I'm gonna go ahead and call this special session of the Bloomington Common Council to order seeing as we've got a quorum and I think everybody else looks ready to Will the clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Flaherty Ruff Rallo Piedmont Smith here Stasberg here Daly here Suleik here Rosenberger here. Sorry here. I Thank you. So this evening we have a special session related to final budget approval for things. That's why we're here. So starting with the agenda summation first we're going to hear a report from the Committee of the Whole a couple weeks ago. We had a Committee of the Whole discussion around these appropriation ordinances and so we will hear from the chair of the Committee of the Whole which was Councilmember Zulek. Next we will have three items of legislation our appropriation ordinances for budget year 2026. We will start with The civil city budget appropriation ordinance 2025 11 then we will do appropriation ordinance 2025 12 for Bloomington Transportation Corporation for 2026 and then appropriation ordinance 2025 13 adopting the budget for the water and wastewater utility departments and for Bloomington again for 2026 after those three pieces of legislation we will have a conversation about elected official salary discussion which we kind of started last week and everybody was like we need to talk about that more any notes about council schedule and then we will adjourn So launching right in the first thing is the report from the committee of the whole from a couple weeks ago council members who look Thank you. The committee of the whole considered the three budget ordinances appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 11 appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 12 and appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 13 during the committee of the whole meeting on September 24th 2025 and makes the following recommendations. Number one the committee of the whole recommends to the council the adoption of appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 11. Number two. The committee of the whole recommends to the council the adoption of appropriation ordinance 2025 12 and number three the committee of the whole recommends to the council the adoption of appropriation ordinance 2025-13 and That is the conclusion of my report. Thank you Thank you very much council members who look does anybody have any questions of for council members who look about her report of the committee of the whole Great no questions, so we can go ahead and launch into our legislation for second readings. I Move that appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 11 be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only second All those in favor, please say aye. Aye opposed Thank you. Will the clerk please read? Appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five dash eleven in ordinance for appropriations and tax rates establishing the twenty twenty six civil city budget for the city of Bloomington. There's no synopsis. Thank you so much. I move that appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five dash eleven be adopted. Thank you. Who is here to present this evening. Go ahead and introduce yourself and floors yours. Good evening council Jessica McClellan city controller. I am here tonight to present for the final adoption the twenty twenty six budget for the city of Bloomington the DLGF reviewed funds total one hundred and ten million one hundred and eighty four thousand one hundred and eight and the non DLGF reviewed funds equal fifty two thousand nine hundred sixty eight. fifty two million nine hundred sixty eight thousand four hundred and forty nine For a total of Sixty five million one hundred and eight south thousand seven hundred and twenty nine dollars I Have a little bit more information to share with you about the fund balance and when we first developed the budget and presented the fund balance in the budget book, we had a estimated $11 million deficit between deficit spending and the general fund. And after we made corrections to the general fund that was reduced to a $9 million deficit spending in the general fund. And the reasons for the reason for that change is, um, and it, increase in the revenue in the general fund from property taxes from 54 million to 55.6 million and This is due to moving property taxes from the parks and rec fund to the general fund And we move property taxes out of the parks and rec fund Because there was about 1.6 million in revenues Miscellaneous revenues in the parks and rec fund that we had not accounted for yet in New World so we Got up got that information added that into new world and we didn't need the property tax support in the parks and rec fund by about 1.6 million that increased the revenue in the general fund there by decreasing the deficit spending We also made changes to the font to the spending in the general fund a combination of decreases due to moving liability insurance And increases due to cola Increases and increasing the amount that is going to the sanitation fund The net of that is an increase in spending of eighty six thousand dollars So there is a slight change that was no changes from the budget that was presented in the public hearing this is just a little bit more information for you about the deficit spending for next year, which is about nine million dollars and that is purely from the revenues that we're receiving next year and versus the spending that we have planned for next year. And I'm going to update you one more time about the planned the planned cash balance and the general fund at the end of twenty twenty six is twenty six million one hundred and sixty one thousand two hundred and fifteen. So that twenty six million is 40 percent of the operating budget. So we would have 40 percent reserves of our total operating budget It's a lot of information I really appreciate you bearing with me this budget season and asking all of your questions and Taking in all this information that I'm sharing with you. I appreciate your concern over many issues that we've come across in the budget and I look forward to your questions and appreciate your consideration tonight. Thank you. I Thank you. Are there questions for Controller McClellan Councilmember Piedmont Smith. Yes I wanted to ask and I sent an email about this but if you could summarize for everybody what our debt situation is total debt of the city and what portion is CBU and what portion is the civil city. Do you have that in front of you. Yes I do not have it in front of me. Just give me one second to bring it up. So right now we're going to review the debt obligations that are outstanding for the city of Bloomington. And I apologize for not having this information in numbers in front of you. I realize that would be a lot easier to digest this if you had it in front of you. But I am looking right now at a report that I pulled off the gateway website and let me make this report bigger so that I can see it. As of January 1st 2025 the outstanding debt obligations for the city of Bloomington a total of property tax bonds general revenue bonds and TIF bonds is one hundred and twenty five million sixty thousand. The total of wastewater the total outstanding for wastewater Is forty eight million seventy one thousand nine hundred and the total outstanding for water bonds is thirty nine million eight hundred and twenty seven thousand eight hundred For a total of two hundred and forty nine million nine hundred fifty nine thousand seven hundred and I'm happy to email this all to you It'd probably be helpful to have like some percentages. What percent is total city? debt obligations versus utilities. We can we can do that analysis easily of course and kind of look at some different ways to review the debt. Can I ask a follow up. In the DLGF I found a report that said our total debt was 414 million. Does that include the things that were not included in what you just reviewed or did I look at that report wrong. 414 million total debt. Let's see 414 million total debt if you would if you would show me that report sometime I'm not able to pull reports on the fly, but I'd be happy to take a look at that and See what that number is. I'm sure we can figure it out Yeah, it's um It's in the end in Gateway. If you look at it should be including civil city parks and CBU. So not just the things that are counted against our debt limit but all debt including property as well. That includes principal and interest. So our outstanding debt obligation is what I'm what I'm. Thank you very, very much. That is a list of all of our payments that are due. So usually when I'm asked what our outstanding debt obligations are, I refer to just our principal balance. And that is a list that includes all the interest payments due with that principal balance. So I did not quote that amount when I when I told you that is not actually on this report. But we can pull those numbers for each bond and include include that in a report too. I have one more. Can you comment at all on our debt per capita and how it compares to other cities? Well, let's see. There are a lot of debt per capita reports on Gateway. And it'll show the city of Bloomington and all the other cities in the state that have debt. And it shows what that rank is and what that debt per capita amount is in the state. I think Deputy Mayor Knapp had answered a previous email with some figures. I don't know. She wants to jump in. I can cite her email but debt is paid from oh hi It starts by figuring out what you're calling debt So if you're in that gateway, you can look at the total debt including parks and all of those other things You can look at debt that counts against our debt limit. So there are different ways of looking at it But by both of the standards that I think I said to you we were pretty much in the middle or in the in the at the bottom of the top third ranked by city and considering that we're the sixth largest city the amount of debt we have as a sixth largest city was considerably lower than if you were looking at how you know if you were assuming that the bigger the city the more debt they would have. I can't remember if it was looking at total debt that put us in the sort of let's call it the 70 60 percent mark and and or whether it was the other figure that put us halfway in the middle But you it's publicly available and it does really depend on what you include When you ask DLGF when you when you input what is the debt whether it's the total debt the debt that counts against the debt limit and so on But not exceptional in other words not exceptionally high by any means for either one of those figures Thank you Are there other questions councilmember Rallo? Thank you for sending the that information controller I wondered if so besides the principal and interest could you send me the Immortization schedule schedule as well. So we yes visualize that yes for each debt obligation Thank you No other questions. We need to go to public comment regarding appropriation ordinance 2025 11 If you're a member of the public in chambers and you would like to make a comment about this appropriation ordinance Please make your way to the podium If you are a member of the public online