WEBVTT

00:00:00.354 --> 00:00:11.744
- I'm gonna call to order this meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals for Thursday. I have the wrong one.

00:00:11.744 --> 00:00:22.697
- I have July 23rd. That's not gonna work, is it? Joe, will you make sure your mic is on? Yeah, it'll

00:00:22.697 --> 00:00:28.830
- be very fast. Is it? Okay. I opened the wrong document.

00:00:38.338 --> 00:00:48.890
- Try it again. All right. I call to order this board of zoning appeals meeting for Thursday,

00:00:48.890 --> 00:01:00.818
- October 22nd. Can we have a roll call, please? Around. Yes, Fernandez. Here, Casenco here, Throckmorton

00:01:00.818 --> 00:01:08.158
- here. Let me see. Did we distribute minutes? Just to remind me.

00:01:08.546 --> 00:01:28.913
- Any amendments to have a motion to have a second second. Let's call that Fernandez. Yes. Casenco. Yes.

00:01:28.913 --> 00:01:38.206
- Throckmorton. Yes. Burrell. Yes. That was for.

00:01:38.562 --> 00:01:47.010
- Last month we had another one attached. I believe it was for August. Correct. So note that that was

00:01:47.010 --> 00:01:55.880
- for September 24th the last meeting. Do we have a motion to approve August 27th motion to approve August

00:01:55.880 --> 00:02:03.230
- 27th minutes. Call it. Cosine go. Yes. Rock Morton. Yes. Burrell. Yes. Fernandez. Yes.

00:02:04.450 --> 00:02:13.136
- I see on the current agenda, there's no petitions continue correct. That hasn't changed. Thank you.

00:02:13.136 --> 00:02:21.995
- We have none on the expedited petition. Very good. We have today a hearing officer case. We will hear

00:02:21.995 --> 00:02:31.116
- that first. That's ZR 2026090039. Then we will have the following petition, which will be ZR 2026090043.

00:02:31.116 --> 00:02:33.374
- And with that, I'll go to

00:02:33.634 --> 00:02:40.877
- The first who's going to do that one. That's going to be. So that's Joe. So the hearing officer case

00:02:40.877 --> 00:02:48.264
- was just simply listed in case the hearing officer continued that from the hearing that was yesterday.

00:02:48.264 --> 00:02:55.579
- But they did approve it. So it's not on the BZA's agenda tonight. So the only case that is on the BZA

00:02:55.579 --> 00:03:03.038
- agenda tonight is a petition for beacon. Okay. 12 0 5 or 12 0 1 West 3rd Street. Okay. So that so that.

00:03:03.234 --> 00:03:09.651
- Hearing officer case that was just put there in case. Yeah. Yes, okay All right, so we'll go on to the

00:03:09.651 --> 00:03:16.131
- only petition tonight we have which is the our 2026 oh nine zero zero four three a request at 1201 West

00:03:16.131 --> 00:03:22.486
- 3rd Street for approval of a phasing plan for the conditional use approved granted under case cu 2423

00:03:22.486 --> 00:03:28.965
- for the use supportive housing large in the mixed-use medium scale zoning district by dawn great beacon

00:03:28.965 --> 00:03:32.766
- ink gratis Development and that's you Eric can have a report

00:03:32.962 --> 00:03:41.058
- Yep. Thank you very much. As mentioned this is a request for a phasing plan for conditional use that

00:03:41.058 --> 00:03:47.390
- the board granted in 2023 for beacon for a property at 1201 West Third Street.

00:03:47.458 --> 00:03:53.550
- At the time that that petition came forward, the petitioner expected that this would be constructed

00:03:53.550 --> 00:03:59.764
- in just one phase for the entirety of the project. As they've moved forward, they've encountered some

00:03:59.764 --> 00:04:06.039
- challenges with securing funding for the entire project as was initially presented. And so they've had

00:04:06.039 --> 00:04:12.192
- to scale back a little bit of what is being proposed. So instead, they are coming forward tonight to

00:04:12.192 --> 00:04:16.030
- request a phasing plan for approximately half of the building.

