WEBVTT

00:00:00.354 --> 00:00:08.239
- I'm gonna go ahead and call this special session of the Bloomington Common Council to order seeing as

00:00:08.239 --> 00:00:15.351
- we've got a quorum and I think everybody else looks ready to Will the clerk please call the

00:00:15.351 --> 00:00:23.700
- roll? Councilmember Flaherty Ruff Rallo Piedmont Smith here Stasberg here Daly here Suleik here Rosenberger

00:00:23.700 --> 00:00:25.246
- here. Sorry here. I

00:00:27.074 --> 00:00:32.681
- Thank you. So this evening we have a special session related to final budget approval for things. That's

00:00:32.681 --> 00:00:38.448
- why we're here. So starting with the agenda summation first we're going to hear a report from the Committee

00:00:38.448 --> 00:00:43.948
- of the Whole a couple weeks ago. We had a Committee of the Whole discussion around these appropriation

00:00:43.948 --> 00:00:49.662
- ordinances and so we will hear from the chair of the Committee of the Whole which was Councilmember Zulek.

00:00:49.826 --> 00:00:57.732
- Next we will have three items of legislation our appropriation ordinances for budget year 2026. We will

00:00:57.732 --> 00:01:05.714
- start with The civil city budget appropriation ordinance 2025 11 then we will do appropriation ordinance

00:01:05.714 --> 00:01:13.392
- 2025 12 for Bloomington Transportation Corporation for 2026 and then appropriation ordinance 2025 13

00:01:13.392 --> 00:01:18.942
- adopting the budget for the water and wastewater utility departments and

00:01:19.362 --> 00:01:25.323
- for Bloomington again for 2026 after those three pieces of legislation we will have a conversation about

00:01:25.323 --> 00:01:31.057
- elected official salary discussion which we kind of started last week and everybody was like we need

00:01:31.057 --> 00:01:36.790
- to talk about that more any notes about council schedule and then we will adjourn So launching right

00:01:36.790 --> 00:01:43.262
- in the first thing is the report from the committee of the whole from a couple weeks ago council members who look

00:01:44.130 --> 00:01:50.857
- Thank you. The committee of the whole considered the three budget ordinances appropriation ordinance

00:01:50.857 --> 00:01:57.651
- 2025 dash 11 appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 12 and appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 13 during the

00:01:57.651 --> 00:02:04.445
- committee of the whole meeting on September 24th 2025 and makes the following recommendations. Number

00:02:04.445 --> 00:02:11.239
- one the committee of the whole recommends to the council the adoption of appropriation ordinance 2025

00:02:11.239 --> 00:02:12.638
- dash 11. Number two.

00:02:13.250 --> 00:02:19.265
- The committee of the whole recommends to the council the adoption of appropriation ordinance 2025 12

00:02:19.265 --> 00:02:25.221
- and number three the committee of the whole recommends to the council the adoption of appropriation

00:02:25.221 --> 00:02:31.475
- ordinance 2025-13 and That is the conclusion of my report. Thank you Thank you very much council members

00:02:31.475 --> 00:02:37.848
- who look does anybody have any questions of for council members who look about her report of the committee

00:02:37.848 --> 00:02:38.622
- of the whole

00:02:42.370 --> 00:02:49.873
- Great no questions, so we can go ahead and launch into our legislation for second readings. I Move that

00:02:49.873 --> 00:02:57.088
- appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 11 be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only

00:02:57.088 --> 00:03:03.870
- second All those in favor, please say aye. Aye opposed Thank you. Will the clerk please read?

00:03:09.346 --> 00:03:17.471
- Appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five dash eleven in ordinance for appropriations and tax rates

00:03:17.471 --> 00:03:25.757
- establishing the twenty twenty six civil city budget for the city of Bloomington. There's no synopsis.

00:03:25.757 --> 00:03:33.641
- Thank you so much. I move that appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five dash eleven be adopted.

00:03:33.641 --> 00:03:37.502
- Thank you. Who is here to present this evening.

00:03:38.018 --> 00:03:45.022
- Go ahead and introduce yourself and floors yours. Good evening council Jessica McClellan city controller.

00:03:45.022 --> 00:03:52.224
- I am here tonight to present for the final adoption the twenty twenty six budget for the city of Bloomington

00:03:52.224 --> 00:03:59.293
- the DLGF reviewed funds total one hundred and ten million one hundred and eighty four thousand one hundred

00:03:59.293 --> 00:04:05.438
- and eight and the non DLGF reviewed funds equal fifty two thousand nine hundred sixty eight.

00:04:05.570 --> 00:04:14.859
- fifty two million nine hundred sixty eight thousand four hundred and forty nine For a total of Sixty

00:04:14.859 --> 00:04:24.424
- five million one hundred and eight south thousand seven hundred and twenty nine dollars I Have a little

00:04:24.424 --> 00:04:30.494
- bit more information to share with you about the fund balance and

00:04:30.786 --> 00:04:38.798
- when we first developed the budget and presented the fund balance in the budget book, we had a estimated

00:04:38.798 --> 00:04:46.428
- $11 million deficit between deficit spending and the general fund. And after we made corrections to

00:04:46.428 --> 00:04:54.364
- the general fund that was reduced to a $9 million deficit spending in the general fund. And the reasons

00:04:54.364 --> 00:04:57.950
- for the reason for that change is, um, and it,

00:04:58.242 --> 00:05:05.588
- increase in the revenue in the general fund from property taxes from 54 million to 55.6 million and

00:05:05.588 --> 00:05:13.375
- This is due to moving property taxes from the parks and rec fund to the general fund And we move property

00:05:13.375 --> 00:05:21.235
- taxes out of the parks and rec fund Because there was about 1.6 million in revenues Miscellaneous revenues

00:05:21.235 --> 00:05:27.038
- in the parks and rec fund that we had not accounted for yet in New World so we

00:05:27.554 --> 00:05:35.305
- Got up got that information added that into new world and we didn't need the property tax support in

00:05:35.305 --> 00:05:42.979
- the parks and rec fund by about 1.6 million that increased the revenue in the general fund there by

00:05:42.979 --> 00:05:50.730
- decreasing the deficit spending We also made changes to the font to the spending in the general fund

00:05:50.730 --> 00:05:57.406
- a combination of decreases due to moving liability insurance And increases due to cola

00:05:57.666 --> 00:06:04.196
- Increases and increasing the amount that is going to the sanitation fund The net of that is an increase

00:06:04.196 --> 00:06:10.475
- in spending of eighty six thousand dollars So there is a slight change that was no changes from the

00:06:10.475 --> 00:06:17.068
- budget that was presented in the public hearing this is just a little bit more information for you about

00:06:17.068 --> 00:06:23.347
- the deficit spending for next year, which is about nine million dollars and that is purely from the

00:06:23.347 --> 00:06:26.110
- revenues that we're receiving next year and

00:06:26.242 --> 00:06:34.417
- versus the spending that we have planned for next year. And I'm going to update you one more time about

00:06:34.417 --> 00:06:42.278
- the planned the planned cash balance and the general fund at the end of twenty twenty six is twenty

00:06:42.278 --> 00:06:50.295
- six million one hundred and sixty one thousand two hundred and fifteen. So that twenty six million is

00:06:50.295 --> 00:06:55.326
- 40 percent of the operating budget. So we would have 40 percent

00:06:56.066 --> 00:07:02.918
- reserves of our total operating budget It's a lot of information I really appreciate you bearing with

00:07:02.918 --> 00:07:10.105
- me this budget season and asking all of your questions and Taking in all this information that I'm sharing

00:07:10.105 --> 00:07:16.890
- with you. I appreciate your concern over many issues that we've come across in the budget and I look

00:07:16.890 --> 00:07:22.398
- forward to your questions and appreciate your consideration tonight. Thank you. I

00:07:25.250 --> 00:07:32.914
- Thank you. Are there questions for Controller McClellan Councilmember Piedmont Smith. Yes I wanted to

00:07:32.914 --> 00:07:40.428
- ask and I sent an email about this but if you could summarize for everybody what our debt situation

00:07:40.428 --> 00:07:48.167
- is total debt of the city and what portion is CBU and what portion is the civil city. Do you have that

00:07:48.167 --> 00:07:55.230
- in front of you. Yes I do not have it in front of me. Just give me one second to bring it up.

00:08:09.410 --> 00:08:16.312
- So right now we're going to review the debt obligations that are outstanding for the city of Bloomington.

00:08:16.312 --> 00:08:22.823
- And I apologize for not having this information in numbers in front of you. I realize that would be

00:08:22.823 --> 00:08:29.530
- a lot easier to digest this if you had it in front of you. But I am looking right now at a report that

00:08:29.530 --> 00:08:35.390
- I pulled off the gateway website and let me make this report bigger so that I can see it.

00:08:40.386 --> 00:08:51.670
- As of January 1st 2025 the outstanding debt obligations for the city of Bloomington a total of property

00:08:51.670 --> 00:09:02.628
- tax bonds general revenue bonds and TIF bonds is one hundred and twenty five million sixty thousand.

00:09:02.628 --> 00:09:09.246
- The total of wastewater the total outstanding for wastewater

00:09:10.914 --> 00:09:18.372
- Is forty eight million seventy one thousand nine hundred and the total outstanding for water bonds is

00:09:18.372 --> 00:09:25.758
- thirty nine million eight hundred and twenty seven thousand eight hundred For a total of two hundred

00:09:25.758 --> 00:09:33.216
- and forty nine million nine hundred fifty nine thousand seven hundred and I'm happy to email this all

00:09:33.216 --> 00:09:39.870
- to you It'd probably be helpful to have like some percentages. What percent is total city?

00:09:40.098 --> 00:09:48.530
- debt obligations versus utilities. We can we can do that analysis easily of course and kind of look

00:09:48.530 --> 00:09:56.962
- at some different ways to review the debt. Can I ask a follow up. In the DLGF I found a report that

00:09:56.962 --> 00:10:05.478
- said our total debt was 414 million. Does that include the things that were not included in what you

00:10:05.478 --> 00:10:09.694
- just reviewed or did I look at that report wrong.

00:10:10.274 --> 00:10:21.623
- 414 million total debt. Let's see 414 million total debt if you would if you would show me that report

00:10:21.623 --> 00:10:32.971
- sometime I'm not able to pull reports on the fly, but I'd be happy to take a look at that and See what

00:10:32.971 --> 00:10:39.582
- that number is. I'm sure we can figure it out Yeah, it's um

00:10:40.066 --> 00:10:52.295
- It's in the end in Gateway. If you look at it should be including civil city parks and CBU. So not just

00:10:52.295 --> 00:11:04.760
- the things that are counted against our debt limit but all debt including property as well. That includes

00:11:04.760 --> 00:11:07.582
- principal and interest.

00:11:07.970 --> 00:11:16.789
- So our outstanding debt obligation is what I'm what I'm. Thank you very, very much. That is a list of

00:11:16.789 --> 00:11:25.695
- all of our payments that are due. So usually when I'm asked what our outstanding debt obligations are,

00:11:25.695 --> 00:11:34.515
- I refer to just our principal balance. And that is a list that includes all the interest payments due

00:11:34.515 --> 00:11:37.022
- with that principal balance.

00:11:37.826 --> 00:11:47.383
- So I did not quote that amount when I when I told you that is not actually on this report. But we can

00:11:47.383 --> 00:11:56.754
- pull those numbers for each bond and include include that in a report too. I have one more. Can you

00:11:56.754 --> 00:12:05.374
- comment at all on our debt per capita and how it compares to other cities? Well, let's see.

00:12:05.794 --> 00:12:14.459
- There are a lot of debt per capita reports on Gateway. And it'll show the city of Bloomington and all

00:12:14.459 --> 00:12:22.954
- the other cities in the state that have debt. And it shows what that rank is and what that debt per

00:12:22.954 --> 00:12:32.044
- capita amount is in the state. I think Deputy Mayor Knapp had answered a previous email with some figures.

00:12:32.044 --> 00:12:35.102
- I don't know. She wants to jump in.

00:12:35.746 --> 00:12:42.545
- I can cite her email but debt is paid from oh hi It starts by figuring out what you're calling debt

00:12:42.545 --> 00:12:49.344
- So if you're in that gateway, you can look at the total debt including parks and all of those other

00:12:49.344 --> 00:12:56.347
- things You can look at debt that counts against our debt limit. So there are different ways of looking

00:12:56.347 --> 00:13:03.282
- at it But by both of the standards that I think I said to you we were pretty much in the middle or in

00:13:03.282 --> 00:13:04.030
- the in the

00:13:04.418 --> 00:13:10.809
- at the bottom of the top third ranked by city and considering that we're the sixth largest city the

00:13:10.809 --> 00:13:17.327
- amount of debt we have as a sixth largest city was considerably lower than if you were looking at how

00:13:17.327 --> 00:13:23.909
- you know if you were assuming that the bigger the city the more debt they would have. I can't remember

00:13:23.909 --> 00:13:28.830
- if it was looking at total debt that put us in the sort of let's call it the

00:13:29.666 --> 00:13:36.349
- 70 60 percent mark and and or whether it was the other figure that put us halfway in the middle But

00:13:36.349 --> 00:13:43.099
- you it's publicly available and it does really depend on what you include When you ask DLGF when you

00:13:43.099 --> 00:13:50.050
- when you input what is the debt whether it's the total debt the debt that counts against the debt limit

00:13:50.050 --> 00:13:57.067
- and so on But not exceptional in other words not exceptionally high by any means for either one of those

00:13:57.067 --> 00:13:58.270
- figures Thank you

00:14:01.410 --> 00:14:10.008
- Are there other questions councilmember Rallo? Thank you for sending the that information controller

00:14:10.008 --> 00:14:19.032
- I wondered if so besides the principal and interest could you send me the Immortization schedule schedule

00:14:19.032 --> 00:14:25.246
- as well. So we yes visualize that yes for each debt obligation Thank you

00:14:33.794 --> 00:14:39.727
- No other questions. We need to go to public comment regarding appropriation ordinance 2025 11 If you're

00:14:39.727 --> 00:14:45.831
- a member of the public in chambers and you would like to make a comment about this appropriation ordinance

00:14:45.831 --> 00:14:51.650
- Please make your way to the podium If you are a member of the public online wishing to make a comment

00:14:51.650 --> 00:14:57.354
- You can raise your hand using the reactions tab or you can send a chat message to the host. I Don't

00:14:57.354 --> 00:15:01.918
- see anybody moving in chambers. Is there anybody who's raised a hand on zoom? I

00:15:08.034 --> 00:15:15.069
- Seeing no public comment. We will go ahead and come back. Oh wait, there's one person who has raised

00:15:15.069 --> 00:15:22.103
- their hand. Let's go ahead and Hear from that person when you're unmuted, please state your name for

00:15:22.103 --> 00:15:29.069
- the record and then you'll have up to three minutes Thank you, can you hear me yes Good evening. My

00:15:29.069 --> 00:15:36.243
- name is Eric host and I appreciate this opportunity to comment as Bloomington faces profound financial

00:15:36.243 --> 00:15:37.566
- shifts, especially

00:15:37.698 --> 00:15:45.275
- from state legislation like SCA-1, we must begin with a clear open discussion of the city's debt profile.

