WEBVTT

00:00:00.642 --> 00:00:10.512
- Welcome to our regularly scheduled council meeting. Would the lovely clerk please call the

00:00:10.512 --> 00:00:21.467
- roll? Councilmember Flaherty? Here. Stossberg? Here. Piedmont-Smith? Here. Zulek? Here. Asari? Here.

00:00:21.467 --> 00:00:28.734
- Daly? Here. Rallo? Here. Ruff? Here. Rosenberger? Here. All right.

00:00:29.346 --> 00:00:36.075
- Thank you very much. And it looks like there are no minutes for approval. Then we'll have our report

00:00:36.075 --> 00:00:43.004
- section for council members, then a presentation on the climate action plan implementation by Sean Mia,

00:00:43.004 --> 00:00:50.332
- council committee report, and our first section of general public comment. Then we will have any appointments

00:00:50.332 --> 00:00:55.262
- to boards and commissions, legislation for first reading, including title

00:00:55.714 --> 00:01:02.430
- 16 amendments to the Bloomington Municipal Code to update the residential rental unit and lodging

00:01:02.430 --> 00:01:09.283
- establishment inspection program and add a new section on short-term rentals, an ordinance to amend

00:01:09.283 --> 00:01:16.616
- Title X of the Bloomington Municipal Code titled Wastewater regarding fats, oils, and grease, and amending

00:01:16.616 --> 00:01:23.606
- Title VI of the Bloomington Municipal Code to update fees and billing and define new requirements for

00:01:23.606 --> 00:01:24.702
- second readings

00:01:24.866 --> 00:01:31.424
- resolutions. We have a resolution to affirm the City of Bloomington as a welcoming and inclusive community

00:01:31.424 --> 00:01:37.613
- for LGBTQ plus residents and visitors and to reinforce local commitments to equal protection, health

00:01:37.613 --> 00:01:44.110
- care access and human rights. We will have an ordinance to fix the salaries of all elected city officials

00:01:44.110 --> 00:01:50.116
- for the City of Bloomington for the year 2027. An ordinance for UDO amendments related to housing

00:01:50.116 --> 00:01:53.854
- attainability and finally an ordinance to vacate an alley on

00:01:54.114 --> 00:02:02.631
- the southwest corner of West 11th Street and North Roger Street. We will conclude with one final section

00:02:02.631 --> 00:02:11.230
- for public comment and council schedule. Okay. Reports from any council members. Council member Stasberg.

00:02:12.738 --> 00:02:20.550
- Thank you. I was originally planning on trying to make a planned comment this evening about this, but

00:02:20.550 --> 00:02:28.363
- I kind of ran out of runway this afternoon with that. So I'm just going to off the cuff say for those

00:02:28.363 --> 00:02:36.022
- of you who may not be aware that last week the US lost its status as having measles eliminated as a

00:02:36.022 --> 00:02:37.630
- society. And that is

00:02:39.842 --> 00:02:47.582
- I feel like it's a little bit shameful in terms of public health, honestly.

00:02:47.682 --> 00:02:54.341
- Really big problem part of I mean it can be a very serious disease and there's a whole host of people

00:02:54.341 --> 00:03:00.935
- who it could impact especially those under one who are not actually eligible to get the vaccine yet,

00:03:00.935 --> 00:03:07.463
- so I guess if you're listening out there and you have a child please vaccinate them and if you have

00:03:07.463 --> 00:03:14.057
- a child that is Unable to be vaccinated because they're too young or because they you know There are

00:03:14.057 --> 00:03:17.648
- some people that have a different set of circumstances

00:03:17.648 --> 00:03:25.249
- which makes them uneligible for different vaccines. And part of the key is having that herd immunity

00:03:25.249 --> 00:03:32.925
- and so that everybody can protect each other and protect those more vulnerable members of our society

00:03:32.925 --> 00:03:40.451
- that are not able to get various vaccines. And I can appreciate the challenges sometimes associated

00:03:40.451 --> 00:03:43.838
- with the overwhelming piece of vaccinations.

00:03:44.482 --> 00:03:53.391
- There are lots of really legitimate educational ways that you can learn about vaccines and about the

00:03:53.391 --> 00:04:02.212
- diseases and that overall the risk of disease is far greater than the risk that might be associated

00:04:02.212 --> 00:04:06.622
- with getting any of those vaccinations. So please

00:04:07.010 --> 00:04:15.309
- vaccinate your kids and if you and if you are one of those more vulnerable members or you have a kid

00:04:15.309 --> 00:04:23.691
- that's too young, like please take precautions and just be aware of who you're around and be aware of

00:04:23.691 --> 00:04:31.580
- that sickness. Thank you. Thank you very much. And now we'll go to council member Rongo online.

00:04:31.580 --> 00:04:36.510
- Thank you. Can you hear me? Can you hear me? OK, thank you.

00:04:37.282 --> 00:04:45.274
- Mr. Rossman, would you put up the slides that I prepared? I want to speak on the accelerating timeline

00:04:45.274 --> 00:04:53.112
- of AI tonight. First, I want to thank my colleagues for the support you offered on ordinance 202629.

00:04:53.112 --> 00:05:01.414
- This is the ordinance to prohibit the deployment of artificial superintelligence, ASI, within Bloomington.

00:05:01.414 --> 00:05:06.846
- First to say that this is a particular AI, so not to cause confusion.

00:05:07.010 --> 00:05:15.030
- in the community. It's characterized by being an autonomous agent that is vastly superior intelligence

00:05:15.030 --> 00:05:22.894
- in all cognitive domains and has the capability to recursively self-improve. That's what makes it so

00:05:22.894 --> 00:05:30.992
- dangerous. This particular AI, ASI, hasn't yet arrived, but it is the stated goal of the Frontier Labs,

00:05:30.992 --> 00:05:33.406
- and it is on the near horizon.

00:05:34.274 --> 00:05:42.773
- It is designed to replace people in the workplace. It is emphatically not what tech businesses are using

00:05:42.773 --> 00:05:51.433
- here or at IU. In fact, IU's AI efforts are human-centered AI, described as a framework focused on ethical

00:05:51.433 --> 00:05:59.932
- deployment, human oversight, and beneficial societal impacts. It's not designed to replace people. Local

00:05:59.932 --> 00:06:01.470
- tech applications,

00:06:01.634 --> 00:06:11.127
- and IU are to be lauded for their approach. ASI, as we have resolved by resolution, has a high probability

00:06:11.127 --> 00:06:20.265
- of existential risk and therefore should be prohibited in every community across the country. However,

00:06:20.265 --> 00:06:29.758
- this will need to happen soon. Estimates have been that its capability has been growing on an exponential.

00:06:30.754 --> 00:06:40.373
- So the first slide I'd like to show is from meter. This is from a report that was released the day after

00:06:40.373 --> 00:06:49.625
- our ordinance was voted on. What it indicates are two major conclusions. One is that the exponential

00:06:49.625 --> 00:06:58.878
- is no longer exponential, but hyper exponential. That is that the doubling time for the capabilities

00:06:59.522 --> 00:07:08.584
- of things like task duration has gone from every seven months to every four months to every 1.7 months.

00:07:08.584 --> 00:07:17.471
- So it is exploding in terms of its capability. The other conclusion in the report is that 80% of this

00:07:17.471 --> 00:07:26.533
- increase is attributable to a recursive self-improvement. That is the most dangerous practice of having

00:07:26.533 --> 00:07:28.798
- the machines design their

00:07:29.410 --> 00:07:38.738
- their successors. The next slide shows on November 9th, Paul Cristiano, who was President Biden's appointment

00:07:38.738 --> 00:07:47.473
- to head the National AI Safety Commission that was essentially eliminated by President Trump, came out

00:07:47.473 --> 00:07:56.208
- with a stark warning. He said, on our trajectory, he predicted a 50-50 chance of an AI takeover within

00:07:56.208 --> 00:07:57.310
- three years.

00:07:58.178 --> 00:08:06.331
- A situation where AI calls the shots, he says, on our destiny, not people. He added that it was possible

00:08:06.331 --> 00:08:14.095
- for an AI to take over the US government within 12 months on our current trajectory. The next slide

00:08:14.095 --> 00:08:22.248
- shows Jeffrey Hinton, who is regarded as the godfather of artificial intelligence using neural networks.

00:08:22.248 --> 00:08:27.838
- This is just several days later on November 12th. He stated that on the

00:08:28.290 --> 00:08:37.763
- the trajectory we are on, the technology could kill everyone within three years. Next slide. Now, for

00:08:37.763 --> 00:08:47.235
- those who doubt that this is possible or wonder how it could happen, MIT came out with this report on

00:08:47.235 --> 00:08:56.800
- existential risk just yesterday and describes the eight domains where this describes what could happen

00:08:56.800 --> 00:08:57.822
- scenarios.

00:08:58.594 --> 00:09:07.960
- So MIT has offered us examples of what an AI takeover would look like. Last slide, please. Yes, this

00:09:07.960 --> 00:09:17.326
- slide is today. It's a general accounting office report that was just issued a few hours ago showing

00:09:17.326 --> 00:09:26.878
- that AI platforms provide terrorist blueprints when prompted. Now, we hope that these models, not ASI,

00:09:27.394 --> 00:09:34.127
- But the point is that the current models are dangerous enough without proceeding to an artificial

00:09:34.127 --> 00:09:41.203
- superintelligence. So in conclusion, as I said before, we need to stop this research on developing ASI

00:09:41.203 --> 00:09:48.348
- as soon as possible. Every day brings greater risks. I'm very proud that Bloomington took the step that

00:09:48.348 --> 00:09:54.462
- other cities could replicate. AI safety luminary Nate Soros contacted me after the vote.

00:09:55.394 --> 00:10:04.216
- and he congratulated us on laying the groundwork for other cities to follow. He said that hopefully

00:10:04.216 --> 00:10:13.037
- this could snowball with other cities taking action that could lead to a national and international

00:10:13.037 --> 00:10:23.006
- cessation on this type of research. Thank you. Thank you very much. Any other council comments or reports? Okay.

00:10:23.138 --> 00:10:31.038
- Now moving on to the presentation on climate action plan implementation. Oh, I'm sorry. Councilmember Asare.

00:10:31.106 --> 00:10:36.851
- I'm so sorry. It's OK if we have to move on. I'll be super fast. But I'm really sorry that I can't be

00:10:36.851 --> 00:10:42.540
- in person today. But I'm here in Nashville this week attending the National League of Cities Summit,

00:10:42.540 --> 00:10:47.722
- speaking on a panel here, and just wanted to share a quick reflection. I think that there's

00:10:47.722 --> 00:10:53.524
- a real opportunity for Bloomington to benefit from membership in the National League of Cities amongst

00:10:53.524 --> 00:10:59.157
- many other organizations that would help us share information with other cities that are facing the

00:10:59.157 --> 00:11:01.072
- type of things that we're facing.

00:11:01.072 --> 00:11:06.745
- that have overcome the type of things that we've overcome or that we're facing. And I'm just really

00:11:06.745 --> 00:11:12.531
- having a great time started today and runs through Friday. And so I think that many of the challenges

00:11:12.531 --> 00:11:18.204
- that we face, whether they're housing affordability, infrastructure, economic development, emerging

00:11:18.204 --> 00:11:24.103
- technologies are all challenges that communities across the country are working to address. And I think

00:11:24.103 --> 00:11:30.003
- that any type of efforts that we can do to increase our networking with other cities, I think will make

00:11:30.003 --> 00:11:31.024
- us more resilient

00:11:31.024 --> 00:11:36.838
- more innovative city. And so I do plan to bring forward a resolution at some point, maybe at one of

00:11:36.838 --> 00:11:43.118
- our, maybe at our last meeting or during the early time in next year, sort of calling, perhaps or proposing

00:11:43.118 --> 00:11:49.049
- the Bloomington Forum Legion, the National League of Cities. So happy to talk a little bit more about

00:11:49.049 --> 00:11:55.038
- that. But again, sorry that I'm not there with you all. And again, welcome back, Kate. I mean, Council

00:11:55.038 --> 00:11:59.166
- Member Rosenberger, it's the most happy day to see you. Okay, bye-bye.

00:12:00.450 --> 00:12:08.391
- Thank you very much. Are there anyone else? I think I have everyone on Zoom, so I can't miss a hand

00:12:08.391 --> 00:12:16.729
- again. OK. Now we are moving on to the presentation on climate action plan implementation with Assistant

00:12:16.729 --> 00:12:24.670
- Director of Sustainability, Sean Mia. Take it away. Or please state your name for the record first.

00:12:25.250 --> 00:12:30.410
- I am Sean Mia, the assistant director of sustainability for the city of Bloomington's economic

00:12:30.410 --> 00:12:36.167
- and sustainable development department. I have provided a lot of slides tonight. I won't be going through

00:12:36.167 --> 00:12:41.598
- all of them, but they are there in the packet. If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them.

00:12:46.946 --> 00:12:53.233
- This is a map of all of the billion dollar weather and climate disasters caused by climate change in

00:12:53.233 --> 00:12:59.271
- 2026. As you can see, the majority of them are in the Midwest. Climate change impacts our public

00:12:59.271 --> 00:13:05.559
- infrastructure, health, economy, quality of life, ecosystem and food security. And so when we invest

00:13:05.559 --> 00:13:09.854
- in our climate action plan, we are investing in all of these things.

00:13:13.890 --> 00:13:21.079
- Since 2023, ESD has successfully helped the city to secure over a million dollars in funding. Here's

00:13:21.079 --> 00:13:28.268
- a list of all of the funding sources. The first section I'm going to talk about is renewable energy.

00:13:28.268 --> 00:13:35.457
- To date we have 35 municipal solar systems installed at various municipal sites throughout the city.

00:13:35.457 --> 00:13:39.230
- To date we have produced over 27 gigawatts of power.

00:13:39.426 --> 00:13:46.027
- We have hired VeriG to maintain all of those systems, and ESD funds any replacement of broken panels,

00:13:46.027 --> 00:13:47.774
- inverters, and optimizers.

00:13:49.570 --> 00:13:55.790
- Our largest grant program is our solar energy efficiency and lighting program. We provide grants up

00:13:55.790 --> 00:14:02.134
- to $25,000 for solar systems to small businesses and nonprofits, and up to $20,000 for nonprofits for

00:14:02.134 --> 00:14:08.541
- battery energy storage systems for nonprofits that provide essential services. And our vendor for this

00:14:08.541 --> 00:14:10.718
- program is Solar Energy Solutions.

00:14:12.226 --> 00:14:20.961
- Each system is approximately eight kilowatts. The lifetime savings of a single system is approximately

00:14:20.961 --> 00:14:29.442
- $56,000, and they will reduce 217 metric tons of CO2 emissions. In 2026, we have approved six solar

00:14:29.442 --> 00:14:38.686
- systems for these sites with two additional installs in the queue for this year at these two sites. In 2026,

00:14:38.978 --> 00:14:47.612
- Bloomington Housing Authority's solar system for the grant that we provided to Bloomington Housing Authority

00:14:47.612 --> 00:14:55.692
- was installed. The total capacity was 85 kilowatts. The 25-year total electric cost savings for these

00:14:55.692 --> 00:15:03.852
- systems is $620,000, and the CO2 emission reductions is over 2,000 metric tons. This year, we launched

00:15:03.852 --> 00:15:08.446
- our Solar Grants for Income Qualified Homeowners program.

00:15:08.642 --> 00:15:16.593
- This system will install five kilowatt systems on 22 houses. The total combined savings for all of these

00:15:16.593 --> 00:15:24.165
- systems over the lifetime of the systems is over 690,000 with reducing over 3000 metric tons of CO2

00:15:24.165 --> 00:15:31.358
- emissions. So far we have approved 12 installations and we have received over 40 applications.

00:15:33.026 --> 00:15:39.248
- This grant will provide ESD staff with excellent experience if the three million dollar solar for all

00:15:39.248 --> 00:15:45.653
- grant that was allocated to the city of Bloomington is reinstated by the EPA. Federal courts ruled EPA's

00:15:45.653 --> 00:15:51.935
- grant termination was illegal in September of twenty twenty six. So that is making its way through the

00:15:51.935 --> 00:15:58.462
- court systems and hopefully that funding will be provided to the city of Bloomington. One grant applicant.

00:15:58.594 --> 00:16:05.770
- said, saving on energy costs will allow us to use money saved on energy on child care for our nearly

00:16:05.770 --> 00:16:12.946
- one-year-old daughter. The next session I'll talk about is energy efficiency. I wanted to provide an

00:16:12.946 --> 00:16:20.264
- update for all of the work that we've done with Donovan Energy, who is our municipal energy efficiency

00:16:20.264 --> 00:16:27.440
- and decarbonization consultant. In 2025, they completed nine level two ASHRAE energy audits on these

00:16:27.440 --> 00:16:28.222
- buildings.

00:16:28.386 --> 00:16:34.921
- And from those audits, they had a list of recommended energy conservation measures. So far, we have

00:16:34.921 --> 00:16:41.521
- completed numerous LED lighting upgrades. We've installed a high volume, low speed fan at Switchyard

00:16:41.521 --> 00:16:48.382
- Park Maintenance Garage. I'll just highlight on some of these. We have installed heat pumps at Rose Hill

00:16:48.482 --> 00:16:56.207
- Maintenance garage and we will be installing heat pumps at the Allison jukebox community center early

00:16:56.207 --> 00:17:04.158
- next year We will also be installing rooftop solar at the animal shelter early next year and the Allison

00:17:04.158 --> 00:17:11.731
- jukebox community center So here are all the buildings that we have completed LED lighting upgrades

00:17:11.731 --> 00:17:13.246
- We received we were

00:17:13.506 --> 00:17:20.830
- awarded $141,000 reimbursement voucher from the U.S. Department of Energy's Energy Efficiency Conservation

00:17:20.830 --> 00:17:27.675
- Block Grant. We anticipate receiving, hoping to receive that reimbursement by the end of this year.

00:17:27.675 --> 00:17:34.794
- We also received a $508,000 grant from the Indiana Office of Energy Development for the Buskirt-Chumlee

00:17:34.794 --> 00:17:41.502
- Theater. This was part of their Empowering Energy Partnerships in Indiana Communities EPIC grant.

00:17:41.730 --> 00:17:48.473
- So today we have hired HFI to complete the HVAC upgrades. We will be installing a 24 kilowatt solar

00:17:48.473 --> 00:17:55.351
- system on the roof. We were supposed to install a battery energy storage system with this project. We

00:17:55.351 --> 00:18:03.038
- issued the ITP and the bids that we received were too high, so that part has been removed from the scope of work.

00:18:03.266 --> 00:18:09.886
- We anticipate the solar installation and the HVAC upgrades to be completed by April of 2027. And we

00:18:09.886 --> 00:18:17.036
- will be hosting four climate talks at the Buskirt Chumlee Theater in 2027. So now for the energy efficiency

00:18:17.036 --> 00:18:23.723
- and lighting portion of the SEAL program, we provide free energy audits and up to $10,000 grants for

00:18:23.723 --> 00:18:30.078
- energy efficiency projects for LED lighting upgrades, heat pump HVAC systems, air conditioners,

00:18:30.178 --> 00:18:37.047
- heat pump, water heaters, insulation, windows, doors, and cool roofs. IFF completes the energy audits.

00:18:37.047 --> 00:18:44.183
- And this is a list of all of the grant recipients that have been approved in 2026. And here are additional

00:18:44.183 --> 00:18:48.318
- sites that have been approved for energy efficiency upgrades.

00:18:52.098 --> 00:18:57.672
- Our Bloomington Green Home Improvement Program is a program where we provide rebates to Bloomington

00:18:57.672 --> 00:19:03.358
- homeowners. Rebates cover 25 percent of the installation or 40 percent for low income residents up to

00:19:03.358 --> 00:19:09.211
- a maximum amount depending on the project type. So for example for solar panels we provide five thousand

00:19:09.211 --> 00:19:15.454
- dollar rebate for heat pumps twenty five hundred dollars. So we provide rebates for all of these project types.

00:19:18.722 --> 00:19:25.872
- And so in 2025, we approved 32 rebates. In 2026, we approved 43 rebates. Six of those were low-income

00:19:25.872 --> 00:19:33.162
- qualified. In 2026, we completed our Bloomington Energy Works program. We were awarded a $250,000 grant

00:19:33.162 --> 00:19:40.312
- by the Coalition for Green Capital in Ickley, USA. We used this funding to create a robust program to

00:19:40.312 --> 00:19:44.798
- promote energy efficiency and renewable energy across the city.

00:19:44.898 --> 00:19:51.192
- Our goal is to bring low-cost capital to Bloomington for project implementation. And our project partner

00:19:51.192 --> 00:19:57.486
- for this program was the Indiana Energy Independence Fund. So with that funding, we provided free energy

00:19:57.486 --> 00:20:03.720
- audits to nine commercial manufacturing nonprofit building owners and MCCSE to develop a list of energy

00:20:03.720 --> 00:20:09.534
- efficiency and solar projects in need of funding for our volunteer community engagement program.

00:20:09.634 --> 00:20:16.429
- Our hired nonprofit Electrify Indiana, they knocked on 7,000 doors and gave group presentations. And

00:20:16.429 --> 00:20:23.292
- we created a robust public-private partnership plan worth $69 million. So the next section is climate

00:20:23.292 --> 00:20:30.020
- adaptation. Our cool corridors program is where we fund tree plantings next to sidewalks to protect

00:20:30.020 --> 00:20:35.806
- pedestrians from extreme heat and to also cool our city and increase our tree canopy.

00:20:36.002 --> 00:20:42.506
- Canopy Bloomington, their grant agreement is for community engagement activities, tree plantings, and

00:20:42.506 --> 00:20:49.074
- tree maintenance for three years. We collaborate with an IU urban forestry class in Haskell Smith, the

00:20:49.074 --> 00:20:56.088
- city of Bloomington's urban forester. We planted 125 trees in BHA's Crestmont and Walnut Woods neighborhoods.

00:20:56.088 --> 00:21:03.102
- We will plant 100 trees north of College Mall in 2027, and we'll plant 100 trees along Second Street in 2028.

00:21:04.642 --> 00:21:11.190
- Our tree assistance program is where we provide funding to remove hazardous limbs or trees for low to

00:21:11.190 --> 00:21:17.737
- moderate income homeowners. This increases electric grid resilience during severe weather by removing

00:21:17.737 --> 00:21:24.606
- tree hazards in your power lines. It decreases property damage. In 2025, we completed 12 tree removals, 12

00:21:24.898 --> 00:21:31.567
- trees needing risk mitigation pruning and the planting of 12 new trees. In 2026, we are assisting 17

00:21:31.567 --> 00:21:38.500
- homeowners with tree removals, risk mitigation pruning, and planting of new trees. In 2026, we completed

00:21:38.500 --> 00:21:45.234
- bus stop shelter installations across the city. We just launched our new residential stormwater grant

00:21:45.234 --> 00:21:51.903
- program in collaboration with CBU. This provides funding for residential grants for rain gardens and

00:21:51.903 --> 00:21:53.950
- bioswales to prevent flooding.

00:21:54.434 --> 00:22:00.410
- on private property. I wanted to give an update of Project 46, the Southern Indiana Regional Climate

00:22:00.410 --> 00:22:06.860
- Alliance. The steering committee is made up of the city of Bloomington, town of Nashville, city of Columbus.

00:22:06.860 --> 00:22:12.363
- Our list of advisory committee members continues to grow every year. So some key milestones.

00:22:12.363 --> 00:22:18.399
- In July 2025, we adopted our bylaws and organizational structure. In May of this year, we hired Lotus

00:22:18.399 --> 00:22:23.902
- Engineering and Sustainability as our regional climate alliance consultant. In July of 2026,

00:22:24.290 --> 00:22:31.792
- Project 46 was awarded $35,000 capacity building grant from the Indianapolis Foundation. And this month

00:22:31.792 --> 00:22:39.583
- we are applying for a grant from the Climate Smart Communities Initiative to fund flood mitigation projects

00:22:39.583 --> 00:22:47.230
- in each of the Project 46 member cities. In September 2026, we held our first strategic planning retreat.

00:22:47.810 --> 00:22:53.952
- We decided on four focus areas, flood and hazard mitigation, energy efficiency, renewable energy, waste

00:22:53.952 --> 00:22:59.444
- and materials management, and EV adoption. The next steps are to do mapping for our partners

00:22:59.444 --> 00:23:05.882
- and stakeholders. We are forming subcommittees for each of the focus areas. With the help of our consultant,

00:23:05.882 --> 00:23:11.964
- we are researching and applying for funding opportunities. And the subcommittees and all of us, we are

00:23:11.964 --> 00:23:14.622
- working on community outreach and education.

00:23:16.450 --> 00:23:22.977
- We are continuing to fund food security grants for Hoosier Hills Food Bank to purchase and distribute

00:23:22.977 --> 00:23:29.632
- locally grown food. Mother Hubbard is covered to support their garden program. Our Earth Day attendance

00:23:29.632 --> 00:23:36.222
- continues to grow every year. And we have our Zero in Bloomington Sustainability Action Platform. It's

00:23:36.222 --> 00:23:38.974
- an online platform that residents can use.

00:23:39.074 --> 00:23:46.221
- So this coming fall winter we are getting ready to launch a new zero heroes group challenge Residents

00:23:46.221 --> 00:23:53.578
- will form groups to complete missions including volunteering We have our climate action dashboard that's

00:23:53.578 --> 00:24:00.864
- still up and running and Finally our climate action plan the five-year anniversary was in April of 2026

00:24:00.864 --> 00:24:06.750
- we are going to be publishing a five-year implementation report early next year and

00:24:07.394 --> 00:24:13.323
- Our departments have submitted over 220 climate actions that will be in that report. We have hired Kim

00:24:13.323 --> 00:24:19.137
- Lundgren and associates who will be leading an internal staff workshop in January to help us refocus

00:24:19.137 --> 00:24:25.066
- the climate action plan and to help us prioritize actions for the next five years. It's not that we're

00:24:25.066 --> 00:24:31.282
- doing away with the original climate action plan. This is just an internal refocus and it'll be an addendum

00:24:31.282 --> 00:24:32.894
- to the climate action plan.

00:24:34.114 --> 00:24:41.438
- So thank you so much, and I'm happy to answer your questions. Thank you. Are there any questions? Council

00:24:41.438 --> 00:24:48.417
- member Stossberg. I'm just curious real fast on the plan to plant the hundred trees north of College

00:24:48.417 --> 00:24:55.465
- Mall. Like, what is, I mean, north of College Mall could be lots of places. So I just wanted a little

00:24:55.465 --> 00:24:57.054
- bit more detail about.

00:24:57.442 --> 00:25:06.537
- where those trees are going to go? Yep. It'll be east of, what is that, 45? East of, or 46 there?

00:25:06.537 --> 00:25:15.818
- East of 46, north of, what is that, 3rd Street? It's the area there by St. Mark's Church, Best Buy,

00:25:15.818 --> 00:25:23.614
- Need More Coffee. There's a whole area there. OK. So they're not necessarily, like,

00:25:25.186 --> 00:25:31.204
- It's like on the private property, essentially. And the right of way and private property. So we're

00:25:31.204 --> 00:25:37.462
- looking at continuous areas where we can plant trees. Sometimes we don't have enough space in the right

00:25:37.462 --> 00:25:43.479
- of way. And so that's where Canopy Bloomington and the IU Urban Forestry class will engage with the

00:25:43.479 --> 00:25:49.918
- property owners to see if we can plant trees on their property. OK. All right. Great. That's like district

00:25:49.918 --> 00:25:53.950
- three. So I would be interested in hearing more about that. Great.

00:25:54.626 --> 00:26:03.022
- Being around for any of that, if that is appropriate. I know sometimes the canopy Bloomington folks

00:26:03.022 --> 00:26:12.258
- do that. We would appreciate your help. Thanks. Councilmember Piedmont-Smith. Yeah, as far as the Bloomington

00:26:12.258 --> 00:26:20.990
- energy works, what phase are we in now? We received the $250,000 investment fund market building grant.

00:26:21.474 --> 00:26:28.500
- Have we continued with the submission of the $50 million, the list of potential projects up to 50 million?

00:26:28.500 --> 00:26:35.263
- Has that been submitted? Yes. The Bloomington Energy Works program has completed. We have expended all

00:26:35.263 --> 00:26:42.091
- of the funding that was provided. And we provided that public-private partnership plan to the Municipal

00:26:42.091 --> 00:26:48.657
- Investment Fund in Ickley, USA. And they're continuing to engage with us and trying to find funders

00:26:48.657 --> 00:26:50.430
- who are willing to provide

00:26:50.882 --> 00:26:59.082
- low-cost capital in Bloomington for those projects. So I'm just looking at the website. There are different

00:26:59.082 --> 00:27:06.751
- steps here. So are we on step three, apply for a potential $2 million phase two municipal investment

00:27:06.751 --> 00:27:14.343
- fund? That funding, the municipal investment fund in Ickley, USA, they were not able to secure that

00:27:14.343 --> 00:27:19.582
- funding for that additional $2 million grant for each of the cities.

00:27:19.682 --> 00:27:26.342
- Their funding is actually frozen. It's it's sitting in their bank, but the Trump administration has

00:27:26.342 --> 00:27:33.069
- frozen those funds and so it's sitting there It's gaining interest, but they're not actually allowed

00:27:33.069 --> 00:27:39.729
- to distribute that funding at this time Okay, so at this point we're just looking for The coalition

00:27:39.729 --> 00:27:46.256
- is helping us look for funding to implement some of the projects on that big list. Yes All right.

00:27:46.256 --> 00:27:48.254
- Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. I

00:27:48.546 --> 00:28:00.764
- Councilmember Rallo. Thank you. That's a very impressive, outstanding volume of work that you've done

00:28:00.764 --> 00:28:13.221
- in finding resources besides too. My question was about, I think of action on climate change from maybe

00:28:13.221 --> 00:28:17.054
- three different angles. One is,

00:28:18.402 --> 00:28:27.878
- Increasing efficiency, so reducing carbon emissions that way. Substituting fossil fuels by using solar

00:28:27.878 --> 00:28:37.170
- wind. And then sequestration. And you're doing a lot of tree planting. Maybe we've done some prairie

00:28:37.170 --> 00:28:47.198
- planting too, which is a really efficient way of sequestering carbon. But I wonder if we keep track of that.

00:28:47.874 --> 00:28:57.170
- Do we quantify the sequestration that these trees contribute to our overall carbon reduction? We haven't

00:28:57.170 --> 00:29:06.201
- done that yet. I believe we were waiting for updated maps of our tree canopy. And so far, that hasn't

00:29:06.201 --> 00:29:15.054
- been included in our greenhouse gas emissions inventory. But that's something that we could look at

00:29:15.054 --> 00:29:16.382
- in the future.

00:29:18.530 --> 00:29:25.476
- Yeah, I just want to say that I think it would be a great idea. But thank you so much for your report.

00:29:25.476 --> 00:29:32.894
- Thank you. Council member Osari. Thank you so much. And I thank you, Director Mia, for all of your incredible

00:29:32.894 --> 00:29:39.637
- work. And I think also the copious amount of work that's being done. But I'm somewhat curious about

00:29:39.637 --> 00:29:46.718
- many targets. I mean, just taking one and sort of maybe building off of Council member Aralo's question.

00:29:46.818 --> 00:29:54.546
- Could you talk a little bit, if you took a sort of step back, about where we are today relative to our

00:29:54.546 --> 00:30:02.574
- 2030 emissions targets, for example? So in terms of our KPIs, how are we doing? Thank you for the question

00:30:02.574 --> 00:30:05.950
- and the opportunity, council members. Sorry.

00:30:06.146 --> 00:30:14.113
- Based on our most recent greenhouse gas inventory report, we are on track to meet our 2030 goal, which

00:30:14.113 --> 00:30:21.848
- is to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions by 25% of our 2018 emission levels. So we are on track to

00:30:21.848 --> 00:30:30.125
- meet that goal. But however, to meet our 2050 goal of carbon neutrality, we need to significantly increase

00:30:30.125 --> 00:30:34.302
- our efforts in reducing our greenhouse gas emissions.

00:30:34.370 --> 00:30:40.946
- So everything they can do. Excellent. And that gets to my follow-up question, which is, have you outlined

00:30:40.946 --> 00:30:47.523
- what increasing our efforts looks like? I mean, obviously, there's some federal elements that are outside

00:30:47.523 --> 00:30:53.727
- of our hands. But within the realm of control that we have, what would you like to see us do in the

00:30:53.727 --> 00:31:00.117
- next couple of years? And I know that there's this asterisk on. We'll also have a better sense of this

00:31:00.117 --> 00:31:04.336
- after the five-year re-strategy. But just from where you stand now,

00:31:04.336 --> 00:31:11.362
- sort of informing the next couple of years, what would you like to see council doing, supporting, advocating

00:31:11.362 --> 00:31:18.001
- for? So if we look at our greenhouse gas inventory, the majority of our emissions come from stationary

00:31:18.001 --> 00:31:24.511
- energy usage, so from our building energy usage. And so everything that we can do to increase energy

00:31:24.511 --> 00:31:31.086
- efficiency in buildings, so all of our municipal buildings trying to make them as energy efficient as

00:31:31.086 --> 00:31:33.342
- possible. And that goes for homes.

00:31:33.858 --> 00:31:40.623
- businesses manufacturers schools all of those buildings every building needs to be more energy efficient

00:31:40.623 --> 00:31:47.065
- and then our second source of greenhouse gas emissions are transportation and so everything that we

00:31:47.065 --> 00:31:53.959
- can do to transfer our municipal fleet to electric vehicles and encouraging EV adoption with our residents

00:31:53.959 --> 00:32:00.917
- providing EV charging stations all over the city encouraging our businesses to provide EV charging stations

00:32:00.917 --> 00:32:02.334
- our manufacturers our

00:32:03.042 --> 00:32:10.446
- schools, wherever people are parking their cars to encourage EV charging stations availability. And

00:32:10.446 --> 00:32:18.221
- then I think just continuing the programs that we already have. So our SEAL program, our BG HIP program,

00:32:18.221 --> 00:32:25.847
- we're providing rebates for EV chargers inside homes. So continuing those programs and wherever we can

00:32:25.847 --> 00:32:27.550
- install solar as well.

00:32:28.066 --> 00:32:35.292
- So encouraging solar, so continuing our seal, BGHIP program, municipal solar installations, encouraging

00:32:35.292 --> 00:32:42.588
- all of our businesses and manufacturers and schools to install solar. All of those things need to happen

00:32:42.588 --> 00:32:49.676
- to really make an impact. Excellent. Thank you. Any other questions? I have a question. OK. Thank you

00:32:49.676 --> 00:32:55.999
- so much for the presentation. And congratulations to you and Miss Jolie Perry, another one

00:32:55.999 --> 00:32:58.014
- of our sustainability staff.

00:32:58.146 --> 00:33:04.696
- for all of your accomplishments over the past year. I was just wondering a little bit about the food

00:33:04.696 --> 00:33:11.311
- security grants. I know that moving into 2027, we're going to see increasing cuts to our SNAP program

00:33:11.311 --> 00:33:17.212
- at the federal level. How are we preparing for that? And in regard to the security grants,

00:33:17.212 --> 00:33:22.206
- how can organizations apply for a food security grant? Thank you. Thank you.

00:33:22.402 --> 00:33:30.222
- So so far we have the same amount budgeted for 2027 that we have all along and So we've been partnering

00:33:30.222 --> 00:33:37.816
- with Hoosier Hills food bank it seems to be a great partnership where they're they're working with a

00:33:37.816 --> 00:33:45.786
- local farmer to Purchase local locally produced food and distribute that and the mother Hubbard's covered

00:33:45.786 --> 00:33:50.974
- their garden program they are providing education to residents about

00:33:51.138 --> 00:34:00.840
- Growing vegetables and all the vegetables that they grow on site they provide to residents So we will

00:34:00.840 --> 00:34:10.542
- continue those programs Thank you so much Okay, any other questions? Okay. Thank you very much. Thank

00:34:10.542 --> 00:34:19.102
- you so much And now we are moving on to reports by council committees do we have any Okay

00:34:19.650 --> 00:34:26.998
- And now we will begin our first section of public comment. Just so everybody is aware, we have three

00:34:26.998 --> 00:34:34.419
- minutes per person. Please state your name for the record, and you will be able to go. And your timer

00:34:34.419 --> 00:34:42.131
- should be up on the screen. Great. Hello. My name is Katherine Corz Rosman. I'm a photographer and artist

00:34:42.131 --> 00:34:47.806
- in the community. And I have been practically run out of the community by two

00:34:47.906 --> 00:34:54.473
- former arts administrators. I tried to speak last night at the Bloomington Arts Commission and while

00:34:54.473 --> 00:35:01.170
- I was speaking the event was hacked with anti-semitic images and penises were put behind my head while

00:35:01.170 --> 00:35:07.996
- I was speaking. This has been a really long and difficult process where I've been searching for an adult

00:35:07.996 --> 00:35:14.238
- in the room who could maybe acknowledge that the retaliation I'm experiencing has gone too far.

