phasing and how much or most of the infrastructure and safety improvements could be made in a kind of

00:43:24.185 --> 00:43:29.533
- sequenced way before changing traffic flow? And if you have any examples, I know New Albany,

00:43:29.533 --> 00:43:32.926
- Indiana is one. South Bend, obviously, Indiana is another.

00:43:33.058 --> 00:43:41.030
- that have converted or restored, really, you know, major arterials to, you know, back to two-way traffic,

00:43:41.030 --> 00:43:48.927
- kind of, any insights, I guess, gleaned from, like, yeah, that combination and phasing of infrastructure

00:43:48.927 --> 00:43:56.522
- versus traffic flow and how that, you would anticipate that proceeding. Yeah, so Bloomington is, the

00:43:56.522 --> 00:44:02.238
- corridor is kind of unique in the stretch, so New Albany and South Bend are

00:44:02.370 --> 00:44:09.541
- good examples of quarter cities that successfully converted and benefits of those. But they needed slightly

00:44:09.541 --> 00:44:16.181
- fewer improvements that potentially Bloomington would need depending on the type of improvement you

00:44:16.181 --> 00:44:21.758
- need. And then so for phasing like I said the city does projects all the time along

00:44:21.922 --> 00:44:29.824
- both corridors where we repave, we do curb improvements, curb ramp improvements, et cetera. And we can

00:44:29.824 --> 00:44:37.573
- continue to do those. They should not largely intersect with the fact that they'll be outside of the

00:44:37.573 --> 00:44:45.552
- two-way conversation. So we can convert those and have those safety benefits in the meantime, including

00:44:45.552 --> 00:44:50.462
- things like the urban trail. And then towards the end, the big,

00:44:50.562 --> 00:44:57.123
- question is the forty one intersections and converting those will need traffic signals that are updated

00:44:57.123 --> 00:45:03.811
- which will include things like right of way acquisition probably short term this is a wide enough quarter

00:45:03.811 --> 00:45:10.183
- that we shouldn't need to buy property from anyone but short-term property conversion so that we can

00:45:10.183 --> 00:45:16.808
- build those new that new infrastructure which will take time and that's kind of the the far-off distance

00:45:16.808 --> 00:45:17.502
- that's the

00:45:17.634 --> 00:45:24.727
- That's really the heart of where we'll be looking for federal funding to do. You kind of aim to do it

00:45:24.727 --> 00:45:32.097
- in one fell swoop kind of towards the end while you get all of the safety improvements with redevelopment

00:45:32.097 --> 00:45:39.120
- and city projects along the way. Just a small follow up. So thinking, if you're constructing shorter

00:45:39.120 --> 00:45:45.726
- cross distances, narrower kind of curb to curb distances, potentially putting in urban trails,

00:45:45.826 --> 00:45:53.094
- like that could all happen while the pair of one-way traffic remains, which would also, I presume, entail

00:45:53.094 --> 00:46:00.018
- reducing the number of vehicle travel lanes to two, you know, from three before the actual potential

00:46:00.018 --> 00:46:06.943
- restoration of two-way traffic. Is that right? Like, am I imagining how the phasing would work? Yes.

00:46:06.943 --> 00:46:14.005
- That would be the ultimate plan is to slowly over time reduce those safety concerns or improve safety.

00:46:14.005 --> 00:46:15.582
- Thank you. Mr. Binder.

00:46:17.602 --> 00:46:25.523
- You spoke a little bit, you touched on the likelihood that the cost of this project in whatever form

00:46:25.523 --> 00:46:33.759
- it might take in the future would be potentially substantially covered by various external funding grant

00:46:33.759 --> 00:46:40.190
- opportunities, state and federal. Could you give us some examples of the types of

00:46:40.642 --> 00:46:46.756
- funding programs that the city's used in the past for projects like this. I'd just be curious to know

00:46:46.756 --> 00:46:52.930
- or get an idea. Obviously it's hard to predict in the future what kinds of, especially I think federal

00:46:52.930 --> 00:46:58.924
- grant opportunities might arise, but maybe just giving us some sense of the degree to which some of

00:46:58.924 --> 00:47:04.798
- the costs might be covered or over what type of time span federal grants might cover these costs.

00:47:05.122 --> 00:47:11.644
- Yeah, that's a great question. I basically can't answer it, but I can answer it because the way federal

00:47:11.644 --> 00:47:18.103
- funding works, new Congress comes up with a new title for a new thing that does substantially the same

00:47:18.103 --> 00:47:24.624
- thing. But Kalamazoo did a similar project using USDOT raise grants. There's the Safe Streets and Roads

00:47:24.624 --> 00:47:31.209
- for All safety grants that are out there, implementation grants. This would be an eligible project among

00:47:31.209 --> 00:47:33.278
- those. And so there's a bunch of

00:47:33.538 --> 00:47:39.806
- There's basically always a federal program that you could tap into, what it's called, and when it is

00:47:39.806 --> 00:47:46.198
- available, it just changes every year. But there's lots of grant opportunities out there. Indianapolis

00:47:46.198 --> 00:47:52.466
- did theirs, the cultural trail, with the support of the, I think it's the Lilly Foundation, I forget

00:47:52.466 --> 00:47:59.169
- off the top of my head, but substantial non-federal grant that we, you know, something we could potentially

00:47:59.169 --> 00:48:00.286
- look for as well.

00:48:04.002 --> 00:48:12.461
- for the questions to my right, to my left. Let me take a crack first if nobody else has first round

00:48:12.461 --> 00:48:21.174
- questions. Can we go back to that slide that said FSI crashes? And while you're pulling that up, I did

00:48:21.174 --> 00:48:29.888
- note something that said transit facilities suffer more under a one way in that chart of outcomes. One

00:48:29.888 --> 00:48:32.510
- of the downsides for a two way

00:48:33.314 --> 00:48:40.476
- Or for a one way was that trans facilities are less advantage. And I wondered why that was. Because

00:48:40.476 --> 00:48:47.924
- it seems like in a one way scheme there'd be room for say a dedicated bus lane. But in a two way scheme

00:48:47.924 --> 00:48:55.085
- there wouldn't be. So I wondered about that. That would also be a part of a slide too. I'm going to

00:48:55.085 --> 00:49:02.462
- take that second part first and you might have to remind me on the first. OK so trans facilities here.

00:49:02.562 --> 00:49:09.690
- It says it's slightly worse for transit under one way, but much better under a two way. How do you explain

00:49:09.690 --> 00:49:16.351
- that? Yeah, so transit and I'll let, oh shoot, I just met him and I've already forgot his name. The

00:49:16.351 --> 00:49:23.212
- new manager of Bloomington Transit is here. I'll let him correct me if I'm wrong. But transit and fire

00:49:23.212 --> 00:49:29.874
- are both unique in that one way facilities hinder their movement. They want to be able to travel in

00:49:29.874 --> 00:49:31.006
- both directions.

00:49:31.426 --> 00:49:37.340
- you know, stabilize the network and make more connections easier and more feasible. Whereas the one

00:49:37.340 --> 00:49:43.431
- way, they're either all on, all the pickups are on college or they're all on Walnut, depending on what

00:49:43.431 --> 00:49:49.640
- direction the traffic, or yeah, the bus is heading. Whereas the two way, you know, if more pickups would

00:49:49.640 --> 00:49:55.732
- happen on college, they can convert to college. So that's kind of the reason it suffers facility-wide.

00:49:55.732 --> 00:50:01.054
- Can you go back to the FSI slide now? I only noted that there was a question I had on it,

00:50:01.602 --> 00:50:09.554
- I won't remember until I see it. It said FSI crashes. Okay, so I don't think I quite followed

00:50:09.554 --> 00:50:18.266
- your explanation here because this went by quickly. What does the blue, the purple, and the green line

00:50:18.266 --> 00:50:23.934
- mean? Yeah, so the, great question, the light blue at the top is a

00:50:24.034 --> 00:50:29.810
- signalized five-lane capacity road. That would be two southbound travel lanes, two northbound travel

00:50:29.810 --> 00:50:36.100
- lanes, and that center turn lane. That doesn't exist now. This is just an example. No, that's a hypothetical.

00:50:36.100 --> 00:50:41.875
- Yes, exactly. In some stretches, we essentially have a six-lane highway. And so that would be a road

00:50:41.875 --> 00:50:47.651
- diet from six lanes. So are you saying that that blue line represents the current capacity of Walnut

00:50:47.651 --> 00:50:53.598
- and College now? No, because it's not designed that way, as you mentioned. But I'm just saying, this is

00:50:53.826 --> 00:51:01.186
- A hypothetical, this is a strode, if you will, if you're familiar with the term. Yes. The ideal strode,

00:51:01.186 --> 00:51:08.900
- not that you have an ideal strode. Strodes are not ideal, no. Yes, but a five lane capacity, two directional

00:51:08.900 --> 00:51:16.190
- travel lanes, and then the... Okay, so the purple line? The purple line is the signalized one way, one

00:51:16.190 --> 00:51:19.870
- lane travel lane, so that would be Walnut or, well,

00:51:20.034 --> 00:51:25.878
- They don't have signals. But Walnut and Lincoln, but with signals, would be that purple line. Whoa,

00:51:25.878 --> 00:51:31.780
- Walnut is two lanes. No, not Walnut. Sorry. Washington and Lincoln. A one-lane, one-way street would

00:51:31.780 --> 00:51:37.974
- function at that purple line. So you're saying that that purple line can carry as much traffic as College

00:51:37.974 --> 00:51:43.877
- Avenue sees? Yeah. Even just one lane could manage that kind of traffic? As long as it's signalized.

00:51:43.877 --> 00:51:49.662
- And yes. OK. And then the green line below it? The green line below it is this three-lane capacity

00:51:49.986 --> 00:51:58.504
- design to the right, that's your standard travel, urban design travel lane, which is one northbound,

00:51:58.504 --> 00:52:07.276
- one southbound lane, and then a dedicated turn lane. So why is it that a green, the green line has less

00:52:07.276 --> 00:52:13.854
- capacity than the purple one? Because of the design, the turning vehicles and

00:52:14.754 --> 00:52:22.227
- The turning vehicles will essentially slow traffic down. They are sometimes in the way of through traffic.

00:52:22.227 --> 00:52:29.210
- So you're saying that the purple line represents a single lane going one way and turns and straight

00:52:29.210 --> 00:52:36.264
- traffic both are in the same lane. And nevertheless, it carries that slightly more traffic than this

00:52:36.264 --> 00:52:43.806
- scheme here. Yeah, right. Because anyone going into the intersection will be moving immediately through it.

00:52:43.970 --> 00:52:52.187
- have to slow down and navigate the oncoming traffic. I have more questions, but I'll defer to a second

00:52:52.187 --> 00:53:00.324
- round of first round questions. Anyone who has not yet asked is favored, but I think Mr. Coppock, you

00:53:00.324 --> 00:53:08.541
- had another question? What kind of response have you got from the Chamber of Commerce and the downtown

00:53:08.541 --> 00:53:13.726
- businesses? I don't believe the chamber actually formally made a

00:53:14.050 --> 00:53:21.601
- recommendation through written response, although I see Mr. M.G. I won't throw him under the bus here,

00:53:21.601 --> 00:53:29.005
- but I believe he is here to speak on their behalf. And then downtown Bloomington incorporated sent a

00:53:29.005 --> 00:53:36.849
- letter of remonstrance, and that is included in the packet. And you can see their objections and concerns.

00:53:36.849 --> 00:53:42.494
- Anything else, Mr. Coppock? OK, further questions to my left, Mr. Stossberg.

00:53:43.330 --> 00:53:51.207
- In your review of other cities who have done one-way to two-way conversions, did you find any that found

00:53:51.207 --> 00:53:58.033
- that they didn't work and then moved back? Yeah, so we did a ton of research on that. That

00:53:58.033 --> 00:54:05.535
- was the million-dollar question, essentially. We found exactly one who had a concern post-adoption.

00:54:05.535 --> 00:54:09.886
- And it was not from the city. It was just from residents.

00:54:10.082 --> 00:54:16.174
- they, it's the city of Columbus, Ohio converted a street. I can't remember off the top of my

00:54:16.174 --> 00:54:22.921
- head, unfortunately, um, in a residential area and the two way design brought additional truck traffic

00:54:22.921 --> 00:54:29.602
- through and they, the residents weren't happy with that, but otherwise the safety benefits, um, were,

00:54:29.602 --> 00:54:36.218
- you know, uh, like I mentioned, Columbus was continuing to pursue conversion of one way arterials to

00:54:36.218 --> 00:54:37.790
- my right. Mr. Flaherty.

00:54:38.850 --> 00:54:48.180
- Thank you. Thinking about funding, can you talk a little bit more about how this might proceed practically

00:54:48.180 --> 00:54:56.900
- in the years to come? I know there's a lot of unknowns. We obviously can do things at the city like

00:54:56.900 --> 00:55:05.620
- bond, issue bonds. And some of that, we have the MPO that has funding that's allocated according to

00:55:05.620 --> 00:55:08.062
- certain plans and policies.

00:55:08.450 --> 00:55:14.865
- one could imagine in a future federal government administration that there might be grant programs to

00:55:14.865 --> 00:55:21.469
- support safe streets. As far as the magnitude of what we're talking, can you say a little bit more about

00:55:21.469 --> 00:55:27.884
- all that? It's a big price tag, but it's hard to consider all at once. Do we imagine that there might

00:55:27.884 --> 00:55:34.299
- be federal grant programs where up to $25 million would be available or something like that? And same

00:55:34.299 --> 00:55:37.758
- thing with, again, the magnitudes of what's realistic.

00:55:37.858 --> 00:55:47.266
- with respect to city bonding, with respect to the MPO funding, and on what timelines? Yeah, great question.

00:55:47.266 --> 00:55:56.238
- Hold on, sorry. Yeah, so grant funding often does not come with a $100 million price tag unless you're

00:55:56.238 --> 00:56:00.158
- a huge city like Chicago or Washington, D.C.

00:56:00.290 --> 00:56:06.476
- Cities our size generally see 25 20 million dollar grants and so that would not cover the entirety of

00:56:06.476 --> 00:56:12.904
- the corridor and instead we would do things like I mentioned those safety improvements along the corridor

00:56:12.904 --> 00:56:19.030
- that would allow us to in the future target additional grant funding and then you know think about a

00:56:19.030 --> 00:56:25.155
- conversion way off in the future but in the meantime get those bulb outs those that urban trail that

00:56:25.155 --> 00:56:25.822
- pedestrian

00:56:26.018 --> 00:56:33.136
- Network completion and things like that including through the MPO college and walnut are in the current

00:56:33.136 --> 00:56:40.049
- tip Not the conversion obviously, but pedestrian safety improvements and things like that are in the

00:56:40.049 --> 00:56:47.099
- current tip and then Something like the urban trail if this is ultimately approved are in the upcoming

00:56:47.099 --> 00:56:52.574
- tip Just yeah, so we'll continue to target little bits like that and make those

00:56:52.674 --> 00:57:00.073
- improvements. That's basically the only way you can do this. You'll never get that hundred million dollars.

00:57:00.073 --> 00:57:07.061
- Just to explain that a tip is a transportation improvement program that's that's a subject of federal

00:57:07.061 --> 00:57:14.049
- or state management. Is that right? Exactly correct. Yes, it's through the we would apply through the

00:57:14.049 --> 00:57:21.448
- Bloomington Mineral County Metropolitan Planning Organization. Thank you. A brief follow up on the category

00:57:21.448 --> 00:57:22.270
- of bonding.

00:57:23.746 --> 00:57:31.537
- There's different types of bonds that we can consider. One is tax increment financing. We've used that

00:57:31.537 --> 00:57:39.328
- for a lot of infrastructure in Bloomington, including I believe 30 or 32 million in debt financing for

00:57:39.328 --> 00:57:46.665
- two parking garages nearish the downtown in 2019. That's about 40 million dollars in today's 20,

00:57:46.665 --> 00:57:52.414
- 26 dollars. So not less than half of what we're talking about here, but not

00:57:52.962 --> 00:58:00.367
- orders of magnitude different. Like it is something we chose to do with no grants, so no matches, right,

00:58:00.367 --> 00:58:08.125
- for the purpose of building additional parking supply. So thinking about the economic benefits in particular,

00:58:08.125 --> 00:58:15.249
- as well as the broader benefits to the city, is TIF funding something that's been discussed or could

00:58:15.249 --> 00:58:22.654
- be paired with federal grant dollars, MPO dollars, to kind of build that together? Any thoughts on that?

00:58:22.882 --> 00:58:29.783
- Those are potential funding options. I do not think we have not considered it as part of this. That's

00:58:29.783 --> 00:58:36.683
- not kind of the ultimate goal of the study. It's something that council and the future administration

00:58:36.683 --> 00:58:43.584
- could consider. It is not something that we're proposing to do at all currently. So there's not a lot

00:58:43.584 --> 00:58:50.416
- of concrete, not much of a capital planning, like concrete plan at this stage, but all of the things

00:58:50.416 --> 00:58:52.446
- that I've discussed, like our

00:58:53.666 --> 00:58:59.708
- are options available to us. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Further questions. Either side. Mr. George go. I'm

00:58:59.708 --> 00:59:05.926
- just curious about the broader context. So the project started years ago and I'm sure the context changes

00:59:05.926 --> 00:59:12.085
- and there are some initiatives and other things going on. Is there anything which changed the priorities

00:59:12.085 --> 00:59:18.068
- or the relevance like anything around how it goes throughout the years and then it will last for more

00:59:18.068 --> 00:59:21.822
- years. So like how do we stay relevant when we are planning it.