00:15:45.275 --> 00:15:52.495
- While our bond rating is strong and bond debt low, the Department of Local Government Finance places

00:15:52.495 --> 00:15:59.714
- our total outstanding debt at a bit above $414 million. SCA-1 limits short-term bond access, meaning

00:15:59.714 --> 00:16:05.790
- less cash and less credit. Public communication should stress structural constraints

00:16:06.946 --> 00:16:14.131
- such as the need to strategically layer and ladder bonds for future infrastructure costs and key debt

00:16:14.131 --> 00:16:21.738
- indicators such as our debt service rate and its proximity to thresholds that would trigger costly petition

00:16:21.738 --> 00:16:29.204
- processes. Establishing performance indicators for debt management will help us protect critical services

00:16:29.204 --> 00:16:35.262
- and infrastructure over the long term. Transparency as the Thomson administration has

00:16:35.394 --> 00:16:42.517
- said is a value means more than posting data. It means understandable, making it understandable and

00:16:42.517 --> 00:16:49.925
- accessible. The controller's goal to meet the public where they are is a great start. It's commendable.

00:16:49.925 --> 00:16:57.760
- To truly be co-creators, council and administration should actively invite public input on budget engagement,

00:16:57.760 --> 00:17:05.310
- making trade-offs visible and using modern tools such as Notebook LM to foster ongoing informed dialogue.

00:17:07.106 --> 00:17:14.233
- Perhaps we could formalize public participation by inviting residents to join the fiscal committee or

00:17:14.233 --> 00:17:21.289
- the budget task force. Leveraging community expertise will strengthen our shared path towards fiscal

00:17:21.289 --> 00:17:28.416
- health. Thank you for your service to our community and for all of your good work. Thank you for your

00:17:28.416 --> 00:17:33.726
- comment. Is there anybody else who's raised a hand on Zoom in the meantime?

00:17:33.858 --> 00:17:41.244
- Okay, let's go to our second Zoom commenter. When you're unmuted, go ahead and state your name for the

00:17:41.244 --> 00:17:48.631
- record and you'll have up to three minutes. It's Kevin Keough. I've spent over 45 years as a financial

00:17:48.631 --> 00:17:55.802
- and IT auditor, including being a CPA, a certified internal auditor, a certified information system

00:17:55.802 --> 00:18:00.894
- auditor, and a certified information systems cybersecurity profession.

00:18:01.282 --> 00:18:08.738
- I mention that only to say that I've spent my career looking for the kinds of control failures that

00:18:08.738 --> 00:18:16.195
- can hide in complex financial systems. I'm concerned that the administration still has not provided

00:18:16.195 --> 00:18:23.875
- a clear documented explanation for the so-called macro errors that reduce the projected budget deficit

00:18:23.875 --> 00:18:27.678
- by $2.3 million, a material and significant error.

00:18:28.290 --> 00:18:35.916
- When heirs of that size appear between the accounting system and the budget document, the cause it impact

00:18:35.916 --> 00:18:43.255
- should be fully reconciled and shared with the public before this council votes. Anything less leaves

00:18:43.255 --> 00:18:50.593
- both the council and the community in the dark, whether the budget numbers are reliable. I understand

00:18:50.593 --> 00:18:54.910
- that mistakes can happen in data transfers or spreadsheets.

00:18:55.266 --> 00:19:02.815
- What's troubling is the lack of transparency. There has been no reconciliation, no errata sheet, and

00:19:02.815 --> 00:19:10.514
- no technical explanation of how the macros failed or which accounts were affected. From a professional

00:19:10.514 --> 00:19:12.158
- auditing perspective,

00:19:12.674 --> 00:19:19.480
- I would urge the council not to approve the 2026 budget until those explanations can be made public

00:19:19.480 --> 00:19:26.354
- and the corrected figures verified. And I would also add, since I have some more time than I thought

00:19:26.354 --> 00:19:33.160
- I'd have, today's Herald Times, the front page. The mayor of Sydney needs to cut spending. Thompson

00:19:33.160 --> 00:19:39.966
- plans to use, and this is the figure, today's paper, $11 million in reserves to balance the budget.

00:19:40.194 --> 00:19:49.297
- directly conflicts with what the controller said this evening. So anyway, I thank you for this opportunity

00:19:49.297 --> 00:19:57.890
- to provide public input. Anybody else raise their hand on Zoom? Okay. And seeing that there's nobody

00:19:57.890 --> 00:20:06.908
- in chambers, we'll go ahead and return to council now. Are there any council member comments or lingering

00:20:06.908 --> 00:20:09.630
- questions in response to public

00:20:12.258 --> 00:20:25.171
- Well, I'd like to Give the administration the opportunity is to respond to these stated discrepancies

00:20:25.171 --> 00:20:38.718
- reliability of data and the 11 million dollars in reserves to balance a budget I Mean it's a charge that I

00:20:40.130 --> 00:20:48.175
- puts in question, I think, for the viewing public and what we're voting on this evening, and I would

00:20:48.175 --> 00:20:56.299
- like to give you a chance to respond to that. I think we've gone through it over the past months, but

00:20:56.299 --> 00:21:04.264
- if you'd like an opportunity. Revenues changed from 54 million to 55.6 million for a total increase

00:21:04.264 --> 00:21:06.494
- in revenues of 1.6 million.

00:21:06.882 --> 00:21:14.461
- Spending the general fund expenses changed from sixty five point two million to sixty five point one

00:21:14.461 --> 00:21:22.040
- million for increase in eighty six thousand in expenses There was planned deficit spending of eleven

00:21:22.040 --> 00:21:29.619
- point one million in the budget book and Mainly due to the revenue increase in the general fund That

00:21:29.619 --> 00:21:34.046
- planned deficit spending is nine point four million now. I

00:21:36.034 --> 00:21:44.821
- There's one table on page 14 of the budget book That states that the expenses in the general fund are

00:21:44.821 --> 00:21:53.522
- sixty five point two million But when we add up all of the legal sheets throughout the budget that's

00:21:53.522 --> 00:22:01.534
- where we get the budget that of sixty five point oh two million and that's where an error in

00:22:01.730 --> 00:22:09.597
- Whatever was used to run the report that made the one table in the memo versus all of the reports that

00:22:09.597 --> 00:22:17.540
- were divided up into all the different departments, there was a little bit of discrepancy between those

00:22:17.540 --> 00:22:25.407
- reports and what the total was in that table. And that's where the macro error occurred. By macro, all

00:22:25.407 --> 00:22:30.142
- we mean is that very simple Excel program that takes a messy,

00:22:30.594 --> 00:22:38.281
- Excel report generated by the computer does a bunch of formatting and saves it as an Excel or as a PDF

00:22:38.281 --> 00:22:45.893
- just if you're very simple macro, it works really well if that base report is always exactly the same

00:22:45.893 --> 00:22:53.580
- but sometimes The program gives us a report that has minor little differences in the macro Didn't work

00:22:53.580 --> 00:22:59.550
- right but we did reconcile every single difference between the general fund and

00:23:00.674 --> 00:23:08.367
- the budget book and the general fund in this adopted budget we know exactly where every change is and

00:23:08.367 --> 00:23:16.061
- I Presented that to you and I was happy to do that work. I feel like that is absolutely Necessary for

00:23:16.061 --> 00:23:23.754
- you to know before you pass this budget Thank you Thank you, are there other lingering questions from

00:23:23.754 --> 00:23:30.014
- council members or any comments that council members would like to make about this

00:23:30.114 --> 00:23:37.344
- Appropriation ordinance councilmember Piedmont Smith Well, I asked the questions that the controller

00:23:37.344 --> 00:23:44.789
- just went over earlier via email and She did send me an excel spreadsheet that laid everything out very

00:23:44.789 --> 00:23:51.947
- clearly the changes between budget book and What's in the final paperwork has that been shared with

00:23:51.947 --> 00:23:59.678
- council or public? Can we do that? Yes Yes, you can do that. Yes, it has not been shared with anyone except

00:23:59.778 --> 00:24:09.226
- The requester which is you Okay, so we can maybe put that I can share it right now and we can put that

00:24:09.226 --> 00:24:18.490
- in a to add to the packet tomorrow Okay, I think that'll that'll help Other comments related to this

00:24:18.490 --> 00:24:28.030
- appropriation ordinance or lingering questions before about councilmember all I had one more. I'm sorry

00:24:28.194 --> 00:24:37.426
- I meant to ask this last time when bounding upon Council was here, but Bloomington City Bloomington

00:24:37.426 --> 00:24:46.751
- has a bond investment grade rating of double a one said right We get rated every time we issue bonds

00:24:46.751 --> 00:24:55.983
- and it fluctuates, okay and But it is investment grade. Yes. Yep, and the the Bloomington utilities

00:24:55.983 --> 00:24:58.014
- has a lower grade and

00:24:58.722 --> 00:25:04.710
- It has consistently it's not a reflection of the current But I think it's it's got an a rating. Is that

00:25:04.710 --> 00:25:10.583
- correct? I just Wondered about rated you might still be in the rating process for your water bonds So

00:25:10.583 --> 00:25:16.456
- utilities has a water bond in the process right now and they may be rated. They may not be rated. I'm

00:25:16.456 --> 00:25:22.271
- not sure So it's in process right now. There's usually something that happens at the end of the bond

00:25:22.271 --> 00:25:25.438
- Process, I don't think you've closed on your bonds yet

00:25:28.290 --> 00:25:35.820
- I don't know off the top of my head what the utilities bond rating is. That's a short answer. You know

00:25:35.820 --> 00:25:43.204
- something we can talk about at some point later, but I just wanted to understand in terms of our you

00:25:43.204 --> 00:25:50.807
- know debt load if it has an influence on bond rating certainly does in many cases or what would account

00:25:50.807 --> 00:25:55.998
- for it. So but we can we can discuss that at a different time. Thanks.

00:25:58.626 --> 00:26:05.125
- Thank you. Are there other councilmember comments or lingering questions? Okay, I just have one thing

00:26:05.125 --> 00:26:11.496
- that I want to say which I'm gonna make it a little bit of a question But mostly it's a comment one

00:26:11.496 --> 00:26:17.868
- of our commenters highlighted the Herald Times article kind of questioning something that was in it

00:26:17.868 --> 00:26:24.430
- in terms of questioning the city's accuracy of information but I also want to call out the end of that

00:26:24.430 --> 00:26:27.998
- article cited that there would be a 2% cola increase in

00:26:28.162 --> 00:26:35.106
- or pay increase for non-union employees. But that was what was in the original budget book. But you

00:26:35.106 --> 00:26:42.190
- have changed that to the 2.7%, which is what we had talked about and requested. And I would like that

00:26:42.190 --> 00:26:49.342
- kind of verbal confirmation right now. Yes, definitely. Between budget hearings and our public hearing

00:26:49.342 --> 00:26:52.606
- earlier last month, it's been changed to 2.7%.

00:26:53.314 --> 00:26:58.781
- Thank you. I actually got a message this morning from a community member who I realized like oh they

00:26:58.781 --> 00:27:04.410
- must have read this and wanted clarification. So for clarification that is at least one inaccuracy that

00:27:04.410 --> 00:27:09.877
- was in this article and I can't tell you if there are other inaccuracies in it but that was one that

00:27:09.877 --> 00:27:15.669
- stood out to me and so I did want to make sure to clarify that for the public that our non union employees

00:27:15.669 --> 00:27:21.082
- do have a 2.7 percent increase which matches inflation for the 2026 year. And that was all I wanted

00:27:21.082 --> 00:27:22.110
- to say. Thank you.

00:27:22.370 --> 00:27:30.157
- So unless there's other lingering comments or questions from council members will oh councilmember Flaherty

00:27:30.157 --> 00:27:37.440
- Yeah, I had a question. Are we? constrained to five minutes to debate or sorry to council comment in

00:27:37.440 --> 00:27:44.651
- this period That is our Like what is standard in our code around that I think it's five minutes for

00:27:44.651 --> 00:27:52.222
- the first comment and then a two minutes additional for additional comments That's right. Thank you Okay

00:27:52.482 --> 00:27:57.110
- So I would have shared more of my thoughts last week, but I was unable to join the Committee of the

00:27:57.110 --> 00:28:01.923
- Whole. Briefly, I'm not gonna be voting in favor of this year's Civil City budget, because I don't feel

00:28:01.923 --> 00:28:06.597
- like I can in good conscience. Not a decision I make lightly, but it's a vote that's consistent with

00:28:06.597 --> 00:28:11.364
- my values and what I think is right, and I'll do my best to explain. I probably will be a little short

00:28:11.364 --> 00:28:16.362
- on time. It's also a vote about accountability for me, and I think the budget is a very poor accountability

00:28:16.362 --> 00:28:21.406
- mechanism. There are much better avenues through conversation and collaboration, negotiation and agreements.

00:28:21.506 --> 00:28:26.606
- things that have largely proven ineffective in my experience with this administration for 20 months.