wishing to make a comment You can raise your hand using the reactions tab or you can send a chat message to the host. I Don't see anybody moving in chambers. Is there anybody who's raised a hand on zoom? I Seeing no public comment. We will go ahead and come back. Oh wait, there's one person who has raised their hand. Let's go ahead and Hear from that person when you're unmuted, please state your name for the record and then you'll have up to three minutes Thank you, can you hear me yes Good evening. My name is Eric host and I appreciate this opportunity to comment as Bloomington faces profound financial shifts, especially from state legislation like SCA-1, we must begin with a clear open discussion of the city's debt profile. While our bond rating is strong and bond debt low, the Department of Local Government Finance places our total outstanding debt at a bit above $414 million. SCA-1 limits short-term bond access, meaning less cash and less credit. Public communication should stress structural constraints such as the need to strategically layer and ladder bonds for future infrastructure costs and key debt indicators such as our debt service rate and its proximity to thresholds that would trigger costly petition processes. Establishing performance indicators for debt management will help us protect critical services and infrastructure over the long term. Transparency as the Thomson administration has said is a value means more than posting data. It means understandable, making it understandable and accessible. The controller's goal to meet the public where they are is a great start. It's commendable. To truly be co-creators, council and administration should actively invite public input on budget engagement, making trade-offs visible and using modern tools such as Notebook LM to foster ongoing informed dialogue. Perhaps we could formalize public participation by inviting residents to join the fiscal committee or the budget task force. Leveraging community expertise will strengthen our shared path towards fiscal health. Thank you for your service to our community and for all of your good work. Thank you for your comment. Is there anybody else who's raised a hand on Zoom in the meantime? Okay, let's go to our second Zoom commenter. When you're unmuted, go ahead and state your name for the record and you'll have up to three minutes. It's Kevin Keough. I've spent over 45 years as a financial and IT auditor, including being a CPA, a certified internal auditor, a certified information system auditor, and a certified information systems cybersecurity profession. I mention that only to say that I've spent my career looking for the kinds of control failures that can hide in complex financial systems. I'm concerned that the administration still has not provided a clear documented explanation for the so-called macro errors that reduce the projected budget deficit by $2.3 million, a material and significant error. When heirs of that size appear between the accounting system and the budget document, the cause it impact should be fully reconciled and shared with the public before this council votes. Anything less leaves both the council and the community in the dark, whether the budget numbers are reliable. I understand that mistakes can happen in data transfers or spreadsheets. What's troubling is the lack of transparency. There has been no reconciliation, no errata sheet, and no technical explanation of how the macros failed or which accounts were affected. From a professional auditing perspective, I would urge the council not to approve the 2026 budget until those explanations can be made public and the corrected figures verified. And I would also add, since I have some more time than I thought I'd have, today's Herald Times, the front page. The mayor of Sydney needs to cut spending. Thompson plans to use, and this is the figure, today's paper, $11 million in reserves to balance the budget. directly conflicts with what the controller said this evening. So anyway, I thank you for this opportunity to provide public input. Anybody else raise their hand on Zoom? Okay. And seeing that there's nobody in chambers, we'll go ahead and return to council now. Are there any council member comments or lingering questions in response to public Well, I'd like to Give the administration the opportunity is to respond to these stated discrepancies reliability of data and the 11 million dollars in reserves to balance a budget I Mean it's a charge that I puts in question, I think, for the viewing public and what we're voting on this evening, and I would like to give you a chance to respond to that. I think we've gone through it over the past months, but if you'd like an opportunity. Revenues changed from 54 million to 55.6 million for a total increase in revenues of 1.6 million. Spending the general fund expenses changed from sixty five point two million to sixty five point one million for increase in eighty six thousand in expenses There was planned deficit spending of eleven point one million in the budget book and Mainly due to the revenue increase in the general fund That planned deficit spending is nine point four million now. I There's one table on page 14 of the budget book That states that the expenses in the general fund are sixty five point two million But when we add up all of the legal sheets throughout the budget that's where we get the budget that of sixty five point oh two million and that's where an error in Whatever was used to run the report that made the one table in the memo versus all of the reports that were divided up into all the different departments, there was a little bit of discrepancy between those reports and what the total was in that table. And that's where the macro error occurred. By macro, all we mean is that very simple Excel program that takes a messy, Excel report generated by the computer does a bunch of formatting and saves it as an Excel or as a PDF just if you're very simple macro, it works really well if that base report is always exactly the same but sometimes The program gives us a report that has minor little differences in the macro Didn't work right but we did reconcile every single difference between the general fund and the budget book and the general fund in this adopted budget we know exactly where every change is and I Presented that to you and I was happy to do that work. I feel like that is absolutely Necessary for you to know before you pass this budget Thank you Thank you, are there other lingering questions from council members or any comments that council members would like to make about this Appropriation ordinance councilmember Piedmont Smith Well, I asked the questions that the controller just went over earlier via email and She did send me an excel spreadsheet that laid everything out very clearly the changes between budget book and What's in the final paperwork has that been shared with council or public? Can we do that? Yes Yes, you can do that. Yes, it has not been shared with anyone except The requester which is you Okay, so we can maybe put that I can share it right now and we can put that in a to add to the packet tomorrow Okay, I think that'll that'll help Other comments related to this appropriation ordinance or lingering questions before about councilmember all I had one more. I'm sorry I meant to ask this last time when bounding upon Council was here, but Bloomington City Bloomington has a bond investment grade rating of double a one said right We get rated every time we issue bonds and it fluctuates, okay and But it is investment grade. Yes. Yep, and the the Bloomington utilities has a lower grade and It has consistently it's not a reflection of the current But I think it's it's got an a rating. Is that correct? I just Wondered about rated you might still be in the rating process for your water bonds So utilities has a water bond in the process right now and they may be rated. They may not be rated. I'm not sure So it's in process right now. There's usually something that happens at the end of the bond Process, I don't think you've closed on your bonds yet I don't know off the top of my head what the utilities bond rating is. That's a short answer. You know something we can talk about at some point later, but I just wanted to understand in terms of our you know debt load if it has an influence on bond rating certainly does in many cases or what would account for it. So but we can we can discuss that at a different time. Thanks. Thank you. Are there other councilmember comments or lingering questions? Okay, I just have one thing that I want to say which I'm gonna make it a little bit of a question But mostly it's a comment one of our commenters highlighted the Herald Times article kind of questioning something that was in it in terms of questioning the city's accuracy of information but I also want to call out the end of that article cited that there would be a 2% cola increase in or pay increase for non-union employees. But that was what was in the original budget book. But you have changed that to the 2.7%, which is what we had talked about and requested. And I would like that kind of verbal confirmation right now. Yes, definitely. Between budget hearings and our public hearing earlier last month, it's been changed to 2.7%. Thank you. I actually got a message this morning from a community member who I realized like oh they must have read this and wanted clarification. So for clarification that is at least one inaccuracy that was in this article and I can't tell you if there are other inaccuracies in it but that was one that stood out to me and so I did want to make sure to clarify that for the public that our non union employees do have a 2.7 percent increase which matches inflation for the 2026 year. And that was all I wanted to say. Thank you. So unless there's other lingering comments or questions from council members will oh councilmember Flaherty Yeah, I had a question. Are we? constrained to five minutes to debate or sorry to council comment in this period That is our Like what is standard in our code around that I think it's five minutes for the first comment and then a two minutes additional for additional comments That's right. Thank you Okay So I would have shared more of my thoughts last week, but I was unable to join the Committee of the Whole. Briefly, I'm not gonna be voting in favor of this year's Civil City budget, because I don't feel like I can in good conscience. Not a decision I make lightly, but it's a vote that's consistent with my values and what I think is right, and I'll do my best to explain. I probably will be a little short on time. It's also a vote about accountability for me, and I think the budget is a very poor accountability mechanism. There are much better avenues through conversation and collaboration, negotiation and agreements. things that have largely proven ineffective in my experience with this administration for 20 months. And I think without real accountability, we won't see real change. And so that's really the motivating factor. First, I think we are very much failing to meaningfully center our operationalized equity in city government, which is central for me as an elected official. Second, in ways that I think are