00:04:16.162 --> 00:04:23.142
- So real quickly this is on the near west side of town off of West 3rd Street The site did previously

00:04:23.142 --> 00:04:30.330
- contain two office warehouse buildings and parking area Those were approved to be removed with the site

00:04:30.330 --> 00:04:37.655
- plan that was approved in 2023 to allow for beacon to develop the site with a 45,000 square foot building

00:04:37.655 --> 00:04:45.534
- that would contain a mix of supportive housing some community service components as well as some living units and

00:04:45.794 --> 00:04:51.565
- and a parking area So as I mentioned the petitioner has encountered some challenges with that funding

00:04:51.565 --> 00:04:57.224
- and so they are coming forward tonight to request a phasing plan To allow for half of that building

00:04:57.224 --> 00:05:03.052
- to be constructed to approximately 20,000 square foot Which is the west side of the building? It would

00:05:03.052 --> 00:05:08.823
- be a two-story building And so they would construct approximately half of the parking spaces that are

00:05:08.823 --> 00:05:14.142
- on the site the remainder of the building of the other parking areas would be constructed and

00:05:14.786 --> 00:05:22.051
- If funding is obtained at a future time all of the stormwater improvements would be installed with Phase

00:05:22.051 --> 00:05:29.108
- 1 the entrance and drive from 3rd Street would be installed with Phase 1 and then as I mentioned with

00:05:29.108 --> 00:05:34.782
- Phase 2 at the later time that would be constructed as funding becomes available.

00:05:34.882 --> 00:05:40.764
- They've submitted revised renderings showing how the building itself would be constructed in that phasing

00:05:40.764 --> 00:05:46.590
- component so you can see here just the elevation that would be shown from the north side. As I mentioned

00:05:46.590 --> 00:05:52.638
- the remainder of the building would be constructed with that additional funding as that has become available

00:05:52.638 --> 00:05:53.470
- in the future.

00:05:53.538 --> 00:06:01.497
- Since it's a little bit unknown from the petitioners perspective of when that funding might be available

00:06:01.497 --> 00:06:09.229
- we did put a timeline on the initiation of phase two that if it has not initiated by January 1st 2029

00:06:09.229 --> 00:06:17.037
- That a new conditional approval would be required So we are recommending approval of this phasing plan

00:06:17.037 --> 00:06:18.174
- with just that

00:06:18.274 --> 00:06:24.087
- One condition approval that I mentioned and I'm happy to answer any questions once the petitioners had

00:06:24.087 --> 00:06:29.900
- a chance to speak. Thank you Eric. Is the petitioner here like to address Don please come forward just

00:06:29.900 --> 00:06:35.770
- sign you don't have to sign in right. Just state your first and last name. Don Gray. Do you affirm that

00:06:35.770 --> 00:06:41.471
- the testimony you're about to give us the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth. I do. You

00:06:41.471 --> 00:06:42.430
- have 20 minutes.

00:06:44.898 --> 00:06:52.336
- I'd like to introduce myself. I'm Dawn Gray with Spring Point Architects. We are the architects for

00:06:52.336 --> 00:06:59.924
- this project and have been working with Beacon Inc. over the last few years. Also here is Katie Stein

00:06:59.924 --> 00:07:07.436
- our site civil engineer and members of the board from Beacon Inc. I would like to thank the planning

00:07:07.436 --> 00:07:11.230
- department and Eric for his thorough presentation.

00:07:11.842 --> 00:07:20.396
- And we'd also like to thank the members of the BZA for your consideration of this petition. We are excited

00:07:20.396 --> 00:07:28.470
- to see this project moving forward in this phase manner but let you know that phase one construction

00:07:28.470 --> 00:07:36.464
- drawings and documents are underway and we are optimistic that construction will begin early twenty

00:07:36.464 --> 00:07:39.262
- twenty seven whether dependent but

00:07:39.458 --> 00:07:46.821
- We're here to answer questions that you might have, and we appreciate your consideration. Thank you.

00:07:46.821 --> 00:07:54.549
- Thank you, Dawn. We'll back to the board. Any questions or comments for the city staff or the petitioner?

00:07:54.549 --> 00:08:01.985
- I mean, I'll start off by saying to remind, I don't know, John, you weren't, I think, on with us when

00:08:01.985 --> 00:08:05.630
- we did this, but I think you were, Leslie, right?