00:28:26.606 --> 00:28:31.808
- And I think without real accountability, we won't see real change. And so that's really the motivating

00:28:31.808 --> 00:28:36.908
- factor. First, I think we are very much failing to meaningfully center our operationalized equity in

00:28:36.908 --> 00:28:42.261
- city government, which is central for me as an elected official. Second, in ways that I think are harming

00:28:42.261 --> 00:28:47.311
- our community, I believe this administration is failing to prioritize and pursue the outcomes we've

00:28:47.311 --> 00:28:49.886
- set through community-driven legislative processes

00:28:50.082 --> 00:28:55.140
- And third, quite sadly really, I no longer consistently trust what this administration tells us based

00:28:55.140 --> 00:29:00.099
- on their past actions and a pattern of behavior exhibited throughout their time in office. I'll try

00:29:00.099 --> 00:29:05.306
- to address each a little bit, though again, I probably don't have adequate time. With respect to equity,

00:29:05.306 --> 00:29:10.463
- for me that is the defining value of what it means to be liberal, what it means to me to be a Democrat.

00:29:10.463 --> 00:29:15.769
- Virtually all decisions in other policy areas flow from this. And in my view, we simply aren't integrating

00:29:15.769 --> 00:29:19.934
- equity as a value in government in a consistent or meaningful way most of the time.

00:29:20.418 --> 00:29:25.261
- This is actually how I felt my entire time in office, but I actually think we've been making meaningful

00:29:25.261 --> 00:29:30.151
- incremental progress most of the time, and I think this year's the first year I feel like we're actually

00:29:30.151 --> 00:29:34.854
- taking a step backwards. As folks may recall, we negotiated over equity in government last year, and

00:29:34.854 --> 00:29:39.557
- kind of gave the administration a pass when they said we need more time, we're only eight months in,

00:29:39.557 --> 00:29:44.214
- we need to do studies, we need to talk to staff, we need to understand what we're doing, we need to

00:29:44.214 --> 00:29:48.126
- come up with outcomes, expectations, et cetera. We'll come back to you with a plan.

00:29:48.514 --> 00:29:53.470
- Then we didn't hear anything for nine months until we took a motion and asked them for an update, and

00:29:53.470 --> 00:29:58.426
- we got one paragraph from the deputy mayor saying that they are not in a position to allocate funding

00:29:58.426 --> 00:30:03.625
- or undertake this work at the present time, going on to explain that the Trump administration's opposition

00:30:03.625 --> 00:30:08.630
- to DEI could put us at risk for accessing federal funds. The mayor of Corporation Council echoed these

00:30:08.630 --> 00:30:13.878
- points. I've got to say, I just find these explanations to be wholly inadequate. By all means, use language

00:30:13.878 --> 00:30:17.182
- strategically when applying for grants, naming programs, et cetera.

00:30:17.378 --> 00:30:23.043
- But now more than ever is the time to stand up for our values if they are indeed our values and indeed

00:30:23.043 --> 00:30:28.763
- leading cities all over the country are doing just that I Understand the administration's position here

00:30:28.763 --> 00:30:33.769
- and I'm opposed to it Second major area of concern is with policy outcomes again community

00:30:33.769 --> 00:30:39.269
- driven legislatively adopted policies. I think those aspects are critical it's how we actually have

00:30:39.269 --> 00:30:41.854
- city policy not just individual priorities and

00:30:41.954 --> 00:30:46.593
- I brought this up last year when the mayor was producing a bunch of action plans to inform their budget

00:30:46.593 --> 00:30:51.367
- priorities. I asked how council was going to be involved, how the public was going to be involved, whether

00:30:51.367 --> 00:30:55.961
- we'd approve these. The answers were basically no, we weren't involved and we didn't approve them. And

00:30:55.961 --> 00:31:00.512
- they're not city policies, they're mayoral priorities. Not the same thing. And so the outcomes in our

00:31:00.512 --> 00:31:03.902
- city policies are my compass and I think we're falling short in many areas.

00:31:04.066 --> 00:31:09.652
- particularly striking cases on both climate action and housing where the mayor has actually actively

00:31:09.652 --> 00:31:15.348
- opposed or even obstructed implementation of current city policy. To me, that's unacceptable and there

00:31:15.348 --> 00:31:20.934
- needs to be accountability for that as well. The path to change those is through the legislative and

00:31:20.934 --> 00:31:26.464
- community involved process, not through opposition or obstruction. A third and final problem is the

00:31:26.464 --> 00:31:32.160
- trust issue. I don't have enough time to go into all the many examples of where I feel like I have not

00:31:32.160 --> 00:31:33.598
- been dealt with honestly.

00:31:33.730 --> 00:31:39.688
- Perhaps one of the more significant is my trust concerns is when the administration, really in the first

00:31:39.688 --> 00:31:45.419
- months in office, disregarded Bond Ordinance 2022-30 and the Appropriation Ordinance 2020-301, which

00:31:45.419 --> 00:31:51.206
- appropriated nearly $30 million to be spent solely and exclusively on public safety facilities. Among

00:31:51.206 --> 00:31:57.221
- those planned expenditures, or actually actual expenditures, was the Showers West building for new police

00:31:57.221 --> 00:31:58.526
- and fire headquarters.

00:31:58.818 --> 00:32:03.947
- That's of course not how that building's being used, arguably a violation of the bond ordinance. I've

00:32:03.947 --> 00:32:09.026
- spoken with our bond council about it and corporation council and city former council attorney Lucas

00:32:09.026 --> 00:32:14.105
- and the mayor, which has informed my view that I think we may well be in violation. There's a lot of

00:32:14.105 --> 00:32:19.285
- things that we negotiated in last year's budget that the administration agreed to do that they in fact

00:32:19.285 --> 00:32:24.364
- have not done. So that undermines my ability to think that we can actually productively negotiate to

00:32:24.364 --> 00:32:28.638
- see improvements. Again, I've run out of time to give the many examples that I have.

00:32:28.738 --> 00:32:38.031
- I'd like for us to spend more time in the future working on these structural challenges. Thank you Thank

00:32:38.031 --> 00:32:47.236
- you for your comment are there any other councilmember comments after that Councilmember Piedmont Smith

00:32:47.236 --> 00:32:56.530
- I think this this year has been frustrating in many ways because We have ostensibly been working towards

00:32:56.530 --> 00:32:58.654
- outcome-based budgeting

00:32:58.818 --> 00:33:08.663
- But it has proceeded very slowly and without prioritization of which outcomes are more important than

00:33:08.663 --> 00:33:18.508
- others. I think part of it is, you know, it's not that there's anybody's fault in particular. I think

00:33:18.508 --> 00:33:27.870
- it's just it's a very heavy lift and having to kind of organize how we think about expenditures,

00:33:28.162 --> 00:33:36.333
- has taken the bulk of the time and I'm hoping that we will actually get to a point where we can we can

00:33:36.333 --> 00:33:44.505
- talk about the outcomes we wish to see and how best to use our limited funds to get there. I feel like

00:33:44.505 --> 00:33:47.678
- that really wasn't done this year and I

00:33:48.674 --> 00:33:55.439
- Again I'm not sure if that's just because we had to you know get some other ducks in a row before we

00:33:55.439 --> 00:34:02.605
- could have that conversation but I just want to express that I certainly hope the council will be actively

00:34:02.605 --> 00:34:09.370
- involved as we move ahead and at some point we have to talk about priorities not just we want to see

00:34:09.370 --> 00:34:13.054
- these 200 outcomes because we can't fund 200 outcomes.

00:34:13.730 --> 00:34:22.544
- So other than that, I appreciate the openness with which our new controller has discussed budget processes

00:34:22.544 --> 00:34:30.863
- with us and presented data. And I think there's been a learning curve on her part and on our part as

00:34:30.863 --> 00:34:39.347
- far as what we need and want to see as far as data before we make budget decisions. So I'm hoping that

00:34:39.347 --> 00:34:40.830
- we can, you know,

00:34:41.058 --> 00:34:47.837
- Both sides can learn from this and next year we'll have more of that data up front rather than me emailing

00:34:47.837 --> 00:34:54.362
- two days before the vote and getting the data on the day of the vote. I'm not pointing blame. I'm just

00:34:54.362 --> 00:35:00.698
- saying that it was a little bit last minute this year that I understood the budget well enough that

00:35:00.698 --> 00:35:06.526
- I feel like I can vote on it. So these are things we can approve upon next year. Thank you.

00:35:09.378 --> 00:35:20.105
- Thank you for the comments so far. So I want to say thank you to the controller. I always really love

00:35:20.105 --> 00:35:31.042
- your presentations and your ability to answer questions whether you know the answer or not. So I always

00:35:31.042 --> 00:35:32.830
- appreciate that.

00:35:33.986 --> 00:35:41.843
- This is something I've wanted to bring up for a long time and I think there has never really been a

00:35:41.843 --> 00:35:49.699
- right time for it because it is an awkward conversation and awkward conversations are difficult and

00:35:49.699 --> 00:35:57.556
- I think that Sometimes making something public is it can feel petty but I do think this is time and

00:35:57.556 --> 00:36:02.270
- after council members Flaherty's kind of high-level view on

00:36:02.530 --> 00:36:09.765
- issues with the administration I did well I think it's hard to just say something you know, like I've

00:36:09.765 --> 00:36:17.000
- lost trust and I think sometimes Examples are important. So I do want to do a dive into an example Of

00:36:17.000 --> 00:36:25.086
- why I too and I think potentially some other other council members are lacking trust with this administration and

00:36:25.218 --> 00:36:31.516
- So in late 2024 and early 2025 for resolutions to amend our unified development ordinance the UDO In

00:36:31.516 --> 00:36:37.752
- accordance with furthering our city's goals and plans housing updates affordability updates climate

00:36:37.752 --> 00:36:43.988
- updates were brought before council two resolutions passed in 2024 without a fuss in March 2025 the

00:36:43.988 --> 00:36:50.286
- other two resolutions were brought before council and voted down on introduction we did not even get

00:36:50.286 --> 00:36:52.094
- a chance to discuss them and

00:36:52.194 --> 00:36:57.961
- The B square bulletin wrote a story that night one because it normally does that write a story and two

00:36:57.961 --> 00:37:03.616
- because it was a very Out-of-character move for City Council. We almost introduced every legislation

00:37:03.616 --> 00:37:09.384
- piece of legislation that comes before us from the B square bulletin This is a quote from the bulletin

00:37:09.384 --> 00:37:15.319
- mayor Thompson told the B square she found out about the resolutions at the same time as a general public

00:37:15.319 --> 00:37:19.966
- when the meeting information packet was released after 5 p.m. On Friday, March 7th

00:37:21.186 --> 00:37:27.100
- These four resolutions were all developed via extensive coordination and collaboration with city staff

00:37:27.100 --> 00:37:33.015
- over the year 2023. Some discussions started with the previous 2024 and some started with the previous

00:37:33.015 --> 00:37:38.757
- administration actually before we were all in office. This is pretty unusual because a lot of a lot

00:37:38.757 --> 00:37:44.958
- of legislation comes either from the administration or from council and there's not a lot of collaboration.

00:37:45.922 --> 00:37:52.766
- Just like for one example and there are many examples of this but an email in August 2024 from the director

00:37:52.766 --> 00:37:59.167
- of planning David Hiddle emailed the council members on Working on these four of us the deputy mayor

00:37:59.167 --> 00:38:05.124
- and the mayor was on the emails but had been dropped He said Thanks for meeting with planning

00:38:05.124 --> 00:38:11.652
- and transportation staff last week to discuss the council's draft list of proposed you deal amendments

00:38:11.652 --> 00:38:15.454
- Here are the follow-up notes following further staff review

00:38:15.682 --> 00:38:22.458
- As P&T staff had already planned to bring forward language, one, updating the methodology for calculating

00:38:22.458 --> 00:38:28.913
- riparian buffer requirements, and two, strictly limiting self-storage as a land use, we could absorb

00:38:28.913 --> 00:38:35.369
- those two items onto our planned staff UDO amendment lift, if so desired by council. Director Hiddle

00:38:35.369 --> 00:38:42.209
- goes on to give updates about what we talked about at one of our meetings for those UDO resolution updates

00:38:42.209 --> 00:38:44.382
- that we were working on together.

00:38:46.274 --> 00:38:54.853
- So I have more on there. I'm sorry, but I want to I Want to keep going on this so that was really hard

00:38:54.853 --> 00:39:03.348
- to understand that quote and after that I had a conversation with one council member And they told me

00:39:03.348 --> 00:39:11.843
- they voted no on introduction because they had talked to the mayor and the mayor told them It was the

00:39:11.843 --> 00:39:12.926
- first time I

00:39:13.506 --> 00:39:20.606
- the resolution, she had seen the resolutions and that they were developed in a vacuum. I was shocked

00:39:20.606 --> 00:39:28.057
- by that because she had been on the emails as well as city staff in the meetings, right? Later I followed

00:39:28.057 --> 00:39:35.227
- up with that council member and I asked, did, I was like, I'm sorry, I'm just clarifying. So like you

00:39:35.227 --> 00:39:42.046
- called the mayor and this happened and they said no, she called me. Then this got a little more,

00:39:42.178 --> 00:39:49.493
- deep right and it's just like it's really hard because there's like no trust there for me but after

00:39:49.493 --> 00:39:56.953
- after I talked to a different council member that one said I asked the mayor if she called anyone and

00:39:56.953 --> 00:40:00.318
- she said she did not so like I it's hard that

00:40:00.482 --> 00:40:10.526
- This is just one example of a place that like all honesty It just feels blown to pieces and I I do follow

00:40:10.526 --> 00:40:20.002
- councilmember Flaherty in that like the lack of trust is so extreme for me. I Want to use a no vote

00:40:20.002 --> 00:40:30.046
- to show that thanks Thank you for your comment are there other councilmember comments Councilmember Rallo

00:40:31.970 --> 00:40:44.889
- I can count the first have you just had questions before? Okay Okay Yes, Mike just briefly I wanted

00:40:44.889 --> 00:40:59.230
- to say that I appreciate the administration and the controller for Meeting the challenges of state legislation

00:40:59.490 --> 00:41:06.608
- Changes in taxation and and and reducing reduced revenue and I appreciate the work that she's done in

00:41:06.608 --> 00:41:13.796
- Navigating that and you've also been very open and responsive to council during the budget process And

00:41:13.796 --> 00:41:21.054
- I I want to extend my appreciation for that as well I appreciate the mayor's efforts to find the proper

00:41:21.054 --> 00:41:27.614
- location for a police station. I voted against showers west purchase that acquisition I think