harming our community, I believe this administration is failing to prioritize and pursue the outcomes we've set through community-driven legislative processes And third, quite sadly really, I no longer consistently trust what this administration tells us based on their past actions and a pattern of behavior exhibited throughout their time in office. I'll try to address each a little bit, though again, I probably don't have adequate time. With respect to equity, for me that is the defining value of what it means to be liberal, what it means to me to be a Democrat. Virtually all decisions in other policy areas flow from this. And in my view, we simply aren't integrating equity as a value in government in a consistent or meaningful way most of the time. This is actually how I felt my entire time in office, but I actually think we've been making meaningful incremental progress most of the time, and I think this year's the first year I feel like we're actually taking a step backwards. As folks may recall, we negotiated over equity in government last year, and kind of gave the administration a pass when they said we need more time, we're only eight months in, we need to do studies, we need to talk to staff, we need to understand what we're doing, we need to come up with outcomes, expectations, et cetera. We'll come back to you with a plan. Then we didn't hear anything for nine months until we took a motion and asked them for an update, and we got one paragraph from the deputy mayor saying that they are not in a position to allocate funding or undertake this work at the present time, going on to explain that the Trump administration's opposition to DEI could put us at risk for accessing federal funds. The mayor of Corporation Council echoed these points. I've got to say, I just find these explanations to be wholly inadequate. By all means, use language strategically when applying for grants, naming programs, et cetera. But now more than ever is the time to stand up for our values if they are indeed our values and indeed leading cities all over the country are doing just that I Understand the administration's position here and I'm opposed to it Second major area of concern is with policy outcomes again community driven legislatively adopted policies. I think those aspects are critical it's how we actually have city policy not just individual priorities and I brought this up last year when the mayor was producing a bunch of action plans to inform their budget priorities. I asked how council was going to be involved, how the public was going to be involved, whether we'd approve these. The answers were basically no, we weren't involved and we didn't approve them. And they're not city policies, they're mayoral priorities. Not the same thing. And so the outcomes in our city policies are my compass and I think we're falling short in many areas. particularly striking cases on both climate action and housing where the mayor has actually actively opposed or even obstructed implementation of current city policy. To me, that's unacceptable and there needs to be accountability for that as well. The path to change those is through the legislative and community involved process, not through opposition or obstruction. A third and final problem is the trust issue. I don't have enough time to go into all the many examples of where I feel like I have not been dealt with honestly. Perhaps one of the more significant is my trust concerns is when the administration, really in the first months in office, disregarded Bond Ordinance 2022-30 and the Appropriation Ordinance 2020-301, which appropriated nearly $30 million to be spent solely and exclusively on public safety facilities. Among those planned expenditures, or actually actual expenditures, was the Showers West building for new police and fire headquarters. That's of course not how that building's being used, arguably a violation of the bond ordinance. I've spoken with our bond council about it and corporation council and city former council attorney Lucas and the mayor, which has informed my view that I think we may well be in violation. There's a lot of things that we negotiated in last year's budget that the administration agreed to do that they in fact have not done. So that undermines my ability to think that we can actually productively negotiate to see improvements. Again, I've run out of time to give the many examples that I have. I'd like for us to spend more time in the future working on these structural challenges. Thank you Thank you for your comment are there any other councilmember comments after that Councilmember Piedmont Smith I think this this year has been frustrating in many ways because We have ostensibly been working towards outcome-based budgeting But it has proceeded very slowly and without prioritization of which outcomes are more important than others. I think part of it is, you know, it's not that there's anybody's fault in particular. I think it's just it's a very heavy lift and having to kind of organize how we think about expenditures, has taken the bulk of the time and I'm hoping that we will actually get to a point where we can we can talk about the outcomes we wish to see and how best to use our limited funds to get there. I feel like that really wasn't done this year and I Again I'm not sure if that's just because we had to you know get some other ducks in a row before we could have that conversation but I just want to express that I certainly hope the council will be actively involved as we move ahead and at some point we have to talk about priorities not just we want to see these 200 outcomes because we can't fund 200 outcomes. So other than that, I appreciate the openness with which our new controller has discussed budget processes with us and presented data. And I think there's been a learning curve on her part and on our part as far as what we need and want to see as far as data before we make budget decisions. So I'm hoping that we can, you know, Both sides can learn from this and next year we'll have more of that data up front rather than me emailing two days before the vote and getting the data on the day of the vote. I'm not pointing blame. I'm just saying that it was a little bit last minute this year that I understood the budget well enough that I feel like I can vote on it. So these are things we can approve upon next year. Thank you. Thank you for the comments so far. So I want to say thank you to the controller. I always really love your presentations and your ability to answer questions whether you know the answer or not. So I always appreciate that. This is something I've wanted to bring up for a long time and I think there has never really been a right time for it because it is an awkward conversation and awkward conversations are difficult and I think that Sometimes making something public is it can feel petty but I do think this is time and after council members Flaherty's kind of high-level view on issues with the administration I did well I think it's hard to just say something you know, like I've lost trust and I think sometimes Examples are important. So I do want to do a dive into an example Of why I too and I think potentially some other other council members are lacking trust with this administration and So in late 2024 and early 2025 for resolutions to amend our unified development ordinance the UDO In accordance with furthering our city's goals and plans housing updates affordability updates climate updates were brought before council two resolutions passed in 2024 without a fuss in March 2025 the other two resolutions were brought before council and voted down on introduction we did not even get a chance to discuss them and The B square bulletin wrote a story that night one because it normally does that write a story and two because it was a very Out-of-character move for City Council. We almost introduced every legislation piece of legislation that comes before us from the B square bulletin This is a quote from the bulletin mayor Thompson told the B square she found out about the resolutions at the same time as a general public when the meeting information packet was released after 5 p.m. On Friday, March 7th These four resolutions were all developed via extensive coordination and collaboration with city staff over the year 2023. Some discussions started with the previous 2024 and some started with the previous administration actually before we were all in office. This is pretty unusual because a lot of a lot of legislation comes either from the administration or from council and there's not a lot of collaboration. Just like for one example and there are many examples of this but an email in August 2024 from the director of planning David Hiddle emailed the council members on Working on these four of us the deputy mayor and the mayor was on the emails but had been dropped He said Thanks for meeting with planning and transportation staff last week to discuss the council's draft list of proposed you deal amendments Here are the follow-up notes following further staff review As P&T staff had already planned to bring forward language, one, updating the methodology for calculating riparian buffer requirements, and two, strictly limiting self-storage as a land use, we could absorb those two items onto our planned staff UDO amendment lift, if so desired by council. Director Hiddle goes on to give updates about what we talked about at one of our meetings for those UDO resolution updates that we were working on together. So I have more on there. I'm sorry, but I want to I Want to keep going on this so that was really hard to understand that quote and after that I had a conversation with one council member And they told me they voted no on introduction because they had talked to the mayor and the mayor told them It was the first time I the resolution, she had seen the resolutions and that they were developed in a vacuum. I was shocked by that because she had been on the emails as well as city staff in the meetings, right? Later I followed up with that council member and I asked, did, I was like, I'm sorry, I'm just clarifying. So like you called the mayor and this happened and they said no, she called me. Then this got a little more, deep right and it's just like it's really hard because there's like no trust there for me but after after I talked to a different council member that one said I asked the mayor if she called anyone and she said she did not so like I it's hard that This is just one example of a place that like all honesty It just feels blown to pieces and I I do follow councilmember Flaherty in that like the lack of trust is so extreme for me. I Want to use a no vote to show that thanks Thank you for your comment are there other councilmember comments Councilmember Rallo I can count the first have you just had questions before? Okay Okay Yes, Mike just briefly I wanted to say that I appreciate the administration and the controller for Meeting the challenges of state legislation Changes in taxation and and and reducing reduced revenue and I appreciate the work that she's done in Navigating that and you've also been very open and responsive to council during the budget process And I I want to extend my appreciation for that