00:08:06.338 --> 00:08:12.655
- You were flopping it, but we so we heard this case was it last year the year before 24 23 23 so it's

00:08:12.655 --> 00:08:19.034
- been a while. So this was an extensive review on granting number of what the variance conditional use

00:08:19.034 --> 00:08:25.288
- I think the time is a conditional use approval for the use itself and then the variance was granted

00:08:25.288 --> 00:08:31.667
- for work in the floodplain and riparian buffer to remove a retaining wall and I think the remnants of

00:08:31.667 --> 00:08:33.918
- a former structure of some sort and

00:08:34.562 --> 00:08:39.967
- So the overall plan is something that BZA, and was that unanimous, I believe? I don't recall the vote,

00:08:39.967 --> 00:08:45.267
- but I believe that may have been true. Yeah, I think it was unanimous, but that can be looked up for

00:08:45.267 --> 00:08:50.777
- the record. But the reason I bring that up is we've already dealt with those issues. So what we're being

00:08:50.777 --> 00:08:55.710
- asked to do tonight is just let them divvy that up and do it over a course of time in phases.

00:08:55.810 --> 00:09:02.565
- So that's what's in front of us and the issue is that we will put a kind of a stop-hold So to speak

00:09:02.565 --> 00:09:09.321
- on doing it before such and such a time before having to come back and ask for a further Okay, so I

00:09:09.321 --> 00:09:16.211
- just wanted to get that on the record or anyone that's here Do we know how much they need to raise to

00:09:16.211 --> 00:09:17.630
- initiate phase two I

00:09:23.874 --> 00:09:32.361
- I'm just wondering about the date and if the date is appropriate. So phase one is estimated at around

00:09:32.361 --> 00:09:41.015
- eight million dollars and that does include a lot of the site development for phase two. The full scope

00:09:41.015 --> 00:09:49.502
- of phase two has not yet been identified fully. So we are kind of working at it from both directions.

00:09:49.502 --> 00:09:51.166
- So I know they are.

00:09:51.810 --> 00:10:01.135
- Looking at further grants and additional funding. I don't have a specific time frame for that Do you

00:10:01.135 --> 00:10:10.368
- feel that the date for? 2029 is appropriate More time would be appreciated. I am sure but You know,

00:10:10.368 --> 00:10:19.694
- I think it was beacons it was beacons Sad or they stated that that would be workable for them. Okay.

00:10:19.694 --> 00:10:20.894
- Thank you. I

00:10:24.002 --> 00:10:29.976
- Did you say yes? Okay. I do. I did just want to pull that up there. It wasn't listed in the packet you

00:10:29.976 --> 00:10:35.835
- gave us about what the vote was. That's what I was looking for. But it does say that the conditional

00:10:35.835 --> 00:10:41.867
- use approval was limited to a facility with a 50 bed overnight shelter, 20 dwelling units and five work

00:10:41.867 --> 00:10:47.784
- to live units on site. And then overall design of billing is consistent with the submitted elevation.

00:10:47.784 --> 00:10:51.902
- So I just, again, wanted to get that. Go ahead, John. Yeah, I guess I,

00:10:52.770 --> 00:11:00.284
- I don't know how this fits into they can to the phasing but you know the concept that the community

00:11:00.284 --> 00:11:07.873
- got behind and I wasn't here so I assume the neighborhood had a lot of input on this but the overall

00:11:07.873 --> 00:11:15.838
- concept is not just the overnight shelters but the integration of services etc. Are any of those services

00:11:15.838 --> 00:11:17.566
- included in phase one.

00:11:20.770 --> 00:11:30.043
- Phase one is the permanent supportive housing. So that's the apartment component, the multifamily part

00:11:30.043 --> 00:11:39.046
- apartment component. Um, uh, and there will be case management, um, offices and community space for

00:11:39.046 --> 00:11:48.319
- phase one, the emergency shelter and the day center beacons shalom function will be part of phase two.

00:11:48.319 --> 00:11:50.750
- So is there overnight? Um,

00:11:51.746 --> 00:11:59.455
- If I remember the model I should remember this better. But so what is the overnight. So there are there

00:11:59.455 --> 00:12:06.867
- are there's what I think five units that were for people who are going to be staying there but have

00:12:06.867 --> 00:12:14.279
- kind of a work requirement to provide overnight kind of management and all the kinds of those kinds

00:12:14.279 --> 00:12:18.430
- of issues. Yes. So there will be to what we're kind of.