00:59:22.466 --> 00:59:29.454
- Yeah. Oh, that's such a good question. So the relevance has not changed. We've continued to do counts

00:59:29.454 --> 00:59:36.853
- engineering department is wonderful and has done several counts. We found that the numbers are for vehicles

00:59:36.853 --> 00:59:42.334
- speeds and counts are roughly the same, you know, as our council way back when.

00:59:42.690 --> 00:59:50.067
- that hasn't changed and we don't expect them to change much. Context has changed quite a bit. The convention

00:59:50.067 --> 00:59:57.242
- center is expanding, like I mentioned, things like that. The assessor has recently depreciated properties

00:59:57.242 --> 01:00:04.078
- on the south stretch of the corridor, so kind of at the urgency of doing some sort of transportation

01:00:04.078 --> 01:00:09.086
- slash economic development project has kind of increased. But ultimately,

01:00:09.602 --> 01:00:16.277
- This is an adoption or an amendment to the transportation plan, which does not take small bites. It

01:00:16.277 --> 01:00:23.219
- takes long bites. It does take small bites. It doesn't take big bites. It takes small, long bites where

01:00:23.219 --> 01:00:30.094
- we look at trying to achieve our goals 100 years in the future rather than immediately. So the context

01:00:30.094 --> 01:00:36.702
- kind of can come and go. But the plan being the recommendation is kind of what it is, essentially.

01:00:40.866 --> 01:00:47.554
- any other ongoing long-term initiatives which will overlap with this direction we take? There isn't

01:00:47.554 --> 01:00:54.442
- anything that will affect this directly. As you are well aware, as a transportation commission member,

01:00:54.442 --> 01:01:01.465
- we are also looking at the Roger Street corridor. That is another high priority network. It won't reduce

01:01:01.465 --> 01:01:08.153
- capacity. The proposal so far is not to reduce capacity on that street, just to redesign it so that

01:01:08.153 --> 01:01:09.022
- it is safer.

01:01:09.282 --> 01:01:17.181
- the any overflow traffic or whatever would easily be manageable on Rogers. Although there won't be any

01:01:17.181 --> 01:01:25.080
- overflow traffic as you can see from this chart here. But yeah, the college and walnut kind of operate

01:01:25.080 --> 01:01:33.056
- as a permanent stalwart and are basically unflappable. And so yeah, there's there's nothing that should

01:01:33.056 --> 01:01:39.038
- affect their ultimate importance in the city. All right. I got a couple more.

01:01:39.138 --> 01:01:46.976
- questions, too. You had a slide up there about how other cities did. You mentioned South Bend. So you

01:01:46.976 --> 01:01:55.044
- mentioned the property values going up in the next city. I think it was Louisville. You had a comparison

01:01:55.044 --> 01:02:02.805
- that the one-way control streets went down. Do we have any sense of how much property values went up

01:02:02.805 --> 01:02:07.646
- outside of the main streets in South Bend in that same period?

01:02:07.842 --> 01:02:15.861
- For South Bend, but that is something I could dig into in the future the I just went off of mayor Pete's

01:02:15.861 --> 01:02:23.804
- Press conference. Well, that's fine. I just you know didn't know how to compare that 21% increase Yeah,

01:02:23.804 --> 01:02:31.442
- that makes a lot since I could look at the other question. I wanted to ask is one that I have heard

01:02:31.442 --> 01:02:37.246
- so many times in my life in Bloomington before I was politically active and

01:02:37.858 --> 01:02:45.319
- since, and that is the block of Walnut Street between 6th and 7th. And specifically, the complaint I

01:02:45.319 --> 01:02:52.779
- hear is what you mentioned earlier, that it's the only place I hear it more than anything else, that

01:02:52.779 --> 01:03:00.387
- when there are two trucks, typically unloading beer, blocking two of the three lanes of Walnut Street.

01:03:00.387 --> 01:03:07.774
- I have never heard people complain more than about this particular thing. So one thing I don't get,

01:03:08.386 --> 01:03:15.968
- is how in either scenario, maybe the one way I sort of understand, I'd like to understand more about

01:03:15.968 --> 01:03:23.700
- how you imagine loading zones. Can you zoom in perhaps to show us what the loading zone might be? Zoom

01:03:23.700 --> 01:03:31.282
- into that slide. But can you explain to us how that block in particular would be resolved by any new

01:03:31.282 --> 01:03:37.438
- design? And how other blocks in the city that might find themselves the object of

01:03:37.730 --> 01:03:45.981
- commercial endeavors might lobby to change their block to add loading zones in the same way should that

01:03:45.981 --> 01:03:53.994
- day come. I mean, I hear a lot. Hold on, I can try to zoom in on that. That'd be great. Give me just

01:03:53.994 --> 01:04:01.928
- half a second. That'd be great. I appreciate your effort here, but I just want to get this question

01:04:01.928 --> 01:04:07.006
- dissected once and for all because I think it has an inordinate

01:04:07.490 --> 01:04:19.937
- amount of grip on the public conscious, conscience, consciousness. Is that the right word? Either one,

01:04:19.937 --> 01:04:32.142
- either one, either one. I could keep riffing while he's pulling it up, but you get the idea. Can you

01:04:32.142 --> 01:04:35.646
- just zoom into that picture?

01:04:35.906 --> 01:04:45.295
- Is there an example of it in that picture? I mean, I guess maybe I could ask an alternate question,

01:04:45.295 --> 01:04:54.402
- which is, could we require a certain company to only load at a certain time in order to prevent?

01:04:54.402 --> 01:05:04.542
- Here we go. All right. Tell us what we're looking at. Kirkwood, sixth and seventh. Yeah, so this is Walnut.

01:05:04.962 --> 01:05:11.811
- Sixth is right there, smack dab in the middle. And then you can see the designated loading zones. These

01:05:11.811 --> 01:05:18.660
- start at the alley and kind of stretch outward. And then this is a pretty good example of what we could

01:05:18.660 --> 01:05:25.378
- propose based on businesses along the blocks requirements. But essentially, you provide extra parking

01:05:25.378 --> 01:05:31.766
- or loading space, which is currently occupied by parking vehicles, and then allow loading zones.

01:05:31.766 --> 01:05:34.334
- I'm sorry. I'm having trouble hearing.

01:05:35.042 --> 01:05:41.907
- Could we ask the audience, please, to keep it down? Say again. Yeah, so this would take up what is currently

01:05:41.907 --> 01:05:48.394
- vehicle parking and allow for loading zones that, like I said earlier, we can work with the businesses

01:05:48.394 --> 01:05:54.754
- along the block place to determine their needs and best suit their needs. So on Walnut here, you can

01:05:54.754 --> 01:06:01.115
- see that both sides of the street will feature that loading zone because so often there's a delivery

01:06:01.115 --> 01:06:04.894
- truck at Brothers and the Bluebird, and that eliminates the

01:06:05.058 --> 01:06:12.891
- the vehicle traveling down to one. So you can see here that the travel or the loading zones will provide

01:06:12.891 --> 01:06:20.352
- that space for. So just tell me what I'm looking at here on the right of the screen where I look it

01:06:20.352 --> 01:06:22.366
- looks like angled parking.

01:06:22.594 --> 01:06:28.723
- Would the angle parking have to be temporarily signed so that a truck could come in, or where is the

01:06:28.723 --> 01:06:34.851
- space? These are not angled parking. This hash is how we're showing the loading zone. Oh, I see. The

01:06:34.851 --> 01:06:41.162
- angled parking is here. You can see it's pulled in angled parking there. This is parallel parking here.

01:06:41.162 --> 01:06:47.230
- And then this is the loading zone, these hashes, which would be designated to the delivery drivers.

01:06:48.034 --> 01:06:53.798
- To answer the second part of your question, which is, can you work with businesses to require delivery

01:06:53.798 --> 01:06:59.730
- times? We've talked to a whole bunch of businesses. I forget the exact number. I think it's 35 businesses

01:06:59.730 --> 01:07:05.550
- along the corridor. And the overwhelming response is that not really. They can't control that. A couple

01:07:05.550 --> 01:07:11.258
- of them were like, potentially we could. But by and large, no. The delivery drivers kind of just show

01:07:11.258 --> 01:07:17.246
- up when they show up and need the space when they need the space. Especially true with less than load LTL.

01:07:17.602 --> 01:07:25.618
- delivery drivers, which you see especially between Kirkwood and Sixth on the square. Those are full

01:07:25.618 --> 01:07:33.955
- semis, but only a portion of that semi delivers to the local business. They're coming from out of state

01:07:33.955 --> 01:07:42.212
- and they need to deliver exactly when they need to deliver. They can't control their times essentially

01:07:42.212 --> 01:07:47.422
- at all. Is that a problem in other cities that have constraints?

01:07:47.554 --> 01:07:55.928
- who force deliveries to come at a certain time because they have no choice, manage it somehow. Is that

01:07:55.928 --> 01:08:04.302
- truly not an alternative? Can we not require delivery companies to be more timely? I believe in theory

01:08:04.302 --> 01:08:12.595
- you could. I think Bloomington is not set up to manage it that way. But yeah, I believe you're right.

01:08:12.595 --> 01:08:17.310
- Philadelphia is an example that has those delivery times.

01:08:17.858 --> 01:08:26.352
- It is something you could do on paper. It's not something that we found any interest in the local business.

01:08:26.352 --> 01:08:34.689
- And I think most public servants, especially in the parking realm, aren't interested in trying to enforce

01:08:34.689 --> 01:08:42.553
- that kind of time management. I mean, I think it's still a more optimal thing. But I just wanted to

01:08:42.553 --> 01:08:46.014
- know what was possible. Thank you for that.

01:08:46.114 --> 01:08:52.706
- With that, if there's no last call for questions, it's time to go to the public for comment on, did

01:08:52.706 --> 01:08:59.429
- you have the last question? We have one more and then we'll go to the public, TCR 2622. This is about

01:08:59.429 --> 01:09:06.615
- the context of changing a road in a college town. I can imagine reducing one-way trips will reduce accidents

01:09:06.615 --> 01:09:13.470
- on move-in day, parents' weekend, and so forth. We also have a very successful football team right now.

01:09:13.986 --> 01:09:21.166
- And we have particular traffic patterns and spikes on those days. Have your traffic projections and

01:09:21.166 --> 01:09:28.848
- capacity looked particularly at game day traffic? Great question. No, but that's because the best practice

01:09:28.848 --> 01:09:36.100
- for designing streets is to not look at your extremes. You certainly want to look at only eight days

01:09:36.100 --> 01:09:41.054
- of extreme traffic that is not something that would occur otherwise.

01:09:41.442 --> 01:09:48.905
- Kind of the good approximation is that historically, engineers kind of thought roadways as drain pipes,

01:09:48.905 --> 01:09:55.650
- where water just goes as fast as water goes, but vehicles don't operate like water. You know,

01:09:55.650 --> 01:10:02.826
- we don't follow, humans make mistakes and they don't follow the same conditions every time. So some

01:10:02.826 --> 01:10:08.926
- of them go 100 miles an hour, some of them go two miles an hour, and that all causes

01:10:09.410 --> 01:10:18.858
- congestion and whatnot and danger. So you don't design for your worst day, you design for your average

01:10:18.858 --> 01:10:28.031
- day. And then we did think about gameday traffic. So the current, I should pull it up, hang on, the

01:10:28.031 --> 01:10:36.286
- current design for north 17th, where you see the kind of the extremes of gameday traffic.

01:10:36.450 --> 01:10:44.219
- We will have to work with INDOT because INDOT owns the bypass. And so ultimate design, we kind of left

01:10:44.219 --> 01:10:51.987
- as a gray area because that's a conversation we'll have to have way off in the future when we're ready

01:10:51.987 --> 01:10:59.530
- to think about conversion there. But hold on, sorry, I'm trying to open it. The design will be very

01:10:59.530 --> 01:11:04.734
- similar to the current design where it's two lanes there, both north

01:11:05.218 --> 01:11:13.384
- And why isn't it sharing? It's very large, yeah. Hang on, sorry, one second. If you need some time,

01:11:13.384 --> 01:11:22.041
- you can go to public comment and you can show it after public comment. I got it on my screen. That should

01:11:22.041 --> 01:11:30.288
- hopefully be enough. But you can see that the current design will maintain the two lanes. So this is

01:11:30.288 --> 01:11:33.310
- a thing that other cities deal with.

01:11:33.762 --> 01:11:41.880
- The kind of local good example is Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis. And they have West Street and Missouri.

01:11:41.880 --> 01:11:49.328
- They are one way couplet through their downtown. And they both convert to southbound traffic to get

01:11:49.328 --> 01:11:56.999
- everyone towards the interstate. So the similarity here would be getting everyone to the bypass to get

01:11:56.999 --> 01:12:00.350
- onto 69. And so you can convert those lanes.

01:12:00.514 --> 01:12:06.594
- in any direction. And the benefit of the two-way travel lanes versus the one-way travel lane is that

01:12:06.594 --> 01:12:12.794
- the infrastructure will be designed to allow traffic in both directions. So you can convert all travel

01:12:12.794 --> 01:12:18.934
- lanes northbound. Currently, they close southbound college on game days to stop the interference with

01:12:18.934 --> 01:12:25.074
- those moving vehicles. But if you suddenly have traffic signals that work in both directions, you can

01:12:25.074 --> 01:12:27.422
- have the police control those to allow

01:12:28.066 --> 01:12:34.544
- vehicles to move quickly through and past the intersection. All right. With that, we go now to public

01:12:34.544 --> 01:12:40.896
- comment. So for those of you who are in chambers who'd like to speak to TCR 2622, we welcome you to

01:12:40.896 --> 01:12:47.311
- come to the podium. Please sign in. You'll have three minutes to speak. Those of you who are online,

01:12:47.311 --> 01:12:53.853
- please use the raise hand function in Zoom and the secretary as someone will acknowledge you and we'll

01:12:53.853 --> 01:12:57.854
- go back and forth as we see people raising their hand in Zoom.

01:12:58.274 --> 01:13:12.336
- Is there anyone who would like to speak to TCR 2622? Please come to the podium, sign in, state your

01:13:12.336 --> 01:13:21.054
- name, and you'll have three minutes. My name is Chris Taylor.

01:13:21.154 --> 01:13:26.942
- I've been a resident of Bloomington for 49 years. I came as a student to IU. My husband and I raised

01:13:26.942 --> 01:13:32.673
- our family here. One of the best lessons I learned growing up in a small northern Indiana town that

01:13:32.673 --> 01:13:38.519
- keeps rewarding me is how to cross the street. We learned that one stop sign. We had one stop sign in

01:13:38.519 --> 01:13:44.594
- our town that had no buttons on it to push. In addition to that one stop light, we had many intersections

01:13:44.594 --> 01:13:51.070
- without any guidelines at all. We looked all four ways and knew how to judge when it was safe to cross the road.

01:13:51.170 --> 01:13:57.107
- Another lesson learned later in life was riding a bike with common sense. Our young son was on the back

01:13:57.107 --> 01:14:02.987
- of my bike. My husband and our two daughters, we all went bike riding all over Bloomington. And we did

01:14:02.987 --> 01:14:06.526
- that all before there were ever any bike lanes. The audacity.

01:14:07.490 --> 01:14:13.622
- The purpose of today's special hearing is to consider the adoption of an amendment of the 2019 transportation

01:14:13.622 --> 01:14:19.420
- plan, although it looked like there were two areas highlighted as amendments. The second one on roughly

01:14:19.420 --> 01:14:24.995
- page 69 does not appear to be amending anything, but was highlighted on November 12th of this year.

01:14:24.995 --> 01:14:30.905
- I looked at the agenda for this meeting. I didn't see it online, so I requested one, but I never received

01:14:30.905 --> 01:14:36.926
- a response from the department. On Saturday, I looked again, and on the agenda had been issued. The agenda.

01:14:37.058 --> 01:14:44.395
- five pages for the staff report, 39 pages for the draft, five pages for documents and two-way concept

01:14:44.395 --> 01:14:51.803
- designs, 75 pages of the transportation plan, 67 pages of the existing conditions report marked draft,

01:14:51.803 --> 01:14:59.211
- 395 pages of the multimodal analysis report from 2025, six PDF documents outlining city of Bloomington

01:14:59.211 --> 01:15:04.606
- traffic count along the corner, 24 responses from the city of Bloomington,

01:15:04.770 --> 01:15:10.953
- for the study feedback. It appears that some of the documents are still in draft form. I don't understand

01:15:10.953 --> 01:15:16.961
- that. And it appears that remaining one way isn't even an option. The only option appears to be moving

01:15:16.961 --> 01:15:22.795
- to a two-way street. Further, the measure under consideration is a tool for planning framework. But

01:15:22.795 --> 01:15:28.861
- I know that what is framework today will eventually be implemented. I say keep it one way. Don't change

01:15:28.861 --> 01:15:31.486
- anything. Do not adopt the staff proposal as

01:15:31.682 --> 01:15:38.301
- has presented. The bicycle friendly community report card issued in the spring of 2023 states overall

01:15:38.301 --> 01:15:44.855
- community ridership is 1.8%. That's less than 2% riding their bikes to work. To use differently, the

01:15:44.855 --> 01:15:51.409
- cutesy term road diet mentioned in the staff report, I recommend that the city go on a bike path and

01:15:51.409 --> 01:15:54.654
- urban trail diet. What we have is enough already.

