I'll go ahead and call the order the border zoning appeals meeting for the state Thursday November 19th two thousand twenty six. And if I could please have a roll call. Burrell here. Fernandez here could sinko here. Throck Morton here. Smith. And then what we'll do is we'll just watch out for him if he joins just let us know please. We did have minutes I believe attached here. Let me just double check We have the October 22nd 2026 minutes to have a motion to approve a motion to approve the October 22nd 22nd minutes second Call the roll Burrell. Yes Fernandez. Yes Cosinco. Yes, Throckmorton. Yes The minutes are put into the record. Before we get to resolutions and communications, I just wanted to make a brief point for the minutes concerning board membership. We have two members whose term expires at the end of the year, which should be just over a month and a half away. And those are Flavia and John. And their terms are both set to expire on the 31st of December this year. So we just want to make this a point of the record so that we can have both of those both of those appointee or pointers aware of it so that we can make sure that we have a full board on January. Okay. And at the moment, Flavia is our vice president. So it would be nice to know what we're going to do on that, on that standpoint. All right, so that's in the record. Let's go ahead and look at what we're gonna do today. We do have one expedited petition. We don't have any that are continued. The expedited agenda item is ZR-2026-10-0044. And then we do have two regular petitions, ZR-2026-10-0045 and ZR-2026-10-0046. And what we will do here, do we have any other communications No, nothing from staff anything from the board before we get going. Okay, very good. Well with that then let's That we've got that Let's go to the expedited agenda items ZR 20 26 10 00 44 11 40 South Morton Street for a variance of Yes, thank you. So this is a request at 1140 South Morton Street from the New Hope for family shelters. They're here tonight to request a variance from setback standards for accessory structures in a planned unit development. So this property was developed in 2019. It's at the northwest corner of Patterson and Morton. It was developed for a variety of uses to provide housing and service needs for families that are in need. They constructed two buildings that are on the site. The property, as I mentioned, sits at the corner. There is also a section of right of way and street that extends from Madison on the northwest corner of the site. So as you can see in this exhibit, the property has a very unique shape, as well as has street frontages on three sides. which creates some challenges with the use on the site. The PUD, the Thompson PUD was silent on accessory structures, so that defaults to the Unified Development Ordinance requirements, which have a 35-foot setback requirement for accessory structures from the front. So the petitioner has constructed two accessory structures. There is a shed on the north side of the property and a gazebo kind of on the south side of the property. Both of those do require a variance to be located on a site with the right of way. There is also a utility easement that runs through the site that also creates a challenge that you can see that moves east and west. So due to the peculiarities of the site regarding the shape as well as the street frontage, there are challenges to constructing the accessory structures on the site without the granting of the variance. So the petitioner is requesting a variance from those setbacks to allow for those two structures, which you can see here again on this slide. So staff has evaluated this for the criteria that are stated in the staff report. As I mentioned, we did find the peculiarities that I've mentioned in regards to the lot configuration as well as road frontage. And we are recommending that the board adopt this petition with the one condition that is listed in staff's report. And I'm happy to answer any questions once the petitioner has had a chance to speak. Thank you, Eric. I have the petitioner. Do you affirm that the testimony you're about to give us the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth Okay, so you have 20 minutes total You don't have to use it all now if after we discuss it We can come back and give you the remainder of your time before we have any type of motion, right? Thank you Thank you all. Thank you for serving on this committee. Thanks to the staff for making time to address our variance request. Like I said, my name is Chase Tekington. I've been on staff here at New Hope for the last seven years, long enough to remember when the property we're talking about was a bare hill, used as overflow parking there on the corner on the B line. So today I just want to briefly show you how we've improved it, how granting this variance will relieve our practical needs, and I think actually serve to elevate the use of the lot. Three years ago, like I said, we constructed those buildings. I'm going to run through some of these slides quickly because Eric has done a good job with this exposition about the history of the lot, but I do want to say that New Hope's programming there addresses the needs of families who are experiencing homelessness or at risk of homelessness in two ways. We have an emergency overnight shelter for families with kids, and we meet those needs by serving the needs of hundreds of families who call us who might become homeless very soon and prevent their homelessness. The emergency shelter provides overnight shelter for all children who experience homelessness in our community. We don't let any kids sleep outside. We always address that. And parents and families move quickly through the shelter into a lease in their name. That's success for us. Statewide, 32% of people leave a shelter to a place to live, which is like 32% of people leaving a soup kitchen with soup, which is a bad statistic. In New Hope, that number is 86% of households move into a lease in their name. So we're really proud of that and the work that we're able to do leveraging these facilities. That's not possible without the Early Learning Center. Most of the families we serve are young themselves. Their kids are birth to five, which means child care is very difficult to access, which affects people's ability to work. and attain and retain housing. So we put those two programs together to make sure that kids are always in shelter, that families are always together, they move out into stable housing, and that they can stay in stable housing because they have the childcare that they need to stay employed. So that's what we're doing with the property and with these facilities. When we grew into these buildings, we also grew our programming in some big ways. So we moved some of our storage of things like a lawnmower and a handful of other items out into that storage shed. We also expanded a lot of programming, like offering a summer camp and family-focused programming that we store a lot of items for in the shed that's out there. Like we mentioned, the many regulatory overlays on the triangular portion of the property make it so there's no other way to get shade onto the property there. precludes a lot of uses. So the gazebo is a way to offer programming there, to offer shade, to house lots of different things that we're doing with families, like having our preschoolers come up to our garden, like hosting events for families who are staying in the shelter, like summer activities and fun volunteer events where people get to come and just have an enjoyable time even though they're still in the context of shelter. So those two buildings underpin a lot of important programming that we're doing and there is not another way to, as you see with the colored map that we'll show at the end, there's another place to put a shed because we've already used the space pretty economically for parking, to accommodate the right of way like we were saying because the property Astonishingly has three fronts and we have a lot of drainage basins and things that we did to make sure that we were addressing all the engineering needs because it's quite a steep grade there. I did want to point out the, forgive me. Finally just with the last few points I want to make are that the UDO provides a three-part test to approve a variance so we just want to address those in that format. First it says that a variance should not interrupt the public health and safety or the morals of the community. I think that the shed and the gazebo pretty unambiguously do not violate that first part of the test. The second part of the test asks if the variance affects the adjacent properties in a substantially adverse manner. No, as evidenced by the letters of support that we've gotten from our neighborhood association and other neighbors. We have strong community support for these structures in particular and for our presence and our programming on that corner generally. Moreover, as we've already mentioned, the placement of the gazebo in the shed don't have a negative effect on people around us, substantial or even ethereal. And instead, I think they make our property more beautiful, more organized, and actually stand to improve the use and the value of the land in our neighbors' properties there. Third, Yes, the strict application of the step-back measurements impose practical difficulties, like we've already mentioned. We can't get shade on the property another way. The setbacks and utility overlays make it difficult to store equipment, items like gasoline that can't be stored indoors at any other place on the property, and that it's related to the particular layout of the land. It's not as if the land is a perfect square and it would work in any other normal lot. spot so in conclusion the variance we're requesting is Supported as part of the general welfare of the community does no harm to anyone around us relieves our practical difficulties that are peculiar to the property and I thank you guys for your attention and your consideration of this request Thank you. How much time does he have left? About 13 minutes 13. Okay. Thank you Thank you. We'll go back to the board you hear any questions of the petitioner or for the staff What about John? No, I'm good. I only have one question. You threw up that diagram, Eric, that showed temporary structure. It was the line drawing. It said temporary structures. And I was just curious as to aren't they really permanent structures? You're not going to take them down every winter or anything like that, are you? That's