00:35:15.138 --> 00:35:21.779
- I have closed my business. I am trying to live and work and function in this community. And the city

00:35:21.779 --> 00:35:28.683
- arts department has made that impossible. I think city arts and the commission has become too political.

00:35:28.683 --> 00:35:35.258
- I think you need to completely disband the Bloomington arts commission at this time. I am not happy

00:35:35.258 --> 00:35:41.965
- with that. I believe in building things up instead of tearing them down. But I believe that a strange

00:35:41.965 --> 00:35:43.806
- brand of political activism

00:35:43.938 --> 00:35:50.826
- has become systemic in our arts in a way that is affecting citizens so they cannot build small creative

00:35:50.826 --> 00:35:57.516
- businesses in our community anymore. Even here tonight, I'm afraid that I'm going to be shot. People

00:35:57.516 --> 00:36:04.470
- have shut down my Instagram all day and my website. And I mean, speaking in front of the Arts Commission

00:36:04.470 --> 00:36:11.358
- last night under the circumstances that I did was one of the most disrespectful experiences of my life.

00:36:11.906 --> 00:36:18.921
- And I cannot believe that my hometown did this to me. I have volunteered hundreds of hours in this community.

00:36:18.921 --> 00:36:25.489
- I have volunteered for marginalized people. I am not fighting the Palestinian cause in any way. I will

00:36:25.489 --> 00:36:31.866
- stand up here and say, free Palestine. I have an incredible amount of empathy for those people. But

00:36:31.866 --> 00:36:38.307
- I am not willing to take that on as if I am the enemy in our community. And that is happening and is

00:36:38.307 --> 00:36:39.646
- happening regularly.

00:36:40.162 --> 00:36:46.452
- and I have spoken to the mayor's office, the legal seemed to think that I was pursuing some kind of

00:36:46.452 --> 00:36:52.994
- liability claim. I don't want to sue the city that I grew up in. I don't want a penny from you. I think

00:36:52.994 --> 00:36:59.346
- that suing a city is taking money away from yourself. That's money I paid for roads and programs for

00:36:59.346 --> 00:37:05.888
- my child and my family. I can't believe I have to come here tonight and ask for help. I don't know what

00:37:05.888 --> 00:37:09.662
- to do to find an adult that will say, this is unacceptable.

00:37:10.818 --> 00:37:17.221
- So I'm asking for help. And last night, the way the meeting was set up, it was set up in a way where

00:37:17.221 --> 00:37:23.751
- there was no comment. No one spoke to my concerns. The meeting was actually established in a way where

00:37:23.751 --> 00:37:30.344
- they weren't able to do that. And public comment was intentionally suppressed. People left. People were

00:37:30.344 --> 00:37:34.782
- not allowed into the meeting. I think it was a failure of governance.

00:37:39.202 --> 00:37:45.619
- Unfortunately the way that the meeting is set up we are not allowed to respond to public comments But

00:37:45.619 --> 00:37:51.911
- thank you, is there anyone else in Chambers who would like to speak? Please state your name. You'll

00:37:51.911 --> 00:37:58.328
- have three minutes Good evening. My name is Kenny Leifert. I am a neighborhood compliance officer for

00:37:58.328 --> 00:38:04.745
- housing neighborhood development I'm here tonight to extend an open invitation to any and all council

00:38:04.745 --> 00:38:09.086
- members before I extend that I'm here with some of my co-workers and

00:38:09.474 --> 00:38:15.930
- I'm on behalf of the ones that aren't here. I just like to give a brief description of what compliance

00:38:15.930 --> 00:38:22.762
- officers do there are 33,000 plus rentals in the city They all have to be inspected All of those inspections

00:38:22.762 --> 00:38:29.093
- have to have a report written Those have to be followed up with the reinspection if those violations

00:38:29.093 --> 00:38:33.982
- are not corrected another report that also includes complaint inspections and

00:38:34.114 --> 00:38:41.925
- It includes BHQA meetings. It includes reports for those meetings. It includes Board of Public Works,

00:38:41.925 --> 00:38:49.582
- if anybody wants to appeal these. We also enforce Title VI of our code. Excessive growth, loose and

00:38:49.582 --> 00:38:57.470
- scattered trash, cans at the curb, snow removal, which I really want to touch on. And that is not just

00:38:57.470 --> 00:39:01.758
- rentals in the city. That is all residents of the city.

00:39:04.514 --> 00:39:12.598
- When we hear some grumblings that we're not doing enough with enforcement, we decided we'd like to kind

00:39:12.598 --> 00:39:20.526
- of stand up and say something on our behalf. There's roughly 243.5 miles of sidewalk in the city. For

00:39:20.526 --> 00:39:28.299
- all of that to be cleared, for seven people to enforce that is quite the job. We know that it's not

00:39:28.299 --> 00:39:33.662
- perfect. We know that it doesn't always get done in a timely manner.

00:39:33.794 --> 00:39:41.446
- We've heard that people would like it to go straight to fines and no warnings be issued. We do not agree

00:39:41.446 --> 00:39:49.025
- with that. We think everyone should get a warning before they get a fine. And one of the things we like

00:39:49.025 --> 00:39:56.531
- to do is we try to enforce around schools first. We try to go to the bus stops and then we try to work

00:39:56.531 --> 00:40:02.142
- from downtown out to make sure, to try to make it safe for everybody. Again,

00:40:02.690 --> 00:40:10.539
- And we receive you report system. I'm sure you're all familiar with that. That is nonstop at every day

00:40:10.539 --> 00:40:18.617
- all day. And that's not just for title six. That is rental complaints, snow complaints, trash complaints,

00:40:18.617 --> 00:40:26.542
- grass complaints. That never stops. So the main reason we came tonight was to extend an open invitation

00:40:26.542 --> 00:40:32.638
- to all members of council that we would like for you, any of you, all of you to

00:40:33.314 --> 00:40:39.588
- come to the hand department and spend a day or a week with a compliance officer. We'd like you to maybe

00:40:39.588 --> 00:40:45.621
- ride with us. We'd like you to go in some of these rentals. We'd like you to see some of the things

00:40:45.621 --> 00:40:51.715
- that we experience on a daily basis. It's not always the greatest. We'd like for you to go into some

00:40:51.715 --> 00:40:57.808
- of them, not some of these nice new shiny builds, but some of these rentals that are a little rough.

00:40:57.808 --> 00:41:01.790
- But we'd also like you to come out especially during snow season.

00:41:02.882 --> 00:41:09.234
- Try and understand just exactly what we are dealing with on a daily basis when there is snow out or

00:41:09.234 --> 00:41:15.649
- In the middle of the summer when people don't want to cut their grass or pick their trash up or pull

00:41:15.649 --> 00:41:22.254
- their trash cans from the curb And we didn't come tonight to make any accusations Obviously, we're just

00:41:22.254 --> 00:41:28.860
- trying to extend an invitation and we would like for everybody on the council to really get a good idea

00:41:28.860 --> 00:41:32.798
- and maybe a first-hand experience of just what we do so again

00:41:34.850 --> 00:41:41.915
- We would really just appreciate if some people, if any of you would just come out and maybe spend a

00:41:41.915 --> 00:41:49.121
- day or a week with us. And it's not a, nobody likes the hand department. I hate to say that, but when

00:41:49.121 --> 00:41:56.185
- we show up, it is either going to cost money or time. Thank you all very much. Thank you. And thank

00:41:56.185 --> 00:42:03.038
- you for your service, Mr. Leifert. I will follow up with you on that. Do we have anyone on zoom?

00:42:03.778 --> 00:42:11.595
- Okay. First person on Zoom, you should be able to unmute and you'll have three minutes. Please state

00:42:11.595 --> 00:42:19.335
- your name. Is that me? Am I the first person? Can you hear me? Yes, we can. Go right ahead. Okay. I

00:42:19.335 --> 00:42:27.074
- wasn't sure there wasn't an indication of who was going to speak, but good evening. My name is Eric

00:42:27.074 --> 00:42:31.486
- Ost and I appreciate this opportunity to offer comments.

00:42:32.162 --> 00:42:38.312
- I want to express my strong support for continued and expanded financial contributions by the city of

00:42:38.312 --> 00:42:44.402
- Bloomington to Bloomington Transit and urge that public transportation receive a greater priority in

00:42:44.402 --> 00:42:50.673
- the allocation of cities, of the city's transportation resources. Public transit is an essential public

00:42:50.673 --> 00:42:57.064
- service. Thousands of residents depend on it to get to work, attend school, obtain medical care, purchase

00:42:57.064 --> 00:42:59.838
- groceries, and participate in community life.

00:43:00.514 --> 00:43:06.193
- For many residents, particularly those with limited incomes, older adults, students, and people with

00:43:06.193 --> 00:43:11.815
- disabilities, public transit is not a single, excuse me, is not simply a transportation preference,

00:43:11.815 --> 00:43:17.494
- it is a necessity. In October alone, Bloomington Transit provided more than 254,000 passenger trips,

00:43:17.494 --> 00:43:23.285
- yet proposed reductions in service threatened to make transportation less accessible and less reliable

00:43:23.285 --> 00:43:25.534
- for the very people who depend upon it.

00:43:26.082 --> 00:43:32.426
- Meanwhile, limiting continues to invest substantial resources in safe streets for all initiatives, traffic

00:43:32.426 --> 00:43:38.889
- calming devices, bicycle lanes, and neighborhood greenways. Some of these investments may provide legitimate

00:43:38.889 --> 00:43:45.055
- safety benefits, but their actual benefits should be objectively measured and compared with alternative

00:43:45.055 --> 00:43:51.458
- uses of those same public funds. The assessment requires open, timely, and ongoing publication of relevant,

00:43:51.458 --> 00:43:53.118
- accurate, and detailed data

00:43:53.282 --> 00:43:59.576
- for access, review, and analysis by your peers, members of the general public. There is a fundamental

00:43:59.576 --> 00:44:05.747
- distinction between bicycle-focused infrastructure serving a limited subset of travelers and public

00:44:05.747 --> 00:44:12.165
- transit serving residents across a broad range of ages, incomes, and physical abilities. Public transit

00:44:12.165 --> 00:44:16.670
- is also a significant traffic safety investment. Reliable public transit

00:44:16.930 --> 00:44:23.403
- can reduce automobile dependence, improve access to employment, and provide essential mobility to those

00:44:23.403 --> 00:44:29.937
- who cannot drive. Transportation investment should therefore be evaluated according to measurable public

00:44:29.937 --> 00:44:36.223
- benefits, actual usage, people served, accessibility, reductions in injuries and fatalities, service

00:44:36.223 --> 00:44:38.526
- reliability, and cost effectiveness.

00:44:38.722 --> 00:44:45.212
- Before committing additional discretionary funding to safe streets for all bicycle focused infrastructure

00:44:45.212 --> 00:44:51.580
- or traffic calming projects, the city should demonstrate that those benefits justify those expenditures

00:44:51.580 --> 00:44:58.009
- relative to investments in public transit. Bloomington's immediate priorities should include competitive

00:44:58.009 --> 00:45:04.560
- driver compensation for bus drivers, reliable operations, adequate service, frequent service, and expanded

00:45:04.560 --> 00:45:05.662
- transit coverage.

00:45:06.818 --> 00:45:12.601
- A safe transportation system is one that residents can actually use. I urge the city to maintain and

00:45:12.601 --> 00:45:18.613
- expand its financial support for Bloomington Transit and make accessible, reliable public transportation

00:45:18.613 --> 00:45:24.396
- a central priority of its transportation and public safety policies. Thank you. Thank you very much.

00:45:24.396 --> 00:45:30.179
- We'll come back in chambers. If you could sign in and state your name, that'd be lovely. You'll have

00:45:30.179 --> 00:45:31.038
- three minutes.

00:45:34.210 --> 00:45:43.094
- Seaforth Breeze, resident of Bloomington for 14-ish years. I wanted to speak today on the subject of

00:45:43.094 --> 00:45:52.418
- seminary point. I know this body is considered it in the past, and we're currently seeing, unfortunately,

00:45:52.418 --> 00:46:01.303
- the end result of a long process with its demolition beginning at this time. I wanted to bring it up

00:46:01.303 --> 00:46:03.326
- as a indication of how

00:46:03.778 --> 00:46:10.753
- You know, today, the UDO will be considered. Short-term rentals, I believe, are also going to be considered.

00:46:10.753 --> 00:46:17.792
- There's a lot of good work that the city council is putting into housing and affordability in this community,

00:46:17.792 --> 00:46:24.063
- which is to be commended. But I just wanted to bring it to the public's attention that, you know,

00:46:24.063 --> 00:46:30.718
- right now, we're seeing the loss of these 29 units that existed, these four commercial spaces that were

00:46:30.718 --> 00:46:32.382
- super affordable as well.

00:46:32.578 --> 00:46:40.387
- at price points that are simply, I mean, they just don't exist in Bloomington in numbers that they need

00:46:40.387 --> 00:46:48.047
- to, right? We see with the Bloomington Housing Authority that right now they're taking concrete steps

00:46:48.047 --> 00:46:55.856
- to try to expand their housing stock, which is good, but that is toward workforce sort of housing, that

00:46:55.856 --> 00:46:58.334
- price point, which is, you know,

00:46:59.074 --> 00:47:06.755
- it's not even in the same ballpark in comparison to the affordable, and then the affordable to the super

00:47:06.755 --> 00:47:14.217
- affordable is another gulf that just so many in our community cannot bridge. So I wanna encourage the

00:47:14.217 --> 00:47:21.825
- city council to continue taking the proactive steps that it's already doing, but also to look into ways

00:47:21.825 --> 00:47:28.190
- that permanent funding can be provided for super affordable housing in this community.

00:47:28.354 --> 00:47:35.101
- That also includes ensuring that it stays that way. It has to be affordable now, so we have to save

00:47:35.101 --> 00:47:41.847
- what it currently exists, and build stuff now when we can, but also has to be affordable forever. I

00:47:41.847 --> 00:47:48.594
- look at Hopewell as an example, and I worry that we will funnel a lot of public money into Hopewell

00:47:48.594 --> 00:47:55.610
- as a project, but if we don't have the right protections in place, it might be affordable for the first

00:47:55.610 --> 00:47:58.174
- people to get their foot in the door,

00:47:58.306 --> 00:48:03.959
- and then that just washes away, which uses up the funds that were set aside in the payments in lieu

00:48:03.959 --> 00:48:09.725
- and things like that. So thank you so much for your time. You all have put in so much work. I've seen

00:48:09.725 --> 00:48:15.716
- you at many of these meetings doing that, but I just, I want to bring it forward again and again, because

00:48:15.716 --> 00:48:21.426
- so many of my coworkers in the union at IU, they are, you know, they used to live in Bloomington and

00:48:21.426 --> 00:48:26.174
- they don't anymore. And, you know, we saw the census number come out with like the,

00:48:26.274 --> 00:48:36.213
- 70% of workers or something ridiculous like that do not live in Bloomington despite working in Bloomington.

00:48:36.213 --> 00:48:45.507
- Anyways, thank you for your time. Thank you. Others in chambers? If you could sign in and state your

00:48:45.507 --> 00:48:54.802
- name, you'll have three minutes. Good evening. Paul Rousseau. It's really nice to see a full council

00:48:54.802 --> 00:48:55.998
- for a while.

00:48:56.546 --> 00:49:05.775
- Two months? I don't know. 10 months ago, I was routinely walking to work for a mile through public sidewalks

00:49:05.775 --> 00:49:14.242
- where every single lot had been unshoveled even 10 weeks. 10 days, excuse me. I'll get it right. 10

00:49:14.242 --> 00:49:23.302
- days after the snowstorm. But I'm here to talk about something else, which is the plan to redesign College

00:49:23.302 --> 00:49:24.318
- and Walnut.

00:49:24.578 --> 00:49:31.277
- which I think is one of the most significant Bloomington public projects of this century. But from what

00:49:31.277 --> 00:49:37.718
- I've observed, the process for public engagement is weak at best and broken at worst. Last October,

00:49:37.718 --> 00:49:43.772
- public input was solicited by the city. I submitted lengthy comments directly to the Planning

00:49:43.772 --> 00:49:49.054
- and Transportation Department by email. But a review of that department's website

00:49:49.314 --> 00:49:54.856
- today appears to show that only comments constrained by the department's online survey questionnaire

00:49:54.856 --> 00:50:00.397
- have been included in the public record. Two days ago, the public had another nominal opportunity to

00:50:00.397 --> 00:50:06.378
- comment at a special hearing of the Transportation Commission. The only copy of the corridor study available

00:50:06.378 --> 00:50:12.194
- to the public was a draft version from eight months ago on the website of the Planning and Transportation

00:50:12.194 --> 00:50:17.022
- Department, while there were no documents about the study on the commission's web page.

00:50:18.690 --> 00:50:25.142
- I was not the only member of the public who felt insufficiently informed about the current details of

00:50:25.142 --> 00:50:31.530
- the project. Neither were the transportation commissioners satisfied as they voted to continue their

00:50:31.530 --> 00:50:37.981
- deliberations until December 7th. So if the commissioners have three more weeks to make more comments

00:50:37.981 --> 00:50:44.623
- at a separate public meeting, why will members of the public be denied further opportunity to also learn

00:50:44.623 --> 00:50:46.014
- more and participate?

00:50:47.106 --> 00:50:54.911
- Is such a prohibition on public participation even legal? What's happening to our public comments? Another

00:50:54.911 --> 00:51:02.570
- thing that I'm noticing is that I did not see any itemized responses to the comments that were submitted

00:51:02.570 --> 00:51:10.010
- under the constrained process that I mentioned before. So I feel like we're being ignored. But I hope

00:51:10.010 --> 00:51:17.086
- that's not the truth. Thanks. Thank you. Is there still somebody on Zoom with their hand raised?

00:51:17.634 --> 00:51:25.026
- Okay, great. Go right ahead. Zoom. Hello, my name is Alex Lani. I'm currently a PhD researcher at the

00:51:25.026 --> 00:51:32.274
- University of Plymouth in the UK, but I was born and raised in Bloomington for 22 years. And I just

00:51:32.274 --> 00:51:39.521
- kind of wanted to reflect on the previous regular meeting that discussed the ASI ordinance and push

00:51:39.521 --> 00:51:43.870
- maybe the committee and the council members to look towards

00:51:44.258 --> 00:51:50.095
- a different approach, maybe a more practical approach to artificial intelligence, which would be making

00:51:50.095 --> 00:51:55.875
- data centers more eco-friendly. And so I'll talk about these details soon. So just from my background,

00:51:55.875 --> 00:52:01.712
- I'm a pre-doctoral researcher at Moth Quantum, and I've done summer internship work at Argonne National

00:52:01.712 --> 00:52:07.325
- Laboratory for two years. So I have a lot of experience with LLMs and OpenAI. The first time I used

00:52:07.325 --> 00:52:11.646
- Chad GBT, I was one of the first two, three million users in December, 2022.

00:52:11.810 --> 00:52:17.129
- And so I just wanted to kind of give my perspective on it because I think there was some missing components

00:52:17.129 --> 00:52:22.252
- that maybe should be addressed that could help the ordinance. I don't want to sound like I'm completely

00:52:22.252 --> 00:52:27.275
- against it. I watched the whole five-hour meeting last time. You all do great work for the community.

00:52:27.275 --> 00:52:32.299
- I just want to put that out there. So following up on the ordinance, I wanted to talk a bit about the

00:52:32.299 --> 00:52:35.550
- difference between AGI and ASI. I kind of view them as overhyped.

00:52:35.650 --> 00:52:41.608
- both of them, but I think we should delineate between them, right? So we're banning ASI, but like AGI

00:52:41.608 --> 00:52:47.450
- comes before that and we're not even at AGI, right? So right now we're at like ANI, so it's kind of

00:52:47.450 --> 00:52:53.350
- narrowly worse than humans in a lot of ways, but we're not even at AGI, which is AI matching humans,

00:52:53.350 --> 00:52:56.446
- let alone ASI, which is AI exceeding humans. MIT put

00:52:56.610 --> 00:53:03.239
- Uh, an opinion piece about, you know, not being fooled by the summer of AI hype. I think this kind of

00:53:03.239 --> 00:53:09.933
- goes along with that. Yann LeCun is considered a godfather of AI. He's the winner of the Turing Award,

00:53:09.933 --> 00:53:16.561
- which is like the noble prize of computing. And he was in a video about why open AI and LLMs will not

00:53:16.561 --> 00:53:23.710
- lead to AGI, let alone ASI. Um, I thought that should be mentioned. Also, uh, Councilman last session posted.

00:53:24.002 --> 00:53:31.284
- slides talking about a paper that said, advanced AI according to 1,580 researchers, uncertain, unsaved,

00:53:31.284 --> 00:53:38.285
- and sooner than we thought. Now, I know that 1,580, that sounds like a big number, but if you go to

00:53:38.285 --> 00:53:45.287
- page four of that paper, you'll see in section 2.1, it says, we sent emails to 19,874 addresses and

00:53:45.287 --> 00:53:50.398
- received 2,052 complete or partial responses for a response rate of 10%.

00:53:50.658 --> 00:53:56.961
- That's about 90% of researchers who felt that this ASI paper wasn't worth their time. And I think that's

00:53:56.961 --> 00:54:03.204
- the most telling detail about us from people that know a lot about AI to say, hey, this is not the best

00:54:03.204 --> 00:54:09.206
- direction right now. So Bloomington, Illinois, they already have 70 news articles about redesigning

00:54:09.206 --> 00:54:15.209
- data centers. We have one at IU. I know that Monroe County has a ban on making them, but that could

00:54:15.209 --> 00:54:17.790
- change. I think we should be open to that.

00:54:18.114 --> 00:54:24.158
- So I just kind of wanted to pitch an idea of, you know, combining IU's Environmental Resilience Institute,

00:54:24.158 --> 00:54:29.751
- O'Neill, Dillman Wastewater Treatment Plant, Bloomington Environmental Commission, Duke Energy to,

00:54:29.751 --> 00:54:35.682
- you know, try to put more legislation into something more practical related to AI, which is eco-friendly

00:54:35.682 --> 00:54:41.501
- data centers. Thank you very much. I'm sorry. That is your time. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone

00:54:41.501 --> 00:54:44.382
- else in chambers who would like to make a comment?

00:54:47.778 --> 00:55:00.764
- Okay. Anyone else on Zoom? Anyone else on Zoom? Thank you. Okay. In that case, we can move on to Section

00:55:00.764 --> 00:55:11.525
- 5, Appointments to Boards and Commissions. Are there any motions? I can make a motion.

00:55:11.525 --> 00:55:17.214
- I'm sorry. Councilmember Flaherty. Thank you.

00:55:17.378 --> 00:55:22.925
- On behalf of Interview Committee B, I'd like to make a few recommendations. I'm just pulling up the

00:55:22.925 --> 00:55:28.528
- page. Sorry, I was on the wrong PDF. So to three different commissions, I'll name them all. If folks

00:55:28.528 --> 00:55:34.130
- want to divide the question or ask questions about them, you're of course welcome to. But again, the

00:55:34.130 --> 00:55:39.678
- committee's recommendations are as follows. For the Utility Service Board, to appoint Patrick Dirks

00:55:39.678 --> 00:55:45.502
- to seat C3. For the Community Advisory and Public Safety Commission, to appoint Amanda Stone to seat C1.

00:55:45.666 --> 00:55:53.737
- Catherine Vasinth to seat C4 and Maya Lukey to seat C7. And for the Environmental Commission, two point

00:55:53.737 --> 00:56:01.575
- Ashish Nambiar to seat C2 and Nathaniel Hand to seat C4. Okay, there has been a motion and a second.

00:56:01.575 --> 00:56:09.491
- Would anyone like to make a comment or ask a question? Council Member Stosberg. Thank you. So we just

00:56:09.491 --> 00:56:14.846
- went through a whole thing about that in some ways boils down to how

00:56:14.978 --> 00:56:23.024
- difficult it might be to ever remove anybody from any of these seats. And so I feel often that we just

00:56:23.024 --> 00:56:31.070
- sort of take the recommendations from the interview team and don't ask any further questions about any

00:56:31.070 --> 00:56:36.382
- of these folks. And I think that it's a really tricky kind of weird

00:56:36.770 --> 00:56:44.022
- piece, because then if we do ask questions, then we're discussing in public. And that just seems weird,

00:56:44.022 --> 00:56:50.994
- too. So I guess I just, you know, anybody from interview team B can can answer this, like, were all

00:56:50.994 --> 00:56:58.525
- of these people interviewed? And, like, were there options in terms of a candidate? Like, were you deciding

00:56:58.525 --> 00:57:04.382
- between candidates and thought that these were like the best candidates in terms of

00:57:04.610 --> 00:57:12.463
- what they added to the board, or were these the only candidates? If anybody could speak to that, it

00:57:12.463 --> 00:57:20.474
- would be great. Councilmember Daley. I'll answer for my part. We did divide up interviews rather than

00:57:20.474 --> 00:57:28.563
- trying to align everybody's schedules. I was responsible for the advisory on Public Safety Commission,

00:57:28.563 --> 00:57:31.390
- community advisory for public caps.

00:57:32.002 --> 00:57:39.695
- Thank you. We had three applicants for four seats, but I did 20 plus phone minute interviews with each

00:57:39.695 --> 00:57:47.387
- of them. And each of these three were extraordinarily qualified. They all had backgrounds that blended

00:57:47.387 --> 00:57:54.931
- nicely into some form of public safety or public care. They gave incredibly thoughtful and committed

00:57:54.931 --> 00:57:57.022
- answers, and they were very

00:57:57.346 --> 00:58:03.879
- excited and eager to be joining. And so I do think that they would have stood out in a crowd anyway.

00:58:03.879 --> 00:58:10.477
- I felt very lucky that we had those applicants and I'm grateful that they applied. Anyone else? Yeah,

00:58:10.477 --> 00:58:17.270
- I could follow up. As Councilmember Daly noted, we were in the interest of time and getting appointments

00:58:17.270 --> 00:58:24.191
- filled, subdividing the tasks to call the best applicants were possible. I had the utility service boards.

00:58:24.191 --> 00:58:27.102
- This was designated by which liaison we were

00:58:27.202 --> 00:58:34.595
- for which commissions we are a liaison. And I guess not the staff liaison, you don't know what I'm talking

00:58:34.595 --> 00:58:41.573
- about, the council lead, yes. So I did talk to Director Zeiger, who's in back of the room, about the

00:58:41.573 --> 00:58:48.551
- applicants. We did have one additional applicant since my conversation with the director. I did call

00:58:48.551 --> 00:58:55.806
- all the applicants. I was only able to speak to two of them. They all seemed like good candidates to me.

00:58:56.002 --> 00:59:02.021
- When it comes to something like screening and trying to keep an eye out for unforeseen circumstances,

00:59:02.021 --> 00:59:08.217
- I think that's probably very difficult to manage, especially with the capacities we have on the council,

00:59:08.217 --> 00:59:14.177
- both as individuals and with our staff, even the clerk's office for that matter. But I think we lean

00:59:14.177 --> 00:59:20.550
- towards the recommendation based on the skills that Mr. Dirk Springs, he's a former city employee actually,

00:59:20.550 --> 00:59:23.678
- an engineer. I worked in the engineering department.

00:59:23.810 --> 00:59:29.134
- and now works in a consulting capacity. And on the Environmental Commission, that was a little bit different.

00:59:29.134 --> 00:59:34.215
- We didn't have our full committee together, but we know the Environmental Commission has been frustrated

00:59:34.215 --> 00:59:39.491
- by kind of the duration of some of the vacancies, understandably, and we were trying to err in the direction

00:59:39.491 --> 00:59:44.330
- of getting those seats filled, especially since they'd been reduced. We had, I would say, four good

00:59:44.330 --> 00:59:49.267
- candidates for two seats on the Environmental Commission. We also try to keep in mind, you know, when

00:59:49.267 --> 00:59:52.606
- there are mayoral appointments or vacancies that might be coming up,

00:59:52.706 --> 00:59:58.940
- there can be opportunities there even when there aren't on the council side. I did speak to a long-serving

00:59:58.940 --> 01:00:04.942
- commissioner about kind of the makeup of the commission right now, what the skill sets are, what would

01:00:04.942 --> 01:00:11.001
- be most helpful to them relative to balancing what's there already or maybe what they've lost recently.

01:00:11.001 --> 01:00:16.478
- And so that was a framework that informed the recommendation we made with the two applicants.

01:00:17.474 --> 01:00:24.304
- Multiple of the applicants we were familiar with through city government in one way or another or community

01:00:24.304 --> 01:00:30.944
- involvement, but we didn't actually conduct phone interviews in the case of the environmental commission

01:00:30.944 --> 01:00:37.394
- specifically. Great. Thank you. I appreciate that additional information about these recommendations.

01:00:37.394 --> 01:00:41.758
- OK, great. Any other questions? Will the clerk please call the roll?

01:00:48.034 --> 01:01:00.824
- member clarity. Yes. Sasberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Sorry. Yes. Daily. Yes. You should

01:01:00.824 --> 01:01:13.489
- offer out. Rallo. Yes. Rough. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. That passes. Are

01:01:13.489 --> 01:01:17.214
- there any other appointments?

01:01:18.434 --> 01:01:28.969
- No. Okay. Then we will move on to legislation for first readings. I move that ordinance 2026-38 be introduced

01:01:28.969 --> 01:01:38.738
- and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. Second. Any discussion? Okay. Will the clerk please

01:01:38.738 --> 01:01:47.358
- call the roll? Council member Stasberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes.

01:01:48.034 --> 01:01:58.251
- Daily? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Thank you. That passes. Will the

01:01:58.251 --> 01:02:02.398
- clerk please read by title and synopsis?

01:02:12.098 --> 01:02:19.093
- Ordinance 2026-38, amending Title 16 of the Bloomington Municipal Code to update the Residential Rental

01:02:19.093 --> 01:02:26.356
- Unit and Lodging Establishment Inspection Program and add a new section on short-term rentals. The synopsis

01:02:26.356 --> 01:02:33.149
- is as follows. This ordinance amending Title 16 includes the following substantive changes. One, the

01:02:33.149 --> 01:02:37.790
- addition of Chapter 16.06 short-term rentals per Indiana Code 36124.

01:02:37.890 --> 01:02:44.645
- Two, an update to the fee schedule in section 16.03.07 fees. Three, inclusion of a vacancy

01:02:44.645 --> 01:02:52.513
- fee for single-family detached homes. Four, removal of sections and references in accordance with Indiana

01:02:52.513 --> 01:03:00.010
- Code 32-31-120. And five, grammatical quality of life and spelling corrections. There are no changes

01:03:00.010 --> 01:03:03.870
- in hands inspections or in the evaluation criteria.

01:03:03.970 --> 01:03:13.824
- The recommended implementation date is July 1, 2027. Your council member's sponsor is Rallo. Thank you

01:03:13.824 --> 01:03:24.060
- very much. I move to discuss ordinance 2026-38. Second. OK. There's been a motion and a second to discuss.

01:03:24.060 --> 01:03:32.574
- Any questions or comments? OK. Will the clerk please call the roll? Piedmont Smith? Yes.

01:03:33.698 --> 01:03:44.154
- Zulek. Yes. Asari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stasberg.

01:03:44.154 --> 01:03:54.714
- Yes. Thank you. Thank you. That passes. Is there anyone here to present? Go right ahead. Please state

01:03:54.714 --> 01:03:57.406
- your name for the record.

01:04:04.930 --> 01:04:12.021
- Good evening council members my name is Taylor Brown I am the assistant city attorney for the housing

01:04:12.021 --> 01:04:19.113
- and neighborhood development code enforcement portion of the code and for the record Kenny I might be

01:04:19.113 --> 01:04:20.990
- biased but I like hand so.

01:04:34.210 --> 01:04:39.390
- This is where you insert the spinning wheel as it's buffering. The buffering, yeah.

01:05:11.266 --> 01:05:18.993
- Appreciate it. All right. So this is the summary of changes. I want to first thank you for your time

01:05:18.993 --> 01:05:26.643
- and attention during the presentation. A special thanks to Council Member Rallo for sponsoring this

01:05:26.643 --> 01:05:34.369
- legislation and to the members of the BHQA for their feedback, which was invaluable as well as their

01:05:34.369 --> 01:05:36.894
- endorsement to this legislation.

01:05:37.698 --> 01:05:43.434
- I will go through a quick summary of changes, is the addition of a chapter requiring the registration

01:05:43.434 --> 01:05:49.113
- of short-term rentals, updating the fee schedule, and inclusion of the vacancy fee for single-family

01:05:49.113 --> 01:05:55.186
- detached homes, removal of certain sections and references under state code, as well as various grammatical

01:05:55.186 --> 01:06:01.091
- readability and spelling corrections. By readability, I mean things like adding in a particular citation

01:06:01.091 --> 01:06:06.714
- for all of the definitions, that way you know exactly which definition. It was a personal pet peeve

01:06:06.714 --> 01:06:07.614
- of mine which I

01:06:07.714 --> 01:06:13.811
- was happy to correct in this legislation. I will go through, because there is a lot, I will go through

01:06:13.811 --> 01:06:19.790
- each of the sections and I will pause after each section for questions and then pause at the end for

01:06:19.790 --> 01:06:25.947
- overarching questions to try to make a little bit of organization. But of course, council members, feel

01:06:25.947 --> 01:06:31.867
- free to interrupt me at any time. So beginning with short-term rentals. So the legislature provided

01:06:31.867 --> 01:06:35.774
- for a program, quick note, the page numbers up top in the titles,

01:06:35.906 --> 01:06:43.537
- reference the specific page in the red line that the legislation is discussing in case you want to follow

01:06:43.537 --> 01:06:50.808
- along or have any questions there. So the legislature provided a program for municipalities to adopt

01:06:50.808 --> 01:06:58.511
- the registration of short-term rentals in 36-1-24. And so the first thing that they input was a definition

01:06:58.511 --> 01:07:03.838
- of short-term rentals. It is defined as a dwelling unit, defined in code.

01:07:03.970 --> 01:07:11.357
- rented for less than 30-day terms through a short-term rental platform. Now a short-term rental platform

01:07:11.357 --> 01:07:18.603
- is also defined basically as a website through unaffiliated third parties can put their dwelling units

01:07:18.603 --> 01:07:19.518
- up for rent.

01:07:19.778 --> 01:07:26.806
- For instance, if you are ABC Rentals, rental company in the city, and you have a website that puts all

01:07:26.806 --> 01:07:33.628
- of your rentals online, that would not qualify as a short-term rental because it is through you are

01:07:33.628 --> 01:07:40.451
- the affiliated party, if that makes sense. For the process, you will register with hand providing a

01:07:40.451 --> 01:07:42.430
- specific set of information.

01:07:42.690 --> 01:07:49.701
- That's outlined in code. It's basic contact information, things like that. There is a one-time $150

01:07:49.701 --> 01:07:56.783
- fee per dwelling unit. Bless you. And again, that is one time. There is no fee to renew. All that is

01:07:56.783 --> 01:08:04.005
- required, and this is again under state law, all that is required is a notice to hand that they intend

01:08:04.005 --> 01:08:11.227
- to renew for the following year so we can keep our list accurate. And then they are good to go for the

01:08:11.227 --> 01:08:11.998
- next year.

01:08:12.418 --> 01:08:19.156
- Again, by state law, it must be issued within 30 days, the permit for the short-term rental,

01:08:19.156 --> 01:08:26.402
- and then it is, again, good for one-year terms. Restrictions, enforcement, and appeals. So if there

01:08:26.402 --> 01:08:33.792
- are three or more ordinance violations in a calendar year, and that is specifically in this instance,

01:08:33.792 --> 01:08:41.182
- trash, noise, excessive growth, Title VI things, the permit can be revoked for no more than one year.

01:08:41.346 --> 01:08:46.841
- Appeals will go through the BHQA, although the ordinance violations themselves will still go through

01:08:46.841 --> 01:08:52.446
- the Board of Public Works. So hearing appeals for noise violations, abatements, things like that, will

01:08:52.446 --> 01:08:58.322
- still go through the Board of Public Works, but then to go and say, hey, I took care of all of my ordinance

01:08:58.322 --> 01:09:04.144
- violations, please reinstate my short-term rental permit, that will be heard at the BHQA. It also provides

01:09:04.144 --> 01:09:09.803
- for certain restricted uses under state law, such as you can't sell alcohol out of a short-term rental,

01:09:09.803 --> 01:09:10.782
- things like that.

