If we can call this meeting to order, this is the special November session of the Bloomington Transportation Commission. Will the secretary please call the roll? Copic? Here. Standifer? Here. Binder? Here. Bowen? Here. Drumme? Sorry. Flaherty? Here. Davis? Skorushko? Here. Stossberg? Here. That's it. Thank you. We have a quorum. I'd also like to welcome our newest member who's here on behalf of the transit, Bloomington Transit. Good luck is all I can say. What a first meeting for you. Anyway, I thought that I would, so our agenda will include reports and communications and one case, TCR 2622, adoption of College and Walnut Corridor Study and amendment to the transportation plan after which we will adjourn. To that end, I'd like to make a very brief presentation just to ground what we're doing in context. waiting for the presentation to here we go. All right. So for those of you who are new to this commission our mandate is it's not it's from more than twenty twenty five or four to guide the city's transportation endeavors through a comprehensive framework which seeks to provide adequate and safe access to all right of way users while prioritizing non automotive modes and sustainability. Our mandate includes providing recommendations and guidance to the mayor and common council in the pursuit of developing and implementing a citywide policy to eliminate all transportation related fatalities and serious injuries to pedestrians bicyclists transit users motorists and passengers. We also shall promote sustainable transportation shall foster equitable access and shall promote community centric design. The commission is only 18 months old. It replaced three other commissions, the bicycle and pedestrian safety commission, the traffic commission and the parking commission. Uh, we were not responsible for the 2019 transportation plan, which is the subject, partially the subject of tonight's case. We are also not responsible for the 2024 vision zero policy to eliminate all fatalities and city streets by 2039, but we are responsible for overseeing the implementation of these documents. Uh, what we are not doing tonight also is trying to rush a decision. Uh, while we have the option, to make a recommendation tonight. We also have the option to continue to a future meeting. The administration is recommending a change to the city's transportation plan. It's going to present it to us tonight. It will then be presented to the plan commission at whatever point we have disposed of it. Then it will eventually go to the common council. So this is the first step in a multi-step process. We are going to hear a statement of the case by staff and report. They're going to make a presentation We're going to have first round questions by Commissioners for staff. We will take public comment. We will hear second round questions from the Commission the Commissioners will discuss the case if not debate it and then we can decide on action and To that end. These are the actions available to us. We can make a positive recommendation to forward to bodies above us, we can make a negative negative recommendation. If one of those two does not come forward when it comes time for us to make a motion, then a member can recommend no recommendation or to continue to a future meeting. Our next meeting will be on December 7th or last meeting of the year in this chamber. So with that, I hope that gives everybody context for what we're doing tonight. And, uh, with that, I'd like to, uh, move straight to unless there's anything that any commissioner would like to say or ask, uh, in reporting on other issues before we continue with the main item tonight. Seeing to my left, to my right, without further ado, I believe that, uh, uh, is John Garza here? John is here. Uh, and, uh, Lynn coin. is here representing the planning transportation department, but the main presentation is going to be made by Ryan Roebling. Mr. Roebling, please take it away. Okay. Thank you. Let me switch this. Sorry. One second. Try to make that a little bit more visible to everybody. Okay. Before us tonight is resolution TCR 2618. And before I begin, I want to clarify immediately that this resolution, what this resolution does and what it does not do tonight's action on an amendment to the 2020 or 2019 transportation plan to adopt the College and Walnut Corridor Study as an official planning addendum and long-range design vision. It does not award a construction contract, it does not commit local tax funds, and it will not trigger construction. It will also not convert the corridor to two-way operations. What it does is establishes a long-term plan for the 4.2 miles of College Avenue and Walnut Street so that As roads are repaved, utilities are upgraded, and developments occur, we can slowly build towards a safer and more economically beneficial corridor. College in Walnut encompasses nearly 32 acres of public space running through the heart of the community. It currently has 404 meter parking spaces and 21 bus stops. This study was formally mandated in the 2019 transportation plan. Within that plan, a thorough technical study is called for along this corridor to solve long-standing safety issues, modernize cross-sections, and protect the vitality of our downtown. Since the outset of this study, we have conducted speed and volume counts, public engagement, synchro modeling, engineer designs, et cetera. It's important to understand how and why we have the corridor that we do today. Until 1956, College and Walnut were traditional two-way city streets. That year, in 1959, or 1956, excuse me, the State Highway Department redesigned the streets of then State Road 37 enforced the one-way couplet upon Bloomington to allow for regional freight to move through the town more easily. At that time, local business owners objected, but the state threatened to pull funding to the city. Eventually, State Road 37, as you probably know, moved west as urban highway corridors fell out of fashion due to traffic and safety concerns. Despite the move west, the highway street design remained. Over the next half century, Bloomington's population grew 44% Yet the vehicle trips on the corridor dropped by 31%. Today, we are maintaining wide multi-lane roadways built for 1950s highway freight demands that no longer exist. So why study the corridor? That's kind of the question at the heart of this. And the first one is to eliminate high-speed crashes, crash risk, and create a comfortable, walkable environment. As Mr. Volin highlighted, we have a Vision zero policy here where we're attempting to eliminate fatal and serious crashes by twenty thirty nine on the city's roadways. And this is obviously a corridor that features city roadways. Second is to provide environmental and public realm benefits expand tree canopy and sidewalk space to lower noise and build noise pollution and build resilient public realm. And finally, drive economic development and tax-based growth, rebalancing pavement to increase customer foot traffic, help eliminate commercial vacancies, and boost property values across the corridor's block phases. So to answer the question of why we're doing anything on College of Walnut, it's because between 2018 and 2022, 34 individuals had their lives forever altered and three lost their lives. This is a corridor identified as the highest priority in the city's safe streets and roads for all action plan. And it experienced 56 injurious crashes, including six serious injuries and one fatality between 2021 and 2025. And here you can see a clip from the safety action plan. You can see that College and Walnut are highlighted here in dark red, similar to state highways, the bypass and West and East Third Street. You can see that the design of state highways often features higher fatality and serious injury crash risks, and because of their lingering design from the 50s, you can see that elevated risk on College of Walnut today. Since the 50s, College of Walnut have been designed as state highways aimed at moving people quickly through and past the city, but despite decades being removed from the state highway designation, they are still designed and operate as such. This is a corridor that includes the heart of downtown, high population density centers to the north and single family neighborhoods to the south. These are areas where people walk, bike, play, park, drive. Yet it is designed with widths wider than I-69. It's 41 feet of lane width on both College and Walnut at Third Street and 35 for 69 at Third Street. You can see that from the speed data collected in 2023, that speeders are going about 10 to 20 miles over the posted speed limit in some areas. And this is a fault of design, not reckless drivers. All right, counts gathered during the study found that over 4,500 motorists exceed the speed limit along the corridor every day, with 85th percentile speeds reaching 42 miles per hour in some areas. A pedestrian truck, A pedestrian crash at 40 miles an hour has an 80% chance of being killed. At 20 miles an hour, that pedestrian survival rate climbs to 90%. Since 1976, motor vehicle volumes along College and Wellman have dropped between 504 vehicles a day and 5,500 vehicles per day, depending on the segment. And since 1976, a number of major changes to the Bloomington's transportation system have taken place. The first is State Road 37 moved west, like I mentioned. Second is that the bypass 30, 45, 46 bypass opened, allowing travel for vehicles wanting to go east to move that direction. And then finally, ultimately, I-69 opened up, removing traffic stops and any impediment to speeding motor vehicles. And you can see, sorry about that, you can see some of those numbers here. Kind of the extreme one here is South College Avenue, south of 9th Street, where it had 1,600, 700, 16,727 vehicles per day in 1976. And then in 2023, we had 11,234. Finally. The opening of I-69 in the late 20 teens further allowed traffic to the ability to bypass downtown. These are designs that, these are drivers that never intended to be downtown. They just wanted to do regional or long distance travel through Bloomington. They had no intention of interacting. You can see the significant drop off in orange is 2018 numbers. And then in that bluish color is 2023 numbers. And then the gray is 1976 numbers. And you can see that this, pretty steep drop off in some areas, specifically north of Third Street on College. We lost about 5,000 drivers per day. All right. So what does this look like in practice? On both corridors, the peak hourly volume was recorded. And on College south of Kirkwood, the high was 900. This is the highest for and hourly rate for anywhere on the corridor was 931 vehicles, which is below the capacity of a one-lane, one-way street, which is roughly 1,050 vehicles per hour, shown here in that purple color in the middle. This means that for a majority of the day, that portion of college has three times the required space available to it, just sitting there unoccupied, allowing vehicles to move, to not only travel quickly, but also to weave in and out of traffic to avoid other traffic that may slow them down. So during these peak hours, standard three-lane design, sorry, hold on. So during those peak hours, the standard three-lane design, which is on the right here, which is one northbound lane, one southbound lane, and then a turn lane would reach capacity by about 70 vehicles during peak. And that's just on north. This is just on southbound college traffic. So one lane of that three-lane design would roughly hit at its peak would be about 70 vehicles over capacity. And that would be just for college, which the two-way design would allow Walnut to also look like that or have an additional southbound line, I should say. Okay so environmental concerns here is flood risk in the city of Bloomington. As you all have probably seen and or heard there is a significant flood risk south especially south along the corridor especially south of Second Street. You can see that in those blue dots. That is a risk that will probably grow as time goes on. Not only environmental changes but also the CBU's Clear Creek project sped up the efficiency of the northern stretch of Clear Creek, which will allow the water to move quickly south and cause potentially more flooding risk until that is alleviated. Then we have the urban heat island effect. You can see here in the reddish and orangish colors that we have a significant heat island effect in the downtown. That is exacerbated by lack of street trees. And the street trees, you can see them on the count on the right side here. As anyone who's been on College and Walnut knows, there are a bunch of trees and they don't grow very old. We have to replace them because they don't have much room to grow. They need more room than we currently allot them. And so they don't grow very old and they stay in eye-poking range when you walk down the corridor. All right. So economic development is the third big reason. When business leaders ask whether changing street geometry is worth the investment, we don't have to rely on theory or speculation. We can look at hard empirical evidence from regional benchmarks right here in Indiana and neighboring Kentucky. that prove modernizing streets directly drives commercial property values and private investment. First, we can take South Bend. When they restored their major north-south downtown arterials to two-way operations, assessed commercial property values along the corridor increased by 21% over a five-year period. That represents real tax-based growth and increased equity for property owners along those streets. Second is Louisville. We they had a three-year study of Brook Street, which was had a two-way conversion take place Property values along Brook Street surged 39% Me way. Meanwhile on adjacent second and third Street one-way couplets That obviously remained one way properties experienced a point for annual depreciation over that same period that shows a stark contrast of two-way restoration, create a thriving economic environment, while legacy one-way design caused property values to stagnate and decline. In the original 2010 analysis, Only Brook Street and First Street were proposed to be converted to two-way traffic, while Second and Third Street were proposed to maintain their one-way status, acting as a control. By March 2018, both Second and Third Street had been converted to two-way traffic, and under-utilized properties began to spring back with to life with retail, hotel, parking, and office space. You can see Third Street prior to 2018 reconfiguration and then after the 2018 reconfiguration. All right. And third, we have the Indianapolis Cultural Trail. When Indianapolis invested in active transportation and pedestrian-focused street infrastructure, it acted as a massive economic catalyst. Property values within one block which is 500 feet in Indianapolis. It's about 330 feet here. The trail skyrocketed by 148%, generating over a billion dollars in new assessed property values. We also did some outreach to other neighboring cities to find out if their two-way conversions were successful. We reached out specifically to Indianapolis, Columbus, Ohio, and Lafayette, Indiana. All had not only seen positive results, but have or were Actively considering additional conversions. I spoke to Michael Berger from the greater Lafayette commerce, which is similar to our chamber And he reported that worries before the conversion had not turned into complaints afterward with no lingering stressors in parking Deliveries or traffic flow the takeaway here is fairly clear streets designed purely for high-speed automobile via automobile throughput drain value from adjacent properties, whereas streets designed for moderate speeds increase storefront visibility and support walking and biking, creating long-term wealth for businesses and property owners alike. And we can see kind of why that is for one reason here. In transportation engineering, there's a well-documented phenomenon known as eclipsed frontage. When a driver approaches an intersection of a multi-lane, one-way street, visual blind spots physically hide 25% of near 25% of near-side storefronts from their line of sight you can kind of see how that happens anywhere that is not in the one direction you're traveling will be Difficult if not impossible to see especially if you're a driver you will not only have the Eclipse frontage of of a business facing the wrong direction, but you also have your A and B pillar, which are the structural components of your window blocking additional views. And so you can see restoring two-way travel eliminates that blind spot entirely by combining traffic moving on both directions. Every single storefront gains 100% visual exposure to drivers and passengers coming from north and south. Furthermore, moderating speeds from highway levels down to comfortable 20 to 25 miles an hour gives people in cars, the reaction time needed to actually read signage, check out Windows displays, and decide to stop and shop. This is a pretty good example of an eclipse frontage. This is College at Sixth Street. This is a photo from the UDO. It features Pictura Gallery, which I believe now is Bluebird Couture and has been a handful of other things since this picture was taken in the 2018 UDO update. Okay, so the study systematically evaluated two build alternatives against community goals. Option one maintains the one-way operation but puts the streets on a road diet, reducing three lanes to two and adding an urban trail on both corridors. While this improves bicycle and pedestrian facilities, it leaves primary problems in place. Drivers will still treat two open one-lane ways as a highway and economic vitality will still suffer. In order to match some of the speed reduction benefits of a two-way design, the one-way design would also feature additional features such as raised mid-block crossings in areas with higher numbers of pedestrians. It's kind of difficult to see, but you can maybe