01:15:55.170 --> 01:16:01.884
- After reading Ordinance 20-2504, the establishment of the Transportation Commission, the first whereas

01:16:01.884 --> 01:16:08.533
- states, to reduce traffic deaths and serious injuries on the city roadways to zero in the city by the

01:16:08.533 --> 01:16:15.052
- year 2039. This language is insane. I had no idea the city could prevent my death by ordinance. Are

01:16:15.052 --> 01:16:21.571
- we going to be locked down at the end of 2038? I'll mark my calendar. Sometimes the government that

01:16:21.571 --> 01:16:23.070
- spends wildly and pays

01:16:23.554 --> 01:16:34.205
- Experts to dream up nonsense is simply justifying their existence. Well time well government Thank you

01:16:34.205 --> 01:16:44.752
- for your comment whoever has ears let them hear thank you next comment in chambers, please My name is

01:16:44.752 --> 01:16:52.094
- Barbara schweigman and I've lived in Bloomington for over 45 years and

01:16:52.354 --> 01:17:03.300
- And I've worked downtown on the square for about six years. I am very much opposed to making Walnut

01:17:03.300 --> 01:17:14.904
- and College two-way. You spelled my name wrong, but that's OK. And on the subject of speeding, to prevent

01:17:14.904 --> 01:17:20.158
- speeding to make the College of Walnut two-way,

01:17:20.354 --> 01:17:29.696
- I thought the speed limit downtown was 20 miles per hour and I think it should have been enforced. It

01:17:29.696 --> 01:17:39.129
- doesn't seem to be enforced. That's a problem. Bloomington is a university town so in my mind it's not

01:17:39.129 --> 01:17:48.470
- like Louisville or South Bend or Indianapolis. So those are different issues. To get back to speeding

01:17:48.470 --> 01:17:50.302
- I wonder when those

01:17:50.434 --> 01:18:01.007
- Accidents happen when they happen, who was involved, what time of year, what time of day. I think those

01:18:01.007 --> 01:18:11.479
- are all elements that need to be looked at. I just keep picturing myself perhaps having a heart attack

01:18:11.479 --> 01:18:20.222
- in Kroger's Seminary Square. The ambulance comes and then it's zooming or not zooming

01:18:20.770 --> 01:18:29.388
- North to the hospital because it has to stop and start where because there are so many two lane stops

01:18:29.388 --> 01:18:38.005
- and starts. I don't understand it. I don't even understand who came up with the idea, but I thank you

01:18:38.005 --> 01:18:46.623
- for your time and your attention. Thank you for your time. Is there anyone online who'd like to speak

01:18:46.623 --> 01:18:47.806
- to the issue?

01:18:49.410 --> 01:19:05.883
- Let's go to our first online speaker. Hello, this is Paul Russo. Can you hear me? You have three minutes.

01:19:05.883 --> 01:19:17.694
- Go ahead. I too had trouble with meeting documents. Am I, is it louder now?

01:19:20.706 --> 01:19:27.029
- I had trouble finding the meeting documents. I'm not sure quite what has changed in the past year since

01:19:27.029 --> 01:19:33.109
- there was public comments solicited. The comments that I made seem to have been completely ignored.

01:19:33.109 --> 01:19:39.371
- As a bicyclist, I would like to say there's a good reason why only 1.8% of the people bicycle to work,

01:19:39.371 --> 01:19:45.451
- and that's because it's dangerous to bicycle. There's complete hegemony by motor vehicle drivers in

01:19:45.451 --> 01:19:49.342
- this town, and calling it bicycle friendly is rather laughable.

01:19:50.946 --> 01:19:58.098
- The comment I made about this particular plan is that bi-directional bike lanes are not best practice

01:19:58.098 --> 01:20:05.530
- and they should not be put in. We can see what happened with a bi-directional bicycle lane on 7th Street.

01:20:05.530 --> 01:20:12.612
- Within weeks or months, we had to put stop signs in every intersection because motor vehicle drivers

01:20:12.612 --> 01:20:17.310
- were unaccustomed to having bicycles traveling in both directions.

01:20:20.674 --> 01:20:26.526
- At every intersection and driveway, bi-directional bike lanes expect drivers to suddenly adopt a new

01:20:26.526 --> 01:20:32.667
- and counterintuitive behavior, looking both ways for bicyclists on a space not wider than a motor vehicle

01:20:32.667 --> 01:20:38.751
- lane. The expectation is that all the more implausible in a city that does virtually nothing with regard

01:20:38.751 --> 01:20:44.777
- to education or enforcement, an unsurprising result from the bi-directional bicycle lanes would be more

01:20:44.777 --> 01:20:47.326
- collisions than with one-way bicycle lanes.

01:20:49.666 --> 01:20:56.736
- There would also, I would expect her to be head on collisions in narrow bi-directional bicycle lanes

01:20:56.736 --> 01:21:03.946
- between scooters and bicyclists. And there's also the issue of the intrusion of motor vehicles because

01:21:03.946 --> 01:21:11.156
- a bi-directional bicycle lane by its nature is wider. Therefore, to prevent motor vehicle drivers from

01:21:11.156 --> 01:21:18.366
- putting their vehicles in the bicycle lane, as we've seen on 7th Street, you have to install bollards.

01:21:19.682 --> 01:21:25.636
- Well, crashing into a bollard as a bicyclist is a lot more consequential than scraping the side of a

01:21:25.636 --> 01:21:31.767
- curb on a narrow one-way lane. And I would hazard to, I would guess that the width of a one-way bicycle

01:21:31.767 --> 01:21:37.897
- lane is slightly wider than half the length of the bi-directional bicycle lanes that are on 7th Street.

01:21:37.897 --> 01:21:43.851
- In any case, all of this is a bad idea and the city seems to be just fixated on these bi-directional

01:21:43.851 --> 01:21:47.742
- bicycle lanes, or at least their consultants do. It's a bad idea.

01:21:48.354 --> 01:21:54.920
- and spending tens of millions of dollars to install this kind of thing? What a disaster. Thank you.

01:21:54.920 --> 01:22:01.748
- Thank you for your comment. Let's go now to the next person in chambers. Please state your name. You'll

01:22:01.748 --> 01:22:08.577
- have three minutes. Excuse me. Yes, my name is Bill Mackey, sir. So I'm going to try and sneak all this

01:22:08.577 --> 01:22:11.006
- into the three minute timeline here.

01:22:11.106 --> 01:22:17.207
- First of all, I think obviously cost benefit analysis really needs to be considered here and we're talking

01:22:17.207 --> 01:22:23.080
- about spending a hundred and six million dollars I would push back fairly strongly on all three of the

01:22:23.080 --> 01:22:28.896
- examples that were given in the presentation Regarding South Bend a very dilapidated area at the time

01:22:28.896 --> 01:22:34.997
- that they made that change There were significant investments and other things it wasn't just they changed

01:22:34.997 --> 01:22:37.278
- the road and magically things showed up

01:22:37.858 --> 01:22:45.857
- Secondarily, as I think somebody on council had mentioned here, a largely vacant area has low property

01:22:45.857 --> 01:22:53.934
- values necessarily. In the Brook Street example in Louisville, the photos shown here in chambers showed

01:22:53.934 --> 01:22:57.118
- essentially surface parking and then the

01:22:57.218 --> 01:23:03.645
- the replacement, suddenly you see millions and millions of dollars worth of structure there. This is

01:23:03.645 --> 01:23:10.073
- not a magic panacea where suddenly property values went up because the road was changed. Look at the

01:23:10.073 --> 01:23:16.563
- amount of money that Indianapolis put into the cultural trail area. Again, this is not a $106 million

01:23:16.563 --> 01:23:20.318
- fix. We better be prepared to spend a lot more to do that.

01:23:20.386 --> 01:23:25.937
- Some other things that I wanted to mention about this, the safety issues. Safety is oftentimes related

01:23:25.937 --> 01:23:31.435
- to speed and related to the number of vehicles that are transiting there. When we're showed this area

01:23:31.435 --> 01:23:36.824
- that says here are where the most accidents are, there is a 100% correlation between that and where

01:23:36.824 --> 01:23:42.214
- traffic is the heaviest. So not surprisingly, in areas where you have a lot more vehicles, you have

01:23:42.214 --> 01:23:48.088
- a lot more traffic, you have a lot more accidents. Somebody else had mentioned this. Speed can be controlled

01:23:48.088 --> 01:23:50.352
- by means other than spending $106 million

01:23:50.352 --> 01:23:56.485
- something like this. A few police officers throwing out tickets would allow people to pretty quickly

01:23:56.485 --> 01:24:01.950
- understand that going 40 miles an hour in a 20-mile zone is not necessarily a great idea.

01:24:02.050 --> 01:24:08.031
- And of course, if we wanted to eliminate fatal crashes and pedestrian incidents, there's lots of ways

01:24:08.031 --> 01:24:14.012
- to do that. You could ban pedestrians entirely in cyclists. There would be no pedestrian accidents if

01:24:14.012 --> 01:24:19.934
- there were no people there. That's, of course, a ridiculous assertion. Well, it's just as ridiculous

01:24:19.934 --> 01:24:25.798
- to state that we're going to drive this number down to zero by making these big time changes. Could

01:24:25.798 --> 01:24:30.430
- that possibly help? Yes. Is it going to drive it to zero? I don't think it is.

01:24:30.562 --> 01:24:37.401
- When we talk about environmental impacts, we've talked about a lot of that stuff here. There is no vehicle

01:24:37.401 --> 01:24:43.920
- that is less efficient than the vehicle driving at zero miles per hour. And all these things that end

01:24:43.920 --> 01:24:50.376
- up causing extraordinary congestion involve standstill traffic. That is the worst possible situation

01:24:50.376 --> 01:24:56.767
- for environment. If we want to actually sort of encourage better environment downtown, how about we

01:24:56.767 --> 01:24:57.854
- put in some more

01:24:58.050 --> 01:25:05.220
- Electric vehicle infrastructure down there. Spend some money on that instead of spending money slowing

01:25:05.220 --> 01:25:12.182
- cars to a crawl. Zero miles per hour is the worst situation possible for environmental. That's your

01:25:12.182 --> 01:25:19.352
- time. Thank you very much. Thank you very much for your time. Let's go to another speaker in the room.

01:25:19.352 --> 01:25:26.314
- Please come forward, state your name, sign in, and you'll have three minutes. All right. My name is

01:25:26.314 --> 01:25:27.358
- George Keller.

01:25:28.162 --> 01:25:33.636
- I am against the proposal to convert the one-way sections of College and Walnut to two-way traffic.

01:25:33.636 --> 01:25:39.383
- I have been against this concept for the last eight years ever since it was first proposed back in 2018.

01:25:39.383 --> 01:25:44.856
- Since I will probably not be able to cover all my arguments here in the three minutes, I would like

01:25:44.856 --> 01:25:50.330
- to ask people here in the audience to please go online to the B Square Bulletin and read through my

01:25:50.330 --> 01:25:54.654
- letter with attachments to the peers in the Bloom Docs section of the website.

01:25:55.138 --> 01:26:00.578
- This document will give you a lot more information than what I'm able to speak about right now. I would

01:26:00.578 --> 01:26:05.967
- first like to comment on what happened back in 2018. Back in 2018, the proposal to convert the one-way

01:26:05.967 --> 01:26:11.407
- sections of College and Walnut to two-way traffic was overwhelmingly rejected by almost everyone except

01:26:11.407 --> 01:26:16.638
- for some people in our city government and the consulting firm that the city hired to do the study.

01:26:16.638 --> 01:26:21.922
- The Bloomington Chamber of Commerce at that time did a survey of their members and found that 88% of

01:26:21.922 --> 01:26:22.654
- their members

01:26:22.914 --> 01:26:29.084
- did not want these streets converted to two-way traffic. The city allowed people to submit comments

01:26:29.084 --> 01:26:35.501
- online concerning the street conversion review. Those comments showed that 75 of the 85 commenters were

01:26:35.501 --> 01:26:41.794
- against the idea. If you go through the math, you'll find that 75 out of 85 worked out to 88% against

01:26:41.794 --> 01:26:47.902
- the same percentage as the business community. CFC properties also came out against this proposal.

01:26:48.418 --> 01:26:53.941
- CFC Properties was responsible for the renovation and rejuvenation of our downtown areas, any other

01:26:53.941 --> 01:26:59.741
- organization in this city, including Fountain Square, Grand Place, and a portion of the Showers Building

01:26:59.741 --> 01:27:05.264
- that we're in right now. A letter from Jim Murphy, who was the president of CFC at the time, stated

01:27:05.264 --> 01:27:11.008
- that the proposal to restore a two-way right-of-way to these roads should be removed from the plan with

01:27:11.008 --> 01:27:17.084
- no further consideration. Studies and evaluation would be costly. Implementing the plan would be additionally

01:27:17.084 --> 01:27:18.078
- cost prohibitive.

01:27:19.394 --> 01:27:24.918
- Despite this massive opposition, the city chose to continue to have work done and spend money on the

01:27:24.918 --> 01:27:30.497
- two-way street proposal, so that's where we find ourselves today. I also would like to comment on the

01:27:30.497 --> 01:27:36.021
- stated speeding issues on College and Walnut. A big reason offered for the conversion of College and

01:27:36.021 --> 01:27:41.491
- Walnut to two-way traffic is the claim that one-way streets promote speeding, which in turn results

01:27:41.491 --> 01:27:47.069
- in an excessive number of crashes. However, the actual historical crash data for North College Avenue

01:27:47.069 --> 01:27:48.382
- and North Walnut Street

01:27:48.674 --> 01:27:54.607
- does not show that speeding is a significant issue for the crashes at all. In fact, if you go to the

01:27:54.607 --> 01:28:00.775
- crash data website for Bloomington Monroe County and look at the cause of crashes for these two streets,

01:28:00.775 --> 01:28:07.001
- you will see that the two speeding categories account for less than 4% of the crashes. The two categories

01:28:07.001 --> 01:28:12.875
- that call out speeding are speed too fast for weather conditions and unsafe speed. Many other crash

01:28:12.875 --> 01:28:15.166
- factors, such as following too closely

01:28:15.522 --> 01:28:22.575
- failure to yield right away and improper turning are listed as far more important. So while people are

01:28:22.575 --> 01:28:29.422
- driving over this beeline on the way sections of the College of Walnut, the crash data shows that's

01:28:29.422 --> 01:28:36.406
- not a significant cause for the crashes. So in conclusion, I'm asking the transportation. Okay. Thank

01:28:36.406 --> 01:28:43.870
- you so much. Okay. I will note that Mr. Keller's letter did appear in the public comment link in the packet.

01:28:44.258 --> 01:28:50.679
- Uh, so it's linked, uh, in our agenda. Uh, and I just wanted to point out that, uh, that it was made

01:28:50.679 --> 01:28:57.100
- publicly available on the city website. Is there anyone online who'd like to speak? All right. Let's

01:28:57.100 --> 01:29:03.458
- go back to chambers. Good evening commission chair of all. And this is, uh, Christopher energy from

01:29:03.458 --> 01:29:08.798
- the greater Bloomington chamber of commerce and a former parking commission member.

01:29:09.250 --> 01:29:16.846
- I would say few issues have drawn as much unsolicited feedback from our members as the college walnut

01:29:16.846 --> 01:29:24.591
- two-way conversion. It's been overwhelmingly negative. Our member survey that we recently put out tells

01:29:24.591 --> 01:29:32.186
- a clear story. We engaged in businesses and their leaders on this subject when the word came out just

01:29:32.186 --> 01:29:38.814
- to get a snapshot of what that is. And that figure is 84% opposed the conversion and 65%

01:29:38.914 --> 01:29:45.187
- strongly oppose it. Nearly 60% expect negative impacts on the business and their organization. Their

01:29:45.187 --> 01:29:51.521
- concerns are just practical as you would think. We've talked about here, customer access, deliveries,

01:29:51.521 --> 01:29:57.732
- loading space, and years of potential construction disruption. On October 20th, Mayor Thompson told

01:29:57.732 --> 01:30:04.253
- the Rotary Club, which I was attending, that the streets won't become two-way during her administration.

01:30:04.253 --> 01:30:07.358
- It drew a tremendous applause from that audience.

01:30:08.706 --> 01:30:15.230
- We agree that the corridor deserves investment. The Chamber's long advocated for investment revitalization

01:30:15.230 --> 01:30:21.388
- along the College Walnut Corridor, particularly the Miller Showers Park area, as we call the stadium

01:30:21.388 --> 01:30:27.668
- district, and also the heavily distraught south end by Seminary Square. Better sidewalks, trees, safer

01:30:27.668 --> 01:30:34.130
- crossing, slower traffic would help residents, visitors, and businesses alike. We appreciate Mr. Robling,

01:30:34.130 --> 01:30:37.118
- the city's planning service manager for Brighton

01:30:37.250 --> 01:30:43.946
- providing some detailed responses on those three fatal crashes in the study, but those fatalities weren't

01:30:43.946 --> 01:30:50.579
- attributed specifically to one-way configuration and really not even speeding per se. The concerns about

01:30:50.579 --> 01:30:56.960
- those speeding, lane movement and pedestrian safety are real. We don't establish that the conversion

01:30:56.960 --> 01:30:59.550
- is a necessary solution to those issues.