01:09:13.314 --> 01:09:20.149
- And that's it. As far as title 16 goes I think it's pretty straightforward but I also have been reading

01:09:20.149 --> 01:09:27.115
- this day in and day out and so I'm seeing it whenever time I close my eyes. So I will pause for questions

01:09:27.115 --> 01:09:33.687
- here. Okay. Councilmember Ruff thank you for your presentation by the way. How does this compare or

01:09:33.687 --> 01:09:40.325
- do you know how this compares to other communities in Indiana in Indiana that we've heard about that

01:09:40.325 --> 01:09:42.494
- have done taken steps to try and

01:09:43.106 --> 01:09:49.379
- permit or regulate short-term rentals like we hear West Lafayette did this and that. Can you compare

01:09:49.379 --> 01:09:55.837
- this? Of course. The legislation that the state passed specifically grandfathered in certain short-term

01:09:55.837 --> 01:10:02.110
- rental programs that already existed, I believe this was back in 21 or so. They grandfathered in the

01:10:02.110 --> 01:10:08.507
- ones that already existed and then provided a very rigid set of here's how municipalities can regulate

01:10:08.507 --> 01:10:11.550
- going forward. Again, this is just registration,

01:10:11.810 --> 01:10:18.513
- regulation or zoning or anything like that. Does that answer your question. So were there communities

01:10:18.513 --> 01:10:25.677
- that had something in place that was stricter than what the state now allows. I can't speak to any specifics

01:10:25.677 --> 01:10:30.014
- but yes there were a couple that had specific areas that said no.

01:10:30.178 --> 01:10:38.201
- short-term rentals in these particular areas. The state legislature did provide a way to do that, but

01:10:38.201 --> 01:10:46.145
- laid out much more specific requirements. I'm not sure how that previous legislation would have been

01:10:46.145 --> 01:10:54.011
- debated or passed, but the legislature then made it more specific and more criteria to be laid out.

01:10:54.011 --> 01:10:58.494
- Is that clear? Yes, no. Can I ask a clarifying question?

01:10:59.522 --> 01:11:06.435
- You said in some communities have like specific areas where they might have set aside. No. So could

01:11:06.435 --> 01:11:13.901
- covenants and restrictions privately agreed upon covenants restrictions in a certain project or development

01:11:13.901 --> 01:11:21.436
- or subdivision prevent just ex-proc prevent prohibit short-term rentals under state law. Excellent question.

01:11:21.436 --> 01:11:24.478
- There is actually a specific place in state

01:11:24.834 --> 01:11:33.843
- law in that section that says this will not interfere with those private organizations such as HOAs

01:11:33.843 --> 01:11:43.122
- and things. Okay. Thank you. You may have already answered a couple of my clarification questions, but

01:11:43.122 --> 01:11:47.806
- I just want to really make sure. So in terms of the

01:11:48.098 --> 01:11:58.179
- It has to be through a short-term rental platform. That's state law. So somebody could, in theory, have

01:11:58.179 --> 01:12:08.066
- a short-term rental that they don't have to go through this registration process with because they're

01:12:08.066 --> 01:12:17.662
- not advertising it on a third-party website. Theoretically, yes. However, the third-party platform

01:12:18.786 --> 01:12:26.235
- pretty broad. So I think you'd be have you'd be stretching to find something that didn't apply if that

01:12:26.235 --> 01:12:33.539
- makes sense for the most part. Yes. Well if you like hosted your own Web site or something like that

01:12:33.539 --> 01:12:37.950
- if you hosted your own Web site then you're running a rental

01:12:38.946 --> 01:12:46.011
- I'm happy to get back to you on that in writing if I dig into it a little bit. I just wanted to clarify

01:12:46.011 --> 01:12:52.872
- in terms of state law. In terms of state law, yes. Why does it have to be through a rental platform?

01:12:52.872 --> 01:12:59.732
- And it's because of state law. Yes, that was lifted straight from that. And then the no renewal fee?

01:12:59.732 --> 01:13:05.982
- Yes. That's also a state law? That is state law, yes. OK. And then the other, I guess, real

01:13:06.178 --> 01:13:14.103
- Question is so are these short-term rentals going to be inspected by hand? Is this adding to their inspection

01:13:14.103 --> 01:13:21.956
- state legislation? Specifically states that they cannot there cannot be a requirement to have them inspected

01:13:21.956 --> 01:13:25.630
- however hand after I discussed it with them we are

01:13:26.274 --> 01:13:32.803
- providing an opportunity for them to be inspected at a discounted rate. So that way, if they want to

01:13:32.803 --> 01:13:39.590
- say on whatever rental platform they're advertising, we had the hand inspectors come in and they certify

01:13:39.590 --> 01:13:46.119
- that this meets the same standards that normal rental properties do, things like that. So we have it

01:13:46.119 --> 01:13:53.036
- as an option for short-term rental owners, but we cannot acquire it. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions?

01:13:53.036 --> 01:13:54.846
- Council Member Rosenberger.

01:13:55.458 --> 01:14:03.702
- Are these full-time rentals or any owner-occupied renting out their home for one weekend? The short-term

01:14:03.702 --> 01:14:11.947
- rental definition means any rental of a single-family home, a dwelling unit within a single-family home,

01:14:11.947 --> 01:14:19.877
- so a room, things like that, a dwelling unit in a two-family or multi-family dwelling, or a dwelling

01:14:19.877 --> 01:14:24.510
- unit in a condominium cooperative or timeshare, and that's

01:14:24.866 --> 01:14:32.754
- Pulled from again state law there is a carve out under title 16 for I think if there is owner occupied

01:14:32.754 --> 01:14:40.566
- they rent to one tenant and They share bathroom facilities and living quarters I think and that is an

01:14:40.566 --> 01:14:48.224
- exemption for title 16 in general and I think that particular carve out is there So it would really

01:14:48.224 --> 01:14:53.662
- depend on the exact Facts of somebody renting out a room in their home

01:14:54.882 --> 01:15:01.416
- I'm sorry to be the lawyer and say it depends, but it depends. Sorry, what was that joke about? Sorry,

01:15:01.416 --> 01:15:07.823
- what was that? What did you just say? I'm sorry. Oh, at the end, I'm sorry to be a lawyer and say it

01:15:07.823 --> 01:15:14.484
- depends, but it depends. Oh, gotcha. OK. What about, I don't know what we call it anymore, but a rooming

01:15:14.484 --> 01:15:20.955
- house, a board? You know, we have a short term option that allows one owner in like four bedrooms. So

01:15:20.955 --> 01:15:24.254
- that would be considered then here as a short term.

01:15:26.594 --> 01:15:32.929
- I'm not quite sure what you're referencing, if you'd like to. We have, I don't know what the definition,

01:15:32.929 --> 01:15:39.143
- do you guys know that? Are you referring to the single room occupancy? No, we have, it's not a rooming

01:15:39.143 --> 01:15:45.176
- house. It's something kind of similar though, where like the owner can live in it and rent out like

01:15:45.176 --> 01:15:51.330
- up to four bedrooms. That is the SRO? Oh, the owner has to live in it. We switched it. Okay, yeah. So

01:15:51.330 --> 01:15:53.502
- an SRO would be under this program?

01:15:55.074 --> 01:16:01.261
- I can double check and make sure that that is where that falls specifically and let you know. I think

01:16:01.261 --> 01:16:07.449
- it's just good to make sure there's only one requirement, I guess, like for an SR to follow, and it's

01:16:07.449 --> 01:16:13.818
- not complicated. Happy to follow up. I think it would be helpful if everyone who has follow-up questions

01:16:13.818 --> 01:16:19.884
- could submit them in writing as well, just so Mr. Brown can keep track of them. Are there any other

01:16:19.884 --> 01:16:24.798
- questions on this part? Councilmember Rallo. Oh, Councilmember Rallo. Thank you.

01:16:24.962 --> 01:16:34.288
- Thank you, Mr. Brown. I appreciate your work on this, as well as Director Killian Hanson and the BHQA.

01:16:34.288 --> 01:16:43.432
- I just have a couple of questions related to potential next steps. I realize that we're hamstrung by

01:16:43.432 --> 01:16:52.668
- the state to a large extent. Is there any possibility for putting an absolute number, restricting the

01:16:52.668 --> 01:16:54.750
- number in Bloomington?

01:16:55.426 --> 01:17:04.864
- of short-term rentals? That is a very good and very complicated question, council member. That is one

01:17:04.864 --> 01:17:14.488
- I will absolutely have to get back to you in writing on. There is a plethora of litigation, legislation

01:17:14.488 --> 01:17:24.574
- around short-term rentals. It's a very hot button topic as you well know. I'm happy to research and see what

01:17:24.834 --> 01:17:33.128
- the next steps could be and get back to you on that. I appreciate that. I appreciate your work on this

01:17:33.128 --> 01:17:41.341
- and but I think that we need to explore options because if we have potentially 800 short term rentals

01:17:41.341 --> 01:17:49.877
- and my understanding is the 44 percent occupancy rate and 80 percent of those rentals are not used except

01:17:49.877 --> 01:17:51.326
- on peak weekends.

01:17:52.930 --> 01:18:03.075
- That's a significant impact on potential housing that could be obviously occupied by full-time residents

01:18:03.075 --> 01:18:12.737
- of Bloomington and must account for significant effect on housing and rental rates and so forth. So

01:18:12.737 --> 01:18:22.206
- there is a potential for zoning as well. Is that correct? That's something that could be explored

01:18:23.522 --> 01:18:34.514
- And then since these are occupied primarily on peak weekends, it seems that this is one potential way

01:18:34.514 --> 01:18:45.291
- to address this would be a market approach whereby hotels would become competitive. In other words,

01:18:45.291 --> 01:18:53.374
- when you were looking at this, is part of the problem lack of hotel rooms?

01:18:53.762 --> 01:19:02.216
- During peak weekends I would say that's probably more of a policy question and I would defer to hand

01:19:02.216 --> 01:19:10.837
- on answering that. I can say like the data you just read off I can say that that has been provided and

01:19:10.837 --> 01:19:19.291
- that gives us a way forward. Again I think to first start would be let's see what we're dealing with

01:19:19.291 --> 01:19:22.974
- first and then we can move forward based on

01:19:23.074 --> 01:19:28.544
- the data that we gather the short term rentals that register things like that. Yeah. Yeah that's a great

01:19:28.544 --> 01:19:33.753
- idea. All right. Thank you for your for your work. I really appreciate it. Thank you sir. Are there

01:19:33.753 --> 01:19:36.670
- other questions at this time. Council member Stahlberg.

01:19:37.890 --> 01:19:43.671
- Sorry, I got reminded by, I think, a Wisconsin member, Rosemarger's question. Would the owner occupied

01:19:43.671 --> 01:19:49.284
- short-term rentals? And maybe you can answer this now, or maybe we need to follow up with it later.

01:19:49.284 --> 01:19:55.178
- But it's specifically defined as a term, but then as I was reading through the actual short-term rentals

01:19:55.178 --> 01:20:00.510
- chapter, I was like, I can't tell. It's defined as a term, but I can't tell what it's actually

01:20:00.610 --> 01:20:07.401
- like defined as a term for, because I didn't see it anywhere else. So is it exempted from things? Is

01:20:07.401 --> 01:20:14.192
- it not exempted from things? Is it just like, so I was just kind of like, we defined it, but then we

01:20:14.192 --> 01:20:20.984
- didn't specifically use it anywhere. And so I don't know if I missed where we used it or what, but I

01:20:20.984 --> 01:20:26.430
- would love some clarity on that in general. Would you like me to follow that up?

01:20:26.658 --> 01:20:35.001
- Yes, that would be great. I'll follow up with that right. Thanks. Thank you I'm not sure if this is

01:20:35.001 --> 01:20:44.095
- appropriate question for short-term rentals, but it was brought up By my colleague councilmember Rosenbarger

01:20:44.095 --> 01:20:53.022
- or maybe this isn't even what she meant but the difference between rooming house and single-room occupancy

01:20:54.338 --> 01:21:02.422
- Makes me think that we need to make sure our terminology between Title 20 and Title 16 is compatible,

01:21:02.422 --> 01:21:10.665
- because we do not have rooming house as a defined term in our UDO anymore. So we should use single room

01:21:10.665 --> 01:21:18.590
- occupancy in this case. We can use both, but we definitely need to reference single room occupancy.

01:21:18.690 --> 01:21:26.423
- Yes, and I believe that was in your email list of questions. I did read and start annotating them, but

01:21:26.423 --> 01:21:34.080
- I haven't responded yet. So yes, I did see that. OK, thank you. OK, any other questions on this part?

01:21:34.080 --> 01:21:42.263
- OK. If everyone could submit their questions in writing to Mr. Brown by noon on Tuesday, just as a reminder,

01:21:42.263 --> 01:21:47.518
- next week is Thanksgiving, and I want to give Mr. Brown ample time to

01:21:47.650 --> 01:21:56.450
- answer the questions in a way that they're in the packet so that the public can also read and prepare

01:21:56.450 --> 01:22:05.423
- for our December 2nd meeting. Take it away, Mr. Brown. Thank you very much. I appreciate the lead time.

01:22:05.423 --> 01:22:13.361
- Next up, we have vacancy fees and fee schedules, the update to the fee schedule. Again, the

01:22:13.361 --> 01:22:17.502
- state legislature, they provided a long list of

01:22:17.602 --> 01:22:28.179
- issues with Vacant homes specifically. It's 36-7-9-4.5 for those of you playing along at home And in

01:22:28.179 --> 01:22:39.175
- recognition of those that extra burden this includes a $500 vacancy fee for single-family detached homes

01:22:39.175 --> 01:22:47.134
- that are vacant for longer than one year again, that will be homes that are

01:22:47.522 --> 01:22:54.058
- for one full calendar year vacant. Now, and this is where, again, the BHQA was invaluable. One of the

01:22:54.058 --> 01:23:00.658
- members pointed out in the event that a housing market cools and someone is desperately trying to sell

01:23:00.658 --> 01:23:07.451
- it and they just can't, the last thing we want to do is include an additional financial burden on someone

01:23:07.451 --> 01:23:10.142
- who is already struggling to sell a home.

01:23:10.242 --> 01:23:19.150
- Which is why any appeals will be taken by to the BHQ a Where they will be able to evaluate the good

01:23:19.150 --> 01:23:28.146
- faith efforts to sell provide extensions to? for the fee things like that And then the update to the

01:23:28.146 --> 01:23:37.054
- fee schedule So the current fee is in that first column the second column is the new fee in general

01:23:37.954 --> 01:23:45.762
- I rounded the fees to the nearest $5 increment just for ease of calculation. Um, the single family detached

01:23:45.762 --> 01:23:53.208
- home fee did not change, uh, and neither did the condominium inspection fee. Um, however, there is one

01:23:53.208 --> 01:24:00.726
- significant change, which is the, uh, second, second and subsequent re-inspection fee, um, for a while.

01:24:00.726 --> 01:24:06.654
- And again, I am doing code enforcement for the city. There have been certain, uh,

01:24:07.010 --> 01:24:16.071
- shall we say, bad actors that have merely included this as a cost of business rather than an opportunity

01:24:16.071 --> 01:24:25.564
- to actually make repairs on their properties. And so they would rather pay the extra two or three inspections

01:24:25.564 --> 01:24:29.534
- that are $77 each rather than make the $1,000

01:24:29.922 --> 01:24:37.270
- repair of a water heater, what have you. So in recognition of that and the extra time that staff takes

01:24:37.270 --> 01:24:44.404
- to do second inspections and things like that, we have raised that fee to $150. Now to clarify what

01:24:44.404 --> 01:24:51.894
- is a second and subsequent re-inspection, so HAND will go out first, do an inspection, they will provide

01:24:51.894 --> 01:24:58.814
- a list of all of the things that they have found that are violations of Title 16, things to fix.

01:24:58.914 --> 01:25:06.101
- They, in general, have 14 days to fix life safety issues and then 60 days to fix everything else. They

01:25:06.101 --> 01:25:13.358
- will come back and make sure that they have fixed everything. That is not the second reinspection, that

01:25:13.358 --> 01:25:20.616
- is the first reinspection. So if they have failed to make the repairs that HAND has asked them to make,

01:25:20.616 --> 01:25:27.454
- the next inspection will be $150 moving forward. Questions on fee schedules and the vacancy fees?

01:25:29.922 --> 01:25:45.960
- Thank you. I have a few questions in this category. Yes. So I guess the first one in terms of the vacancy

01:25:45.960 --> 01:25:55.038
- fee is I am not a tax expert but I have heard over the last

01:25:55.490 --> 01:26:05.517
- few years of sitting in this seat that there are different management companies that specifically would

01:26:05.517 --> 01:26:15.254
- prefer to leave properties vacant in order to get tax break related stuff for income loss as opposed

01:26:15.254 --> 01:26:24.702
- to rent them. So do you know anything in terms of that $500 fee for vacancy like is that going to

01:26:25.442 --> 01:26:32.868
- offset enough in terms of any sort of tax break that somebody might get from or tax loss that somebody

01:26:32.868 --> 01:26:40.150
- might get from deliberately leaving a property vacant? I see you writing something down, so I assume

01:26:40.150 --> 01:26:47.648
- you're going to have to look that up. On my best day in law school, tax law always evaded me. So I will

01:26:47.648 --> 01:26:51.902
- absolutely be looking that up, and I will get back to you.

01:26:52.130 --> 01:27:00.838
- Thank you. That would be great. I have more questions, too, but I saw another hand down there. So do

01:27:00.838 --> 01:27:09.804
- you want me to go on? Councilmember Rosenberger. Hi, yes, thank you. Did you consider vacancy of, well,

01:27:09.804 --> 01:27:18.684
- vacant lots as well as vacant homes? No, that would be outside the scope of this particular title. OK,

01:27:18.684 --> 01:27:22.046
- all right, because I think vacant lots

01:27:22.146 --> 01:27:28.042
- are the most egregious here. And then the second most egregious are vacant homes. One example is that

01:27:28.042 --> 01:27:33.938
- someone in near West Side tore down a house because they didn't want to look at it. And they just own

01:27:33.938 --> 01:27:40.007
- that vacant lot. And I think if we're in the city, we should be building homes on our lot. So what title

01:27:40.007 --> 01:27:45.961
- is that? It doesn't matter. And then with these fees, are they just? I'm sorry that I missed this. I'm

01:27:45.961 --> 01:27:50.238
- just going to be honest. My brain is mush because there's a lot going on.

01:27:50.626 --> 01:27:56.595
- Are we just getting up to this 125 amount like for inflation purposes because we've been at 105 for

01:27:56.595 --> 01:28:02.565
- a long time. Correct. So this was last updated in 2012. The last the fee schedule has been the same

01:28:02.565 --> 01:28:08.892
- since 2015 with one 10 percent increase in 2019. So that so as far as like the increases in twenty twenty

01:28:08.892 --> 01:28:15.101
- eight and twenty twenty nine I followed the exact same pattern that the previous fee schedule did which

01:28:15.101 --> 01:28:19.518
- was a ten dollar increase for single family detached homes and et cetera.

01:28:19.778 --> 01:28:26.659
- With the exception of the second and subsequent fee, which I increased to yes. Okay. And then I mean,

01:28:26.659 --> 01:28:33.539
- we don't see past 2029. Are we mostly sticking to the 125 at that point for a while? You think? Yeah.

01:28:33.539 --> 01:28:40.353
- So again, just like in the previous, the previous time this was made, uh, after 2020. So 2020, 2030,

01:28:40.353 --> 01:28:47.166
- sorry. Yikes. Uh, 2030, um, January one, any increase, uh, will be the board of public works by 10%.

01:28:47.362 --> 01:28:55.830
- Unless a larger one is required then that would of course come to council. Okay, and last question on

01:28:55.830 --> 01:29:04.297
- the fees condos versus multifamily dwellings, so it is Does that mean it's a hundred and five dollars

01:29:04.297 --> 01:29:12.350
- for one condo? unit I Believe so. Yes, but then each building for multifamily is $77 it would be

01:29:12.994 --> 01:29:19.758
- 80 for the new fee and I believe that is so 80 for the building and then each unit in that building

01:29:19.758 --> 01:29:26.792
- is 30 So if you look at the two the line right underneath, so it'd be 80 flat and then add 30 I'm gonna

01:29:26.792 --> 01:29:33.150
- look at I'm getting the nod from director Kelly. So yes. Okay. Thank you Councilmember, sorry

01:29:34.210 --> 01:29:40.760
- Thank you so much. A couple of questions that may be built off of both Councilmember Stosberg's and

01:29:40.760 --> 01:29:47.440
- Councilmember Rosenberger's questions around the fees specifically. And first, just to make sure that

01:29:47.440 --> 01:29:54.382
- I'm understanding correctly, the short term rental permit is capped at 150 by state law. Is that correct?

01:29:54.382 --> 01:30:00.670
- That is correct. Yes. And is that a one time fee or is it recurring every time that they renew?

01:30:00.962 --> 01:30:08.311
- Uh, that is a one-time fee there. Again, by state law, there cannot be a renewal fee. Okay. But then

01:30:08.311 --> 01:30:15.879
- the other fees, so the regular rental inspections, um, the repeat inspections and the vacant properties

01:30:15.879 --> 01:30:23.155
- that we're putting on here, um, those are not capped by state law. We get to set those, right? They

01:30:23.155 --> 01:30:28.030
- are capped, but it is a general ordinance violation cap at $2,500.

01:30:28.546 --> 01:30:37.994
- Okay, okay, that is just for your records state law 36-1-6 Fantastic the but then the inspection fees

01:30:37.994 --> 01:30:47.256
- Are we are recovering and think this is relevant to the public comment we received earlier? But are

01:30:47.256 --> 01:30:52.350
- we recovering the actual cost of inspections I mean or

01:30:52.674 --> 01:31:00.017
- Mean, or is there a different sort of is this cost recovery or is it is it a different sort of theory

01:31:00.017 --> 01:31:07.288
- of change? Yeah, I would defer to Hand to answer that particular question. I believe it is just cost

01:31:07.288 --> 01:31:14.775
- recovery if you want to Hi director Killian Hansen The state does not allow us to recoup our full costs

01:31:14.775 --> 01:31:20.030
- of inspections so at one point they did try to take away the program and

01:31:20.130 --> 01:31:27.510
- Part of that deliberation was that we are not allowed to recoup the full cost of the program. Okay.

01:31:27.510 --> 01:31:35.259
- And then, but then, and so my final question then is, is why, you know, why, why 150 and 200 for repeat?

01:31:35.259 --> 01:31:42.712
- Why 105 for, uh, for the regular rental inspections? So the 105, I wanted to keep the fees the same,

01:31:42.712 --> 01:31:49.502
- uh, for this next, um, cycle. So that way there would know there were no big surprises. Um,

01:31:49.954 --> 01:31:56.682
- basically, and then the implementation date would be July 1, so that we would get through all of the

01:31:56.682 --> 01:32:03.410
- new, the students coming in and out and everything else, and then once the busy season is over, July

01:32:03.410 --> 01:32:10.072
- 1 is when the new fees would kick in. My reasoning for the second and subsequent re-inspection fee,

01:32:10.072 --> 01:32:15.934
- frankly, I doubled it and then went to the nearest $5 increment. That was my rationale.

01:32:16.034 --> 01:32:22.734
- But but then why not make it why not make the reinspection fee a thousand dollars You in your if you

01:32:22.734 --> 01:32:29.368
- would like to do that you're more than welcome to this was my first Passed by and I felt that might

01:32:29.368 --> 01:32:36.002
- be egregious giving the other Inspection fees, but I'm happy to entertain anything else. That makes

01:32:36.002 --> 01:32:39.518
- sense. Okay, those all my questions. Thank you. Yeah

01:32:41.154 --> 01:32:49.252
- I am going to ask a question before we go back to councilmember Stasberg. So in regard to the fee for

01:32:49.252 --> 01:32:56.636
- vacancies, I see that it's $500. I have the Indiana state code pulled up here. It looks like

01:32:56.636 --> 01:33:02.590
- an IC 36-7-9-4.5, legislative findings, vacant or deteriorated structures.

01:33:02.850 --> 01:33:09.001
- It says, in recognition of the problems created in a community by vacant structures, the General Assembly

01:33:09.001 --> 01:33:14.977
- finds that vigorous and disciplined action should be taken to ensure the proper maintenance and repair

01:33:14.977 --> 01:33:20.954
- of vacant structures and encourages local bodies to adopt maintenance and repair standards appropriate

01:33:20.954 --> 01:33:26.814
- for the community in accordance with this chapter and other statutes. That's what it's referring to,

01:33:26.814 --> 01:33:30.238
- is that correct? Correct. Is it possible to increase that?

01:33:30.562 --> 01:33:37.606
- I know that one of our biggest problems that we struggle with in Bloomington is vacancy rates, so I'm

01:33:37.606 --> 01:33:44.649
- just curious if that number is flexible or if state code has laid out a different cost in a different

01:33:44.649 --> 01:33:51.969
- spot. Happy to look into that and get back to you. Thank you very much. I'll follow up in writing. Great.

01:33:51.969 --> 01:33:59.358
- Councilmember Rosen. Oh, Councilmember Ruff. We're going first round. Councilmember Zulek's last question.

01:33:59.554 --> 01:34:08.506
- What councilman was like read from code state code seemed to suggest that the reasoning for having a

01:34:08.506 --> 01:34:17.546
- a vacancy fee or penalty Sounds like the logic is that is associated with concern about deteriorating

01:34:17.546 --> 01:34:26.942
- structures and Resulting negative impacts on the community on the neighborhood by deteriorating structure

01:34:26.942 --> 01:34:29.246
- so in the absence of that

01:34:32.002 --> 01:34:38.652
- any concern about the structure not being maintained or deteriorated but just vacant. Is that the kind

01:34:38.652 --> 01:34:45.172
- of thing that the Board of Zoning Appeals would do you envision or does administration vision that I

01:34:45.172 --> 01:34:51.757
- mean the Housing Quality Authority is a board would approve if someone said hey I've got a sabbatical

01:34:51.757 --> 01:34:58.278
- for a year plus we're going to be in New Zealand and so we're going to stay an extra four months for

01:34:58.278 --> 01:35:01.054
- the summer so we move more than a year and

01:35:01.474 --> 01:35:07.634
- We don't need to rent the house. We don't need the income. We're just gonna leave it vacant It'll be

01:35:07.634 --> 01:35:13.854
- fine. It'll be in great good shape Does that run afoul or are they likely to get this $500? Thank you

01:35:13.854 --> 01:35:20.319
- so much for asking this because this is nestled in title 16 This only applies to vacant rental properties

01:35:20.319 --> 01:35:26.174
- Not for instance someone who owns a home and like for instance leaving for a year on sabbatical

01:35:30.914 --> 01:35:38.372
- other first rounds okay I'm gonna go councilmember Stasberg and then we'll go back to you councilmember

01:35:38.372 --> 01:35:45.757
- Rosenberger thank you so in terms of wait kind of continuing to follow up actually I'm a councilmember

01:35:45.757 --> 01:35:52.928
- rough was talking about with like evaluating that the the exemptions that might be allowed in terms

01:35:52.928 --> 01:35:57.374
- of that $500 fee so it only applies to rental homes I guess I

01:35:57.570 --> 01:36:04.908
- The big question that I have is what kind of guidance is going to be given to the, which board did you

01:36:04.908 --> 01:36:12.033
- say it would be? Board of Housing Quality Appeals. Board of Housing and Quality Appeals to evaluate

01:36:12.033 --> 01:36:19.300
- good faith efforts. And so especially I'm thinking like, I mean, you mentioned a good faith effort to

01:36:19.300 --> 01:36:25.214
- sell a property, but what about a good faith effort to rent the property out, say,

01:36:25.730 --> 01:36:36.513
- for the example of somebody trying to rent a property for well over the standard kind of going rate,

01:36:36.513 --> 01:36:47.404
- or folks that might, or properties that might not necessarily be in good working order, and they are,

01:36:47.404 --> 01:36:55.518
- once again, I've also heard speculation that some property owners sometimes

01:36:55.682 --> 01:37:04.131
- very deliberately let properties decay so that then they have better justification to demo it. And so

01:37:04.131 --> 01:37:12.993
- I guess I just am concerned about those issues and concerned mostly about how to evaluate those exceptions

01:37:12.993 --> 01:37:22.270
- and to do it in a way that is fair to all of the petitioners that might request that and expected and also like

01:37:22.658 --> 01:37:29.401
- goes toward the ultimate goal, which is to have our properties being lived in. So how do you envision,

01:37:29.401 --> 01:37:36.209
- I guess, that process? Is there going to be a rubric? What's the guidance? Where's the guidance? Right.

01:37:36.209 --> 01:37:43.213
- Well, I would say, first off, to kind of go back to what you had said earlier in the meeting, you evaluate

01:37:43.213 --> 01:37:49.956
- these committee members. You evaluate their qualifications, whether or not they're suited for a board,

01:37:49.956 --> 01:37:51.134
- things like that.

01:37:51.490 --> 01:37:58.057
- in their judgment and wisdom, they would be able to make those kinds of determinations. Um, that's the

01:37:58.057 --> 01:38:04.560
- purpose of legislative bodies and things is to come together for those kinds of things. Um, as far as

01:38:04.560 --> 01:38:11.383
- guidance is concerned, more than happy to collaborate on anything that council might think is appropriate.

01:38:11.383 --> 01:38:17.886
- Um, but that they, when I brought this up with them and discussed it with the BHQA members, um, they,

01:38:18.658 --> 01:38:27.008
- brought up the very examples I was giving, which is good faith efforts, trying to sell, trying to rent,

01:38:27.008 --> 01:38:35.438
- things like that. Does that? Well, it answers the question. I guess I would just encourage whoever would

01:38:35.438 --> 01:38:44.350
- need to do that to have some sort of written documentation in place. Right. And I'm not even sure who the best

01:38:44.930 --> 01:38:51.497
- body would be to create that, maybe the BHQA themselves, maybe the hand department, maybe a collaboration.

01:38:51.497 --> 01:38:56.222
- I don't think that that's necessarily the thing that council usually ends up

01:38:56.738 --> 01:39:03.287
- getting in the middle of. But I think that it's generally important in terms of evaluation to make sure

01:39:03.287 --> 01:39:10.088
- that every petition is getting evaluated based on the same standards. And so ideally, then, those standards

01:39:10.088 --> 01:39:16.448
- would be written down somewhere and would be transparent to the community. I'm also the attorney for

01:39:16.448 --> 01:39:23.123
- BHQA advising them. So I'd be more than happy to say, hey, guys, heard this when I was talking to counsel

01:39:23.123 --> 01:39:26.334
- and put something together. Absolutely. Thank you.

01:39:26.562 --> 01:39:34.059
- Hi, thanks. Getting more into the vacancy fee. Okay, so this does not apply to owner-occupied homes,

01:39:34.059 --> 01:39:41.555
- is what you're saying. No, this is nestled in Title 16, so it is only rental properties. Okay, and I

01:39:41.555 --> 01:39:49.126
- see that that is the case, but I see that that is a problem for me because we're basically, it's like

01:39:49.126 --> 01:39:55.806
- an equity problem that if your home is, the policy goal here is to not have homes vacant.

01:39:56.066 --> 01:40:03.202
- any home, I think. And so then we're saying if you are able to leave your home vacant and go rent somewhere

01:40:03.202 --> 01:40:10.272
- else for a year, you don't have to pay a fee. That feels problematic to me. I know that these are separate

01:40:10.272 --> 01:40:17.143
- titles, but it does feel problematic to me. Second, what about second homes that are vacant? So someone

01:40:17.143 --> 01:40:23.486
- has a second home here and they come three weekends out of the year. Does it get a vacancy fee?

01:40:25.282 --> 01:40:32.851
- Well, as you said three weekends out of the year, right it has to be vacant for a full calendar year

01:40:32.851 --> 01:40:40.495
- so vacant second homes here Won't get any kind of fee From according to your example, they would come

01:40:40.495 --> 01:40:47.989
- live in there in the home six days six days out of the year they would need to be vacant for a full

01:40:47.989 --> 01:40:50.462
- year for this fee to kick in and

01:40:50.690 --> 01:40:57.132
- Okay, so also for the policy goal of getting humans living in our houses, that is a problem for me,

01:40:57.132 --> 01:41:03.704
- because second homes are even worse than Airbnbs, because Airbnbs at least house our guests when they

01:41:03.704 --> 01:41:10.404
- come to town, because our hotels are full. I think Councilmember Varallo asked if our hotels were full,

01:41:10.404 --> 01:41:14.398
- but yes, they are all full for our football games and things.

01:41:14.914 --> 01:41:21.134
- Places like Notre Dame have insane problems with blocks of second homes. I don't think, don't get me

01:41:21.134 --> 01:41:27.478
- wrong, Ayu, but I don't know that our football team will ever be that good. But I think that- They won

01:41:27.478 --> 01:41:34.068
- a championship already, Councilmember Rosenberger. I know. And according to people, our team is different.

01:41:34.068 --> 01:41:40.350
- I don't follow. I love it. Thank you. I love everyone doing it. Let's do more football. I think that-

01:41:40.834 --> 01:41:46.646
- I know we're in Title 16, but I think this is a more holistic problem than what we're looking at. And

01:41:46.646 --> 01:41:52.629
- I think this is targeting landlords and renters in a way that feels unfair to me. And I think when we're

01:41:52.629 --> 01:41:58.839
- looking at these fees, most, well, when I did a long-term rental, I almost always had to get a re-inspection

01:41:58.839 --> 01:42:04.594
- because something needed to be updated. So then you update it, and then they come back. And so we're

01:42:04.594 --> 01:42:05.278
- looking at,

01:42:05.762 --> 01:42:11.116
- $325 and like landlords mostly to the best of their ability don't absorb any costs and they pass those

01:42:11.116 --> 01:42:16.419
- on to tenants So I think we have to be thinking about these fees I think councilmember sorry said can

01:42:16.419 --> 01:42:21.929
- it be a thousand dollars? But like I don't think that's a good idea because we're talking about landlords

01:42:21.929 --> 01:42:27.388
- wanting to make money So it's I think it's just more complicated than how much can we charge? I'm sorry.

01:42:27.388 --> 01:42:33.054
- How are you getting the $325? There might be a misunderstanding a Subsequent. All right, they go they do the

01:42:33.730 --> 01:42:41.227
- Well, I'm looking at 2029. So the first fee is 125. They have some things not in compliance. They have

01:42:41.227 --> 01:42:48.724
- to get things into compliance and schedule another inspection. So that would be $325. No. So thank you

01:42:48.724 --> 01:42:56.294
- for the clarification. So the second and subsequent reinspection fee would be hand shows up to inspect.

01:42:56.294 --> 01:43:03.646
- They come back to make sure that all of the things on their list were fixed. That is not the second.

01:43:04.194 --> 01:43:09.940
- Re-inspection that is the first re-inspection. It's Worded strangely and we could perhaps clarify that

01:43:09.940 --> 01:43:15.686
- but then the if there is anything that they failed to fix Beforehand comes back and hand has to return

01:43:15.686 --> 01:43:21.487
- again for a third time That is when the second and subsequent re-inspection fee would begin. Okay, it's

01:43:21.487 --> 01:43:25.950
- cut off I know I have in my packet, but it looks like it says re-inspection fee

01:43:26.946 --> 01:43:36.233
- So maybe that's a little unclear. We can change it by next reading. OK. Another hypothetical. I have

01:43:36.233 --> 01:43:45.611
- a house I'm renting on Airbnb, but I don't accept bookings for one year. Do I get a vacancy fee? Yes.

01:43:45.611 --> 01:43:55.358
- The way this is written. OK. OK. Thank you. That's it. Any other questions? Councilmember Piedmont-Smith.

01:43:56.546 --> 01:44:02.135
- I guess it begs the question, how would you know that this house is vacant for a year? Which is why

01:44:02.135 --> 01:44:07.781
- the fee exists, right? So Hand actually monitors a lot of these things. We discuss with utilities if

01:44:07.781 --> 01:44:13.259
- there is, there are usually signs that the inspectors know if they can, they can usually tell if,

01:44:13.259 --> 01:44:18.904
- you know, cars aren't in the driveway, they don't see lights on, things like that at different times

01:44:18.904 --> 01:44:24.158
- they're going by their neighborhoods. If there is a, if there is suspicion that it is vacant,

01:44:24.290 --> 01:44:31.021
- Um, like for instance, when there are certain rentals, when someone asks, you know, they asked to be

01:44:31.021 --> 01:44:37.819
- exempt from title 16 because a home is vacant. We can usually go to utilities and say, have there any

01:44:37.819 --> 01:44:44.550
- utilities been used in the last however long? Um, so there are, there are methods and ways that, uh,

01:44:44.550 --> 01:44:50.815
- hand does investigate how, if whether or not a home is vacant. If that answers your question.