as well I appreciate the mayor's efforts to find the proper location for a police station. I voted against showers west purchase that acquisition I think It's yet to be determined how that will play out, but I'm pleased that it is not going to be the location of the police They never wanted to be there. It was inappropriate for them. And then actually I think it was hazardous so I'm I'm very appreciative of that and also appreciative of the mayor's attention to the police the Meeting their needs in other ways as well salary and and so forth and I also wanted to say that I Forgotten what I was going to say that on you know, if my negative comments during the budget were mostly focused on Accounting for past growth and how that affects current fees and Taxes and so forth and and and spending I don't think that we fully account for it it's something that we could work on and I think that I wanted to bring it to the attention of Everyone in the including the administration If there is one thing that I think that we should reconsider in the future in terms of our budgetary constraints that is Whether or not the infrastructure that is available to us right now needs to be redesigned I know that in best times it may be advisable You know in an optimal sense maybe to have a redesign of major streets in Bloomington But is it something that we can afford to do? facing a future probably austerity I think that that discussion Should should be had and I and I've remembered my other comment and that is that The administration has been open to increasing salaries From 2 to 2.7 percent to keep place with cost of living increases and I appreciate that that was no small feat and I I think that was the appropriate thing to do in the past we had not been keeping up and I Would prefer after we've gone through the salary study there were major increases last year that were needed For cost of living I would hate us to get behind incrementally. So so that was a very I Appreciate that very much the administration. So I will be supporting this budget and I think it's a sound budget and And I want to thank the controller again in the administration for presenting it to us Thank you for that comment are there other councilmember comments comes member rough I also want to thank the administration for what I think was you know a real effort at providing a information when it was requested and providing it in a relatively timely way and for for what I think was Compared to certainly compared to some former administration situations it was it was pretty give-and-take I and for I Appreciate it. I I also just want to That I agree with councilman Barallo that if we are really in a time of austerity Throwing large sums of money at redesigning and reengineering existing infrastructure that is Serving the community arguably relatively well Is is not something I support or want to see and I think it's contradicts this the austerity are your concerns and the Uncertainty of future revenues with state with state laws. I just I just cannot see the justification for these large amounts of money They are going towards redesign reengineering and then reconstruction shifts in construction Finally, I just like to say You know when councilman Flaherty made his initial comments on he was asking about the procedure in about the five minutes and whether it be and the clock was running and I don't I don't think that was fair so I would say if Councilmember Flaherty has another 30 seconds of time I think it's fair to add because you shouldn't have been timed during asking You know what our process was going to be Thank you for your comment to clarify councilmember Flaherty in theory has another two minutes if he wanted to take a a second comment but I will leave that up to are there any other comments from council members about appropriation ordinance 2025 11 I'll go ahead and say something short just because I think that I kind of owe it to my constituents to say something I also plan to support this budget this evening, but I do want to say that I appreciate the words from council members Flaherty and Rosenberger just in terms of being upfront and explaining their reasoning. I do feel as though This process has been collaborative, and I have felt like the administration has been responsive to things that I've said, both individually as part of fiscal committee comments and during the question and answer period of the hearings itself. Both, I suppose, responsive to myself, but also responsive to other council members who have raised questions and issues, and I appreciate that responsiveness. I also understand that that disappointment that council members Flaherty and Rosenberger mentioned. But I do think that the administration has tried really hard to to make a budget that was a collaborative effort. So I am planning on supporting this this evening. So if there are no other comments. Will the clerk please call the roll on appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five eleven Flaherty no breath. Yes Rallo. Yes Piedmont Smith. Yes Stasberg. Yes Daly. Yes Zulek. Yes Rosenberger. No, sorry. Yes Thank you. That ordinance passes seven to I move that appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five dash twelve be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only Second, it's been moved and seconded to introduce appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five twelve. All those in favor, please say aye Opposed. Thank you. Will the clerk please read Appropriation ordinance 2025-12 an ordinance for appropriations and tax rates for Bloomington Transportation Corporation for 2026 There's no synopsis I move that appropriation ordinance 2025-12 be adopted Second Thank you who is here tonight for appropriation ordinance 2025 12 Good evening. John Connell general manager of Bloomington Public Transportation Corporation here respectfully requesting final approval of the 2026 Bloomington Public Transportation Corporation budget. There have been no changes to the budget since it was last presented. The total budget for 2026 is 19 million three hundred eighty three thousand four hundred and two dollars proposed tax levy of point zero three seven one. Thank you for your consideration Thank you, are there councilmember questions for mr. Connell councilmember Flaherty I did have one and I meant to ask this earlier in the process and I forgot that someone else did forgive me but um, we talked early early in the budget process that the mo you that had agreed to to Commit a certain amount of ed lit funds to Bloomington Transit and a transfer on an annual basis Time we're sunsetting I think at the 2027 and we're correctly if that's wrong 28 I believe 28. Okay. Thank you. And I was curious for your perspective, which I don't think I got on The impact of that if the things that those dollars are supporting now I know some of it was like match dollars for federal grant opportunities for electrification of fleet for instance Yeah, the outlook there I guess with that changing just so we can anticipate appropriately like How that will impact transit how that might impact city decisions on so Previous ed lift funding we've used primarily as matching funds for federal dollars for example in 2025 we Drawn down 24 million dollars in federal funding. So if you look at We have 16 additional battery electric buses. There are million dollars each not to mention the infrastructure and There were two separate grant applications that we were awarded money to buy those purchase those vehicles and without that ED lit funding in place I doubt very seriously that we would have received those discretionary funds as far as the 2025 and 2026 lit funds we've pulled those and we're programming them for local matching funds for our new facility and acquisition of land so When we set out on our strategic plan transform BT All those projects that we're getting ready and this budget does include a hundred thousand dollars to upgrade that or Review and update the strategic plan But a lot of the boxes have been checked in terms of technology the vehicles as a result of the ED lit funding so it truly has allowed us to transform BT One brief follow-up. That's okay. And thank you for is any of it committed to debt service right now or no The microtransit. Yes microtransit services. So this year we have opted to use Internal funding so we could set aside the 3.8 to show The Federal Transit Administration that we do have the local funds in place so knowing how important that was to counsel we have Continued the blink program and the microtransit program and we've absorbed those costs internally Okay. Thank you Thank you. Are there other questions? It's just like to give you an opportunity to reflect on federal and state budget challenges in the future and what You know what we might anticipate Federal funding reauthorization is set for 2026. I don't have a crystal ball. I'm cautiously optimistic. The funding levels will remain pretty consistent, particularly in terms of formula funding. There has been a clear indication that, for example, the low no, the low admission, no admission programs will probably Sunset or just cease to exist But as far as the federal formula funding Like I said, I'm cautiously optimistic that it'll remain at a steady level And just to follow up we've our fleet has transitioned largely to correct either hybrid or to fully electric Yeah over 40 Really was 42% of our vehicles now And we have 18 total 16 the newer 16 new buses are 40-foot and why that's important is they have an extra battery pack and we're getting 12 12 hours of State of charge so the vehicle can be out all day. So it's been a fantastic improvement great Well, thank you for moving ahead with that transitioning while we While the landscape allowed us to write to do so Yeah, thank you Are there other councilmember questions All right seeing none, let's go ahead and go to the public for public comment regarding appropriation ordinance 2025 12 and If there are any members of the public in chambers who would like to make a comment, you can make your way to the podium. If you're online, please raise your hand using the reactions tab or send a chat message to the host. I don't see anybody moving in chambers. Is there anybody online with a hand raised? Okay, I'll give it another minute because at the last one there were a couple of last minute hands that suddenly went up. So going once on public comment for appropriation ordinance 2025-12. Going twice. All right. No public comment today. Returning to counsel for any council member comments regarding this appropriation ordinance. All right. Seeing no comments at this time will the clerk please call the roll on appropriation ordinance 2025 12. Council member Roth. Yes. Rollo yes Piedmont Smith yes Stasberg yes Bailey yes Zulik yes Rosenberger yes sorry yes Flaherty yes thank you and that passes with a vote of nine zero I move that appropriation ordinance twenty twenty five dash thirteen be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. Awesome second so moved and seconded to introduce appropriation ordinance 2025 13 all those in favor please say aye opposed. Thank you. Will the clerk please read appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 