01:31:00.898 --> 01:31:06.761
- So tonight's decision has long-term consequences. Staffs confirmed the adaptive study of the transportation

01:31:06.761 --> 01:31:12.570
- would establish a two-way conversion as a city's long-term direction, even without immediate construction.

01:31:12.570 --> 01:31:18.542
- Meanwhile, the city has already approved 1.27 million preliminary engineering for an intersection, pedestrian

01:31:18.542 --> 01:31:24.351
- improvements, et cetera, that do not require converting college and Walnut to two-way traffic. Our request

01:31:24.351 --> 01:31:29.726
- is straightforward. Separate the safety and streetscape improvements from the conversion proposal.

01:31:29.986 --> 01:31:36.511
- evaluate less disruptive alternatives and their measurable safety benefits. Don't establish two-way

01:31:36.511 --> 01:31:43.231
- conversion as long as policy without real evaluation. We can have safer streets, a revitalized stadium

01:31:43.231 --> 01:31:50.147
- district and seminary square area, greener, more welcoming downtown without converting college and Walnut

01:31:50.147 --> 01:31:53.214
- to two-way traffic. We recommend this body not

01:31:53.410 --> 01:32:01.049
- adopt the study as currently written, removing the two-way conversion would be your best alternative.

01:32:01.049 --> 01:32:08.687
- Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. Further public comment? Anybody online? In the room, please come

01:32:08.687 --> 01:32:16.176
- to the podium, state your name. You'll have three minutes. My name is Wendy Brisht. I didn't really

01:32:16.176 --> 01:32:20.894
- prepare, but I did make some notes from what I saw here, which

01:32:21.314 --> 01:32:28.442
- I've been thinking about this quite a bit. Every time I drive down or up on that corridor, I give God

01:32:28.442 --> 01:32:35.500
- thanks, because it's so easy to get through town and to town. And it's really, to me, it's one thing

01:32:35.500 --> 01:32:42.628
- that really works about our transportation system. And I think most people feel that way. But it just

01:32:42.628 --> 01:32:45.982
- keeps coming back at us, and I think people are

01:32:46.466 --> 01:32:53.959
- are a little bit alarmed. I think there are easier and different ways to decrease the speed and increase

01:32:53.959 --> 01:33:01.095
- the safety. As somebody already mentioned, it's driver distraction, driver impairment distractions,

01:33:01.095 --> 01:33:08.231
- maybe worse with a two-way street with all those things coming and going. I think the drive will be

01:33:08.231 --> 01:33:12.798
- much longer either direction. People will look for ways around.

01:33:13.026 --> 01:33:19.092
- Buses might not be able to go both ways as easily but imagine how much longer they're going to take

01:33:19.092 --> 01:33:25.219
- To get through town and to get to where they're going which will move less passengers. I think speed

01:33:25.219 --> 01:33:31.345
- monitors I think maybe timing lights for slower traffic more police presence. I I don't think moving

01:33:31.345 --> 01:33:36.926
- some of that traffic on the quiet onto the quieter pedestrian streets is going to be a good

01:33:37.538 --> 01:33:44.276
- More pedestrian streets anyway is gonna be a good alternative because then you're gonna have those having

01:33:44.276 --> 01:33:50.760
- more traffic and more accidents. I think trees are important for downtown. It's getting hot and shade

01:33:50.760 --> 01:33:57.116
- is really important. If you wanna have pedestrians, it's really important to have shade and I think

01:33:57.116 --> 01:34:03.918
- trees are really good for that. And I think that, I know that Rogers gets congested. I know that Indiana's

01:34:03.918 --> 01:34:06.206
- getting to be a one-way street now.

01:34:06.402 --> 01:34:13.073
- A lot of those good alternatives are being used up. And this is not simply any street. This is not a

01:34:13.073 --> 01:34:19.678
- street that can be compared with any other street in any other town. It is the north south corridor

01:34:19.678 --> 01:34:21.726
- that Bloomington residents and

01:34:22.114 --> 01:34:27.810
- visitors depend on to get where they need to go. I need to go to my physical therapist. I need to go

01:34:27.810 --> 01:34:33.674
- to work. I need to get through town, and that's how I can do it because of where I live. And so I think

01:34:33.674 --> 01:34:39.313
- it's a really important thing to consider residents' needs in this regard. Thank you. Thank you for

01:34:39.313 --> 01:34:44.952
- your comment. Is there any other comment in the chamber? One more. Wendy, please, if you don't mind

01:34:44.952 --> 01:34:50.366
- to sign in before you leave so that we have that record. Thank you. Your name is spelled right.

01:34:57.218 --> 01:35:04.423
- While we're waiting for the next speaker, is there anyone else online who's waiting to speak? All right,

01:35:04.423 --> 01:35:11.285
- in the chamber, please state your name, sign in, you'll have three minutes. My name's Dan Rary, and

01:35:11.285 --> 01:35:18.215
- I have Dan Rary Real Estate at 517 North Walnut Street, which is between 9th and 10th streets. And I

01:35:18.215 --> 01:35:24.734
- have owned that building there since 1973, 53 years. So I've seen a lot of comings and goings.

01:35:25.186 --> 01:35:33.787
- Parenthetically, when I was going to IU in the 1960s from 65 to 70, I worked the whole time. And part

01:35:33.787 --> 01:35:42.388
- of the time I worked as a delivery driver for Coca-Cola. So I'm very familiar with how this all works

01:35:42.388 --> 01:35:50.989
- with the trucking and deliveries and everything. And I just don't see any way it would be possible to

01:35:50.989 --> 01:35:52.254
- continue that.

01:35:52.418 --> 01:36:01.306
- if you turn these streets back to two-way. The problems there with speeding can be solved a lot of other

01:36:01.306 --> 01:36:09.601
- ways other than turning them into two-way streets. More enforcement and the timing of the lights.

01:36:09.601 --> 01:36:18.235
- I mean, I personally am always in a hurry, and I hate to see traffic slow down. But there are ways to

01:36:18.235 --> 01:36:21.790
- do that, and probably that should happen.

01:36:21.890 --> 01:36:30.748
- The disruption to the businesses that are in that corridor would be unbelievable. I remember when they

01:36:30.748 --> 01:36:39.606
- had the South Walnut Street widening and that ran businesses out left and right. When they had the big

01:36:39.606 --> 01:36:48.550
- dig on Kirkwood, if you can run McDonald's out of business, you have done something. And that's exactly

01:36:48.550 --> 01:36:51.646
- what happened. So I think that the,

01:36:51.746 --> 01:36:59.612
- disruption of a total switch to two-way streets I I'll be 80 my next birthday. I probably wouldn't live

01:36:59.612 --> 01:37:07.780
- long enough to see the thing completed And as far as the cost Those costs are always overrun. The timelines

01:37:07.780 --> 01:37:15.344
- are always overrun. I just think it'd be a disaster I Don't see any way to do this without changing

01:37:15.344 --> 01:37:18.974
- some of the parking and that street parking and

01:37:19.362 --> 01:37:27.687
- is vital because nobody's got enough parking in downtown Bloomington. I have a fairly good amount of

01:37:27.687 --> 01:37:36.506
- parking unless I want to change something on my building and then I'll start losing parking places because

01:37:36.506 --> 01:37:44.749
- of what planning would make me do. It happened just next door to my office building. So I guess I'm

01:37:44.749 --> 01:37:46.974
- skeptical. I think this is

01:37:47.682 --> 01:37:54.568
- been run at us again since 2018. I think there are a lot of people that have their mind made up, yeah,

01:37:54.568 --> 01:38:01.521
- this is what we're going to do, regardless of what the public thinks. And I'm not hearing anything from

01:38:01.521 --> 01:38:08.541
- anybody that thinks this is a good idea. I appreciate you letting me speak. Thank you for your comments.

01:38:08.541 --> 01:38:14.558
- Is there anybody else who'd like to speak? Please come to the podium and state your name.

01:38:21.538 --> 01:38:29.741
- Three minutes. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Margaret Clements and I've been a member of the Monroe County

01:38:29.741 --> 01:38:37.480
- Plan Commission since 2018 for several of those years I served as its president and therefore I was

01:38:37.480 --> 01:38:45.374
- assigned as the Monroe County Plan Commission's delegate to the Metropolitan Planning Organization so

01:38:45.666 --> 01:38:53.071
- couple of the things that I want to point out and there's so many of them I know I won't have enough

01:38:53.071 --> 01:39:00.697
- time in three minutes to mention them. There are a lot of inferential flaws that were mentioned tonight

01:39:00.697 --> 01:39:08.102
- in Mr. Roebling's discussion. I think it derives from tool designs results that they shared with you

01:39:08.102 --> 01:39:10.302
- which is probably a franchise

01:39:10.754 --> 01:39:18.715
- that they've tried to sell to exactly cities our size, you know. South Bend was mentioned as a comparison,

01:39:18.715 --> 01:39:26.155
- and I grew up in South Bend within one or two blocks of all of the changes that have been advocated

01:39:26.155 --> 01:39:33.595
- by Mayor Pete, et cetera. And there's some striking differences between South Bend and Bloomington.

01:39:33.595 --> 01:39:38.878
- Number one, South Bend had a dead downtown, and they had to revive it.

01:39:39.138 --> 01:39:47.280
- We have had a live downtown and we're in the process of killing it. I'm going to repeat what I said

01:39:47.280 --> 01:39:49.886
- in 2018 when the two way study.

01:39:50.018 --> 01:39:56.867
- was brought up for the first time, and that is that these are over-engineered solutions to non-existent

01:39:56.867 --> 01:40:03.453
- problems. And I really would appreciate it if the leadership in this community could just listen to

01:40:03.453 --> 01:40:10.302
- the smart constituents you have. You know, you have a lot of people with a lot of experience, with love

01:40:10.302 --> 01:40:13.726
- for the community, and this isn't working for them.

01:40:13.826 --> 01:40:21.996
- It took me 45 minutes to get across town the other day. I took 3rd Street out from the east side to

01:40:21.996 --> 01:40:30.820
- Lowe's. I have options. You know, I could go to Bedford. I could go to Columbus. I could go to Martinsville

01:40:30.820 --> 01:40:39.643
- for something that I needed, a store. I mean, how far away do you want to drive business, harm the climate,

01:40:39.643 --> 01:40:40.542
- et cetera?

01:40:40.642 --> 01:40:48.504
- It's just becoming ridiculous. The next day, there was a road rage incident involving a gun on that

01:40:48.504 --> 01:40:56.367
- corridor at about the same time. The reduction in the traffic having been reduced by 31% is because

01:40:56.367 --> 01:41:04.543
- you've made it so miserable to drive in Bloomington, Indiana. And so I'd like to advocate, which nobody

01:41:04.543 --> 01:41:09.182
- does, for the driver experience. People have things to do.

01:41:09.346 --> 01:41:16.675
- Places to go they have work to do Please use these roadways for what they were intended to do and that

01:41:16.675 --> 01:41:23.933
- is to help the taxpayer become efficient productive and Contributing citizens to our community. Thank

01:41:23.933 --> 01:41:31.049
- you very much. Thank you for your comment Anyone online Let's go to the next commenter in chambers,

01:41:31.049 --> 01:41:35.390
- please sign in state your name. You'll have three minutes. I

01:41:46.594 --> 01:41:54.838
- My name is Scott Ferris. My family's been in Bloomington since 1826, and I'm a sixth generation. We've

01:41:54.838 --> 01:42:02.922
- had several businesses along the Walnut, even some buildings on College, and we've been around for a

01:42:02.922 --> 01:42:10.526
- long time. Members of my family have been involved in the city politics here over the decades.

01:42:11.714 --> 01:42:17.651
- Matter of fact, my father, I believe, sat in this body at one point in time on the Traffic Commission.

01:42:17.651 --> 01:42:23.416
- I'm very familiar because I grew up in this environment of how the city of Bloomington was going to

01:42:23.416 --> 01:42:29.353
- move traffic through the community. And this is north, south, east, and west. You had College, Walnut,

01:42:29.353 --> 01:42:35.406
- you had Atwater, and you had Third Street. And eventually, because they moved the semis out of the city,

01:42:35.406 --> 01:42:39.326
- they put them out on the bypass. And that was the flow of the city.

01:42:40.194 --> 01:42:47.255
- For all intents and purposes, not a whole lot has changed since that took place, other than some of

01:42:47.255 --> 01:42:54.315
- the measures that were put in place to take and promote public safety. And I support public safety,

01:42:54.315 --> 01:43:01.376
- but I believe there should be a balance. So Indiana University, back when I was here in the 70s, we

01:43:01.376 --> 01:43:08.436
- had probably, I don't know, 34,000 students. Now we've got 45,000, 50,000 students. The housing for

01:43:08.436 --> 01:43:09.566
- those students,

01:43:09.858 --> 01:43:16.618
- for the most part, are in apartments and also in rental properties because the university has not built

01:43:16.618 --> 01:43:23.183
- enough additional dormitories. And it used to be that the students could not drive until your junior

01:43:23.183 --> 01:43:29.943
- year. There were restrictions for that. So we've got a tremendous influx of traffic. We've got measures

01:43:29.943 --> 01:43:36.573
- that have been put in place which are slowing down that traffic. And a fundamental flaw in this study

01:43:36.573 --> 01:43:38.718
- is that not taking consideration

01:43:39.490 --> 01:43:46.501
- anything to do with IU and the traffic that comes with it. I'm talking about football games, basketball

01:43:46.501 --> 01:43:53.377
- games, parents' weekends, which happens all the time. Just go downtown on a Friday and Saturday night

01:43:53.377 --> 01:44:00.253
- to go to dinner and you'll see it. Taking Walnut and College from three to two lanes makes absolutely

01:44:00.253 --> 01:44:07.870
- no sense at all. Just go up at noontime and sit around the square and watch the traffic flow. It makes no sense.

01:44:08.354 --> 01:44:14.224
- I'm not going to repeat what others have said because of the time. You all need to take to heart what

01:44:14.224 --> 01:44:20.267
- the mayor has said with respect about what she's not going to do during her tenure as mayor with respect

01:44:20.267 --> 01:44:26.253
- to college and Walnut. The B-squared document, which was published this morning, goes into great detail

01:44:26.253 --> 01:44:32.065
- and does an excellent summary of a lot of positions I was going to bring up, and I encourage you all

01:44:32.065 --> 01:44:36.094
- to look at it. And because I'm running out of time, I would hope that

01:44:36.482 --> 01:44:42.518
- You all would open up the documents from the athletic director, IU athletic director, and also from

01:44:42.518 --> 01:44:48.857
- the airport director, and read them so all of us can see what, in fact, were discussed in those letters.

01:44:48.857 --> 01:44:54.953
- I do not support any aspect of this study. It is an absolute waste of money, and the taxpayer should

01:44:54.953 --> 01:45:01.473
- not take upon any additional burden. Thank you. Thank you very much. Further public comment in the chamber,

01:45:01.473 --> 01:45:06.302
- please come to the podium. Sign in. State your name. You'll have three minutes.

01:45:15.234 --> 01:45:22.711
- Good evening. I'm Paul Kerberg. I'm not much of a public speaker, so you know it's important for me

01:45:22.711 --> 01:45:30.188
- to get up here to actually speak. I'm a lifelong Monero County resident and former city engineering

01:45:30.188 --> 01:45:37.665
- employee. To me, just the cost of this project is astronomically insane. I'm all about revitalizing

01:45:37.665 --> 01:45:43.198
- downtown, spending that money to improve the downtown area, the corridor.

01:45:43.330 --> 01:45:50.923
- College and Walnut are main thoroughfares through town. And we need to keep them that way and not restrict

01:45:50.923 --> 01:45:58.374
- the flow of traffic. I'm also a former cyclist. I've probably ridden more than most people in this room.

01:45:58.374 --> 01:46:05.258
- And to me, I would not want to ride on a primary arterial. You want to be away from the traffic.

01:46:05.258 --> 01:46:12.638
- And to me, there's also a lot of just speculation and what ifs. We really don't know what this will do.

01:46:13.954 --> 01:46:21.627
- We know how things are now, and we could improve upon what we have existing within the city and revitalize

01:46:21.627 --> 01:46:28.798
- the corridor. So yes, I'm definitely against this plan. Thanks. Thank you for your comment. Further

01:46:28.798 --> 01:46:36.542
- public comment on TCR 2622. Please come to the podium. Sign in. State your name. You'll have three minutes.

01:46:51.106 --> 01:47:00.735
- Good evening. My name is Eric host and appreciate this opportunity to offer comment I asked you to proceed

01:47:00.735 --> 01:47:09.645
- carefully because Well for many reasons hopefully I'll get to them I want to speak to transparency

01:47:09.645 --> 01:47:16.574
- measurement accountability and trust We're talking about safety this evening

01:47:17.186 --> 01:47:25.313
- And in order for us to determine what safety is, we have to define it. And I don't think we've adequately

01:47:25.313 --> 01:47:33.286
- defined what safety is. Safety isn't merely slower speeds. Safety isn't merely fewer injuries on roads.