01:44:50.815 --> 01:44:53.214
- Thank you. Council member Stasberg.

01:44:54.050 --> 01:45:00.401
- Thank you. I think that this is actually my last question about this is it's actually about the the

01:45:00.401 --> 01:45:07.007
- funds that the fees go into and then what gets paid out of those funds. So Director Killian Hansen also

01:45:07.007 --> 01:45:13.485
- already said that like it doesn't fully cover the cost of the programs. But does it just like go into

01:45:13.485 --> 01:45:20.091
- general fund. So like how does that work by state law. All funds received through Title 16 whether they

01:45:20.091 --> 01:45:23.838
- be fines fees etc. are placed in the unsafe building fund.

01:45:24.002 --> 01:45:33.435
- And the unsafe building fund is specifically for and I'm gonna look at you. I believe it's for Any abatements

01:45:33.435 --> 01:45:42.096
- that need to happen? emergency repairs things like that The actual like operating costs of hand come

01:45:42.096 --> 01:45:51.358
- out of it at all so it's so what exactly is this fund used for or what it has been used for in the past and

01:45:51.842 --> 01:46:00.970
- So Title 17 of the Bloomington Municipal Code is related to unsafe buildings so we can issue orders

01:46:00.970 --> 01:46:03.070
- to seal vacate remove.

01:46:03.170 --> 01:46:10.229
- Etc when those buildings that we have declared unsafe do not comply Then we can step in with an abatement

01:46:10.229 --> 01:46:16.888
- and take care of it So you might remember the fire that occurred on Walnut Street a couple of years

01:46:16.888 --> 01:46:23.680
- ago It was gosh. I can't remember the address off the top of my head But it burned pretty rapidly and

01:46:23.680 --> 01:46:30.406
- the owners were unable to step in there was no contact with them And so we ended up stepping in with

01:46:30.406 --> 01:46:33.136
- unsafe funds demolishing removing making

01:46:33.136 --> 01:46:41.393
- the area safe. So and I will say just in relation to the vacant homes some of the biggest problems that

01:46:41.393 --> 01:46:50.206
- we have are related to festering properties that have overgrowth. Nobody's living in them. We have issues with

01:46:50.338 --> 01:46:58.037
- Title 17 specifically. So if you were interested in addressing potentially some of the vacancies with

01:46:58.037 --> 01:47:06.039
- owner occupied, I would direct you to do that through Title 17 changes because that is one of the biggest

01:47:06.039 --> 01:47:14.040
- challenges that we have. There's probably a hundred ish properties in Bloomington that are sitting vacant

01:47:14.040 --> 01:47:19.550
- that are just degradated and failing. Probably a hundred ish. Thank you.

01:47:20.482 --> 01:47:28.277
- How much more presentation do you have? I believe I have one slide. Okay, great. Go for it. So the specific

01:47:28.277 --> 01:47:35.567
- removal of sections and references. So the legislature passed 32-31-1-20, which prohibits regulation

01:47:35.567 --> 01:47:43.218
- of landlord-tenant relationships. The code hasn't been updated since then, so we went through and removed

01:47:43.218 --> 01:47:48.126
- certain sections that were now prohibited and void under state law.

01:47:48.290 --> 01:47:54.838
- Also, this year, the Indiana Fire Prevention and Building Safety Commission was disbanded and absorbed

01:47:54.838 --> 01:48:01.513
- back into the Indiana Department of Homeland Security. And so we removed any references to that specific

01:48:01.513 --> 01:48:07.870
- commission, seeing as it no longer exists. Thank you. Thank you. Any final questions for Mr. Brown?

01:48:07.870 --> 01:48:14.227
- Thank you, you guys. OK. Thank you so much for your presentation. And thank you for your stamina. I

01:48:14.227 --> 01:48:17.278
- know we've kept you up here for quite a minute.

01:48:17.378 --> 01:48:24.046
- Thank you very much. Thank you. We'll try to get those questions into you by noon on Tuesday so that

01:48:24.046 --> 01:48:31.175
- you have enough time to actually get them answered. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. Any final comments

01:48:31.175 --> 01:48:37.843
- from council members? That is for second reading. We do questions, comments, and then public comment

01:48:37.843 --> 01:48:43.454
- during first reading. Are there any comments? Okay, then we'll go to public comment.

01:48:43.682 --> 01:48:53.305
- Would anyone in chambers like to speak on this ordinance in particular? Anyone online? OK. Then I will

01:48:53.305 --> 01:49:02.834
- entertain a motion. I move to send Ordinance 2026-38 to a second reading on December 2nd. Second. OK.

01:49:02.834 --> 01:49:11.710
- There has been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Will the clerk please call the roll?

01:49:13.026 --> 01:49:28.085
- Council Member Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Naly? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty?

01:49:28.085 --> 01:49:35.838
- Yes. Stosberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Thank you.

01:49:36.002 --> 01:49:44.573
- Thank you. That passes, and we will continue Ordinance 2026-38 onto our next regularly scheduled meeting

01:49:44.573 --> 01:49:52.899
- on December 2nd. Any other motions? I move that Ordinance 2026-39 be introduced and read by the clerk

01:49:52.899 --> 01:50:01.144
- by title and synopsis only. Second. OK. There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Will

01:50:01.144 --> 01:50:05.470
- the clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Asari?

01:50:05.858 --> 01:50:15.388
- Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont-Smith.

01:50:15.388 --> 01:50:22.718
- Yes. Zulek. Yes. Thank you. Thank you. That passes. Will the clerk please read.

01:50:26.082 --> 01:50:33.273
- Ordinance 2026-39 to amend Title 10 of the Bloomington Municipal Code titled Wastewater Regarding Fats,

01:50:33.273 --> 01:50:40.602
- Oils, and Grease. The synopsis is as follows. This ordinance amends Title 10 of the Bloomington Municipal

01:50:40.602 --> 01:50:48.000
- Code at Chapter 10.17 to bring the city's FOG program into compliance with recently enacted House Enrolled

01:50:48.000 --> 01:50:52.702
- Act 1348, which established new legislation at Indiana Code 8146.1,

01:50:52.802 --> 01:51:02.390
- for the regulation of fats, oils, and grease. The council sponsor is Flaherty. Thank you very much.

01:51:02.390 --> 01:51:12.074
- I move to discuss ordinance 2026-39. Second. There's been a motion and a second. Any comments? Okay.

01:51:12.074 --> 01:51:21.374
- Thank you. Will the clerk please call the roll? Council Member Daly? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes.

01:51:21.506 --> 01:51:30.699
- Rosenberger. Yes, clarity. Yes, Stossberg. Yes, Piedmont Smith. Yes, Azulik. Yes, sorry Yes Thank you.

01:51:30.699 --> 01:51:39.625
- Thank you very much that passes. Is there anyone to present? Go right ahead, please state your name

01:51:39.625 --> 01:51:49.086
- Good evening, I'm Stephen Stanford the pretreatment coordinator for the city of Bloomington utilities and

01:51:51.746 --> 01:52:01.288
- I'm here to tell you a little bit about some recommended revisions to Title X that are intended to make

01:52:01.288 --> 01:52:10.831
- our city ordinance consistent with the new state code. Fats, oils, and grease. These are the regulatory

01:52:10.831 --> 01:52:20.006
- citations. History and background. The city of Bloomington has regulated the fats, oils, and grease

01:52:20.006 --> 01:52:21.566
- discharges since

01:52:21.826 --> 01:52:31.158
- That's under Chapter 10.17 of the Municipal Code. The new state law, HEA 1348, was signed in March of

01:52:31.158 --> 01:52:40.398
- this year, and it became effective in July of this year. So this law already applies and establishes

01:52:40.398 --> 01:52:50.462
- a statewide framework for the regulations of fog discharges that contribute to sewer blockages and overflows.

01:52:51.010 --> 01:53:00.444
- And it also requires the continued acceptance of septage from neighboring jurisdictions from which we

01:53:00.444 --> 01:53:09.693
- were receiving septage on January 1st, 2024. The amendments that we recommend to our city ordinance

01:53:09.693 --> 01:53:18.942
- to make it consistent with the new state law is to adopt certain state definitions require that the

01:53:19.586 --> 01:53:27.914
- Grease control be designed by professional engineers or architects. We've adopted a grease control device

01:53:27.914 --> 01:53:35.928
- sizing equation. We've established procedures for exemptions and alternative service frequencies. And

01:53:35.928 --> 01:53:44.020
- we also intend to adopt a time limitation of 60 days for plan reviews when, say, a developer is coming

01:53:44.020 --> 01:53:47.870
- into town and they want to build a new facility.

01:53:48.258 --> 01:53:58.468
- We have no longer than 60 days to review the fog related sections of the project. In terms of fiscal

01:53:58.468 --> 01:54:08.880
- impact, what we anticipate is that a potential for substantial savings for a developer who is building

01:54:08.880 --> 01:54:16.158
- a commercial property in an area zoned for food service establishments.

01:54:16.770 --> 01:54:25.250
- Currently we require that they install a large fog control device. That blanket mandate is eliminated

01:54:25.250 --> 01:54:33.729
- under the state law. And so if the developer was to build a multi-use building that has retail space,

01:54:33.729 --> 01:54:42.708
- for example, previously we would have required a grease interceptor to be installed as part of the project.

01:54:42.708 --> 01:54:45.950
- We can no longer require that upfront.

01:54:48.002 --> 01:54:59.325
- Another change is that using the sizing equation, the developers and operators of the businesses could

01:54:59.325 --> 01:55:11.198
- propose smaller grease control devices than are customary today. What we anticipate is that the maintenance

01:55:11.198 --> 01:55:13.726
- of smaller devices can

01:55:14.978 --> 01:55:21.585
- fall by the wayside more frequently than the larger devices that have a regular subscription service

01:55:21.585 --> 01:55:28.714
- from a hauler. And so we think that we're going to probably see as a consequence of this more fog discharges

01:55:28.714 --> 01:55:35.517
- into the sewer and possibly more frequent sewer cleaning. It's difficult to project how many additional

01:55:35.517 --> 01:55:42.189
- sewer cleaning events that we would need, but on a case-by-case basis, those things typically cost us

01:55:42.189 --> 01:55:42.974
- about $250.

01:55:43.074 --> 01:55:51.907
- to $2,500 per event depending on the size and severity of the problem. If in the end we find that we're

01:55:51.907 --> 01:56:00.400
- going to need a new jet vac truck and crew for enhanced sewer maintenance as a consequence of these

01:56:00.400 --> 01:56:09.062
- changes, that would increase our operating costs by about $200,000 to $250,000 per year. We thank you

01:56:09.062 --> 01:56:13.054
- for your consideration and I would like to ask

01:56:13.186 --> 01:56:20.876
- That you move forward with the proposed amendments and I will be glad to answer any questions that you

01:56:20.876 --> 01:56:28.491
- might have Thank you very much are there any questions Councilmember Stossberg I just have a question

01:56:28.491 --> 01:56:36.180
- about what you ended with in terms of that fiscal impact. So that's like a theoretical possible fiscal

01:56:36.180 --> 01:56:41.854
- impact kind of depending on how well the the interceptors actually work and

01:56:42.178 --> 01:56:49.347
- That's our best projection based on the experience and what we anticipate based on expected changes

01:56:49.347 --> 01:56:56.515
- in the nature of the devices that could be used and installed. Because the state is saying this has

01:56:56.515 --> 01:57:03.827
- changed the guidelines and so we have to go along with the state's change. That's correct. We're just

01:57:03.827 --> 01:57:10.494
- attempting to meet the state law in this particular instance. Okay. Do you happen to know if

01:57:10.658 --> 01:57:20.285
- this was a consideration that was given at the state legislature when they changed this? I can't speak

01:57:20.285 --> 01:57:29.911
- to their deliberation process. I'm not familiar with the process that went into this. Because I assume

01:57:29.911 --> 01:57:36.734
- this is true for the entire state, so every municipality, every utility,

01:57:36.834 --> 01:57:47.042
- And so every utility would be potentially dealing with this kind of fiscal impact related to maintenance.

01:57:47.042 --> 01:57:57.346
- Yes. Okay. Thanks. Council member Piedmont Smith. Yes. In looking at the ordinance or the the code changes

01:57:57.346 --> 01:58:06.398
- we have different sections for installation requirements for new food service establishments.

01:58:06.754 --> 01:58:13.092
- installation requirements for newly remodeled food service establishments, installation requirements

01:58:13.092 --> 01:58:19.556
- for existing food service establishments. They're all the same as far as I can tell. So why do we need

01:58:19.556 --> 01:58:26.146
- three different sections? Actually, the next one is the same as well. Why do we need all these different

01:58:26.146 --> 01:58:31.166
- sections if the requirements are the same for all the different establishments?

01:58:32.866 --> 01:58:41.391
- I would leave that question to our drafter of those particular regulations. We were working with the

01:58:41.391 --> 01:58:50.506
- old ones to start with, and what we did was we put the new state definitions into our existing definitions.

01:58:50.506 --> 01:58:58.946
- Would that be attorney Chris Wheeler, or who wrote this? Yes, attorney Wheeler helped us with this.

01:58:58.946 --> 01:59:02.238
- Is he online by any chance? I am, yes.

01:59:04.418 --> 01:59:14.309
- Hello. Hello. Did you hear my question? I did. I was listening. So when we drafted the fog ordinance

01:59:14.309 --> 01:59:24.200
- many years ago, we tried to capture all of the different food service establishment, whether they're

01:59:24.200 --> 01:59:31.838
- brand new, whether they're existing, whether they're moving into a new place.

01:59:32.482 --> 01:59:39.765
- And in each one of those instances, we were just trying to capture all of the different possible ways

01:59:39.765 --> 01:59:47.047
- that a food service establishment should get captured by this fog regulation so that we can make sure

01:59:47.047 --> 01:59:54.616
- that they're putting the right, at that time, put in a grease interceptor. When we worked on this update,

01:59:54.616 --> 02:00:00.542
- we didn't get rid of the terms, we just put that same definition into those terms.

02:00:01.218 --> 02:00:07.520
- I think where I can speculate where you might be going is why don't we just consolidate it and say any

02:00:07.520 --> 02:00:13.761
- restaurant has to do this, right? But just for the sake of brevity, or not brevity, but simplicity in

02:00:13.761 --> 02:00:20.124
- making the amendments, we just made it apply to all of those different categories that already had been

02:00:20.124 --> 02:00:26.548
- in place and existing in the current code rather than trying to consolidate it. That's all that happened

02:00:26.548 --> 02:00:29.118
- there. It wasn't anything more than that.

02:00:31.778 --> 02:00:42.024
- Well, I guess this is more of a comment, but since it's first reading, am I allowed to make a comment

02:00:42.024 --> 02:00:52.068
- as well? To me, it seems much easier to consolidate them. Okay. Well, you might be right. So we can

02:00:52.068 --> 02:00:56.990
- talk about that a little later. Related to that,

02:00:58.498 --> 02:01:06.189
- You have section 10, 17.100, installation requirements for food service establishments causing

02:01:06.189 --> 02:01:14.610
- or contributing to a sanitary sewer overflow. So I'm a little puzzled why we need this section, because

02:01:14.610 --> 02:01:22.706
- aren't all food service establishments already covered by the categories above? The new commercial,

02:01:22.706 --> 02:01:26.430
- the remodel commercial, et cetera, et cetera.

02:01:26.818 --> 02:01:35.011
- and this language seems the same, so is this somehow, did I miss something? Is this language harsher

02:01:35.011 --> 02:01:43.529
- for ones that actually caused a sanitary sewer overflow? Yeah, so if they actually are, if in fact there

02:01:43.529 --> 02:01:52.047
- are issues that are causing a congestion in the sanitary lines that's causing it back up, because that's

02:01:52.047 --> 02:01:55.454
- just a specific type of a situation where

02:01:55.682 --> 02:02:02.800
- if in fact they're creating a problem that's causing sanitary sewer to overflow because of the fact

02:02:02.800 --> 02:02:10.274
- that there's all this grease coming into the sanitary sewer and plugging it up. That's what we're trying

02:02:10.274 --> 02:02:17.535
- to get out there with that definitional term. Okay. But again, the actual text underneath the heading

02:02:17.535 --> 02:02:23.870
- is the same. Okay. Again, all of the different definitional terms we just simply applied

02:02:24.162 --> 02:02:32.157
- that one term to all of them. So it works evenly across the board now for every possible type of food

02:02:32.157 --> 02:02:40.386
- service establishment that's out there. OK. Well, I'll email you about consolidating that perhaps. Sure.

02:02:40.386 --> 02:02:48.538
- Thank you. Thank you. And thanks for being here, Mr. Wheeler. Thank you. Are there any other questions?

02:02:48.538 --> 02:02:50.654
- Oh, Council member, sorry.

02:02:51.746 --> 02:02:59.671
- Thank you so much, Madam Chair. And thank you for the work on this, both Mr. Wheeler and the wonderful

02:02:59.671 --> 02:03:07.364
- CBU staff. I had a question about cost shifting. I mean, because I sort of get the tension. I think

02:03:07.364 --> 02:03:15.289
- I get the tension that we have this financial trade-off in the middle of this, that we think that, and

02:03:15.289 --> 02:03:21.598
- I think it's the sort of model that's presented. So if I understand it correctly,

02:03:21.698 --> 02:03:31.273
- Smaller equipment can reduce the cost for private businesses, but we think that that's going to increase

02:03:31.273 --> 02:03:38.750
- maintenance costs for the utility. And so, first, do I understand that correctly?

02:03:43.106 --> 02:03:52.720
- the facilities operating the smaller devices tend to forego maintenance more frequently than the larger

02:03:52.720 --> 02:04:02.057
- facilities. Okay, and so how do we ensure if at all that those, I guess the lead up question to this

02:04:02.057 --> 02:04:07.326
- is do you have some estimate of, because I know a lot of

02:04:07.490 --> 02:04:13.999
- of restaurateurs, a lot of developers. I mean, this has been a pain point for a long time, the huge

02:04:13.999 --> 02:04:20.899
- cost of putting in grease traps and those type of things. And so, do we have any estimates on what uptake

02:04:20.899 --> 02:04:27.538
- is going to be? I mean, I don't, this might be too hypothetical, but really the more pointed question

02:04:27.538 --> 02:04:34.698
- is, you know, one, how do we ensure that any additional costs aren't simply transferred to utility customers,

02:04:34.698 --> 02:04:35.870
- and two, perhaps,

02:04:35.970 --> 02:04:43.698
- More directly and immediately important is is do we currently have sufficient pretreatment inspection,

02:04:43.698 --> 02:04:51.425
- you know enforcement capacity, etc To monitor compliance if there's if there's a sort of more variable

02:04:51.425 --> 02:04:59.078
- equipment and maintenance schedules We do require all of the food service establishments to subscribe

02:04:59.078 --> 02:05:01.854
- to a cloud-based customer portal and

02:05:02.562 --> 02:05:10.116
- to log their cleanouts for us so that we know that they're, number one, they're in business, and number

02:05:10.116 --> 02:05:17.743
- two, how often they're cleaning it out. And the pretreatment team does inspect restaurants in particular

02:05:17.743 --> 02:05:25.225
- that are out of compliance. Do you anticipate needing more staff, more operational capacity in any way

02:05:25.225 --> 02:05:31.326
- to enforce this with these changes? I think we're in pretty good shape, Councilman.

02:05:31.554 --> 02:05:40.134
- In terms of staff to keep up with this because this is not a new Business for us. It's we're just making

02:05:40.134 --> 02:05:48.960
- some adjustments to the existing ordinance Okay, excellent. Excellent. Thank you so much I have a follow-up

02:05:48.960 --> 02:05:57.213
- that I kind of thought of well other council members were asking their questions. Has there been any

02:05:57.213 --> 02:06:01.054
- consideration within utilities to assess fines

02:06:01.250 --> 02:06:11.307
- for those establishments that are slacking, you can say, on some of that maintenance and thus causing

02:06:11.307 --> 02:06:21.168
- backups? Is there a way to really figure out how a backup is caused? I guess I kind of similarly to

02:06:21.168 --> 02:06:27.774
- what Council Member Asari said, I don't want this transferred onto

02:06:27.970 --> 02:06:35.756
- all of our utility customers at large, especially if there's individual establishments that could be

02:06:35.756 --> 02:06:43.697
- doing a better job at maintenance. We have something that's called our enforcement response plan. It's

02:06:43.697 --> 02:06:50.558
- a graduated enforcement approach to customers who are not complying with city ordinance.

02:06:50.754 --> 02:06:59.324
- Starts with things like telephone calls emails works its way to written warnings and then it goes to

02:06:59.324 --> 02:07:08.148
- fines and we we have a history of imposing fines on Food service establishments who are not taking care

02:07:08.148 --> 02:07:17.566
- of business Okay, great. Great. Thank you any Councilmember Piedmont Smith Yes, do I understand correctly that

02:07:18.146 --> 02:07:27.575
- Garbage disposals are not allowed. Is that a new requirement? That requirement's been in place since

02:07:27.575 --> 02:07:37.097
- 2012, to my knowledge. OK. I saw it as read in the text, so maybe it was just moved from one place to

02:07:37.097 --> 02:07:46.526
- another. I believe that's correct. OK. And is that can be exempted if the food service establishment

02:07:47.234 --> 02:07:55.033
- somehow proves that they don't have a lot of grease or something like that? Yes, there is a method for

02:07:55.033 --> 02:08:02.831
- an operator to go through that process. Okay. Thank you. Did I see Mr. Wheeler have his hand up? Yeah,

02:08:02.831 --> 02:08:10.857
- I did. And I was going to just chime in and explain that all of the enforcement procedures are in section

02:08:10.857 --> 02:08:16.990
- 1030 of Title 10. And so if you had been looking through 1017 and didn't see any

02:08:17.378 --> 02:08:28.912
- fine or enforcement provisions, that's because it's in section 1030. Thank you very much. Are there

02:08:28.912 --> 02:08:40.676
- any final questions? Any council comments? Would anyone in the chambers like to make a public comment

02:08:40.676 --> 02:08:46.558
- on this ordinance? Is there anyone on Zoom? Great.

02:08:46.658 --> 02:08:56.177
- At this point in time, I will entertain a motion. I move that we move this item of legislation, ordinance

02:08:56.177 --> 02:09:05.157
- 2026-39, to our regular session on December 2nd for a second reading. Second. Great. There's been a

02:09:05.157 --> 02:09:10.366
- motion and a second. Will the clerk please call the roll?

02:09:18.082 --> 02:09:26.828
- Councilmember Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stosberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith?

02:09:26.828 --> 02:09:35.574
- Yes. Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Ann Daly? Yes. Thank you very much. That passes. We will pick this back

02:09:35.574 --> 02:09:44.493
- up on December 2nd. And please, if you have any follow-up questions, please send them in writing again

02:09:44.493 --> 02:09:47.870
- by Tuesday at noon. Thank you so much.

02:09:48.002 --> 02:09:57.238
- for your endurance. I know it's a little bit of a late night. OK. So now that we have completed ordinance

02:09:57.238 --> 02:10:06.300
- 2026-39, do I hear a motion? I move that ordinance 2026-41 be introduced and read by the clerk by title

02:10:06.300 --> 02:10:15.361
- and synopsis only. Second. OK. There has been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Will the clerk

02:10:15.361 --> 02:10:17.278
- please call the roll?

02:10:19.202 --> 02:10:30.154
- Councilmember Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek.

02:10:30.154 --> 02:10:39.710
- Yes. Asari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Thank you very much. Will the clerk please read.

02:10:43.618 --> 02:10:49.929
- Ordinance 2026-41 amending Title VI of the Bloomington Municipal Code to increase solid waste cart fees

02:10:49.929 --> 02:10:55.998
- and other sanitation service fees and to establish new requirements for solid waste collection. The

02:10:55.998 --> 02:11:02.431
- synopsis says as follows, Ordinance 2026-41 amends Title VI of the Bloomington Municipal Code to increase

02:11:02.431 --> 02:11:08.621
- fees for waste services, including trash carts, large items, appliances, and yard waste, to establish

02:11:08.621 --> 02:11:11.230
- fees for new carts and for cart exchanges,

02:11:11.362 --> 02:11:17.963
- to require new residential developments, acquire carts for each property prior to the start of city

02:11:17.963 --> 02:11:25.093
- sanitation services, to hold landlords responsible for ensuring the rental property has trash and recycling

02:11:25.093 --> 02:11:31.761
- carts at the start of a tenancy, and to make further updates to billing and other required practices

02:11:31.761 --> 02:11:38.494
- with regards to waste services. The council sponsor is Flaherty. I move to discuss ordinance 2026-40.

02:11:42.530 --> 02:11:50.754
- Well, I'm just wondering if this is that I guess I need to ask our council attorney Mr. Rossman, is

02:11:50.754 --> 02:11:59.224
- this the kind of just a piece of legislation where because it has to do with Finance it has to do with

02:11:59.224 --> 02:12:07.777
- money, you know, we'd raised we did this with the fees. We talked about the fees earlier on the housing

02:12:07.777 --> 02:12:12.382
- Legislation, but it's just the kind of legislation that

02:12:12.610 --> 02:12:20.424
- Folks can't be referred to remote for this is a first reading and we're not taking a vote on it. And

02:12:20.424 --> 02:12:28.238
- so I just want to be sure that they won't have to they won't have to. And so I didn't really think I

02:12:28.238 --> 02:12:36.129
- deserve a look of disdain for that. But I just want to be sure that they don't that we're not running

02:12:36.129 --> 02:12:40.926
- a foul of a law. If it stays on track for first reading there

02:12:42.242 --> 02:12:53.364
- No problem to discuss. Okay. Thank you. Councilmember daily. Go ahead. It's twenty twenty six dash forty

02:12:53.364 --> 02:13:04.275
- one be discussed. Okay. There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion. Will the clerk please call

02:13:04.275 --> 02:13:11.902
- the roll. Councilmember Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stasburg. Yes.

02:13:12.482 --> 02:13:25.982
- Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. Director Wason.

02:13:35.170 --> 02:13:41.853
- Good evening members of the council Adam Wason public works director for the city of Bloomington It's

02:13:41.853 --> 02:13:48.732
- always an honor and a privilege to be with you and to serve the city of Bloomington Tonight's discussion

02:13:48.732 --> 02:13:55.284
- on rate changes for the sanitation division is not my favorite reason for being in front of you But

02:13:55.284 --> 02:13:59.870
- here we are As you'll recall during the 2027 budget deliberations the

02:14:00.354 --> 02:14:07.319
- the sanitation division budget request was reduced with a request from the council to for staff to bring

02:14:07.319 --> 02:14:14.218
- forward a Rate proposal to eliminate the general fund support for sanitation So tonight we will discuss

02:14:14.218 --> 02:14:20.918
- the rates that we are proposing to do such To do just that and then some additional changes to title

02:14:20.918 --> 02:14:25.694
- six that we would like to implement while we are updating the ordinance

02:14:26.338 --> 02:14:33.596
- So what is in front of you tonight is just that a rate proposal for the next three budget cycles that

02:14:33.596 --> 02:14:41.281
- would eliminate the roughly one point six million dollars that makes up the difference between the revenues

02:14:41.281 --> 02:14:48.396
- brought in compared to the full cost of operating the sanitation division. So a couple of things to

02:14:48.396 --> 02:14:53.662
- point out on our sanitation services and why we are where we're at today.

02:14:54.146 --> 02:15:02.413
- So you will all remember that the sanitation division collects our solid waste, recycling, yard waste,

02:15:02.413 --> 02:15:10.439
- leaves, appliances, large items, and holiday trees. We service approximately 14,000 units any given

02:15:10.439 --> 02:15:18.706
- week. And additionally, sanitation crews respond to the different types of events downtown and service

02:15:18.706 --> 02:15:22.398
- those, whether it's the IU Homecoming Parade,

02:15:22.722 --> 02:15:30.223
- The solid waste from the actual festivals like taste of Bloomington, but all of the crowds that use

02:15:30.223 --> 02:15:37.800
- the pedestrian scale Cart trash cans throughout the downtown the Sanitation's division also services

02:15:37.800 --> 02:15:44.926
- all city facilities. So City Hall the police station facilities fire stations trailheads pools

02:15:45.058 --> 02:15:53.877
- parking lots and garages, et cetera. So that's 23 different parks, 20 buildings, and around 50 downtown

02:15:53.877 --> 02:16:02.696
- pedestrian-scale carts and cans. Overall, we've seen significant costs increase over these last several

02:16:02.696 --> 02:16:11.176
- years, and I can provide some specific examples for you as we go through tonight. You know, where a

02:16:11.176 --> 02:16:12.702
- trash truck, a...

02:16:13.026 --> 02:16:22.047
- So the 25 yard rear load trash trucks that we were buying in 2023 and prior were around $245,000. That

02:16:22.047 --> 02:16:31.243
- same truck now cost $315,000. Additional costs, we have increased costs on a lot of other areas, whether

02:16:31.243 --> 02:16:39.038
- it's just the supplies, the gloves, the bags, the cleaning materials for all the things.

02:16:39.234 --> 02:16:45.737
- One of the biggest things and we've all seen this with fuel costs throughout the year the last year

02:16:45.737 --> 02:16:52.241
- at this time in 20 November of 2025 we were paying about three dollars a gallon for diesel Everyone

02:16:52.241 --> 02:16:58.744
- knows what we're paying what we've been seeing this last year as of November for this year We're at

02:16:58.744 --> 02:17:05.378
- five dollars and 82 cents per gallon for diesel So, you know, we're seeing significant cost increases

02:17:05.378 --> 02:17:07.134
- across the board that have

02:17:07.330 --> 02:17:14.667
- honestly done away with a lot of the cost savings we were hoping to see in the new, more efficient program

02:17:14.667 --> 02:17:21.662
- with what we implemented in 2017. So for a lot of these factors, with increased costs and everything,

02:17:21.662 --> 02:17:29.136
- additionally we have our new collective bargaining agreements with our AFSCME employees, which is increasing

02:17:29.136 --> 02:17:30.782
- our category one costs.

02:17:30.978 --> 02:17:38.013
- After all the discussions with our budget hearings in August September and October We heard from the

02:17:38.013 --> 02:17:45.257
- council that they wanted to see a proposal that would reduce that general fund support amount over From

02:17:45.257 --> 02:17:52.571
- what we bring in with our revenues So what we're proposing is a rate proposal that would cut six hundred

02:17:52.571 --> 02:17:58.910
- thousand dollars in costs for 2027 cut an additional six hundred thousand in costs for and

02:17:59.682 --> 02:18:05.819
- not cost but cut six hundred thousand dollars in general fund support in twenty seven another six hundred

02:18:05.819 --> 02:18:11.724
- thousand dollar reduction of general fund support in twenty twenty eight and then a final cut of four

02:18:11.724 --> 02:18:17.687
- hundred thousand dollars in twenty twenty nine to completely eliminate the general fund support to the

02:18:17.687 --> 02:18:23.882
- sanitation division. What does that look like an actual rate term. So you'll see in the yellow highlighted

02:18:23.882 --> 02:18:29.150
- area of this chart we would be moving the thirty five gallon carts for twenty twenty seven

02:18:29.250 --> 02:18:39.909
- to 1061, the 64-gallon carts to 1940, and the 96-gallon carts to $29.10. Additionally, we are proposing

02:18:39.909 --> 02:18:50.363
- some additional rate changes to yard waste, moving that from $1 to $2, large items to $30, appliances

02:18:50.363 --> 02:18:53.950
- to $40, and cart exchanges to $30.

02:18:54.530 --> 02:19:01.918
- This next chart here shows, so if a resident has an additional pickup need on a week where they had

02:19:01.918 --> 02:19:09.527
- a particularly heavy volume of solid waste in a given week, we will do an extra Friday pickup. We make

02:19:09.527 --> 02:19:17.062
- that cost based on an approximate fourth of the cost of a typical monthly charge to do the additional

02:19:17.062 --> 02:19:20.830
- pickups there. So that was the 2027 rate increase.

02:19:20.930 --> 02:19:29.733
- Proposals for 2028 we would do an additional increase To eliminate that additional six hundred thousand

02:19:29.733 --> 02:19:38.197
- dollars from the general fund support Here that would take rates to 1238 for the 35 gallon 2264 for

02:19:38.197 --> 02:19:46.915
- the 64 gallon and $33.96 for the 96 gallon Again, here's what it would look like in 2029 with the rate

02:19:46.915 --> 02:19:48.862
- increases on that same

02:19:49.602 --> 02:19:57.711
- projected reduction of the general fund support. And again 1374 for the 35 gallon cart and 96 gallon

02:19:57.711 --> 02:20:01.726
- cart would be thirty seven dollars seventy cents.

02:20:02.722 --> 02:20:08.706
- A couple other changes that we're asking for the council to consider as part of this ordinance update

02:20:08.706 --> 02:20:14.573
- includes winter weather collection access. So just clarifying some language last year really showed

02:20:14.573 --> 02:20:20.499
- us with our big 12 inch snowfall that we need to encourage residents to make sure they can get those

02:20:20.499 --> 02:20:25.662
- carts into an area where our staff can accept actually access the carts for collection.

02:20:25.858 --> 02:20:33.949
- We are updating some language about residential rental property container accountability That's a long

02:20:33.949 --> 02:20:42.511
- way of saying that we're asking that landlords confirm that the carts are on their property when residential

02:20:42.511 --> 02:20:50.601
- turnover occurs so in August when Tenants move out that the landlords confirm that the carts are still

02:20:50.601 --> 02:20:54.686
- there for their addresses we also have a Request to

02:20:54.978 --> 02:21:01.598
- the cost of providing carts to new developments. So we have some different new housing developments

02:21:01.598 --> 02:21:08.350
- coming in. This past year, we realized we were carrying the full cost of providing the carts to those

02:21:08.350 --> 02:21:15.101
- new homes. So we're asking that we update the ordinance to capture the full cost of the cart delivery

02:21:15.101 --> 02:21:21.787
- for new residential developments. Just a few minor adjustments on the enforcement procedures, moving

02:21:21.787 --> 02:21:24.766
- that from seven days to seven calendar days.

02:21:25.218 --> 02:21:31.804
- in the language and then the ordinance obviously captures the rate increases again just to kind of wrap

02:21:31.804 --> 02:21:38.643
- up and open it up for questions from the council members you know these rate increases that we're proposing

02:21:38.643 --> 02:21:45.039
- are in line with what was discussed as part of the twenty twenty seven budget process where we heard

02:21:45.039 --> 02:21:46.686
- loud and clear that there

02:21:47.266 --> 02:21:53.894
- We heard loud and clear by action of the council to reduce our budget requests by that $600,000 amount

02:21:53.894 --> 02:22:00.587
- for 2027 Later after those budget hearings, we went to the financial subcommittee Had a good discussion

02:22:00.587 --> 02:22:07.408
- with that team of council members on this proposal and the result is what you see in front of you tonight

02:22:07.408 --> 02:22:13.908
- I'm happy to answer any questions and will Defer to some staff if I don't know the answers and would

02:22:13.908 --> 02:22:15.710
- get back to you on those so

02:22:16.386 --> 02:22:24.070
- Thank you for your time tonight. Thank you for yours. And thank you for the presentation. Any council

02:22:24.070 --> 02:22:32.131
- questions. Councilmember Piedmont Smith. Yeah. The proposal to build the general fund two hundred thousand

02:22:32.131 --> 02:22:39.966
- dollars next year for the services that sanitation provides that are separate from the curbside pickup.