correct. They do not have foundations. They're on runners. So I think that in a technical sense, they are permanent structures. And then in a much realer sense, we could move them. That doesn't make any difference. I was just curious about why it was labeled that way, Eric. It was on one of the just plain black and white, the one that pointed them out with the big arrows. It just said temporary structures. Both of those maps were made by one of our. Temporary structures. Yeah, those were made by our dedicated volunteer, Kathy Weller. She's a retired landscape architect. And she did not label those with the UDO's meaning of temporary structure in mind. We're calling them accessory buildings, right? Yeah, we classify them as permanent structures. There's no separate allowances, temporary structures, other than with a temporary use, which this is not. So we treat them as permanent. And so that's why they have to meet the setback requirements. OK. Then the only other thing was, while we as a board really enjoy hearing about what the organizations do, we try to focus in on the things that you're talking about towards the end, which is why these are placed where they are and the need for that. And I just want to make sure that I completely understand. I don't think there's any issue with the city. But for the clarity of those who actually look at these meetings, the two positions you have, the gazebo and the storage shed, what we're hearing is that there's no other realistic option for those to be placed anywhere else in the building. And if you put that overhead back up, for example, you don't want to stick that shed back behind the family building, say, in the north-west corner, because it wouldn't be accessible easily to do things with it. Correct. And the gazebo is pretty much out on the street, so it is fairly close. Yes. But you're saying that there's no other place that's on the current property that would allow for that type of structure to be placed where it would be done so with enough safe space around it and things like that for those people to use it. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay. All right. Thank you. Um, if we have no other, if we have no other questions, it'll go back to, um, the public for comment. Is anyone here wishing to comment on this petition? And if not in chambers, anyone online? There's anybody online, please use to raise hand function and we could recognize you for comment time I'm not seeing anybody online and seeing none. Does the petitioner have anything that they would like to say in the with their final 13 minutes I Yield. Okay with that it goes back to the board seeking a motion, please. I Make a motion to approve ZR twenty twenty six dash ten dash zero zero four four with the following condition the variant the variance approves only the existing locations of the gazebo and shed as shown in the petitioner site plan Second we have a second further discussion Seeing none I call the question bro. Yes Fernandez Yes, because thank you. Yes. Throck Morton. Yes. Motion passes. Thank you for your time. We'll move on to the non expedited agenda items. We'll go to the petitions up is the are 2026 10 double 045. It's requested to 846 East 3rd Street for a variance from building design standards, et cetera. We're going to go to the staff report, please. Certainly, my name is Gabriel Holbrough. I'm the zoning planner, here to present the staff report. And here we go. Is it following along? There we go. So this is a request for a variance from building design standards to allow reuse of an existing building for a retail sales medium use in the mixed use corridor or MC zoning district. As you'll see, this is about building design standards, it really comes down to one window that is existing that they wanna take out. And then as you'll see later when we get to the proposed findings, the difference of opinion between the petitioner and staff really boils down to one issue, that is whether there are peculiarities of the property that cause practical difficulty. So we'll get there. I'm just giving you a heads up, we're really talking about one window and one criterion. So this is at the College Mall, this is highlighted, the College Mall properties. Third Street is roughly along the top of this image, north of the College Mall. College Mall Road is to the left along the west side of the College Mall property and then it reaches over the old Macy's building all the way to Clariz Boulevard there on the right side of the screen on the east. But we're zooming in to this part here. That's the building we're talking about. It's a separate building from the rest of the mall that's right next to it on the west side of the main mall building. We'll zoom in a little bit here. That's College Mall Road. on the left side of the image right at the intersection with Second Street and one of the entrances to the mall, and we're talking about this building right here. It was most recently a Red Robin restaurant. This is an image from Google Street View showing the south facade. And if we compare that to their proposed south facade, actually we're sort of looking at the corner, but on the right side of the image is the proposed south facade, where those black and white horizontal stripes are in the middle, they're proposing to remove the window, but the details are in the staff report, but this facade actually still is compliant with our design standards. Just barely, but it is. So that's fine. Turning to the west facade is what existing. You can see sort of three window areas, one around the building entrance on the right, and then two others. And then this is the proposed, And again, in an essential area, they're planning on removing a window. Now, because of how the design standards fit in with these existing and proposed facades, the windows are actually relevant for this facade. So removing a window brings them further out of compliance that can only be allowed by a variance. So to the variance criteria, this is just a summary. The full proposed findings are in the packet, but the summary is that it will not be injurious to the public health and welfare of the community. It will degrade the pedestrian experience, but these facades are far from public streets and in a parking lot context, so any harm to the welfare of the community is expected to be minimal. For the second criterion, No substantial adverse effects on adjacent properties. For one thing, the facades are relatively far from adjacent properties. So to the third criteria, and I would ask the petitioners to correct me if I'm wrong, but my understanding is this is the only point that staff is understanding things differently than what they're proposing. So in summary for the third criterion, The strict application that you do, it will result in practical difficulties. But those are difficulties specifically for the desired operations of this proposed store. The difficulties are not caused by aspects of the property or of the existing building. The difficulties are instead due to the nature of the desired operations model of the store. And the difficulties would not apply to other allowed and feasible uses, such as the previous restaurant or a hypothetical different cosmetics retail that had different operations. So staff's recommended finding is there are no peculiarities of the property which result in practical difficulties in the use of the property in general. So with that, the Planning and Transportation Department recommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals adopt the proposed findings and deny the variance. Thank you. Thank you. Who do we have here from the petitioner who would like to speak to us? There are three. There are three people who are associated with the petition. I'm not sure who would like to speak first. Are they all online? Yes, all of them are online. Yes, I don't know. We do not have anyone in the room. Well, let's to make things a little easier for us because they're unable to attend in chambers. Let's pick one person that will hear from initially. When that person is done, the others then we can add them in as needed. But if they could actually have one person as a spokesperson because they are online, it makes it very difficult to have multiple people in this conversation since we don't control the Zoom. So who might that be from the petitioner? Hello, sir. My name is Luke Chow. I'm the senior store design manager for Sephora USA. The truth and nothing but the truth? I do, sir. Okay, so Luke, what'll happen here is, to make things easier, is we'll have you speak for the petitioner at this moment. However, we'll be happy to square anyone else in later. You have a total of 20 minutes total to speak to this petition. Whatever time you don't use here initially, after the board has asked questions, you will have the remainder of that time in order to make any further statements that you would like. and then it'll come back to the board for a motion. Does that make sense, Luke? I understand, sir. Okay, very good. So when you get to the point when you feel that you have nothing more to add and you want to add others, let me know and we'll swear them in and we'll continue, okay? Go ahead and start the timer now. Please, we'd love to hear from you. Yeah, hi. I do want to thank Gabriel, first of all, for helping us through this process. He's been extremely helpful. The thing I would like to note, and I guess the differences that we are talking about is the third criteria. Unfortunately for us, based upon the model of business that we use, we need more wall space than typically is necessary for a typical retailer. What ends up happening is that many brands have negotiations with our company and they are required to be on the wall or on the floor, depending on who they are. But because of that, we have a specific amount of wall space needed. In a store in this shape, typically we are limited because not only that, we have services. that are wall-based as well as our cash wrap and where our point of sale ends up being. And so with a store that is kind of square, which if you took a look at the planning on this store is a little more square-like. Unfortunately, what ends up happening is with a storefront, you have less wall space than a typical store that we usually go into, which is kind of a narrow storefront, but deep. building which will usually allow us more wall space without interfering with like a storefront where there's glazing and visibility into the store. We are asking to remove this window specifically because there are certain