00:41:27.778 --> 00:41:35.663
- It's yet to be determined how that will play out, but I'm pleased that it is not going to be the location

00:41:35.663 --> 00:41:43.251
- of the police They never wanted to be there. It was inappropriate for them. And then actually I think

00:41:43.251 --> 00:41:50.764
- it was hazardous so I'm I'm very appreciative of that and also appreciative of the mayor's attention

00:41:50.764 --> 00:41:57.310
- to the police the Meeting their needs in other ways as well salary and and so forth and

00:41:57.538 --> 00:42:11.086
- I also wanted to say that I Forgotten what I was going to say that on you know, if my negative comments

00:42:11.086 --> 00:42:24.894
- during the budget were mostly focused on Accounting for past growth and how that affects current fees and

00:42:25.346 --> 00:42:34.102
- Taxes and so forth and and and spending I don't think that we fully account for it it's something that

00:42:34.102 --> 00:42:42.688
- we could work on and I think that I wanted to bring it to the attention of Everyone in the including

00:42:42.688 --> 00:42:51.445
- the administration If there is one thing that I think that we should reconsider in the future in terms

00:42:51.445 --> 00:42:54.590
- of our budgetary constraints that is

00:42:55.170 --> 00:43:04.948
- Whether or not the infrastructure that is available to us right now needs to be redesigned I know that

00:43:04.948 --> 00:43:14.916
- in best times it may be advisable You know in an optimal sense maybe to have a redesign of major streets

00:43:14.916 --> 00:43:24.030
- in Bloomington But is it something that we can afford to do? facing a future probably austerity

00:43:24.546 --> 00:43:33.799
- I think that that discussion Should should be had and I and I've remembered my other comment and that

00:43:33.799 --> 00:43:42.871
- is that The administration has been open to increasing salaries From 2 to 2.7 percent to keep place

00:43:42.871 --> 00:43:52.125
- with cost of living increases and I appreciate that that was no small feat and I I think that was the

00:43:52.125 --> 00:43:54.302
- appropriate thing to do

00:43:54.466 --> 00:44:03.089
- in the past we had not been keeping up and I Would prefer after we've gone through the salary study

00:44:03.089 --> 00:44:11.971
- there were major increases last year that were needed For cost of living I would hate us to get behind

00:44:11.971 --> 00:44:21.370
- incrementally. So so that was a very I Appreciate that very much the administration. So I will be supporting

00:44:21.370 --> 00:44:22.750
- this budget and

00:44:23.458 --> 00:44:33.645
- I think it's a sound budget and And I want to thank the controller again in the administration for presenting

00:44:33.645 --> 00:44:42.998
- it to us Thank you for that comment are there other councilmember comments comes member rough I also

00:44:42.998 --> 00:44:51.518
- want to thank the administration for what I think was you know a real effort at providing a

00:44:51.938 --> 00:45:03.153
- information when it was requested and providing it in a relatively timely way and for for what I think

00:45:03.153 --> 00:45:13.714
- was Compared to certainly compared to some former administration situations it was it was pretty

00:45:13.714 --> 00:45:20.574
- give-and-take I and for I Appreciate it. I I also just want to

00:45:21.090 --> 00:45:30.716
- That I agree with councilman Barallo that if we are really in a time of austerity Throwing large sums

00:45:30.716 --> 00:45:40.625
- of money at redesigning and reengineering existing infrastructure that is Serving the community arguably

00:45:40.625 --> 00:45:49.118
- relatively well Is is not something I support or want to see and I think it's contradicts

00:45:49.826 --> 00:45:58.319
- this the austerity are your concerns and the Uncertainty of future revenues with state with state laws.

00:45:58.319 --> 00:46:07.138
- I just I just cannot see the justification for these large amounts of money They are going towards redesign

00:46:07.138 --> 00:46:15.549
- reengineering and then reconstruction shifts in construction Finally, I just like to say You know when

00:46:15.549 --> 00:46:19.550
- councilman Flaherty made his initial comments on

00:46:20.322 --> 00:46:27.065
- he was asking about the procedure in about the five minutes and whether it be and the clock was running

00:46:27.065 --> 00:46:33.808
- and I don't I don't think that was fair so I would say if Councilmember Flaherty has another 30 seconds

00:46:33.808 --> 00:46:40.487
- of time I think it's fair to add because you shouldn't have been timed during asking You know what our

00:46:40.487 --> 00:46:47.425
- process was going to be Thank you for your comment to clarify councilmember Flaherty in theory has another

00:46:47.425 --> 00:46:49.694
- two minutes if he wanted to take a

00:46:49.826 --> 00:46:58.667
- a second comment but I will leave that up to are there any other comments from council members about

00:46:58.667 --> 00:47:07.683
- appropriation ordinance 2025 11 I'll go ahead and say something short just because I think that I kind

00:47:07.683 --> 00:47:11.710
- of owe it to my constituents to say something

00:47:13.634 --> 00:47:22.605
- I also plan to support this budget this evening, but I do want to say that I appreciate the words from

00:47:22.605 --> 00:47:31.664
- council members Flaherty and Rosenberger just in terms of being upfront and explaining their reasoning.

00:47:31.664 --> 00:47:33.406
- I do feel as though

00:47:33.602 --> 00:47:40.373
- This process has been collaborative, and I have felt like the administration has been responsive to

00:47:40.373 --> 00:47:47.280
- things that I've said, both individually as part of fiscal committee comments and during the question

00:47:47.280 --> 00:47:54.119
- and answer period of the hearings itself. Both, I suppose, responsive to myself, but also responsive

00:47:54.119 --> 00:48:00.958
- to other council members who have raised questions and issues, and I appreciate that responsiveness.

00:48:01.602 --> 00:48:10.815
- I also understand that that disappointment that council members Flaherty and Rosenberger mentioned.

00:48:10.815 --> 00:48:20.582
- But I do think that the administration has tried really hard to to make a budget that was a collaborative

00:48:20.582 --> 00:48:29.150
- effort. So I am planning on supporting this this evening. So if there are no other comments.

00:48:30.082 --> 00:48:43.164
- Will the clerk please call the roll on appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five eleven Flaherty no

00:48:43.164 --> 00:48:56.894
- breath. Yes Rallo. Yes Piedmont Smith. Yes Stasberg. Yes Daly. Yes Zulek. Yes Rosenberger. No, sorry. Yes

00:48:59.298 --> 00:49:06.386
- Thank you. That ordinance passes seven to I move that appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five dash

00:49:06.386 --> 00:49:13.821
- twelve be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only Second, it's been moved and seconded

00:49:13.821 --> 00:49:21.325
- to introduce appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five twelve. All those in favor, please say aye Opposed.

00:49:21.325 --> 00:49:23.966
- Thank you. Will the clerk please read

00:49:25.218 --> 00:49:35.041
- Appropriation ordinance 2025-12 an ordinance for appropriations and tax rates for Bloomington Transportation

00:49:35.041 --> 00:49:44.322
- Corporation for 2026 There's no synopsis I move that appropriation ordinance 2025-12 be adopted Second

00:49:44.322 --> 00:49:50.270
- Thank you who is here tonight for appropriation ordinance 2025 12

00:49:51.330 --> 00:49:58.328
- Good evening. John Connell general manager of Bloomington Public Transportation Corporation here respectfully

00:49:58.328 --> 00:50:04.880
- requesting final approval of the 2026 Bloomington Public Transportation Corporation budget. There have

00:50:04.880 --> 00:50:11.560
- been no changes to the budget since it was last presented. The total budget for 2026 is 19 million three

00:50:11.560 --> 00:50:18.430
- hundred eighty three thousand four hundred and two dollars proposed tax levy of point zero three seven one.

00:50:20.034 --> 00:50:27.473
- Thank you for your consideration Thank you, are there councilmember questions for mr. Connell councilmember

00:50:27.473 --> 00:50:34.500
- Flaherty I did have one and I meant to ask this earlier in the process and I forgot that someone else

00:50:34.500 --> 00:50:41.526
- did forgive me but um, we talked early early in the budget process that the mo you that had agreed to

00:50:41.526 --> 00:50:48.414
- to Commit a certain amount of ed lit funds to Bloomington Transit and a transfer on an annual basis

00:50:48.514 --> 00:50:54.768
- Time we're sunsetting I think at the 2027 and we're correctly if that's wrong 28 I believe 28. Okay.

00:50:54.768 --> 00:51:01.083
- Thank you. And I was curious for your perspective, which I don't think I got on The impact of that if

00:51:01.083 --> 00:51:07.399
- the things that those dollars are supporting now I know some of it was like match dollars for federal

00:51:07.399 --> 00:51:13.838
- grant opportunities for electrification of fleet for instance Yeah, the outlook there I guess with that

00:51:13.838 --> 00:51:17.182
- changing just so we can anticipate appropriately like

00:51:17.410 --> 00:51:25.002
- How that will impact transit how that might impact city decisions on so Previous ed lift funding we've

00:51:25.002 --> 00:51:32.816
- used primarily as matching funds for federal dollars for example in 2025 we Drawn down 24 million dollars

00:51:32.816 --> 00:51:40.335
- in federal funding. So if you look at We have 16 additional battery electric buses. There are million

00:51:40.335 --> 00:51:44.094
- dollars each not to mention the infrastructure and

00:51:44.386 --> 00:51:52.568
- There were two separate grant applications that we were awarded money to buy those purchase those vehicles

00:51:52.568 --> 00:51:59.604
- and without that ED lit funding in place I doubt very seriously that we would have received

00:51:59.604 --> 00:52:07.633
- those discretionary funds as far as the 2025 and 2026 lit funds we've pulled those and we're programming

00:52:07.633 --> 00:52:13.598
- them for local matching funds for our new facility and acquisition of land so

00:52:13.730 --> 00:52:22.955
- When we set out on our strategic plan transform BT All those projects that we're getting ready and this

00:52:22.955 --> 00:52:32.092
- budget does include a hundred thousand dollars to upgrade that or Review and update the strategic plan

00:52:32.092 --> 00:52:41.229
- But a lot of the boxes have been checked in terms of technology the vehicles as a result of the ED lit

00:52:41.229 --> 00:52:43.358
- funding so it truly has

00:52:43.522 --> 00:52:51.192
- allowed us to transform BT One brief follow-up. That's okay. And thank you for is any of it committed

00:52:51.192 --> 00:52:59.012
- to debt service right now or no The microtransit. Yes microtransit services. So this year we have opted

00:52:59.012 --> 00:53:06.682
- to use Internal funding so we could set aside the 3.8 to show The Federal Transit Administration that

00:53:06.682 --> 00:53:13.374
- we do have the local funds in place so knowing how important that was to counsel we have

00:53:13.858 --> 00:53:22.857
- Continued the blink program and the microtransit program and we've absorbed those costs internally Okay.

00:53:22.857 --> 00:53:31.514
- Thank you Thank you. Are there other questions? It's just like to give you an opportunity to reflect

00:53:31.514 --> 00:53:39.742
- on federal and state budget challenges in the future and what You know what we might anticipate

00:53:41.570 --> 00:53:51.426
- Federal funding reauthorization is set for 2026. I don't have a crystal ball. I'm cautiously optimistic.

00:53:51.426 --> 00:54:01.001
- The funding levels will remain pretty consistent, particularly in terms of formula funding. There has

00:54:01.001 --> 00:54:11.326
- been a clear indication that, for example, the low no, the low admission, no admission programs will probably

00:54:11.554 --> 00:54:21.390
- Sunset or just cease to exist But as far as the federal formula funding Like I said, I'm cautiously

00:54:21.390 --> 00:54:31.424
- optimistic that it'll remain at a steady level And just to follow up we've our fleet has transitioned

00:54:31.424 --> 00:54:38.014
- largely to correct either hybrid or to fully electric Yeah over 40

00:54:38.146 --> 00:54:46.959
- Really was 42% of our vehicles now And we have 18 total 16 the newer 16 new buses are 40-foot and why

00:54:46.959 --> 00:54:55.685
- that's important is they have an extra battery pack and we're getting 12 12 hours of State of charge

00:54:55.685 --> 00:55:04.756
- so the vehicle can be out all day. So it's been a fantastic improvement great Well, thank you for moving

00:55:04.756 --> 00:55:08.126
- ahead with that transitioning while we

00:55:09.250 --> 00:55:18.374
- While the landscape allowed us to write to do so Yeah, thank you Are there other councilmember questions

00:55:18.374 --> 00:55:27.238
- All right seeing none, let's go ahead and go to the public for public comment regarding appropriation

00:55:27.238 --> 00:55:29.150
- ordinance 2025 12 and

00:55:29.794 --> 00:55:35.962
- If there are any members of the public in chambers who would like to make a comment, you can make your

00:55:35.962 --> 00:55:42.369
- way to the podium. If you're online, please raise your hand using the reactions tab or send a chat message

00:55:42.369 --> 00:55:48.536
- to the host. I don't see anybody moving in chambers. Is there anybody online with a hand raised? Okay,

00:55:48.536 --> 00:55:54.943
- I'll give it another minute because at the last one there were a couple of last minute hands that suddenly

00:55:54.943 --> 00:55:59.614
- went up. So going once on public comment for appropriation ordinance 2025-12.

00:55:59.778 --> 00:56:09.880
- Going twice. All right. No public comment today. Returning to counsel for any council member comments

00:56:09.880 --> 00:56:20.279
- regarding this appropriation ordinance. All right. Seeing no comments at this time will the clerk please

00:56:20.279 --> 00:56:27.806
- call the roll on appropriation ordinance 2025 12. Council member Roth. Yes.

00:56:29.826 --> 00:56:40.450
- Rollo yes Piedmont Smith yes Stasberg yes Bailey yes Zulik yes Rosenberger yes sorry yes Flaherty yes

00:56:40.450 --> 00:56:50.969
- thank you and that passes with a vote of nine zero I move that appropriation ordinance twenty twenty

00:56:50.969 --> 00:56:59.614
- five dash thirteen be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only.