01:47:33.286 --> 01:47:41.183
- Because safety involves things like emergency response. So when we talk about safety and we talk about

01:47:41.183 --> 01:47:45.630
- trust, I think we need to listen to emergency responders.

01:47:47.234 --> 01:47:56.347
- whose very commitment is to help people in need. And I want to note that the emergency responders uniformly

01:47:56.347 --> 01:48:04.785
- objected to the plan for East Rogers Road, but yet we're still moving forward with that. So I think

01:48:04.785 --> 01:48:13.982
- you have to carefully consider what we're doing here. I also want to speak in favor of data and measurement.

01:48:14.082 --> 01:48:22.567
- So I would ask that all traffic studies, all traffic counts, vehicle type counts, vehicle velocity counts,

01:48:22.567 --> 01:48:30.576
- accident reports in complete ARIES format be published prior and current and present, I mean future,

01:48:30.576 --> 01:48:38.505
- so that we can actually see what the data says. Data does say that 1.8% of our population commutes.

01:48:38.505 --> 01:48:41.598
- The estimate in city documents is that

01:48:42.146 --> 01:48:49.370
- 5% or fewer people recreationally bicycle. That's a minority. It's an important way to get around, but

01:48:49.370 --> 01:48:56.523
- I think choice, I mean, I've been a lifelong bicyclist, so I knew how to get around even before there

01:48:56.523 --> 01:49:03.606
- were protected bike lanes and other infrastructure that we're building right now. I would also speak

01:49:03.606 --> 01:49:09.918
- in favor of enforcement rather than obstruction because making it more difficult to drive

01:49:11.682 --> 01:49:19.176
- Does not make the road safer for anyone. I think that's all I'd like to say tonight. Thank you. Thank

01:49:19.176 --> 01:49:26.965
- you for your comment. Are there any other public comments on TCR 2622? Please come to the podium. Anybody

01:49:26.965 --> 01:49:34.606
- online who wants to speak? Anyone who's raised their hand? Last call. If you'd like to speak and you're

01:49:34.606 --> 01:49:40.190
- online, please use the raise hand function in zoom and you'll be called on.

01:49:42.338 --> 01:49:50.026
- Last call in chambers. We'll come back to the commission for second round of questions. Are there any

01:49:50.026 --> 01:49:58.015
- questions from commissioners on TCR 2622? To my left. To my right, Mr. Flaherty. Yeah, I wanted to follow

01:49:58.015 --> 01:50:06.080
- up about the comment from Mr. Rousseau in particular with regard to the design choice of two-way protected

01:50:06.080 --> 01:50:11.582
- bike lanes, which I think would be in either one-way or two-way concept.

01:50:12.098 --> 01:50:20.417
- Could you say a little bit more about that design choice, why that's recommended over, say, protected

01:50:20.417 --> 01:50:28.898
- bike lanes that are on both sides of the street next to the drive lane that's going the same direction,

01:50:28.898 --> 01:50:37.054
- what the tradeoffs are, and why the recommendation? Yes. There's a couple of tradeoffs to consider.

01:50:37.218 --> 01:50:46.232
- One way Mr. Russo is correct that one way bike lanes are the safest for essentially all the reasons

01:50:46.232 --> 01:50:53.534
- he pointed out. However there are some major drawbacks in that they prefer they.

01:50:53.730 --> 01:50:59.888
- change the location of the curb because you in order to protect them the bike lane has to be between

01:50:59.888 --> 01:51:06.107
- the curb and the existing curb so that would eliminate things like it could potentially eliminate and

01:51:06.107 --> 01:51:11.838
- reduce space for things like parking things like loading zones and things like that the other

01:51:12.354 --> 01:51:23.426
- A thing we heard from public engagement, especially early on, was that in regards to the seven line,

01:51:23.426 --> 01:51:34.499
- drivers specifically, excuse me, did not like the lower street level bike lane. We looked at what we

01:51:34.499 --> 01:51:40.638
- could do to fix that solution and the best proposal was

01:51:40.738 --> 01:51:49.044
- Similar to the cultural trail in Indianapolis was an urban trail, which is raised elevated and separated

01:51:49.044 --> 01:51:57.192
- it allowed drivers to see them bicyclists pedestrians scooter riders more easily from further away and

01:51:57.192 --> 01:52:05.182
- it the similar to the Seven line the urban trail design features other safety improvements including

01:52:05.410 --> 01:52:11.382
- Pedestrian leading pedestrian intervals and similar for bicycles and scooter riders where they will

01:52:11.382 --> 01:52:17.474
- be able to move easily through the traffic and then they'll have turn phases which are Separated from

01:52:17.474 --> 01:52:23.745
- those phases so they there won't be vulnerable road users in the crosswalk At the time the turn vehicles

01:52:23.745 --> 01:52:28.702
- have a green light. So we took the feedback we got from the seven line and kind of

01:52:29.090 --> 01:52:36.425
- Said, what could we do to make that better? But yeah, ultimately a one way for safety for bicyclists

01:52:36.425 --> 01:52:43.759
- is the one way protected by clean is the optimal design, but it takes up considerably more space and

01:52:43.759 --> 01:52:51.167
- you can't have the kind of features, the additional safety benefits that you get from the urban trail

01:52:51.167 --> 01:52:57.630
- design through the urban set core of the city. Thank you. For the questions, Mr. Binder.

01:53:00.674 --> 01:53:09.748
- several commenters mentioned enforcement. And I do agree that traffic enforcement downtown is pretty

01:53:09.748 --> 01:53:19.362
- lacking at times. So Mr. Roebling, what would your response be to that particular bit of feedback? Because

01:53:19.362 --> 01:53:29.694
- I think I've heard maybe at least half of the commenters mention that if only we were to enforce traffic laws more

01:53:30.178 --> 01:53:38.424
- explicitly speed in particular, that would do a lot to help things. What would you say to that, and

01:53:38.424 --> 01:53:46.916
- I guess really specifically, what is it about enforcement that alone it wouldn't accomplish the city's

01:53:46.916 --> 01:53:50.462
- goals? Yeah, that is such a good question.

01:53:51.074 --> 01:53:59.118
- Enforcement is one of the three E's of traffic safety. There's now five but engineering and education

01:53:59.118 --> 01:54:07.399
- are the other two classic three E's and it is the hardest kind of to do because you need police officers

01:54:07.399 --> 01:54:13.630
- readily available to constantly enforce vehicle speed limits and that it takes

01:54:13.730 --> 01:54:20.241
- those police officers off their beat, for lack of a better word, and requires them to just

01:54:20.241 --> 01:54:27.539
- sit and occasionally look out for speeders. You can see this on I-69. You see state highway patrolmen

01:54:27.539 --> 01:54:34.981
- sitting at various intersections waiting for speeders to come by. You can also see what happens is cars

01:54:34.981 --> 01:54:42.207
- slow down, they slam on their brakes, they see the police ahead, and then immediately afterward they

01:54:42.207 --> 01:54:43.710
- pick up often to the

01:54:44.098 --> 01:54:50.187
- you know, always to the same speed, but often to a higher speed than they had previously. So

01:54:50.187 --> 01:54:56.799
- their enforcement benefit would have to be constant and continuous, which is incredibly difficult on

01:54:56.799 --> 01:55:03.608
- an already stressed police enforcement or police staff. And the state of Indiana, unfortunately, limits

01:55:03.608 --> 01:55:10.155
- our ability to do things like speed cameras and traffic enforcement, automated traffic enforcement.

01:55:10.155 --> 01:55:12.446
- So those are additionally limited.

01:55:12.546 --> 01:55:21.483
- essentially limiting our ability to attack this at the enforcement only angle, which would be amazing.

01:55:21.483 --> 01:55:30.333
- I think everybody would be supportive of that, but it's just with limited funds and staff hours. It's

01:55:30.333 --> 01:55:37.534
- difficult. Thank you. The questions to my right to my left. Mr Sossberg. Oh, okay.

01:55:38.498 --> 01:55:45.632
- I've got a question. I'd like to ask about the cost of this project. First of all, it doesn't sound

01:55:45.632 --> 01:55:52.908
- like one project. It sounds like a series of projects over time, number one. Number two, can you give

01:55:52.908 --> 01:56:00.327
- us a sense of what other street improvement projects have cost over the years? What's a ballpark figure

01:56:00.327 --> 01:56:06.462
- for improving an entire block in terms of repairing curbs, building sidewalks, adding

01:56:06.626 --> 01:56:13.494
- bike racks, adding lanes, changing lights. Do we have any kind of ballpark figures to compare these

01:56:13.494 --> 01:56:20.567
- numbers to? Certainly. I don't want to overstep my engineering knowledge, so I'll see if Mr. Garzi has

01:56:20.567 --> 01:56:27.572
- a better estimation as an engineer, but I'm happy to jump back. Mr. Garzi, at last, your services are

01:56:27.572 --> 01:56:33.822
- of use. Can you give us any kind of ballpark figure to compare to this 103 to 109 million?

01:56:35.618 --> 01:56:44.841
- answer but unfortunately I don't. Okay so this is at least something that we ought to find information

01:56:44.841 --> 01:56:54.243
- for for further up the line. Iris Bull. I'm the administrative assistant for the engineering department.

01:56:54.243 --> 01:57:03.198
- One of my duties involves supporting the capital project staff on projects and this question is one

01:57:03.330 --> 01:57:10.894
- personally that I have asked many times in my two years, almost two years with the department. I'm delighted

01:57:10.894 --> 01:57:17.833
- you're here. So I understand the desire to want to be able to nail down a specific number to like a

01:57:17.833 --> 01:57:24.911
- particular asset. And in my time with the department, I have learned that unfortunately the answer is

01:57:24.911 --> 01:57:30.462
- less standardized than we would like. And there are unfortunately almost always

01:57:30.722 --> 01:57:38.023
- conditions, real-world conditions that get in the way of good faith estimates. So even when our project,

01:57:38.023 --> 01:57:45.255
- we put an enormous amount of effort into scheduling a cost for projects. There are just so many factors

01:57:45.255 --> 01:57:52.556
- outside of staff control that drive costs up and that has everything to do with the larger macroeconomic

01:57:52.556 --> 01:57:58.814
- environment. It has to do with the scheduling of different contractors. It has to do with

01:57:59.458 --> 01:58:07.026
- the weather sometimes. And to your point that we should be able to identify, for example, the cost of

01:58:07.026 --> 01:58:14.445
- a curb ramp, we absolutely can do that. It's, I think, a public education process that I would like

01:58:14.445 --> 01:58:21.865
- to put on our agenda as something that we can continue to talk about. I don't know that it would be

01:58:21.865 --> 01:58:28.542
- particularly educational in this moment to be able to say, well, that $103 tool estimated

01:58:28.642 --> 01:58:36.390
- is something that is intimately tied with our department's budgeting or anything. But I'm not looking

01:58:36.390 --> 01:58:43.987
- for that. I appreciate the answer, but I'm looking for, again, a ballpark figure. What is a typical

01:58:43.987 --> 01:58:51.963
- cost that engineering estimates that the city incurs in the normal maintenance of our built environment,

01:58:51.963 --> 01:58:54.014
- of our built right of way?

01:58:54.114 --> 01:59:02.536
- How much more does a project like this add? I mean, we're always having to maintain our streets, right,

01:59:02.536 --> 01:59:10.634
- to upgrade traffic lights. This is all normal course of business. I'm just trying to get a sense of

01:59:10.634 --> 01:59:13.630
- is this an ordinate cost compared to

01:59:14.530 --> 01:59:21.016
- Yeah. So I can offer two things. One, I can come back with recent engineered numbers, but I can also

01:59:21.016 --> 01:59:27.758
- give what engineering often gives as a napkin estimate is a mile of sidewalk is about a million dollars.

01:59:27.758 --> 01:59:34.372
- I'll let Mr. Garza yell at me if I'm wrong. And traffic signal is about a quarter of a million or half

01:59:34.372 --> 01:59:40.986
- a million to three quarters of a million, depending on what the geometry of the intersection requires.

01:59:40.986 --> 01:59:42.142
- And yeah, we have

01:59:42.274 --> 01:59:49.318
- numbers for all of that. Well, let's stop right there for a second. So the corridor we're talking about

01:59:49.318 --> 01:59:56.294
- is 4.1 miles. Is that right? 4.2 miles. And how many lights are on that quarter? There are 25 signaled

01:59:56.294 --> 02:00:03.135
- intersections. All right. So we're talking about 12 and a half to 17 million dollars just to replace

02:00:03.135 --> 02:00:10.111
- traffic lights if we ever needed to. And over time we need to. And four miles of sidewalk on each side

02:00:10.111 --> 02:00:11.262
- of both streets.

02:00:11.362 --> 02:00:19.651
- is one, two, three, four, $16 million right there. So we're looking at just the normal course of replacing

02:00:19.651 --> 02:00:27.862
- or adding sidewalks and traffic lights in this corridor. We're talking about 30 to $35 million. So that's

02:00:27.862 --> 02:00:35.608
- what I'm looking for is some kind of a ballpark. That's normal cost just to keep things the same if

02:00:35.608 --> 02:00:40.798
- you're trying to replace it. So what would you say are the biggest

02:00:41.410 --> 02:00:48.860
- changes to the normal way, to the way that the roads are now, that would be the most significant expense

02:00:48.860 --> 02:00:56.240
- among all the things that might be done over a 20-year period. Yeah, so in the keeping things or adding

02:00:56.240 --> 02:01:03.407
- smaller things like sidewalks, curb, changing curb, existing curb and relocating them, that's a huge

02:01:03.407 --> 02:01:07.806
- expense. Things like the urban trail would be a huge expense.

02:01:07.906 --> 02:01:14.203
- Those are the largest chunks. But there's also, in the cost estimate, there is bridge reconstruction,

02:01:14.203 --> 02:01:20.746
- which is not something that's part of normal every day. Did you say brick reconstruction? Bridge. Bridge,

02:01:20.746 --> 02:01:26.981
- sorry. Yeah, sorry. No, I think Rick's doing great. OK. But no, bridge reconstruction, and those are

02:01:26.981 --> 02:01:32.414
- things that would need to be updated anyway, but outside of a larger project, or sorry,

02:01:32.514 --> 02:01:40.804
- both outside of a larger project and outside of your everyday. And those add to huge costs. So you have

02:01:40.804 --> 02:01:48.934
- the Dodd Street Bridge. So my last follow-up then would be what portion does the city usually pay for

02:01:48.934 --> 02:01:55.390
- projects like this knowing that state and federal funds are often used for them?

02:01:55.554 --> 02:02:02.326
- Is 103 million dollars or 109 million dollars going to all come out of city coffers or that's the total

02:02:02.326 --> 02:02:08.968
- cost of the project and A fraction of that will come out of our coffers if you were to do it tomorrow

02:02:08.968 --> 02:02:15.675
- Just hypothetically not that that's the proposal it we would expect to do 20% local match And then the

02:02:15.675 --> 02:02:22.187
- rest would be federal so practically speaking over the course of 20 years a project like this might

02:02:22.187 --> 02:02:23.294
- cost us 20 to 21

02:02:23.778 --> 02:02:31.267
- 20 to 22 million dollars out of the city coffers or roughly a million dollars a year is It's what we're

02:02:31.267 --> 02:02:38.684
- talking about for a project like this Whatever that's my assumption. Let me go to other questions. Mr.

02:02:38.684 --> 02:02:46.101
- Coppock. I think you've raised one Ryan is that the cost that said construction cost does that include

02:02:46.101 --> 02:02:53.086
- the What we call soft costs like engineering design and right away is that all included in that?

02:02:53.218 --> 02:03:03.157
- Six million or whatever it was. Both of those totals are the entirety of cost, so design everything.

02:03:03.157 --> 02:03:13.392
- Further questions? Ms. Sucuruchko. Yeah, how do we plan to measure our goals, or like how do we achieve

02:03:13.392 --> 02:03:19.198
- success with this project? Oh, yeah, such a good question.

02:03:19.490 --> 02:03:26.207
- As with every project we do we do before and afters this one is unique in that we did a huge study looking

02:03:26.207 --> 02:03:32.736
- at the before. So I would propose that planning and engineering staff work together to do a huge follow

02:03:32.736 --> 02:03:37.758
- up especially since kind of the findings are so important to the city's future.

02:03:38.338 --> 02:03:44.586
- development. So that's kind of what we would do. We would go back and do look at the exact same things

02:03:44.586 --> 02:03:50.651
- we looked at before and see if any other issues popped up or other concerns or other things that we

02:03:50.651 --> 02:03:56.899
- kind of saw as needs. Like I mentioned in the Columbus, Ohio example earlier, the residents complained

02:03:56.899 --> 02:04:00.478
- about truck traffic and so they redesigned the street with

02:04:00.578 --> 02:04:05.702
- They didn't change, modify the street, but they redesigned truck routes to, you know, prevent those

02:04:05.702 --> 02:04:11.082
- trucks from traveling through those neighborhoods and things like that. So those are the types of things

02:04:11.082 --> 02:04:16.462
- we would constantly be analyzing. We update the, well, we required to update the safe streets and roads.