see the bump out if my mouse will ever come on screen. That right there is a mid-block crossing where the two bump outs kind of encroach into the parking lot. I can't see that. Can you point to it again? Yeah. Oh, sorry. Can you see my mouse there? No. Just describe it for what part of it. In the middle of the blocks between 4th and Kirkwood, you can see a pretty good example on college. You can see a pretty good example of a mid-block bump out, which is an area where the curb cuts into the parking lane, further reducing crossing distances and allowing pedestrians to be more visibly seen. All right, thank you. Yeah. OK. And then option B would restore the College and Walnut to their original two-way motor vehicle operations with one motor vehicle traveling per direction. This concept includes a center turn lane in key segments along College, and includes intersection and signal upgrades to maintain motor vehicle traffic flow and improve multimodal safety. The concept includes a new urban trail along Walnut Street, connecting neighborhoods to downtown from the bypass to Allen Street. An urban trail would also run along College, north of 7th to the bypass. Okay, here is how the right-of-way would be distributed within the existing 88 feet of required right-of-way. On both streets, there will be space for 11-foot travel lanes, eight-foot sidewalks. On college specifically, extra space will be allowed to expand to pedestrian space, including sidewalk, cafe, dining, space for accessible bus shelters, and green stormwater infrastructure. On Walnut, in the downtown, pull in angled parking, Will be provided on both sides of the street. This is sorry along courthouse square Pulling angled parking will be provided as well as a 10-foot urban trail that provides physically separated and raised Bicycle and pedestrian traffic that's separated from motor vehicles And then at intersection curb bumpouts will shorten street crossings This is an example of what an urban trail kind of looks like. This is the cultural trail in Indianapolis. This connected Fountain Square to downtown. If you're familiar with Indianapolis, this is an area, Fletcher Place is an area that runs through this and was a gray, kind of sad, desolate, vacant area, and now features two of the most famous restaurants in probably Indiana, in Bluebeard and Milktooth, if anyone's familiar with those two. All right, we had a single standard one-way urban traveling with coordinated traffic signals comfortably carries about 1,000 vehicles an hour in an urban setting. At its busiest intersection along the corridor of College South of Kirkwood, like I mentioned, reached 931 vehicles per hour, meaning our busiest intersection does not reach the capacity of a single lane. Today, we are dedicating two to three lanes in each direction. Even though that two-way design will right-size vehicle travel lanes, our traffic engineering capacity models show that every intersection will continue operating smoothly at a level of service A through C. At the same time, we're proposing critical safety treatments like protected turns, truck aprons, and leading pedestrian intervals to protect people walking and biking. The consultant modeled every single signalized intersection along the corridor. That modeling found that under two-way operations with signal timing and dedicated turnpockets where required, every intersection would maintain that level of service A through C. And the two-way design during peak evening rush hours, motor vehicles on College and Kirkwood will operate at a level of service B down from a level of service A. It's important here to note I'm sure transportation commission members will have heard me say this before, but just for everyone, it's important to note that level of service uses letters similar to a grading scale, but they don't function as a grading scale, meaning a level of service of A is not the best possible condition. Instead, it describes how vehicles move through the intersection. In this case, level of service A means traffic is free to flow through with low volumes and conditions for high speeds. Level service A is expected on highways. I-69, State Road 37, those are expected to be designed at a level of service A, not in urban areas with high numbers of conflict points, pedestrians, and turning vehicles. Some other logistics here we heard important feedback regarding delivery trucks parking and emergency response during our public engagement Today delivery trucks have no dedicated space to unload So they double park in active travel lanes creating danger dangerous sudden merges and traffic delays on walnut Six between six and seventh is kind of the highlighted area that everybody thinks about when they're talking about this issue There are often two delivery trucks reducing the number of available lanes to just one and Proposed design resolves this by creating dedicated curbside loading space adjacent to the curb These loading zones will be designed around the businesses on each block face Meaning we can go in and talk to those businesses to find out what their needs are So some blocks may find it necessary to have more loading zones than others While others may prefer prefer additional on-street parking be provided The design for college will feature a continuous center turn lane, which will allow emergency vehicles to utilize the space, allowing first responders to maneuver around vehicles that are stopped on the vehicle travel lanes. Today the entire corridor features 404 meter spaces But those spaces many of those spaces see little to not no utilization especially in the northern and southern extents outside of the downtown in The core of downtown where parking is most utilized which is third through seventh. It has 143 spaces the proposed two-way design the entire corridor will feature 253 meter spaces and However, the core downtown, it will actually increase the number of parking from 143 to 144, while also providing those dedicated loading zones. This is because slower speeds and the design of two-way streets allow for additional rows of angled parking. So you can see here, oops, you can see here, maybe, you can't really see here, but I promise there are lines that show pull-in angled parking along both College and Walnut. Between Kirkwood and six, especially that if you look at the the grander scheme You can see that additional angled parking is provided south of Kirkwood Okay So a big question that everybody likes to think about is how much will this cost the one-way design has in 20 $26 has a hundred and three million dollar cost estimate and the two-way design has a hundred nine million dollar cost estimate that's $6 million difference. And that is for total reconstruction estimates. It is not how much we're spending on this project. This is just if you were to design or to dedicate the funding tomorrow, how much would it cost? And that's just to give us an idea of cost benefit analysis. But it's important to know those numbers. The consultant did a design comparison of the existing design, one-way concept in the two-way concept versus the stated community goals at the onset, which come from the transportation plan, the climate action plan, the comprehensive plan, and other related city documents, as well as what we heard from feedback during our public engagement. And they compared each of those goals against each other and so black dot here is the design contributes to outcomes that strongly conflict with those goals. The white dot is that they just conflict. What is happening to my computer? I'm not sure, sorry about that. The black circle with the white dot is they conflict. The blue circle with the bluish color in the middle is that they support our goals. And then the solid blue is that they strongly support. And you can see the big separation between the one-way concept and the two-way concept. Both of them have big improvements. The one-way concept is better for pedestrians and bicyclists. It features the urban trail on both. We know that in some cases, pedestrians are safer on one-way design streets. However, it depends on the pedestrian. So the most vulnerable, you see a lower case of safety. So that means children and people over the age of 65 are less safe on one-way streets just due to the speed of vehicles, oncoming vehicles. So that gets a higher score than the two-way. But you can see that there's pretty strong negative points in the street network resilience. You can see today that we're doing construction on the convention center and that is at one point completely closed college. That is a design where engineering and the consultant Determine what vehicles would do and they found that 50% of the vehicles they weren't sure where they would go They knew that 50% would take Rogers and or other dedicated streets But for 50% they didn't know where they would go and that's because there is no what network resiliency You could go over to Rogers and then if you don't do that, where do you go? You probably take Washington and that backs up in front of two sticks or wherever so the two-way design increases the grid that we don't currently see much of in the north-south and other than Rogers. And then navigability is difficult on one way, especially for people who are unfamiliar with the city. You see a lot of people with Illinois license plates turning the wrong way on college if you hang out on a corridor long enough. Okay. I don't know what's going on. There we go. So I want to pause here and address the most immediate question on many people's minds, and that is, when does this happen if this were to be adopted? And I want to be perfectly clear, two-way conversion is not happening anytime soon. Tonight's resolution does not schedule road closures. It does not set a start date for two-way traffic. In any long-term corridor reconstruction, changing traffic direction is the very last step of phased implementation. It's not the beginning. The vast majority of safety and public rail improvements within the plan, including building the urban trail, adding pedestrian improvements, and modernizing the streetscape and stormwater infrastructure can be constructed and operated under our existing one-way traffic pattern. Moving forward, the city's approach, as outlined in the proposed amendment to the transportation plan, is to be incremental and financially disciplined. The updated corridor design will target improvements segment by segment during scheduled street resurfacing and adjacent property redevelopment. This is the same approach that every other corridor in the city's transportation plan is designed using. When construction happens adjacent to the right of way, the city and developers look at the transportation plan to determine what infrastructure elements are required, including sidewalks, tree plots, and intersection improvements. So this will be no different. Adopting this amendment to the transportation plan allows the city to aggressively pursue competitive grants. For example, USDOT raise grants, like peer cities have done, ensuring that we bring outside federal dollars into Bloomington to rebuild our infrastructure. Those funds will be used to construct those safety improvements outlined in the plan over time. So to summarize, like the entire transportation plan, this is a 20 plus year vision. safety upgrades come first under the streets as they currently operate and Operational conversion remains a long-term carefully evaluated future phase Okay, as Commissioner Boland mentioned this is the first step in multiple public engagement and boards and Commission review So we're here at Transportation Commission tonight of ultimately this will go to plan commission for their recommendation and finally common council for approval or adoption. Okay with all of that being said we have criteria in the municipal code that the transportation commission is required to find before adopting any resolution and these criteria include sorry that it is consistent with the comprehensive plan and other applicable city goals. I listed a bunch of applicable city goals, but I'll highlight here goal 4.2, which supports local businesses, encourage and support local businesses, the arts and cultural events downtown, promote walking and biking and public transit, continue to integrate all modes into the transportation network and to prioritize bicycle, pedestrian, public transit and other non-automotive modes to make our network equally accessible, safe, and efficient for all road users, and built environment in Greenscape to drive increased efficiency and reduce environmental impacts on the built environment. Next is, is it consistent with the best practices for eliminating all transportation-related fatalities and serious injuries within the city? The study advances the city's goals of eliminating fatal and serious injury crashes by addressing documented safety, Concerns along two of Bloomington's highest risk corridors the proposed design applies proven safe system strategies to reduce vehicle speeds improve intersections and provide safer separated facilities for vulnerable road users It is it consistent with the Advancing a sustainable transportation system and equitable access to all transportation facility users While prioritizing on automotive modes, this study advances a sustainable, equitable, and multimodal transportation system by reallocating roadway space to prioritize walking, biking, and public transit. The proposed improvements will close gaps in pedestrian and bicycle networks, improve accessibility, and provide safer, more connected transportation options for people of all ages and abilities. Has it adequately conducted public engagement and considered community centric design tied to targeted outcomes the studying included extensive public engagement with residents businesses and stakeholders throughout the planning process with feedback directly informing the preferred design the resulting concept balances safety accessibility and multimodal connectivity with businesses needs downtown parking and loading needs and environmental improvements all considered All right. And so with all that said, staff recommends that the transportation commission forward the proposed amendment to the transportation plan with a positive recommendation to the city of Bloomington plan commission and common council. And I can answer any questions. Thank you for the presentation, Mr. Roebling. Let me just clarify that the items listed under the case in the agenda, you weren't intending to present every document. They're simply there for us and for the public to, to read. Yes, and I'm happy to open up and discuss any document you have a question about. Yeah. Okay. Well, there are a bunch of substantial documents here in support of this, but it's time now to open the floor to questions from commissioners for TCR 2622. Let's start on my left. Is there anyone who would like to ask questions? I hope everyone will have some. Mr. Stossberg. Mr. Robley, this design reduces road capacity. Well, it's intended to service for decades. So how do we do those projections for what our capacity would be in the future? And sort of what's the expected lifespan of this design of we don't want to make a road smaller and then find that it doesn't service in 10 years? Yeah, great question. So the consultant looked at the current day numbers rather than projected growth numbers because the current design of the roadway and proposed design of the roadway are both so overbuilt for capacity. We have so much ample space that would be required that you could essentially increase those numbers back up to the 1976 numbers and you would still have capacity available. So that those are including regional and interstate transportation users who aren't intending to be in Bloomington. So even if our population grew by that number, we would safely and comfortably be able to manage that number. Questions to my left. Mr. Coppock, please get close to the mic and turn it on. You mentioned the street trees in the corridor south and South College and in that section in there. But is the city's policy still to have the build forward with the bill to go up against the right away? And doesn't that decrease your growth of trees in there? I mean, There are, that's a great question, there are areas in the downtown that do require build forward buildings that is not the entirety of the corridor, especially in that southern stretch. The downtown has special UDO requirements that require building forward that potentially could limit the number of trees, but street trees aren't provided on private property, they're provided in the right of way in a tree plot that is different than the private property. And I got another question, too. Of course, the fatalities that you noted really aren't related to speed. I mean, from what the reports I read on those, I think you gave them to everybody else. I mean, I don't know that this would reduce that. So I think that's kind of misleading in there. Is that a comment or a question? That's a comment, I guess. Or maybe it's a question as to whether he thinks it's related to speed of the vehicles. Mr. Roebling? Yeah, so it's best practice to not focus on any individual crash and instead to take the entire corridor. But I will say that there is at least one fatal crash that was speed related. Certainly there was a motorcycle driving at high speeds that caused a crash. There are two others where speed wasn't the immediate cause of the that crash. But again, going back to the safe systems approach, we know that slower vehicles cause fewer fatalities. One more question. When you mentioned South Bend and Louisville, I think in part of what you said, were those areas that were underutilized in redevelopment type areas as opposed to this quarter, which most of it's pretty well developed and established? Well, I would challenge that The downtown is certainly well established in Bloomington. I would say that the southern stretch features very few buildings. There's