02:22:40.066 --> 02:22:46.695
- It makes sense to me. I'm just wondering how did you arrive at that two hundred thousand dollar. We

02:22:46.695 --> 02:22:53.457
- did some calculation estimates based on the amount of time staff spend servicing all those facilities

02:22:53.457 --> 02:23:00.285
- the number of carts or cans at them. And I can get you kind of more specific information on that. What

02:23:00.285 --> 02:23:05.854
- exactly went into that. But it was our staff doing some estimations on the time and

02:23:06.530 --> 02:23:16.728
- Fuel costs and and such for the teams that do those collections Thank you You recycling every week have

02:23:16.728 --> 02:23:26.632
- we thought about doing every other week Not as part of this proposal, but that could be on the table

02:23:26.632 --> 02:23:33.790
- as we talk about service delivery methods. Thanks Councilmember Stasberg

02:23:36.354 --> 02:23:44.871
- Thank you. In terms of the new cart delivery, $75 delivery fee, should there maybe be some flexibility

02:23:44.871 --> 02:23:53.141
- in there at the discretion of the director as opposed to that strict fee? And I guess my thought is

02:23:53.141 --> 02:23:57.854
- something like if somebody is getting a delivery of both

02:23:58.018 --> 02:24:06.379
- trash and a recycling is that $150 if it's a duplex or a triplex and so it's getting a delivery of a

02:24:06.379 --> 02:24:14.906
- lump to like a single location on a single trip then that would be like multiplied potentially by more

02:24:14.906 --> 02:24:23.350
- and so I guess I'm you know like absolutely want to kind of recoup some of those real costs for those

02:24:23.350 --> 02:24:25.502
- services but also want to

02:24:25.666 --> 02:24:35.635
- leave some kind of flexibility or understanding for that sort of multiple cart delivery at one time

02:24:35.635 --> 02:24:45.703
- sort of situation. OK. Let us think about that in the time we have between tonight and next hearings

02:24:45.703 --> 02:24:54.974
- and discuss that internally. The $75 probably doesn't capture the whole cost of the delivery

02:24:55.138 --> 02:25:01.607
- the whole cost of the cart purchase itself and the delivery. But let me dig into that with the team

02:25:01.607 --> 02:25:03.806
- and see what we think about that.

02:25:04.002 --> 02:25:09.402
- What type of language we might propose to amend the current ordinance to seek some of that flexibility

02:25:09.402 --> 02:25:14.802
- as you were as you were making your comment I was thinking you're probably going more towards the idea

02:25:14.802 --> 02:25:20.097
- of you know, what if we had a Strong affordable housing development and if we wanted to do something

02:25:20.097 --> 02:25:25.392
- there So let me let me rack our brains and public works on how we might want to word that so that we

02:25:25.392 --> 02:25:27.070
- have some discretion I think we

02:25:27.170 --> 02:25:32.538
- Instead of making it at the discretion of the director we might think of something like at the discretion

02:25:32.538 --> 02:25:37.754
- of the Board of Public Works to take it in front of an official body make the case of why and such but

02:25:37.754 --> 02:25:42.869
- We can chew on that and come back a couple weeks with maybe some amended language that we could work

02:25:42.869 --> 02:25:45.502
- with you on okay, I guess I'm also looking at it as

02:25:46.786 --> 02:25:54.493
- Fee is just for the actual delivery of the item not for the cart itself And I think based on what you

02:25:54.493 --> 02:26:02.503
- just said you intend it to be the delivery plus the cart the whole the $75 per cart includes the delivery

02:26:02.503 --> 02:26:08.926
- And the cost okay, so art itself does e cart exchange $30 per cart. Is that correct?

02:26:09.122 --> 02:26:16.209
- of just the delivery then or is that the cart and that's more maybe we just need to clean up that language

02:26:16.209 --> 02:26:23.098
- to clarify that a little bit because I clearly had a different understanding of what that $75 was doing

02:26:23.098 --> 02:26:29.788
- then you did so so let's think of it this way the $75 is more of a capital recovery cost and the $30

02:26:29.788 --> 02:26:32.702
- is more for a new so let's think of the $75

02:26:33.250 --> 02:26:40.240
- charge for a new residential unit that needs new carts. That's more of a capital recovery. Whereas the

02:26:40.240 --> 02:26:47.502
- cart exchange fee is more of the labor and fuel to do that. OK. OK. I thought that that that that delivery

02:26:47.502 --> 02:26:54.764
- that seventy five dollars was the labor fee and not the cart fee. We can clarify language. Yep. Clarifying

02:26:54.764 --> 02:27:00.126
- that language would be fantastic. Thanks. Other questions. Councilmember Ruff.

02:27:02.626 --> 02:27:10.537
- I apologize if it was in the materials we've gotten. I just overlooked it. I didn't get an understanding

02:27:10.537 --> 02:27:16.414
- of it. But when there's a damaged card, it's always been a great service that

02:27:16.770 --> 02:27:23.549
- A new lid comes and is put on by our new that continues that's going to continue with at no charge at

02:27:23.549 --> 02:27:30.460
- no charge. So if you say with our automated equipment in particular the side loads with 35 gallon carts

02:27:30.460 --> 02:27:37.173
- they tend to cause the most issue for that. But yeah we would continue if we cause the damage. We're

02:27:37.173 --> 02:27:44.084
- going to go ahead and repair that through our as we do today. OK. Thank you. Final questions. OK. Thank

02:27:44.084 --> 02:27:46.078
- you very much Director Wason.

02:27:47.074 --> 02:27:58.065
- Council comments. Council Member Piedmont-Smith. I'm in favor of this proposal. I think it is more equitable

02:27:58.065 --> 02:28:08.249
- to not charge, okay, let me put it this way. Currently, a lot of residents of Bloomington are paying

02:28:08.249 --> 02:28:17.022
- into the general fund, which is providing $1.6 million a year for sanitation services.

02:28:17.122 --> 02:28:26.464
- But they are not benefiting from the curbside services, which is most of what our sanitation division

02:28:26.464 --> 02:28:36.172
- does. So I think it is more equitable to raise the amount of fees that are charged directly to the people

02:28:36.172 --> 02:28:45.331
- who benefit from the services. And I think it's very smart to also carve out that $200,000 to cover

02:28:45.331 --> 02:28:46.430
- the public,

02:28:47.394 --> 02:28:57.478
- of sanitation division that benefit everybody the downtown Trash cans the ones in the parks, etc So

02:28:57.478 --> 02:29:07.765
- I am in favor of the proposal. Thank you Thank you any other comments Okay, Oh councilmember Flaherty

02:29:07.765 --> 02:29:14.622
- I Brother agree with the councilmember Piedmont Smith. I I do think

02:29:15.490 --> 02:29:21.682
- a few things worth noting that I think were in the memo perhaps or have been discussed otherwise. But

02:29:21.682 --> 02:29:28.177
- even after these changes, the city sanitation services are below market rates. So you can't get sanitation

02:29:28.177 --> 02:29:34.490
- service this cheap from a private hauler. So that is true for roughly half of households in Bloomington

02:29:34.490 --> 02:29:40.682
- who don't get service from the city sanitation. And then additionally, I think the incremental nature

02:29:40.682 --> 02:29:44.446
- of it, we're talking about a couple of dollars a month change

02:29:45.026 --> 02:29:51.825
- You know, over the next three years each, I think I'm hopeful that in most circumstances that will not

02:29:51.825 --> 02:29:58.427
- stress people's finances in a way that makes a major difference. You know, again, we're talking one

02:29:58.427 --> 02:30:05.094
- to $4 a month difference for next year, for instance, relative to the baseline, similar in the years

02:30:05.094 --> 02:30:12.224
- to follow. But I'll also note that because we bill in a combined fashion with City of Bloomington Utilities

02:30:12.224 --> 02:30:13.214
- Water Service,

02:30:13.410 --> 02:30:19.292
- There is a program that's been refined and improved over recent years to provide billing assistance

02:30:19.292 --> 02:30:25.410
- for folks that are struggling to pay their utility bills. The trash bill is part of that bill for folks

02:30:25.410 --> 02:30:31.410
- that are struggling that is available and so wanting people to be aware of that and also just if they

02:30:31.410 --> 02:30:37.410
- need it but also aware of it as another effort the city makes to mitigate the inevitable impacts that

02:30:37.410 --> 02:30:41.822
- folks feel from what seem like endlessly rising costs that of course track

02:30:42.690 --> 02:30:49.312
- Costs that do indeed endlessly rise fuel costs and equipment costs and infrastructure and personnel

02:30:49.312 --> 02:30:55.934
- and all the rest So yeah, there's just a couple of things worth noting as well. Thank you Thank you

02:30:55.934 --> 02:31:02.821
- any final comments councilmember Stasberg I guess the thing that I'll tag on to that that I don't think

02:31:02.821 --> 02:31:09.310
- has mentioned yet like nobody really likes to increase fees but the other thing that I think is a

02:31:09.698 --> 02:31:18.779
- Valuable to think about in this context is that this fee is to literally Get rid of our trash and the

02:31:18.779 --> 02:31:27.682
- things that we use and I think that we should all kind of be paying that real cost for disposal and

02:31:27.682 --> 02:31:37.120
- it partly recognizes like and it forces hopefully individuals to recognize the true cost of items because

02:31:37.120 --> 02:31:38.366
- it's not just

02:31:38.530 --> 02:31:44.318
- the price that you pay at the store, it's also you have to get rid of the packaging or dispose of

02:31:44.386 --> 02:31:51.061
- whatever bits and pieces come with it, and that that is a piece of the true cost. And there's been a

02:31:51.061 --> 02:31:57.934
- lot of different environmental-based movements, bulk buying, for example, bulk grocery, filling up your

02:31:57.934 --> 02:32:04.873
- own jar, bringing your own bags to the grocery store. And then, of course, we have things like recycling

02:32:04.873 --> 02:32:08.574
- and trying to purchase things in recyclable containers.

02:32:08.642 --> 02:32:16.478
- Composting to try to reduce that overall load of what it is that we're putting in the in the cans on

02:32:16.478 --> 02:32:24.236
- the curb and so I You know you hate to raise prices on anything but I also have to kind of put some

02:32:24.236 --> 02:32:32.615
- place some value and importance on people actually having to pay the full price for those sorts of disposal

02:32:32.615 --> 02:32:38.046
- and understanding that it costs something to throw something away and

02:32:38.626 --> 02:32:44.936
- That's just reality. So thank you. Councilmember Rosenberger. I just wanted to give my first seven year

02:32:44.936 --> 02:32:51.064
- comment that pay as you throw is the best way to make people aware of actually what they're throwing

02:32:51.064 --> 02:32:57.252
- away. I know we're not doing that right now but what councilmember Stossberg just said as long as you

02:32:57.252 --> 02:32:58.526
- have a monthly rate.

02:32:59.234 --> 02:33:04.913
- You're not thinking about that so much because you're paying the same amount whether you buy all the

02:33:04.913 --> 02:33:10.704
- plastics and things at the grocery store, bring your own containers. But if you were to be charged for

02:33:10.704 --> 02:33:16.158
- every trash bag like we used to, then you might bring your own containers. That's it. Thank you.

02:33:16.158 --> 02:33:18.238
- Thank you. Council member Stossberg.

02:33:18.786 --> 02:33:27.345
- Would advocate that the system that we have does sort of encourage that and say that we are a household

02:33:27.345 --> 02:33:35.740
- of four to five depending on how many teenagers and our household manages to exist on the smallest of

02:33:35.740 --> 02:33:44.546
- the trash bins that the city provides and that That is kind of a choice that we make to be very deliberate

02:33:44.546 --> 02:33:47.838
- about how we're managing our belongings

02:33:47.938 --> 02:33:57.288
- So I would say that there is some element of pay as you throw right now in the choice of which trash

02:33:57.288 --> 02:34:06.824
- bin you get and seeking to reduce down to that lowest amount, which is, I mean, it's like $10 a month,

02:34:06.824 --> 02:34:16.267
- which is quite low in general. Would anyone else like to make a comment? Great. We're going to public

02:34:16.267 --> 02:34:17.470
- comment now?

02:34:18.018 --> 02:34:25.510
- Would anyone in chambers like to make a comment? You'll have three minutes. Anyone online? Great. Person

02:34:25.510 --> 02:34:32.717
- online, please unmute yourself and state your name for the record. You'll have three minutes. Hello,

02:34:32.717 --> 02:34:38.782
- my name is Sarah Wolford and I just wanted to thank Sanitation for all that they do.

02:34:38.882 --> 02:34:47.800
- My mom worked in sanitation for a while. Jane St. John was also involved in, or was in New York during

02:34:47.800 --> 02:34:56.459
- the sanitation strike. So I just think it's good to take a moment to appreciate the dirty work that

02:34:56.459 --> 02:34:59.230
- doesn't always get appreciated.

02:34:59.426 --> 02:35:09.620
- I also think it would be interesting to look into incentives to potentially downsize or a way to incentivize

02:35:09.620 --> 02:35:19.253
- downsizing your units right now. You have to pay a fee in order to swap if you are someone at a rental

02:35:19.253 --> 02:35:27.390
- and you want to like reduce or get a smaller one, you have to kind of coordinate that.

02:35:27.522 --> 02:35:34.291
- potentially looking into some way to incentivize people to downsize their trash, I think could

02:35:34.291 --> 02:35:41.702
- be interesting. And then just because it kind of involves a lot of people and a lot of things that have

02:35:41.702 --> 02:35:48.828
- been under discussion tonight, I just wanted to kind of highlight that Public Works actually owns a

02:35:48.828 --> 02:35:51.678
- vacant house at 2541 West Third Street.

02:35:52.258 --> 02:36:00.440
- and they've owned it since 2008. So I'm just also kind of, this kind of, I guess, references earlier

02:36:00.440 --> 02:36:08.621
- things talked about tonight, but I am just kind of curious how the city will handle vacancy fees for

02:36:08.621 --> 02:36:16.722
- their own properties. And yeah, anyway, that's all, thank you. Thank you very much. Is there anyone

02:36:16.722 --> 02:36:20.286
- else on Zoom who would like to speak? Okay.

02:36:20.482 --> 02:36:29.455
- Second person online, you will have three minutes. Please unmute yourself and state your name.

02:36:29.455 --> 02:36:38.994
- Is that me? Yes, we can hear you. OK, thank you. There's just no indication of the order. So anyway,

02:36:38.994 --> 02:36:48.439
- good evening. My name's Eric Gost, and I appreciate this opportunity to offer public comment on the

02:36:48.439 --> 02:36:49.950
- important topic

02:36:50.082 --> 02:36:56.836
- of the future of city sanitation services. Before approving the proposed sanitation rate increases,

02:36:56.836 --> 02:37:03.927
- which would recommend, I'm recommending that you continue this perhaps to another meeting, but certainly

02:37:03.927 --> 02:37:10.748
- there might be time before the next one. I urge you to consider a more comprehensive and potentially

02:37:10.748 --> 02:37:18.110
- more economical alternative, extending city sanitation services to all residential dwellings in Bloomington.

02:37:18.242 --> 02:37:24.639
- including larger apartment buildings, condominiums, and private street communities. The current proposal

02:37:24.639 --> 02:37:31.218
- would increase sanitation cart rates by approximately 48 percent over three years, principally to eliminate

02:37:31.218 --> 02:37:37.433
- the general fund operating subsidy. But it assumes that the city's existing service boundaries should

02:37:37.433 --> 02:37:43.525
- remain unchanged. There's been no publicly presented comprehensive financial analysis demonstrating

02:37:43.525 --> 02:37:48.094
- that this being the current proposal is the most economical way to provide

02:37:48.450 --> 02:37:57.242
- residential sanitation services. There might be alternatives. The city's registration rental data raises

02:37:57.242 --> 02:38:05.699
- important questions about the fairness and efficiency of the existing system. A preliminary analysis

02:38:05.699 --> 02:38:14.240
- identifies approximately 6,937 unique rental permits representing 29,175 rental units. Of these 6,379

02:38:14.240 --> 02:38:15.998
- permits representing

02:38:16.290 --> 02:38:24.309
- of these, excuse me, 6379 permits represent 7357 rental units involving properties containing four or

02:38:24.309 --> 02:38:32.327
- fewer units. The remaining 558 permits represent 21,818 units of larger rental properties. That means

02:38:32.327 --> 02:38:40.189
- approximately 25% of registered rental units are in the category of residents currently required to

02:38:40.189 --> 02:38:44.670
- pay the city sanitation services while approximately 75%

02:38:44.994 --> 02:38:51.023
- are in larger rental properties that are by the city's choice intentionally excluded from services.

02:38:51.023 --> 02:38:57.413
- This is important because the suggestion that homeowners receive subsidized city sanitation while renters

02:38:57.413 --> 02:39:03.683
- do not is simply incorrect. Many renters already receive city sanitation services. The real distinction

02:39:03.683 --> 02:39:09.833
- is based largely on building size and location, not on whether residents own or rent their homes. Why

02:39:09.833 --> 02:39:12.606
- should Bloomington continue excluding so much

02:39:12.834 --> 02:39:20.196
- of its residential housing for municipal collection without first determining whether universal service

02:39:20.196 --> 02:39:27.345
- would benefit the entire community. A preliminary financial model suggests that expanding collection

02:39:27.345 --> 02:39:34.637
- from approximately 14,700 existing municipal cart accounts to roughly 33,200 residential dwelling unit

02:39:34.637 --> 02:39:35.486
- equivalents

02:39:35.682 --> 02:39:42.249
- could reduce the average fully allocated costs from approximately $27.85 to $20.87 per month. It's about

02:39:42.249 --> 02:39:47.940
- a 25% reduction. The expansion could support approximately- Thank you very much, Mr. Post.

02:39:47.940 --> 02:39:53.881
- That is unfortunately your time. Okay, I apologize. I will submit the rest of this in writing.

02:39:53.881 --> 02:40:00.323
- Thank you. Thank you. Is there someone in chambers who would like to speak? You'll have three minutes.

02:40:00.323 --> 02:40:03.262
- Please state your name. This is Paul Rousseau.

02:40:04.418 --> 02:40:11.357
- At times like this, I wish that there was more than three minutes for some people. But I'm one of the

02:40:11.357 --> 02:40:18.160
- people who lives in the 75% of renters who do not get to recycle, because the landlord is not going

02:40:18.160 --> 02:40:25.100
- to pay for more than just they're required to do. At least that's my impression, because I live in my

02:40:25.100 --> 02:40:30.270
- neighborhood is in the stadium district, which is almost all large rentals.

02:40:30.754 --> 02:40:39.002
- What I can see day by day all I see are large bins and all that in the parking lots of all the large

02:40:39.002 --> 02:40:47.413
- apartment buildings and I Have a lifetime of experience of doing exactly what two council members here

02:40:47.413 --> 02:40:55.742
- talked about reducing my personal waste stream I Habitually reflexively separate plastic glass put it

02:40:55.742 --> 02:40:58.110
- on the refrigerator and then

02:40:58.818 --> 02:41:06.752
- After a couple weeks, I put it in a plastic bag, take it out to the dump, and dump it into the bin.

02:41:06.752 --> 02:41:14.924
- It doesn't get recycled. About 90% of my waste stream could be recycled. But it's not, because I don't

02:41:14.924 --> 02:41:22.859
- get that option. And you multiply my experience over, well, 20,000 people, something like that. And

02:41:22.859 --> 02:41:28.254
- so I strongly advocate extending the city program to all residents.

02:41:28.546 --> 02:41:38.171
- Other than that, I'm a little bit agnostic on whether pay as you go or the cart fees are more efficient.

02:41:38.171 --> 02:41:47.797
- But I do remember the pay as you go system when we had the stickers. Actually, I guess I'm not agnostic.

02:41:47.797 --> 02:41:56.414
- I think that we should use a pay as you go system that does not use stickers anymore but uses

02:41:56.578 --> 02:42:04.040
- Scannable carts and I think the previous speaker if he had been given more time could have given you

02:42:04.040 --> 02:42:11.502
- more details on that But that's all I have thank you, thank you, is there anyone else who would like

02:42:11.502 --> 02:42:19.260
- to speak on this Online okay. Great. Thank you very much at this time. I'll entertain a motion Ordinance

02:42:19.260 --> 02:42:23.102
- 2026 dash 41 to a second reading on December 2nd. I

02:42:24.994 --> 02:42:36.874
- There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Thank you. Will the clerk please call the roll?

02:42:36.874 --> 02:42:48.754
- clarity. Yes. Stasberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Vasari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff.

02:42:48.754 --> 02:42:52.638
- Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Thank you.

02:42:53.186 --> 02:42:58.358
- Thank you. That passes. We will continue this on December 2nd. Great. Thank you, council members. I

02:42:58.358 --> 02:43:03.685
- will just make a quick note. I likely will not be here on the second, but we'll have other public work

02:43:03.685 --> 02:43:08.856
- staff here with sanitation and our deputy director. So I appreciate you all. Thank you. Y'all heard

02:43:08.856 --> 02:43:14.235
- it here first. If you have questions for director Wason, submit them in writing by Tuesday at 12. Thank

02:43:14.235 --> 02:43:19.407
- you for being here. And now we have moved on to legislation for second readings and resolutions. Do

02:43:19.407 --> 02:43:20.286
- I hear a motion?

02:43:20.610 --> 02:43:29.593
- I move that resolution twenty twenty six dash twenty four be introduced and read by the clerk by title

02:43:29.593 --> 02:43:38.314
- and synopsis only. Okay. There's been a motion and a second. Do we have any discussion. Great. Will

02:43:38.314 --> 02:43:47.034
- the clerk please call the roll. Yes. Councilmember Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes.

02:43:47.034 --> 02:43:50.174
- Sorry. Yes. Daily. Yes. Rallo. Yes.

02:43:54.018 --> 02:44:17.470
- Rosenberger? Yes. And Flaherty? Yes. All right. Will the clerk please read by title and synopsis? Yes. Sorry.

02:44:19.106 --> 02:44:25.375
- Resolution 2026-24 to affirm the city of Bloomington as a welcoming and inclusive community for LGBTQ

02:44:25.375 --> 02:44:31.644
- plus residents and visitors and to reinforce local commitments to equal protection health care access

02:44:31.644 --> 02:44:37.790
- and human rights. The synopsis is as follows. Sponsored by council members Daly and Piedmont Smith.

02:44:38.274 --> 02:44:43.941
- No, my apologies, Zulek. This resolution affirms the city of Bloomington as a welcoming and inclusive

02:44:43.941 --> 02:44:49.997
- community for LGBTQ plus residents, workers and visitors, and reaffirms the city's commitments to protecting

02:44:49.997 --> 02:44:52.830
- their civil rights, equal protections and dignity.

02:44:52.962 --> 02:45:00.992
- Specifically, it reiterates Bloomington's gender-affirming health care policy, resolution 2024-09, upholds

02:45:00.992 --> 02:45:08.572
- non-discrimination protections across municipal operations, programs, and services, and recommits to

02:45:08.572 --> 02:45:16.077
- annual recognition of Transgender Day of Visibility, LGBTQ Plus Pride Month, and Transgender Day of

02:45:16.077 --> 02:45:21.630
- Remembrance. Oh, and the sponsors were Daley and Zulek. Sorry. All right.

02:45:22.274 --> 02:45:29.974
- Do I hear a motion? Thank you. I move that resolution 2026-24 be adopted. Second. All right. And just

02:45:29.974 --> 02:45:37.900
- to explain, the person presiding shouldn't be sponsoring the legislation, so that's why I have the gavel

02:45:37.900 --> 02:45:45.374
- for now. But council members Daley and Zulek, would you like to present? Yes. Thank you very much.

02:45:45.666 --> 02:45:53.780
- Okay, so in June of 2024, this council unanimously passed resolution 2024-09, declaring Bloomington

02:45:53.780 --> 02:46:02.057
- a safe haven for gender-affirming healthcare. And it was very meaningful, but a lot has changed since

02:46:02.057 --> 02:46:10.334
- then. We've seen more rollbacks and barriers put in place, and frankly, more hate impacting our LGBTQ

02:46:10.334 --> 02:46:12.606
- friends and family members.

02:46:12.994 --> 02:46:19.315
- and our communities. And this is 100% unacceptable. One of the most important things that we can do

02:46:19.315 --> 02:46:25.699
- as a community and as humans is to be a source of unconditional belonging. Everyone deserves a place

02:46:25.699 --> 02:46:32.019
- where they can simply live, thrive, and feel safe without having to constantly defend their rights.

02:46:32.019 --> 02:46:36.254
- So that is this promise that we want to keep alive in Bloomington.

02:46:36.994 --> 02:46:43.250
- So tonight, Councilmembers Zulik and I are proud to introduce a resolution that turns the promise of

02:46:43.250 --> 02:46:49.692
- our 2024 resolution into action. But before I give a quick walkthrough of it, I do want to take a pause

02:46:49.692 --> 02:46:56.010
- to extend a sincere thank you to Liliana Young. She drafted the initial text of this legislation, and

02:46:56.010 --> 02:47:02.204
- she brought it to Councilmembers Zulik and I for passage. So community-driven advocacy like hers is

02:47:02.204 --> 02:47:05.982
- the heartbeat of local government, and I'm greatly deep full

02:47:07.842 --> 02:47:15.539
- deeply grateful, let's just go with it, for her care initiative and her partnership. So tonight's resolution

02:47:15.539 --> 02:47:22.813
- builds directly on that foundation and on the vital proclamations that Mayor Thompson issued for Pride

02:47:22.813 --> 02:47:30.086
- Month of that year as well to meet the broader challenges of this moment though. So specifically, this

02:47:30.086 --> 02:47:33.758
- legislation commits our city to four clear actions.

02:47:33.890 --> 02:47:40.459
- Number one, it reaffirms our unwavering support for the civil rights, equal protections, and dignity

02:47:40.459 --> 02:47:47.354
- of all LGBTQ plus residents, workers, and visitors. It renews our commitment to our 2024 gender affirming

02:47:47.354 --> 02:47:53.858
- healthcare policy and upholds our local human rights ordinance across every municipal operation and

02:47:53.858 --> 02:48:00.752
- service. It locks in annual community visibility, committing the city to officially recognize and support

02:48:00.752 --> 02:48:03.614
- Transgender Day of Visibility, Pride Month,

02:48:04.002 --> 02:48:11.049
- and tomorrow's transgender day of remembrance for every single year moving forward. And it turns our

02:48:11.049 --> 02:48:18.026
- commitment outward, encouraging local schools, businesses, and other organizations to use our Human

02:48:18.026 --> 02:48:25.074
- Rights Commission as an educational resource while sending an unmistakable message to all LGBTQ plus

02:48:25.074 --> 02:48:32.051
- Hoosiers. Bloomington opens its doors, values your presence, and welcomes you home. So in a climate

02:48:32.051 --> 02:48:32.958
- of shifting,

02:48:33.186 --> 02:48:40.033
- state and federal policies, silence can create fear. By passing this resolution, we ensure that Bloomington

02:48:40.033 --> 02:48:46.373
- remains a steady beacon of safety, dignity, and true belonging for everyone who calls our community

02:48:46.373 --> 02:48:52.966
- home. And I'll pass it on over to Councilmember Zulek. Thank you. You covered that so well. I just have

02:48:52.966 --> 02:48:57.150
- a couple extra comments. So this past election cycle, we saw some

02:48:57.282 --> 02:49:04.390
- incredibly upsetting and disrespectful political ads attacking transgender people. Thankfully, we also

02:49:04.390 --> 02:49:11.361
- saw those ads backfire in a very substantial way on election night. And so I believe that now is the

02:49:11.361 --> 02:49:18.331
- time to reaffirm our solidarity with the LGBTQ plus community. We have also as a council spent quite

02:49:18.331 --> 02:49:25.854
- a bit of time over the past few months holding deliberation sessions on the council's role in public safety.

02:49:26.178 --> 02:49:33.155
- And one of the many things that we learned is that community and belonging actually do have a tangible

02:49:33.155 --> 02:49:40.268
- impact on how safe someone feels in our city. And I know that this resolution won't eradicate homophobia

02:49:40.268 --> 02:49:47.110
- or transphobia in our country or even in our city, but it is my hope that by passing this, our LGBTQ

02:49:47.110 --> 02:49:53.885
- plus siblings are reminded that Bloomington wants you here and that when we say public safety, your

02:49:53.885 --> 02:49:55.646
- safety is a part of that.

02:49:57.922 --> 02:50:05.939
- We are happy to answer any questions. Thank you, council sponsors, Daley and Zulek. Are there any questions

02:50:05.939 --> 02:50:13.659
- from colleagues? Council Member Stosberg. I do actually have one little question. Council Member Daley,

02:50:13.659 --> 02:50:21.379
- you were emphasizing in section four, like during your presentation, section four, kind of the official

02:50:21.379 --> 02:50:22.270
- recognition

02:50:22.466 --> 02:50:30.318
- recognition of those different observances does that change anything about how we're currently recognizing

02:50:30.318 --> 02:50:37.876
- those because I kind of feel like they already are official are they not actually official and we just

02:50:37.876 --> 02:50:45.214
- do it as far as I know it's not official part of the city calendar recognition okay thanks sponsors

02:50:50.338 --> 02:51:00.618
- I will just follow up on Council Member Stossberg's question. So what do you envision as the, how would

02:51:00.618 --> 02:51:10.601
- we annually recognize these, the Transgender Day of Visibility and Day of Remembrance? Would that be

02:51:10.601 --> 02:51:19.102
- some kind of a proclamation or what do you have in mind? Proclamation would be great.

02:51:19.330 --> 02:51:29.938
- city activities around any of them, officially recognizing, especially for Pride Month. I know we in

02:51:29.938 --> 02:51:40.651
- Bloomington celebrated in August. Typically, it's celebrated in June. I'd love to do both. I think in

02:51:40.651 --> 02:51:49.054
- a lot of ways, us re-establishing, hey, these are days that we celebrate and or

02:51:50.050 --> 02:51:57.970
- participate in, depending on the type of day. I know we have one day of remembrance. But also,

02:51:57.970 --> 02:52:06.556
- this year, Governor Braun established June as the nuclear family month. And so I know that that is not

02:52:06.556 --> 02:52:14.892
- something that any of us up here agree with. And I also know that not everyone in Bloomington might

02:52:14.892 --> 02:52:17.310
- know that, unless we say it.

02:52:17.410 --> 02:52:24.993
- part of this vote is to say, you know what, actually June is for Pride Month, and in Bloomington so

02:52:24.993 --> 02:52:32.652
- is August, and the rest of the year. Thank you. All right, any other questions or any comments from,

02:52:32.652 --> 02:52:40.613
- oh no, we'll just do questions, sorry. Yes, Council Member Stossberg. I do have a question then in light

02:52:40.613 --> 02:52:45.694
- of some of that answer and realizing that in section four it says,

02:52:46.082 --> 02:52:55.142
- Pride month in August specifically So I assume that that was deliberate or do you I mean do you because

02:52:55.142 --> 02:53:03.941
- August isn't actually pride month, but that's when we celebrate pride So is that phrase the best way

02:53:03.941 --> 02:53:12.478
- that we want to phrase that right now I guess Would you like to bring forward an amendment well I

02:53:13.346 --> 02:53:20.874
- I just want to make sure that we're not locking into something that we don't really want to lock into

02:53:20.874 --> 02:53:28.254
- in terms of that idea of celebrating Pride Month in June and August. So are we saying we definitely

02:53:28.254 --> 02:53:35.635
- want to celebrate in August, and then maybe we'll celebrate in June later? I was also being mindful

02:53:35.635 --> 02:53:41.982
- when we were working through this resolution to not overreach or overextend to create

02:53:44.738 --> 02:53:54.580
- I thought this was a good place to start. Honestly, yeah, I'll leave it at that. OK. As long as everybody

02:53:54.580 --> 02:54:03.958
- else feels good about that language, I'm good. All right. If there are no other questions, we can go

02:54:03.958 --> 02:54:13.150
- to public comment. Is there anybody in the public who would like to comment on resolution 2026-24?

02:54:14.434 --> 02:54:21.823
- we'll start here in council chambers. Please go ahead, state your name for the record and you'll have

02:54:21.823 --> 02:54:29.067
- up to three minutes. Good evening council and for the record, I am Liliana Young. I am the chair of

02:54:29.067 --> 02:54:36.601
- the Bloomington DSA Stonewall Working Group that put this resolution in front of the council. The LGBTQ

02:54:36.601 --> 02:54:42.686
- community has been under cultural and legal assault for decades. Indeed, even after

02:54:42.914 --> 02:54:51.385
- advancements in social acceptance and marriage equality and baseline employment and housing protections

02:54:51.385 --> 02:54:59.530
- and health care access we have still seen in this recent era an erosion of these things or Promises

02:54:59.530 --> 02:55:07.757
- from some of the nation's most powerful people to erode them This council does not have the power to

02:55:07.757 --> 02:55:09.630
- repair that damage and

02:55:11.394 --> 02:55:20.722
- My own immediate community, transgender people, have been facing the brunt of this for the last decade,

02:55:20.722 --> 02:55:29.782
- a sustained campaign to vilify and demonize us and paint us as the nation's most destabilizing force

02:55:29.782 --> 02:55:31.486
- in modern history.

02:55:34.562 --> 02:55:41.774
- funded by arch conservative billionaires and perpetuated by Republican politicians, both nationally

02:55:41.774 --> 02:55:49.563
- and right here in our home state. And this council does not have the wealth to combat that unequal footing.

02:55:49.563 --> 02:55:57.135
- Truly things have deteriorated so heavily and so quickly for trans people that simply being openly trans

02:55:57.135 --> 02:56:01.246
- in this modern era imposes a stress and a danger upon us

02:56:01.474 --> 02:56:09.491
- that the cisgender people in this room are fundamentally incapable of understanding, but know that when

02:56:09.491 --> 02:56:17.277
- we are beaten half to death in public restrooms, that when we are murdered in the supposed safety of

02:56:17.277 --> 02:56:25.140
- our apartment laundry rooms, and when right here in Bloomington, one of our own was seconds away from

02:56:25.140 --> 02:56:31.230
- being physically attacked in a women's locker room, that when I leave my home,

02:56:31.362 --> 02:56:39.415
- To do this kind of advocacy for the basic dignity of my people that might be the last day I see my own

02:56:39.415 --> 02:56:47.546
- wife and my child and This council does not have the power to restore that safety for everyone But what

02:56:47.546 --> 02:56:55.833
- this council does have the power to do is to declare with us? loudly and proudly that here in Bloomington

02:56:55.833 --> 02:57:00.446
- we celebrate curiosity and differences and science that in

02:57:00.706 --> 02:57:10.155
- Bloomington, all members of the LGBTQ community will find dignity and inclusion no matter who's in charge

02:57:10.155 --> 02:57:19.248
- of the state government or federal government, and that this city will help continue to advance queer

02:57:19.248 --> 02:57:28.252
- liberation, not just through pretty words, but also further policy to come. And we invite you to use

02:57:28.252 --> 02:57:30.302
- that power. Thank you.

02:57:33.346 --> 02:57:41.551
- Next speaker here in chambers, please. Hello. My name is Jordan Connor, a relatively recent transplantee

02:57:41.551 --> 02:57:49.444
- into Bloomington. And I felt in my time here that Bloomington feels accepting of all different types

02:57:49.444 --> 02:57:57.336
- of people. And that's one thing that makes me really proud to get so invested into the community. So

02:57:57.336 --> 02:58:02.494
- a resolution like this would really mean a lot to me to see pass.

02:58:02.850 --> 02:58:11.850
- I also think that it would be an excellent first step in the continuing progress of defending our LGBTQ

02:58:11.850 --> 02:58:20.677
- plus populace and would love to see this set the groundwork for future ordinances and activities that

02:58:20.677 --> 02:58:28.638
- would continue to make tangible beneficial change in our community. So thank you very much.

02:58:34.562 --> 02:58:41.199
- One more here in chambers and then we'll check online. Good evening, y'all. My name is Kate Lubbin.

02:58:41.199 --> 02:58:46.974
- I'm a social worker. I'm transgender. I'm speaking in favor of the resolution tonight.

02:58:47.042 --> 02:58:52.566
- I just want to thank Council Member Daley and Zulik for sponsoring this. Now, a little bit of history

02:58:52.566 --> 02:58:58.091
- about me. I first moved to Bloomington 10 years ago. Before that, I was living in rural Texas, and it

02:58:58.091 --> 02:59:03.561
- wasn't long after moving here that I realized that a certain weight had been lifted off of my chest.

02:59:03.561 --> 02:59:09.194
- Now, I realized that the dread and fear that I had been living with, the fear that someone would follow

02:59:09.194 --> 02:59:14.014
- me home to attack me or that I would be suddenly fired just for being myself was lifted.

02:59:14.146 --> 02:59:20.575
- That is to say, in short, I felt a sense of belonging. In short order, Bloomington became my home. And

02:59:20.575 --> 02:59:26.817
- that is a beautiful feeling to feel a sense of belonging and a sense of being at home. But more and

02:59:26.817 --> 02:59:33.122
- more each day, people like me see the communities in which they live become less and less like home.

02:59:33.122 --> 02:59:39.613
- They see ads on TV. They see statements from politicians vilifying their existence. They see assemblies

02:59:39.613 --> 02:59:42.110
- trying to make their existence illegal.

02:59:43.138 --> 02:59:48.841
- That is, until one day these people decide that they have had enough and they pack their things,

02:59:48.841 --> 02:59:54.780
- they leave, just like I did from my community in Texas. I recognize that this city council's options

02:59:54.780 --> 03:00:01.012
- are limited when it comes to pushing back against a state and federal government who would like to remove

03:00:01.012 --> 03:00:07.009
- people like me from society. But what this council can do is to make it clear to all that Bloomington

03:00:07.009 --> 03:00:10.302
- is a safe place, a community where everyone is welcome.