00:12:18.626 --> 00:12:27.152
- Termin has lived to work units and that is for People to provide work in lieu of rent so there will

00:12:27.152 --> 00:12:35.848
- be eyes there and a person there So that was limited to two units instead of the five They are hoping

00:12:35.848 --> 00:12:44.630
- to add additional units once the other phase two comes online But as far as the spaces that were there

00:12:44.630 --> 00:12:47.870
- for other kinds of services including

00:12:49.026 --> 00:12:57.310
- You know jobs for mental health Public safety none of that's included in phase one. That's correct Those

00:12:57.310 --> 00:13:05.436
- will still function as part of the Shalom Center and their friends place Locate at their friends place

00:13:05.436 --> 00:13:13.562
- or the locations In in the original packet just to follow up on that dawn in the original packet there

00:13:13.562 --> 00:13:17.822
- were two letters of support that went to the city and

00:13:17.986 --> 00:13:24.707
- But there was also a third that was a letter of support, but it was a letter of support that expressed

00:13:24.707 --> 00:13:31.427
- concern because of that very issue, John, which is how far are you away from services, things like the

00:13:31.427 --> 00:13:38.018
- bus line, et cetera. So that was a comment that was made by a member of the public. I'm just stating

00:13:38.018 --> 00:13:44.608
- that that was brought up as part of the original discussions that we had. And having those corrected

00:13:44.608 --> 00:13:46.174
- or fulfilled are ideal.

00:13:47.202 --> 00:13:55.596
- And I would just say it is beacons intent and mission to to build out phase two to fulfill the full

00:13:55.596 --> 00:14:04.243
- realization of that that overall project. Did we have a question about if they do the first or if they

00:14:04.243 --> 00:14:12.889
- do this phase is there a possibility to not do the further phases. Is that a question. You know I mean

00:14:12.889 --> 00:14:17.086
- I think a lot of the concerns people have is that

00:14:17.666 --> 00:14:27.029
- Are we creating a holistic solution here and improving the capacity to serve that population and mitigate

00:14:27.029 --> 00:14:35.862
- some of the other offsite stuff that's been happening on South Walnut. And if we're bifurcating the

00:14:35.862 --> 00:14:45.402
- project it seems like there's a big missing piece that helps address kind of the community the neighborhood

00:14:45.402 --> 00:14:46.462
- issues etc.

00:14:47.234 --> 00:14:59.408
- Exactly Yeah, I'm sorry say that were you on mic I'm sorry as after speaking with Deacon this week The

00:14:59.408 --> 00:15:11.463
- reason for the funding is they lost federal funding So it does sound like that there would be a major

00:15:11.463 --> 00:15:13.118
- concern about

00:15:13.922 --> 00:15:19.521
- about getting into unbilling part of it and then saying, oh, well, we can't raise any more funds. We're

00:15:19.521 --> 00:15:25.011
- just gonna leave it this way. And there's really no, there's really nothing that we can do after that

00:15:25.011 --> 00:15:30.018
- point. It's built. Um, but the services aren't there. So I understand that that's a concern,

00:15:30.018 --> 00:15:35.455
- but this Eric, does the city not have that same concern? Well, um, you know, obviously we can't make

00:15:35.455 --> 00:15:40.946
- somebody build a portion of a building that they can't afford. Um, you know, we can only approve what

00:15:40.946 --> 00:15:43.422
- they bring forward. Um, yeah, that's, that's,

00:15:43.618 --> 00:15:51.203
- kind of the reality for us. So even if they, let's say theoretically had all the funds, they could still

00:15:51.203 --> 00:15:58.789
- build one and then stop. Yep. Okay. All right. I just want to make sure people understand that. So thank

00:15:58.789 --> 00:16:06.013
- you for putting that on the record and making that clear for us. Any other questions? With that, we

00:16:06.013 --> 00:16:13.598
- can go to the public for comments. Anyone here that would like to speak to this petition? Anyone online?