adjacencies to the worlds that we are operating in that require wall space specifically in that area. Our original plan was to remove two of the windows on that side because we really needed them, but we made adjustments based upon how we can go. But at this point, we are really limited in how we can operate because if we have to remove this window, we'll probably have to put our cash wraps onto these custom units that we put into the sales floor. And that's not a great experience for our customer, as well as becoming kind of an LP issue. And we've experienced some, I won't say violent crime issues, but when you have the cash register on the sales floor, it becomes an issue. So that's our concern with this. Other than that, we really do feel strongly that this is a less impactful situation if we can just close this one window. We have already agreed to leave the other glazing to remaining so that we can have visibility into the stores and we will work in any way possible to adjust our store as needed to be as little as little impactful when it comes to the visibility of the storefront to our neighbors. Is there anyone else with you, Luke, on your team that would like to speak at this point? I do not believe so. I think I'm speaking for the design point of view as well as any questions that the board may have. team members are here specifically to support me if there's an architectural or structural need. OK, very good. So we'll withhold the rest of your time, which is about how much time they have left? 16. So you roughly have 15, 16 minutes left. So you can use that later on if you choose. But at the moment, we'll stop there then, Luke, if that's the end of your initial comments. Is it? It is. OK, with that then, we can go to the Board to see if they have any questions of the petitioner or of the staff Please petitioner so as I understand the necessity to remove the window is an operational issue for the type of business that will occupy this location correct and It is. What is going to take place there? Is it shelving? It is a displace. In that space, it is merchandise being displayed on the wall and sold. Okay. All right. Thank you. Actually, I'm going to open this up first to the staff because they may be able to resolve this. If you go by a place like CVS on Kirkwood, they have the windows there, but they're not looking into the building. They have some kind of like a display there, like a permanent artwork or something that represents their store. Did you guys discuss having the same thing done where they left the structural windows intact and then cover the windows from the inside in a similar manner? Did you have that discussion so that down the road, say Sephora leaves, that building then could have the interior removed and it's back in compliance? Again, this is Gabriel Holbrook, zoning planner. Staff discussion with the petitioner and the petitioner's group. I believe we discussed the idea of keeping glazing glass, but maybe other things would be behind it. There are some challenges with that, that the windows, in order for them to be considered windows for the purposes of facade, Design standards, there has to be actual usable space behind it where a person could be or there could be things happening. In the case you brought up of CVS on Kirkwood, I'm actually not familiar. I've walked by the building, but I can't picture in my head what it looks like or how it was approved. I apologize that I can't make that comparison point here, but generally speaking, there has to be something behind those windows. And they are actually doing something that's a little similar to that on the south facade, which is the one that is compliant. Their initial plan took out the central window that they're taking on and also a window on the right. But then they modified their plan to have that I believe it already currently is sort of, it comes out almost like a bay window. And then I think there's gonna, I have to look at the plans, but my recollection is that there's some usable space there and then there's actually a wall behind it where they're gonna have merchandise on that wall. So they did take an approach kind of like that on the south wall. Well, the reason I'm bringing up is they're seeking a variance. To me, it's a lot easier to have a compromise in the variance by keeping the building intact, structurally intact, so that we know that in a place like a mall that there's turnover in businesses. So my concern is we give them a variance. They cover up or take out those windows. It becomes a wall. Then the next people to come in, they would have to then turn around and rebuild the windows into it, correct, in order to come into compliance? Yes. So I'm just looking ahead at what's a way to compromise so that it would still need a variance for us to go, okay, this isn't really what classifies as a usable window, but what it does is it prevents unnecessary construction cost in terms of ripping out a window, putting it up a wall, et cetera, and instead you cover it up I'm just I'm just asking like what kind of options were discussed in order to try to make it Both economically feasible to do it as well as maintaining that building in compliance down the road should it no longer become a Sephora and something else So I think you understand why I'm asking. Yeah, certainly and and your your General ideas is spot-on. It's and we tried to you know approach I think My understanding was the Sephora team was also approaching it, trying to figure out what's the ways to come closest to compliance. I'd let the petitioner speak directly to this, but my understanding is this proposal is as close as they think they can get to compliance. Another just a minor point which doesn't change your overall point. If this variance were approved, then any future tenant would also enjoy the variance as well. So if the variance is approved, there's no future scenario where someone has to put back a window. Or similarly, the Red Robin facades, the West facade, wasn't completely compliant anyway now. And if support wanted to move in and keep all the windows, that's fine. They can continue. The issue is just bringing them further out of compliance. We can't attach anything on it, though, to say that the building has to return if it's vacated by this particular petitioner. My understanding is that would be a condition that you could make. We would have concerns about the enforcement about that. It would be a little bit challenging. Yeah. No, I understand that. It would be on the next person. But they're moving into a building. They're going to make a change from Red Robin. So the construction's on. the current tenant. I was just asking on a couple of different scenarios to see what would make the most sense. I would like to see a comparison between the south side and the west side. I know you explained, I know it's been explained, but I want, yes. Sure. Let's see, would it be more helpful to look at the existing or the proposed? Okay, well, let's start with existing. So this is the south facade. Well, actually, if it's okay, I'm just gonna hop back and forth a little bit. This is the south facade existing slash previous. I mean, the Red Robin signage might be down already, but... And... This is the west facade. So other than being mirror image of each other, very similar. We have sort of three, I don't wanna use the word facade module because that's actually something specific in the code and we're actually counting it as two facade modules, but we have sort of three sections here. We've got the tower on the right where the entrance is. You got the middle one that has a sort of gray stone color. and then you got the red one farther to the left. And then if we hop back to the south facade, similar idea, we got the entrance on the left there, we got the central one, and then we got a red one over on the right. Of course, Sephora plans on not having to be red, but for this image, it's red on the right. So the, what the difference really comes, so the facade standards are, you have to have three elements. They can be canopy, windows, change in building height, and recesses or projections. So the part of the building is farther forward, part of the building is recessed farther back. And the crucial difference here is that on this facade, the sort of bump out of the window on the right means that it is different, It's projecting farther out. So we have the tower on the left projecting out, the middle part recessing in, and the part on the right projecting out. So we've got projections. And then, of course, we have building height change, and we have canopies. And so we don't need the windows because that would be a fourth item. It's great that the windows are there. And then on the west facade, Again, we have change in building height, we've got canopies, and between the tower, or sorry, the entrance area, calling it tower, it's not really tower, the entrance area on the right, and the other parts, the entrance area is farther forward, it's projecting forward, and the others are recessed, so that's good, but then it's, the remaining part is longer than 40 feet, and there is a little bit of a, recess projection between the middle one and the one on the left, but it's, I believe, half a foot, so it's not enough to count. So it really all comes down to the difference, for the compliance, the difference between the west facade and the south facade, is that the south facade has that projection on the outer part of it, the one on the right, and the west facade doesn't have that projection on the part to the left. The one thing that's confusing to me, though, is this facade, the west facade, is the one that faces the most people. And the south facade actually faces a blank wall on that walkway. So it would be very easy for me to say, you can have a variance on that south wall. Just fill that one in because it's not really degrading the pedestrian experience as much as you would think. Why not that? Can it not be flipped due to the way the store's laid out? Or did you guys discuss that as well? Because this is the one that's most publicly facing, the west side. And this is the one that they're looking for the variance on, in addition to the other side. So the other side gets blocked in, right? It gets removed. The window gets removed on the south side, correct? Correct, correct. That makes a lot of sense. That's a no-brainer. this one's the one that everyone sees. That's why it's a little more difficult. That's why I ask about keeping, as you call it, the glazing, keeping it, even if we found a