00:56:59.746 --> 00:57:06.413
- Awesome second so moved and seconded to introduce appropriation ordinance 2025 13 all those in favor

00:57:06.413 --> 00:57:13.145
- please say aye opposed. Thank you. Will the clerk please read appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 13 to

00:57:13.145 --> 00:57:19.746
- transfer funds from the general fund to the fiber connectivity fund and specially appropriate funds

00:57:19.746 --> 00:57:24.894
- not otherwise. That is so absolutely wrong that you guys are going to have to

00:57:25.122 --> 00:57:39.233
- Bear with me because we'll start over with that reading of the title synopsis of 2025 13. Yeah. But

00:57:39.233 --> 00:57:53.345
- do you give me just a moment because I did something very strange here again. Sorry. Okay let's try

00:57:53.345 --> 00:57:55.038
- that again.

00:57:55.490 --> 00:58:02.929
- Preparation ordinance 2025 dash 13 an ordinance adopting a budget for the operation maintenance debt

00:58:02.929 --> 00:58:10.958
- service and capital improvements for the water and wastewater utility departments of the city of Bloomington

00:58:10.958 --> 00:58:18.471
- Indiana for the year 2026. The synopsis is as follows. This ordinance approved by the utility service

00:58:18.471 --> 00:58:23.774
- board in August of 2025 sets the water and wastewater budgets for 2026.

00:58:25.314 --> 00:58:33.156
- Thank you. I move that appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 13 be adopted second. All right. You want to

00:58:33.156 --> 00:58:40.845
- state your name for the record and then you've got the floor. Thank you. All right. Catherine Zager

00:58:40.845 --> 00:58:44.766
- utilities director. Good evening. I am presenting.

00:58:45.250 --> 00:58:53.373
- an ordinance adopting the utilities budget for the year 2026 for both water and wastewater for final

00:58:53.373 --> 00:59:01.496
- approval. The water utility budget for 2026 is twenty three million one hundred and nineteen dollars

00:59:01.496 --> 00:59:09.860
- and the wastewater total budget is thirty four million five hundred and ninety dollars. Happy to answer

00:59:09.860 --> 00:59:14.846
- questions. This remains unchanged from the last presentation.

00:59:18.370 --> 00:59:27.854
- Thank you. Are there any council member questions for directors? Any questions at all. OK. Seeing none

00:59:27.854 --> 00:59:37.430
- at this time we'll just go straight to public comment. There's any members of the public who would like

00:59:37.430 --> 00:59:42.494
- to make a comment on appropriation ordinance 20 25 13.

00:59:42.626 --> 00:59:47.826
- If you're in chambers, you can make your way to the podium. If you're online, you can raise your hand

00:59:47.826 --> 00:59:52.925
- using the reactions tab or send a chat message to the host. I don't see anybody moving in chambers.

00:59:52.925 --> 00:59:58.074
- If you want to make a comment, go ahead and come up to the microphone so I do see somebody moving in

00:59:58.074 --> 01:00:03.173
- chambers. If you want to go ahead and sign in, there should be a sign in sheet there and then state

01:00:03.173 --> 01:00:06.334
- your name for the record and you'll have up to three minutes.

01:00:12.962 --> 01:00:21.064
- Hi council. My name is Joshua Stockton. I do work at the water treatment plant. I did have a comment.

01:00:21.064 --> 01:00:29.008
- I wanted to formally invite all of you to come take a tour soon whether it all be together or a few

01:00:29.008 --> 01:00:37.110
- of you at a time and I would love to personally show you around and show you everything that you guys

01:00:37.110 --> 01:00:42.750
- really do need to see and I would highly recommend that you guys go to

01:00:43.074 --> 01:00:52.510
- the wastewater treatment plant and you discuss with all of our utility staff all the problems all the

01:00:52.510 --> 01:01:01.853
- concerns anything that we have because I personally feel that there is a separation I Feel like that

01:01:01.853 --> 01:01:11.104
- is something that has been brought up tonight that we do have transparency issues and It's not just

01:01:11.104 --> 01:01:12.862
- towards the public

01:01:13.122 --> 01:01:25.454
- I think it's within our own organization as well and that's why I ask you to come come tour Thank you

01:01:25.454 --> 01:01:37.182
- Thank you Are there any anybody who's raised her hand on zoom Anybody else in chambers then Okay

01:01:38.786 --> 01:01:45.399
- We'll revert back to council then if there are councilmember comments regarding appropriation ordinance

01:01:45.399 --> 01:01:51.948
- 2025 13 Councilmember Flaherty sure. Thank you. Thank you for the comment first Just uh, I have toured

01:01:51.948 --> 01:01:58.370
- those facilities at previously though. It's been a number of years. I really enjoyed it. So plug for

01:01:58.370 --> 01:02:05.173
- that Thank you to Director Zager and the city movement in utilities staff and just wanted to speak briefly

01:02:05.173 --> 01:02:08.670
- with respect to the board in particular as I serve and

01:02:09.346 --> 01:02:15.976
- as our ex-physio non-voting seat on the utility service board. Just that I have a lot of confidence

01:02:15.976 --> 01:02:22.673
- in that board. I get to see them every other week, which you all don't necessarily. And I think they

01:02:22.673 --> 01:02:29.369
- do a great job. It's really balanced. I think diligence is a word that comes to mind. They're asking

01:02:29.369 --> 01:02:36.464
- detailed and thoughtful questions. And they are ensuring that they follow up on things that are unresolved

01:02:36.464 --> 01:02:38.718
- in the meeting, you know, months.

01:02:38.914 --> 01:02:46.108
- Years down the line if needed. So just wanted to share that and give kudos to the board members Since

01:02:46.108 --> 01:02:53.372
- I am our laser. Thanks Great. Thank you. Are there other councilmember comments? All right seeing none

01:02:53.372 --> 01:03:00.425
- I also just want to Thank mr. Stockton for the invitation to tour and I appreciate that he came and

01:03:00.425 --> 01:03:08.254
- commented this evening So with that if the clerk could please call the roll on appropriation ordinance 2025 13

01:03:09.506 --> 01:03:21.824
- Councilmember Rallo. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Stossberg. Yes. Daily. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Rosenberger.

01:03:21.824 --> 01:03:31.678
- Yes. Sorry. Yes. Clarity. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Thank you. And that passes nine zero.

01:03:32.962 --> 01:03:40.955
- That brings us to the end of our legislation for this evening. And so now we are down to the elected

01:03:40.955 --> 01:03:48.949
- official salary discussion topic. So as preface for this over the weekend council members were asked

01:03:48.949 --> 01:03:52.510
- a kind of series of questions focused on the

01:03:53.634 --> 01:04:00.098
- the process last year with the ad hoc committee and some of the conclusions that they came to. And so

01:04:00.098 --> 01:04:06.435
- that was released in a packet addendum yesterday. And so for this discussion this evening, I wanted

01:04:06.435 --> 01:04:13.088
- to first start with statements from the mayor and the clerk regarding their thoughts on elected official

01:04:13.088 --> 01:04:19.425
- salaries for the year 2026. So if we want to go ahead and start with the mayor for that and come on

01:04:19.425 --> 01:04:22.974
- forward and probably introduce yourself for the record.

01:04:23.074 --> 01:04:36.146
- And go ahead and share your thoughts with us on the matter Tall microphone, I'm Carrie Thompson. I'm

01:04:36.146 --> 01:04:49.347
- the mayor I've been asked tonight to comment on the salary ordinance and I appreciate the opportunity

01:04:49.347 --> 01:04:51.806
- to address you and

01:04:52.418 --> 01:05:00.661
- Given the same opportunity last year, I asked council to establish principles by which elected officials'

01:05:00.661 --> 01:05:08.593
- salaries would be evaluated each year. I am requesting the same of you this year. I have run multiple

01:05:08.593 --> 01:05:15.358
- organizations and salaries are best set with a single comprehensive set of principles.

01:05:15.650 --> 01:05:23.148
- Our non-union staff salaries at the city are set based on market, and while we can all agree that I

01:05:23.148 --> 01:05:30.795
- cannot shop around for a new mayor's job in another city any more than one of you can run for council

01:05:30.795 --> 01:05:38.368
- in another city, those salaries of other municipalities do inform at least our awareness of where we

01:05:38.368 --> 01:05:45.566
- rank. The Association of Indiana Municipalities tracks those for us, and in their last ranking,

01:05:46.050 --> 01:05:55.310
- of salaries of elected officials. Our current mayoral salary ranks sixth in the state and will be seventh

01:05:55.310 --> 01:06:04.046
- once Indianapolis implements their time delayed raise. Our council ranks seventh as well. Our clerk

01:06:04.046 --> 01:06:08.414
- is ranked third, third highest paid in the state.

01:06:09.058 --> 01:06:16.156
- Should we go with market, I would suggest that we adjust electeds for population size and scope of job

01:06:16.156 --> 01:06:23.047
- as not all electeds have the same level of responsibility as their counterparts. It should be noted

01:06:23.047 --> 01:06:30.008
- that once we raise salaries for elected officials, we are unable to decrease them. So it's important

01:06:30.008 --> 01:06:36.899
- for the public to understand that this is a one-way trajectory and we must be careful to understand

01:06:36.899 --> 01:06:37.726
- it as such.

01:06:39.586 --> 01:06:46.092
- It has been suggested that the clerk and I should get paid based on the equivalencies of department

01:06:46.092 --> 01:06:52.598
- heads. I want to first note that we have three department heads that are already underpaid based on

01:06:52.598 --> 01:06:59.105
- our current salary structure. Their responsibilities combined with their tenure would put them at a

01:06:59.105 --> 01:07:05.676
- level that far exceeds what they're making now. And last year we decided to cap the salaries so that

01:07:05.676 --> 01:07:08.734
- the highest paid city employee makes $155,000.

01:07:09.666 --> 01:07:18.602
- putting us into a department head calculus would be complicated to be sure, and I'm not sure there's

01:07:18.602 --> 01:07:27.892
- actually an equivalency for council. I wanted to note that some comments in the council survey indicated

01:07:27.892 --> 01:07:37.182
- that there was a consultant used, and I will note that the consultant's advice included a recommendation

01:07:37.346 --> 01:07:44.706
- to consider other Indiana elected salaries. This was very common sense advice which was not incorporated

01:07:44.706 --> 01:07:51.785
- into the recommendations. Given that we are elected public servants and we all got into this knowing

01:07:51.785 --> 01:07:58.934
- what it would pay before we ran, my suggestion for this year is that we each take a 2.7% COLA that is

01:07:58.934 --> 01:08:01.598
- being offered to the other employees.

01:08:02.338 --> 01:08:09.123
- It's a priority of councils to establish working principles moving forward in order to restructure elected

01:08:09.123 --> 01:08:15.655
- officials' salaries with a predictable metric each year. I would be happy to work on a team that seeks

01:08:15.655 --> 01:08:22.059
- to set those parameters. Given that we have not done that work this year, I suggest COLA is the best

01:08:22.059 --> 01:08:28.401
- way to move forward, especially given the funding realities that we are facing moving forward under

01:08:28.401 --> 01:08:30.430
- SEA-1. Thank you for your time.

01:08:32.642 --> 01:08:40.125
- Thank you. I also want to say that when we after the mayor and and then after the clerk goes with a

01:08:40.125 --> 01:08:47.759
- statement both of those parties are also invited to participate in the less formal discussion part of

01:08:47.759 --> 01:08:55.467
- this so We're gonna move to the clerk now though Okay Good evening. My name is clerk Nicole Bolden and

01:08:55.467 --> 01:08:59.358
- I am NOT going to have nearly as Composed statement

01:08:59.874 --> 01:09:05.616
- to start off with as Mayor Thompson did, so please forgive me for that. But there were a few points

01:09:05.616 --> 01:09:11.646
- that I wanted to touch base on for this evening in terms of talking about the elected official salaries.

01:09:11.646 --> 01:09:17.790
- One, and I made this point earlier during the fiscal committee meeting, I think it would be a good process

01:09:17.790 --> 01:09:23.590
- to actually separate out into rather having one ordinance where you're looking at all of the elected

01:09:23.590 --> 01:09:26.174
- official salaries, but to separate them out.

01:09:26.274 --> 01:09:32.525
- so that you have a separate ordinance for the common council one for the mayor salary and one for the

01:09:32.525 --> 01:09:38.714
- clerk salary that would allow all of you to have separate negotiations. And if there comes a problem

01:09:38.714 --> 01:09:45.209
- in the future you won't have to go through the process of dividing the question which can be complicated.

01:09:45.209 --> 01:09:51.521
- And while it has come up before in the past I think it was in twenty twenty two or twenty twenty three

01:09:51.521 --> 01:09:55.198
- where it was proposed but discarded as being too difficult.

01:09:55.650 --> 01:10:04.021
- I've said it a few times over the last week or so. I think that considering where we are with SBA one

01:10:04.021 --> 01:10:12.392
- I think it makes more sense to do cola increases to parallel that of the civil city staff for elected

01:10:12.392 --> 01:10:14.526
- officials moving forward.

01:10:14.882 --> 01:10:21.777
- Until such time as we have a better idea of what we're doing or until we're looking at 20 28 for elected

01:10:21.777 --> 01:10:29.001
- official salaries for those who are coming in after having run for office And being given a clear opportunity

01:10:29.001 --> 01:10:35.831
- to state what they think their salaries should be That will help to inform any voters or people running

01:10:35.831 --> 01:10:42.858
- as to what they would like to see I know that last year when the fiscal committee was looking at different

01:10:42.858 --> 01:10:43.646
- processes I

01:10:44.194 --> 01:10:50.943
- offered some perspectives on the different considerations that were made. I will continue to do so if

01:10:50.943 --> 01:10:57.758
- you have any opinions about it. I hesitate even as a board member of Accelerate Indiana municipalities

01:10:57.758 --> 01:11:04.441
- I would hesitate to use their salary study as the guide. I think again going to the source materials

01:11:04.441 --> 01:11:11.323
- and having all the salary ordinances to compare the numbers for if you're looking at other second class

01:11:11.323 --> 01:11:13.374
- cities is probably the smarter

01:11:13.474 --> 01:11:21.423
- way to go because the aim salary study is self-reported. You can also go to Gateway and get the salary

01:11:21.423 --> 01:11:29.372
- information from there. And last two things one like Mayor Thompson happy to work on a team answer any

01:11:29.372 --> 01:11:37.707
- questions that you may have. And to the point because I saw it in the answers we all knew what our salaries

01:11:37.707 --> 01:11:41.566
- were going to be when they ran. Of course we did.