13 to transfer funds from the general fund to the fiber connectivity fund and specially appropriate funds not otherwise. That is so absolutely wrong that you guys are going to have to Bear with me because we'll start over with that reading of the title synopsis of 2025 13. Yeah. But do you give me just a moment because I did something very strange here again. Sorry. Okay let's try that again. Preparation ordinance 2025 dash 13 an ordinance adopting a budget for the operation maintenance debt service and capital improvements for the water and wastewater utility departments of the city of Bloomington Indiana for the year 2026. The synopsis is as follows. This ordinance approved by the utility service board in August of 2025 sets the water and wastewater budgets for 2026. Thank you. I move that appropriation ordinance 2025 dash 13 be adopted second. All right. You want to state your name for the record and then you've got the floor. Thank you. All right. Catherine Zager utilities director. Good evening. I am presenting. an ordinance adopting the utilities budget for the year 2026 for both water and wastewater for final approval. The water utility budget for 2026 is twenty three million one hundred and nineteen dollars and the wastewater total budget is thirty four million five hundred and ninety dollars. Happy to answer questions. This remains unchanged from the last presentation. Thank you. Are there any council member questions for directors? Any questions at all. OK. Seeing none at this time we'll just go straight to public comment. There's any members of the public who would like to make a comment on appropriation ordinance 20 25 13. If you're in chambers, you can make your way to the podium. If you're online, you can raise your hand using the reactions tab or send a chat message to the host. I don't see anybody moving in chambers. If you want to make a comment, go ahead and come up to the microphone so I do see somebody moving in chambers. If you want to go ahead and sign in, there should be a sign in sheet there and then state your name for the record and you'll have up to three minutes. Hi council. My name is Joshua Stockton. I do work at the water treatment plant. I did have a comment. I wanted to formally invite all of you to come take a tour soon whether it all be together or a few of you at a time and I would love to personally show you around and show you everything that you guys really do need to see and I would highly recommend that you guys go to the wastewater treatment plant and you discuss with all of our utility staff all the problems all the concerns anything that we have because I personally feel that there is a separation I Feel like that is something that has been brought up tonight that we do have transparency issues and It's not just towards the public I think it's within our own organization as well and that's why I ask you to come come tour Thank you Thank you Are there any anybody who's raised her hand on zoom Anybody else in chambers then Okay We'll revert back to council then if there are councilmember comments regarding appropriation ordinance 2025 13 Councilmember Flaherty sure. Thank you. Thank you for the comment first Just uh, I have toured those facilities at previously though. It's been a number of years. I really enjoyed it. So plug for that Thank you to Director Zager and the city movement in utilities staff and just wanted to speak briefly with respect to the board in particular as I serve and as our ex-physio non-voting seat on the utility service board. Just that I have a lot of confidence in that board. I get to see them every other week, which you all don't necessarily. And I think they do a great job. It's really balanced. I think diligence is a word that comes to mind. They're asking detailed and thoughtful questions. And they are ensuring that they follow up on things that are unresolved in the meeting, you know, months. Years down the line if needed. So just wanted to share that and give kudos to the board members Since I am our laser. Thanks Great. Thank you. Are there other councilmember comments? All right seeing none I also just want to Thank mr. Stockton for the invitation to tour and I appreciate that he came and commented this evening So with that if the clerk could please call the roll on appropriation ordinance 2025 13 Councilmember Rallo. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Stossberg. Yes. Daily. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Sorry. Yes. Clarity. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Thank you. And that passes nine zero. That brings us to the end of our legislation for this evening. And so now we are down to the elected official salary discussion topic. So as preface for this over the weekend council members were asked a kind of series of questions focused on the the process last year with the ad hoc committee and some of the conclusions that they came to. And so that was released in a packet addendum yesterday. And so for this discussion this evening, I wanted to first start with statements from the mayor and the clerk regarding their thoughts on elected official salaries for the year 2026. So if we want to go ahead and start with the mayor for that and come on forward and probably introduce yourself for the record. And go ahead and share your thoughts with us on the matter Tall microphone, I'm Carrie Thompson. I'm the mayor I've been asked tonight to comment on the salary ordinance and I appreciate the opportunity to address you and Given the same opportunity last year, I asked council to establish principles by which elected officials' salaries would be evaluated each year. I am requesting the same of you this year. I have run multiple organizations and salaries are best set with a single comprehensive set of principles. Our non-union staff salaries at the city are set based on market, and while we can all agree that I cannot shop around for a new mayor's job in another city any more than one of you can run for council in another city, those salaries of other municipalities do inform at least our awareness of where we rank. The Association of Indiana Municipalities tracks those for us, and in their last ranking, of salaries of elected officials. Our current mayoral salary ranks sixth in the state and will be seventh once Indianapolis implements their time delayed raise. Our council ranks seventh as well. Our clerk is ranked third, third highest paid in the state. Should we go with market, I would suggest that we adjust electeds for population size and scope of job as not all electeds have the same level of responsibility as their counterparts. It should be noted that once we raise salaries for elected officials, we are unable to decrease them. So it's important for the public to understand that this is a one-way trajectory and we must be careful to understand it as such. It has been suggested that the clerk and I should get paid based on the equivalencies of department heads. I want to first note that we have three department heads that are already underpaid based on our current salary structure. Their responsibilities combined with their tenure would put them at a level that far exceeds what they're making now. And last year we decided to cap the salaries so that the highest paid city employee makes $155,000. putting us into a department head calculus would be complicated to be sure, and I'm not sure there's actually an equivalency for council. I wanted to note that some comments in the council survey indicated that there was a consultant used, and I will note that the consultant's advice included a recommendation to consider other Indiana elected salaries. This was very common sense advice which was not incorporated into the recommendations. Given that we are elected public servants and we all got into this knowing what it would pay before we ran, my suggestion for this year is that we each take a 2.7% COLA that is being offered to the other employees. It's a priority of councils to establish working principles moving forward in order to restructure elected officials' salaries with a predictable metric each year. I would be happy to work on a team that seeks to set those parameters. Given that we have not done that work this year, I suggest COLA is the best way to move forward, especially given the funding realities that we are facing moving forward under SEA-1. Thank you for your time. Thank you. I also want to say that when we after the mayor and and then after the clerk goes with a statement both of those parties are also invited to participate in the less formal discussion part of this so We're gonna move to the clerk now though Okay Good evening. My name is clerk Nicole Bolden and I am NOT going to have nearly as Composed statement to start off with as Mayor Thompson did, so please forgive me for that. But there were a few points that I wanted to touch base on for this evening in terms of talking about the elected official salaries. One, and I made this point earlier during the fiscal committee meeting, I think it would be a good process to actually separate out into rather having one ordinance where you're looking at all of the elected official salaries, but to separate them out. so that you have a separate ordinance for the common council one for the mayor salary and one for the clerk salary that would allow all of you to have separate negotiations. And if there comes a problem in the future you won't have to go through the process of dividing the question which can be complicated. And while it has come up before in the past I think it was in twenty twenty two or twenty twenty three where it was proposed but discarded as being too difficult. I've said it a few times over the last week or so. I think that considering where we are with SBA one I think it makes more sense to do cola increases to parallel that of the civil city staff for elected officials moving forward. Until such time as we have a better idea of what we're doing or until we're looking at 20 28 for elected official salaries for those who are coming in after having run for office And being given a clear opportunity to state what they think their salaries should be That will help to inform any voters or people running as to what they would like to see I know that last year when the fiscal committee was looking at different processes I offered some perspectives on the different considerations that were made. I will continue to do so if you have any opinions about it. I hesitate even as a board member of Accelerate Indiana municipalities I would hesitate to use their salary study as the guide. I think again going to the source materials and having all the salary ordinances to compare the numbers for if you're looking at other second class cities is probably the smarter way to go because the aim salary study is self-reported. You can also go to Gateway and get the salary information from there. And last two things one like Mayor Thompson happy to work on a team answer any questions that you may have. And to the point because I saw it in the answers we all knew what our salaries were going to be when they ran. Of course we did. It's not hidden, it's very public. I think it's very important to have that discussion. But you