different way to allow that product to be displayed on the inside, even though that also is against code. Yeah, so I mean, I think that would be a good question for the petitioner. Yes, and I want the petitioner to address it, but I wanted to know where the city was on this, where the, You know, what's, he needs to know, Luke, if you haven't discussed it, he needs to know what's allowed and what's not allowed. And the code doesn't really allow for us to do that, to maybe put up a wall right there against the windows and put some kind of faux advertising, whatever nature scene, whatever you want, and then have the interior have a wall. If you didn't discuss that, that's why I'm asking you first, and then if Luke wants to. We only discussed it as far as to say that that wouldn't, that would still not be compliant with the facade standards. With the facade, even if the, because it's not a useful window. Right. Right, however, it goes to the idea that it still has the impression of a useful window. Yeah, certainly, I think you could make an analysis that it's better than no window at all, right? Right, and down the road, if there's a changeover, it's also easier if that person wants to turn it back into a, a usable window, they take the wall down as opposed to a full construction deal where they have to rip out the windows or put new windows in. I'm just asking what the options are and what makes the most sense economically, as well as what we're trying to maintain, which is a certain visual approach we want. I think that's an option for the board to condition a variance on something like that. Unfortunately, it's not an option for staff to approve. No, I'm not asking that. I'm just asking where that stands so that when I go to Luke here and say, I mean, is that something that they consider? Is that something they can do? Then at least we know, is that even feasible for them? So, but I just thank you for clarifying what it was, Gabriel. So let's go to Luke. Luke, do you understand what we're talking about here on the West? I do. Yeah, as Gabriel had said, You know, we did not go far in the discussion because, you know, one of the things we did propose that on on the glazing originally, but Gabriel did note that that wasn't going to help us in our compliance. So we never looked at it in the sense of a compromise for the variance to make it easier. So, so, so We did consider it. It's one of those things that, yes, I think we can do that as an option. I think for us, and our opinion from a design point of view is that if we covered the windows with, say, a vinyl graphic, we would want to make it serviceable. If we want to make it serviceable, it will be first surface. That means that we probably put a graphic over the windows on the exterior rather than interior, because we would probably, to make it work, we would have to build a wall behind that glazing. And then it would be unserviceable if, say, we put a graphic in there and it started to peel or bubble or do something like that. So we would probably first surface apply the graphic. I think one of the things that we considered when we put our design into this variance was also to, we considered if we take out the windows and just made it a continuous wall, I think it would also look more, a little less, we were concerned that it would look a little slap dashed into our design or something. So while we're as understandable that you guys want to preserve this building as much as possible for the next vendor to use when it comes up. We're just concerned that with our design, it would be a little more integrated with it so that it would be a better look while we are in the store, in that location, if you understand what I mean. That makes sense. That was just a question that I had. Just exploring. Yes. Just the board knows mr. Fernandez stuff has his hand raised, okay Go ahead John Yeah, I guess I I'm not suggesting that we do this if we haven't already observed it, but I guess my I wanted to make a comment about the orientation of this building and I think Joe you made the comment that most people experience the building from the West side. I would say that's true when they're in their cars. There's an entrance to the mall on the you know just past the the South side of this building most of the people coming into that red Robin building are coming from the North lot. Most of the pedestrian activity is on the south side of the building where, you know, the main entrance to the mall is, yes, that. So, I mean, it's... So I'm just having to... I'm just trying to... No, I understand what you're saying, John, and I agree, because that is a main entrance. I was just talking about how that window overlooks... And my question is that with the proposed... Do you have the renderings of the proposed store? We do. Gabriel, do you need me to share? Yeah, let me see if I can pull them up. OK. Because I guess my question is, is that big, is that mature tree going to still be there? That tree's not going to be there. I have to... Were you looking at the west side or the south side? The one right there on the right. The west side. It's the one right there on the right. That tree's going to remain. That's my understanding. Yes, there would remain that's what's Well, their plans don't we're talking we're talking about One window that is partially obscured by a growing tree On the side of the building that really doesn't have the majority of the pedestrian traffic That's what we're talking about, right? So I just you know, I want to start by saying Thank you to Luke and his team For their willingness to make an investment like this in Bloomington. I mean some context matters. I mean, this is the only mall in Bloomington and There's a lot vacancies in that mall so I'm glad that your company's interested in making this kind of investment and I'll save my comments and motions for later and Yeah, and so following on to watch John saying the reason I brought up that issue about the window the glazing was because we're being recommended by the the staff to deny this petition Correct So I'm just trying to establish that there aren't maybe some other avenues for us to go down before we get to that point Because we'll have to come up with alternative findings so John what John says is true in terms of There's a there's an awful lot of wall space on a mall anyway So and this is a newer portion of it and it's for the most part in compliance. So it's it's a little easier to find To it's a little easier in my opinion to grant a variance But now when we go down that road, the question is why have we looked at other options? That was one of the reasons I discussed that but giving that there are really no options that make a lot of sense to go through such as maintaining the glazing and It doesn't really seem to be necessary. So if that's the case, then we could certainly grant the variance, I think, easily. But then the question becomes, we just need to have good findings for that. Sure. Well, I have another way of looking at this. So we're removing a window, and we have to have four elements, you said, on that facade. Three. Three elements. So what are we missing? They have change in building hiding canopy. So the other two possible ones are windows and recess or projection Okay, so if they bumped out the the third The red part on that facade if that got bumped out a little bit To the front would that do? Yes then they could remove the window and bump that wall out a little. Right. Because then it would be analogous to the south side. Yes. And as long as they kept the awning over the bump that window. Yes. And kept the awning. So my question for the petitioner is, does that sound like an idea you would entertain? That is that. may run into other issues like setback, foundation. It may be prohibitively expensive for us to change the envelope of the building, as well as that is actually something that I think the landlord would probably have to take into consideration and get, for us, it's a large change. It's not something that I think can necessarily be, I can say yes to, especially since based upon leasing and all the negotiations that go through something like this, I'm not certain I could say yes to something like that. But hold that image right there, though. I mean, let's go again to what John said. I mean, we have a semi-mature tree right there that's essentially covering up that window anyway. So losing that window, again, from that side, from the pedestrian or from those that are driving by, from their experience, it's going to be negligible, in my opinion. What's the difference between the west side window and the other window? Are you talking about the one that they want to remove or are you talking about the ones next to it that has a punch out? What's the difference with the west side window and the other one that is approved? Yeah, the difference between the west facade and the south facade really comes down to the opposite side from the entrance. So on the south, that's the right, has a projection out. Correct. Okay, so I'm looking at a picture of it dead on, and the red part projecting looks exactly the same on both. Yeah, so if you look at the, sorry, Eric. So is it only the front, is it only the red robin front section? On the image here on the screen, you see up at the top gourmet burgers and brews, which you'll no longer be there as Sephora. just to stay zoomed in. And then we have the awning. And then you can see sort of silver, there's like a silver grid, right? And on the far left of that, there's a face that's actually right angles to the other one. So that's the projection. So the sort of grid you can see with the windows in it is poking out. Whereas on the west facade, the window is just a window. That's really the... When you boil it down, that's the difference. Does that make sense what you're saying? Because the one in the red brick projects out. It's got sides on it. This is projecting. Yeah, and the other one's not. That's the only... I'm talking about the red side. This one here, that one's flat. And then on the other side, it's projected out. I just had a view where it showed that the red was exactly projecting out the same. When I look at the west side, and I see their proposed drawing, the symmetry of what they are doing makes sense. Otherwise, it just won't make sense. Can you put their proposed drawing up, please? do you want to clarify that for them? Yeah, I think the difference was I wasn't talking about the windows on the red building. I was talking about the distance coming out from the wall. The projection. The