02:04:16.462 --> 02:04:21.689
- We're all safety action plan every five years. So we'll be able to see incremental improvements along

02:04:21.689 --> 02:04:26.915
- any corridor. And we're constantly looking at every, basically every street. Engineering does traffic

02:04:26.915 --> 02:04:28.862
- counts all over the city every month.

02:04:30.370 --> 02:04:37.302
- Thank you. But before we start the project, it would be interesting to see how we envision those goals

02:04:37.302 --> 02:04:44.100
- and how each of the projects will contribute to achieving those goals. But I think it's a bit harder

02:04:44.100 --> 02:04:51.167
- to grasp right now. Just a comment. OK. Is there any other last minute questions before we go to debate?

02:04:51.167 --> 02:04:57.897
- All right. So once again, the choices ahead of us are to make a positive recommendation, a negative

02:04:57.897 --> 02:04:58.974
- recommendation,

02:04:59.458 --> 02:05:07.421
- no recommendation or to continue to another meeting. So as members speak to this issue based on what

02:05:07.421 --> 02:05:14.832
- they've heard tonight, please keep that in mind. It might be helpful if you can say what kind

02:05:14.832 --> 02:05:23.111
- of recommendation you're leaning toward as you speak. So with that, who would like to speak to TCR 2622?

02:05:23.111 --> 02:05:26.974
- Let's not all raise your hands at the same time.

02:05:28.770 --> 02:05:35.606
- On my right, anyone have an opinion? Mr. Flaherty. I can start. Thank you. First of all, just thank

02:05:35.606 --> 02:05:42.511
- you very much to city staff for your work on this and the presentation. Obviously, it's been part of

02:05:42.511 --> 02:05:49.416
- the city plans for the last eight years and something that's been working through a lot of extensive

02:05:49.416 --> 02:05:51.262
- public engagement designed

02:05:51.554 --> 02:05:58.687
- maybe not design shorts, but corridor walks and a lot of direct outreach and engagement with the business

02:05:58.687 --> 02:06:05.752
- community, et cetera. I do appreciate some of what we heard around balancing trade-offs across a variety

02:06:05.752 --> 02:06:12.750
- of different goals and some of the things that we can make real no-regrets improvements on, like adding

02:06:12.750 --> 02:06:20.286
- loading zones. I think most of us have experienced the problems with trucks simply just parking in drive lanes.

02:06:20.450 --> 02:06:28.338
- And the risks that entails is people, you know, try to time and whip out in front of, you know, or traffic

02:06:28.338 --> 02:06:35.784
- coming up behind them to get around because they're tired of waiting. So those things are, you know,

02:06:35.784 --> 02:06:41.534
- exciting. I think broadly we have defined in city code what our criteria are.

02:06:41.698 --> 02:06:48.988
- to try to effectuate and advance city goals, which are contained in comprehensive plan, transportation

02:06:48.988 --> 02:06:56.066
- plan, and outlined in the recommendation from staff. Definitely recognize and appreciate the public

02:06:56.066 --> 02:07:03.214
- comments tonight. So there was a lot of focus on two-way versus one-way, which that's not really the

02:07:03.214 --> 02:07:10.291
- core question, I guess, to me. I would be interested to hear from colleagues if there are folks who

02:07:10.291 --> 02:07:11.070
- feel like,

02:07:11.266 --> 02:07:17.443
- I didn't review, for instance, any one-way concept designs to actually look at, I don't think they were

02:07:17.443 --> 02:07:23.441
- included in the packet, to actually look at cross-section street design for the one-way alternative.

02:07:23.441 --> 02:07:29.499
- But I'd be curious, and my colleagues on the commission here feel like we want to explore that option

02:07:29.499 --> 02:07:35.439
- more deeply and talk about the trade-offs there. I did hear a fair amount of opposition, folks just

02:07:35.439 --> 02:07:40.190
- sort of not thinking this is necessary right, or like they don't agree with it.

02:07:40.706 --> 02:07:46.844
- in principle, and it seems like there's some disagreement with the city's goals. Or if there's agreement

02:07:46.844 --> 02:07:52.807
- with the broad goals, like a disagreement with kind of the core principles of how to accomplish them.

02:07:52.807 --> 02:07:58.828
- So I heard a lot of skepticism about reducing speeds and the impact of that about things like reducing

02:07:58.828 --> 02:08:05.025
- crossing distances, LPIs, having separated dedicated infrastructure for vulnerable road users, especially

02:08:05.025 --> 02:08:05.726
- bicyclists.

02:08:05.922 --> 02:08:11.434
- And I'm not sure we can really solve those things. There's a diversity of opinions. I really try to

02:08:11.434 --> 02:08:17.278
- lean into what evidence we have, not always from our Bloomington community, but from really meta-analyses

02:08:17.278 --> 02:08:22.680
- of what's been done in communities across the country and around the world to make infrastructure

02:08:22.680 --> 02:08:28.578
- improvements, safety by design in essence, and what the track record is on those. So I hear folks thinking

02:08:28.578 --> 02:08:33.374
- it's absurd that we could even state a goal of eliminating traffic deaths in our city.

02:08:33.506 --> 02:08:39.489
- I just respectfully disagree. I think that is a goal that we should have. When we talked about some

02:08:39.489 --> 02:08:45.651
- similar concepts at the city council recently, I noted that in the last 35 years or so, Europe has cut

02:08:45.651 --> 02:08:51.634
- their annual deaths, Europe as a whole, in traffic, from 75,000 a year down to about 20,000 a year.

02:08:51.634 --> 02:08:57.797
- So no, they're not at zero, but that's 55,000 lives a year that they are saving relative to where they

02:08:57.797 --> 02:09:02.942
- used to be. They used to be two and a half times the annual rate of deaths in the US.

02:09:03.170 --> 02:09:09.385
- And now they're about half. That is a pretty striking and dramatic change. And it's been driven mostly

02:09:09.385 --> 02:09:15.480
- by infrastructure choices, design choices, trying to make streets safe by design. So I guess just as

02:09:15.480 --> 02:09:21.936
- a core foundational principle here, I do believe in what we're doing and trying to accomplish here through

02:09:21.936 --> 02:09:28.574
- design changes. Definitely respect if folks have a different opinion about that. But that's where I am on it.

02:09:29.378 --> 02:09:35.560
- I think the presentation was relatively compelling on the two-way versus the one-way and the benefits.

02:09:35.560 --> 02:09:41.862
- I really appreciated the analysis of all the different things that we can consider, economic development

02:09:41.862 --> 02:09:48.104
- lenses, loading zones, things like that. Certainly safety obviously is the first and foremost principle

02:09:48.104 --> 02:09:55.006
- that we're meant to prioritize through city code and city goals. So yeah, when it comes to the proposal, I have no

02:09:55.554 --> 02:10:02.307
- qualms delaying if folks want more time to dig into particular issues. I tend to align with the draft

02:10:02.307 --> 02:10:09.324
- recommendations from staff to forward a positive recommendation on the concept design supported by staff.

02:10:09.324 --> 02:10:15.944
- And so I'd be happy to do that if there was support for it. And if not, again, we'd be very curious

02:10:15.944 --> 02:10:22.366
- to hear what alternatives folks would be interested in. To me, the kind of outright rejection of

02:10:22.722 --> 02:10:30.794
- safety improvements on Walnut and College runs counter to city code, counter to city goals, and counter

02:10:30.794 --> 02:10:39.022
- to the mission of this commission. So that doesn't really seem like a suitable path before us. But again,

02:10:39.022 --> 02:10:46.939
- glad to hear the other perspectives. Thank you for your comments. Who would like to go next? Speak to

02:10:46.939 --> 02:10:51.518
- TCR 2622, Mr. Coppock. Well, from what I've heard tonight,

02:10:52.034 --> 02:10:58.686
- I haven't really heard any overwhelming support for making it two-way traffic. It's got an exorbitant

02:10:58.686 --> 02:11:05.404
- cost associated with it. And I think it's really going to prohibit people's ability to get around town

02:11:05.404 --> 02:11:12.056
- for service vehicles, delivery vehicles. I think you're going to get more of a bottleneck than you've

02:11:12.056 --> 02:11:19.100
- ever had. Everybody knows it on Friday. You always go to the middle lane when you're going through downtown

02:11:19.100 --> 02:11:20.926
- because of the beer trucks.

02:11:21.922 --> 02:11:29.434
- And I mean, I think that instead of this overwhelming, you know, over $100 million project, you could

02:11:29.434 --> 02:11:36.504
- look at some, evaluate if you do have some safety issues. You could make some spot improvements

02:11:36.504 --> 02:11:44.384
- or intersection improvements that could help eliminate those, but I just don't see the, I mean, it doesn't

02:11:44.384 --> 02:11:50.718
- seem like it's broke, so I don't know what we're trying to fix. Thank you. Thank you.

02:11:51.906 --> 02:12:14.334
- Further comment on TCR 2622? Anybody? Really? No thoughts? All right. Well, I'll take a crack here.

02:12:17.954 --> 02:12:25.830
- Two-way traffic is a feature of the vast majority of the city of Bloomington. I don't understand why

02:12:25.830 --> 02:12:34.174
- that is such an objection. Most places in town were used to two-way traffic. If anything, it's the one-way

02:12:34.174 --> 02:12:42.283
- traffic that messes up visitors to town who come in the fall to move their students here. I can't think

02:12:42.283 --> 02:12:47.742
- about College and Wallet and not think about East 3rd Street, east of

02:12:47.970 --> 02:12:57.761
- College Mall. I was god smacked when INDOT announced, INDOT of all entities said, there's not as much

02:12:57.761 --> 02:13:07.743
- traffic on this road as there used to be. We're going to reduce its width. They had dropped from 18,000

02:13:07.743 --> 02:13:17.918
- cars a day to 12,000 cars a day. And since when does an organization that is all about moving cars reduce

02:13:18.082 --> 02:13:24.984
- Capacity and yet they did the same principle is here when I came to town 40 years ago. I Used to see

02:13:24.984 --> 02:13:32.160
- the signs on wallet for business 37. It was a highway It was designed to be a highway. We heard evidence

02:13:32.160 --> 02:13:39.131
- that That we were it was the city. It was forced upon the city 70 years ago to make it into a highway

02:13:39.131 --> 02:13:46.238
- or you you're you know because that was the way to get in and out of this city and it's not anymore and

02:13:46.498 --> 02:13:55.047
- 2011, 15 years ago, we saw the massive improvement to what we call the bypass. This is what cities do

02:13:55.047 --> 02:14:03.512
- anymore and states serving cities, they don't run highways through cities anymore, they bypass them.

02:14:03.512 --> 02:14:12.228
- Why are we still trying to defend College and Walnut being a highway? It was designed to move cars like

02:14:12.228 --> 02:14:13.150
- a highway,

02:14:13.346 --> 02:14:21.321
- The state forced us to do that. And we've heard evidence that it's one of the most dangerous quarters

02:14:21.321 --> 02:14:29.218
- in the city. And I do not take that lightly. I represented this area, this most of the streets south

02:14:29.218 --> 02:14:37.272
- of 17th Street when I was on the council. In my last term on council, there were not one, not two, but

02:14:37.272 --> 02:14:39.774
- three pedestrian deaths, one on

02:14:40.130 --> 02:14:47.527
- third in Indiana, one and third in Washington, one and third and Walnut that were due to cars and they

02:14:47.527 --> 02:14:54.852
- didn't necessarily, they weren't necessarily driving too fast, they were just so much bigger than the

02:14:54.852 --> 02:15:02.320
- people that they hit. College and Walnut are going to need to be redesigned no matter which way traffic

02:15:02.320 --> 02:15:09.214
- runs, whether it's one way or two way. I was agnostic about it when I first heard the proposals

02:15:09.634 --> 02:15:16.327
- I was surprised when I heard the administration suggesting the two-way traffic would work. But after

02:15:16.327 --> 02:15:22.689
- the presentation tonight, after the material here, I see why they did it. It does have a number

02:15:22.689 --> 02:15:27.262
- of advantages. But I used to live downtown. I went to Ferris Market.

02:15:27.426 --> 02:15:33.415
- around the corner. I remember it on Walnut Street. I had a business on 4th Street, and I hated cars

02:15:33.415 --> 02:15:39.763
- zooming past my business. I wanted to slow down and see it. I wanted them to not run into the pedestrians

02:15:39.763 --> 02:15:45.811
- who were walking into my business. I didn't think that three lanes of traffic speeding by, the speed

02:15:45.811 --> 02:15:51.800
- wasn't good. The visibility was. The visibility would be better if it was two-way. People could see

02:15:51.800 --> 02:15:56.830
- it coming from both directions. They say don't build your church for Easter Sunday.

02:15:58.338 --> 02:16:06.444
- We shouldn't also not be building our parking lots for Black Friday, and we shouldn't be building our

02:16:06.444 --> 02:16:14.549
- roads for ladder trucks. 10 times as many people die in car crashes as in fires. If we had really had

02:16:14.549 --> 02:16:22.655
- concern about getting people to a hospital quicker, maybe we shouldn't have moved the hospital to the

02:16:22.655 --> 02:16:27.582
- edge of town. But I know that slower traffic moves more cars.

02:16:27.906 --> 02:16:35.095
- the formula for headway, the amount of space that someone has to keep between the car ahead of you in

02:16:35.095 --> 02:16:42.214
- order to keep a safe distance, it increases geometrically with speed. And so you can carry more cars

02:16:42.214 --> 02:16:49.333
- at 25 miles an hour on the same lane that you can at 35 miles an hour. It makes sense for any number

02:16:49.333 --> 02:16:56.382
- of reasons, not just safety, to reduce traffic speeds and improvements favor the prepared. So if we

02:16:56.578 --> 02:17:03.522
- have a shovel ready project. If we know what we want to do, we're more likely to be able to build it

02:17:03.522 --> 02:17:10.741
- cost effectively than if we keep dithering about it. So I am certainly supportive of any plan to improve

02:17:10.741 --> 02:17:17.823
- the city. I agree with the idea that engineering and design is by far the most effective way to reduce

02:17:17.823 --> 02:17:21.054
- speeds. You can't possibly hire enough police.

02:17:21.506 --> 02:17:28.989
- to enforce everything the way people think it should be done, who have people who have spoken about

02:17:28.989 --> 02:17:36.621
- it tonight. I would, however, like more information on costs. Like I estimated just the rough cost of

02:17:36.621 --> 02:17:44.104
- replacing sidewalks, updating or improving. I mean, I know how much time we spent grieving over our

02:17:44.104 --> 02:17:49.342
- inability to fund all the sidewalks demand that there is in the city.

02:17:49.858 --> 02:17:56.784
- So I know that it's not cheap just to do basic replacement of something as it is. I don't think that

02:17:56.784 --> 02:18:03.778
- this is going to be that much more expensive than just the normal course of maintenance over the next

02:18:03.778 --> 02:18:10.704
- 20 years. If we're going to maintain and change things, if we're going to update our infrastructure,

02:18:10.704 --> 02:18:17.767
- let's redesign it so that it's better. I mean, we already do this with utility programs. We change the

02:18:17.767 --> 02:18:19.070
- design of streets.

02:18:19.618 --> 02:18:27.034
- When we know there's a utility project about to happen But that design has to be made before the utilities

02:18:27.034 --> 02:18:34.381
- needs to to update the pipe underneath So rounded to the nearest million dollars. I'd like some estimates

02:18:34.381 --> 02:18:41.381
- on what it would cost You know like what the different where the costs came from They may already be

02:18:41.381 --> 02:18:45.470
- in the tool report and I missed it but I think it would be

02:18:45.986 --> 02:18:53.482
- instructive not only for that, but to give us a sense of how much other costs we incurred collectively,

02:18:53.482 --> 02:19:00.761
- maybe with the state and federal dollars, for projects like East 3rd Street, East Mall. How much did

02:19:00.761 --> 02:19:07.969
- it cost to change? How much did the bypass cost to expand? How much did South Walnut cost back when

02:19:07.969 --> 02:19:13.086
- it was updated, the couple blocks of South Walnut south of 3rd Street?

02:19:14.210 --> 02:19:22.289
- Anything to give us a ballpark sense of what this costs. So while I'm inclined to Give this a positive

02:19:22.289 --> 02:19:30.290
- recommendation. I would really rather continue it to our December 4th meeting, but that's my personal

02:19:30.290 --> 02:19:38.448
- opinion and I Welcome other people's opinions Just to get that data at least Mr. Binder Thanks, I first

02:19:38.448 --> 02:19:40.958
- of all, I want to thank all the

02:19:41.314 --> 02:19:49.272
- members of the public who came here tonight to comment. And I do want to acknowledge that we've heard

02:19:49.272 --> 02:19:57.151
- a lot of comments against this project in general. That said, I think the bottom line for me is that

02:19:57.151 --> 02:20:05.499
- you weigh that against all of the data and analyses presented by staff tonight. And it's pretty convincing

02:20:05.499 --> 02:20:11.038
- to me. I think staff has approached it from a lot of different angles.