the rallies and then the post office, but few else. And then similar to the north, there's longstanding vacancies. But Bloomington, or sorry, Louisville and South Bend, to answer that portion of the question, both were economically depressed areas, but not completely eliminated. area in Louisville is where the convention center was located. It was as hopping as a convention center in a major American city can be. Let's go to some other questions. Any questions on my right? Mr. Flaherty. Thank you for the presentation. Looking at the staff recommendation among the two options that would broadly aim to improve safety and achieve the city's goals, The recommendation is the two-way conversion. You mentioned that there would be a phased approach, obviously funding contingent over many years, potentially decades. Can you tell us a little bit more about the phasing and how much or most of the infrastructure and safety improvements could be made in a kind of sequenced way before changing traffic flow? And if you have any examples, I know New Albany, Indiana is one. South Bend, obviously, Indiana is another. that have converted or restored, really, you know, major arterials to, you know, back to two-way traffic, kind of, any insights, I guess, gleaned from, like, yeah, that combination and phasing of infrastructure versus traffic flow and how that, you would anticipate that proceeding. Yeah, so Bloomington is, the corridor is kind of unique in the stretch, so New Albany and South Bend are good examples of quarter cities that successfully converted and benefits of those. But they needed slightly fewer improvements that potentially Bloomington would need depending on the type of improvement you need. And then so for phasing like I said the city does projects all the time along both corridors where we repave, we do curb improvements, curb ramp improvements, et cetera. And we can continue to do those. They should not largely intersect with the fact that they'll be outside of the two-way conversation. So we can convert those and have those safety benefits in the meantime, including things like the urban trail. And then towards the end, the big, question is the forty one intersections and converting those will need traffic signals that are updated which will include things like right of way acquisition probably short term this is a wide enough quarter that we shouldn't need to buy property from anyone but short-term property conversion so that we can build those new that new infrastructure which will take time and that's kind of the the far-off distance that's the That's really the heart of where we'll be looking for federal funding to do. You kind of aim to do it in one fell swoop kind of towards the end while you get all of the safety improvements with redevelopment and city projects along the way. Just a small follow up. So thinking, if you're constructing shorter cross distances, narrower kind of curb to curb distances, potentially putting in urban trails, like that could all happen while the pair of one-way traffic remains, which would also, I presume, entail reducing the number of vehicle travel lanes to two, you know, from three before the actual potential restoration of two-way traffic. Is that right? Like, am I imagining how the phasing would work? Yes. That would be the ultimate plan is to slowly over time reduce those safety concerns or improve safety. Thank you. Mr. Binder. You spoke a little bit, you touched on the likelihood that the cost of this project in whatever form it might take in the future would be potentially substantially covered by various external funding grant opportunities, state and federal. Could you give us some examples of the types of funding programs that the city's used in the past for projects like this. I'd just be curious to know or get an idea. Obviously it's hard to predict in the future what kinds of, especially I think federal grant opportunities might arise, but maybe just giving us some sense of the degree to which some of the costs might be covered or over what type of time span federal grants might cover these costs. Yeah, that's a great question. I basically can't answer it, but I can answer it because the way federal funding works, new Congress comes up with a new title for a new thing that does substantially the same thing. But Kalamazoo did a similar project using USDOT raise grants. There's the Safe Streets and Roads for All safety grants that are out there, implementation grants. This would be an eligible project among those. And so there's a bunch of There's basically always a federal program that you could tap into, what it's called, and when it is available, it just changes every year. But there's lots of grant opportunities out there. Indianapolis did theirs, the cultural trail, with the support of the, I think it's the Lilly Foundation, I forget off the top of my head, but substantial non-federal grant that we, you know, something we could potentially look for as well. for the questions to my right, to my left. Let me take a crack first if nobody else has first round questions. Can we go back to that slide that said FSI crashes? And while you're pulling that up, I did note something that said transit facilities suffer more under a one way in that chart of outcomes. One of the downsides for a two way Or for a one way was that trans facilities are less advantage. And I wondered why that was. Because it seems like in a one way scheme there'd be room for say a dedicated bus lane. But in a two way scheme there wouldn't be. So I wondered about that. That would also be a part of a slide too. I'm going to take that second part first and you might have to remind me on the first. OK so trans facilities here. It says it's slightly worse for transit under one way, but much better under a two way. How do you explain that? Yeah, so transit and I'll let, oh shoot, I just met him and I've already forgot his name. The new manager of Bloomington Transit is here. I'll let him correct me if I'm wrong. But transit and fire are both unique in that one way facilities hinder their movement. They want to be able to travel in both directions. you know, stabilize the network and make more connections easier and more feasible. Whereas the one way, they're either all on, all the pickups are on college or they're all on Walnut, depending on what direction the traffic, or yeah, the bus is heading. Whereas the two way, you know, if more pickups would happen on college, they can convert to college. So that's kind of the reason it suffers facility-wide. Can you go back to the FSI slide now? I only noted that there was a question I had on it, I won't remember until I see it. It said FSI crashes. Okay, so I don't think I quite followed your explanation here because this went by quickly. What does the blue, the purple, and the green line mean? Yeah, so the, great question, the light blue at the top is a signalized five-lane capacity road. That would be two southbound travel lanes, two northbound travel lanes, and that center turn lane. That doesn't exist now. This is just an example. No, that's a hypothetical. Yes, exactly. In some stretches, we essentially have a six-lane highway. And so that would be a road diet from six lanes. So are you saying that that blue line represents the current capacity of Walnut and College now? No, because it's not designed that way, as you mentioned. But I'm just saying, this is A hypothetical, this is a strode, if you will, if you're familiar with the term. Yes. The ideal strode, not that you have an ideal strode. Strodes are not ideal, no. Yes, but a five lane capacity, two directional travel lanes, and then the... Okay, so the purple line? The purple line is the signalized one way, one lane travel lane, so that would be Walnut or, well, They don't have signals. But Walnut and Lincoln, but with signals, would be that purple line. Whoa, Walnut is two lanes. No, not Walnut. Sorry. Washington and Lincoln. A one-lane, one-way street would function at that purple line. So you're saying that that purple line can carry as much traffic as College Avenue sees? Yeah. Even just one lane could manage that kind of traffic? As long as it's signalized. And yes. OK. And then the green line below it? The green line below it is this three-lane capacity design to the right, that's your standard travel, urban design travel lane, which is one northbound, one southbound lane, and then a dedicated turn lane. So why is it that a green, the green line has less capacity than the purple one? Because of the design, the turning vehicles and The turning vehicles will essentially slow traffic down. They are sometimes in the way of through traffic. So you're saying that the purple line represents a single lane going one way and turns and straight traffic both are in the same lane. And nevertheless, it carries that slightly more traffic than this scheme here. Yeah, right. Because anyone going into the intersection will be moving immediately through it. have to slow down and navigate the oncoming traffic. I have more questions, but I'll defer to a second round of first round questions. Anyone who has not yet asked is favored, but I think Mr. Coppock, you had another question? What kind of response have you got from the Chamber of Commerce and the downtown businesses? I don't believe the chamber actually formally made a recommendation through written response, although I see Mr. M.G. I won't throw him under the bus here, but I believe he is here to speak on their behalf. And then downtown Bloomington incorporated sent a letter of remonstrance, and that is included in the packet. And you can see their objections and concerns. Anything else, Mr. Coppock? OK, further questions to my left, Mr. Stossberg. In your review of other cities who have done one-way to two-way conversions, did you find any that found that they didn't work and then moved back? Yeah, so we did a ton of research on that. That was the million-dollar question, essentially. We found exactly one who had a concern post-adoption. And it was not from the city. It was just from residents. they, it's the city of Columbus, Ohio converted a street. I can't remember off the top of my head, unfortunately, um, in a residential area and the two way design brought additional truck traffic through and they, the residents weren't happy with that, but otherwise the safety benefits, um, were, you know, uh, like I mentioned, Columbus was continuing to pursue conversion of one way arterials to my right. Mr. Flaherty. Thank you. Thinking about funding, can you talk a little bit more about how this might proceed practically in the years to come? I know there's a lot of unknowns. We obviously can do things at the city like bond, issue bonds. And some of that, we have the MPO that has funding that's allocated according to certain plans and policies. one could imagine in a future federal government administration that there might be grant programs to support safe streets. As far as the magnitude of what we're talking, can you say a little bit more about all that? It's a big price tag, but it's hard to consider all at once. Do we imagine that there might be federal grant programs where up to $25 million would be available or something like that? And same thing with, again, the magnitudes of what's realistic. with respect to city bonding, with respect to the MPO funding, and on what timelines? Yeah, great question. Hold on, sorry. Yeah, so grant funding often does not come with a $100 million price tag unless you're a huge city like Chicago or Washington, D.C. Cities our size generally see 25 20 million dollar grants and so that would not cover the entirety of the corridor and instead we would do things like I mentioned those safety improvements along the corridor that would allow us to in the future target additional grant funding and then you know think about a conversion way off in the future but in the meantime get those bulb outs those that urban trail that pedestrian Network completion and things like that including through the MPO college and walnut are in the current tip Not the conversion obviously, but pedestrian safety improvements and things like that are in the current tip and then Something like the urban trail if this is ultimately approved are in the upcoming tip Just yeah, so we'll continue to target little bits like that and make those improvements. That's basically the only way you can do this. You'll never get that hundred million dollars. Just to explain that a tip is a transportation improvement program that's that's a subject of federal or state management. Is that right? Exactly correct. Yes, it's through the we would apply through the Bloomington Mineral County Metropolitan Planning Organization. Thank you. A brief follow up on the category of bonding. There's different types of bonds that we can consider. One is tax increment financing. We've used that for a lot of infrastructure in Bloomington, including I believe 30 or 32 million in debt financing for two parking garages nearish the downtown in 2019. That's about 40 million dollars in today's 20, 26 dollars. So not less than half of what we're talking about here, but not orders of magnitude different. Like it is something we chose to do with no grants, so no matches, right, for the purpose of building additional parking supply. So thinking about the economic benefits in particular, as well as the broader benefits to the city, is TIF funding something that's been discussed or could be paired with federal grant dollars, MPO dollars, to kind of build that together? Any thoughts on that? Those are potential funding options. I do not think we have not considered it as part of this. That's not kind of the ultimate goal of the study. It's something that council and the future administration could consider. It is not something that we're proposing to do at all currently. So there's not a lot of concrete, not much of a capital planning, like concrete plan at this stage, but all of the things that I've discussed, like our are options available to us. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Further questions. Either side. Mr. George go. I'm just curious about the broader context. So the project started years ago and I'm sure the context changes and there are some initiatives and other things going on. Is there anything which changed the priorities or the relevance like anything around how it goes throughout the years and then it will last for more years. So like how do we stay relevant when we are planning it. Yeah. Oh, that's such a good question. So the relevance has not changed. We've continued to do counts engineering department is wonderful and has done several counts. We found that the numbers are for vehicles speeds and counts are roughly the same, you know, as our council way back when. that hasn't changed and we don't expect them to change much. Context has changed quite a bit. The convention center is expanding, like I mentioned, things like that. The assessor has recently depreciated properties on the south stretch of the corridor, so kind of at the urgency of doing some sort of transportation slash economic development project has kind of increased. But ultimately, This is an adoption or an amendment to the transportation plan, which does not take small bites. It takes long bites. It does take small bites. It doesn't take big bites. It takes small, long bites where we look at trying to achieve our goals 100 years in the future rather than immediately. So the context kind of can come and go. But the plan being the recommendation is kind of what it is, essentially. any other ongoing long-term initiatives which will overlap with this direction we take? There isn't anything that will affect this directly. As you are well aware, as a transportation commission member, we are also looking at the Roger Street corridor. That is another high priority network. It won't reduce capacity. The proposal so far is not to reduce capacity on that street, just to redesign it so that it is safer. the any overflow traffic or whatever would easily be manageable on Rogers. Although there won't be any overflow traffic as you can see from this chart here. But yeah, the college and walnut kind of operate as a permanent stalwart and are basically unflappable. And so yeah, there's there's nothing that should affect their ultimate importance in the city. All right. I got a couple more. questions, too. You had a slide up there about how other cities did. You mentioned South Bend. So you mentioned the property values going up in the next city. I think it was Louisville. You had a comparison that the one-way control streets went down. Do we have any sense of how much property values went up outside of the main streets in South Bend in that same period? For South Bend, but that is something I could dig into in the future the I just went off of mayor Pete's Press conference. Well, that's fine. I just you know didn't know how to compare that 21% increase Yeah, that makes a lot since I could look at the other question. I wanted to ask is one that I have heard so many times in my life in Bloomington before I was politically active and since, and that is the block of Walnut Street between 6th and 7th. And specifically, the complaint I hear is what you mentioned earlier, that it's the only place I hear it more than anything else, that when there are two trucks, typically unloading beer, blocking two of the three lanes of Walnut Street. I have never heard people complain more than about this particular thing. So one thing I don't get, is how in either scenario, maybe the one way I sort of understand, I'd like to understand more about how you imagine loading zones. Can you zoom in perhaps to show us what the loading zone might be? Zoom into that slide. But can you explain to us how that block in particular would be resolved by any new design? And how other blocks in the city that might find themselves the object of commercial endeavors might lobby to change their block to add loading zones in the same way