projection. Got it. Yeah, so that is the same on the two sides, right? Correct. OK. So there's no difference in that. The only difference between the two sides is that the red has a window coming out. Yes, yes. So how does that affect the window on the other side? Because then it meets the the one of the design standards of having recesses and projections in this case. It's a projection on the south side Yeah, so there's no projection that is happening other than the tower element at the southeast corner at the southwest corner So on the south side, you've got two areas of projections that are happening You've got the tower and then the east side of the building and On the west side, there's only the tower element projection at the southwest corner, and then the rest of the building faces flush. So the windows are meeting the requirement for the other third element. They're coming closer in terms of the 50% glass. So the lack of the projection along the west side only gives it two elements, the awning, the windows, and the change in building height, Windows aren't meeting it they're close and this variance or this request would be bringing it further Okay Okay, I'll save my comments John do you have anything further before we move on to the public? No, I don't Flavia Okay, not right now let's do the public and so we'll have a couple of comments it sounds like from the board before I We go to a motion. So let's go ahead and go to the public Is there anyone in the public here to address this particular petition if they would like to do so, please come to the podium and sign in Or if you're online, please raise your hand so you can be recognized No one in chambers I'm not seeing anybody online with the raised hand. Okay, I With that, it goes back to the petitioner. So Luke, do you have anything for you to use the remainder of your time, the 16 minutes, for any further presentation on your part? No, I yield my time. In that case, it's back to the board. We'll either take a motion or further questions at this point. Leslie, I think you said you might have a. Oh, go ahead, John. No, I was going to make a motion. Yes, please do. Okay, let me see if I can do this. I just dropped some proposed wording for revised frightening for criteria three. And so I would move that we adopt the staff findings for ZR 2026 10 0 5 for criteria one and two and adopt I propose a new findings for criteria three. I'll read those and then the motion would be to approve the variance. My proposed findings read strict application of the terms of the unified development ordinance will result in practical difficulties in the use of the property. Those difficulties are peculiar to this property and the variance will relieve them. The property is peculiar because the building is an outbuilding of the college mall, the only closed shopping mall in Bloomington, Indiana. It sits within a wall property of 62 acres. That stereo facade standards in the UDO section 20, 04, 70, D2D are meant to support an active pedestrian experience with transparent glass and broken up building walls. The subject property is far from College Mall Road and is surrounded by mall parking and drive aisles. The department makes the same point in the proposed finding for criteria one. The facades are far from the public street and in a parking lot context. The south side of the building is where most pedestrians entering the mall will experience the building, and the south facade fully complies with the standards. The variance is needed only for a small portion of the west facade module, which faces a parking lot. and not a public street. These particular conditions come from the property's location, layout, and mall setting. They do not come from a petitioner's operations. Any retail user that needs interior wall space on that side of the building would face the same conflict between street-oriented standards and the building's actual setting. Strict application would require additional glazing and full high facade. projections on the secondary parking lot facing wall of an existing building, which was already, luckily, not conforming. That would impose real costs and design limits on reusing this building while delivering none of the public benefit the standard is meant to achieve, granting the variance to release these practical difficulties that allows productive reuse of an existing building at the college mall. building south facade and its interest module still meet the purpose of the facade standards and public interest and the public's interest as standard of tax is not compromised. So that's my proposed amended finding and I would again propose that we make a motion that we approve the variance and adopt the staff recommendations for criteria one and two replace it with this new proposed criteria three Now here's the trick John. So on a second, I want you to repeat exactly everything you said I'm just kidding. So we do have a motion in front of the board I Do have a motion in front of the board. Do I have a second second? Okay with that I will before we have further discussion. Is there any issues from staff that we need to address in the alternative findings? Or was it sufficient? Just real quick, Mr. Fernandez, I did just send you a chat. I don't see those findings in our chat. If you could email those to me, that would be very helpful. So we can get them in the record when we sign off tonight? Yes, I will do that right now, Eric. Other than that, though, legal or staff? I can yes, please just if Would recommend a condition like like you just saw with the The new hope for families variance something like this variance approves only the proposed building facades as shown in the petitioners submitted plans just to clarify the scope of the John if you were Yes, okay, I will amend your With with the following words the variance approves only the proposed building building facades as shown in the petition submitted plans that we've viewed today And in the record reflects that John John accepted that amendment So we have a first and a second with the amendment any further discussion before votes taken Okay. So again a vote of yes is to approve this variance That's been applied for by Sephora Anything further? I call the question. And just for the record, Ms. Borrell, you were the second, correct? Yes, I was. Thank you. And the amender. She was the second and the amender. And the amender, yes. And Eric, when you're ready. Oh, yeah, thank you. Sorry, I missed that. Yes. Fernandez. Yes. Cosinco. Yes. Throckmorton. Yes. The motion passes. 4-0. They left this, so I had to use it. Sorry. Sorry, Eric. Thanks again. Thanks again, Luke. All right. Thank you. And Luke, thank you for your patience on that, and good luck. Thank you very much, sir. You bet. It's public service at work. Thanks, Gabriel. Thank you, Gaber. All right, we're gonna move on to ZR 2026-10046, request at 2379 South Walnut Street for variances for maximum parking, vehicle parking allowance as standards and for landscape bump outs, islands, and escape standards for the use of vehicular repair major within a mixed corridor. Can I have a staff report, please? Can't hear you. Good evening. I'm Joe Patterson zoning a long-range planner. Are you here? No, we're not hearing you Sorry Good evening. I am Joe Patterson zoning and long-range planner And tonight we are looking at two variances for 2379 South Walnut Street one is for maximum vehicle parking allowance and the other is for land variance from landscape bumpouts islands and in caps and This location was previously a soil furniture warehouse. To the west, you have JC Bank, to the north church, to the northwest TNT pet food supply. Southwest is Dairy Queen. And all those properties are zoned mixed use corridor. To the east and to the south, you have Timber Ridge Town Homes, which is zoned multifamily residential. Currently, there is a, as I discussed, the stall furniture warehouse building. There is a gravel parking lot on the east side of that, as well as existing vegetation along the east and south sides of the property. Calibre Collision is proposing to renovate the facility, as well as construct two parking areas, one in yellow and one in blue. The detention pond is also proposed in the southeast corner, as well as additional screening vegetation shown in green. The two parking areas will consist of 42 total spaces. There's a north parking area in yellow and the blue parking area. For each of these, the blue parking area will also be fenced to provide additional screening. that will primarily be used for employees, as well as staging for vehicles receiving service. There is one interior planting island in that north parking lot, consisting of about 350 square feet of landscaping. Now the petitioner is proposing to have 20 service bays on site, as well as just shy of 1,500 square feet of office sales space and so that would normally equate to 24 parking spaces allowed by the UDO. Now the petitioner based off of their day-to-day operations the number of employees required for those 20 service bays and how they process the vehicles in and out of for their repairs does show that they would need a minimum of 42 spaces which is what they are requesting and Sorry, going back to the blue parking area, the east parking area. One major point of contention here is that the drive aisle is 60 feet wide. The UDO requires a minimum drive access aisle of 20 feet. And so having that large of a parking area unnecessarily raise the amount of required landscaping. Now, with this proposed layout and the number of required parking spaces, we do find a practical difficulty in maintaining the number of required spaces for their day-to-day operations. By moving into our findings for each of the two variances, that the approval would not be injurious to the health safety morals, general welfare. For the maximum parking number, based off of their day-to-day operations, we do not find any injury there. For the parking and landscaping and bump-outs variants, the minor changes that could be incorporated to reduce the amount of parking area, as we outlined with the conditions attached at the very end, we feel if those conditions were met, then that would reduce the amount of required landscaping and would not be injurious at that point. For criteria two, the use and value adjacent to the areas would not be affected in a substantially adverse manner. Again, for the max parking number, we find that with the conversion of the parking lot, as well as the installation of fencing and additional screening and buffering of