01:11:42.498 --> 01:11:49.155
- It's not hidden, it's very public. I think it's very important to have that discussion. But you do not

01:11:49.155 --> 01:11:56.071
- as a body pass your salary ordinances over the course of your term. You pass it every year. If you weren't

01:11:56.071 --> 01:12:02.600
- planning on changing the salaries, you could pass one ordinance at the start of this body's term and

01:12:02.600 --> 01:12:09.063
- say, we're going to only do COLA increases for the next four years or until the composition of this

01:12:09.063 --> 01:12:11.390
- body changes. You have not done so.

01:12:11.490 --> 01:12:19.426
- So saying well you knew what it was going to be when you ran also knowing it can change every year seems

01:12:19.426 --> 01:12:27.060
- to be having it both ways. And again I would like to reiterate I am not asking for a salary increase

01:12:27.060 --> 01:12:34.694
- this year. I think a cola increase is absolutely appropriate and I'm happy to help or participate in

01:12:34.694 --> 01:12:38.398
- any further discussion. OK. Thank you very much.

01:12:39.842 --> 01:12:48.328
- So I think part of this discussion is to be able to do it in a less formal way than we of course do

01:12:48.328 --> 01:12:56.985
- legislation. But we are all up here in a line and it's really hard to see folks if you're speaking at

01:12:56.985 --> 01:13:01.822
- the end of the line. So who would like to start with any

01:13:01.954 --> 01:13:08.475
- Any reflections that you want to say about your own things any questions that we might have for each

01:13:08.475 --> 01:13:15.061
- other or for the clerk or the mayor? Hopefully everybody got a chance to review the survey answers So

01:13:15.061 --> 01:13:21.518
- if anybody has questions for other council members about those survey answers like like this is the

01:13:21.518 --> 01:13:27.006
- moment Councilmember Piedmont Smith I'm just looking at number six on the survey and

01:13:27.202 --> 01:13:35.729
- Which says given the uncertain financial future of Indiana cities in light of SCA one Do you think elected

01:13:35.729 --> 01:13:44.096
- officials should receive at most a two point seven percent cola increase for twenty twenty six and there

01:13:44.096 --> 01:13:52.702
- were seven Council members who said yes and two who said no So I think it's pretty clear that a majority of

01:13:53.602 --> 01:14:03.301
- would like to have no more than the COLA increase. So I think we can kind of start there and then because

01:14:03.301 --> 01:14:12.817
- we do have to, you know, make a decision without having any further certainty about our revenue future,

01:14:12.817 --> 01:14:21.967
- which looks kind of grim right now. So we can perhaps agree on that and then move on to think about

01:14:21.967 --> 01:14:22.974
- how we can

01:14:23.842 --> 01:14:31.399
- further develop a principled, repeatable system for setting salaries in the future. Although I would

01:14:31.399 --> 01:14:39.031
- say to respond to the mayor, I think the committee last year did have a set of principles. If we look

01:14:39.031 --> 01:14:46.589
- at other survey answers, I don't think everybody agreed with them. But going back to this number six

01:14:46.589 --> 01:14:52.350
- and the maximum increase of a COLA, I was one of the two people who said no.

01:14:52.642 --> 01:15:01.723
- But I think I was, I didn't think through it fully because if we do any further increase this year,

01:15:01.723 --> 01:15:10.896
- of course that's gonna carry forward to our salaries for 27 and 28 and 29 when SEA 1 is really gonna

01:15:10.896 --> 01:15:19.614
- hit us hard. So I think I would change that to a yes now. So anyway, that's what I want to say.

01:15:22.050 --> 01:15:30.835
- So I think that's kind of a proposal by councilmember Piedmont Smith to just do a cola for our Ordinance

01:15:30.835 --> 01:15:39.286
- next year and that most people agreed with that. I think I just look through councilmember Flaherty.

01:15:39.286 --> 01:15:46.398
- Are you the other no on that? Probably I speak briefly to it. I almost find it to be

01:15:47.490 --> 01:15:52.928
- Directly oppositional to the first question which is should the council create a values-based and repeatable

01:15:52.928 --> 01:15:58.117
- method for setting salaries Departing from recent past practice of making minor adjustments to salaries

01:15:58.117 --> 01:16:03.156
- based primarily and whatever the salary was the year before plus a cola That's saying should we have

01:16:03.156 --> 01:16:08.295
- a values-based framework? And move away from just using cola and I think most people said yes And then

01:16:08.295 --> 01:16:13.534
- when we're asked if we should just use the cola for this year. Most people also said yes those seem like

01:16:13.730 --> 01:16:19.775
- diametrically opposed points of view. I think my votes were consistent. That's not to call anyone out

01:16:19.775 --> 01:16:25.821
- or like I'm just reflecting. And I think the reason I would say is that it's just the wrong question.

01:16:25.821 --> 01:16:32.222
- I mean, maybe we have no increase this year. That's fine too. It doesn't really matter. I'm most interested

01:16:32.222 --> 01:16:38.445
- in a values-based and repeatable method, and settling that in some way is, I guess, my highest priority,

01:16:38.445 --> 01:16:42.238
- and the COLA seems a little bit immaterial to that, or at least

01:16:43.938 --> 01:16:51.157
- follows it I guess. Okay. Would anybody else like to speak to that kind of dichotomy of saying well

01:16:51.157 --> 01:16:58.377
- we want a values based framework but yeah we also think that we should only get a cola this year. I

01:16:58.377 --> 01:17:05.596
- would like to point out question number seven was like if you answered yes to both of those can you

01:17:05.596 --> 01:17:12.382
- talk about that. So would anybody like to eat and see that now. Councilmember Piedmont Smith.

01:17:14.114 --> 01:17:23.135
- Well, I'm the one who wrote these questions and I'm not a professional survey taker. I think what I,

01:17:23.135 --> 01:17:32.156
- a creator of surveys, I think what I was getting at was, in principle, do you think we should have a

01:17:32.156 --> 01:17:41.266
- systemic values-based and repeatable method for setting salaries, yes or no? And then the second part

01:17:41.266 --> 01:17:43.678
- was specifically for 2026,

01:17:44.386 --> 01:17:52.398
- Since it's already October and there's been a lot of disagreement in SEA 1 and all this stuff, do you

01:17:52.398 --> 01:18:00.410
- think we should just have a COLA? So I think you could still answer yes, we should only do a COLA for

01:18:00.410 --> 01:18:08.737
- next year. But I do ultimately want to see a principles-based, values-driven system for setting salaries.

01:18:08.737 --> 01:18:11.486
- I think you could say yes to both.

01:18:13.730 --> 01:18:20.544
- But if they contradict, I'm sorry. I'll just do my best. Would anybody else like to speak to

01:18:20.544 --> 01:18:28.237
- that? Councilmember Ruff. Yeah, thank you. Yeah, I don't I don't see the contradiction. As Councilmember

01:18:28.237 --> 01:18:35.711
- Piedmont Smith said, it wasn't saying immediately we need to do this. As a matter of fact, the follow

01:18:35.711 --> 01:18:43.038
- up question is if you answered yes to number one and number six, what do you think is the timeline?

01:18:43.170 --> 01:18:50.208
- For one I just tossed out two to three years knowing that this would take time to to figure out what

01:18:50.208 --> 01:18:57.177
- a values-based Approach might be and maybe then it wouldn't even work after wrestling with it for a

01:18:57.177 --> 01:19:04.494
- while But I I don't see that they're contradictory to have answered the way that the majority of council

01:19:04.494 --> 01:19:09.790
- members answered Any other comments about that council member Rosenberger I

01:19:10.146 --> 01:19:18.226
- Hi thanks I would say I was a little confused about number six so you just can ignore my response honestly

01:19:18.226 --> 01:19:25.928
- I think on that one because I felt like number seven if you entered yes to number one numbers one and

01:19:25.928 --> 01:19:33.630
- six why do you think it's a good. Oh what do you think is a good time. I felt like number seven meant

01:19:35.394 --> 01:19:42.109
- Wanted to know went together honestly because I was like, oh, maybe I'm not understanding number six

01:19:42.109 --> 01:19:48.957
- correctly I guess basically so I'm sorry about that councilmember Piedmont Smith. I Do also align more

01:19:48.957 --> 01:19:55.606
- with councilmember Flaherty just that I think the creating the principles is really important and I

01:19:55.606 --> 01:20:02.254
- Think the work that was done last year like reviewing that work in these questions, right? Like the

01:20:02.254 --> 01:20:05.246
- first questions are those principles I think

01:20:05.442 --> 01:20:14.731
- I think they still hold pretty strong for me and I I guess hope that if the committee continues down

01:20:14.731 --> 01:20:24.204
- that path of making I guess a different framework I hope that's not thrown out and still used as valid

01:20:24.204 --> 01:20:32.574
- work that got done. Thank you. Other comments right now I think I'm going to try to try to

01:20:32.994 --> 01:20:38.932
- Bring us back if that's possible to that original maybe proposal that I mentioned which was that the

01:20:38.932 --> 01:20:44.811
- majority of folks seem to say a two point seven percent COLA increase though councilmember Flaherty

01:20:44.811 --> 01:20:50.926
- also just threw out the concept of no increase at all. I don't know if you meant to do that but there's

01:20:50.926 --> 01:20:53.630
- also the concept of no increase because it is

01:20:53.986 --> 01:21:00.601
- Accurate that that question did say at most a 2.7 percent cola increase and I also think that I remember

01:21:00.601 --> 01:21:06.963
- councilmember daily may be mentioning that last Time when we talked about this at all the concept of

01:21:06.963 --> 01:21:13.452
- no increase And it you know that that maybe you'd be okay with a 2.7 percent increase but no more than

01:21:13.452 --> 01:21:20.003
- that if I'm remembering your Yeah, I think my comments had been before we even mentioned cola increase.

01:21:20.003 --> 01:21:22.334
- Yeah, so it hadn't been on my mind I

01:21:23.074 --> 01:21:30.332
- I think I would be fine either way as well. I wouldn't have a problem with no increase but I wouldn't

01:21:30.332 --> 01:21:37.590
- fight a cola increase either. I'm interested to know what the clerk or the mayor would think about no

01:21:37.590 --> 01:21:45.630
- increase at all not even a cola increase. Do either I mean you guys don't have to answer that. I'm just curious.

01:21:52.130 --> 01:22:03.907
- Do you mean for next year? Yeah Yeah, I think there should be a coal increase for the clerk salary Mayor

01:22:03.907 --> 01:22:15.236
- Thompson I just am gonna stay consistent with what I've said in the past, which is I think we should

01:22:15.236 --> 01:22:22.078
- be as consistent across the organization as we can be and so

01:22:22.370 --> 01:22:32.076
- we did two point seven for the rest of the non-union city staff and So my recommendation would be Do

01:22:32.076 --> 01:22:42.359
- cola for electeds? I'm also fine without it Okay, thank you. Do other people have thoughts on that concept

01:22:42.359 --> 01:22:48.894
- of a of a no increase versus Cola increase councilmember Rallo Well

01:22:49.442 --> 01:22:58.945
- Councilmember Ruff is probably gonna say what I'll say As he is want to say if We don't give a coal

01:22:58.945 --> 01:23:08.922
- increase then it is essentially a pay cut so if that is the intention of anyone's salary, then I I guess

01:23:08.922 --> 01:23:17.950
- there's a discrepancy between There is a they were overpaid and so, you know, we should try to

01:23:18.242 --> 01:23:26.794
- Rainback and you know someone's salary or something like that the only time that I think the council

01:23:26.794 --> 01:23:35.686
- did not take a coal increase was during the 20 2008 2009 Economic crisis where we were Really struggling

01:23:35.686 --> 01:23:44.492
- fortunately did not have to eliminate any jobs but we made me some major cuts and one of those happened

01:23:44.492 --> 01:23:47.710
- to be our cost of living increase and

01:23:47.906 --> 01:23:54.306
- Don't see any need for that. I think that we should just keep up with the cost of living as everyone

01:23:54.306 --> 01:24:01.150
- should My position Councilmember rough. Did you also want to speak? That's what I was about to say actually

01:24:01.150 --> 01:24:07.931
- All right. We have a ditto over there from councilmember rough. Anybody else want to comment councilmember

01:24:07.931 --> 01:24:14.458
- Zulek? Thank you. I'm in favor of keeping a consistent approach across the board and thus I'm in favor

01:24:14.458 --> 01:24:17.310
- of a 2.7 percent cola increase. Thank you. I

01:24:18.946 --> 01:24:28.357
- Anybody else want to address Cola versus nothing. OK. I'm not hearing anybody really advocate strongly

01:24:28.357 --> 01:24:37.494
- for nothing. Is that correct right now. Anybody wants to advocate strongly for nothing like this is

01:24:37.494 --> 01:24:45.534
- the moment to let the fiscal committee know this is what you that you want nothing. OK.

01:24:46.210 --> 01:24:52.202
- we did talk about this at fiscal committee a little bit earlier in terms of trying to like think about

01:24:52.202 --> 01:24:58.019
- this survey and think about long-term and how Like the goals of having this conversation. So one of

01:24:58.019 --> 01:25:03.953
- the goals was What should we put in this ordinance? in terms of an increase so I think the conclusion

01:25:03.953 --> 01:25:09.770
- that we just came to was as was reflected in the survey reflected right now into the discussion and

01:25:09.770 --> 01:25:15.646
- reflected by the mayor and the clerk was all the 2.7 percent COLA increase so that kind of meets our

01:25:15.874 --> 01:25:26.472
- number one objective from fiscal committee right councilmember Piedmont Smith and then our number two

01:25:26.472 --> 01:25:36.966
- objective was looking in to more of the future and Was that the next one as we were going to go back

01:25:36.966 --> 01:25:45.278
- to question number one, right? I mean several of the questions do you deal with

01:25:45.922 --> 01:25:53.605
- How do we come up in the in the future for future years? How do we come up with a systemic way of setting

01:25:53.605 --> 01:26:01.144
- salaries? That's Not arbitrary So yes that starts with question one, okay So in question one where most

01:26:01.144 --> 01:26:08.755
- of us seem to say like yes We want to create some kind of values based and repeatable method for setting

01:26:08.755 --> 01:26:14.046
- salaries I don't think that the clerk commented on that strongly in your

01:26:14.754 --> 01:26:21.485
- Commented on the idea of in the future having a repeatable process based on our values In terms of like

01:26:21.485 --> 01:26:27.956
- a goal for future years the mayor did say and hers like yes, something like that would be great but

01:26:27.956 --> 01:26:34.622
- the question is like What are the guiding principles essentially? So last year we created some guiding

01:26:34.622 --> 01:26:40.382
- principles as part of that if I remember right last year, I don't I don't think that the

01:26:41.090 --> 01:26:47.388
- The guiding principles I think were not beloved by everybody And that's that is also reflected in the

01:26:47.388 --> 01:26:53.624
- survey though. I think the majority of people either agree or are neutral on on them but the I think

01:26:53.624 --> 01:26:59.983
- that that's the next question is if part of what we want to do moving forward is create something like

01:26:59.983 --> 01:27:06.466
- that and if part of what the fiscal committee is supposed to do is Kind of work on that stuff throughout

01:27:06.466 --> 01:27:07.454
- the year and it

01:27:07.554 --> 01:27:15.998
- takes a while to figure that out. So what kinds of guiding principles or values do we want to use. If

01:27:15.998 --> 01:27:24.441
- you disagreed with some of the ones from last year like talk about that Councilmember Piedmont Smith.