03:00:10.850 --> 03:00:16.486
- Let us remember that inclusion benefits everyone. When people are driven out, as council member Daley

03:00:16.486 --> 03:00:22.178
- mentioned, these are our family members, these are our friends, these are our community members, these

03:00:22.178 --> 03:00:27.704
- are our neighbors. These are real people who could otherwise help us create a beautiful and vibrant

03:00:27.704 --> 03:00:32.732
- community together. Let us ensure that there is no doubt in anyone's mind, all are welcome

03:00:32.732 --> 03:00:36.766
- here in Bloomington. I urge you all to vote in favor of this resolution.

03:00:41.314 --> 03:00:48.608
- Thank you. Is there anybody on Zoom who has their hand raised? No? Okay. Well, we can continue here

03:00:48.608 --> 03:00:56.047
- in council chambers. There's another person who would like to comment. Hi, Paul Russo. I'll just make

03:00:56.047 --> 03:01:03.706
- it brief. If I had seen a resolution like this a year ago, I thought maybe it would be gilding the lily,

03:01:03.706 --> 03:01:10.270
- because it seems to me that Bloomington, of course, is the oasis that we all think it is.

03:01:11.778 --> 03:01:20.332
- In July, a woman at the First United Church was attacked while she was gardening. And it was covered

03:01:20.332 --> 03:01:29.140
- in the B Square bulletin. She was attacked for her color and for being lesbian. And it kind of reminded

03:01:29.140 --> 03:01:37.610
- us that you can't let your guard down. So if nothing else, a resolution like this reminds us of who

03:01:37.610 --> 03:01:40.574
- we really are. And it's important.

03:01:41.698 --> 03:01:50.474
- While I'm at it, I'd like to give a plug for the Coriolan Men's Chorus. They're having their 25th anniversary

03:01:50.474 --> 03:01:58.930
- this year, one of the largest, longest-standing gay men's choruses. And their concert will be the weekend

03:01:58.930 --> 03:02:06.270
- before Christmas, 19th and 20th. Thank you. Would anybody else in chambers like to comment?

03:02:20.098 --> 03:02:26.683
- Hi, Joshua Stockton. I would just like to start off by saying I want to thank everyone for showing up

03:02:26.683 --> 03:02:33.268
- today, especially my queer siblings. I did want to comment specifically on the policy itself. I think

03:02:33.268 --> 03:02:39.724
- it would be perfectly fine to have Pride in August. I gave it some thought while sitting there, and

03:02:39.724 --> 03:02:45.534
- I was like, I think it'll get more attention. I frankly think it would get more attention

03:02:46.274 --> 03:02:52.408
- broadly, if we have it in Pride Month. And I think it also makes sense for our community, too, because

03:02:52.408 --> 03:02:58.364
- August is a welcoming time in Bloomington. Historically, June has been Pride Month because of queer

03:02:58.364 --> 03:03:04.439
- liberation in New York City. But I think having it in August would also make a statement about who we

03:03:04.439 --> 03:03:10.692
- are. It doesn't really matter what time of the year we do it. It just matters that we do it. And I think

03:03:10.692 --> 03:03:12.062
- more importantly, it's

03:03:12.706 --> 03:03:18.490
- important that we have transgender day of remembrance and trans visibility day even more than we have

03:03:18.490 --> 03:03:24.275
- pride month because those are the people who have really fought for my rights and for everyone else's

03:03:24.275 --> 03:03:30.003
- rights too. So I also have to say the city needs to follow up with it. If we are going to do this as

03:03:30.003 --> 03:03:35.844
- a thing we need to be sending out those emails. We need to be printing out the papers and posting them

03:03:35.844 --> 03:03:41.118
- in the staff lounge and out where the public is. We need to also have events like we need to

03:03:41.698 --> 03:03:48.039
- have a meeting, a gathering, something where we can actually remember, we can actually see visibility.

03:03:48.039 --> 03:03:54.319
- Because since moving here in 2020, I've seen the visibility diminish. I've watched it. The way people

03:03:54.319 --> 03:04:00.538
- interact, the clothes they wear, the way they cut their hair or dye it, it truly has changed. And it

03:04:00.538 --> 03:04:06.879
- has diminished. And that's what we're fighting for today is against that. We will be out here. We will

03:04:06.879 --> 03:04:10.142
- be ourselves. And we will be queer. Thank you, guys.

03:04:15.234 --> 03:04:23.970
- Anybody else in council chambers, please come to the microphone. Hello, my name is Kip Reedlove. I've

03:04:23.970 --> 03:04:32.706
- lived in Bloomington for about eight years since 2019, and I fell in love with the community and with

03:04:32.706 --> 03:04:41.613
- Indiana, but I'm not really in love with the hate that is enshrined an hour north in Indianapolis every

03:04:41.613 --> 03:04:43.326
- day at the Capitol.

03:04:43.874 --> 03:04:52.282
- So I just want to urge you to please vote yes on this ordinance. I don't want my queer friends such

03:04:52.282 --> 03:05:01.111
- as Kate who spoke tonight to have to leave Bloomington because that would only make the community worse.

03:05:01.111 --> 03:05:10.024
- And also I'd like to note for the record that Trans Remembrance Day is not tomorrow, it's Friday. Anyway,

03:05:10.024 --> 03:05:12.126
- thank you for your time.

03:05:13.378 --> 03:05:22.277
- Thank you. I apologize. It's the 20th. You're absolutely right. I thought today was the 19th. Not bad.

03:05:22.277 --> 03:05:31.089
- Is there anybody online now? Yes. And Clerk Bolden. OK, let's go to the person online, and then we'll

03:05:31.089 --> 03:05:39.729
- go to Clerk Bolden. So individual who has raised their hand online, you should be unmuted and ready

03:05:39.729 --> 03:05:41.630
- to give us your name.

03:05:42.914 --> 03:05:54.597
- Hello, this is Sarah Wilford again. I just wanted to thank members of council for putting this forward

03:05:54.597 --> 03:06:06.393
- and I lend my support and also kind of echo earlier comments on how I think this is a great. Oh, Sarah,

03:06:06.393 --> 03:06:08.094
- are you there?

03:06:11.010 --> 03:06:22.707
- accepting values, but I also think we need to continue. You are going in and out. Oh, it's the zoom.

03:06:22.707 --> 03:06:34.751
- The moment that we think that it's okay to kind of take a pause or take a break is when our adversaries

03:06:34.751 --> 03:06:40.542
- take advantage of that and start to work to limit

03:06:40.834 --> 03:06:49.556
- limit our freedoms. So I think this is a great first step, but I also look forward to further measures

03:06:49.556 --> 03:06:58.193
- to help protect our LGBTQ family and community. Thanks. Thank you. Clerk Polden, did you want to make

03:06:58.193 --> 03:07:06.661
- a statement? Thank you. I wanted to say thank you to council members Daley and Zulek for taking the

03:07:06.661 --> 03:07:10.302
- language that had been proposed by Liliana

03:07:10.402 --> 03:07:21.216
- and putting forth a resolution. I do appreciate it. This is Loomington. We're a town of extremes at

03:07:21.216 --> 03:07:33.002
- times. And being in a community that tries to affirm and recognize our marginalized communities is something

03:07:33.002 --> 03:07:39.166
- I'm grateful for as a black LGBTQ plus community member.

03:07:40.482 --> 03:07:47.663
- I am fully aware of the hostility and discrimination and high rates of violence towards our community,

03:07:47.663 --> 03:07:54.914
- particularly our black trans community. And so I say thank you for this resolution. I think it's a very

03:07:54.914 --> 03:08:02.513
- good step. I would love to see the city actually pursue further measures, including gender neutral bathrooms

03:08:02.513 --> 03:08:09.694
- and other things that we could do, at least in our city buildings, if not citywide for all businesses.

03:08:10.338 --> 03:08:18.004
- And to those who showed up tonight and spoke, I say thank you. Again, it's nice to see you in the room.

03:08:18.004 --> 03:08:25.448
- I hope you show up more. And that is all. Thank you. Thank you. Last call, would anybody else in the

03:08:25.448 --> 03:08:33.114
- council chambers like to make a comment? Is there anybody else online? All right. Thank you. We'll come

03:08:33.114 --> 03:08:40.190
- back to council members. Would any council member like to make a comment? Council member Zulek.

03:08:41.058 --> 03:08:47.138
- Thank you. I just want to thank Liliana, who we've had the pleasure of working with on this resolution,

03:08:47.138 --> 03:08:52.985
- and also thank everyone who came to speak today. I know it's no small thing to come up here and put

03:08:52.985 --> 03:08:59.241
- your name on the public record and say what you need to say about your own safety. Advocating for yourself

03:08:59.241 --> 03:09:05.146
- is probably one of the scariest things you can do, especially as a young person. And so thank you. I

03:09:05.146 --> 03:09:08.478
- hope that you pat yourself on the back when you go home.

03:09:10.978 --> 03:09:16.731
- Councilmember Daly. I had a whole bunch more that I had written up that I was going to say, but you

03:09:16.731 --> 03:09:22.598
- guys don't need more flowery words. I already said some. But I do just want to make sure that I thank

03:09:22.598 --> 03:09:28.466
- everybody who did show up tonight and echo Councilmember Zulek's comments and Clerk Bolden's comments

03:09:28.466 --> 03:09:34.334
- about showing up and making comment that is incredibly impactful and very valuable. And I just wanted

03:09:34.334 --> 03:09:39.166
- to say that Bloomington sees you, we value you, and we welcome you home. Thank you.

03:09:41.986 --> 03:09:51.870
- Any other council member comments? I will just say that I appreciate my colleagues bringing this forward.

03:09:51.870 --> 03:10:01.288
- I appreciate Ms. Young for working on it and the whole working group that she's part of. And I agree

03:10:01.288 --> 03:10:11.358
- with Clerk Bolden that one important step we could take is gender neutral restrooms, at least in City Hall,

03:10:11.522 --> 03:10:19.210
- all city buildings. This is something that I've been thinking about for a while. In addition, we need

03:10:19.210 --> 03:10:27.275
- to make sure that all of our ordinances have gender neutral language. One of the ordinances we had tonight

03:10:27.275 --> 03:10:35.340
- for first reading, I think it was the one about Title VI, had some phrase about how the masculine language

03:10:35.340 --> 03:10:38.430
- shall also refer to the feminine and the

03:10:38.626 --> 03:10:45.983
- plural shall also refer to the singular or something like this. I'm like, no, that is not sufficient,

03:10:45.983 --> 03:10:53.629
- and I will be authoring an amendment to change that. That's just lazy. I mean, we can change the language

03:10:53.629 --> 03:11:00.987
- to they, them. It's just a matter of common sense and being inclusive, and that's what we need to do.

03:11:00.987 --> 03:11:07.262
- We represent everybody in the community, and we value everybody's voice. So with that,

03:11:07.458 --> 03:11:18.014
- There are no other comments. I'm looking up there. We can go for a roll call vote, please.

03:11:18.014 --> 03:11:29.266
- Well, Councilmember Piedmont-Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Daly. Oh, no. I'm sorry. Sorry. First. Yes.

03:11:29.266 --> 03:11:34.718
- Thank you. Daly. Yes. Morello. Yes. Ruff. Yes.

03:11:35.138 --> 03:11:46.735
- Rosenberger yes clarity yes and Stasberg yes thank you that passes unanimously thank you all right on

03:11:46.735 --> 03:11:55.262
- to our next piece of legislation do I hear any word I'm sorry do I hear it

03:11:55.490 --> 03:12:03.552
- Yes. Council member Stasberg. I would like to make a motion to suspend the rules and amend the agenda

03:12:03.552 --> 03:12:11.535
- and move ordinance twenty twenty six thirty one which is item C under second readings resolutions up

03:12:11.535 --> 03:12:19.440
- so that we hear it right now. So basically switching B and C. OK. There's been a motion. Is there a

03:12:19.440 --> 03:12:22.206
- second second. OK. Any discussion.

03:12:24.226 --> 03:12:34.509
- Councilmember Stasberg, can you send that to me in writing, please? I love it. I'm sorry, what? Will

03:12:34.509 --> 03:12:44.793
- you please send that to me in writing? Oh, yeah. Thank you. OK. And no discussion, so will the clerk

03:12:44.793 --> 03:12:53.854
- please call the roll? Yes, one moment, please. That's not going to work. I'm sorry? Yes.

03:12:54.498 --> 03:13:06.174
- Daily? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stosberg? Yes. And Piedmont-Smith?

03:13:06.174 --> 03:13:18.304
- Yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. That passes. And so now, ordinance 2026-31 will come before ordinance

03:13:18.304 --> 03:13:20.798
- 2026-27. Any motions?

03:13:24.258 --> 03:13:34.481
- Sorry. Oh, yes. I move that ordinance 2026-31 be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis

03:13:34.481 --> 03:13:44.312
- only. Second. OK. There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Thank you. Will the clerk

03:13:44.312 --> 03:13:54.142
- please call the roll? Councilmember Asari? Yes. Daly? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes.

03:13:54.306 --> 03:14:05.928
- Clarity. Stasberg. Yes. Piedmont-Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Thank you. Passes. Will the clerk please read?

03:14:05.928 --> 03:14:10.622
- This is 2026-31, correct? Yes. Thank you.

03:14:15.842 --> 03:14:23.041
- Ordinance 2026-31, UDO amendments related to housing attainability. The synopsis is as follows. This

03:14:23.041 --> 03:14:30.383
- ordinance contains amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance to amend the use specific standards

03:14:30.383 --> 03:14:37.654
- regulating the use dwelling accessory unit, dwelling cottage home, dwelling duplex, dwelling triplex,

03:14:37.654 --> 03:14:42.430
- and dwelling fourplex. The council sponsor is Stasburg. Thank you.

03:14:43.618 --> 03:14:53.553
- Since twenty twenty six dash thirty one be adopted second Okay, who is here to present please state

03:14:53.553 --> 03:15:03.487
- your name and go ahead Thank you very much Eric Grulick development services manager so I'm here to

03:15:03.487 --> 03:15:09.150
- present or just kind of give a brief overview of what we

03:15:09.378 --> 03:15:16.004
- Discussed about two weeks ago regarding this series of amendments to the UDO. So this is the third series

03:15:16.004 --> 03:15:22.318
- of amendments that the department kind of brought forward starting several months ago. Some of these

03:15:22.318 --> 03:15:28.756
- were just following up on items within the UDO that we had highlighted a while ago earlier in the last

03:15:28.756 --> 03:15:29.694
- year actually.

03:15:29.858 --> 03:15:36.229
- Um, look at what we can do to improve housing attainability within the community. Um, some of these

03:15:36.229 --> 03:15:42.664
- were also then, um, or we're also folded into some changes that the state brought forward in a house

03:15:42.664 --> 03:15:49.417
- bill 10 0 1 directing communities to look at certain aspects of their zoning codes that are, um, possibly

03:15:49.417 --> 03:15:51.838
- holding back housing, um, looking at,

03:15:51.970 --> 03:15:58.968
- Diversifying the use table. So we had identified a couple things within the UDO related to accessory

03:15:58.968 --> 03:16:05.896
- dwelling units cottage homes and duplexes and triplexes So we brought forward some amendments these

03:16:05.896 --> 03:16:13.032
- were heard at the Playing Commission So when House Bill 1001 was coming forward and moving through the

03:16:13.032 --> 03:16:19.198
- legislation last year there were some broad series of initiatives within there that were

03:16:19.298 --> 03:16:25.405
- going to possibly come forward. Some of those played out some of those didn't. One of the things that

03:16:25.405 --> 03:16:31.572
- was incorporated within there was a definition a new definition for accessory dwelling units that gave

03:16:31.572 --> 03:16:37.738
- a certain size as the department had looked at and considered modifying some of the accessory dwelling

03:16:37.738 --> 03:16:43.725
- unit standards. We saw this as a good opportunity to sink our definition of an ADU with the state's

03:16:43.725 --> 03:16:49.054
- definition and also give a slight increase with the size of the accessory dwelling unit.

03:16:49.154 --> 03:16:56.455
- So the legislation that came forward with HB 10 0 1 as I mentioned give that no definition that said

03:16:56.455 --> 03:17:03.901
- 80 use could be no more than a thousand square feet or 75 percent of a dwelling unit. So we're sinking

03:17:03.901 --> 03:17:11.203
- our language with that with this as I mentioned we had highlighted some things with a use within the

03:17:11.203 --> 03:17:11.998
- UDL called

03:17:12.162 --> 03:17:18.122
- cottage home developments. So cottage home development is something that doesn't get used very much.

03:17:18.122 --> 03:17:19.774
- In fact, we've only had one

03:17:19.842 --> 03:17:26.675
- petition come forward with that and so some of the restrictions within those density standards were

03:17:26.675 --> 03:17:33.577
- certainly seen as a hindrance some of the other standards regarding buffering and setbacks also kind

03:17:33.577 --> 03:17:40.479
- of created challenges with use utilizing those incentives within the UDO so we've proposed modifying

03:17:40.479 --> 03:17:46.014
- those density allowances to give a greater likelihood of those being implemented

03:17:46.082 --> 03:17:53.595
- And then for duplexes and triplexes We had identified a couple things within there that that we could

03:17:53.595 --> 03:18:01.034
- look at Loosening or removing to help try to make these a little bit more attainable as well some of

03:18:01.034 --> 03:18:08.767
- the things that are in the UDO that regulate those are the use specific standards and then also a number

03:18:08.767 --> 03:18:11.198
- a maximum number of accessory of

03:18:11.554 --> 03:18:18.102
- Duplexes that can be approved within a year and then there is a 150 foot buffer that is created around

03:18:18.102 --> 03:18:24.524
- any approved duplexes for two years So we had highlighted the last two there The maximum number that

03:18:24.524 --> 03:18:30.945
- could be done per calendar year and then also the buffer as two possible things that we could remove

03:18:30.945 --> 03:18:36.158
- And then in regards to the use specific standards as we have gone through several

03:18:37.122 --> 03:18:43.722
- Petitions of those one of the the key elements that we do always make sure to evaluate when they there

03:18:43.722 --> 03:18:50.385
- are four elements Let me rephrase that back up a little bit. There are four you specific standards that

03:18:50.385 --> 03:18:56.921
- govern duplexes Those are roof pitch front porch width and depth front building setback and vehicular

03:18:56.921 --> 03:19:01.598
- access that the you specific standards say that those elements should be

03:19:01.698 --> 03:19:08.551
- Similar to a majority of the structures on a block face in regards to the the roof pitch. We have also

03:19:08.551 --> 03:19:15.404
- always Interpreted that to mean roof orientation. So roof pitch and orientation are very intrinsically

03:19:15.404 --> 03:19:22.258
- designed and so we we are adding language to the roof pitch to just supplement to say that Orientation

03:19:22.258 --> 03:19:28.978
- is also an element of that as well. So that's just kind of following up with our our common practice

03:19:28.978 --> 03:19:30.974
- and so as I mentioned we also

03:19:31.106 --> 03:19:38.846
- proposing to remove the cap, the maximum number 15 that are allowed per year and the 150 foot buffer.

03:19:38.946 --> 03:19:45.157
- And then also there was a standard associated with triplexes and fourplexes That restricted those to

03:19:45.157 --> 03:19:51.367
- only one or I'm sorry two entrances for the building as a whole And then it did create challenges in

03:19:51.367 --> 03:19:57.640
- situations where somebody wanted to town Turn those into townhomes and couldn't have a door for every

03:19:57.640 --> 03:20:03.789
- unit that was in there So we saw that as a hindrance as well. And so we're proposing to remove that

03:20:03.789 --> 03:20:07.294
- So the Planning Commission did hear this in their septum

03:20:07.426 --> 03:20:15.942
- September meeting sorry, it's been a while and voted to send this to you Five oh, I believe so with

03:20:15.942 --> 03:20:24.543
- that I'm here to have any happy to answer any questions. Thank you I think there are two amendments.

03:20:24.543 --> 03:20:33.229
- Would it make more sense to propose those first? Councilmember Piedmont Smith Yes So I move amendment

03:20:33.229 --> 03:20:35.358
- one to ordinance 2026-31

03:20:38.562 --> 03:20:48.346
- There's been a, so this is brought forward by myself and council members Rallo and Ruff and it basically

03:20:48.346 --> 03:20:58.317
- eliminates two paragraphs that are proposed to be changed by the ordinance. So it eliminates those changes

03:20:58.317 --> 03:21:06.238
- and they are about the maximum number of approved duplex dwellings in R1, R2 and R3.

03:21:06.786 --> 03:21:16.033
- shall be 15 per year. We want to keep that in there. The 150-foot buffer shall be created around the

03:21:16.033 --> 03:21:25.188
- approved duplex dwelling in R1, R2, and R3 zoning districts. We want to keep that in there as well.

03:21:25.188 --> 03:21:34.526
- My rationale, and I welcome my co-sponsors, of course, to talk as well, but my main rationale is that

03:21:35.810 --> 03:21:42.227
- The main argument in favor of allowing duplexes in R1, R2, and R3 zoning districts in 2021 was that

03:21:42.227 --> 03:21:48.837
- higher density housing in these districts would bring down housing prices. But what I've actually seen

03:21:48.837 --> 03:21:55.447
- occurring in my district is that old affordable rental homes have been torn down and replaced with new

03:21:55.447 --> 03:21:57.950
- duplexes with much higher lease rates.

03:21:58.850 --> 03:22:04.955
- In addition, the replacement of single-family homes with duplexes has led to a shortage of on-street

03:22:04.955 --> 03:22:11.060
- parking in some neighborhoods that has not been adequately addressed through changes in city policy.

03:22:11.060 --> 03:22:17.527
- So that's my presentation. Councilmembers Ruffin, Rollo? If there's anything to add. I don't have anything

03:22:17.527 --> 03:22:24.478
- to add, but I want to thank Councilmember Piemont-Smith for taking the initiative to bring this amendment forward.

03:22:30.018 --> 03:22:39.115
- Yeah, I just would like to thank my colleague, too, for bringing it forward. I feared what I've seen

03:22:39.115 --> 03:22:48.121
- happen, which is conversion of small single-family homes, including ones that are rental, that have

03:22:48.121 --> 03:22:57.758
- been perplexed, which increases density, but it doesn't address affordability. And so the affordability is

03:22:58.754 --> 03:23:10.204
- has not manifested. And so I would be, I think it's consistent to say that that number of approvals

03:23:10.204 --> 03:23:21.997
- shouldn't change because we would just expedite the process. That's all. Thank you. And I do just want

03:23:21.997 --> 03:23:26.462
- to let everyone know that an amendment

03:23:26.658 --> 03:23:37.922
- could possibly send the ordinance back to Plan Commission for an automatic 45-day kickback. And I'm

03:23:37.922 --> 03:23:49.411
- hoping that Attorney Rossman can provide a little more detail. I'd be happy to. Thank you. This is an

03:23:49.411 --> 03:23:54.142
- openly good question tonight. Here's why.

03:23:54.530 --> 03:24:05.965
- Under the traditional planning law, Indiana Code 36-7-4-607, amending a favorably certified zoning proposal

03:24:05.965 --> 03:24:16.552
- requires a mandatory 45-day return to plan commission. However, recent state statutory updates have

03:24:16.552 --> 03:24:23.646
- created some ambiguity. Our code hasn't been updated, and our code

03:24:23.874 --> 03:24:36.944
- references the old Indiana code is my understanding. Also our UDO is a question as well. I'm not able

03:24:36.944 --> 03:24:49.758
- to provide a formal opinion tonight on how the latest state statute reconciles with our local code.

03:24:50.274 --> 03:24:58.354
- Uh, I couldn't guarantee that adopting amendment one will allow final passage tonight. Okay. Thank you.

03:24:58.354 --> 03:25:06.201
- The sponsors of the amendment like to respond to that and or do you have any thoughts? Well, it's my

03:25:06.201 --> 03:25:14.203
- understanding that it's always been the case. If we amend something that plan commission brings to us,

03:25:14.203 --> 03:25:18.942
- they have a certain time period to accept it or override it.

03:25:19.778 --> 03:25:30.713
- So I don't see that this is any different. Okay. Are there any questions for sponsors for Amendment

03:25:30.713 --> 03:25:41.648
- 1? Okay. We'll go to public comment. Would any member of the public like to comment in chambers? Go

03:25:41.648 --> 03:25:48.318
- right ahead. Please state your name. Is there anyone online?

03:25:56.834 --> 03:26:03.095
- Because I'm the only one left at 10 o'clock. Yes. Yes strongly support the amendment for the reasons

03:26:03.095 --> 03:26:09.356
- cited I Talked to the people at 614 grant the end of the spring semester and they were four students

03:26:09.356 --> 03:26:15.741
- renting a four-bedroom house for $2,200 that's five hundred and fifty dollars a piece and then in this

03:26:15.741 --> 03:26:21.941
- fall in August or September I talked to the Students across the street and they thought they have a

03:26:21.941 --> 03:26:26.590
- good deal because they're renting at $1,200 a bedroom new construction and

03:26:27.330 --> 03:26:37.200
- And their neighbors are paying $1,600 a month. It's anecdotal, I know. But I support this. Thank you.

03:26:37.200 --> 03:26:46.585
- Thank you. Looks like we have one more person in chambers. Anybody online? OK, great. Thank you.

03:26:46.585 --> 03:26:55.294
- Go ahead. Hi, Joshua Stockton again. I would say I do support this, a personal testimony.

03:26:55.682 --> 03:27:02.759
- Lot across the street from me a home was just demolished. It was a two bedroom home. I was older in

03:27:02.759 --> 03:27:09.837
- the community built 1930s. The units were about five to six hundred dollars a month per bedroom. So

03:27:09.837 --> 03:27:17.268
- about twelve hundred dollars a month. But in my neighborhood this is a lot of what we're seeing is homes

03:27:17.268 --> 03:27:22.718
- being torn down that were affordable for students many of whom are Hoosiers.

03:27:22.978 --> 03:27:29.728
- That's one thing specifically in my neighborhood and at the university right now is that a lot of Hoosiers

03:27:29.728 --> 03:27:36.100
- are being priced out from just living here and being able to go to school here. So this would help a

03:27:36.100 --> 03:27:42.850
- lot of that. And I would say this can help retain the housing in my neighborhood, because now you wouldn't

03:27:42.850 --> 03:27:49.348
- be able to build around it. And also, I will say the on-street parking issue in my neighborhood, which

03:27:49.348 --> 03:27:51.934
- is something I recently found out about,

03:27:52.066 --> 03:27:57.980
- how I can't get a parking pass, even though there's no one that parks in front of the building. There's

03:27:57.980 --> 03:28:03.724
- going to be 12 new residents across the street that are going to have no place to put their cars. So

03:28:03.724 --> 03:28:09.126
- I don't know where they're going to put them. They're probably going to put them in my parking

03:28:09.126 --> 03:28:14.813
- lot eventually. And then I'm not going to have a place to park. So that's also something that needs

03:28:14.813 --> 03:28:20.272
- to be addressed in the future. But I think this is a step in the right direction. So thank you.

03:28:20.272 --> 03:28:21.694
- Thank you. Anybody else?

03:28:22.594 --> 03:28:31.312
- We have one more member of the public in here. Nobody on Zoom? OK. We'll come back to Council comment.

03:28:31.312 --> 03:28:39.860
- Council member Stasberg. Thank you. I wanted to comment on this in terms of my representation to the

03:28:39.860 --> 03:28:48.324
- Planning Commission. At Planning Commission, we did talk about these two sections. And the argument

03:28:48.324 --> 03:28:51.710
- that was generally given toward keeping

03:28:52.610 --> 03:28:59.261
- keeping these sections in as opposed to eliminating them had to do actually with something slightly

03:28:59.261 --> 03:29:05.979
- different, which is the fact that plexes are conditional right now. And so then everything has to go

03:29:05.979 --> 03:29:12.630
- to the BZA, the Board of Zoning Appeals. And so if suddenly we remove the restrictions around that,

03:29:12.630 --> 03:29:17.086
- then are we going to suddenly get a lot more cases in front of the

03:29:17.218 --> 03:29:26.406
- the BZA. The numbers that were shared by staff when we were considering this was that over the last

03:29:26.406 --> 03:29:35.961
- few years, the number approved or before the BZA has not approached this maximum of 15 and there hasn't

03:29:35.961 --> 03:29:44.414
- been an issue with the buffer. That was why we left it in, figuring that anything else like

03:29:44.706 --> 03:29:54.556
- as the body, figuring than anything else, was more of a political decision as opposed to something land

03:29:54.556 --> 03:30:04.122
- use based. I'm agnostic about it in a lot of ways because I think that my real concern with duplexes

03:30:04.122 --> 03:30:08.574
- does lie in the fact that they're conditional.

03:30:09.378 --> 03:30:15.725
- And this doesn't change that, whether this is in or whether it's not in. They're still conditional,

03:30:15.725 --> 03:30:22.327
- and they've got to go before the Board of Zoning Appeals. And there are just numerous challenges within

03:30:22.327 --> 03:30:29.182
- that process for everybody involved, I think, including community members, neighbors of potential projects,

03:30:29.182 --> 03:30:35.530
- the developers themselves, the Board of Zoning Appeals, volunteers, and what they're being asked to

03:30:35.530 --> 03:30:36.926
- do in their capacity.

03:30:37.474 --> 03:30:46.931
- I'm fine supporting this tonight to leave these in. Yeah. I'm agnostic either way. Go either way. Thanks.

03:30:46.931 --> 03:30:55.943
- Councilmember Rosa Parker. I agree. I think if the first step had been making them permitted I would

03:30:55.943 --> 03:31:04.062
- have liked that a little more. But I think that allowing more duplexes that end up staying

03:31:05.218 --> 03:31:13.580
- in the BZA for months and slowing down projects and increasing costs will just force that issue, so

03:31:13.580 --> 03:31:22.361
- I'm okay with this right now. I did have a question about the ADUs, I think. Oh, where is the amendment?

03:31:22.361 --> 03:31:30.890
- Okay, so that's what I think. So I wouldn't approve the amendment and I would be okay with just going

03:31:30.890 --> 03:31:33.566
- with the UDO, the update as is.

03:31:35.234 --> 03:31:42.775
- Thank you. Any final Councilmember Flaherty? Yeah, I'm not going to support the amendment. I understand

03:31:42.775 --> 03:31:50.026
- the logical chain that's in the rationale. I did want to share my different perspective from what's

03:31:50.026 --> 03:31:57.568
- reflected there. One is that, and I've said this in other contexts, I think parking issues of all kinds

03:31:57.568 --> 03:32:03.006
- are appropriately regulated through parking policy and not housing policy.

03:32:03.170 --> 03:32:10.432
- So if we are having overly parked streets, it means we need to price them or permit them differently,

03:32:10.432 --> 03:32:17.836
- not, you know, avoid having certain types of housing. I think my perspective, I guess, on the rationale

03:32:17.836 --> 03:32:25.097
- outline for the amendment is that it takes a very narrow lens over a very short time scale that leads

03:32:25.097 --> 03:32:31.006
- to a sort of misunderstanding of how housing affordability works in the community.

03:32:31.298 --> 03:32:37.686
- First of all new construction is more expensive than older homes like full stop of any type And so that's

03:32:37.686 --> 03:32:43.773
- true of new single-family homes. It's true of any type of new homes and we're not here to crying You

03:32:43.773 --> 03:32:50.041
- know the the homes being torn down for new single-family homes being built. We just sort of like target

03:32:50.041 --> 03:32:56.188
- it on a small multifamily and missing middle housing for some reason and if it's because they're more

03:32:56.188 --> 03:32:59.262
- likely to house renters or students or what but it

03:32:59.746 --> 03:33:05.672
- We tend to be inconsistent in the application of that logic about the expense of new housing and the

03:33:05.672 --> 03:33:11.539
- housing loss that we're experiencing From you know older homes which you know Just just to be frank

03:33:11.539 --> 03:33:17.582
- like aren't always in great shape and often, you know are maybe not needing to be preserved They might

03:33:17.582 --> 03:33:23.742
- entail 150 or 200 thousand dollars of work to be made, you know livable so having experienced the rental

03:33:23.742 --> 03:33:27.614
- market here myself for some time like I know that is the case and

03:33:27.714 --> 03:33:33.818
- So while people are paying more, they're also getting a higher quality home in many instances. That

03:33:33.818 --> 03:33:40.348
- doesn't address the one-to-one affordability question of the exact lot or property where that's happening,

03:33:40.348 --> 03:33:46.452
- of course, but again, that kind of misses the forest for the trees. Broadly, I believe we need much

03:33:46.452 --> 03:33:52.800
- more housing than we have because we are a desirable community with a massive net in commute and people

03:33:52.800 --> 03:33:54.814
- who want to live here who can't.

03:33:55.010 --> 03:34:00.120
- There's a dire need for affordable housing solutions of all kinds through various forms of subsidies

03:34:00.120 --> 03:34:05.381
- and there's a need for much greater housing availability of all types. We can't just do extremely large

03:34:05.381 --> 03:34:10.694
- apartment complexes and detached single family homes. I believe strongly having a range of housing types

03:34:10.694 --> 03:34:13.982
- that reflects the historical nature of our community housing and

03:34:14.306 --> 03:34:19.833
- There's good imperial research on all this from cities that have done this better than we have of the

03:34:19.833 --> 03:34:25.632
- actual broader affordability benefits at the system. Again, not at the lot looking at that single question

03:34:25.632 --> 03:34:31.159
- about a single lot and what happened there, but looking at the rents and home prices across the whole

03:34:31.159 --> 03:34:36.686
- system. So, you know, we talk about these things ad nauseam. That's nothing new exactly. Just sharing

03:34:36.686 --> 03:34:41.726
- a different perspective on the questions we should be asking when it comes to something like

03:34:41.954 --> 03:34:50.574
- Duplexes and triplexes their role in the community and what we should be expecting of them. So that's

03:34:50.574 --> 03:34:59.700
- why I'm not supporting it. Thank you Yeah, I certainly understand the arguments that councilmember Flaherty

03:34:59.700 --> 03:35:08.151
- is making and those are the arguments I made in 2021 when You know, I actually wanted to to make it

03:35:08.151 --> 03:35:10.686
- easier to build duplexes this

03:35:10.914 --> 03:35:20.791
- 15 per year and 150 foot buffer was a compromise then. But what I've seen happen in the neighborhoods

03:35:20.791 --> 03:35:30.572
- I represent is not single family homes being torn down to build new single family homes. It's single

03:35:30.572 --> 03:35:40.062
- family homes being torn down to build duplexes. And they are more expensive. And I also have seen

03:35:40.514 --> 03:35:47.948
- Uh, that the city has not done the pricing of parking. Um, so I'm just looking at the reality on the

03:35:47.948 --> 03:35:55.530
- ground and not trying to make it any worse. And, and, you know, as others have said, this is not a big

03:35:55.530 --> 03:36:02.964
- change either way. It's not going to make much of a difference. Um, but I, I just don't want to make

03:36:02.964 --> 03:36:10.398
- a problem that I'm seeing, um, for my residents, uh, worse, even if it's just a tiny bit. Thank you.

03:36:10.850 --> 03:36:27.958
- Thank you. Final comments? OK. Will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 1? Yes. Rallo? Yes.

03:36:27.958 --> 03:36:40.446
- Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? No. Flaherty? No. Stosberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith?

03:36:41.666 --> 03:36:55.808
- Zulik? Yes. Sorry? Yes. Okay, that passes of 6-2. 7-2. Wow, all of us are here tonight. Would anyone

03:36:55.808 --> 03:37:05.470
- like to introduce a second amendment? Yeah, I'll move amendment two.

03:37:08.642 --> 03:37:17.868
- Okay, there's been a motion in a second. Take it away, council member Piedmont-Smith. This is just correcting

03:37:17.868 --> 03:37:26.340
- some typos. Are there any questions? Okay. No questions? Would any member of the public like to make

03:37:26.340 --> 03:37:35.902
- comment on typos? Anyone on Zoom? Great. Thank you. Back to council for council comment. Council member Stasberg.

03:37:37.602 --> 03:37:46.329
- Terms to term and plan commission. So maybe this is a second terms to term, but I Don't know if it's

03:37:46.329 --> 03:37:55.402
- the same one or not. I'll have to look at that Thank thank thank you for catching these as usual careful

03:37:55.402 --> 03:38:04.475
- reader Piedmont Smith Okay, any other comments Great. Well the clerk, please call the roll Councilmember

03:38:04.475 --> 03:38:07.326
- Allah Yes breath yes Rosenberger

03:38:08.962 --> 03:38:19.794
- Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stasberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Daly? Yes. Thank you.