vegetation, that the adjacent properties would not be affected substantially. for the parking landscaping and bump-outs variants. Again, since the solid wood panel fencing and planned vegetation would screen and provide that buffer from the adjacent residential areas, and with decreasing the amount of pavement within the parking areas and lowering that overall threshold for the landscape requirement, again, we find that the peculiarities of maintaining those 42 spaces while reducing the overall pavement would then meet the peculiar conditions. For criteria three, that the application would result in practical difficulties and that the variance would relieve those. Again, for the maximum parking number, we find that the granting would relieve the practical difficulties based off of their day-to-day operations. And for the parking and landscaping, again, the majority of this comes down to that 60-foot drive access aisle as well as the slightly lengthened parking spaces that they are proposing. So that does place a unnecessary and self-imposed requirement for the additional landscaping. And by lowering those thresholds or installing additional landscaping within those drive access aisles that could increase the amount or lower the threshold to meeting the required amount of landscaping. By meeting the conditions that we attach to this, we feel that the peculiarities would then be satisfied. Therefore, It is our recommendation that the board adopt the proposed findings and approve both of the variances with the following conditions. That the approval allows a maximum of 42 parking spaces. The interior drive aisle on the East parking area shall be reduced to a maximum of 20 feet wide. Parking spaces shall be reduced to a maximum of 16 feet long. A staff level minor site plan site development permit reviews and approvals are required prior to establishing and commencing business operations on site. The proposed solid panel wood fencing and additional vegetation is to be installed to meet screening concerns and verified to meet UDO requirements. Large canopy trees are to be installed along the entire eastern edge of the parking lot. And all parking spaces provided above the maximum are to be constructed with primary will pavers or other approved previous services. Thank you. We have a petitioner here that would like to speak to this petition. Is it one person or three? If all three of you want to speak, we can just swear you all in right now and be done with it. Go ahead and come on forward and we'll just do all of you. All right, what's your first and last name, please? Anthony Willis. Anthony, do you affirm the testimony you're about to give us, the whole truth and nothing but the truth? I do. Thank you. Who's next? Aaron Bertrand. Aaron, do you also affirm that the testimony you're about to give is the whole truth and nothing but the truth? I do. Thank you. And? Brett Flory. Brett? Yeah. Do you affirm the testimony you're about to give is the whole truth and nothing but the truth? I do. Speaking to the mic when you say that, please, for the record. I do. Thank you. All right. So you guys have heard the drill. You've gone through two. So you get a total of 20 minutes. Use what you want now, addressing the concerns of the petition. And then whatever you don't use, Held and then after we've had some discussion then you have the remainder of that time to address as you wish Using that time anything you've heard before any action is taken by the board. Okay, so with that we'll go ahead and start you off and Please give us your presentation My name is Anthony Willis. I'm an engineer with Bynum finance and I'm here with the petitioner tonight. So Caliber Collision is an auto-body repair service shop. Their main services they offer are minor auto-body repair, some painting, and some other automated repair uses. So with this site, this is a limited compliance project, and as the staff mentioned, it's the old stall furniture place. With our improvements, we're proposing improving the existing gravel pavement to asphalt pavement, landscaping improvements, fencing in the eastern parking area that will be for the vehicles that will be under maintenance, employee parking, as well as some customer parking on the north side of the building. We'll have some perimeter landscaping along the eastern portion of the parking lot with some additional landscaping on the eastern property line. We'll also be constructing one water quality and detention facility to treat any runoff from the parking areas in the building. So with the two variances on the petition tonight, we would like to revise two of the conditions. We would like to remove the condition number two. So the UDO requires a minimum drive-out width of 20 feet. However, it's silent on a maximum width. And since this is an automotive repair, auto body repair, There will be times where there are larger vehicles that will need maintenance or there will be, you know, the necessity for a tow truck to enter the site and drop off a vehicle. With that 20 feet drive aisle width and parking on both sides of that drive aisle, it's going to be very difficult for the tow trucks in these larger vehicles to maneuver the parking area safely and without damaging, you know, the potential of damaging other vehicles that are parked there that have had previous work done on them. And since this is a limited compliance project, we're not expanding the existing limits of the gravel paved area and we're not really changing the shape of it. We feel that just paving these areas and improving it and creating the new drive aisle and parking areas That's kind of follows the nature of the limited compliance projects. And then so condition number six, we would like to revise that to say that the additional parking spaces over the allowed maximum is allowed to be asphalt pavement and not permeable pavers. With this being a limited compliance project, the goal of the UDO is to kind of reuse and revitalize existing vacant properties in the town with minimizing improvements that are necessary to bring the site into compliance with certain aspects of the UDO. We feel that the pavers create an additional long-term maintenance difficulty, as well as adding some construction difficulties and construction costs to the project. Since we're not really expanding the limits of the existing gravel area, and like I said, we're matching the shape, we feel that That entire area being paved with asphalt paving is consistent with a limited compliance project. With the landscaping variance, you know, reducing the interior landscaping requirements for the parking lot, that's really to, you know, reach that total that's necessary for this business operation. I think it was mentioned that there was 20 bays within the within the building, and they'll have about 20 employees on site. So all those employees and vehicles that are being dropped off to be worked on will all be parked in that eastern parking area, and we really need to maximize that parking to get to the 42 that's necessary for the operations. We propose significant landscaping permits along that eastern portion of that paved area, which will provide some, you know, shade and relief for mitigating heat from the parking lot. So we are still taking several steps to kind of mitigate the increase in the asphalt or the replacement with the asphalt paving. So we feel this won't really have an impact on the adjacent properties. It won't be interest to the public. We're still, you know, taking steps to kind of upgrade the site and bring a lot of it into compliance. And I think that's all I had tonight. If you have any questions for me, I'm more than happy to answer. Sure. Does anyone else like to speak at this point, or do you want to hold your time? OK, please. So I'm Brett Flory. I'm the architect. And I do most of Caliber's work all over the country for the last 14 years. But I just wanted to add one thing. So this building was a furniture warehouse. And the parking lot actually slopes towards the south. And that overhead door on the south end of the building is actually a dock high. It's a dock, basically. 48 inches above grade. And so we have a ramp on there. You can kind of see it on the site plan. And the ramp is 48 feet long. We typically try to just do one inch per foot. We could probably reduce it a little bit. But they actually pull records in the building And that's why we kind of create a loop through the entire building. And on that end of the building, we have a 48 foot concrete ramp. So if we did try to, I mean, we couldn't reduce the drive-all very much more than it is right now. Just if you're driving a wrecker through the building and then you're coming down a 48 foot ramp and trying to make the turn and get out of there. So that's one of the reasons this drive-all's so wide. That's the main reason this drive-all's so wide. Now we do have 20 foot deep parking spaces. We could probably make those 18 foot deep and that would save four foot overall in asphalt all the way across the back of the parking lot. That would help some, but they really need that wide drive, that driveway back there to get access, full access back there. Plus the fire truck is coming around there and I don't know, Doesn't have great fire department access, but they did approve it. We sent it to them. They're okay with it But I'm happy to answer any questions that you have you know, this is an outdoor vehicle storage area and that's secured Public never goes back. They're just caliber employees. They move cars around some armor wrecked some armor repaired They're just waiting for the customers and they will have some employees parking back there, too so It's, um, actually they typically have more parking spaces in this, but they're willing to, um, go with a reduced number, total number of parking spaces to try to be here. And they want to be at this location. Okay. Do you wish? Okay. How much time do they have left? Uh, 11, little over 11 minutes. Okay. So there's 11 minutes remaining that you can use. Uh, after we've had further discussion. Thank you. Thank you. So with that we're back to the board for any questions so the petitioner for the staff. Do you have anything. So how would this this is for the petitioner. How would condition to read the interior drive aisle on the East parking area shall be reduced to the maximum of. Yes. So we would like to remove that condition remove it all together. Yes. So he mentioned that the Parking spaces could be eight Did he say 18 feet long? Yes, so the minimum parking space length that the city requires