do not as a body pass your salary ordinances over the course of your term. You pass it every year. If you weren't planning on changing the salaries, you could pass one ordinance at the start of this body's term and say, we're going to only do COLA increases for the next four years or until the composition of this body changes. You have not done so. So saying well you knew what it was going to be when you ran also knowing it can change every year seems to be having it both ways. And again I would like to reiterate I am not asking for a salary increase this year. I think a cola increase is absolutely appropriate and I'm happy to help or participate in any further discussion. OK. Thank you very much. So I think part of this discussion is to be able to do it in a less formal way than we of course do legislation. But we are all up here in a line and it's really hard to see folks if you're speaking at the end of the line. So who would like to start with any Any reflections that you want to say about your own things any questions that we might have for each other or for the clerk or the mayor? Hopefully everybody got a chance to review the survey answers So if anybody has questions for other council members about those survey answers like like this is the moment Councilmember Piedmont Smith I'm just looking at number six on the survey and Which says given the uncertain financial future of Indiana cities in light of SCA one Do you think elected officials should receive at most a two point seven percent cola increase for twenty twenty six and there were seven Council members who said yes and two who said no So I think it's pretty clear that a majority of would like to have no more than the COLA increase. So I think we can kind of start there and then because we do have to, you know, make a decision without having any further certainty about our revenue future, which looks kind of grim right now. So we can perhaps agree on that and then move on to think about how we can further develop a principled, repeatable system for setting salaries in the future. Although I would say to respond to the mayor, I think the committee last year did have a set of principles. If we look at other survey answers, I don't think everybody agreed with them. But going back to this number six and the maximum increase of a COLA, I was one of the two people who said no. But I think I was, I didn't think through it fully because if we do any further increase this year, of course that's gonna carry forward to our salaries for 27 and 28 and 29 when SEA 1 is really gonna hit us hard. So I think I would change that to a yes now. So anyway, that's what I want to say. So I think that's kind of a proposal by councilmember Piedmont Smith to just do a cola for our Ordinance next year and that most people agreed with that. I think I just look through councilmember Flaherty. Are you the other no on that? Probably I speak briefly to it. I almost find it to be Directly oppositional to the first question which is should the council create a values-based and repeatable method for setting salaries Departing from recent past practice of making minor adjustments to salaries based primarily and whatever the salary was the year before plus a cola That's saying should we have a values-based framework? And move away from just using cola and I think most people said yes And then when we're asked if we should just use the cola for this year. Most people also said yes those seem like diametrically opposed points of view. I think my votes were consistent. That's not to call anyone out or like I'm just reflecting. And I think the reason I would say is that it's just the wrong question. I mean, maybe we have no increase this year. That's fine too. It doesn't really matter. I'm most interested in a values-based and repeatable method, and settling that in some way is, I guess, my highest priority, and the COLA seems a little bit immaterial to that, or at least follows it I guess. Okay. Would anybody else like to speak to that kind of dichotomy of saying well we want a values based framework but yeah we also think that we should only get a cola this year. I would like to point out question number seven was like if you answered yes to both of those can you talk about that. So would anybody like to eat and see that now. Councilmember Piedmont Smith. Well, I'm the one who wrote these questions and I'm not a professional survey taker. I think what I, a creator of surveys, I think what I was getting at was, in principle, do you think we should have a systemic values-based and repeatable method for setting salaries, yes or no? And then the second part was specifically for 2026, Since it's already October and there's been a lot of disagreement in SEA 1 and all this stuff, do you think we should just have a COLA? So I think you could still answer yes, we should only do a COLA for next year. But I do ultimately want to see a principles-based, values-driven system for setting salaries. I think you could say yes to both. But if they contradict, I'm sorry. I'll just do my best. Would anybody else like to speak to that? Councilmember Ruff. Yeah, thank you. Yeah, I don't I don't see the contradiction. As Councilmember Piedmont Smith said, it wasn't saying immediately we need to do this. As a matter of fact, the follow up question is if you answered yes to number one and number six, what do you think is the timeline? For one I just tossed out two to three years knowing that this would take time to to figure out what a values-based Approach might be and maybe then it wouldn't even work after wrestling with it for a while But I I don't see that they're contradictory to have answered the way that the majority of council members answered Any other comments about that council member Rosenberger I Hi thanks I would say I was a little confused about number six so you just can ignore my response honestly I think on that one because I felt like number seven if you entered yes to number one numbers one and six why do you think it's a good. Oh what do you think is a good time. I felt like number seven meant Wanted to know went together honestly because I was like, oh, maybe I'm not understanding number six correctly I guess basically so I'm sorry about that councilmember Piedmont Smith. I Do also align more with councilmember Flaherty just that I think the creating the principles is really important and I Think the work that was done last year like reviewing that work in these questions, right? Like the first questions are those principles I think I think they still hold pretty strong for me and I I guess hope that if the committee continues down that path of making I guess a different framework I hope that's not thrown out and still used as valid work that got done. Thank you. Other comments right now I think I'm going to try to try to Bring us back if that's possible to that original maybe proposal that I mentioned which was that the majority of folks seem to say a two point seven percent COLA increase though councilmember Flaherty also just threw out the concept of no increase at all. I don't know if you meant to do that but there's also the concept of no increase because it is Accurate that that question did say at most a 2.7 percent cola increase and I also think that I remember councilmember daily may be mentioning that last Time when we talked about this at all the concept of no increase And it you know that that maybe you'd be okay with a 2.7 percent increase but no more than that if I'm remembering your Yeah, I think my comments had been before we even mentioned cola increase. Yeah, so it hadn't been on my mind I I think I would be fine either way as well. I wouldn't have a problem with no increase but I wouldn't fight a cola increase either. I'm interested to know what the clerk or the mayor would think about no increase at all not even a cola increase. Do either I mean you guys don't have to answer that. I'm just curious. Do you mean for next year? Yeah Yeah, I think there should be a coal increase for the clerk salary Mayor Thompson I just am gonna stay consistent with what I've said in the past, which is I think we should be as consistent across the organization as we can be and so we did two point seven for the rest of the non-union city staff and So my recommendation would be Do cola for electeds? I'm also fine without it Okay, thank you. Do other people have thoughts on that concept of a of a no increase versus Cola increase councilmember Rallo Well Councilmember Ruff is probably gonna say what I'll say As he is want to say if We don't give a coal increase then it is essentially a pay cut so if that is the intention of anyone's salary, then I I guess there's a discrepancy between There is a they were overpaid and so, you know, we should try to Rainback and you know someone's salary or something like that the only time that I think the council did not take a coal increase was during the 20 2008 2009 Economic crisis where we were Really struggling fortunately did not have to eliminate any jobs but we made me some major cuts and one of those happened to be our cost of living increase and Don't see any need for that. I think that we should just keep up with the cost of living as everyone should My position Councilmember rough. Did you also want to speak? That's what I was about to say actually All right. We have a ditto over there from councilmember rough. Anybody else want to comment councilmember Zulek? Thank you. I'm in favor of keeping a consistent approach across the board and thus I'm in favor of a 2.7 percent cola increase. Thank you. I Anybody else want to address Cola versus nothing. OK. I'm not hearing anybody really advocate strongly for nothing. Is that correct right now. Anybody wants to advocate strongly for nothing like this is the moment to let the fiscal committee know this is what you that you want nothing. OK. we did talk about this at fiscal committee a little bit earlier in terms of trying to like think about this survey and think about long-term and how Like the goals of having this conversation. So one of the goals was What should we put in this ordinance? in terms of an increase so I think the conclusion that we just came to was as was reflected in the survey reflected right now into the discussion and reflected by the mayor and the clerk was all the 2.7 percent COLA increase so that kind of meets our number one objective from fiscal committee right councilmember Piedmont Smith and then our number two objective was looking in to more of the future and Was that the next one as we were going to go back to question number one, right? I mean several of the questions do you deal with How do we come up in the in the future for future years? How do we come up with a systemic way of setting salaries? That's Not arbitrary So yes that starts with question one, okay So in question one where most of us seem to say like yes We want to create some kind of values based and repeatable method for setting salaries I don't think that the clerk commented on that strongly in your Commented on the idea of in the future having a repeatable process based on our values In terms of like a goal for future years the mayor did say and hers like yes, something like that would be great but the