should that day come. I mean, I hear a lot. Hold on, I can try to zoom in on that. That'd be great. Give me just half a second. That'd be great. I appreciate your effort here, but I just want to get this question dissected once and for all because I think it has an inordinate amount of grip on the public conscious, conscience, consciousness. Is that the right word? Either one, either one, either one. I could keep riffing while he's pulling it up, but you get the idea. Can you just zoom into that picture? Is there an example of it in that picture? I mean, I guess maybe I could ask an alternate question, which is, could we require a certain company to only load at a certain time in order to prevent? Here we go. All right. Tell us what we're looking at. Kirkwood, sixth and seventh. Yeah, so this is Walnut. Sixth is right there, smack dab in the middle. And then you can see the designated loading zones. These start at the alley and kind of stretch outward. And then this is a pretty good example of what we could propose based on businesses along the blocks requirements. But essentially, you provide extra parking or loading space, which is currently occupied by parking vehicles, and then allow loading zones. I'm sorry. I'm having trouble hearing. Could we ask the audience, please, to keep it down? Say again. Yeah, so this would take up what is currently vehicle parking and allow for loading zones that, like I said earlier, we can work with the businesses along the block place to determine their needs and best suit their needs. So on Walnut here, you can see that both sides of the street will feature that loading zone because so often there's a delivery truck at Brothers and the Bluebird, and that eliminates the the vehicle traveling down to one. So you can see here that the travel or the loading zones will provide that space for. So just tell me what I'm looking at here on the right of the screen where I look it looks like angled parking. Would the angle parking have to be temporarily signed so that a truck could come in, or where is the space? These are not angled parking. This hash is how we're showing the loading zone. Oh, I see. The angled parking is here. You can see it's pulled in angled parking there. This is parallel parking here. And then this is the loading zone, these hashes, which would be designated to the delivery drivers. To answer the second part of your question, which is, can you work with businesses to require delivery times? We've talked to a whole bunch of businesses. I forget the exact number. I think it's 35 businesses along the corridor. And the overwhelming response is that not really. They can't control that. A couple of them were like, potentially we could. But by and large, no. The delivery drivers kind of just show up when they show up and need the space when they need the space. Especially true with less than load LTL. delivery drivers, which you see especially between Kirkwood and Sixth on the square. Those are full semis, but only a portion of that semi delivers to the local business. They're coming from out of state and they need to deliver exactly when they need to deliver. They can't control their times essentially at all. Is that a problem in other cities that have constraints? who force deliveries to come at a certain time because they have no choice, manage it somehow. Is that truly not an alternative? Can we not require delivery companies to be more timely? I believe in theory you could. I think Bloomington is not set up to manage it that way. But yeah, I believe you're right. Philadelphia is an example that has those delivery times. It is something you could do on paper. It's not something that we found any interest in the local business. And I think most public servants, especially in the parking realm, aren't interested in trying to enforce that kind of time management. I mean, I think it's still a more optimal thing. But I just wanted to know what was possible. Thank you for that. With that, if there's no last call for questions, it's time to go to the public for comment on, did you have the last question? We have one more and then we'll go to the public, TCR 2622. This is about the context of changing a road in a college town. I can imagine reducing one-way trips will reduce accidents on move-in day, parents' weekend, and so forth. We also have a very successful football team right now. And we have particular traffic patterns and spikes on those days. Have your traffic projections and capacity looked particularly at game day traffic? Great question. No, but that's because the best practice for designing streets is to not look at your extremes. You certainly want to look at only eight days of extreme traffic that is not something that would occur otherwise. Kind of the good approximation is that historically, engineers kind of thought roadways as drain pipes, where water just goes as fast as water goes, but vehicles don't operate like water. You know, we don't follow, humans make mistakes and they don't follow the same conditions every time. So some of them go 100 miles an hour, some of them go two miles an hour, and that all causes congestion and whatnot and danger. So you don't design for your worst day, you design for your average day. And then we did think about gameday traffic. So the current, I should pull it up, hang on, the current design for north 17th, where you see the kind of the extremes of gameday traffic. We will have to work with INDOT because INDOT owns the bypass. And so ultimate design, we kind of left as a gray area because that's a conversation we'll have to have way off in the future when we're ready to think about conversion there. But hold on, sorry, I'm trying to open it. The design will be very similar to the current design where it's two lanes there, both north And why isn't it sharing? It's very large, yeah. Hang on, sorry, one second. If you need some time, you can go to public comment and you can show it after public comment. I got it on my screen. That should hopefully be enough. But you can see that the current design will maintain the two lanes. So this is a thing that other cities deal with. The kind of local good example is Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis. And they have West Street and Missouri. They are one way couplet through their downtown. And they both convert to southbound traffic to get everyone towards the interstate. So the similarity here would be getting everyone to the bypass to get onto 69. And so you can convert those lanes. in any direction. And the benefit of the two-way travel lanes versus the one-way travel lane is that the infrastructure will be designed to allow traffic in both directions. So you can convert all travel lanes northbound. Currently, they close southbound college on game days to stop the interference with those moving vehicles. But if you suddenly have traffic signals that work in both directions, you can have the police control those to allow vehicles to move quickly through and past the intersection. All right. With that, we go now to public comment. So for those of you who are in chambers who'd like to speak to TCR 2622, we welcome you to come to the podium. Please sign in. You'll have three minutes to speak. Those of you who are online, please use the raise hand function in Zoom and the secretary as someone will acknowledge you and we'll go back and forth as we see people raising their hand in Zoom. Is there anyone who would like to speak to TCR 2622? Please come to the podium, sign in, state your name, and you'll have three minutes. My name is Chris Taylor. I've been a resident of Bloomington for 49 years. I came as a student to IU. My husband and I raised our family here. One of the best lessons I learned growing up in a small northern Indiana town that keeps rewarding me is how to cross the street. We learned that one stop sign. We had one stop sign in our town that had no buttons on it to push. In addition to that one stop light, we had many intersections without any guidelines at all. We looked all four ways and knew how to judge when it was safe to cross the road. Another lesson learned later in life was riding a bike with common sense. Our young son was on the back of my bike. My husband and our two daughters, we all went bike riding all over Bloomington. And we did that all before there were ever any bike lanes. The audacity. The purpose of today's special hearing is to consider the adoption of an amendment of the 2019 transportation plan, although it looked like there were two areas highlighted as amendments. The second one on roughly page 69 does not appear to be amending anything, but was highlighted on November 12th of this year. I looked at the agenda for this meeting. I didn't see it online, so I requested one, but I never received a response from the department. On Saturday, I looked again, and on the agenda had been issued. The agenda. five pages for the staff report, 39 pages for the draft, five pages for documents and two-way concept designs, 75 pages of the transportation plan, 67 pages of the existing conditions report marked draft, 395 pages of the multimodal analysis report from 2025, six PDF documents outlining city of Bloomington traffic count along the corner, 24 responses from the city of Bloomington, for the study feedback. It appears that some of the documents are still in draft form. I don't understand that. And it appears that remaining one way isn't even an option. The only option appears to be moving to a two-way street. Further, the measure under consideration is a tool for planning framework. But I know that what is framework today will eventually be implemented. I say keep it one way. Don't change anything. Do not adopt the staff proposal as has presented. The bicycle friendly community report card issued in the spring of 2023 states overall community ridership is 1.8%. That's less than 2% riding their bikes to work. To use differently, the cutesy term road diet mentioned in the staff report, I recommend that the city go on a bike path and urban trail diet. What we have is enough already. After reading Ordinance 20-2504, the establishment of the Transportation Commission, the first whereas states, to reduce traffic deaths and serious injuries on the city roadways to zero in the city by the year 2039. This language is insane. I had no idea the city could prevent my death by ordinance. Are we going to be locked down at the end of 2038? I'll mark my calendar. Sometimes the government that spends wildly and pays Experts to dream up nonsense is simply justifying their existence. Well time well government Thank you for your comment whoever has ears let them hear thank you next comment in chambers, please My name is Barbara schweigman and I've lived in Bloomington for over 45 years and And I've worked downtown on the square for about six years. I am very much opposed to making Walnut and College two-way. You spelled my name wrong, but that's OK. And on the subject of speeding, to prevent speeding to make the College of Walnut two-way, I thought the speed limit downtown was 20 miles per hour and I think it should have been enforced. It doesn't seem to be enforced. That's a problem. Bloomington is a university town so in my mind it's not like Louisville or South Bend or Indianapolis. So those are different issues. To get back to speeding I wonder when those Accidents happen when they happen, who was involved, what time of year, what time of day. I think those are all elements that need to be looked at. I just keep picturing myself perhaps having a heart attack in Kroger's Seminary Square. The ambulance comes and then it's zooming or not zooming North to the hospital because it has to stop and start where because there are so many two lane stops and starts. I don't understand it. I don't even understand who came up with the idea, but I thank you for your time and your attention. Thank you for your time. Is there anyone online who'd like to speak to the issue? Let's go to our first online speaker. Hello, this is Paul Russo. Can you hear me? You have three minutes. Go ahead. I too had trouble with meeting documents. Am I, is it louder now? I had trouble finding the meeting documents. I'm not sure quite what has changed in the past year since there was public comments solicited. The comments that I made seem to have been completely ignored. As a bicyclist, I would like to say there's a good reason why only 1.8% of the people bicycle to work, and that's because it's dangerous to bicycle. There's complete hegemony by motor vehicle drivers in this town, and calling it bicycle friendly is rather laughable. The comment I made about this particular plan is that bi-directional bike lanes are not best practice and they should not be put in. We can see what happened with a bi-directional bicycle lane on 7th Street. Within weeks or months, we had to put stop signs in every intersection because motor vehicle drivers were unaccustomed to having bicycles traveling in both directions. At every intersection and driveway, bi-directional bike lanes expect drivers to suddenly adopt a new and counterintuitive behavior, looking both ways for bicyclists on a space not wider than a motor vehicle lane. The expectation is that all the more implausible in a city that does virtually nothing with regard to education or enforcement, an unsurprising result from the bi-directional bicycle lanes would be more collisions than with one-way bicycle lanes. There would also, I would expect her to be head on collisions in narrow bi-directional bicycle lanes between scooters and bicyclists. And there's also the issue of the intrusion of motor vehicles because a bi-directional bicycle lane by its nature is wider. Therefore, to prevent motor vehicle drivers from putting their vehicles in the bicycle lane, as we've seen on 7th Street, you have to install bollards. Well, crashing into a bollard as a bicyclist is a lot more consequential than scraping the side of a curb on a narrow one-way lane. And I would hazard to, I would guess that the width of a one-way bicycle lane is slightly wider than half the length of the bi-directional bicycle lanes that are on 7th Street. In any case, all of this is a bad idea and the city seems to be just fixated on these bi-directional bicycle lanes, or at least their consultants do. It's a bad idea. and spending tens of millions of dollars to install this kind of thing? What a disaster. Thank you. Thank you for your comment. Let's go now to the next person in chambers. Please state your name. You'll have three minutes. Excuse me. Yes, my name is Bill Mackey, sir. So I'm going to try and sneak all this into the three minute timeline here. First of all, I think obviously cost benefit analysis really needs to be considered here and we're talking about spending a hundred and six million dollars I would push back fairly strongly on all three of the examples that were given in the presentation Regarding South Bend a very dilapidated area at the time that they made that change There were significant investments and other things it wasn't just they changed the road and magically things showed up Secondarily, as I think somebody on council had mentioned here, a largely vacant area has low property values necessarily. In the Brook Street example in Louisville, the photos shown here in chambers showed essentially surface parking and then the the replacement, suddenly you see millions and millions of dollars worth of structure there. This is not a magic panacea where suddenly property values went up because the road was changed. Look at the amount of money that Indianapolis put into the cultural trail area. Again, this is not a $106 million fix. We better be prepared to spend a lot more to do that. Some other things that I wanted to mention about this, the safety issues. Safety is oftentimes related to speed and related to the number of vehicles that are transiting there. When we're showed this area that says here are where the most accidents are, there is a 100% correlation between that and where traffic is the heaviest. So not surprisingly, in areas where you have a lot more vehicles, you have a lot more traffic, you have a lot more accidents. Somebody else had mentioned this. Speed can be controlled by means other than spending $106 million something like this. A few police officers throwing out tickets would allow people to pretty quickly understand that going 40 miles an hour in a 20-mile zone is not necessarily a great idea. And of course, if we wanted to eliminate fatal crashes and pedestrian incidents, there's lots of ways to do that. You could ban pedestrians entirely in cyclists. There would be no pedestrian accidents if there were no people there. That's, of course, a ridiculous assertion. Well, it's just as ridiculous to state that we're going to drive this number down to zero by making these big time changes. Could that possibly help? Yes. Is it going to drive it to zero? I don't think it is. When we talk about environmental impacts, we've talked about a lot of that stuff here. There is no vehicle that is less efficient than the vehicle driving at zero miles per hour. And all these things that end up causing extraordinary congestion involve standstill traffic. That is the worst possible situation for environment. If we want to actually sort of encourage better environment downtown, how about we put in some more Electric vehicle infrastructure down there. Spend some money on that instead of spending money slowing cars to a crawl. Zero miles per hour is the worst situation possible for environmental. That's your time. Thank you very much. Thank you very much for your time. Let's go to another speaker in the room. Please come forward, state your name, sign in, and you'll have three minutes. All right. My name is George Keller. I am against the proposal to convert the one-way sections of College and Walnut to two-way traffic. I have been against this concept for the last eight years ever since it was first proposed back in 2018. Since I will probably not be