03:38:19.794 --> 03:38:30.413
- Thank you very much. Amendment two passes. And now we will go back to ordinance 2026-27 as amended.

03:38:30.413 --> 03:38:38.590
- So questions. Council member Rosenberger, did you want to ask your question?

03:38:39.906 --> 03:38:49.837
- Yep, it's so late, you know, I'm just, I can't, okay, I have a question about the ADUs. I was trying

03:38:49.837 --> 03:38:59.670
- to find it in the UDO, like in, okay, I'm sorry, so they're getting changed to 1,000 square feet or

03:38:59.670 --> 03:39:08.126
- 75% of the primary residents. In some cases, is that smaller than what's allowed now?

03:39:09.634 --> 03:39:16.273
- No, because the minimum would be a thousand, whichever is less. So let's say that, you know, the house

03:39:16.273 --> 03:39:23.170
- was was really big, then they could go seventy five percent of that. Yeah. But if your house is a thousand

03:39:23.170 --> 03:39:29.874
- square feet, yes, then you get six seventy five maybe in places that it would normally be eight hundred

03:39:29.874 --> 03:39:31.550
- right now. Is that right?

03:39:32.386 --> 03:39:38.171
- I mean, it would have to be a really, really small house. I think, you know, I'd have to do the math

03:39:38.171 --> 03:39:43.956
- of what. I mean, Prospect Hill has a lot of a thousand square foot homes. I'm sorry, say that again.

03:39:43.956 --> 03:39:49.741
- Prospect Hill has a lot of a thousand square foot homes. So is this? Yeah, but every two, I mean, if

03:39:49.741 --> 03:39:55.468
- it's a two story, then both of those would, would count. Both of those floors would count for that.

03:39:55.468 --> 03:40:00.222
- If what's the two story? If the, you're talking about a thousand square foot home.

03:40:00.514 --> 03:40:07.827
- If it was a one story then sure it would just be a thousand if it was a two story then it obviously

03:40:07.827 --> 03:40:15.287
- would be a two thousand square foot home that we would take that seventy five percent from. I'm sorry

03:40:15.287 --> 03:40:22.819
- I feel confused that I thought it was saying that started over the ADU can be either a thousand square

03:40:22.819 --> 03:40:28.158
- feet or seventy five percent of the primary residents whichever is less.

03:40:28.258 --> 03:40:35.038
- Is the lesser of the two, yes. So if your primary residence is 1,000 square feet, why are you talking

03:40:35.038 --> 03:40:41.286
- about 2,000 square feet? Yeah, so in that case, it would be 750. If it was 1,000 square feet,

03:40:41.286 --> 03:40:48.132
- it would be 750. So in that case now, I mean, right now in Prospect Hill, it would be 580. That's what

03:40:48.132 --> 03:40:54.979
- it's limited to right now. Is it getting smaller or bigger? OK, so it's still getting bigger? Yes. OK,

03:40:54.979 --> 03:40:55.710
- thank you.

03:40:57.474 --> 03:41:07.312
- Other questions? Okay, we'll go to public comment on ordinance 2026-27 at, or I'm sorry, ordinance 2026-31

03:41:07.312 --> 03:41:17.058
- as amended. Anyone in chambers? Okay, anyone online? Okay, great. Person online, you'll be able to unmute

03:41:17.058 --> 03:41:22.942
- yourself. Please state your name and you'll have three minutes.

03:41:28.354 --> 03:41:38.172
- is Audrey Smith. I apologize. I am also feeling the time of night it is. So my thoughts are not very

03:41:38.172 --> 03:41:47.989
- put together. But I just want to encourage the council to support density. And I think that allowing

03:41:47.989 --> 03:41:56.446
- ADUs and duplexes is a good way to do that. People have raised concerns about parking.

03:41:56.578 --> 03:42:03.673
- And earlier in the evening, there was discussion of public transportation and what we can do to support

03:42:03.673 --> 03:42:10.768
- public transportation. And I think that that is one way of addressing parking concerns that hadn't been

03:42:10.768 --> 03:42:17.863
- brought into the conversation yet. There are lots of ways that we can make it so that people don't need

03:42:17.863 --> 03:42:24.686
- cars as much. And that will make it so that we don't need as much space devoted to parking. I think

03:42:24.686 --> 03:42:25.982
- that's all I have.

03:42:26.146 --> 03:42:35.699
- Thank you. Thank you very much. Anyone else? Okay. Second person on Zoom, take it away. Please state

03:42:35.699 --> 03:42:45.535
- your name. Hello, this is Sarah Wolford. I just wanted to also say that I encourage council to continue

03:42:45.535 --> 03:42:49.886
- to look at ways that we can increase density.

03:42:50.018 --> 03:43:00.378
- both from a sustainability perspective and also from a housing affordability standpoint. I think I live

03:43:00.378 --> 03:43:10.540
- in Isabel Piedmont Smith's district. And so I appreciate her concerns over parking and the demolition

03:43:10.540 --> 03:43:17.214
- of some houses or the planned demolition of homes in our district.

03:43:17.346 --> 03:43:29.478
- I think that there are other ways to potentially address some of the concerns around parking and around

03:43:29.478 --> 03:43:41.143
- demolition delays that can happen. And that's not necessarily my area of expertise. I'll leave that

03:43:41.143 --> 03:43:47.326
- to the politicians. But I just want to say that the,

03:43:47.586 --> 03:43:57.176
- The need to be creative and to use all the tools in our toolbox during this housing crisis is really

03:43:57.176 --> 03:44:06.766
- important. And I appreciate council taking steps to address density and just encourage to kind of be

03:44:06.766 --> 03:44:16.830
- moving in that direction. I'd love to see more about potential alley frontage in areas as well. And yeah.

03:44:17.154 --> 03:44:26.163
- Thank you. Thank you very much. In chambers. Evening, Paul Rousseau again. In my opinion, density alone

03:44:26.163 --> 03:44:35.086
- does not create a walkable and bicyclable neighborhood. Just increasing the density will bring in more

03:44:35.086 --> 03:44:43.835
- cars. And that's what we're saying. I've said this before. I'm like a broken record. I think this is

03:44:43.835 --> 03:44:46.174
- the cart before the horse.

03:44:46.882 --> 03:44:54.494
- If we have a mass transit system, if we have college and Walnut redesigned, if we have a lot of things

03:44:54.494 --> 03:45:01.957
- to encourage bicycling and walking that we don't have now, and then you add the density, well, yeah,

03:45:01.957 --> 03:45:09.569
- maybe that would work. But if you just add the density in a car-centric city, you're going to get more

03:45:09.569 --> 03:45:15.998
- cars. And it's not good. So I oppose this. It's just growth by other means. Thank you.

03:45:17.762 --> 03:45:27.218
- Thank you. Anyone else in chambers online? Great. We'll come back for final council comment. Anybody?

03:45:27.218 --> 03:45:36.860
- Council members Stasberg and then Flaherty. I just want to address that adding density in a car centric

03:45:36.860 --> 03:45:44.926
- city is going to add more cars concept because I think that one of our challenges with

03:45:45.058 --> 03:45:52.966
- with cars in Bloomington is that we have a really large student population. And students sometimes bring

03:45:52.966 --> 03:46:00.799
- cars, right? And I think that one of the things, societally, that we don't necessarily think about when

03:46:00.799 --> 03:46:07.878
- we own a car is where we're going to put the car. And so I think a piece of it is educational

03:46:07.878 --> 03:46:11.870
- and collaborating with IU to make sure that in their

03:46:12.002 --> 03:46:18.553
- literature and understanding they're saying to their students when they come, hey, you've got to have

03:46:18.553 --> 03:46:25.554
- a plan for where you're going to put your car. Where are you going to store your car? And it's not something

03:46:25.554 --> 03:46:32.169
- that societally I think we've typically thought about. The United States is really big, right? There's

03:46:32.169 --> 03:46:38.206
- all this space in the United States to put stuff. But in cities, that's not necessarily true.

03:46:38.306 --> 03:46:45.088
- you know, thinking about New York City, thinking about Chicago, thinking about some of those really

03:46:45.088 --> 03:46:51.395
- big urban areas. I mean, you know, my kid wanted to drive to visit New York over the summer,

03:46:51.395 --> 03:46:58.245
- and you know, she's 18 now, I can only control so much. But my question to her was, are you actually

03:46:58.245 --> 03:47:05.502
- gonna bring your car into New York City? Because that is a thing. And she hadn't fully thought about that.

03:47:06.402 --> 03:47:14.065
- even though she's like my kid and we talk about that kind of thing all the time. So if that's not part

03:47:14.065 --> 03:47:21.654
- of the culture of, well, where are you going to park? You can't necessarily assume there's a place to

03:47:21.654 --> 03:47:29.168
- park. I mean, we have to somehow make that part of the culture for not only the people who live here

03:47:29.168 --> 03:47:34.078
- full-time, year-round for years and years and years, but also our

03:47:34.370 --> 03:47:40.666
- more temporary student population coming in, and we need to say, hey, you need to make a plan for where

03:47:40.666 --> 03:47:47.023
- you're going to put your car. Here are some options for how that works. And that's communication, that's

03:47:47.023 --> 03:47:53.319
- collaboration, that's education. Thanks. Councilmember Flaherty. Yeah, I also just wanted to talk about

03:47:53.319 --> 03:47:58.526
- some of the sustainability things, because a few members of the public brought it up.

03:47:59.746 --> 03:48:05.619
- There's multiple benefits to allowing more people to live here. It's not that allowing more folks to

03:48:05.619 --> 03:48:11.551
- live in neighborhoods that are close to campus when there are students there or staff there. It's not

03:48:11.551 --> 03:48:17.482
- that they're going to necessarily get rid of cars, though some might. It's that they're going to have

03:48:17.482 --> 03:48:23.530
- to drive a whole heck of a lot less than they would if they were living in Bedford or out in the county

03:48:23.530 --> 03:48:29.694
- somewhere. And so increased density, a big part of it is just allowing people to live close to where they

03:48:30.146 --> 03:48:35.579
- you know, work and playing and shop such that the trips are shorter. More trips can be made by foot

03:48:35.579 --> 03:48:41.283
- and bike, even if it's not, you know, where we ideally like to see it. Also just noting that multifamily

03:48:41.283 --> 03:48:46.716
- housing has shared walls that reduces energy costs substantially. These things do pay big dividends

03:48:46.716 --> 03:48:52.257
- over time. Like it's, again, I'm just a fundamental believer in missing middle housing as a role, and

03:48:52.257 --> 03:48:57.745
- I think we lose sight of that sometimes because new housing isn't affordable, like full stop. Market

03:48:57.745 --> 03:48:59.646
- rate new housing isn't affordable.

03:49:00.130 --> 03:49:05.362
- of almost any type, whether it's massive multi-family buildings or single-family homes. If we wanted

03:49:05.362 --> 03:49:10.542
- to get really serious about trying to control prices, we would set maximum sizes for the homes that

03:49:10.542 --> 03:49:15.774
- can be built. We wouldn't let anything be bigger than 1,500 square feet, because that's going to cut

03:49:15.774 --> 03:49:21.265
- the cost of a new home in half. So that's pretty aggressive. We're not going to do that. I get it. People

03:49:21.265 --> 03:49:26.497
- would call us communists or something. But just noting that there's a lot of sustainability benefits

03:49:26.497 --> 03:49:28.414
- to small-scale multi-family housing.

03:49:28.994 --> 03:49:35.395
- Understand that the trade-offs that folks folks have in mind and the concerns around it When when we

03:49:35.395 --> 03:49:42.113
- see an older home that might be pretty affordable now disappear for something newer that's not affordable

03:49:42.113 --> 03:49:48.513
- right now So I get it, but just wanted to talk to those sustainability aspects as well. Thanks Thank

03:49:48.513 --> 03:49:55.104
- you. Any other final comments? Okay Councilmember Rosenberger, I'll just go a little bit about parking.

03:49:55.104 --> 03:49:58.590
- It's fun, you know, I Lived in Denver and I lived in a

03:49:58.946 --> 03:50:05.383
- an apartment across from a restaurant bar, and if I moved my car after 5 p.m., I couldn't find a spot

03:50:05.383 --> 03:50:11.946
- anywhere near me. It changed how I lived, and it changed the decisions I was making about driving. It's

03:50:11.946 --> 03:50:12.830
- a good thing.

03:50:13.026 --> 03:50:18.767
- I didn't have a car when I went to school here, and my parents didn't either. And I think it's sad how

03:50:18.767 --> 03:50:24.676
- many cars are here now. If students need them to go home, I think that's OK. You can park at the stadium.

03:50:24.676 --> 03:50:30.418
- So students get to park at the stadium and pay, I think, $77 or something like that. Our city also has

03:50:30.418 --> 03:50:36.382
- garages that you can do seven days a week, non-reserved. You can do five days a week. You can do reserved.

03:50:37.122 --> 03:50:43.037
- They're not sold out. So there's places to put your car if you need to come here. And it doesn't necessarily

03:50:43.037 --> 03:50:48.573
- need to be right in front of your house. I think it's a neat way to live, right? And the fact that we

03:50:48.573 --> 03:50:54.217
- have so many people who come here and say, oh my gosh, you live here. I can't believe it. I could never

03:50:54.217 --> 03:50:59.698
- afford to live here. I think we need to make big changes. And I think we're making some. And I think

03:50:59.698 --> 03:51:05.342
- rents are starting to look a little better. I'm in Prospect Hill and looking at what to rent seems like

03:51:06.338 --> 03:51:12.696
- It's not going up as much as it used to, I think, which is really neat. And it's showing that maybe

03:51:12.696 --> 03:51:19.245
- we're building housing and folks are choosing to live. Students maybe are living in bigger spaces. I'm

03:51:19.245 --> 03:51:25.794
- not quite sure. But what we're not allowing still is missing middle housing. And it's so controversial

03:51:25.794 --> 03:51:32.343
- here. I think it's a real bummer that we're saying that we have so many duplexes and we're not allowed

03:51:32.343 --> 03:51:36.094
- to make more, even though they work fine in neighborhoods.

03:51:36.194 --> 03:51:42.118
- Like new ones, old ones, Prospect Hill has a lot of duplexes. But no, we can't make any more. It's just

03:51:42.118 --> 03:51:47.815
- kind of wild to me. We can't build what's right across the street from us. Like, why is that? We've

03:51:47.815 --> 03:51:53.625
- regulated housing prices to be so expensive. And it is just a supply and demand. And then in terms of

03:51:53.625 --> 03:51:59.549
- climate change, it really matters where we're putting these homes. So I hope this is going to be a tiny

03:51:59.549 --> 03:52:05.758
- little thing again that we change. And I guess I just hope this council can still do more than this. Thanks.

03:52:06.754 --> 03:52:20.027
- Any other comments? OK, will the clerk please call the roll on ordinance 2026 31 as amended?

03:52:20.027 --> 03:52:35.870
- Yes. Councilmember Ruff? No. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stossberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Zulek? Yes.

03:52:36.738 --> 03:52:48.105
- Sorry. Yes. Daily. Yes. Bravo. Yes. Okay thank you that passes eight one. And now we are back to ordinance

03:52:48.105 --> 03:52:58.940
- twenty twenty six dash twenty seven. Twenty six dash twenty seven be introduced and read by the clerk

03:52:58.940 --> 03:53:03.614
- by title and synopsis only. Any discussion.

03:53:05.410 --> 03:53:17.352
- Will the clerk please call the roll. Councilmember Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stossberg. Yes.

03:53:17.352 --> 03:53:29.294
- Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Asari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Thank you very much.

03:53:29.294 --> 03:53:32.638
- Will the clerk please read.

03:53:39.714 --> 03:53:47.227
- ordinance twenty twenty six twenty seven to fix the salaries of all elected city officials for the city

03:53:47.227 --> 03:53:54.595
- of bloomington for the year twenty twenty seven the synopsis is as follows this ordinance recommended

03:53:54.595 --> 03:54:01.891
- by the special fiscal committee sets the twenty twenty seven salaries for all elected city officials

03:54:01.891 --> 03:54:07.742
- for the city of bloomington thank you very much six dash twenty seven be adopted

03:54:11.970 --> 03:54:22.428
- I don't have very much to present. I talked about it a little bit at first reading this and there's

03:54:22.428 --> 03:54:32.886
- a memo in there that I wrote in terms of the recommendation coming from the fiscal committee with a

03:54:32.886 --> 03:54:41.566
- 2-1 vote with Councilmember Flaherty being absent that day and I voted against it.

03:54:41.730 --> 03:54:53.627
- I included two amendments in there that are sponsored by myself. I don't know if you guys want me to

03:54:53.627 --> 03:55:06.467
- pick an amendment and introduce that first or just have any questions about the ordinance as it's presented.

03:55:06.467 --> 03:55:10.590
- Well, I think in this case because

03:55:11.170 --> 03:55:21.187
- amendments one and two contradict each other, it might be worth a motion to suspend the rules to discuss

03:55:21.187 --> 03:55:31.108
- both amendments simultaneously. I guess my thought on that immediately is that at first reading, I kind

03:55:31.108 --> 03:55:37.118
- of brought that up as a, you know, can we discuss it and there

03:55:37.282 --> 03:55:47.237
- was very little discussion, I felt like, from colleagues. So I don't know if people have more opinions

03:55:47.237 --> 03:55:57.580
- on it now or whether it would be more instrumental to pick one. That is up to you, Councilmember Stosberg.

03:55:57.580 --> 03:56:05.022
- I guess I'll go ahead and introduce Amendment 1 then. I'll move Amendment 1.

03:56:08.770 --> 03:56:15.837
- second. All right, go right ahead council member Stossberg. So basically, you know this this discussion

03:56:15.837 --> 03:56:22.768
- in general this year the resounding conclusion from fiscal committee was that we're essentially going

03:56:22.768 --> 03:56:29.563
- to do a COLA increase and one of the other issues is that you know the the overall like cost of the

03:56:29.563 --> 03:56:36.495
- COLA increase is what is currently in our city budget and so exceeding that in general would just not

03:56:36.495 --> 03:56:37.310
- be good. So

03:56:37.698 --> 03:56:49.743
- What amendment one does is it addresses my ongoing issue that I have with COLA increases, that a standard

03:56:49.743 --> 03:57:00.766
- COLA increase across all positions just exacerbates the salary gap. This idea actually came from

03:57:01.570 --> 03:57:08.597
- Controller McKim, he said it publicly, so I think it's okay in a meeting. What the county had done,

03:57:08.597 --> 03:57:15.905
- because the county had dealt with this too, right, in terms of that idea of the exacerbating the salary

03:57:15.905 --> 03:57:23.073
- gap between high and low wage workers. When he was on county council, what he said was that they took

03:57:23.073 --> 03:57:24.830
- that overall cost of the

03:57:24.930 --> 03:57:31.379
- COLA increase and just divided it by the number of positions. And so then everybody got a flat increase,

03:57:31.379 --> 03:57:37.889
- which meant that the lower end of the salaries got a higher percentage and the higher end of the salaries

03:57:37.889 --> 03:57:41.758
- got a lower percentage, but they all got the same flat amount.

03:57:43.042 --> 03:57:49.706
- That was just a way to counteract that kind of increasing wage gap. And so amendment one is just taking

03:57:49.706 --> 03:57:56.370
- that concept across these positions, these three positions. And I can appreciate the concept that we're

03:57:56.370 --> 03:58:02.778
- only doing this with these three salaries as opposed to all of civil city salaries, because it's an

03:58:02.778 --> 03:58:05.790
- issue with all of civil city salaries as well.

03:58:06.082 --> 03:58:12.949
- You know, these are the wages that we really control. These are the salaries that we control as the

03:58:12.949 --> 03:58:19.816
- elected salaries. And it also is just a really interesting example of how that works. I also wanted

03:58:19.816 --> 03:58:26.820
- to address, Clerk Bolden mentioned when we did it for first reading, this idea like, well, if it does

03:58:26.820 --> 03:58:33.755
- this, she kind of broke it down to hourly. And I do want to make clear that we can't really, by law,

03:58:33.755 --> 03:58:35.678
- think about hourly with our

03:58:35.842 --> 03:58:45.718
- salaries with the elected salaries. But I did because it's an interesting exercise and I'm a math person.

03:58:45.718 --> 03:58:54.942
- And so Clerk Bolden's comment was like, ooh, if council works 20 hours a week, say, on that 26,827

03:58:55.074 --> 03:59:01.717
- proposed salary with Amendment 1, then that's $25 an hour, and that's true. But if we take the mayor's

03:59:01.717 --> 03:59:08.231
- hourly rate based on $40 an hour and that same in Amendment 1, it's over $70 an hour. And even at 60

03:59:08.231 --> 03:59:14.746
- hours a week, because I've heard the mayor say that she works way more than 40 hours, and whether or

03:59:14.746 --> 03:59:19.454
- not that's advisable or good, it's still over $47 an hour, and the clerk

03:59:19.650 --> 03:59:26.993
- You know, at 40 hours is almost $45 an hour, and at 50 hours is almost $36 an hour. So there's still

03:59:26.993 --> 03:59:34.335
- a huge differential there in terms of what elected officials are getting paid versus our, we can say

03:59:34.335 --> 03:59:42.114
- the lowest wage workers in the city are getting paid, which the living wage is something like 16 something

03:59:42.114 --> 03:59:44.222
- an hour, maybe 22 this year.

03:59:44.706 --> 03:59:54.238
- Um, so I'm not sure that that was necessarily relevant in this situation, but I thought it was an interesting

03:59:54.238 --> 04:00:02.990
- thought exercise. Um, and as I said, we can't really base it on hours anyway, because we can't go by

04:00:02.990 --> 04:00:09.662
- hours. So anyway, in some ways, this is a thought exercise on amendment one.

04:00:14.402 --> 04:00:22.303
- Councilmember Rosenberger. Sorry I just popped back in the bathrooms were closed I had to go and couldn't

04:00:22.303 --> 04:00:30.129
- find one blah blah blah. Did you say we can't go on ours but the real narrative is we were like we could

04:00:30.129 --> 04:00:34.750
- but we're choosing not to. My understanding from when we were

04:00:35.266 --> 04:00:41.261
- doing this salary stuff over the last couple of years is that state law actually says that we can't

04:00:41.261 --> 04:00:47.317
- be paid based on an hourly wage. Oh, be paid hourly. Yes, but we should, like, create a salary based

04:00:47.317 --> 04:00:53.492
- on hours. Yes. Yes. Yeah. OK. Yeah. And so, like, they said roughly on a part-to-half-time job. Right.

04:00:53.492 --> 04:00:59.727
- Right. OK, yes. Right. Yeah. Clerk Bolden? Oh, I was just going to clarify. My point was not about your

04:00:59.727 --> 04:01:01.406
- hours worked. My point was,

04:01:01.570 --> 04:01:08.790
- looking at the COLA increase that you were proposing by splitting it up, which was if you did that,

04:01:08.790 --> 04:01:16.588
- you'd be getting a larger COLA increase than some of our lowest paid employees who are making significantly

04:01:16.588 --> 04:01:24.025
- less. And that's where I brought in the hourly rate as a point of comparison. Because depending, there

04:01:24.025 --> 04:01:31.390
- are some council members who are working over 30 hours a week and some who are working with much more

04:01:32.290 --> 04:01:40.083
- constraint on their time availability due to other positions and responsibilities. So I didn't want

04:01:40.083 --> 04:01:48.188
- to lock it into the hourly rate. And yeah, I was having fun with math as well. So I did want to clarify

04:01:48.188 --> 04:01:56.059
- that. Thank you. Are there any other questions? I want to respond to that if I could. I just want to

04:01:56.059 --> 04:02:01.982
- appreciate that clarification and also kind of say, I think that across the

04:02:02.178 --> 04:02:08.959
- the city in terms of, I mean, I think that there needs to be a flat increase, essentially,

04:02:08.959 --> 04:02:16.485
- to help compensate, essentially, for our lower wage workers having that lower COLA increase. Like, I

04:02:16.485 --> 04:02:24.533
- think that it's problematic across the city. Are there any other questions? OK, let's go to public comment.

04:02:24.533 --> 04:02:30.718
- Would anyone in chambers like to speak on Amendment 1? OK, is there anyone online?

04:02:31.746 --> 04:02:41.107
- Okay, we're coming back to council member comments. Council member Piedmont Smith. I agree with council

04:02:41.107 --> 04:02:50.109
- member Stossberg that wage compression is a problem in the city, but I don't think that applying it

04:02:50.109 --> 04:02:59.110
- just to the elected positions is equitable or really worthwhile at this point. So I would encourage

04:02:59.110 --> 04:03:00.190
- increase in

04:03:00.354 --> 04:03:09.129
- ongoing conversations with HR and with the mayor about Addressing wage compression across the board

04:03:09.129 --> 04:03:17.991
- next year Other councilmember comments Okay, I will just second councilmember Piedmont Smith's point

04:03:17.991 --> 04:03:23.870
- and one last call for comments before we council member Stasberg I

04:03:24.962 --> 04:03:38.044
- Just want to say it's that very concern is why I had amendment to as well as another option Okay,

04:03:38.044 --> 04:03:53.662
- so yeah, thank you other comments Okay, will the clerk please call the roll and amendment one? Councilmember clarity

04:03:56.514 --> 04:04:14.479
- Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont-Smith. No. Zulek. No. Massari. No. Daly. No. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger.

04:04:14.479 --> 04:04:26.174
- Yes. OK. I got to do math. I think that fails four or five. Yes. OK.

04:04:26.498 --> 04:04:38.298
- Okay. Well, would anyone like to introduce another amendment and or we could discuss it just as is?

04:04:38.298 --> 04:04:50.216
- Go ahead. I'll go ahead and move Amendment 2. Second. Okay. Go ahead. So Amendment 2 keeps our wages

04:04:50.216 --> 04:04:55.998
- the same across the board with no COLA increase.

04:04:56.098 --> 04:05:06.458
- kind of on a principle, honestly, that I think that there are problems with straight COLA increases,

04:05:06.458 --> 04:05:16.715
- and it has some equity issues, and I don't want to exacerbate that by making it worse, that elected

04:05:16.715 --> 04:05:23.998
- salaries can only go up, they can never go down, and similarly, we can

04:05:24.098 --> 04:05:32.388
- say that the fiscal committee as a body still had a real struggle with figuring this out and trying

04:05:32.388 --> 04:05:41.010
- to get a good framework and do all of that work this year. And so kind of on the principle that I would

04:05:41.010 --> 04:05:49.963
- rather keep things the way they are than continue to maybe make things worse in terms of equity, especially

04:05:49.963 --> 04:05:51.870
- when thinking about if

04:05:52.642 --> 04:05:59.800
- I don't have it in here, but a couple years ago when we had that ad hoc committee and we were looking

04:05:59.800 --> 04:06:06.958
- at the rate of increases across these positions, and just mathematically at some point when you think

04:06:06.958 --> 04:06:14.116
- about that increase, there's exponential growth at some point. When the salary gets so high that that

04:06:14.116 --> 04:06:15.870
- 2% or 3% all of a sudden

04:06:15.970 --> 04:06:21.624
- You know, it really shoots up in a curve. And the mayor's salary is starting to do that. The clerk's

04:06:21.624 --> 04:06:27.221
- salary hasn't quite done it. Council salary is nowhere close to doing it. But it's like investment.

04:06:27.221 --> 04:06:32.875
- It's like you think that you're not building very much interest until all of a sudden your principal

04:06:32.875 --> 04:06:38.865
- is so big that you're building a lot of interest. And so it's the same kind of concept. So this amendment,

04:06:38.865 --> 04:06:44.630
- too, is more like, well, if we're not actually going to fix it and make it better, then let's just not

04:06:44.630 --> 04:06:45.470
- make it worse.

04:06:46.562 --> 04:06:54.828
- So another thought exercise you could say okay questions on amendment two Okay, we'll go to public comment

04:06:54.828 --> 04:07:02.785
- on amendment two would anyone in chambers like to speak Okay, is there anyone online? Great. Thank you

04:07:02.785 --> 04:07:08.734
- One last call for public comment. Okay, and we'll go back Oh clerk pulled in

04:07:14.146 --> 04:07:19.523
- I know that public comment is not a time to go back in a back and forth. So I don't know if this is

04:07:19.523 --> 04:07:24.954
- the appropriate place for me to do it or if I'm doing it as a member of staff or however you want to

04:07:24.954 --> 04:07:30.492
- put it. But if you haven't done the framework, you're saying to just keep it the way it is, but you're

04:07:30.492 --> 04:07:36.085
- not keeping it the way it is because elected officials have traditionally gotten the same COLA increase

04:07:36.085 --> 04:07:41.838
- that other staff have done. So you are changing it significantly by this. And you're also giving everybody

04:07:41.838 --> 04:07:43.774
- who holds elected office a pay cut.

04:07:44.578 --> 04:07:50.925
- Because while you are keeping everything flat, and I understand that perspective, you're not addressing

04:07:50.925 --> 04:07:57.272
- the fact that costs of living have gone up across the board. And I cannot tell you how upset I was that

04:07:57.272 --> 04:08:03.375
- I couldn't get my overpriced eggs today. But there it is. So looking at what's going to happen over

04:08:03.375 --> 04:08:09.844
- the next year or two with increasing costs, but a decrease in salary, which is what you're talking about,

04:08:09.844 --> 04:08:11.614
- that does have a pain point.

04:08:11.714 --> 04:08:17.672
- And while for some positions or for some people who hold elected office, that may or may not be a big

04:08:17.672 --> 04:08:23.923
- deal, at least for myself and for future clerks, I look at that as problematic because this is a full-time

04:08:23.923 --> 04:08:29.764
- position. Some people will be able to hold the position with additional income and some people will

04:08:29.764 --> 04:08:35.839
- not. But that does create issues for people. And that is a different type of equity that you're looking

04:08:35.839 --> 04:08:39.870
- at. Council, sorry, didn't mean to make it at one person. Thank you.

04:08:40.738 --> 04:08:48.977
- Anyone else for public comment? OK, one person online. You'll have the opportunity to unmute yourself.

04:08:48.977 --> 04:08:57.055
- Please state your name for the record. You'll have three minutes. Hi, this is Mayor Thompson. I also

04:08:57.055 --> 04:09:03.294
- don't know how to engage with this as a member of public or elected official.

04:09:03.554 --> 04:09:11.953
- I'll just say that I think that the work that was started two years ago to look at the principles behind

04:09:11.953 --> 04:09:20.192
- elected salaries was a good start and that work was supposed to continue. But every year we talk about

04:09:20.192 --> 04:09:28.191
- how we're going to structure elected salaries. We talk about pay compression, et cetera, et cetera.

04:09:28.191 --> 04:09:33.310
- And I think at the very least we should be as elected officials

04:09:33.506 --> 04:09:44.084
- compensated in similar ways to the way the rest of the city staff is compensated and on similar principles.

04:09:44.084 --> 04:09:54.270
- And so I would just say that until we get an understanding of how we would like to operate differently,

04:09:54.722 --> 04:10:04.194
- I would recommend that we go with a straight COLA increase. I agree with the clerk. It is essentially

04:10:04.194 --> 04:10:13.481
- a pay cut. We all come from different places and can't presume hardship or otherwise, but salary is

04:10:13.481 --> 04:10:15.710
- compensation for a job.

04:10:15.810 --> 04:10:24.403
- And there are many factors to determining compensation. I know that our consultants two years ago gave

04:10:24.403 --> 04:10:33.080
- recommendations for how to determine that to the subcommittee that was working. And I would expect that

04:10:33.080 --> 04:10:41.757
- those recommendations are still valid. Thank you. Any other member of the public? OK. You'll have three

04:10:41.757 --> 04:10:44.510
- minutes. Please state your name.

04:10:47.170 --> 04:10:59.824
- Hello, this is Sarah Wolford again. And as someone who has been lucky enough to work at an organization

04:10:59.824 --> 04:11:12.112
- who historically and continues to give COLA, I do appreciate the concern with COLA, but I also think

04:11:12.112 --> 04:11:13.694
- that without

04:11:14.818 --> 04:11:26.599
- without a recommendation for how to address how to adjust for the incredible increase in cost of living

04:11:26.599 --> 04:11:38.154
- that people have seen over the last year. I feel like it is I think unfair to punish the employees of

04:11:38.154 --> 04:11:44.158
- our city government who help it run to not give them

04:11:44.770 --> 04:11:56.805
- to basically not provide them with adjustment because that adjustment is problematic. So I would urge

04:11:56.805 --> 04:12:08.604
- that if another amendment can't be put forward that to address the issues with COLA, that COLA just

04:12:08.604 --> 04:12:14.622
- continues to move forward as it stands. Thank you.

04:12:15.202 --> 04:12:23.661
- Is there anyone else online? Great. Anyone in chambers? Last call? OK. We will come back to council

04:12:23.661 --> 04:12:32.711
- comment. Council member Stosberg. I want to start off, I think, by responding to the last public commenter

04:12:32.711 --> 04:12:40.916
- that I put forth that amendment that I thought would fix Colomor and it failed. So there's that.

04:12:40.916 --> 04:12:43.454
- But secondly, more generally,

04:12:43.810 --> 04:12:51.506
- It's not as though the city that elected officials have always had COLA increases. And in fact, in the

04:12:51.506 --> 04:12:59.128
- chart that Clerk Bolden made a couple of years ago when we were first looking at this and the history

04:12:59.128 --> 04:13:06.974
- of salaries for these three positions in 2005 and in 2013, there were no COLA increases. They were flat.

04:13:07.202 --> 04:13:17.457
- salaries that are the same in 2012 as 2013, same in 2004 as 2005. So the idea of not giving the elected

04:13:17.457 --> 04:13:27.613
- a COLA increase is not this crazy new thing. It has happened a couple of times. But that was citywide.

04:13:27.613 --> 04:13:34.910
- Well, still, it's happened a couple of times. And I appreciate that idea.

04:13:35.074 --> 04:13:41.827
- well, we need to do the same thing with our electeds as we're doing with all of the rest of our employees.

04:13:41.827 --> 04:13:48.264
- But I also agree with Mayor Thompson, we've been talking about this for a couple of years and nothing

04:13:48.264 --> 04:13:54.576
- changed about COLA this year for city staff either. So who is going to actually drop the hammer and

04:13:54.576 --> 04:14:00.887
- say, okay, something different has to happen. And so both of these amendments were my way of saying

04:14:00.887 --> 04:14:04.926
- something different really has to happen. And like whether they

04:14:05.122 --> 04:14:14.237
- get approved or not. I mean, something different has to happen. And sometimes I think it's dramatic.

04:14:14.237 --> 04:14:23.261
- I liked Amendment 1 way better than Amendment 2. But I think that sometimes you just have to put it

04:14:23.261 --> 04:14:32.285
- out there and have the conversation and see what happens. OK. Is there other council members? Dave,

04:14:32.285 --> 04:14:33.278
- excuse me.

04:14:33.442 --> 04:14:42.024
- I'm so sorry. Council Member Aralo. Thank you. And thank you, Council Member Stasberg. I think this

04:14:42.024 --> 04:14:50.693
- has been a good discussion and I appreciate it as a thought experiment. I too favored Amendment 1. I

04:14:50.693 --> 04:14:59.532
- voted for it. I understand your meaning of supporting a set of principle. You don't want to worsen the

04:14:59.532 --> 04:15:02.622
- differential. However, I think that

04:15:02.850 --> 04:15:14.802
- We should go with the COLA this time around and concentrate on addressing this wage compression problem

04:15:14.802 --> 04:15:26.639
- in the next year, because I think you're absolutely right. I think that we do need to focus on raising

04:15:26.639 --> 04:15:28.478
- the wage floor.

04:15:29.442 --> 04:15:37.804
- It would be really unjust or it is unjust for people who work full time for the city that they can't

04:15:37.804 --> 04:15:46.249
- afford to live in. So I think that needs to be addressed by us. And I appreciate this, your effort in

04:15:46.249 --> 04:15:54.860
- bringing this to our attention and for consideration. But I won't be supporting this amendment. Thanks.

04:15:54.860 --> 04:15:57.758
- Thank you. Final council comments.

04:15:59.234 --> 04:16:10.318
- Okay. Clerk Bolton, would you please call the roll on Amendment 2? Council Member Stasberg.

04:16:10.318 --> 04:16:21.763
- Yes. Piedmont-Smith? No. Zulek? No. Daly? I'm so sorry. I keep doing this today. I'm so sorry,

04:16:21.763 --> 04:16:28.510
- Council Member. Sorry, I'm not trying to leave you out.

04:16:29.378 --> 04:16:44.266
- Is it me? No. Okay. Thank you. Daily? No. Rallo? No. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? No. And Flaherty? No.