01:27:24.441 --> 01:27:32.802
- Well I'm not responding from my own perspective I'm responding from what I've I've heard and read in

01:27:32.802 --> 01:27:37.438
- the survey and I think that several council members and

01:27:37.762 --> 01:27:46.466
- the mayor as well have said that we should one principle or one consideration should be what the salaries

01:27:46.466 --> 01:27:54.759
- are in other second class cities. And that was not considered last year. And I think I don't know if

01:27:54.759 --> 01:28:02.642
- it's a majority but I've heard it from several people up here. Would anybody else like to speak

01:28:02.642 --> 01:28:05.598
- to comparisons. Council member all.

01:28:08.354 --> 01:28:17.069
- Yeah, I think that I prove first of all, I want to say I appreciate the work that was done that council

01:28:17.069 --> 01:28:25.449
- committee But I think that its major shortcoming was lack of context and comparison so I Think that

01:28:25.449 --> 01:28:34.415
- had we adopted the proposed salary for the council would have essentially doubled our current then current

01:28:34.415 --> 01:28:38.270
- salary And We would be an outlier we would be

01:28:38.402 --> 01:28:48.947
- the highest paid council in the state now one possibility is other cities have a flawed process of Evaluating

01:28:48.947 --> 01:28:58.821
- salaries Another is that We're an outlier because of greater workload so more frequent longer meetings

01:28:58.821 --> 01:29:03.902
- committee assignments, etc. And that that is true so

01:29:04.098 --> 01:29:11.756
- Just want to say I'm open to considering information related to those possibilities going forward You

01:29:11.756 --> 01:29:19.715
- know that means very passionate comments were made that you know many Public servants have been underpaid

01:29:19.715 --> 01:29:27.373
- and that's generally the case in a lot of cities. So that's Possibility it's interesting. I'd like to

01:29:27.373 --> 01:29:32.478
- know more about that. I don't know I haven't reviewed that you know

01:29:32.642 --> 01:29:43.056
- In-depth the the workloads of those cities for instance, so So that's what I would like to see going

01:29:43.056 --> 01:29:53.470
- forward I I think that the process might be better just left in the hands of a objective third party

01:29:53.470 --> 01:30:00.894
- so You know consultants Occasionally evaluate salaries and determine on

01:30:01.282 --> 01:30:15.454
- Maybe a basis of, as we said, but what that amount should be. That's all. Thanks. Thank you. Other thoughts on that?

01:30:20.194 --> 01:30:25.403
- I just want to say I don't love the idea of leaving it in the hands of an objective third party, i.e.

01:30:25.403 --> 01:30:30.510
- a consultant, because then we'd have to pay a consultant. And it just kind of gawls me, the idea of

01:30:30.510 --> 01:30:35.872
- paying a consultant to figure out how much we're paid. It feels like kind of like an unwise expenditure,

01:30:35.872 --> 01:30:41.183
- especially to do on a regular basis, like a one time every once in a while, like the city did last year

01:30:41.183 --> 01:30:46.341
- in terms of having that large assessment. It seems reasonable, but to do it on a regular basis seems

01:30:46.341 --> 01:30:49.150
- a little bit wonky. Clerk Bolden, did I see your hand?

01:30:49.730 --> 01:30:59.138
- Go for it. I do not envy you all your task of trying to figure out what things to include in looking

01:30:59.138 --> 01:31:08.546
- at salaries. I do know that last year you looked at the salaries for all second class cities and you

01:31:08.546 --> 01:31:17.022
- looked at their salary data for the mayor the council president the council and the clerk.

01:31:17.154 --> 01:31:24.380
- You also looked at the elected official salaries over the year for the city of Bloomington for all appointees

01:31:24.380 --> 01:31:31.145
- of the mayor and staff. You looked at the councils by frequency for second class cities and broke down

01:31:31.145 --> 01:31:38.042
- their population and their council salaries. And there was also looking at the percentage of the mayoral

01:31:38.042 --> 01:31:44.611
- salary and you also looked at it in terms of pay per regular meeting. So the information was looked

01:31:44.611 --> 01:31:46.910
- at in a variety of different ways.

01:31:47.202 --> 01:31:53.301
- and considerations so I just for the sake of the fiscal committee who put in hours of work looking at

01:31:53.301 --> 01:31:59.339
- this information it wasn't a case of not having the information and not looking at it. They actually

01:31:59.339 --> 01:32:05.498
- took the time to review all of that information and discuss it as part of their settings. I would also

01:32:05.498 --> 01:32:11.835
- include if you are going to look at it in terms of different cities you should also look at the different

01:32:11.835 --> 01:32:16.798
- costs of living in those different cities because doing a street apples for apples

01:32:17.250 --> 01:32:25.773
- Considering that Bloomington's cost of living is higher than other cities Would be doing a disservice

01:32:25.773 --> 01:32:34.129
- to well all of you and there was one thing I forgot to say at the beginning of my statement If it's

01:32:34.129 --> 01:32:42.652
- not too late to add it. I Do think that the council should be paid more Period Although not this year

01:32:42.652 --> 01:32:46.078
- Thank you are there other comments about

01:32:46.434 --> 01:32:53.800
- Both the need to consider peer cities which councilmember Piedmont Smith brought up or other comments

01:32:53.800 --> 01:33:01.310
- related to establishment of guiding principles Or the specific guiding principles that were established

01:33:01.310 --> 01:33:08.675
- last year So I would I would be especially interested to hear from some people who said that they did

01:33:08.675 --> 01:33:12.286
- that they disagreed with the different principles

01:33:14.050 --> 01:33:20.795
- just to get a better idea of like why they disagreed with them. And I guess like I don't want to call

01:33:20.795 --> 01:33:27.539
- people out necessarily with with this but I know that Mayor Thompson also said that last year I think

01:33:27.539 --> 01:33:34.813
- I remember her saying that shouldn't necessarily like agree with these guiding principles like as principles.

01:33:34.813 --> 01:33:41.822
- So I guess I'm really curious to understand more about that moving forward and creating a set that people

01:33:41.822 --> 01:33:43.806
- are in better alignment with.

01:33:45.474 --> 01:33:54.926
- Sorry, I don't know if I'm going to address your question, but I think maybe Two or three and we'll

01:33:54.926 --> 01:34:05.040
- see how related their thoughts I Think the first maybe a broad question that we should evaluate is whether

01:34:05.040 --> 01:34:08.254
- there's any mechanisms for us and

01:34:08.578 --> 01:34:15.460
- whether there are any mechanisms for us to raise our salary in some way that's not permanent.

01:34:15.460 --> 01:34:23.001
- And so I know, so is there a way that you have like, you know, yearly increases or tagged to something

01:34:23.001 --> 01:34:30.323
- that floats with a baseline salary and code or something like that might help address those issues?

01:34:30.323 --> 01:34:37.278
- And I should have said that second because I think, you know, I would say that we shouldn't be

01:34:38.562 --> 01:34:45.419
- We don't need to be zero-sum with critique of a value-based statement. So if people came up with a committee

01:34:45.419 --> 01:34:52.088
- last year, worked hard, and came up with four statements, and the fact that, like, yeah, there's problems

01:34:52.088 --> 01:34:58.505
- with each of those, maybe not collectively held, but I can say, OK, there's an issue with this claim.

01:34:58.505 --> 01:35:04.922
- There's an issue with that claim. They might create other inequities. They create other problems that

01:35:04.922 --> 01:35:06.558
- we can't quite adjust to.

01:35:06.658 --> 01:35:13.452
- But that's not a zero-sum critique. It's not like, oh, because there's a problem with it, we should

01:35:13.452 --> 01:35:20.449
- reject it. We have to keep working on it and figure out how do we actually put this into practice. But

01:35:20.449 --> 01:35:27.379
- I say all of that, though, with I think we have to balance out. There's a little bit of maybe like an

01:35:27.379 --> 01:35:32.542
- epistemological tension, which is that we started with a sort of assumption

01:35:32.674 --> 01:35:39.005
- And I even just phrased it with the way I phrased my first question, which is that we're creating a

01:35:39.005 --> 01:35:41.854
- value-based way to set salaries but with the

01:35:42.018 --> 01:35:48.520
- generally held assumption that we need to raise them. And so as a consequence, we're almost like trying

01:35:48.520 --> 01:35:54.835
- to argue like, why should we raise our salaries? And some of the arguments that were made or some of

01:35:54.835 --> 01:36:01.462
- the claims that were made, some of the positions that were put forward might actually result in us coming

01:36:01.462 --> 01:36:06.526
- up with an answer that is roughly where we're at now. And I kind of feel like we

01:36:06.626 --> 01:36:13.201
- reject that as a possible outcome of looking at those four that have been proposed. But I certainly

01:36:13.201 --> 01:36:20.170
- just think that in this conversation, it's not like reject all the things that are on the table or accept

01:36:20.170 --> 01:36:26.744
- them. It doesn't feel super productive. The question is just like, if you're going to accept any of

01:36:26.744 --> 01:36:33.582
- those, how are you going to address the genuine concerns or the gaps that might exist with any of those

01:36:33.582 --> 01:36:36.606
- proposals if you think that those gaps exist?

01:36:37.666 --> 01:36:44.111
- So a little bit incoherent all over the place but Thank you I do want to say that as in terms of your

01:36:44.111 --> 01:36:50.493
- last comment of like starting with the assumption that we should raise salaries I think last year on

01:36:50.493 --> 01:36:56.812
- that ad hoc committee because I was on it. We didn't start with that assumption We started from the

01:36:56.812 --> 01:37:03.383
- values part and we started from the how should we assess a part? So so first we went to what do we care

01:37:03.383 --> 01:37:05.342
- about and then we went to like

01:37:05.794 --> 01:37:12.002
- how we should base salaries. So that's where we base the mayor's salary on Civil City, in terms of the

01:37:12.002 --> 01:37:18.029
- theory of what we said is the mayor's salaries on Civil City, the clerk's salary on Civil City, and

01:37:18.029 --> 01:37:24.116
- then the council's salary on the mayor. And so it was like, we started from that, and then we looked

01:37:24.116 --> 01:37:30.384
- at the salary charts. And I know for me, that sticker shock that everybody else had, I had that sticker

01:37:30.384 --> 01:37:35.326
- shock too, in that meeting. Whoa, we created this thing, and it resulted in this.

01:37:35.458 --> 01:37:41.854
- Like, whoa, and that was where, I mean, I almost voted no on that recommendation because of the sticker

01:37:41.854 --> 01:37:48.434
- shock part, but ultimately I had to go like, well, we put this effort into these principles and we started

01:37:48.434 --> 01:37:54.768
- from the blank slate scratch and this is what we came to. We didn't start with something and then fill

01:37:54.768 --> 01:38:00.917
- in behind it. So I just wanna clarify that as part of that process, I think we tried really hard to

01:38:00.917 --> 01:38:02.270
- blank slate it, yeah.

01:38:04.482 --> 01:38:10.634
- So just, I mean, I might recollect differently, but the reason why I hold that position is because if

01:38:10.634 --> 01:38:16.666
- you recall, even before we put together the committee, and when you read, if you read the reporting

01:38:16.666 --> 01:38:22.939
- on it, at that day when the committee was established, I said very clearly, I do not support any raises

01:38:22.939 --> 01:38:26.558
- to our salary, and said the exact same argument that I made

01:38:26.850 --> 01:38:32.935
- throughout the rest of the time. And that was contextual statement based on what we were talking about

01:38:32.935 --> 01:38:39.137
- at the time. When establishing that committee, it was clearly said by multiple members of the committee.

01:38:39.137 --> 01:38:45.104
- We just said it out loud. And there's no problem with this position. I'm just saying that it puts us

01:38:45.104 --> 01:38:49.534
- in a rhetorical bind in some ways. But the argument was made very clearly.

01:38:49.666 --> 01:38:55.731
- Council should get higher salaries. Let's put together a committee to discuss this. So there was that

01:38:55.731 --> 01:39:01.678
- starting point, whether you could then disabuse yourself of that, I don't doubt that you could, but

01:39:01.678 --> 01:39:07.862
- that was the context in which we were having these conversations. It was driven by increasing salaries,

01:39:07.862 --> 01:39:14.046
- not by, I mean, we certainly can't reduce them, nor by let's justify the salary that we currently have.

01:39:18.370 --> 01:39:23.862
- I guess we remember that meeting just a little bit differently in terms of like where that origin was

01:39:23.862 --> 01:39:29.407
- but I'm also talking about when we are actually in that committee meeting room going where do we start

01:39:29.407 --> 01:39:34.845
- with this and how do we start with this and and that is one of the reasons why we ultimately brought

01:39:34.845 --> 01:39:40.445
- in that consultant to help lead us through it so that we were trying like doing our level best to start

01:39:40.445 --> 01:39:45.829
- from that like place of inquiry as opposed to start with a with an assumption on the back end other

01:39:45.829 --> 01:39:47.390
- comments councilmember daily

01:39:49.314 --> 01:39:57.033
- Thank you. So what I'm hearing at this moment right now is that we're all pretty much unified that this

01:39:57.033 --> 01:40:04.678
- year Cola increase we all support that and not fighting for anything more. I think you know it doesn't

01:40:04.678 --> 01:40:12.174
- do us any favors to at the end of a budget cycle to start the conversation about what how we want to

01:40:12.174 --> 01:40:14.846
- proceed going forward for electeds.