02:20:11.586 --> 02:20:18.767
- safety, cost, feasibility, impact on local businesses and so forth. And I've also heard people say,

02:20:18.767 --> 02:20:25.948
- well, why are we still talking about this after seven, eight, nine years of talking about it? Well,

02:20:25.948 --> 02:20:33.273
- because it's a big project and I think it does deserve a lot of scrutiny that we are giving it and it

02:20:33.273 --> 02:20:40.670
- does deserve a lot of debate and consideration and examination of lots of different alternatives which

02:20:40.866 --> 02:20:51.958
- I think we've all heard lots of variations of at this point. Anyway, so when you look at other big comparable

02:20:51.958 --> 02:21:02.445
- public works projects like this, changes to the character of downtowns, you often find the public being

02:21:02.445 --> 02:21:10.814
- against it. The public is against congestion pricing in any city that proposes it.

02:21:11.362 --> 02:21:18.216
- before it's implemented. And then after it's implemented, you always find that in retrospect, people

02:21:18.216 --> 02:21:25.205
- change their opinion and having seen the positive effects that it brings, it turns into something that

02:21:25.205 --> 02:21:32.059
- enjoys a majority public support. Same for tearing down highways. I grew up in Milwaukee, Wisconsin,

02:21:32.059 --> 02:21:38.912
- and the mayor in the 1990s, John Norquist, tore down an urban freeway. And there was a lot of public

02:21:38.912 --> 02:21:39.998
- voicing against

02:21:40.514 --> 02:21:47.616
- doing that. And then after it was removed, it wasn't long. Just a few years later, people could scarcely

02:21:47.616 --> 02:21:54.650
- believe that it had been there in the first place. And I anticipate that, assuming some version of this

02:21:54.650 --> 02:22:01.413
- college walnut redesign goes through eventually, people will also look back at it in that same way,

02:22:01.413 --> 02:22:08.312
- too. They will scarcely believe that there were three lanes of traffic each direction running through

02:22:08.312 --> 02:22:10.206
- downtown, like the highway.

02:22:10.978 --> 02:22:19.482
- So I'm broadly in favor of this project. Like some other, I think, commissioners here, I'm not terribly

02:22:19.482 --> 02:22:27.822
- in favor or against one variant of the proposal or another, two-way or one-way, for example. But I do

02:22:27.822 --> 02:22:35.998
- look at these versions of the proposal, and I see why it is necessary to try to improve safety from

02:22:35.998 --> 02:22:38.206
- an engineering standpoint.

02:22:38.978 --> 02:22:46.393
- There are just too many examples out there of other cities that have accomplished dramatic increases

02:22:46.393 --> 02:22:53.221
- in road safety for everybody through good design. And I do believe that's possible here too.

02:22:53.221 --> 02:23:00.783
- So thank you. Point out the administration is proposing a particular proposal. This proposes a two way

02:23:00.783 --> 02:23:08.638
- change. So if members want to propose a one way change, they should maybe say that, indicate that in their

02:23:09.058 --> 02:23:17.226
- I mean, in that case, I think I should clarify that given that that's what is being proposed,

02:23:17.226 --> 02:23:26.003
- I am in favor. All right. Further comments? To my left, Mr. Stosberg. Yes. I come here from what was

02:23:26.003 --> 02:23:34.693
- the Bicycle, Pedestrian Safety Commission. I had a particular focus on crash analysis, particularly

02:23:34.693 --> 02:23:39.038
- looking at local crashes and how to prevent them.

02:23:39.842 --> 02:23:47.067
- Staff presenting is consistent with what I've learned and trends nationally. Drivers drive the design

02:23:47.067 --> 02:23:54.646
- speed, not the sign speed. This redesigning the roadway is an effective way to improve the overall safety.

02:23:54.646 --> 02:24:01.801
- A lot of those hearings we had here and at the Bike Pet Commission, people ask, what about emergency

02:24:01.801 --> 02:24:06.334
- vehicles? That's been asked a lot and the staff works with the,

02:24:07.554 --> 02:24:14.166
- parts of the city to make sure our designs work for them. They presented here a travel lane. They said

02:24:14.166 --> 02:24:20.907
- it works for the emergency vehicles. This is going to be better for move-in day. It's going to be better

02:24:20.907 --> 02:24:27.584
- for parents day, less people turning the wrong way on one-way streets. We asked about game day. They're

02:24:27.584 --> 02:24:34.132
- designing it for what it should be. This is not a Black Friday parking lot situation where it's going

02:24:34.132 --> 02:24:37.470
- to be empty the most of the year. They've looked at

02:24:38.114 --> 02:24:45.188
- check the box looking at economic impact and comparable cities. Not only do they look for cities like

02:24:45.188 --> 02:24:52.192
- comparable cities, but nationally, this is the trend. Cities are converting one ways to two ways and

02:24:52.192 --> 02:24:59.612
- they're keeping them. They're finding them successful economically and for safety. In terms of the volume,

02:24:59.612 --> 02:25:06.616
- it's not really a reduction in capacity as they explain. It's a way overbuilt street that gives us a

02:25:06.616 --> 02:25:07.934
- lot of possibility

02:25:08.130 --> 02:25:14.059
- to design it better and still meet our capacity needs. So that's going to work for us. And there are

02:25:14.059 --> 02:25:19.988
- other cities who are practicing this vision zero goal and having success. And so we're following the

02:25:19.988 --> 02:25:26.386
- footsteps of other places who've had success with these kinds of changes. And I think they can be successful

02:25:26.386 --> 02:25:32.374
- here too. This is also our commission is one step in a long process. There's the planning commission.

02:25:32.374 --> 02:25:36.894
- There's the city council. Even that only puts it in the transportation plan.

02:25:36.994 --> 02:25:43.677
- I have looked at many things in the transportation plan which never get implemented before the plan

02:25:43.677 --> 02:25:50.361
- gets rewritten. It does unlock some ability to start on some incremental improvements which I think

02:25:50.361 --> 02:25:57.311
- are going to be good in any case and just help us do long-term planning. For those reasons and for some

02:25:57.311 --> 02:26:04.463
- others given here, I'm in line to move this forward with a positive recommendation for the two-way design.

02:26:04.463 --> 02:26:06.334
- Thank you. Further comment?

02:26:08.610 --> 02:26:15.225
- I would honestly say that I think I'm lacking information at this stage to be inclined to choose one

02:26:15.225 --> 02:26:21.774
- option over another, but I feel like if we need to move it forward, do we have to choose the design

02:26:21.774 --> 02:26:28.717
- we're moving with right now or we're just discussing whether we can move the further analysis and design.

02:26:28.717 --> 02:26:35.921
- It's in a way question and there will be comment. It's a nine member commission. It requires five affirmative

02:26:35.921 --> 02:26:37.886
- votes for any motion. So, uh,

02:26:38.178 --> 02:26:44.952
- If a motion does not get five votes, then we have to make another motion that would. It might be positive,

02:26:44.952 --> 02:26:51.347
- it might be negative, it might be no, it might wind up, we might punt if we don't have enough votes.

02:26:51.347 --> 02:26:57.931
- So it would take five out of seven votes tonight to advance any kind of recommendation. Everyone should

02:26:57.931 --> 02:27:02.046
- take that into their consideration as they consider how to vote.

02:27:02.306 --> 02:27:07.865
- I would say that I do have open questions. And in general, I'm in support on improving that street.

02:27:07.865 --> 02:27:13.702
- And I'm very much in improving the downtown, workability of it, and safety of it. So I feel like I would

02:27:13.702 --> 02:27:19.317
- like to see, I mean, questions around budget were very interesting. I feel like we can dig more into

02:27:19.317 --> 02:27:24.876
- that. And I would love to see other options on how other improvements can be done and compare them.

02:27:24.876 --> 02:27:30.601
- I'm liking that information right now. So I'm in support of moving these improvements further. I don't

02:27:30.601 --> 02:27:32.158
- have a strong opinion about

02:27:32.482 --> 02:27:40.748
- one option over another right now. OK, any other thoughts about a motion? I'm not the one who's going

02:27:40.748 --> 02:27:49.258
- to make a motion, so someone else has to decide which way they want to go. Mr. Flaherty. I'll just know.

02:27:49.258 --> 02:27:57.605
- It sounds like we have some folks who are aligned and ready to make a positive recommendation tonight,

02:27:57.605 --> 02:28:00.766
- other folks who are generally aligned,

02:28:01.442 --> 02:28:07.040
- feel like they want more information or more time. I don't have any qualms with waiting for that additional

02:28:07.040 --> 02:28:12.274
- information and waiting additional time for that for folks who want it. But we should just be pretty

02:28:12.274 --> 02:28:17.665
- clear, I think, about what is being asked, if that's the case. Even if that's by way of email follow-up

02:28:17.665 --> 02:28:22.951
- or whatever it is for those commissioners who want something specific, I would just want to make sure

02:28:22.951 --> 02:28:26.942
- that we're setting ourselves up to be prepared for our December 4th meeting.

02:28:29.954 --> 02:28:37.589
- I'm starting to hear an inclination towards a continue so as to satisfy. I and one other member have

02:28:37.589 --> 02:28:45.451
- said we'd like more information. Perhaps if we are going to continue, we should state now what specific

02:28:45.451 --> 02:28:53.010
- things we'd like while it's fresh in our minds. Is there any information that members would like to

02:28:53.010 --> 02:28:57.470
- ask of staff besides what has already been asked of staff?

02:28:58.306 --> 02:29:06.207
- and we can recapitulate it before we're done. Mr. Drew. I'm personally interested in the first option.

02:29:06.207 --> 02:29:14.030
- And I think what can be done if we don't go with two ways, but we keep the first option, which is not

02:29:14.030 --> 02:29:21.777
- recommended. So keep things as they are, sounds like. That's the first option we have, option A. No,

02:29:21.777 --> 02:29:27.070
- no. Right now, we are considering whether to adopt the two-way plan.

02:29:27.426 --> 02:29:33.118
- And our potential votes are positive recommendation, negative no. Only for this option, right?

02:29:33.118 --> 02:29:39.170
- Recommendation. I would say the information I am lacking right now, the public mentioned a couple of

02:29:39.170 --> 02:29:45.161
- times that there are some other ways on how safety can be improved. So I think the information I am

02:29:45.161 --> 02:29:51.512
- lacking right now is what else can be done? And how much will it cost in comparison to what was proposed?

02:29:51.512 --> 02:29:56.126
- OK. Anyone else have anything to add here before we entertain a motion about

02:29:56.642 --> 02:30:07.336
- What information, if any, you'd like to see should a continue motion carry? Here's your chance. On to

02:30:07.336 --> 02:30:18.450
- my right. Mr. Flaherty. I guess I'm a little confused by the most recent comments. For the one-way design

02:30:18.450 --> 02:30:23.902
- concept, for instance, as proposed, I think I don't

02:30:24.098 --> 02:30:29.633
- Correct me if I'm wrong. I don't think the packet included PDFs of design did it, and I missed them.

02:30:29.633 --> 02:30:35.279
- No, it originally did not. I have updated it since commissioners were asking about it. But originally,

02:30:35.279 --> 02:30:40.650
- before the meeting, it did not. I just wanted to make it available in case anyone was here. Yeah,

02:30:40.650 --> 02:30:46.350
- got it. So those are things that I think are worth looking at. But then I think if we're talking about,

02:30:46.350 --> 02:30:51.392
- if there's a majority of commissioners who support advancing one of the two concept designs

02:30:51.392 --> 02:30:53.310
- for transportation plan amendment,

02:30:54.498 --> 02:31:01.640
- I feel like that might be different than what I was just hearing, which is the idea that is there something

02:31:01.640 --> 02:31:08.517
- other than either of those two concepts that would maybe cost less and improve safety? And I'm not sure

02:31:08.517 --> 02:31:15.130
- that's something that we're in a great position to have staff come up with. Just to be clear, and I

02:31:15.130 --> 02:31:22.206
- know this is not clear and I'm sorry about it, staff is recommending that College and Walnut be redesigned

02:31:22.206 --> 02:31:23.198
- to be two-way.

02:31:23.586 --> 02:31:32.271
- If there are members who wish to recommend a one-way redesign, that's not on the table. If there are

02:31:32.271 --> 02:31:40.956
- members who want to not recommend either redesign, they should reject anything that comes before us.

02:31:40.956 --> 02:31:49.554
- But we don't have the option of, we can say in our comments, I would rather see the one-way design.

02:31:49.554 --> 02:31:52.478
- But what you're voting on tonight

02:31:52.674 --> 02:31:59.704
- Whether or not to forward a recommendation a positive recommendation of a two-way design We're talking

02:31:59.704 --> 02:32:06.598
- about the two-way design tonight because that's what they advanced. All right So I just want to make

02:32:06.598 --> 02:32:13.833
- sure everyone understands what we're voting on. Do I have that right staff? You have most of that correct

02:32:13.833 --> 02:32:18.270
- we're going to rewrite these bylaws man because We're struggling

02:32:18.658 --> 02:32:25.552
- Well, I don't think the bylaw issue I think you have the bylaws correct. Okay. The actual recommendation

02:32:25.552 --> 02:32:32.381
- and proposal on the table is that there is an adoption of the proposed amendments to the transportation

02:32:32.381 --> 02:32:39.341
- plan and the corridor study which makes a recommendation to two way and has the two way design. So you're

02:32:39.341 --> 02:32:46.366
- mostly correct. But I just want to know. Okay. Okay. That's even finer slice than I would have done it. So

02:32:48.226 --> 02:32:54.543
- talking about plans and it's so much of the current discussion is about a plan concept that anything

02:32:54.543 --> 02:33:01.109
- any one component of that would still come back to Transportation Commission. So the reason that perhaps

02:33:01.109 --> 02:33:07.613
- alternatives haven't been provided is because that's not sort of the that's outside the scope of what's

02:33:07.613 --> 02:33:13.867
- being asked at this juncture. But effectively what staff has said and in the press release for this

02:33:13.867 --> 02:33:17.182
- said that they were recommending the two-way scheme.

02:33:17.442 --> 02:33:24.467
- That would go into the plan. Am I wrong about that? That is the general recommendation. Yeah, I guess

02:33:24.467 --> 02:33:31.631
- if I could clarify, please, let's suppose that a commissioner would like to instead make a they instead

02:33:31.631 --> 02:33:38.174
- favor the one way design concept and those safety improvements and they want to indicate that.

02:33:38.466 --> 02:33:44.934
- What would be the optimal way to do that? Would it be to reject the staff recommendation with proposed

02:33:44.934 --> 02:33:51.277
- alternative findings that say make a case for why the one-way alternative better meets city code and

02:33:51.277 --> 02:33:57.682
- city goals? Something different, that's what I'm trying to clarify and making sure that if that's not

02:33:57.682 --> 02:34:04.024
- a path that someone is theoretically interested in pursuing, that, yeah. Yes, you could certainly do

02:34:04.024 --> 02:34:05.406
- that. You could adopt

02:34:05.602 --> 02:34:11.598
- completely different findings and you could even so the first step would be to reject this finding and

02:34:11.598 --> 02:34:17.360
- forward it with a negative recommendation and then like you said include what your preff preferred

02:34:17.360 --> 02:34:23.239
- alternative was and then after that staff could look at it bring it back or we could just bring that

02:34:23.239 --> 02:34:29.293
- forward to the Planning Commission so that they can note it they have the ability to edit this document

02:34:29.293 --> 02:34:33.950
- since it's essentially their document as well as council so okay okay thank you

02:34:35.650 --> 02:34:44.568
- Now, after all that belaboring, is there anyone who wants to make a motion? And if so, which motion?

02:34:44.568 --> 02:34:54.192
- If no one has a motion, let's move to continue. I'll make the straightforward motion that the Transportation

02:34:54.192 --> 02:35:03.022
- Commission forward the proposed amendment to the transportation plan with a positive recommendation

02:35:03.022 --> 02:35:05.406
- to the planned commission.

02:35:05.730 --> 02:35:15.545
- That's needs a second. Second. We have a motion and a second. Is there any discussion on the motion?

02:35:15.545 --> 02:35:25.748
- Seeing none, we'll ask the secretary to call a roll call vote on the motion to recommend with a positive

02:35:25.748 --> 02:35:34.494
- to forward it to the plan commission with a positive recommendation. TCR 2622. Copic? No.

02:35:37.282 --> 02:35:56.201
- Sandifer? No. Binder? Yes. Volin? Abstain. Drumme? It's not here. Thank you. Flaherty? Yes. Scudersko?

02:35:56.201 --> 02:36:07.038
- Abstain. Stasberg? Yes. That's all. So that's a three yes.

02:36:07.234 --> 02:36:17.181
- Two no, two abstentions. Correct. All right. Is there another motion? Make a motion to continue. To

02:36:17.181 --> 02:36:27.824
- which meeting? Our next meeting? December 7th. December 7th. We need a second for that motion to continue.

02:36:27.824 --> 02:36:35.582
- Second. We have a motion and a second. Is there any discussion on the motion?

02:36:38.530 --> 02:36:43.737
- Um, yeah, I just encourage again folks to make sure that they're being quite clear and specific and

02:36:43.737 --> 02:36:49.255
- the questions they're asking and follow up with staff. And if you, um, on a few instances, we have either

02:36:49.255 --> 02:36:54.514
- rejected staff findings or come with alternatives, um, to the extent that folks can prepare those in

02:36:54.514 --> 02:37:00.085
- advance to be circulated or come with, you know, a draft that would really be helpful if, if they propose,

02:37:00.085 --> 02:37:05.448
- um, you know, something other than, uh, the proposed findings from staff. Thanks. All right. Any other

02:37:05.448 --> 02:37:07.166
- comments before we go to a vote?