able to cover all my arguments here in the three minutes, I would like to ask people here in the audience to please go online to the B Square Bulletin and read through my letter with attachments to the peers in the Bloom Docs section of the website. This document will give you a lot more information than what I'm able to speak about right now. I would first like to comment on what happened back in 2018. Back in 2018, the proposal to convert the one-way sections of College and Walnut to two-way traffic was overwhelmingly rejected by almost everyone except for some people in our city government and the consulting firm that the city hired to do the study. The Bloomington Chamber of Commerce at that time did a survey of their members and found that 88% of their members did not want these streets converted to two-way traffic. The city allowed people to submit comments online concerning the street conversion review. Those comments showed that 75 of the 85 commenters were against the idea. If you go through the math, you'll find that 75 out of 85 worked out to 88% against the same percentage as the business community. CFC properties also came out against this proposal. CFC Properties was responsible for the renovation and rejuvenation of our downtown areas, any other organization in this city, including Fountain Square, Grand Place, and a portion of the Showers Building that we're in right now. A letter from Jim Murphy, who was the president of CFC at the time, stated that the proposal to restore a two-way right-of-way to these roads should be removed from the plan with no further consideration. Studies and evaluation would be costly. Implementing the plan would be additionally cost prohibitive. Despite this massive opposition, the city chose to continue to have work done and spend money on the two-way street proposal, so that's where we find ourselves today. I also would like to comment on the stated speeding issues on College and Walnut. A big reason offered for the conversion of College and Walnut to two-way traffic is the claim that one-way streets promote speeding, which in turn results in an excessive number of crashes. However, the actual historical crash data for North College Avenue and North Walnut Street does not show that speeding is a significant issue for the crashes at all. In fact, if you go to the crash data website for Bloomington Monroe County and look at the cause of crashes for these two streets, you will see that the two speeding categories account for less than 4% of the crashes. The two categories that call out speeding are speed too fast for weather conditions and unsafe speed. Many other crash factors, such as following too closely failure to yield right away and improper turning are listed as far more important. So while people are driving over this beeline on the way sections of the College of Walnut, the crash data shows that's not a significant cause for the crashes. So in conclusion, I'm asking the transportation. Okay. Thank you so much. Okay. I will note that Mr. Keller's letter did appear in the public comment link in the packet. Uh, so it's linked, uh, in our agenda. Uh, and I just wanted to point out that, uh, that it was made publicly available on the city website. Is there anyone online who'd like to speak? All right. Let's go back to chambers. Good evening commission chair of all. And this is, uh, Christopher energy from the greater Bloomington chamber of commerce and a former parking commission member. I would say few issues have drawn as much unsolicited feedback from our members as the college walnut two-way conversion. It's been overwhelmingly negative. Our member survey that we recently put out tells a clear story. We engaged in businesses and their leaders on this subject when the word came out just to get a snapshot of what that is. And that figure is 84% opposed the conversion and 65% strongly oppose it. Nearly 60% expect negative impacts on the business and their organization. Their concerns are just practical as you would think. We've talked about here, customer access, deliveries, loading space, and years of potential construction disruption. On October 20th, Mayor Thompson told the Rotary Club, which I was attending, that the streets won't become two-way during her administration. It drew a tremendous applause from that audience. We agree that the corridor deserves investment. The Chamber's long advocated for investment revitalization along the College Walnut Corridor, particularly the Miller Showers Park area, as we call the stadium district, and also the heavily distraught south end by Seminary Square. Better sidewalks, trees, safer crossing, slower traffic would help residents, visitors, and businesses alike. We appreciate Mr. Robling, the city's planning service manager for Brighton providing some detailed responses on those three fatal crashes in the study, but those fatalities weren't attributed specifically to one-way configuration and really not even speeding per se. The concerns about those speeding, lane movement and pedestrian safety are real. We don't establish that the conversion is a necessary solution to those issues. So tonight's decision has long-term consequences. Staffs confirmed the adaptive study of the transportation would establish a two-way conversion as a city's long-term direction, even without immediate construction. Meanwhile, the city has already approved 1.27 million preliminary engineering for an intersection, pedestrian improvements, et cetera, that do not require converting college and Walnut to two-way traffic. Our request is straightforward. Separate the safety and streetscape improvements from the conversion proposal. evaluate less disruptive alternatives and their measurable safety benefits. Don't establish two-way conversion as long as policy without real evaluation. We can have safer streets, a revitalized stadium district and seminary square area, greener, more welcoming downtown without converting college and Walnut to two-way traffic. We recommend this body not adopt the study as currently written, removing the two-way conversion would be your best alternative. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. Further public comment? Anybody online? In the room, please come to the podium, state your name. You'll have three minutes. My name is Wendy Brisht. I didn't really prepare, but I did make some notes from what I saw here, which I've been thinking about this quite a bit. Every time I drive down or up on that corridor, I give God thanks, because it's so easy to get through town and to town. And it's really, to me, it's one thing that really works about our transportation system. And I think most people feel that way. But it just keeps coming back at us, and I think people are are a little bit alarmed. I think there are easier and different ways to decrease the speed and increase the safety. As somebody already mentioned, it's driver distraction, driver impairment distractions, maybe worse with a two-way street with all those things coming and going. I think the drive will be much longer either direction. People will look for ways around. Buses might not be able to go both ways as easily but imagine how much longer they're going to take To get through town and to get to where they're going which will move less passengers. I think speed monitors I think maybe timing lights for slower traffic more police presence. I I don't think moving some of that traffic on the quiet onto the quieter pedestrian streets is going to be a good More pedestrian streets anyway is gonna be a good alternative because then you're gonna have those having more traffic and more accidents. I think trees are important for downtown. It's getting hot and shade is really important. If you wanna have pedestrians, it's really important to have shade and I think trees are really good for that. And I think that, I know that Rogers gets congested. I know that Indiana's getting to be a one-way street now. A lot of those good alternatives are being used up. And this is not simply any street. This is not a street that can be compared with any other street in any other town. It is the north south corridor that Bloomington residents and visitors depend on to get where they need to go. I need to go to my physical therapist. I need to go to work. I need to get through town, and that's how I can do it because of where I live. And so I think it's a really important thing to consider residents' needs in this regard. Thank you. Thank you for your comment. Is there any other comment in the chamber? One more. Wendy, please, if you don't mind to sign in before you leave so that we have that record. Thank you. Your name is spelled right. While we're waiting for the next speaker, is there anyone else online who's waiting to speak? All right, in the chamber, please state your name, sign in, you'll have three minutes. My name's Dan Rary, and I have Dan Rary Real Estate at 517 North Walnut Street, which is between 9th and 10th streets. And I have owned that building there since 1973, 53 years. So I've seen a lot of comings and goings. Parenthetically, when I was going to IU in the 1960s from 65 to 70, I worked the whole time. And part of the time I worked as a delivery driver for Coca-Cola. So I'm very familiar with how this all works with the trucking and deliveries and everything. And I just don't see any way it would be possible to continue that. if you turn these streets back to two-way. The problems there with speeding can be solved a lot of other ways other than turning them into two-way streets. More enforcement and the timing of the lights. I mean, I personally am always in a hurry, and I hate to see traffic slow down. But there are ways to do that, and probably that should happen. The disruption to the businesses that are in that corridor would be unbelievable. I remember when they had the South Walnut Street widening and that ran businesses out left and right. When they had the big dig on Kirkwood, if you can run McDonald's out of business, you have done something. And that's exactly what happened. So I think that the, disruption of a total switch to two-way streets I I'll be 80 my next birthday. I probably wouldn't live long enough to see the thing completed And as far as the cost Those costs are always overrun. The timelines are always overrun. I just think it'd be a disaster I Don't see any way to do this without changing some of the parking and that street parking and is vital because nobody's got enough parking in downtown Bloomington. I have a fairly good amount of parking unless I want to change something on my building and then I'll start losing parking places because of what planning would make me do. It happened just next door to my office building. So I guess I'm skeptical. I think this is been run at us again since 2018. I think there are a lot of people that have their mind made up, yeah, this is what we're going to do, regardless of what the public thinks. And I'm not hearing anything from anybody that thinks this is a good idea. I appreciate you letting me speak. Thank you for your comments. Is there anybody else who'd like to speak? Please come to the podium and state your name. Three minutes. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Margaret Clements and I've been a member of the Monroe County Plan Commission since 2018 for several of those years I served as its president and therefore I was assigned as the Monroe County Plan Commission's delegate to the Metropolitan Planning Organization so couple of the things that I want to point out and there's so many of them I know I won't have enough time in three minutes to mention them. There are a lot of inferential flaws that were mentioned tonight in Mr. Roebling's discussion. I think it derives from tool designs results that they shared with you which is probably a franchise that they've tried to sell to exactly cities our size, you know. South Bend was mentioned as a comparison, and I grew up in South Bend within one or two blocks of all of the changes that have been advocated by Mayor Pete, et cetera. And there's some striking differences between South Bend and Bloomington. Number one, South Bend had a dead downtown, and they had to revive it. We have had a live downtown and we're in the process of killing it. I'm going to repeat what I said in 2018 when the two way study. was brought up for the first time, and that is that these are over-engineered solutions to non-existent problems. And I really would appreciate it if the leadership in this community could just listen to the smart constituents you have. You know, you have a lot of people with a lot of experience, with love for the community, and this isn't working for them. It took me 45 minutes to get across town the other day. I took 3rd Street out from the east side to Lowe's. I have options. You know, I could go to Bedford. I could go to Columbus. I could go to Martinsville for something that I needed, a store. I mean, how far away do you want to drive business, harm the climate, et cetera? It's just becoming ridiculous. The next day, there was a road rage incident involving a gun on that corridor at about the same time. The reduction in the traffic having been reduced by 31% is because you've made it so miserable to drive in Bloomington, Indiana. And so I'd like to advocate, which nobody does, for the driver experience. People have things to do. Places to go they have work to do Please use these roadways for what they were intended to do and that is to help the taxpayer become efficient productive and Contributing citizens to our community. Thank you very much. Thank you for your comment Anyone online Let's go to the next commenter in chambers, please sign in state your name. You'll have three minutes. I My name is Scott Ferris. My family's been in Bloomington since 1826, and I'm a sixth generation. We've had several businesses along the Walnut, even some buildings on College, and we've been around for a long time. Members of my family have been involved in the city politics here over the decades. Matter of fact, my father, I believe, sat in this body at one point in time on the Traffic Commission. I'm very familiar because I grew up in this environment of how the city of Bloomington was going to move traffic through the community. And this is north, south, east, and west. You had College, Walnut, you had Atwater, and you had Third Street. And eventually, because they moved the semis out of the city, they put them out on the bypass. And that was the flow of the city. For all intents and purposes, not a whole lot has changed since that took place, other than some of the measures that were put in place to take and promote public safety. And I support public safety, but I believe there should be a balance. So Indiana University, back when I was here in the 70s, we had probably, I don't know, 34,000 students. Now we've got 45,000, 50,000 students. The housing for those students, for the most part, are in apartments and also in rental properties because the university has not built enough additional dormitories. And it used to be that the students could not drive until your junior year. There were restrictions for that. So we've got a tremendous influx of traffic. We've got measures that have been put in place which are slowing down that traffic. And a fundamental flaw in this study is that not taking consideration anything to do with IU and the traffic that comes with it. I'm talking about football games, basketball games, parents' weekends, which happens all the time. Just go downtown on a Friday and Saturday night to go to dinner and you'll see it. Taking Walnut and College from three to two lanes makes absolutely no sense at all. Just go up at noontime and sit around the square and watch the traffic flow. It makes no sense. I'm not going to repeat what others have said because of the time. You all need to take to heart what the mayor has said with respect about what she's not going to do during her tenure as mayor with respect to college and Walnut. The B-squared document, which was published this morning, goes into great detail and does an excellent summary of a lot of positions I was going to bring up, and I encourage you all to look at it. And because I'm running out of time, I would hope that You all would open up the documents from the athletic director, IU athletic director, and also from the airport director, and read them so all of us can see what, in fact, were discussed in those letters. I do not support any aspect of this study. It is an absolute waste of money, and the taxpayer should not take upon any additional burden. Thank you. Thank you very much. Further public comment in the chamber, please come to the podium. Sign in. State your name. You'll have three minutes. Good evening. I'm Paul Kerberg. I'm not much of a public speaker, so you know it's important for me to get up here to actually speak. I'm a lifelong Monero County resident and former city engineering employee. To me, just the cost of this project is astronomically insane. I'm all about revitalizing downtown, spending that money to improve the downtown area, the corridor. College and Walnut are main thoroughfares through town. And we need to keep them that way and not restrict the flow of traffic. I'm also a former cyclist. I've probably ridden more than most people in this room. And to me, I would not want to ride on a primary arterial. You want to be away from the traffic. And to me, there's also a lot of just speculation and what ifs. We really don't know what this will do. We know how things are now, and we could improve upon what we have existing within the city and revitalize the corridor. So yes, I'm definitely against this plan. Thanks. Thank you for your comment. Further public comment on TCR 2622. Please come to the podium. Sign in. State your name. You'll have three minutes. Good evening. My name is Eric host and appreciate this opportunity to offer comment I asked you to proceed carefully because Well for many reasons hopefully I'll