00:16:13.986 --> 00:16:21.429
- Anyone online? If there is anybody online that would like to speak to this, please use the raise hand

00:16:21.429 --> 00:16:29.163
- function and we can recognize you. I'm not seeing anybody online. OK, so this is the only time for public

00:16:29.163 --> 00:16:36.533
- comment for this petition. So with that we can go back to the petitioner for any final comments that

00:16:36.533 --> 00:16:42.078
- you might have if you have any. Before going back to the board for emotion.

00:16:44.898 --> 00:16:51.390
- No further comments. Thank you. Thank you. All right, so it's back to the board further comments or

00:16:51.390 --> 00:16:57.881
- questions If not, we will entertain a motion. I Have a question for for us if you can come up State

00:16:57.881 --> 00:17:04.438
- your first and last name, please sure forest Gilmore Executive director of beacon. Do you affirm the

00:17:04.438 --> 00:17:11.838
- testimony? You're about to give us the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Yes, absolutely Thank you

00:17:12.226 --> 00:17:22.001
- We were talking before you arrived and the question that I had was 2029 too early And does beacon approve

00:17:22.001 --> 00:17:31.591
- of that date? That was the first question and the second question was What happens if phase two doesn't

00:17:31.591 --> 00:17:41.182
- happen? Is that is that a possibility and in this? Phasing situation that phase two may never happen So

00:17:42.082 --> 00:17:52.603
- So the so 2029 is the question about whether phase two can be completed by faced by this is initiated

00:17:52.603 --> 00:18:02.918
- by 2029 We have a four million dollar deficit so that's where we are for phase two We're working on

00:18:02.918 --> 00:18:10.654
- getting through all the processes needed for phase one before we dive into

00:18:10.850 --> 00:18:18.054
- Wholeheartedly into phase two and even get a sense of those costs because we really want to we have

00:18:18.054 --> 00:18:25.329
- a grant timeline That's gonna get phased that we need to complete phase one by X number of dates the

00:18:25.329 --> 00:18:33.037
- property and the building are Self-contained in phase one. So so what occurs in phase one is not dependent

00:18:33.037 --> 00:18:34.910
- on phase two occurring so

00:18:35.074 --> 00:18:44.317
- The housing and the and all of that is set up independently in terms of what it's capable of doing So

00:18:44.317 --> 00:18:54.286
- if the worst-case scenario were to occur that phase two were not completable, it would still be a functioning

00:18:54.286 --> 00:19:04.798
- successful housing property That said We're doing everything we can to ensure that phase two goes forward this is a

00:19:05.058 --> 00:19:15.442
- deeply mission-driven approach process for us. It's the future of our organization, and we will do everything

00:19:15.442 --> 00:19:25.166
- we can to ensure that it happens. I think to 2029 is potentially a reasonable date, but I'm not in any

00:19:25.166 --> 00:19:33.662
- way gonna put guarantees on anything because it's a substantial amount of money to raise.

00:19:34.178 --> 00:19:43.605
- We've raised approximately, I believe, around 14 million at this point in time or something, which is

00:19:43.605 --> 00:19:53.032
- pretty extraordinary. But another $4 million to raise is a lot of money. And so without firm, without

00:19:53.032 --> 00:20:03.198
- those being firm, it's hard for me to go absolutely 100%. I will say that we are absolutely 100% committed to

00:20:03.746 --> 00:20:11.677
- that accomplishment, and we believe that that will get there. But I can't guarantee anything, especially

00:20:11.677 --> 00:20:19.910
- in these times, which are quite unpredictable. So I don't know if that's sufficient to answer your question,

00:20:19.910 --> 00:20:27.614
- but that's the most honest answer I can give you is yes. But the world is mysterious and challenging,

00:20:27.614 --> 00:20:32.222
- and we don't always know what's going to happen. Absolutely.