is 18 feet or 16 feet so we can produce it So the reason we have it set up is the 20 by 60 by 20 that matches the limits of that existing gravel area But you want to remove condition to all together Correct. Yeah, so we had Remove condition to all together for that additional maneuver ability for the the tow trucks, the wreckers and a 20 foot drive aisle. It's it would be too difficult to really maneuver a truck of that size in that area without, you know, really risking damage to parked vehicles. What's the standard with for What's the standard with if it's not 20? I'm sorry. What's the standard with that if it's not 20, what's the with you would ask for? The drive aisle? We would ask for 60. Is it current 60? What is the current with the existing Well, what they're what they're showing is 60 feet. So we don't have, you know, a turning exhibit or anything that's showing that, you know, as the petitioner said, they're just simply paving all of the gravel that is there now. And so that is just wound up to an aisle that is 60 feet wide. So it wasn't necessary, hasn't been demonstrated that there's a turning exhibit that this is the minimum that is necessary for a tow truck to get in here and use this. You know, we don't have any information other than their statement of they're just paving exactly everything that is there now. Okay. As we mentioned, you know, the UD only requires a 20 foot drive while, um, for two way traffic. Yeah. But that, that would be for regular cars, not, um, uh, semi or a big truck. Sure. So, you know, I mean, a semi is not getting back here. Um, you know, they, they just can't even get in here and turn around. Um, you know, if a record truck is getting in here, I mean, again, you know, show us a turning exhibit and we're happy to, um, you know, review that. Do you have a turning exhibit? We do not know. John, do you have any questions? Yeah, I'm sorry. Mr. Fernandez said he had to step away for another business engagement. Any other questions yet before we go to the public? So I did have one question, which was I completely understand what you're asking about on But item six, I'm trying to understand. You're asking us to provide a variance where we're taking the parking lot, the current gravel coverage that is permeable and turning it completely into an impermeable surface without any mitigation on your part. Is that what you're asking? Yeah. So what we've done to kind of, you know, mitigate, you know, the I guess the increase from gravel, which is permeable to the asphalt paving is we've incorporated a water quality and detention for this site. I don't believe there was previously a adequate retention or water quality or detention facility on the site. So we're adding a new water quality detention pond, which will treat the stormwater runoff and will kind of mitigate any adverse impacts from the transition from gravel to pavement. Did you do a cost analysis between what it would cost to do the full paving as opposed to doing partial paving with permeable pavers? I have not, no. We are allowed as a board to consider some of the economic impact. Why would you not do that? It's just something we haven't done. We haven't been asked to do yet. The reason I say that is because you were saying that it would be cost prohibitive. How did you arrive at a statement like that if you haven't done a cost analysis? In our experience, previous projects that we specced and have priced out or completed estimates on, the pavers are more expensive than simply paving with asphalt. The pavers themselves as opposed to the asphalt itself or for the full cost? For the full cost of the materials and the construction. So you have those numbers? I don't have a number off the top of my head. That's just from our experience that any time we've prepared estimates for other developers, contractors, the pavers are more expensive And then the asphalt paving, you know, speaking of a relative area, I just, I don't know those numbers off the top of my head because they're constantly changing. All right. But there were a certain number of items that the city set exceptions and number six was one of them. And you've asked for two things to be considered. And I think that's pretty important. And it seems to me that if it's that important to you to ask for it and ask us to to vary that, because that's a pretty serious variance, that you would have done due diligence on that, and you haven't. You should bring us those numbers so that we can understand whether this is really a particular hardship for you. So that's difficult for us as a board to just give you that. Now, number two, though, addressing that, I can understand that, because the while of the aisle width, it does seem inherently to make sense. But I understand I think really what the city's saying is if it was a narrower aisle, then it wouldn't cover the entire gravel. So that would also mitigate part of what we would lose in terms of permeable surface area. That's a fair statement, isn't it, Eric, for me to say? Yeah, so what we were obviously looking for in terms of reducing the aisle width was just reducing the amount of the variance that is being requested here. You know, the presence of the wider dry valve just exasperates the variance request, making it narrower reduces that variance request into a little bit more. That was my understanding. But at the same time, though, I do understand. And first of all, let's be clear about what this site is. It's off the road. It's behind the bank. It's going to have a fence. We've had this discussion before on other automobile. We just had one a few months ago about moving that automobile dealership. So we understand that. And we've gone through those things as far as islands and coverage for landscaping, et cetera. But I would just say that looking at this before we go to the public is that number two, that makes a lot of sense. I don't really have so much of an issue. But if I'm going to do that, there's no way I'm going to agree to number six, because that's just way too much of a request, especially without any findings on your side to present to us. Yeah. For us, condition two is really the crucial one for the business operations. That's the crucial change in conditions. Since John has left us, I can almost hear what John would say, which is there has to be some compromise and understanding about what's needed for a business like yours. Business like this and that does make a lot of sense, especially given where it's locked into the land there And there will be landscaping etc. So that all makes sense to us but there are certain things that we do need to mitigate and one of those is is what's gonna happen with water and That is a pretty serious issue Okay, so I just wanted you to understand kind of where my questions are right now. Yeah, I understand All right. Now with that do we have any other questions on the board? No, not at this moment, okay We can go to the public then for comment. Is there anyone in chambers who would like to speak to this? And if no one in chambers, is there anyone online if you make yourself known by raising, using the raise hand function? Yeah, there's nobody online. Okay. So then that means it goes back to the petitioner. Any of you may speak using the remainder of your time to anything that's come up to this point before the board takes action. So the time is yours at this point. I just wanted to add one thing. It sounds like the concern is how much the pervious surface we're adding, because it is a gravel lot right now. Caliber does have shops where they do their outdoor vehicle storage on gravel lots. But most cities want paved surfaces in the outdoor vehicle storage area. I assume that's the way it is here. I'm not sure. Yeah. OK. We have done pavers before. and we've done pervious asphalt, it costs more. It's like probably 40 to 50% more than just average asphalt. And they don't, it serves a purpose, I guess, because there's less pervious surface. But there is a, the whole backside of this property is all grass. It's all native vegetation back there. So it's, Understand the desire, you know to have the pavers there because we're exceeding the parking requirement But I mean one thing that might I don't know well, I guess y'all wouldn't allow that I was thinking maybe we could just do gravel in the parking areas You know for the spaces that we would have to have pavers But how many pavers do we have to like 20? 18 parking spaces, we'd have to have pavers. I mean, normally, if we were going to have to do pavers, we'd put them on the customer side so you'd be able to see them. It would actually look better. But putting them behind the fences, it serves the purpose of having less impervious, but no one sees it. But anyway, it would be helpful maybe if we just had to do the ones out on the customer side. If that's something y'all would consider, but just want to throw that out there. Thanks. How much time do they have left? Nine minutes, 45 seconds left. Yeah, I just want to kind of piggyback on that a little bit. So the previous area kind of what we've done is like, With the landscaping improvements along the east side and the water quality detention and, you know, this large area east of the parking area where all the runoff will be directed, that is the mitigation efforts for the change in the gravel to the pavement. But we understand your concerns. And like I previously said, you know, that number two items are crucial one. We would prefer, you know, the condition number six, um, be revised that it's just asphalt paving just because of those, those long-term maintenance items, um, the cost and the construction difficulties associated with pavers. Um, but yeah, so, um, just want to thank you again for, you know, hearing this petition, um, and being here tonight. Anything further from the petitioner? Okay. With that we're back. board. I mean, let me just jump on that since you're addressing my concern, which is looking at the property. Um, there's grass. Uh, yeah, there is grass. There's a small piece of grass to the south side and it runs into a parking lot, which means that any water that runs off that asphalt is going to go into that parking lot. It's going to continue to go on. Uh, that's, that's a problem for me. The other one is if it does go east, it goes right towards the housing development. So it goes into their backyard, and there's a walking path there, et cetera. This is my concern. And I understand it's not ideal in terms of not being able to use the less expensive asphalt. But unfortunately, when you come in