get to them I want to speak to transparency measurement accountability and trust We're talking about safety this evening And in order for us to determine what safety is, we have to define it. And I don't think we've adequately defined what safety is. Safety isn't merely slower speeds. Safety isn't merely fewer injuries on roads. Because safety involves things like emergency response. So when we talk about safety and we talk about trust, I think we need to listen to emergency responders. whose very commitment is to help people in need. And I want to note that the emergency responders uniformly objected to the plan for East Rogers Road, but yet we're still moving forward with that. So I think you have to carefully consider what we're doing here. I also want to speak in favor of data and measurement. So I would ask that all traffic studies, all traffic counts, vehicle type counts, vehicle velocity counts, accident reports in complete ARIES format be published prior and current and present, I mean future, so that we can actually see what the data says. Data does say that 1.8% of our population commutes. The estimate in city documents is that 5% or fewer people recreationally bicycle. That's a minority. It's an important way to get around, but I think choice, I mean, I've been a lifelong bicyclist, so I knew how to get around even before there were protected bike lanes and other infrastructure that we're building right now. I would also speak in favor of enforcement rather than obstruction because making it more difficult to drive Does not make the road safer for anyone. I think that's all I'd like to say tonight. Thank you. Thank you for your comment. Are there any other public comments on TCR 2622? Please come to the podium. Anybody online who wants to speak? Anyone who's raised their hand? Last call. If you'd like to speak and you're online, please use the raise hand function in zoom and you'll be called on. Last call in chambers. We'll come back to the commission for second round of questions. Are there any questions from commissioners on TCR 2622? To my left. To my right, Mr. Flaherty. Yeah, I wanted to follow up about the comment from Mr. Rousseau in particular with regard to the design choice of two-way protected bike lanes, which I think would be in either one-way or two-way concept. Could you say a little bit more about that design choice, why that's recommended over, say, protected bike lanes that are on both sides of the street next to the drive lane that's going the same direction, what the tradeoffs are, and why the recommendation? Yes. There's a couple of tradeoffs to consider. One way Mr. Russo is correct that one way bike lanes are the safest for essentially all the reasons he pointed out. However there are some major drawbacks in that they prefer they. change the location of the curb because you in order to protect them the bike lane has to be between the curb and the existing curb so that would eliminate things like it could potentially eliminate and reduce space for things like parking things like loading zones and things like that the other A thing we heard from public engagement, especially early on, was that in regards to the seven line, drivers specifically, excuse me, did not like the lower street level bike lane. We looked at what we could do to fix that solution and the best proposal was Similar to the cultural trail in Indianapolis was an urban trail, which is raised elevated and separated it allowed drivers to see them bicyclists pedestrians scooter riders more easily from further away and it the similar to the Seven line the urban trail design features other safety improvements including Pedestrian leading pedestrian intervals and similar for bicycles and scooter riders where they will be able to move easily through the traffic and then they'll have turn phases which are Separated from those phases so they there won't be vulnerable road users in the crosswalk At the time the turn vehicles have a green light. So we took the feedback we got from the seven line and kind of Said, what could we do to make that better? But yeah, ultimately a one way for safety for bicyclists is the one way protected by clean is the optimal design, but it takes up considerably more space and you can't have the kind of features, the additional safety benefits that you get from the urban trail design through the urban set core of the city. Thank you. For the questions, Mr. Binder. several commenters mentioned enforcement. And I do agree that traffic enforcement downtown is pretty lacking at times. So Mr. Roebling, what would your response be to that particular bit of feedback? Because I think I've heard maybe at least half of the commenters mention that if only we were to enforce traffic laws more explicitly speed in particular, that would do a lot to help things. What would you say to that, and I guess really specifically, what is it about enforcement that alone it wouldn't accomplish the city's goals? Yeah, that is such a good question. Enforcement is one of the three E's of traffic safety. There's now five but engineering and education are the other two classic three E's and it is the hardest kind of to do because you need police officers readily available to constantly enforce vehicle speed limits and that it takes those police officers off their beat, for lack of a better word, and requires them to just sit and occasionally look out for speeders. You can see this on I-69. You see state highway patrolmen sitting at various intersections waiting for speeders to come by. You can also see what happens is cars slow down, they slam on their brakes, they see the police ahead, and then immediately afterward they pick up often to the you know, always to the same speed, but often to a higher speed than they had previously. So their enforcement benefit would have to be constant and continuous, which is incredibly difficult on an already stressed police enforcement or police staff. And the state of Indiana, unfortunately, limits our ability to do things like speed cameras and traffic enforcement, automated traffic enforcement. So those are additionally limited. essentially limiting our ability to attack this at the enforcement only angle, which would be amazing. I think everybody would be supportive of that, but it's just with limited funds and staff hours. It's difficult. Thank you. The questions to my right to my left. Mr Sossberg. Oh, okay. I've got a question. I'd like to ask about the cost of this project. First of all, it doesn't sound like one project. It sounds like a series of projects over time, number one. Number two, can you give us a sense of what other street improvement projects have cost over the years? What's a ballpark figure for improving an entire block in terms of repairing curbs, building sidewalks, adding bike racks, adding lanes, changing lights. Do we have any kind of ballpark figures to compare these numbers to? Certainly. I don't want to overstep my engineering knowledge, so I'll see if Mr. Garzi has a better estimation as an engineer, but I'm happy to jump back. Mr. Garzi, at last, your services are of use. Can you give us any kind of ballpark figure to compare to this 103 to 109 million? answer but unfortunately I don't. Okay so this is at least something that we ought to find information for for further up the line. Iris Bull. I'm the administrative assistant for the engineering department. One of my duties involves supporting the capital project staff on projects and this question is one personally that I have asked many times in my two years, almost two years with the department. I'm delighted you're here. So I understand the desire to want to be able to nail down a specific number to like a particular asset. And in my time with the department, I have learned that unfortunately the answer is less standardized than we would like. And there are unfortunately almost always conditions, real-world conditions that get in the way of good faith estimates. So even when our project, we put an enormous amount of effort into scheduling a cost for projects. There are just so many factors outside of staff control that drive costs up and that has everything to do with the larger macroeconomic environment. It has to do with the scheduling of different contractors. It has to do with the weather sometimes. And to your point that we should be able to identify, for example, the cost of a curb ramp, we absolutely can do that. It's, I think, a public education process that I would like to put on our agenda as something that we can continue to talk about. I don't know that it would be particularly educational in this moment to be able to say, well, that $103 tool estimated is something that is intimately tied with our department's budgeting or anything. But I'm not looking for that. I appreciate the answer, but I'm looking for, again, a ballpark figure. What is a typical cost that engineering estimates that the city incurs in the normal maintenance of our built environment, of our built right of way? How much more does a project like this add? I mean, we're always having to maintain our streets, right, to upgrade traffic lights. This is all normal course of business. I'm just trying to get a sense of is this an ordinate cost compared to Yeah. So I can offer two things. One, I can come back with recent engineered numbers, but I can also give what engineering often gives as a napkin estimate is a mile of sidewalk is about a million dollars. I'll let Mr. Garza yell at me if I'm wrong. And traffic signal is about a quarter of a million or half a million to three quarters of a million, depending on what the geometry of the intersection requires. And yeah, we have numbers for all of that. Well, let's stop right there for a second. So the corridor we're talking about is 4.1 miles. Is that right? 4.2 miles. And how many lights are on that quarter? There are 25 signaled intersections. All right. So we're talking about 12 and a half to 17 million dollars just to replace traffic lights if we ever needed to. And over time we need to. And four miles of sidewalk on each side of both streets. is one, two, three, four, $16 million right there. So we're looking at just the normal course of replacing or adding sidewalks and traffic lights in this corridor. We're talking about 30 to $35 million. So that's what I'm looking for is some kind of a ballpark. That's normal cost just to keep things the same if you're trying to replace it. So what would you say are the biggest changes to the normal way, to the way that the roads are now, that would be the most significant expense among all the things that might be done over a 20-year period. Yeah, so in the keeping things or adding smaller things like sidewalks, curb, changing curb, existing curb and relocating them, that's a huge expense. Things like the urban trail would be a huge expense. Those are the largest chunks. But there's also, in the cost estimate, there is bridge reconstruction, which is not something that's part of normal every day. Did you say brick reconstruction? Bridge. Bridge, sorry. Yeah, sorry. No, I think Rick's doing great. OK. But no, bridge reconstruction, and those are things that would need to be updated anyway, but outside of a larger project, or sorry, both outside of a larger project and outside of your everyday. And those add to huge costs. So you have the Dodd Street Bridge. So my last follow-up then would be what portion does the city usually pay for projects like this knowing that state and federal funds are often used for them? Is 103 million dollars or 109 million dollars going to all come out of city coffers or that's the total cost of the project and A fraction of that will come out of our coffers if you were to do it tomorrow Just hypothetically not that that's the proposal it we would expect to do 20% local match And then the rest would be federal so practically speaking over the course of 20 years a project like this might cost us 20 to 21 20 to 22 million dollars out of the city coffers or roughly a million dollars a year is It's what we're talking about for a project like this Whatever that's my assumption. Let me go to other questions. Mr. Coppock. I think you've raised one Ryan is that the cost that said construction cost does that include the What we call soft costs like engineering design and right away is that all included in that? Six million or whatever it was. Both of those totals are the entirety of cost, so design everything. Further questions? Ms. Sucuruchko. Yeah, how do we plan to measure our goals, or like how do we achieve success with this project? Oh, yeah, such a good question. As with every project we do we do before and afters this one is unique in that we did a huge study looking at the before. So I would propose that planning and engineering staff work together to do a huge follow up especially since kind of the findings are so important to the city's future. development. So that's kind of what we would do. We would go back and do look at the exact same things we looked at before and see if any other issues popped up or other concerns or other things that we kind of saw as needs. Like I mentioned in the Columbus, Ohio example earlier, the residents complained about truck traffic and so they redesigned the street with They didn't change, modify the street, but they redesigned truck routes to, you know, prevent those trucks from traveling through those neighborhoods and things like that. So those are the types of things we would constantly be analyzing. We update the, well, we required to update the safe streets and roads. We're all safety action plan every five years. So we'll be able to see incremental improvements along any corridor. And we're constantly looking at every, basically every street. Engineering does traffic counts all over the city every month. Thank you. But before we start the project, it would be interesting to see how we envision those goals and how each of the projects will contribute to achieving those goals. But I think it's a bit harder to grasp right now. Just a comment. OK. Is there any other last minute questions before we go to debate? All right. So once again, the choices ahead of us are to make a positive recommendation, a negative recommendation, no recommendation or to continue to another meeting. So as members speak to this issue based on what they've heard tonight, please keep that in mind. It might be helpful if you can say what kind of recommendation you're leaning toward as you speak. So with that, who would like to speak to TCR 2622? Let's not all raise your hands at the same time. On my right, anyone have an opinion? Mr. Flaherty. I can start. Thank you. First of all, just thank you very much to city staff for your work on this and the presentation. Obviously, it's been part of the city plans for the last eight years and something that's been working through a lot of extensive public engagement designed maybe not design shorts, but corridor walks and a lot of direct outreach and engagement with the business community, et cetera. I do appreciate some of what we heard around balancing trade-offs across a variety of different goals and some of the things that we can make real no-regrets improvements on, like adding loading zones. I think most of us have experienced the problems with trucks simply just parking in drive lanes. And the risks that entails is people, you know, try to time and whip out in front of, you know, or traffic coming up behind them to get around because they're tired of waiting. So those things are, you know, exciting. I think broadly we have defined in city code what our criteria are. to try to effectuate and advance city goals, which are contained in comprehensive plan, transportation plan, and outlined in the recommendation from staff. Definitely recognize and appreciate the public comments tonight. So there was a lot of focus on two-way versus one-way, which that's not really the core question, I guess, to me. I would be interested to hear from colleagues if there are folks who feel like, I didn't review, for instance, any one-way concept designs to actually look at, I don't think they were included in the packet, to actually look at cross-section street design for the one-way alternative. But I'd be curious, and my colleagues on the commission here feel like we want to explore that option more deeply and talk about the trade-offs there. I did hear a fair amount of opposition, folks just sort of not thinking this is necessary right, or like they don't agree with it. in principle, and it seems like there's some disagreement with the city's goals. Or if there's agreement with the broad goals, like a disagreement with kind of the core principles of how to accomplish them. So I heard a lot of skepticism about reducing speeds and the impact of that about things like reducing crossing distances, LPIs, having separated dedicated infrastructure for vulnerable road users, especially bicyclists. And I'm not sure we can really solve those things. There's a diversity of opinions. I really try to lean into what evidence we have, not always from our Bloomington community, but from really meta-analyses of what's been done in communities across the country and around the world to make infrastructure improvements, safety by design in essence, and what the track record is on those. So I hear folks thinking it's absurd that we could even state a goal of eliminating traffic deaths in our city. I just respectfully disagree. I think that is a goal that we should have. When we talked about some similar concepts at the city council recently, I noted that in the last 35 years or so, Europe has cut their annual deaths, Europe as a whole, in traffic, from 75,000 a year down to about 20,000 a year. So no, they're not at zero, but that's 55,000 lives a year that they are saving relative to where they used to be. They used to be two and a half times the annual rate of deaths in the US. And now they're about half. That is a pretty striking and dramatic change. And it's been driven mostly