question is like What are the guiding principles essentially? So last year we created some guiding principles as part of that if I remember right last year, I don't I don't think that the The guiding principles I think were not beloved by everybody And that's that is also reflected in the survey though. I think the majority of people either agree or are neutral on on them but the I think that that's the next question is if part of what we want to do moving forward is create something like that and if part of what the fiscal committee is supposed to do is Kind of work on that stuff throughout the year and it takes a while to figure that out. So what kinds of guiding principles or values do we want to use. If you disagreed with some of the ones from last year like talk about that Councilmember Piedmont Smith. Well I'm not responding from my own perspective I'm responding from what I've I've heard and read in the survey and I think that several council members and the mayor as well have said that we should one principle or one consideration should be what the salaries are in other second class cities. And that was not considered last year. And I think I don't know if it's a majority but I've heard it from several people up here. Would anybody else like to speak to comparisons. Council member all. Yeah, I think that I prove first of all, I want to say I appreciate the work that was done that council committee But I think that its major shortcoming was lack of context and comparison so I Think that had we adopted the proposed salary for the council would have essentially doubled our current then current salary And We would be an outlier we would be the highest paid council in the state now one possibility is other cities have a flawed process of Evaluating salaries Another is that We're an outlier because of greater workload so more frequent longer meetings committee assignments, etc. And that that is true so Just want to say I'm open to considering information related to those possibilities going forward You know that means very passionate comments were made that you know many Public servants have been underpaid and that's generally the case in a lot of cities. So that's Possibility it's interesting. I'd like to know more about that. I don't know I haven't reviewed that you know In-depth the the workloads of those cities for instance, so So that's what I would like to see going forward I I think that the process might be better just left in the hands of a objective third party so You know consultants Occasionally evaluate salaries and determine on Maybe a basis of, as we said, but what that amount should be. That's all. Thanks. Thank you. Other thoughts on that? I just want to say I don't love the idea of leaving it in the hands of an objective third party, i.e. a consultant, because then we'd have to pay a consultant. And it just kind of gawls me, the idea of paying a consultant to figure out how much we're paid. It feels like kind of like an unwise expenditure, especially to do on a regular basis, like a one time every once in a while, like the city did last year in terms of having that large assessment. It seems reasonable, but to do it on a regular basis seems a little bit wonky. Clerk Bolden, did I see your hand? Go for it. I do not envy you all your task of trying to figure out what things to include in looking at salaries. I do know that last year you looked at the salaries for all second class cities and you looked at their salary data for the mayor the council president the council and the clerk. You also looked at the elected official salaries over the year for the city of Bloomington for all appointees of the mayor and staff. You looked at the councils by frequency for second class cities and broke down their population and their council salaries. And there was also looking at the percentage of the mayoral salary and you also looked at it in terms of pay per regular meeting. So the information was looked at in a variety of different ways. and considerations so I just for the sake of the fiscal committee who put in hours of work looking at this information it wasn't a case of not having the information and not looking at it. They actually took the time to review all of that information and discuss it as part of their settings. I would also include if you are going to look at it in terms of different cities you should also look at the different costs of living in those different cities because doing a street apples for apples Considering that Bloomington's cost of living is higher than other cities Would be doing a disservice to well all of you and there was one thing I forgot to say at the beginning of my statement If it's not too late to add it. I Do think that the council should be paid more Period Although not this year Thank you are there other comments about Both the need to consider peer cities which councilmember Piedmont Smith brought up or other comments related to establishment of guiding principles Or the specific guiding principles that were established last year So I would I would be especially interested to hear from some people who said that they did that they disagreed with the different principles just to get a better idea of like why they disagreed with them. And I guess like I don't want to call people out necessarily with with this but I know that Mayor Thompson also said that last year I think I remember her saying that shouldn't necessarily like agree with these guiding principles like as principles. So I guess I'm really curious to understand more about that moving forward and creating a set that people are in better alignment with. Sorry, I don't know if I'm going to address your question, but I think maybe Two or three and we'll see how related their thoughts I Think the first maybe a broad question that we should evaluate is whether there's any mechanisms for us and whether there are any mechanisms for us to raise our salary in some way that's not permanent. And so I know, so is there a way that you have like, you know, yearly increases or tagged to something that floats with a baseline salary and code or something like that might help address those issues? And I should have said that second because I think, you know, I would say that we shouldn't be We don't need to be zero-sum with critique of a value-based statement. So if people came up with a committee last year, worked hard, and came up with four statements, and the fact that, like, yeah, there's problems with each of those, maybe not collectively held, but I can say, OK, there's an issue with this claim. There's an issue with that claim. They might create other inequities. They create other problems that we can't quite adjust to. But that's not a zero-sum critique. It's not like, oh, because there's a problem with it, we should reject it. We have to keep working on it and figure out how do we actually put this into practice. But I say all of that, though, with I think we have to balance out. There's a little bit of maybe like an epistemological tension, which is that we started with a sort of assumption And I even just phrased it with the way I phrased my first question, which is that we're creating a value-based way to set salaries but with the generally held assumption that we need to raise them. And so as a consequence, we're almost like trying to argue like, why should we raise our salaries? And some of the arguments that were made or some of the claims that were made, some of the positions that were put forward might actually result in us coming up with an answer that is roughly where we're at now. And I kind of feel like we reject that as a possible outcome of looking at those four that have been proposed. But I certainly just think that in this conversation, it's not like reject all the things that are on the table or accept them. It doesn't feel super productive. The question is just like, if you're going to accept any of those, how are you going to address the genuine concerns or the gaps that might exist with any of those proposals if you think that those gaps exist? So a little bit incoherent all over the place but Thank you I do want to say that as in terms of your last comment of like starting with the assumption that we should raise salaries I think last year on that ad hoc committee because I was on it. We didn't start with that assumption We started from the values part and we started from the how should we assess a part? So so first we went to what do we care about and then we went to like how we should base salaries. So that's where we base the mayor's salary on Civil City, in terms of the theory of what we said is the mayor's salaries on Civil City, the clerk's salary on Civil City, and then the council's salary on the mayor. And so it was like, we started from that, and then we looked at the salary charts. And I know for me, that sticker shock that everybody else had, I had that sticker shock too, in that meeting. Whoa, we created this thing, and it resulted in this. Like, whoa, and that was where, I mean, I almost voted no on that recommendation because of the sticker shock part, but ultimately I had to go like, well, we put this effort into these principles and we started from the blank slate scratch and this is what we came to. We didn't start with something and then fill in behind it. So I just wanna clarify that as part of that process, I think we tried really hard to blank slate it, yeah. So just, I mean, I might recollect differently, but the reason why I hold that position is because if you recall, even before we put together the committee, and when you read, if you read the reporting on it, at that day when the committee was established, I said very clearly, I do not support any raises to our salary, and said the exact same argument that I made throughout the rest of the time. And that was contextual statement based on what we were talking about at the time. When establishing that committee, it was clearly said by multiple members of the committee. We just said it out loud. And there's no problem with this position. I'm just saying that it puts us in a rhetorical bind in some ways. But the argument was made very clearly. Council should get higher salaries. Let's put together a committee to discuss this. So there was that starting point, whether you could then disabuse yourself of that, I don't doubt that you could, but that was the context in which we were having these conversations. It was driven by increasing salaries, not by, I mean, we certainly can't reduce them, nor by let's justify the salary that we currently have. I guess we remember that meeting just a little bit differently in terms of like where that origin was but I'm also talking about when we are actually in that committee meeting room going where do we start with this and how do we start with this and and that is one of the reasons why we ultimately brought in that consultant to help lead us through it so that we were trying like doing our level best to start from that like place of inquiry as opposed to start with a with an assumption on the back end other comments councilmember daily Thank you. So what I'm hearing at this moment right now is that we're all pretty much unified that this year Cola increase we all support that and