01:40:15.106 --> 01:40:20.410
- Salaries, so I think that we have a really good start right here We got a really good base especially

01:40:20.410 --> 01:40:25.766
- with the salary and the conversation that we've had and I feel like maybe now then this is a good time

01:40:25.766 --> 01:40:30.966
- for the fiscal committee to process that information and have the conversations and keep working on

01:40:30.966 --> 01:40:36.322
- that and then maybe come back in three months and you know start the conversation again when we're not

01:40:36.322 --> 01:40:41.522
- so close to budget time and You know, there's been a little more thought put into it and processing

01:40:41.522 --> 01:40:43.966
- all of these responses. That's my proposal and

01:40:45.890 --> 01:40:55.030
- Other comments Councilmember Flaherty, I just wanted to briefly support clerk Bolton's Recommendation

01:40:55.030 --> 01:41:04.080
- that we separate new ordinances for council clerk and mayor Councilmember Rallo I just wanted to say

01:41:04.080 --> 01:41:13.041
- that I think that the the hearing on the proposal by the committee Really didn't get a fair hearing

01:41:13.041 --> 01:41:15.102
- because of the process

01:41:15.330 --> 01:41:25.395
- Because we had a very contracted time and they felt to bring it forward it landed in a packet as a resolution

01:41:25.395 --> 01:41:34.911
- and we were we were You know the committee didn't have time to report it for a full-throated discussion

01:41:34.911 --> 01:41:44.702
- so So when I offered a compromise it was really meant as a stopgap really to to allow more conversation to

01:41:44.834 --> 01:42:00.346
- Which we're doing so that's good. I Think that's that's all I'll say Other than oh, I'll say that when

01:42:00.346 --> 01:42:14.654
- I query grok you do it it also thinks we should be paid more That took me a minute I just said

01:42:14.818 --> 01:42:23.144
- You know be aware Yeah That would be an interesting justification Other comments I Guess I want to address

01:42:23.144 --> 01:42:30.926
- the idea of having this conversation now. I mean as as somebody who oh Geez, I'm the only one right

01:42:30.926 --> 01:42:39.486
- now that is on the fiscal committee currently and was also on that that ad hoc salary committee last year and

01:42:39.586 --> 01:42:44.669
- And I think that we tried really hard on that salary committee to come up with something and then we

01:42:44.669 --> 01:42:49.802
- got to council and it was basically like no we don't agree with these principles we don't think their

01:42:49.802 --> 01:42:54.936
- principles we don't think it's valid and I don't want to go through that again on fiscal committee so

01:42:54.936 --> 01:42:59.968
- I don't feel as a member of the fiscal committee like I am moving forward with any more information

01:42:59.968 --> 01:43:05.152
- about what the majority of council is interested in in terms of guiding principles or values that they

01:43:05.152 --> 01:43:08.222
- think that or you all think that we should base salaries on.

01:43:08.482 --> 01:43:14.712
- I mean it's clear that go okay a majority of you think that we should have something but what exactly

01:43:14.712 --> 01:43:21.126
- is this something that we should have and what I just heard was oh just just dump it on fiscal committee

01:43:21.126 --> 01:43:27.417
- to figure out and we did that last year with Salary Committee and it ended up being a Big mess so Like

01:43:27.417 --> 01:43:33.648
- not to say that we should you know, we're necessarily gonna have any answers we keep on talking about

01:43:33.648 --> 01:43:36.030
- this tonight, but I'm just saying that

01:43:36.130 --> 01:43:44.437
- without guidance from everybody about what people actually want, it puts a committee of four in a real

01:43:44.437 --> 01:43:52.664
- bind. Councilmember Piedmont-Smith. I mean, I think we got some good feedback on the survey as to why

01:43:52.664 --> 01:44:00.891
- there was disagreement with some of these five principles. But in other cases, we didn't. People just

01:44:00.891 --> 01:44:05.246
- said neutral or disagree and then didn't tell us why.

01:44:05.346 --> 01:44:12.117
- And I do want to just address one council member said so question three was if you disagree with one

01:44:12.117 --> 01:44:18.820
- or more of the guiding principles please indicate why for each case below. And one person said this

01:44:18.820 --> 01:44:25.792
- this I think this question was anyone who disagrees on the defensive and is unfair. Everybody or nobody

01:44:25.792 --> 01:44:30.686
- should be asked to explain their answers. And I understand that I guess.

01:44:30.786 --> 01:44:37.390
- as the person writing the questions, I read the memo again from the ad hoc committee, and that memo

01:44:37.390 --> 01:44:44.125
- explained why they put forward those principles. So I thought the argument in favor of the principles

01:44:44.125 --> 01:44:50.795
- had already been made by that ad hoc committee, and so that's why I was just asking for explanations

01:44:50.795 --> 01:44:57.398
- if you disagree. So just to clarify that. So in some cases, we did get, well, I disagree because of

01:44:57.398 --> 01:45:00.766
- this, and I could understand that. In other cases,

01:45:01.570 --> 01:45:07.991
- We didn't get responses why somebody disagreed and especially there were some that were neutral that

01:45:07.991 --> 01:45:14.349
- I was like I don't know what to do with that as chair of the fiscal committee. I don't know what to

01:45:14.349 --> 01:45:20.770
- do with that if somebody says neutral. So I think the fiscal committee could only do this if like we

01:45:20.770 --> 01:45:27.446
- each have conversations with each of the people who are not on the fiscal committee to really understand

01:45:27.446 --> 01:45:31.006
- because else I agree with council member Stossberg that

01:45:32.354 --> 01:45:40.859
- The four of us on the fiscal committee could agree with something but again it can come back and not

01:45:40.859 --> 01:45:49.784
- get buy in from the rest of the council. Although I think we do have a leg up from last year just because

01:45:49.784 --> 01:45:58.878
- we've learned some things but it's hard. Other comments. I wanted to clarify a point that was made earlier.

01:45:59.714 --> 01:46:08.188
- And I want to make sure I actually say it so that it could be incorporated into the record. Sorry that

01:46:08.188 --> 01:46:16.498
- always makes me laugh. Earlier Mayor Thompson said the clerk was the third highest paid clerk in the

01:46:16.498 --> 01:46:24.725
- state and that she was the sixth highest paid mayor in the state which is incorrect. The council is

01:46:24.725 --> 01:46:29.086
- ranked sixth in the state. The clerk is the seventh.

01:46:29.986 --> 01:46:38.533
- And the mayor is the 10th even incorporating the shift in salary for the clerk's office. That was a

01:46:38.533 --> 01:46:46.824
- couple hundred dollars over cola last year. It's still the 10th highest paid clerk in the state.

01:46:46.824 --> 01:46:54.174
- That was it. Oh also I don't know what rock is. Did you say that the council is sick.

01:47:00.194 --> 01:47:07.648
- Great. Other comments. Council member Rosa Marger I just want to say I understand definitely the finance

01:47:07.648 --> 01:47:14.747
- committee's frustration and probably trepidation around trying to do again what was done last year.

01:47:14.747 --> 01:47:21.847
- I mean I do think it's somehow worth. I mean maybe you were saying Council member Piedmont Smith is

01:47:21.847 --> 01:47:28.094
- one on ones. I mean I try really hard to if I trust the process I trust the outcome and

01:47:28.322 --> 01:47:34.740
- I mean just for me like an example is I totally believe in the stadium district but I don't like that

01:47:34.740 --> 01:47:41.158
- process and I was going to vote no on that right because neighborhoods were involved. But like I just

01:47:41.158 --> 01:47:47.512
- think like is it possible that council members can believe in a process and then vote on the outcome

01:47:47.512 --> 01:47:54.119
- of that process. And I think that is the disconnect to me and the pie charts with the answers that maybe

01:47:54.119 --> 01:47:56.510
- they believe in the process but don't

01:47:56.802 --> 01:48:11.326
- believe in the outcome and I guess it is like how do we how do we get to a place where folks can like

01:48:11.326 --> 01:48:23.998
- the process no matter the outcome I guess. Other thoughts. She's throwing one out there.

01:48:24.098 --> 01:48:30.305
- I'm not always seeing hands down there at the ends tonight. I don't know if we're being shy or what

01:48:30.305 --> 01:48:36.511
- I think you were looking the other way in the other direction when I raised it we talked like Quite

01:48:36.511 --> 01:48:42.718
- quite a level of depth last year about the overall compensation Framework and approach for the city

01:48:42.718 --> 01:48:49.049
- and something the mayor said in her opening remarks this evening resonated which was you know that in

01:48:49.049 --> 01:48:54.014
- general kind of the best system is uniform one we should be looking at that and

01:48:54.178 --> 01:49:00.102
- We recognized, and I briefly mentioned this in my survey results, that there are some things, I think

01:49:00.102 --> 01:49:06.258
- there's seven attributes in this sort of like weighted calculation that goes into the grade determination

01:49:06.258 --> 01:49:12.182
- for folks, and it has to do with like the stress level of the job and the level of responsibility and

01:49:12.182 --> 01:49:18.222
- things like that, right? Sometimes degrees required, professional certifications, those aren't relevant

01:49:18.222 --> 01:49:24.030
- for elected officials. There were some other things that weren't relevant, but most of it could map

01:49:24.130 --> 01:49:31.180
- pretty well. We did talk about that and talk about those aspects. It wasn't really centered,

01:49:31.180 --> 01:49:38.760
- I don't think, in the committee's proposal, but we thought of that as something of a check as well,

01:49:38.760 --> 01:49:46.416
- something to look at as helping see if this was reasonable based on the principles we've set for the

01:49:46.416 --> 01:49:48.766
- whole city. I wonder if that's

01:49:49.218 --> 01:49:55.567
- Maybe not. But I wonder if that's a more fruitful entry point for, you know, if the committee or at

01:49:55.567 --> 01:50:01.916
- any point, you know, we decide to do something beyond just COLA's, which ostensibly the majority of

01:50:01.916 --> 01:50:08.329
- people support, you know, maybe that's a way to do it. And I wonder if actually like pretending like

01:50:08.329 --> 01:50:15.123
- the council job is a full-time job using that system of evaluation, seeing where you land and then saying,

01:50:15.123 --> 01:50:17.726
- okay, but council's not a full-time job.

01:50:17.954 --> 01:50:24.538
- and then trying to be reasonable about what type of job it is or what type of job we want it to be.

01:50:24.538 --> 01:50:31.320
- Is it a quarter-time job? Is it a five-hour-a-week job? Is it a third-time job? And so I know we don't

01:50:31.320 --> 01:50:37.707
- actually set hours, and I think statute prohibits us from tracking hours in that way. But still,

01:50:37.707 --> 01:50:44.094
- just to, again, try to use some type of systematic approach, maybe that's an option. That's all.

01:50:44.094 --> 01:50:47.518
- Thank you. And that actually reminds me of the last

01:50:47.682 --> 01:50:54.762
- I think it's the last question that I'm trying to get to is what other considerations should go into

01:50:54.762 --> 01:51:01.982
- it. And one of the things that I mentioned at that time was trying to figure out what job descriptions

01:51:01.982 --> 01:51:08.991
- elected positions would have and then how they would be assessed by the HR rubric. And I was really

01:51:08.991 --> 01:51:15.230
- interested in that last year too, but it seemed like last year it was almost like it was

01:51:15.330 --> 01:51:20.963
- It almost felt like a magic HR box in terms of you know, you there's some program or I mean I think

01:51:20.963 --> 01:51:26.709
- that it was actually some spreadsheet where you literally like fill out the things and then you click

01:51:26.709 --> 01:51:32.511
- enter and then it gives a result and that that's how it felt on the committee when I was trying to dig

01:51:32.511 --> 01:51:38.539
- into like how are you assessing this because there are some ways that it just doesn't Align like education

01:51:38.539 --> 01:51:44.510
- requirements. There are no education requirements and so it it Maybe if we had more time we could make it

01:51:44.610 --> 01:51:52.714
- Figure out a way for it to fit better Then we had we just did not have very much time last year to to

01:51:52.714 --> 01:52:01.057
- really dig in with HR exactly how how they were assessing those different like kind of like rubric style

01:52:01.057 --> 01:52:09.161
- you know check boxes in terms of those job descriptions and Yeah, so thank you councilmember Flaherty

01:52:09.161 --> 01:52:13.054
- for bringing up that That concept Other comments

01:52:16.962 --> 01:52:27.815
- Member Piedmont Smith do you feel as fiscal committee chair that you have something to go on here. Yes.

01:52:27.815 --> 01:52:38.772
- So if there are no other last comments from anybody including clerk and mayor I do have one last comment

01:52:38.772 --> 01:52:44.094
- for you all related to the whole evening if I may.

01:52:46.082 --> 01:52:51.637
- As a reminder for all council members you all have to sign appropriation ordinances 2025 dash 11 and

01:52:51.637 --> 01:52:57.303
- 2025 dash 12 and I'd like to get all of your signatures this evening including the mayor who's already

01:52:57.303 --> 01:53:02.969
- graciously agreed to sign them so we can have all of our budget ordinances ready to go and upload into

01:53:02.969 --> 01:53:08.414
- gateway. So if you could please take the time to come over and sign I would greatly appreciate it.

01:53:09.506 --> 01:53:15.109
- All right. Thank you. I think that that was a note on council schedule, which was the next thing on

01:53:15.109 --> 01:53:20.993
- the agenda. So that is a great transition Please make sure that you sign the two documents, right? Clerk

01:53:20.993 --> 01:53:26.708
- Bolden. Did you say two documents? Everybody has to sign in two places before you leave the room this

01:53:26.708 --> 01:53:30.462
- evening And are there any other notes on council schedule? we have

01:53:30.562 --> 01:53:36.915
- a deliberation session next Wednesday, which I believe is the 15th with the Historic Preservation Commission.

01:53:36.915 --> 01:53:42.286
- And then our next regular session is the week after that on the 22nd. And thank you so much.

01:53:42.286 --> 01:53:43.326
- We are adjourned.