by infrastructure choices, design choices, trying to make streets safe by design. So I guess just as a core foundational principle here, I do believe in what we're doing and trying to accomplish here through design changes. Definitely respect if folks have a different opinion about that. But that's where I am on it. I think the presentation was relatively compelling on the two-way versus the one-way and the benefits. I really appreciated the analysis of all the different things that we can consider, economic development lenses, loading zones, things like that. Certainly safety obviously is the first and foremost principle that we're meant to prioritize through city code and city goals. So yeah, when it comes to the proposal, I have no qualms delaying if folks want more time to dig into particular issues. I tend to align with the draft recommendations from staff to forward a positive recommendation on the concept design supported by staff. And so I'd be happy to do that if there was support for it. And if not, again, we'd be very curious to hear what alternatives folks would be interested in. To me, the kind of outright rejection of safety improvements on Walnut and College runs counter to city code, counter to city goals, and counter to the mission of this commission. So that doesn't really seem like a suitable path before us. But again, glad to hear the other perspectives. Thank you for your comments. Who would like to go next? Speak to TCR 2622, Mr. Coppock. Well, from what I've heard tonight, I haven't really heard any overwhelming support for making it two-way traffic. It's got an exorbitant cost associated with it. And I think it's really going to prohibit people's ability to get around town for service vehicles, delivery vehicles. I think you're going to get more of a bottleneck than you've ever had. Everybody knows it on Friday. You always go to the middle lane when you're going through downtown because of the beer trucks. And I mean, I think that instead of this overwhelming, you know, over $100 million project, you could look at some, evaluate if you do have some safety issues. You could make some spot improvements or intersection improvements that could help eliminate those, but I just don't see the, I mean, it doesn't seem like it's broke, so I don't know what we're trying to fix. Thank you. Thank you. Further comment on TCR 2622? Anybody? Really? No thoughts? All right. Well, I'll take a crack here. Two-way traffic is a feature of the vast majority of the city of Bloomington. I don't understand why that is such an objection. Most places in town were used to two-way traffic. If anything, it's the one-way traffic that messes up visitors to town who come in the fall to move their students here. I can't think about College and Wallet and not think about East 3rd Street, east of College Mall. I was god smacked when INDOT announced, INDOT of all entities said, there's not as much traffic on this road as there used to be. We're going to reduce its width. They had dropped from 18,000 cars a day to 12,000 cars a day. And since when does an organization that is all about moving cars reduce Capacity and yet they did the same principle is here when I came to town 40 years ago. I Used to see the signs on wallet for business 37. It was a highway It was designed to be a highway. We heard evidence that That we were it was the city. It was forced upon the city 70 years ago to make it into a highway or you you're you know because that was the way to get in and out of this city and it's not anymore and 2011, 15 years ago, we saw the massive improvement to what we call the bypass. This is what cities do anymore and states serving cities, they don't run highways through cities anymore, they bypass them. Why are we still trying to defend College and Walnut being a highway? It was designed to move cars like a highway, The state forced us to do that. And we've heard evidence that it's one of the most dangerous quarters in the city. And I do not take that lightly. I represented this area, this most of the streets south of 17th Street when I was on the council. In my last term on council, there were not one, not two, but three pedestrian deaths, one on third in Indiana, one and third in Washington, one and third and Walnut that were due to cars and they didn't necessarily, they weren't necessarily driving too fast, they were just so much bigger than the people that they hit. College and Walnut are going to need to be redesigned no matter which way traffic runs, whether it's one way or two way. I was agnostic about it when I first heard the proposals I was surprised when I heard the administration suggesting the two-way traffic would work. But after the presentation tonight, after the material here, I see why they did it. It does have a number of advantages. But I used to live downtown. I went to Ferris Market. around the corner. I remember it on Walnut Street. I had a business on 4th Street, and I hated cars zooming past my business. I wanted to slow down and see it. I wanted them to not run into the pedestrians who were walking into my business. I didn't think that three lanes of traffic speeding by, the speed wasn't good. The visibility was. The visibility would be better if it was two-way. People could see it coming from both directions. They say don't build your church for Easter Sunday. We shouldn't also not be building our parking lots for Black Friday, and we shouldn't be building our roads for ladder trucks. 10 times as many people die in car crashes as in fires. If we had really had concern about getting people to a hospital quicker, maybe we shouldn't have moved the hospital to the edge of town. But I know that slower traffic moves more cars. the formula for headway, the amount of space that someone has to keep between the car ahead of you in order to keep a safe distance, it increases geometrically with speed. And so you can carry more cars at 25 miles an hour on the same lane that you can at 35 miles an hour. It makes sense for any number of reasons, not just safety, to reduce traffic speeds and improvements favor the prepared. So if we have a shovel ready project. If we know what we want to do, we're more likely to be able to build it cost effectively than if we keep dithering about it. So I am certainly supportive of any plan to improve the city. I agree with the idea that engineering and design is by far the most effective way to reduce speeds. You can't possibly hire enough police. to enforce everything the way people think it should be done, who have people who have spoken about it tonight. I would, however, like more information on costs. Like I estimated just the rough cost of replacing sidewalks, updating or improving. I mean, I know how much time we spent grieving over our inability to fund all the sidewalks demand that there is in the city. So I know that it's not cheap just to do basic replacement of something as it is. I don't think that this is going to be that much more expensive than just the normal course of maintenance over the next 20 years. If we're going to maintain and change things, if we're going to update our infrastructure, let's redesign it so that it's better. I mean, we already do this with utility programs. We change the design of streets. When we know there's a utility project about to happen But that design has to be made before the utilities needs to to update the pipe underneath So rounded to the nearest million dollars. I'd like some estimates on what it would cost You know like what the different where the costs came from They may already be in the tool report and I missed it but I think it would be instructive not only for that, but to give us a sense of how much other costs we incurred collectively, maybe with the state and federal dollars, for projects like East 3rd Street, East Mall. How much did it cost to change? How much did the bypass cost to expand? How much did South Walnut cost back when it was updated, the couple blocks of South Walnut south of 3rd Street? Anything to give us a ballpark sense of what this costs. So while I'm inclined to Give this a positive recommendation. I would really rather continue it to our December 4th meeting, but that's my personal opinion and I Welcome other people's opinions Just to get that data at least Mr. Binder Thanks, I first of all, I want to thank all the members of the public who came here tonight to comment. And I do want to acknowledge that we've heard a lot of comments against this project in general. That said, I think the bottom line for me is that you weigh that against all of the data and analyses presented by staff tonight. And it's pretty convincing to me. I think staff has approached it from a lot of different angles. safety, cost, feasibility, impact on local businesses and so forth. And I've also heard people say, well, why are we still talking about this after seven, eight, nine years of talking about it? Well, because it's a big project and I think it does deserve a lot of scrutiny that we are giving it and it does deserve a lot of debate and consideration and examination of lots of different alternatives which I think we've all heard lots of variations of at this point. Anyway, so when you look at other big comparable public works projects like this, changes to the character of downtowns, you often find the public being against it. The public is against congestion pricing in any city that proposes it. before it's implemented. And then after it's implemented, you always find that in retrospect, people change their opinion and having seen the positive effects that it brings, it turns into something that enjoys a majority public support. Same for tearing down highways. I grew up in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and the mayor in the 1990s, John Norquist, tore down an urban freeway. And there was a lot of public voicing against doing that. And then after it was removed, it wasn't long. Just a few years later, people could scarcely believe that it had been there in the first place. And I anticipate that, assuming some version of this college walnut redesign goes through eventually, people will also look back at it in that same way, too. They will scarcely believe that there were three lanes of traffic each direction running through downtown, like the highway. So I'm broadly in favor of this project. Like some other, I think, commissioners here, I'm not terribly in favor or against one variant of the proposal or another, two-way or one-way, for example. But I do look at these versions of the proposal, and I see why it is necessary to try to improve safety from an engineering standpoint. There are just too many examples out there of other cities that have accomplished dramatic increases in road safety for everybody through good design. And I do believe that's possible here too. So thank you. Point out the administration is proposing a particular proposal. This proposes a two way change. So if members want to propose a one way change, they should maybe say that, indicate that in their I mean, in that case, I think I should clarify that given that that's what is being proposed, I am in favor. All right. Further comments? To my left, Mr. Stosberg. Yes. I come here from what was the Bicycle, Pedestrian Safety Commission. I had a particular focus on crash analysis, particularly looking at local crashes and how to prevent them. Staff presenting is consistent with what I've learned and trends nationally. Drivers drive the design speed, not the sign speed. This redesigning the roadway is an effective way to improve the overall safety. A lot of those hearings we had here and at the Bike Pet Commission, people ask, what about emergency vehicles? That's been asked a lot and the staff works with the, parts of the city to make sure our designs work for them. They presented here a travel lane. They said it works for the emergency vehicles. This is going to be better for move-in day. It's going to be better for parents day, less people turning the wrong way on one-way streets. We asked about game day. They're designing it for what it should be. This is not a Black Friday parking lot situation where it's going to be empty the most of the year. They've looked at check the box looking at economic impact and comparable cities. Not only do they look for cities like comparable cities, but nationally, this is the trend. Cities are converting one ways to two ways and they're keeping them. They're finding them successful economically and for safety. In terms of the volume, it's not really a reduction in capacity as they explain. It's a way overbuilt street that gives us a lot of possibility to design it better and still meet our capacity needs. So that's going to work for us. And there are other cities who are practicing this vision zero goal and having success. And so we're following the footsteps of other places who've had success with these kinds of changes. And I think they can be successful here too. This is also our commission is one step in a long process. There's the planning commission. There's the city council. Even that only puts it in the transportation plan. I have looked at many things in the transportation plan which never get implemented before the plan gets rewritten. It does unlock some ability to start on some incremental improvements which I think are going to be good in any case and just help us do long-term planning. For those reasons and for some others given here, I'm in line to move this forward with a positive recommendation for the two-way design. Thank you. Further comment? I would honestly say that I think I'm lacking information at this stage to be inclined to choose one option over another, but I feel like if we need to move it forward, do we have to choose the design we're moving with right now or we're just discussing whether we can move the further analysis and design. It's in a way question and there will be comment. It's a nine member commission. It requires five affirmative votes for any motion. So, uh, If a motion does not get five votes, then we have to make another motion that would. It might be positive, it might be negative, it might be no, it might wind up, we might punt if we don't have enough votes. So it would take five out of seven votes tonight to advance any kind of recommendation. Everyone should take that into their consideration as they consider how to vote. I would say that I do have open questions. And in general, I'm in support on improving that street. And I'm very much in improving the downtown, workability of it, and safety of it. So I feel like I would like to see, I mean, questions around budget were very interesting. I feel like we can dig more into that. And I would love to see other options on how other improvements can be done and compare them. I'm liking that information right now. So I'm in support of moving these improvements further. I don't have a strong opinion about one option over another right now. OK, any other thoughts about a motion? I'm not the one who's going to make a motion, so someone else has to decide which way they want to go. Mr. Flaherty. I'll just know. It sounds like we have some folks who are aligned and ready to make a positive recommendation tonight, other folks who are generally aligned, feel like they want more information or more time. I don't have any qualms with waiting for that additional information and waiting additional time for that for folks who want it. But we should just be pretty clear, I think, about what is being asked, if that's the case. Even if that's by way of email follow-up or whatever it is for those commissioners who want something specific, I would just want to make sure that we're setting ourselves up to be prepared for our December 4th meeting. I'm starting to hear an inclination towards a continue so as to satisfy. I and one other member have said we'd like more information. Perhaps if we are going to continue, we should state now what specific things we'd like while it's fresh in our minds. Is there any information that members would like to ask of staff besides what has already been asked of staff? and we can recapitulate it before we're done. Mr. Drew. I'm personally interested in the first option. And I think what can be done if we don't go with two ways, but we keep the first option, which is not recommended. So keep things as they are, sounds like. That's the first option we have, option A. No, no. Right now, we are considering whether to adopt the two-way plan. And our potential votes are positive recommendation, negative no. Only for this option, right? Recommendation. I would say the information I am lacking right now, the public mentioned a couple of times that there are some other ways on how safety can be improved. So I think the information I am lacking right now is what else can be done? And how much will it cost in comparison to what was proposed? OK. Anyone else have anything to add here before we entertain a motion about What information, if any, you'd like to see should a continue motion carry? Here's your chance. On to my right. Mr. Flaherty. I guess I'm a little confused by the most recent comments. For the one-way design concept, for instance, as proposed, I think I don't Correct me if I'm wrong. I don't think the packet included PDFs of design did it, and I missed them. No, it originally did not. I have updated it since commissioners were asking about it. But originally, before the meeting, it did not. I just wanted to make it available in case anyone was here. Yeah, got it. So those are things that I think are worth looking at. But then I think if we're talking about, if there's a majority of commissioners who support advancing one of the two concept designs for transportation plan amendment, I feel like that might be different than what I was just hearing, which is the idea that is there something other than either of those two concepts that would maybe cost less and improve safety? And I'm not sure that's something that we're in a great position to have staff come up