situations like this, when you're asking for a variance, you're asking for us to balance what is the company's responsibility to the overall good of that area. And the overall good is to see to it that we can mitigate these issues that we have with water runoff. And so yeah, that's a difficult thing. And we understand that it costs money. That's why I was asking about, did you do a true cost analysis of that so that we would have a better understanding of what you're asking us to give up for that money? Because this is not really a great place to put a whole lot more asphalt, as you can see from the overhead. The building next to you is the bank, and it's all asphalt. To the south, the Dairy Queen, all asphalt. And to the east of that, all asphalt. And that's more asphalt. The water's gotten nowhere to go. And so unfortunately with this request, this is the one place where we can mitigate it. Those will all be handled in future when new uses are asked for for those properties. They will all have the same requirements. So that's part of what the UDO is about. So I did want to let you understand why we were at. I'm particularly asking for that issue. All right. Anything else from the board? I have a question for the for staff so. Just to clarify what one of the petitioners talk about the paper the papers being on the. Instead of being in the back being on. On the client tell side. Is are you opposed to that is there any issues with that. So so we don't you know we did not in our condition of approval state where on the site where the papers we just simply said The parking spaces that are over that maximum number have to be in papers, whether they put those all on the customer side or they put some in the front and some of the back, that's up to them. Like I said, this was just a recommended condition of approval. The board can certainly adjust that if they want to require only for the eight spaces that are along the front or something in between there. So how many spaces total would be papers? So they are currently 18 over. So 18 spaces would be pavers. Correct. And how many spaces are on a customer side? On that north side, including the two ADA spaces, there are nine. Nine. So they could do half of the pavers there and then on the other side. OK. But this is in front of the board, too, for discussion. I mean, I'm just throwing that out as that concerns me. This doesn't mean I can't be swayed, but I'm saying that sticks out as, I think, a little too much. But you have a little bit more experience with building than I do. Well, when I look at this, I'm looking at the type of business. So I understand why they are asking asphalt, because it's a continuous surface that they're going to be bringing cars in and out. And when you have favors in the back, One paver pops up, and then you're bringing cars back, and it's not their car, it's somebody else's car, which, viability as well. So I understand why they are saying that. My other question is about the water mitigation. If the runoff water mitigation that is in place is sufficient to take care of the water of this large asphalt surface that they're proposing. So, yeah, that evaluation will be done by Seablomington Utilities. They're currently going through that process. I know that they do have some comments back to Binomfano for some updates that are required, and that would be reviewed during the minor site plan review process. We could put a condition in there that CBU has to approve the water mitigation to fit this this size of paved area. That'll be required regardless. You don't have to put a condition on that. I'm just trying to figure out what do we do here because okay, we approve the paved area, but then we end up with a problem down the road with CBU and that's what I'm trying to figure out. Yeah, certainly it's hard to predict how CBU will review that or incorporate the pavers in their review, whether they look at it as permeable or not. That's a separate thing. We can't speak to that. You know, we're just simply approaching it from a typical perspective and the udio does have language in situations where the director or you know at a staff level Adjustments to parking maximum are done. It says that all of those spaces over the maximum has to be permeable So we've we've taken the same approach in some other situations of you know recommending that all parking spaces over that maximum be of pavers So again, you know, we're just that is a suggested condition of approval. The board can incorporate it. They can modify it. They can strike it What was the overdue in 18 or 20? What was it 18? So, you know, the thing is probably that that's a good point and it goes to what the petitioner said which is to use the public parking area That's nine. That's half. Well half is a lot better than zero Yeah in my opinion and it also makes sense because it doesn't have the truck traveling my concern too was wanted to have that 60 feet and when why not 40 and you mitigate because then you don't have to be as, you don't have to cover the entire surface. So right now it's a matter of we have this gravel and it covers this area and if we just paved this area then that leaves us a 60 foot wide drive line, which again they don't have a turning, would you call it a turning? Yeah, turning exhibit. Yeah, so there's no turning exhibit. So we don't really know what they need even though it's been stated they need 60. But we don't have a document that shows that. Regardless, that's why I'm trying to figure out what's the way to get around I completely for Having some kind of water control. That's a great idea But whatever we can do to to do our best to see to it that is it's not going to just flow out into these other two properties It was my concern and at least we could do is say that we require the nine public spaces to be permeable to use the pavers Which is goes along with your question. I mean that could be made up of Because then after that's done, if the CBU comes in and says, well, this water handling that they want isn't going to meet it, then they're still going to have to figure out a way to mitigate that, whether it's narrowing up the entire width of that paved area or turning some of those spaces into pavers. I mean, again, those are two documents we were looking to use. I mean, knowing that this is what standard helps a lot. Yeah, please. Yeah. So we do turning radius templates all the time. So that's something we could turn in with our SOP plan for the minor SOP plan or whatever we got to do. We can include that with that. It's not a problem. And then I would just add, yeah. He's going to talk to you about the drainage a little bit. Yep. Yeah. water quality detention facility will be reviewed and approved by cbu. They will be reviewing that for compliance to cat. They have you know for limited compliance have seen you typically treats that is whatever the disturbed areas you have to capture that provide as much water quality as possible. And that's what we're doing with our Now, this may not be the final design as we're going through the CBU review process, but whatever we do propose will be reviewed and approved by CBU. Additionally, I do not believe the ADA parking in the public area can be pavers. That typically has to be a hard, smooth surface. So I don't think, you know, it would be a good idea to have pavers for that ADA area. So that would leave seven spaces in the public parking area. the employees be parking? In the eastern Finstan parking area. Okay. Where would the employees be parking? So would it, could we have an employee, the employee parking be pavers? Yeah, so really just the ADA is what cannot be pavers. Yeah, I understand, because then it's uneven. They're getting out of the car. They might fall, break a Yes, I understand. And to that point, if you fill in the remainder of those 11 spaces on the eastern side, starting from the north going south on the east side, that's well away from the slope that has to be used to turn into. Just as another note, so there would be no reason, even if there were no cars parked further south Along the east side and he wanted to make a wider turn that heavy vehicle which would be a tow truck would not be going across pavers Do you see that on the overhead? So that does make a lot of sense I mean I think that for me that makes a lot of senses to just ask for that Because it does look very feasible here. I mean, that's a hundred. That's a hundred feet wide And that's sixty that's a sixty foot turn that seems to be ample in it I Don't see why tow truck cannot get in there to that to that slope easily on asphalt So that that's my only only comment I could eat you know if I were to make the motion that might be something that I would add Is there any other questions Before we before we go forward then I mean For me, I'm not making a motion here. But for me, I would I think that all of the conditions Should remain intact except for two I don't really have an issue with with dropping two doesn't do you guys have an issue with dropping number two so long as we get the permeable which is it will be permeable pavers and item six and What kind of findings do I need to have for number two to be dropped? Any? No, because of how the criteria were found, it would just be that staff recommended that with the conditions, then the peculiarities would be met. Okay. But I think the petitioner had said, you know, it has a minimum of 20, but there's no maximum listed, right? I was in the same line is the parking spaces shall be reduced to 16 feet long. So it's not just the drive. So it's not going to be 100 feet wide. Yeah. Well, no, I'm saying it's not just the drive. It's the parking space length. Okay. That makes sense. Any, any other comments? Uh, we had no public comment, right? So we can make a motion. You want me to make the motion? Sure, that'd be great if you would. Make the motion for ZR 2026-10-0046. The motion is that we adopt the proposed findings from the city of Bloomington and approve the variance of maximum parking allowance standards and the variance from landscapes, bump outs and islands and then cap standards with the following conditions. Number one, exclude number three, number two, three, four, five and six. Do I have a second? Second. Motion for the board, any further discussion? Seeing none, can I call the question please? Voted a vote of yeses to approve the petition with that minor adjustment, please bro. Yes Cosinka. Yes Yes, the petition passes Thank you. Now, let's see. Do we have any further business in front of this board? Seeing none we stand adjourned