00:20:34.114 --> 00:20:42.984
- Thanks for all you do. I know it's a very difficult gig Is there a plan to Like provide some kind of

00:20:42.984 --> 00:20:51.765
- transportation. I mean if you're having You know, the beauty of the plan is that integration of all

00:20:51.765 --> 00:20:59.230
- the different services this is a very different project if it's only the housing and

00:21:00.482 --> 00:21:09.437
- Yeah, so phase one is built Similarly to all of the other supportive housing projects in the city so

00:21:09.437 --> 00:21:18.836
- it won't have the advantage of that full design that we wanted and and hoped for but it's very consistent

00:21:18.836 --> 00:21:23.358
- with other supportive housing projects in terms of

00:21:23.490 --> 00:21:30.042
- There's community spaces and there's meeting spaces. There's case management office spaces there. There's

00:21:30.042 --> 00:21:36.533
- the property management there all the support that is traditionally associated with a supportive housing

00:21:36.533 --> 00:21:42.838
- program is there there's room for Visiting agencies to come and and visit there's community space all

00:21:42.838 --> 00:21:48.030
- those things are in the plan for phase one, so it's it's contained in of itself and

00:21:48.514 --> 00:21:55.691
- and There is public transportation nearby, but I don't think there's an active plan to say Pick people

00:21:55.691 --> 00:22:03.146
- up and bring them over to shalom or something like that to the day center at this time. Yeah and Generally

00:22:03.146 --> 00:22:10.253
- speaking our experience with supportive housing is that when people move into supportive housing They

00:22:10.253 --> 00:22:17.918
- stop using those daytime resources that we've that they rely on the resources in their housing so for example

00:22:18.434 --> 00:22:24.943
- Well a lot of our programs you a lot of our supportive housing residents You wouldn't even know that

00:22:24.943 --> 00:22:31.516
- there are apartments all over the city. And so they work closely with With the case managers that are

00:22:31.516 --> 00:22:38.153
- working with them but places like But our experience has been like with Kinzer flats and with Crawford

00:22:38.153 --> 00:22:44.790
- and other supportive housing properties that they work within their their complex and they travel when

00:22:44.790 --> 00:22:45.886
- they need to but

00:22:46.018 --> 00:22:53.514
- The support of services they need they get on site What was the thinking on? the order operation of

00:22:53.514 --> 00:23:01.535
- orders As opposed to phase one versus phase two. Yeah making that phase one It was almost entirely defined

00:23:01.535 --> 00:23:09.106
- by the the seven million dollar grant for the housing portion of the property so there's a there's a

00:23:09.106 --> 00:23:12.254
- deadline where we have to be leased up by

00:23:12.770 --> 00:23:19.937
- March 31st of 2028 or we lose that seven million dollars in funding So that's that's the core of the

00:23:19.937 --> 00:23:27.103
- time That's the reason we're phasing at all is to is to accommodate that that grant timing I'm sorry

00:23:27.103 --> 00:23:34.625
- to break ground by a certain date or no, it needs to be occupied by March 31st 2028 it needs to be leased

00:23:34.625 --> 00:23:37.534
- up is the term that they've given us and

00:23:37.858 --> 00:23:53.276
- which may not mean that people need to be in it, but it needs to be, everything needs to be passed and

00:23:53.276 --> 00:24:07.646
- we have leases in place. Any other questions? If not, entertain a motion. Make a motion for ZR.

00:24:07.746 --> 00:24:16.310
- twenty twenty six dash zero nine dash zero zero four three The motion is the board of zoning appeals

00:24:16.310 --> 00:24:25.043
- approve the proposed phasing plan with the following condition of approval Number one if phase two has

00:24:25.043 --> 00:24:33.776
- not been initiated by January 1st 2029 a new conditional use approval is required for phase two Motion

00:24:33.776 --> 00:24:36.574
- is second any further discussion

00:24:38.114 --> 00:24:49.801
- Call the question. Thorek Morton? Yes. Burrell? Yes. Fernandez? Yes. Cosinka? Yes. 4-0. The petition

00:24:49.801 --> 00:25:01.604
- passes. Thank you. Let's see. That was it, right? OK. You had a question last month, Leslie. Has that

00:25:01.604 --> 00:25:07.390
- been addressed? OK. You want to share it with us?

00:25:08.546 --> 00:25:16.589
- about the occupancy of our previous case get the address and The office looked into it and nobody is

00:25:16.589 --> 00:25:24.632
- residing there. It was just a sign for other people Thank you. Any other new business seeing none we

00:25:24.632 --> 00:25:26.782
- stand adjourned. Thank you