with. Just to be clear, and I know this is not clear and I'm sorry about it, staff is recommending that College and Walnut be redesigned to be two-way. If there are members who wish to recommend a one-way redesign, that's not on the table. If there are members who want to not recommend either redesign, they should reject anything that comes before us. But we don't have the option of, we can say in our comments, I would rather see the one-way design. But what you're voting on tonight Whether or not to forward a recommendation a positive recommendation of a two-way design We're talking about the two-way design tonight because that's what they advanced. All right So I just want to make sure everyone understands what we're voting on. Do I have that right staff? You have most of that correct we're going to rewrite these bylaws man because We're struggling Well, I don't think the bylaw issue I think you have the bylaws correct. Okay. The actual recommendation and proposal on the table is that there is an adoption of the proposed amendments to the transportation plan and the corridor study which makes a recommendation to two way and has the two way design. So you're mostly correct. But I just want to know. Okay. Okay. That's even finer slice than I would have done it. So talking about plans and it's so much of the current discussion is about a plan concept that anything any one component of that would still come back to Transportation Commission. So the reason that perhaps alternatives haven't been provided is because that's not sort of the that's outside the scope of what's being asked at this juncture. But effectively what staff has said and in the press release for this said that they were recommending the two-way scheme. That would go into the plan. Am I wrong about that? That is the general recommendation. Yeah, I guess if I could clarify, please, let's suppose that a commissioner would like to instead make a they instead favor the one way design concept and those safety improvements and they want to indicate that. What would be the optimal way to do that? Would it be to reject the staff recommendation with proposed alternative findings that say make a case for why the one-way alternative better meets city code and city goals? Something different, that's what I'm trying to clarify and making sure that if that's not a path that someone is theoretically interested in pursuing, that, yeah. Yes, you could certainly do that. You could adopt completely different findings and you could even so the first step would be to reject this finding and forward it with a negative recommendation and then like you said include what your preff preferred alternative was and then after that staff could look at it bring it back or we could just bring that forward to the Planning Commission so that they can note it they have the ability to edit this document since it's essentially their document as well as council so okay okay thank you Now, after all that belaboring, is there anyone who wants to make a motion? And if so, which motion? If no one has a motion, let's move to continue. I'll make the straightforward motion that the Transportation Commission forward the proposed amendment to the transportation plan with a positive recommendation to the planned commission. That's needs a second. Second. We have a motion and a second. Is there any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, we'll ask the secretary to call a roll call vote on the motion to recommend with a positive to forward it to the plan commission with a positive recommendation. TCR 2622. Copic? No. Sandifer? No. Binder? Yes. Volin? Abstain. Drumme? It's not here. Thank you. Flaherty? Yes. Scudersko? Abstain. Stasberg? Yes. That's all. So that's a three yes. Two no, two abstentions. Correct. All right. Is there another motion? Make a motion to continue. To which meeting? Our next meeting? December 7th. December 7th. We need a second for that motion to continue. Second. We have a motion and a second. Is there any discussion on the motion? Um, yeah, I just encourage again folks to make sure that they're being quite clear and specific and the questions they're asking and follow up with staff. And if you, um, on a few instances, we have either rejected staff findings or come with alternatives, um, to the extent that folks can prepare those in advance to be circulated or come with, you know, a draft that would really be helpful if, if they propose, um, you know, something other than, uh, the proposed findings from staff. Thanks. All right. Any other comments before we go to a vote? I just staff is in favor of that. We just would like some clarifying ground rules because we have members of the public here and I want to respect their time. So we have a very busy December agenda. We would likely ask that the commission put this towards the end because it's such a big topic. But then we also want to clarify public speaking rules. We've opened public Thank you. And now have closed it. So we just want to clarify what the commission is thinking, um, for public comment in the next meeting. I can only speak for myself when I say that, uh, I asked for more information. Um, I think of it as sort of an extension of this process that we've already heard public comment and that we're just trying to get the information that we needed to make a decent decision. Um, So I'm fine with compressing the amount of time we spend on this to limit it. I mean, to limit the amount of time we spend it at the next meeting, not to exceed half an hour, not to exceed an hour, whatever it takes, because we've already deliberated on it tonight. But I, for one, share Ms. Sugruchko's concern about ballpark figures of costs. I want to get a sense, as I said, of how this figure compares to Other typical projects we've done. It's the kind of information that the Commission has wanted in general, but it's particularly relevant for for this But I'm happy to work with staff to limit the agenda for the next meeting so that we don't We don't need a full presentation again. This does not require a second reading That's totally fine. I would just ask that the proposed amendment include an understanding of what your understanding of public comment in the next meeting would be just so everyone's clear. That's it. That's thank you. Well, I don't remember exactly how we defined continuation in bylaws, but generally when you continue an item like it's I don't know if this is where I'm I'm at a loss. I could ask that the maker of the motion change the motion to say that it will be limited to a certain period of time or limited to a second round of questions. I don't know how to structure this. Staff is open to whatever. We just want to make sure it's clear for members of the public. Which is just to say there's not a right answer to that, that what you've just proposed is a perfectly acceptable way to phrase the amendment. So far, the only concerns that have been heard, two of us have said, we'd like to see more financial information. If there were a panoply of topics that people wanted to ask questions about, we might need to reopen it. But I think we're asking for one piece of information. So I think we could limit the time and the structure of this discussion at the next meeting to just getting the question answered and entertaining a motion. Mr. Coppock. Could we get construction costs today's dollars? So yeah, so I've been seeping with regret about how I answered that question earlier, because actually, there's a better answer. It's that all of our construction costs are actually set by NDOT, and NDOT publishes a schedule of construction costs for all items that are related to transportation construction on their website. And it changes every year. So there's already a spreadsheet with thousands of little line items for individual things that you could reference for this particular answer. So the answer, in short, is yes, we can absolutely provide you with this information. But if what you're asking for is a very contextualized reading of that information in this plan, I would have to defer to Ryan Robley. Mr. Stossberg. Just a point of clarification with the staff. What we're proposing in any case is an amendment to the transportation plan. I've read versions of it. It's not like a spreadsheet with a bunch of prices on the right-hand side. We're talking about a project which might be done incrementally over 10 or 20 years, over many contracts, over which time there will be new inflations and wars and cyber attacks and other things that will change prices. We're not approving any version of a contract with price tags. We are approving the idea of something that goes in a plan. The plan has had things like, we'd like a bike path to Lake Lemon, but we don't have a price tag for that. And we might never do it. We might. So I just want to clarify that we're not approving a price tag on anything. We're approving the aspiration of something that goes in the long-term plan. Is that correct? That's exactly correct. Any other comments on this? Mr. Binder? One comment, one question. To Commissioner Stosberg's inquiry about sort of, could we have more of an itemized, I think, list of how that cost breaks down. There is a document attached, although I think maybe it was added by staff after the fact. So I think everybody would be well served to look at that. It's number 11 on the packet. And the title is Opinion of Probable Cost for the two-way design. That's the first thing I would say. And then the second, I guess, is more of a question, which is that ... I mean, I'm not sure how to really interpret the idea that we should be considering this without regard to cost and thinking of it solely in terms of whether it's a good idea just from an aspirational standpoint. Because I think if that were true, then the cost should not have been introduced into this discussion in the first place. But given that it has, and also given that this is the real world and things cost money. I mean, of course cost is a consideration. So I guess I'm having trouble squaring in my head the idea that we would consider this completely separate from the idea of how much it would cost. I think in my mind it is kind of an inseparable part of the consideration is in fact ballpark how much it would cost. So that's, am I totally off base here? Yeah. So for me, anyway, I mean, I think even with the cost, I'm still in favor of this proposal, but I'm just trying to understand whether or not we are in fact considering cost as part of the proposal. Any other comments on this before I say something? Look, this has been promoted by the city with a cost estimate. It's a headline maker, 103 to 109 million dollars. It's entirely reasonable to ask where that cost came from, and it's just as reasonable to ask, well, how does that compare to what we normally spend money on? There's no way to separate this estimate from the question, even if we're just making it part of the plan, because all that people are gonna think about who don't look at this too closely is, oh, the city is going to spend another $110 million. They just said they're going to. This is an ongoing mission of the commission to try to make it clearer how transportation works, and the costs are an essential part of it. And just to know that this document has appeared on the agenda during the meeting, I mean, there wasn't time to look at it. I'm looking at it now. I have interest, but I mean, this is no way to to educate. If education is one of the ways that we we manage safety on the roads, along with engineering and enforcement, we have to do a better job of educating. So I still say I need to know comparable projects in Bloomington, how much did it cost to change East 3rd Street? How much did South Walnut cost back when it was done? Something that Bloomingtonians can say, compare to and say, this is either really unusual compared to what we've done before, or it's entirely in keeping with what we've done before, that it's only a marginal change, we don't have that answer now. That's what I'm looking for for December 7th. I hope that makes a difference to everyone. Mr. Flaherty. Yeah, this is interesting. I think it's fine to consider costs. I don't think it's our explicit purview to do so. Code specifies what it is we are charged with finding. It's an analysis and a framework that looks at safety, city goals, public engagement and sustainability. So that's what the structure of the findings is. If people want to base their vote, you know, Say all those findings notwithstanding. I think this is too much money So I'm voting no then they can say that and I would encourage them to say that if that is indeed the rationale But I don't think it's central. I you know, I'm with you. I find I find inch I would find it interesting in 2026 or 2020 $30 or whatever, you know what some of these other changes, you know have cost the city I gave a figure of 40 million for 2026 dollars for the parking garages, right? So two parking garages we built. That's a little less than half of what's proposed here. So yeah, those things are helpful, I think, for reference and frame. But ultimately, I don't think that's really what we are charged with. That's a broader fiscal policy question, which is why the city council will consider and vote on this eventually, as well as the role of the mayor and the city executive about what to prioritize when Including you know on a contingent basis based on whether we can leverage federal funding, right? So These things are good to know but again, it is a little bit ancillary for at least for this body, you know per se code Any other comments mr. Binder Just to try to kind of pull the thread through and maybe sum up some of the the concerns I'm hearing here so one is I do want to say I appreciate the staff was I think trying to respond to the commission's request for more information by appending some additional documents to the packet. But I think knowing that there are now some other documents, I think it's perfectly appropriate to continue this to the next meeting, given that nobody's had time to really look at those documents beforehand. So that's, I guess, one thing I would say. And then, well, yeah, I'll just stop there. Hopefully some pretty broad agreement that we can continue this to the next meeting. All right. I mean, I do think that cost is germane because if we hear an objection, one objection I've heard tonight is to what extent do we balance safety and expense? OK. And I'm not saying that the commission's job, I mean, Uh, we shall, uh, we're trying to eliminate fatalities. We're trying to promote sustainable transportation. Uh, sustainable includes cost, all right? So it's not unreasonable to say, well, if it's an inordinate cost, it's not worth making the change. Uh, and again, we don't have to, I mean, again, to the nearest million dollars. It doesn't have to be, uh, uh, down to the penny, uh, but, It's a reasonable set of questions to ask, and especially with data coming in even during the meeting, we should take a little time to do it. I have to say I'm inclined to the two-way solution as well. I think people heard that in my comments, but I think this information is as important to the commission's mission as a decision right now. I would just say that I'm in support of the information you requested. I'm also interested in that, and I feel it's not central to making this decision, but it's an important comparison to make. If there's no other comments, Mr. Binder. I will say actually one other thing. This is, I think, more for the sake of staff to try to help do some fact-finding for next time, which is that there has been a lot of discussion of or inference that this kind of project being a very large one would necessarily happen over many years and happen in many phases. And I guess I would be curious to see just even some hypotheticals of what that would actually kind of be like, how you might actually phase something like this. given that, I mean, short of taking out a $100 million bond, we're probably not gonna be spending that money all in one single go, that this would be something, this would be a change that happens over many years. So maybe having kind of a little bit more of a clear understanding of how this type of design could be phased, because I think there are probably some straightforward answers to that question, and then maybe others, particularly when it comes to making the big changes, like switching traffic directions, that's hard to break down into phases, I think. So that's maybe something that would be helpful for staff to try to collate for the commission for any discussion next time. I agree. I would love to see it too. If staff's looking for specific projects and we're talking about a 20-year timeline, I can go back 20 years and I'm gonna say East 3rd Street, east of the mall, the bypass, South Walnut Street project, and the West 3rd Street project, west from Patterson, the redesign of 3rd, 5th Adams, West 3rd Street. Those are all, I mean, just the roughest possible figures to give people a sense of how many miles were constructed, about how much it cost over time, Any information you can provide us will be specific things we could compare to this. Yeah, sorry. Step has no concern. We're happy to provide all that we can come up with numbers for everything. We were just concerned about the public comment period because I don't want to disrupt the public's understanding of if they'll be allowed to speak because they're going to have to probably wait to the end of a long meeting. So that's okay. Very good. With that, let's if everyone's ready for a vote on the motion to continue. Without objection, the secretary will call the roll. The motion to continue to December 7th, TCR 2622. Yes. Binder? Yes. Bollin? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Skourishko? Yes. Stosberg? Yes. Coppock? Yes. The motion to continue carries 7-0. That concludes our business for the evening. If there's no other comments, this meeting is adjourned.