not fighting for anything more. I think you know it doesn't do us any favors to at the end of a budget cycle to start the conversation about what how we want to proceed going forward for electeds. Salaries, so I think that we have a really good start right here We got a really good base especially with the salary and the conversation that we've had and I feel like maybe now then this is a good time for the fiscal committee to process that information and have the conversations and keep working on that and then maybe come back in three months and you know start the conversation again when we're not so close to budget time and You know, there's been a little more thought put into it and processing all of these responses. That's my proposal and Other comments Councilmember Flaherty, I just wanted to briefly support clerk Bolton's Recommendation that we separate new ordinances for council clerk and mayor Councilmember Rallo I just wanted to say that I think that the the hearing on the proposal by the committee Really didn't get a fair hearing because of the process Because we had a very contracted time and they felt to bring it forward it landed in a packet as a resolution and we were we were You know the committee didn't have time to report it for a full-throated discussion so So when I offered a compromise it was really meant as a stopgap really to to allow more conversation to Which we're doing so that's good. I Think that's that's all I'll say Other than oh, I'll say that when I query grok you do it it also thinks we should be paid more That took me a minute I just said You know be aware Yeah That would be an interesting justification Other comments I Guess I want to address the idea of having this conversation now. I mean as as somebody who oh Geez, I'm the only one right now that is on the fiscal committee currently and was also on that that ad hoc salary committee last year and And I think that we tried really hard on that salary committee to come up with something and then we got to council and it was basically like no we don't agree with these principles we don't think their principles we don't think it's valid and I don't want to go through that again on fiscal committee so I don't feel as a member of the fiscal committee like I am moving forward with any more information about what the majority of council is interested in in terms of guiding principles or values that they think that or you all think that we should base salaries on. I mean it's clear that go okay a majority of you think that we should have something but what exactly is this something that we should have and what I just heard was oh just just dump it on fiscal committee to figure out and we did that last year with Salary Committee and it ended up being a Big mess so Like not to say that we should you know, we're necessarily gonna have any answers we keep on talking about this tonight, but I'm just saying that without guidance from everybody about what people actually want, it puts a committee of four in a real bind. Councilmember Piedmont-Smith. I mean, I think we got some good feedback on the survey as to why there was disagreement with some of these five principles. But in other cases, we didn't. People just said neutral or disagree and then didn't tell us why. And I do want to just address one council member said so question three was if you disagree with one or more of the guiding principles please indicate why for each case below. And one person said this this I think this question was anyone who disagrees on the defensive and is unfair. Everybody or nobody should be asked to explain their answers. And I understand that I guess. as the person writing the questions, I read the memo again from the ad hoc committee, and that memo explained why they put forward those principles. So I thought the argument in favor of the principles had already been made by that ad hoc committee, and so that's why I was just asking for explanations if you disagree. So just to clarify that. So in some cases, we did get, well, I disagree because of this, and I could understand that. In other cases, We didn't get responses why somebody disagreed and especially there were some that were neutral that I was like I don't know what to do with that as chair of the fiscal committee. I don't know what to do with that if somebody says neutral. So I think the fiscal committee could only do this if like we each have conversations with each of the people who are not on the fiscal committee to really understand because else I agree with council member Stossberg that The four of us on the fiscal committee could agree with something but again it can come back and not get buy in from the rest of the council. Although I think we do have a leg up from last year just because we've learned some things but it's hard. Other comments. I wanted to clarify a point that was made earlier. And I want to make sure I actually say it so that it could be incorporated into the record. Sorry that always makes me laugh. Earlier Mayor Thompson said the clerk was the third highest paid clerk in the state and that she was the sixth highest paid mayor in the state which is incorrect. The council is ranked sixth in the state. The clerk is the seventh. And the mayor is the 10th even incorporating the shift in salary for the clerk's office. That was a couple hundred dollars over cola last year. It's still the 10th highest paid clerk in the state. That was it. Oh also I don't know what rock is. Did you say that the council is sick. Great. Other comments. Council member Rosa Marger I just want to say I understand definitely the finance committee's frustration and probably trepidation around trying to do again what was done last year. I mean I do think it's somehow worth. I mean maybe you were saying Council member Piedmont Smith is one on ones. I mean I try really hard to if I trust the process I trust the outcome and I mean just for me like an example is I totally believe in the stadium district but I don't like that process and I was going to vote no on that right because neighborhoods were involved. But like I just think like is it possible that council members can believe in a process and then vote on the outcome of that process. And I think that is the disconnect to me and the pie charts with the answers that maybe they believe in the process but don't believe in the outcome and I guess it is like how do we how do we get to a place where folks can like the process no matter the outcome I guess. Other thoughts. She's throwing one out there. I'm not always seeing hands down there at the ends tonight. I don't know if we're being shy or what I think you were looking the other way in the other direction when I raised it we talked like Quite quite a level of depth last year about the overall compensation Framework and approach for the city and something the mayor said in her opening remarks this evening resonated which was you know that in general kind of the best system is uniform one we should be looking at that and We recognized, and I briefly mentioned this in my survey results, that there are some things, I think there's seven attributes in this sort of like weighted calculation that goes into the grade determination for folks, and it has to do with like the stress level of the job and the level of responsibility and things like that, right? Sometimes degrees required, professional certifications, those aren't relevant for elected officials. There were some other things that weren't relevant, but most of it could map pretty well. We did talk about that and talk about those aspects. It wasn't really centered, I don't think, in the committee's proposal, but we thought of that as something of a check as well, something to look at as helping see if this was reasonable based on the principles we've set for the whole city. I wonder if that's Maybe not. But I wonder if that's a more fruitful entry point for, you know, if the committee or at any point, you know, we decide to do something beyond just COLA's, which ostensibly the majority of people support, you know, maybe that's a way to do it. And I wonder if actually like pretending like the council job is a full-time job using that system of evaluation, seeing where you land and then saying, okay, but council's not a full-time job. and then trying to be reasonable about what type of job it is or what type of job we want it to be. Is it a quarter-time job? Is it a five-hour-a-week job? Is it a third-time job? And so I know we don't actually set hours, and I think statute prohibits us from tracking hours in that way. But still, just to, again, try to use some type of systematic approach, maybe that's an option. That's all. Thank you. And that actually reminds me of the last I think it's the last question that I'm trying to get to is what other considerations should go into it. And one of the things that I mentioned at that time was trying to figure out what job descriptions elected positions would have and then how they would be assessed by the HR rubric. And I was really interested in that last year too, but it seemed like last year it was almost like it was It almost felt like a magic HR box in terms of you know, you there's some program or I mean I think that it was actually some spreadsheet where you literally like fill out the things and then you click enter and then it gives a result and that that's how it felt on the committee when I was trying to dig into like how are you assessing this because there are some ways that it just doesn't Align like education requirements. There are no education requirements and so it it Maybe if we had more time we could make it Figure out a way for it to fit better Then we had we just did not have very much time last year to to really dig in with HR exactly how how they were assessing those different like kind of like rubric style you know check boxes in terms of those job descriptions and Yeah, so thank you councilmember Flaherty for bringing up that That concept Other comments Member Piedmont Smith do you feel as fiscal committee chair that you have something to go on here. Yes. So if there are no other last comments from anybody including clerk and mayor I do have one last comment for you all related to the whole evening if I may. As a reminder for all council members you all have to sign appropriation ordinances 2025 dash 11 and 2025 dash 12 and I'd like to get all of your signatures this evening including the mayor who's already graciously agreed to sign them so we can have all of our budget ordinances ready to go and upload into gateway. So if you could please take the time to come over and sign I would greatly appreciate it. All right. Thank you. I think that that was a note on council schedule, which was the next thing on the agenda. So that is a great transition Please make sure that you sign the two documents, right? Clerk Bolden. Did you say two documents? Everybody has to sign in two places before you leave the room this evening And are there any other notes on council schedule? we have a deliberation session next Wednesday, which I believe is the 15th with the Historic Preservation Commission. And then our next regular session is the week after that on the 22nd. And thank you so much. We are adjourned.