02:37:08.962 --> 02:37:17.519
- I just staff is in favor of that. We just would like some clarifying ground rules because we have members

02:37:17.519 --> 02:37:25.752
- of the public here and I want to respect their time. So we have a very busy December agenda. We would

02:37:25.752 --> 02:37:34.147
- likely ask that the commission put this towards the end because it's such a big topic. But then we also

02:37:34.147 --> 02:37:38.910
- want to clarify public speaking rules. We've opened public

02:37:39.234 --> 02:37:46.409
- Thank you. And now have closed it. So we just want to clarify what the commission is thinking, um, for

02:37:46.409 --> 02:37:53.514
- public comment in the next meeting. I can only speak for myself when I say that, uh, I asked for more

02:37:53.514 --> 02:38:00.689
- information. Um, I think of it as sort of an extension of this process that we've already heard public

02:38:00.689 --> 02:38:07.934
- comment and that we're just trying to get the information that we needed to make a decent decision. Um,

02:38:08.290 --> 02:38:15.867
- So I'm fine with compressing the amount of time we spend on this to limit it. I mean, to limit the amount

02:38:15.867 --> 02:38:22.444
- of time we spend it at the next meeting, not to exceed half an hour, not to exceed an hour,

02:38:22.444 --> 02:38:30.021
- whatever it takes, because we've already deliberated on it tonight. But I, for one, share Ms. Sugruchko's

02:38:30.021 --> 02:38:37.598
- concern about ballpark figures of costs. I want to get a sense, as I said, of how this figure compares to

02:38:38.082 --> 02:38:44.929
- Other typical projects we've done. It's the kind of information that the Commission has wanted in general,

02:38:44.929 --> 02:38:51.391
- but it's particularly relevant for for this But I'm happy to work with staff to limit the agenda for

02:38:51.391 --> 02:38:58.686
- the next meeting so that we don't We don't need a full presentation again. This does not require a second reading

02:39:00.322 --> 02:39:07.493
- That's totally fine. I would just ask that the proposed amendment include an understanding of what your

02:39:07.493 --> 02:39:14.733
- understanding of public comment in the next meeting would be just so everyone's clear. That's it. That's

02:39:14.733 --> 02:39:21.628
- thank you. Well, I don't remember exactly how we defined continuation in bylaws, but generally when

02:39:21.628 --> 02:39:26.110
- you continue an item like it's I don't know if this is where I'm

02:39:27.138 --> 02:39:35.053
- I'm at a loss. I could ask that the maker of the motion change the motion to say that it will be limited

02:39:35.053 --> 02:39:42.667
- to a certain period of time or limited to a second round of questions. I don't know how to structure

02:39:42.667 --> 02:39:50.431
- this. Staff is open to whatever. We just want to make sure it's clear for members of the public. Which

02:39:50.431 --> 02:39:55.934
- is just to say there's not a right answer to that, that what you've just

02:39:56.034 --> 02:40:02.854
- proposed is a perfectly acceptable way to phrase the amendment. So far, the only concerns that have

02:40:02.854 --> 02:40:09.811
- been heard, two of us have said, we'd like to see more financial information. If there were a panoply

02:40:09.811 --> 02:40:17.041
- of topics that people wanted to ask questions about, we might need to reopen it. But I think we're asking

02:40:17.041 --> 02:40:23.997
- for one piece of information. So I think we could limit the time and the structure of this discussion

02:40:23.997 --> 02:40:25.566
- at the next meeting to

02:40:26.210 --> 02:40:34.154
- just getting the question answered and entertaining a motion. Mr. Coppock. Could we get construction

02:40:34.154 --> 02:40:42.019
- costs today's dollars? So yeah, so I've been seeping with regret about how I answered that question

02:40:42.019 --> 02:40:50.278
- earlier, because actually, there's a better answer. It's that all of our construction costs are actually

02:40:50.278 --> 02:40:55.390
- set by NDOT, and NDOT publishes a schedule of construction costs

02:40:55.490 --> 02:41:01.648
- for all items that are related to transportation construction on their website. And it changes every

02:41:01.648 --> 02:41:07.867
- year. So there's already a spreadsheet with thousands of little line items for individual things that

02:41:07.867 --> 02:41:14.390
- you could reference for this particular answer. So the answer, in short, is yes, we can absolutely provide

02:41:14.390 --> 02:41:21.097
- you with this information. But if what you're asking for is a very contextualized reading of that information

02:41:21.097 --> 02:41:25.182
- in this plan, I would have to defer to Ryan Robley. Mr. Stossberg.

02:41:26.050 --> 02:41:32.011
- Just a point of clarification with the staff. What we're proposing in any case is an amendment to the

02:41:32.011 --> 02:41:37.914
- transportation plan. I've read versions of it. It's not like a spreadsheet with a bunch of prices on

02:41:37.914 --> 02:41:44.108
- the right-hand side. We're talking about a project which might be done incrementally over 10 or 20 years,

02:41:44.108 --> 02:41:50.128
- over many contracts, over which time there will be new inflations and wars and cyber attacks and other

02:41:50.128 --> 02:41:51.998
- things that will change prices.

02:41:52.610 --> 02:41:58.534
- We're not approving any version of a contract with price tags. We are approving the idea of something

02:41:58.534 --> 02:42:04.400
- that goes in a plan. The plan has had things like, we'd like a bike path to Lake Lemon, but we don't

02:42:04.400 --> 02:42:10.208
- have a price tag for that. And we might never do it. We might. So I just want to clarify that we're

02:42:10.208 --> 02:42:16.016
- not approving a price tag on anything. We're approving the aspiration of something that goes in the

02:42:16.016 --> 02:42:19.326
- long-term plan. Is that correct? That's exactly correct.

02:42:21.538 --> 02:42:30.347
- Any other comments on this? Mr. Binder? One comment, one question. To Commissioner Stosberg's inquiry

02:42:30.347 --> 02:42:38.982
- about sort of, could we have more of an itemized, I think, list of how that cost breaks down. There

02:42:38.982 --> 02:42:48.136
- is a document attached, although I think maybe it was added by staff after the fact. So I think everybody

02:42:48.136 --> 02:42:49.950
- would be well served

02:42:50.114 --> 02:42:59.313
- to look at that. It's number 11 on the packet. And the title is Opinion of Probable Cost for the two-way

02:42:59.313 --> 02:43:08.336
- design. That's the first thing I would say. And then the second, I guess, is more of a question, which

02:43:08.336 --> 02:43:17.185
- is that ... I mean, I'm not sure how to really interpret the idea that we should be considering this

02:43:17.185 --> 02:43:19.550
- without regard to cost and

02:43:19.842 --> 02:43:28.523
- thinking of it solely in terms of whether it's a good idea just from an aspirational standpoint. Because

02:43:28.523 --> 02:43:36.872
- I think if that were true, then the cost should not have been introduced into this discussion in the

02:43:36.872 --> 02:43:41.502
- first place. But given that it has, and also given that

02:43:41.602 --> 02:43:48.969
- this is the real world and things cost money. I mean, of course cost is a consideration. So I guess

02:43:48.969 --> 02:43:56.410
- I'm having trouble squaring in my head the idea that we would consider this completely separate from

02:43:56.410 --> 02:44:04.513
- the idea of how much it would cost. I think in my mind it is kind of an inseparable part of the consideration

02:44:04.513 --> 02:44:11.070
- is in fact ballpark how much it would cost. So that's, am I totally off base here? Yeah.

02:44:11.426 --> 02:44:20.276
- So for me, anyway, I mean, I think even with the cost, I'm still in favor of this proposal, but I'm

02:44:20.276 --> 02:44:29.303
- just trying to understand whether or not we are in fact considering cost as part of the proposal. Any

02:44:29.303 --> 02:44:39.038
- other comments on this before I say something? Look, this has been promoted by the city with a cost estimate.

02:44:39.842 --> 02:44:48.130
- It's a headline maker, 103 to 109 million dollars. It's entirely reasonable to ask where that cost came

02:44:48.130 --> 02:44:56.258
- from, and it's just as reasonable to ask, well, how does that compare to what we normally spend money

02:44:56.258 --> 02:45:04.307
- on? There's no way to separate this estimate from the question, even if we're just making it part of

02:45:04.307 --> 02:45:09.566
- the plan, because all that people are gonna think about who don't

02:45:09.794 --> 02:45:19.048
- look at this too closely is, oh, the city is going to spend another $110 million. They just said they're

02:45:19.048 --> 02:45:27.861
- going to. This is an ongoing mission of the commission to try to make it clearer how transportation

02:45:27.861 --> 02:45:36.850
- works, and the costs are an essential part of it. And just to know that this document has appeared on

02:45:36.850 --> 02:45:39.582
- the agenda during the meeting,

02:45:39.682 --> 02:45:47.789
- I mean, there wasn't time to look at it. I'm looking at it now. I have interest, but I mean, this is

02:45:47.789 --> 02:45:56.136
- no way to to educate. If education is one of the ways that we we manage safety on the roads, along with

02:45:56.136 --> 02:46:04.162
- engineering and enforcement, we have to do a better job of educating. So I still say I need to know

02:46:04.162 --> 02:46:07.774
- comparable projects in Bloomington, how much

02:46:08.066 --> 02:46:14.154
- did it cost to change East 3rd Street? How much did South Walnut cost back when it was done? Something

02:46:14.154 --> 02:46:20.243
- that Bloomingtonians can say, compare to and say, this is either really unusual compared to what we've

02:46:20.243 --> 02:46:26.390
- done before, or it's entirely in keeping with what we've done before, that it's only a marginal change,

02:46:26.390 --> 02:46:32.774
- we don't have that answer now. That's what I'm looking for for December 7th. I hope that makes a difference

02:46:32.774 --> 02:46:35.966
- to everyone. Mr. Flaherty. Yeah, this is interesting.

02:46:36.546 --> 02:46:42.987
- I think it's fine to consider costs. I don't think it's our explicit purview to do so. Code specifies

02:46:42.987 --> 02:46:48.985
- what it is we are charged with finding. It's an analysis and a framework that looks at safety,

02:46:48.985 --> 02:46:55.426
- city goals, public engagement and sustainability. So that's what the structure of the findings is. If

02:46:55.426 --> 02:46:58.078
- people want to base their vote, you know,

02:46:58.722 --> 02:47:04.723
- Say all those findings notwithstanding. I think this is too much money So I'm voting no then they can

02:47:04.723 --> 02:47:10.782
- say that and I would encourage them to say that if that is indeed the rationale But I don't think it's

02:47:10.782 --> 02:47:16.783
- central. I you know, I'm with you. I find I find inch I would find it interesting in 2026 or 2020 $30

02:47:16.783 --> 02:47:22.666
- or whatever, you know what some of these other changes, you know have cost the city I gave a figure

02:47:22.666 --> 02:47:27.902
- of 40 million for 2026 dollars for the parking garages, right? So two parking garages we

02:47:28.226 --> 02:47:33.803
- built. That's a little less than half of what's proposed here. So yeah, those things are helpful,

02:47:33.803 --> 02:47:39.721
- I think, for reference and frame. But ultimately, I don't think that's really what we are charged with.

02:47:39.721 --> 02:47:45.525
- That's a broader fiscal policy question, which is why the city council will consider and vote on this

02:47:45.525 --> 02:47:51.102
- eventually, as well as the role of the mayor and the city executive about what to prioritize when

02:47:51.938 --> 02:47:58.666
- Including you know on a contingent basis based on whether we can leverage federal funding, right? So

02:47:58.666 --> 02:48:05.461
- These things are good to know but again, it is a little bit ancillary for at least for this body, you

02:48:05.461 --> 02:48:12.389
- know per se code Any other comments mr. Binder Just to try to kind of pull the thread through and maybe

02:48:12.389 --> 02:48:19.250
- sum up some of the the concerns I'm hearing here so one is I do want to say I appreciate the staff was

02:48:19.250 --> 02:48:21.182
- I think trying to respond to

02:48:21.282 --> 02:48:28.505
- the commission's request for more information by appending some additional documents to the packet.

02:48:28.505 --> 02:48:36.306
- But I think knowing that there are now some other documents, I think it's perfectly appropriate to continue

02:48:36.306 --> 02:48:43.602
- this to the next meeting, given that nobody's had time to really look at those documents beforehand.

02:48:43.602 --> 02:48:49.886
- So that's, I guess, one thing I would say. And then, well, yeah, I'll just stop there.

02:48:51.234 --> 02:49:01.217
- Hopefully some pretty broad agreement that we can continue this to the next meeting. All right. I mean,

02:49:01.217 --> 02:49:10.911
- I do think that cost is germane because if we hear an objection, one objection I've heard tonight is

02:49:10.911 --> 02:49:21.182
- to what extent do we balance safety and expense? OK. And I'm not saying that the commission's job, I mean,

02:49:21.282 --> 02:49:29.363
- Uh, we shall, uh, we're trying to eliminate fatalities. We're trying to promote sustainable transportation.

02:49:29.363 --> 02:49:37.069
- Uh, sustainable includes cost, all right? So it's not unreasonable to say, well, if it's an inordinate

02:49:37.069 --> 02:49:44.776
- cost, it's not worth making the change. Uh, and again, we don't have to, I mean, again, to the nearest

02:49:44.776 --> 02:49:50.462
- million dollars. It doesn't have to be, uh, uh, down to the penny, uh, but,

02:49:51.650 --> 02:49:58.318
- It's a reasonable set of questions to ask, and especially with data coming in even during the meeting,

02:49:58.318 --> 02:50:04.856
- we should take a little time to do it. I have to say I'm inclined to the two-way solution as well. I

02:50:04.856 --> 02:50:11.654
- think people heard that in my comments, but I think this information is as important to the commission's

02:50:11.654 --> 02:50:13.790
- mission as a decision right now.

02:50:15.426 --> 02:50:21.916
- I would just say that I'm in support of the information you requested. I'm also interested in that,

02:50:21.916 --> 02:50:28.795
- and I feel it's not central to making this decision, but it's an important comparison to make. If there's

02:50:28.795 --> 02:50:35.545
- no other comments, Mr. Binder. I will say actually one other thing. This is, I think, more for the sake

02:50:35.545 --> 02:50:42.814
- of staff to try to help do some fact-finding for next time, which is that there has been a lot of discussion of

02:50:43.330 --> 02:50:52.686
- or inference that this kind of project being a very large one would necessarily happen over many years

02:50:52.686 --> 02:51:01.951
- and happen in many phases. And I guess I would be curious to see just even some hypotheticals of what

02:51:01.951 --> 02:51:09.854
- that would actually kind of be like, how you might actually phase something like this.

02:51:10.114 --> 02:51:17.050
- given that, I mean, short of taking out a $100 million bond, we're probably not gonna be spending that

02:51:17.050 --> 02:51:24.053
- money all in one single go, that this would be something, this would be a change that happens over many

02:51:24.053 --> 02:51:30.855
- years. So maybe having kind of a little bit more of a clear understanding of how this type of design

02:51:30.855 --> 02:51:37.791
- could be phased, because I think there are probably some straightforward answers to that question, and

02:51:37.791 --> 02:51:39.070
- then maybe others,

02:51:39.170 --> 02:51:48.259
- particularly when it comes to making the big changes, like switching traffic directions, that's hard

02:51:48.259 --> 02:51:57.349
- to break down into phases, I think. So that's maybe something that would be helpful for staff to try

02:51:57.349 --> 02:52:06.078
- to collate for the commission for any discussion next time. I agree. I would love to see it too.

02:52:06.658 --> 02:52:13.042
- If staff's looking for specific projects and we're talking about a 20-year timeline, I can go back 20

02:52:13.042 --> 02:52:19.301
- years and I'm gonna say East 3rd Street, east of the mall, the bypass, South Walnut Street project,

02:52:19.301 --> 02:52:25.747
- and the West 3rd Street project, west from Patterson, the redesign of 3rd, 5th Adams, West 3rd Street.

02:52:25.747 --> 02:52:32.256
- Those are all, I mean, just the roughest possible figures to give people a sense of how many miles were

02:52:32.256 --> 02:52:35.198
- constructed, about how much it cost over time,

02:52:35.458 --> 02:52:40.957
- Any information you can provide us will be specific things we could compare to this. Yeah, sorry. Step

02:52:40.957 --> 02:52:46.296
- has no concern. We're happy to provide all that we can come up with numbers for everything. We were

02:52:46.296 --> 02:52:51.955
- just concerned about the public comment period because I don't want to disrupt the public's understanding

02:52:51.955 --> 02:52:57.400
- of if they'll be allowed to speak because they're going to have to probably wait to the end of a long

02:52:57.400 --> 02:53:03.326
- meeting. So that's okay. Very good. With that, let's if everyone's ready for a vote on the motion to continue.

02:53:05.026 --> 02:53:18.275
- Without objection, the secretary will call the roll. The motion to continue to December 7th, TCR 2622.

02:53:18.275 --> 02:53:30.110
- Yes. Binder? Yes. Bollin? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Skourishko? Yes. Stosberg? Yes. Coppock? Yes.

02:53:31.010 --> 02:53:36.464
- The motion to continue carries 7-0. That concludes our business for the evening. If there's no other

02:53:36.464 --> 02:53:38.462
- comments, this meeting is adjourned.