04:16:44.266 --> 04:16:57.950
- Thank you. Thank you. That fails to seven. And now we will come back to ordinance 2026-27.

04:16:59.234 --> 04:17:09.577
- Are there any questions? OK. Would anybody in the public like to speak? OK. OK. If you would like to

04:17:09.577 --> 04:17:20.125
- speak, if you could unmute yourself and state your name for the record, that would be great. Or if you

04:17:20.125 --> 04:17:28.318
- could put your hand down, that would also be great. Great. Thank you very much.

04:17:28.642 --> 04:17:42.056
- If no other takers, that concludes our comment period for the ordinance itself. Back to final council

04:17:42.056 --> 04:17:55.338
- comment. Council member Piedmont-Smith. It's been very difficult to find a rational principled basis

04:17:55.338 --> 04:17:58.494
- from which to calculate

04:17:58.594 --> 04:18:08.499
- appropriate salaries for council members, clerk, and mayor. I still think it's something we need to

04:18:08.499 --> 04:18:18.900
- try to do. But as I think Mayor Thompson said, we haven't gotten very far in two years since the initial

04:18:18.900 --> 04:18:27.518
- proposal came forward. So I don't think this is ideal that we just do a COLA increase.

04:18:27.682 --> 04:18:37.849
- I think that there needs to be some principled way that we arrive at fair salaries instead

04:18:37.849 --> 04:18:49.356
- of just perpetuating the salaries that somehow have historically trickled down to us because there was

04:18:49.356 --> 04:18:54.942
- no rational basis for those really to begin with.

04:18:55.138 --> 04:19:05.161
- And it's particularly tricky because I think that most communities don't really think through this and

04:19:05.161 --> 04:19:15.379
- just kind of keep with the COLA increases or other increases that regular staff of the city get. I think

04:19:15.379 --> 04:19:23.262
- in 2027 we have an opportunity as it being the last year of this council term to

04:19:23.682 --> 04:19:31.946
- make some difficult decisions and know that we may not necessarily benefit from them as some of us will

04:19:31.946 --> 04:19:40.210
- be stepping off council and nobody is guaranteed to stay on. So I think we should do it and I encourage

04:19:40.210 --> 04:19:48.394
- all members and not just those members of the fiscal committee to think about this and give the fiscal

04:19:48.394 --> 04:19:50.142
- committee your ideas.

04:19:50.658 --> 04:19:58.753
- And really engage in this and not wait until we have legislation in front of us that nobody is thrilled

04:19:58.753 --> 04:20:06.615
- about. Thank you. Any Councilmember Stasberg? I want to thank my colleagues and the public for going

04:20:06.615 --> 04:20:14.710
- along with my thought experiments this evening. I know that it is late, but I appreciate it. I do think

04:20:14.710 --> 04:20:19.614
- that it's important. And as Councilmember Piedmont Smith said,

04:20:20.098 --> 04:20:27.046
- It has been a struggle. It has been a struggle. And I think that I'm actually maybe the only council

04:20:27.046 --> 04:20:34.063
- member up here who was on the ad hoc committee working with the consultants, also on fiscal committee

04:20:34.063 --> 04:20:41.011
- last year and then on fiscal committee again this year. So it's like every year and it's kind of the

04:20:41.011 --> 04:20:43.006
- same frustrations I do have.

04:20:43.138 --> 04:20:50.595
- hopes of a better calendar related to it next year in terms of having the conversation sooner, being

04:20:50.595 --> 04:20:58.273
- able to engage more with the Office of the Controller around increases, because one of the other things

04:20:58.273 --> 04:21:06.173
- is if there are potentially larger increases, those have to be worked into budget numbers that get decided

04:21:06.173 --> 04:21:10.750
- much earlier than now. And so then either way, we kind of get

04:21:10.850 --> 04:21:17.054
- locked into different corners. And this isn't a decision that should be made because

04:21:17.250 --> 04:21:24.080
- we get blocked into a corner, this should be a decision that we're making deliberately. Whether it's

04:21:24.080 --> 04:21:30.978
- a decision to not give any increase at all or whether it's a decision to give increases here or there

04:21:30.978 --> 04:21:37.808
- or whatever it is, it should be with deliberation and intent. So I think that it's a good goal and I

04:21:37.808 --> 04:21:44.638
- will carry forth in the next year to continue trying to meet that goal of being able to do this with

04:21:44.834 --> 04:21:51.575
- Consistency and transparency and deliberation because our community deserves that. Thanks councilmember

04:21:51.575 --> 04:21:58.316
- Rosenberger No on this I just wanted to respond to the mayor's comments that I kind of I think she said

04:21:58.316 --> 04:22:04.798
- something about like why haven't you all figured this out yet? One reason we haven't figured it out

04:22:04.798 --> 04:22:11.539
- is because for every year she has said she will support no more than a cola increase It says right here

04:22:11.539 --> 04:22:12.446
- in the packet

04:22:12.578 --> 04:22:19.732
- Both the mayor and the clerk gave feedback that they would support no more than the 2.7% COLA increase,

04:22:19.732 --> 04:22:26.749
- but neither were able to attend the meeting on October 2nd. So I think council hasn't gotten a lot of

04:22:26.749 --> 04:22:28.606
- help in figuring this out.

04:22:29.250 --> 04:22:36.212
- the mayor thinks there is anything to figure out. I think it's unfortunate that we're going into an

04:22:36.212 --> 04:22:43.384
- election year with the same salary and that people have to forfeit making a living wage should do this

04:22:43.384 --> 04:22:50.346
- job. So I think it's a missed opportunity again, and I'm going to vote no on these salaries because

04:22:50.346 --> 04:22:57.726
- I think council needs to be compensated fairly for the hours that they're putting in. Any final comments?

04:23:00.514 --> 04:23:16.133
- Will the clerk please call the roll? Council member Piedmont-Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Vasari. Yes. Daly.

04:23:16.133 --> 04:23:27.998
- Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. No. Flaherty. No. Stosberg. No. Okay.

04:23:28.322 --> 04:23:38.828
- Thank you. That passes 6-3. Is there a motion? I move that ordinance 2026-34 be introduced and read

04:23:38.828 --> 04:23:49.544
- by the clerk by title and synopsis only. There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion? Will the

04:23:49.544 --> 04:23:57.214
- clerk please call the roll? Council member Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Daly?

04:24:00.866 --> 04:24:11.206
- All right, that time. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? No. Flaherty? Yes. Stosberg? Yes.

04:24:11.206 --> 04:24:22.782
- And Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Thank you. That passes 8-1. Will the clerk please read by title and synopsis?

04:24:26.530 --> 04:24:33.115
- Ordinance 2026-34, to vacate public parcels regarding two 12-foot wide alley segments located in the

04:24:33.115 --> 04:24:39.635
- southwest corner of West 11th Street and North Rogers Street, Trades District Community Development

04:24:39.635 --> 04:24:46.742
- LLC petitioner-owner. The synopsis is as follows. The petitioner-owner Trades District Community Development

04:24:46.742 --> 04:24:48.894
- LLC, operated by Dimension Mill,

04:24:48.994 --> 04:24:57.045
- requests vacation of two alleys that are in the southwest corner of West 11th Street and North Rogers

04:24:57.045 --> 04:25:05.491
- Street. These parcels are part of the trades district west phase and are being prepared for redevelopment.

04:25:05.491 --> 04:25:13.385
- The council sponsor is Council Member Asari. Thank you. The board needs 2026-34 be adopted. Second.

04:25:13.385 --> 04:25:18.910
- Okay. Who is here to present? I think Director Coopersmith is online.

04:25:19.106 --> 04:25:29.555
- Okay, Director Coopersmith, I'm hoping you're still with us. Please take it away if you are here. In

04:25:29.555 --> 04:25:39.901
- some ways, this feels like talking to a ghost. She's here. I just don't know. And she's unmuted, so

04:25:39.901 --> 04:25:47.454
- she just needs to be given access, I guess, or something. Council staff?

04:25:47.842 --> 04:26:11.710
- Is Director Coopersmith able to unmute? Okay. Okay. Director Coopersmith, are you with us? A chat perhaps?

04:26:28.322 --> 04:26:40.511
- Hey. Unfortunately, if you are trying to speak, we can't hear you. If you aren't trying to speak, you

04:26:40.511 --> 04:26:52.222
- should be unmuted. And please try again. I have to admit, you guys, I don't know what to do here.

04:26:53.730 --> 04:26:59.800
- did right and she said that she was speaking and she was questioning whether why we couldn't hear her

04:26:59.800 --> 04:27:03.966
- oh so okay yes unfortunately director Gruber Smith we cannot hear you

04:27:18.626 --> 04:27:25.997
- I can just read what she wrote. She said, my audio isn't working. I didn't have a formal presentation

04:27:25.997 --> 04:27:33.224
- this evening. Ms. Fernanda has been in communication and submitted formal materials. I'm supportive

04:27:33.224 --> 04:27:40.740
- of this hourly vacation in order to facilitate this economic development project in the Trade District.

04:27:40.740 --> 04:27:47.678
- Thank you very much. Does anyone have any questions? I recognize that this is not conventional,

04:27:49.058 --> 04:27:58.566
- Sometimes you do what you can with what you have. Does anyone have any questions? Okay. Would anybody

04:27:58.566 --> 04:28:08.074
- like to speak in terms of public comment? I'm not seeing anyone get up. Anyone on Zoom? Okay. Council

04:28:08.074 --> 04:28:18.142
- comments? Council Member Piedmont-Smith and then Council Member Flaherty. Well, just for the public in case

04:28:18.658 --> 04:28:27.715
- Anybody is still paying attention aside from the few people here in the room. But this is about two

04:28:27.715 --> 04:28:37.135
- alley segments north of the Beeline Heights apartment building at the corner roughly of Rogers and West

04:28:37.135 --> 04:28:46.193
- 11th Street. So just so you know what we're talking about here. And Mr. Fernandez, the director of,

04:28:46.193 --> 04:28:48.638
- what's it called? Amplify.

04:28:48.738 --> 04:28:58.740
- Sorry, I changed its name. Presented this at our last regular session. And the reasoning, I believe,

04:28:58.740 --> 04:29:08.644
- was because they want to maintain maximum flexibility for proposals from developers to develop that

04:29:08.644 --> 04:29:17.854
- land. So anyway, I'm just saying that because there was really no context for people online.

04:29:19.618 --> 04:29:26.152
- Thank you. Any other final comments? Councilmember Rosen, pardon, oh, I'm so sorry. Councilmember Flaherty,

04:29:26.152 --> 04:29:32.202
- I forgot about you. Thank you. When we heard this at first reading, I indicated that would probably

04:29:32.202 --> 04:29:38.615
- be a no vote, and I in fact will be. I mentioned that it's just a pretty tall bar for me to vacate public

04:29:38.615 --> 04:29:44.725
- land. It's a decision that has, you know, lasts in perpetuity, could have impacts a century from now

04:29:44.725 --> 04:29:46.238
- that we don't know about

04:29:46.370 --> 04:29:52.678
- Whatever gets built there next is long gone. We might wish we had the alley. Also, I think there are

04:29:52.678 --> 04:29:59.485
- near-term benefits to alleys that are multiple. They help with utilities, where you put trash and dumpsters,

04:29:59.485 --> 04:30:05.856
- where you put vehicles to load instead of, say, blocking college or Walnut, which can lead to its own

04:30:05.856 --> 04:30:12.164
- problems, or any other street for that matter. They help control building massing and keep things at

04:30:12.164 --> 04:30:14.974
- a human scale. There's just lots of reasons.

04:30:15.234 --> 04:30:20.511
- There are cases to be made, give the Convention Center as an example. I'm not a big fan of the public

04:30:20.511 --> 04:30:25.685
- money we spent on that project. Sure, a building that size for the purpose of a convention needs to

04:30:25.685 --> 04:30:31.118
- be the size of a city block. I get it. Let's vacate an alley for that. But here, there's really no pitch

04:30:31.118 --> 04:30:36.396
- being made. The planning memo says, well, they're not currently being used as alleys, and they're not

04:30:36.396 --> 04:30:41.983
- currently improved. But again, that's really not the question we should be asking about when we're vacating

04:30:41.983 --> 04:30:43.070
- public land forever.

04:30:43.234 --> 04:30:49.878
- And then the ordinance itself, there's a whereas clause that says this is essentially the case being

04:30:49.878 --> 04:30:56.653
- made. Amplify is interested in furthering development of the land and existing alleys would negatively

04:30:56.653 --> 04:31:03.495
- impact the potential sale and development of the real estate. That's just sort of like a true statement

04:31:03.495 --> 04:31:09.086
- for anyone trying to sell land, like giving away public land for private development

04:31:09.442 --> 04:31:16.468
- will make that private developer happier. That's just a given. There's no strong case being made. I

04:31:16.468 --> 04:31:23.776
- just don't really see it. I understand why it would be more attractive for somebody to not have to deal

04:31:23.776 --> 04:31:31.084
- with the public allies. So I understand the rationale, but I just don't think, to me, it's aligned with

04:31:31.084 --> 04:31:38.110
- the public interest more broadly. Thank you. Thank you very much. And I'm very sorry, but I have to

04:31:38.370 --> 04:31:45.016
- open up public comment again because I forgot to read my script that attorney Rossman so graciously

04:31:45.016 --> 04:31:51.861
- provided me. I note for the record that public hearing notice ran in the Herald Times on October 23rd,

04:31:51.861 --> 04:31:58.773
- 2026 and went by certified mail to all three abutting owners at the notice November 4th regular session

04:31:58.773 --> 04:32:05.485
- hearing. No public objections were offered. Public comment will also be taken tonight. And if anyone

04:32:05.485 --> 04:32:06.814
- has public comment,

04:32:07.042 --> 04:32:17.146
- Please approach the podium and state your name, if you would. Very well. Very well stated. Once it's

04:32:17.146 --> 04:32:27.551
- gone, it's gone. And right now there's no obvious reason for why it has to be vacated. Thank you. Thank

04:32:27.551 --> 04:32:35.454
- you very much. Anyone else in public comment? Online? OK. Then that concludes.

04:32:36.546 --> 04:32:43.581
- the public hearing. Council Member Rosenberger and then Ruff. I got a little something I would like

04:32:43.581 --> 04:32:50.617
- to first say hard ditto to what Council Member Flaherty said. Although I would like to say, I don't

04:32:50.617 --> 04:32:57.722
- think vacating an alley is always super profitable for a developer. For instance, you can park in an

04:32:57.722 --> 04:33:01.662
- alley for 15 minutes, I think, in our city code without

04:33:02.018 --> 04:33:10.552
- parking and finding a spot, paying a meter. I'm just saying, not everyone do it, but I think it's allowed

04:33:10.552 --> 04:33:18.361
- a little bit. I mean, the access that alleys give us are pretty cool, and that's why they exist.

04:33:18.361 --> 04:33:26.573
- And I just, again, hard ditto that we shouldn't be giving away public land like this. Thanks. Council

04:33:26.573 --> 04:33:31.806
- Member Ruff and then Rollo. I agree that Council Member Flaherty

04:33:31.938 --> 04:33:46.539
- put it very eloquently and very effectively. So over the years, I served on council, we've vacated alleys,

04:33:46.539 --> 04:34:00.321
- spaces for various times and for various reasons. Sometimes I felt strongly one way or the other. In

04:34:00.321 --> 04:34:01.822
- this case,

04:34:02.946 --> 04:34:11.542
- I'm leaning towards going ahead and approving it, I guess, at this point. When we say once it's gone,

04:34:11.542 --> 04:34:20.054
- once we have an easement or an alleyway or something like this, it's gone forever. I mean, arguably,

04:34:20.054 --> 04:34:28.482
- yeah, but government has the power of eminent domain that most other entities don't. So, and though

04:34:28.482 --> 04:34:32.190
- I'm loathe to use it, and I hate to see it,

04:34:32.578 --> 04:34:41.691
- It is an option if there was a dramatic need in a given situation, even something that spun off of something

04:34:41.691 --> 04:34:50.720
- like this. But I don't really foresee anything like that. So I really appreciate the way it was articulated

04:34:50.720 --> 04:34:59.081
- by Council Member Flaherty. But at this point, I think I'm going to be voting. Go ahead and support

04:34:59.081 --> 04:35:02.174
- it. Thank you. Council Member Rallo.

04:35:06.114 --> 04:35:15.165
- I generally agree with my colleagues who are loath to give up private land, especially alleys that could

04:35:15.165 --> 04:35:24.044
- be utilized for transportation and connectivity and so forth. I've generally been very judicious about

04:35:24.044 --> 04:35:32.836
- doing it. As Council Member Ruff said, I think in this case with no apparent use of these alleys, but

04:35:32.836 --> 04:35:35.422
- with an apparent public good,

04:35:36.226 --> 04:35:45.952
- to provide flexibility because this happens to be a node for one of the most promising areas for job

04:35:45.952 --> 04:35:55.582
- creation. I trend towards approving this. So on balance, I think this serves a public good and I'll

04:35:55.582 --> 04:36:05.982
- be supporting it. Thank you. Any final comments? Council Member Stosberg. I have a question first, I guess.

04:36:06.082 --> 04:36:12.197
- The problem I'm struggling with right now is which person should I ask this to? Because I'm not sure

04:36:12.197 --> 04:36:18.434
- if Director Cooper-Smith is going to know the answer, or I don't know if council members, sorry, might

04:36:18.434 --> 04:36:24.549
- be able to address it. But one of the things that- I'm happy to answer, but also John's on line. Oh,

04:36:24.549 --> 04:36:30.604
- wonderful. OK, so maybe Mr. Fernandez can address this. But one of the things that I remember being

04:36:30.604 --> 04:36:33.086
- mentioned was the idea that essentially,

04:36:33.986 --> 04:36:42.607
- These alleys essentially form a cross, right? And the south end and the west end, essentially dead end

04:36:42.607 --> 04:36:51.143
- and other properties. And so to me, it makes complete sense to vacate the alleys that are essentially

04:36:51.143 --> 04:36:59.597
- alleys to nowhere. We talk about sidewalks to nowhere sometimes. These are alleys to nowhere. But it

04:36:59.597 --> 04:37:03.614
- makes less sense for me to think about vacating

04:37:04.034 --> 04:37:12.136
- north section and the east section, because they would kind of form an L, which is sort of how we have

04:37:12.136 --> 04:37:20.317
- the alley on the other side in the trades district. We vacated part of the alley, so then it would form

04:37:20.317 --> 04:37:28.419
- an L around, I can't remember which building, the forge, no, the mill. I can't remember which building

04:37:28.419 --> 04:37:30.622
- that is anymore, the forge.

04:37:30.786 --> 04:37:37.477
- And so I guess the question is whether there was consideration of that vacation and whether that would

04:37:37.477 --> 04:37:44.103
- potentially compromise with the Amplify Bloomington and the Trades District plan to make it easier to

04:37:44.103 --> 04:37:50.794
- build there, but also maybe kind of a compromise with my colleagues who are reluctant to vacate public

04:37:50.794 --> 04:37:57.356
- land because those two sections of alley, they're just not going anywhere. They're not gonna be good

04:37:57.356 --> 04:37:58.590
- for anything ever.

04:38:08.162 --> 04:38:18.888
- I'm happy to jump in, President Esau, because that's OK. I'm not sharing. Oh, sorry. It's totally fine.

04:38:18.888 --> 04:38:29.511
- I apologize for joining like I'm on the road here. But I hear what you're saying on that question. But

04:38:29.511 --> 04:38:35.390
- I think the issue is that these are at least to nowhere.

04:38:36.802 --> 04:38:45.620
- They've never been really improved. They're platted. They're impediments to kind of thinking about how

04:38:45.620 --> 04:38:54.439
- someone might want to build on these properties. The alley that runs to the south does not even go all

04:38:54.439 --> 04:39:03.599
- the way through the land that we owned. It stops halfway through the property, so it doesn't even continue

04:39:03.599 --> 04:39:04.798
- to the south.

04:39:05.506 --> 04:39:16.202
- where the apartments are, so it would run into that parking lot if it was continued all the way to the

04:39:16.202 --> 04:39:27.001
- south. The east-west, as it goes towards the Bender property, even if the Bender property was developed

04:39:27.001 --> 04:39:34.270
- on the west end of the Bender property, is one of those major utility

04:39:35.266 --> 04:39:46.992
- poles that has the high power lines for electric that you cannot build under. So you cannot run an alley

04:39:46.992 --> 04:39:58.382
- to the west all the way to Fairview. At the end of the day, the whole issue in my view is that alleys

04:39:58.382 --> 04:40:03.966
- are supposed to provide access for, historically,

04:40:04.578 --> 04:40:17.761
- for deliveries and other kinds of egress into a property. They weren't originally designed to be pedestrian

04:40:17.761 --> 04:40:30.334
- ways or even access for vehicles. They were mainly for deliveries. If you look at the site as a whole,

04:40:31.074 --> 04:40:38.311
- As it develops, anything that happens on this property is going to have to go through the planning

04:40:38.311 --> 04:40:45.621
- department. If it's a site plan, it's going to go to the planning commission. So the whole issue of

04:40:45.621 --> 04:40:52.931
- like access and whether it's pedestrian, whether it's deliveries, whether it's vehicles is going to

04:40:52.931 --> 04:41:00.606
- require a substantial amount of review. And so I, you know, we're talking about theoretical things about

04:41:00.834 --> 04:41:09.002
- what could happen or not happen. And at the end of the day, nothing has happened on this property for

04:41:09.002 --> 04:41:17.650
- a very long time. And so I would hope that we would trust the planning staff, trust the planning commission

04:41:17.650 --> 04:41:26.459
- and others to ensure that any development plan that goes forward on this property is going to be sufficiently

04:41:26.459 --> 04:41:29.982
- reviewed and all these issues of access and

04:41:30.370 --> 04:41:40.160
- Yeah, connectivity are gonna be addressed in a meaningful way. Thank you. If I could, I think, Mr. Fernandez,

04:41:40.160 --> 04:41:49.328
- I appreciate your response, but I think that you missed what I was asking in terms of, right now, it's

04:41:49.328 --> 04:41:54.846
- a cross-shape alley, so I'm asking about the consideration of

04:41:55.458 --> 04:42:02.467
- whether you considered only requesting vacating part of that to make it an L-shaped alley, and then

04:42:02.467 --> 04:42:09.616
- it would connect 11th Street to Rogers Street. And so the two pieces that you mentioned that are kind

04:42:09.616 --> 04:42:16.765
- of going to nowhere, those would be vacated. And public property would be maintained in that L-shape.

04:42:16.765 --> 04:42:19.358
- And that's, I think, what the debate

04:42:19.458 --> 04:42:27.924
- or the concern was by a couple of my colleagues and by the public commenters, this idea of vacating

04:42:27.924 --> 04:42:36.389
- public right of way forever and that it's kind of a giveaway to private enterprise. Yeah, no, I did

04:42:36.389 --> 04:42:45.109
- not misinterpret the question. I may not have answered it sufficiently. I just think that those alleys

04:42:45.109 --> 04:42:49.342
- were never developed. The city had them on a map.

04:42:50.178 --> 04:42:58.345
- And so we're not giving up anything. I think that the notion, the way it works is that you've got these

04:42:58.345 --> 04:43:06.826
- impediments to people bringing forward plans because they can't develop anything with any kind of certainty

04:43:06.826 --> 04:43:14.835
- because they don't know what the rules are. And at the end of the day, that's the issue we have. This

04:43:14.835 --> 04:43:18.526
- property has been undeveloped for a long time.

04:43:19.586 --> 04:43:27.904
- It has other impediments. It has the recorded environmental conditions. It has unbelievably

04:43:27.904 --> 04:43:36.945
- old infrastructure. The water lines on it are from 1920. There are a bunch of impediments to anyone

04:43:36.945 --> 04:43:46.439
- being able to bring forward a plan because they don't know what they can or can't do. And so the premise

04:43:46.439 --> 04:43:47.614
- here is that

04:43:47.810 --> 04:43:57.943
- let's trust the process that if we're interested in having adequate planning for pedestrians, for vehicles,

04:43:57.943 --> 04:44:07.700
- for other kinds of access at piece of property, that we have so many layers of review and consideration

04:44:07.700 --> 04:44:14.174
- that are going to bring those kinds of conditions and considerations

04:44:14.370 --> 04:44:21.914
- Uh, into the public process for review and, and, and ultimately for decision-making that we've got place.

04:44:21.914 --> 04:44:29.103
- We've got a lot of processes here that can ensure that we're going to address those kinds of issues.

04:44:29.103 --> 04:44:36.362
- But right now, I mean, there's just so much uncertainty. Nobody wants to, you know, take the risk and

04:44:36.362 --> 04:44:42.910
- make commitments and design plans because they don't know what the rules are. I think that.

04:44:43.746 --> 04:44:51.385
- all these issues, whether it's an L-shaped, it might be a different shape. But Council Member Strouser,

04:44:51.385 --> 04:44:58.877
- I think that at the end of the day, anybody who's gonna make this kind of investment is going to want

04:44:58.877 --> 04:45:06.589
- to ensure that you have the right kind of ingress, egress, that's gonna serve their needs and the public

04:45:06.589 --> 04:45:09.086
- need. And whether it's a T-shape,

04:45:09.762 --> 04:45:19.044
- or some other shape, I don't know. But I think we have plenty of guardrails in place to ensure that

04:45:19.044 --> 04:45:28.697
- we address those kind of public considerations. Thank you. Are there any final comments? Council Member

04:45:28.697 --> 04:45:36.030
- Flaherty. First of all, just noting again that in this case and in many cases,

04:45:36.162 --> 04:45:41.672
- The idea of pedestrian access or something is quite minimal or ancillary and so is connectivity. Like

04:45:41.672 --> 04:45:47.181
- those are not the primary benefits of alleys in my mind, which kind of became a little bit of a focus

04:45:47.181 --> 04:45:52.637
- in the discussion. I also don't, with respect to Mr. Fernandez, don't quite understand the idea that

04:45:52.637 --> 04:45:58.093
- there's uncertainty about the rules. Alleys are alleys. They're public right of way. You can't build

04:45:58.093 --> 04:46:02.846
- them full stop. Like those are the rules. We're considering changing the rules tonight.

04:46:02.946 --> 04:46:09.616
- and creating a new set of rules, and that benefits a private developer who will have more land and more

04:46:09.616 --> 04:46:16.222
- flexibility in the size of things they can build and what they can do with it. I get that, but I just,

04:46:16.222 --> 04:46:22.251
- I'm gonna have to disagree that having alleys, you know, creates uncertainty. I think a good,

04:46:22.251 --> 04:46:29.050
- I don't know, analog to consider is Hopewell, where the council fought very hard last term to get planted

04:46:29.050 --> 04:46:31.038
- alleys into the Hopewell site.

04:46:31.298 --> 04:46:37.077
- the administration didn't want to. They wanted a giant blank slate with no alleys there. And I think,

04:46:37.077 --> 04:46:42.742
- again, for value engineering and other purposes, what most likely is going to happen when you don't

04:46:42.742 --> 04:46:48.464
- set the basic urban form in a pattern that has worked very well for us for a very, very long time is

04:46:48.464 --> 04:46:50.334
- that you're not going to use it.

04:46:50.818 --> 04:46:56.040
- And I really don't think that the plan commission or planning staff process is up to the task

04:46:56.040 --> 04:47:01.763
- of administering that. It's not that I don't trust their processes. It's about what they're suited for

04:47:01.763 --> 04:47:07.374
- and what they're not suited for. So when it comes to the basic urban fabric and rules of the game, I

04:47:07.374 --> 04:47:13.152
- just think and have always thought that, you know, public alleys are an important piece of that fabric.

04:47:13.152 --> 04:47:18.875
- I still think that, again, it's not that they can never be vacated, but I'm just really not seeing the

04:47:18.875 --> 04:47:19.486
- case here.

04:47:19.778 --> 04:47:25.315
- even though I understand that the folks at Amfly Bloomington feel strongly about it. Again, I appreciate

04:47:25.315 --> 04:47:31.115
- Mr. Fernandez being here with us very late and the petition itself. So thank you. Council Member Rosenberger.

04:47:31.115 --> 04:47:36.757
- Things written down, we do know the rules. They're very clear. We don't build on public roads. The parcels

04:47:36.757 --> 04:47:42.188
- are smaller across the street. I mean, I assume this is going to pass. I would urge my colleagues stop

04:47:42.188 --> 04:47:47.566
- using alley connectivity as a big test for whether or not we should vacate an alley. We have a lot of

04:47:47.566 --> 04:47:48.990
- alleys that don't connect.

04:47:49.250 --> 04:47:56.925
- And I think vacating them in the life of a city over centuries is short-sighted. I live in Prospects

04:47:56.925 --> 04:48:04.979
- Hill. Our alleys don't connect. People use them. We've had somebody here come and ask to vacate an alley.

04:48:04.979 --> 04:48:12.958
- I just don't want us to start doing that. I think there are barriers. There can be barriers to building.

04:48:13.154 --> 04:48:19.467
- The public realm and the pedestrian realm doesn't do well with massive buildings. It does better with

04:48:19.467 --> 04:48:25.842
- smaller buildings. So I think that is fine. I think there are a lot of creative ways. I don't know why

04:48:25.842 --> 04:48:32.527
- the building has to be so big, I guess. Also, the RDC is into giving land away at the expense of taxpayers.

04:48:32.527 --> 04:48:38.840
- So if there are a lot of barriers on this property, I feel like it could be given away to developers,

04:48:38.840 --> 04:48:42.430
- I guess. I think I feel very strongly that we should keep

04:48:42.722 --> 04:48:50.936
- City's public land and we should be good stewards of that. Thanks Their final comments councilmember

04:48:50.936 --> 04:48:59.474
- Stasberg I'm at this point pretty Well convinced as I'm looking at this picture that I would much prefer

04:48:59.474 --> 04:49:07.932
- to keep an L shaped alley here and if we I would be open to continuing that and working on an amendment

04:49:07.932 --> 04:49:11.998
- if That is something that would be of interest to

04:49:12.258 --> 04:49:20.861
- a majority of my colleagues. But I think that it would be much more interesting for that whole area

04:49:20.861 --> 04:49:29.722
- to have it kind of mirror that other block, which also has an L-shaped alley around the forge and that

04:49:29.722 --> 04:49:38.669
- hotel. I don't think that it's ideal in that space, just thinking about how that space is, to just have

04:49:38.669 --> 04:49:40.734
- one big building there.

04:49:41.954 --> 04:49:52.216
- If it's not one big building, then why do we need to vacate the alleys? I agree with Councilmember Flaherty,

04:49:52.216 --> 04:50:01.819
- the planning commission and that whole process, they don't deal with road access as much as they deal

04:50:01.819 --> 04:50:09.822
- with building design. And then if something kind of checks all the boxes, then it's,

04:50:10.018 --> 04:50:18.249
- You know, yeah, it goes to your plan commission, but it's almost like a rubber stamp. Like, oh, they

04:50:18.249 --> 04:50:26.969
- met all the requirements, so we just have to say yes at this point. So I'm gonna vote no, I guess, tonight

04:50:26.969 --> 04:50:35.525
- on this unless there is a motion to continue and look at amending to make it an L instead of that cross.

04:50:35.525 --> 04:50:38.622
- Thanks. Councilmember Piedmont-Smith.

04:50:39.778 --> 04:50:48.920
- Yeah, I like the idea of keeping the north and east portions of this alley network that would

04:50:48.920 --> 04:50:58.743
- be a connection, and it's kind of a compromise. And I do think there's value in alleys. I agree with

04:50:58.743 --> 04:51:09.246
- what Councilmembers Flaherty and Rosenberger have said. That's really the only thing that would prevent one

04:51:09.794 --> 04:51:19.957
- Building, well, we may have some rules about building with, no we don't, okay. We have building variation

04:51:19.957 --> 04:51:29.833
- in the facade, but it could still be one building, which I think would not be very pedestrian friendly

04:51:29.833 --> 04:51:38.558
- or very, well, it's just not a good fit for the city. So I would be in favor of postponing

04:51:39.106 --> 04:51:47.773
- and working on amending this, because if we vote this down now, I think they cannot bring back a new

04:51:47.773 --> 04:51:56.612
- proposal for just part of the alleys. I think it's a no for forever, at least for a significant period

04:51:56.612 --> 04:52:05.365
- of time. So that's where I'm standing now. I think I would vote no tonight, but if we could pare down

04:52:05.365 --> 04:52:08.798
- the request, I would probably vote yes.

04:52:11.970 --> 04:52:19.764
- I see Mr. Fernandez has his hand up. I was prepared to make a motion. Mr. Fernandez, do you?

04:52:19.764 --> 04:52:28.228
- Let's go with Mr. Fernandez first then. Yeah, you know, I mean, I understand what people are saying.

04:52:28.228 --> 04:52:36.609
- I appreciate it. But, you know, I mean, there's so many conflicting objectives that I hear from the

04:52:36.609 --> 04:52:39.710
- city as it relates to how we want to

04:52:41.122 --> 04:52:51.843
- Uh, see our city evolve. Um, and you know, when, when you have things like recorded environmental conditions

04:52:51.843 --> 04:53:02.073
- that increases the complexity and the cost, uh, that anybody who wants to bring forward a proposal that

04:53:02.073 --> 04:53:08.958
- might be exactly, um, aligned with the ambitions of the city council.

04:53:10.050 --> 04:53:23.633
- that at the end of the day, sometimes form is not going to be able to meet this kind of historic shape

04:53:23.633 --> 04:53:36.030
- of blocks. You require a little bit of density to be able to offset the infrastructure costs,

04:53:36.450 --> 04:53:46.584
- and the remediation costs. This is a brownfield that has been vacant for a very long time and you know

04:53:46.584 --> 04:53:56.718
- it's a trade-off and I appreciate that but at the end of the day it's like the objective of the trades

04:53:56.718 --> 04:54:05.278
- district is to try and bring if you read the your own plans it's about bringing a more

04:54:05.634 --> 04:54:13.873
- Mitch use urban development to increase economic activity for our city. And, you know, maybe it's a

04:54:13.873 --> 04:54:22.113
- leap of faith and I appreciate if you don't want to make that, but at some point, you know, we have

04:54:22.113 --> 04:54:30.352
- to work together to try and bring forward some ideas that might actually take this undeveloped land

04:54:30.352 --> 04:54:34.142
- that's not producing a single dime of benefit

04:54:35.138 --> 04:54:46.475
- to the public into some kind of activity that delivers value. And we can have a platted alley that has

04:54:46.475 --> 04:54:57.592
- never been improved, never been developed and maintained by the city of Bloomington and have it on a

04:54:57.592 --> 04:55:00.894
- map and have vacant property.

04:55:01.698 --> 04:55:11.125
- Or we can remove these impediments. Let's work together to bring forward something that might actually

04:55:11.125 --> 04:55:20.460
- deliver some real value to the community. And I'm just asking you that I think we've tried to deliver

04:55:20.460 --> 04:55:24.670
- benefit to the community. Let's move forward.

04:55:26.242 --> 04:55:34.242
- I know there's a lot of mistrust and all of that when it comes to development. But I think the people

04:55:34.242 --> 04:55:42.241
- who are working here are trying to do things that are for our collective benefit. And if you don't do

04:55:42.241 --> 04:55:50.241
- this and you say, well, we've got to impose some development model that may or may not be relevant to

04:55:50.241 --> 04:55:55.966
- the market, you may have vacant property for another who knows how long.

04:55:56.514 --> 04:56:03.839
- You know, I don't think that's going to serve our interest. Thank you. Council member, sorry.

04:56:03.839 --> 04:56:11.631
- Thanks so much. And I'm happy to vote on this tonight. I mean, just I mean, guess being the sponsor

04:56:11.631 --> 04:56:19.579
- doesn't necessarily mean that one is in favor of it. In this case, I am. I'll be as brief as possible

04:56:19.579 --> 04:56:26.046
- because I know it's very late. But, you know, I think we have, as I understand it,

04:56:26.146 --> 04:56:35.219
- arguments on both sides here. As I see it, the arguments in support of vacating the alley are one that

04:56:35.219 --> 04:56:44.732
- it's not currently being used. This two notion that as currently plated, they don't connect to any existing

04:56:44.732 --> 04:56:46.494
- network. That three

04:56:47.138 --> 04:56:57.886
- They are obstructing or at least presenting a challenge to redevelopment and I think that that point we have.

04:56:57.986 --> 04:57:06.748
- evidence for in our packet, not just in the arguments of the person requesting it of Amplified Bloomington,

04:57:06.748 --> 04:57:14.941
- our trades district more specifically. But the planning department says they agree that the existing

04:57:14.941 --> 04:57:23.297
- right of ways make adequate construction space along the 11th Street extremely difficult and that they

04:57:23.297 --> 04:57:27.678
- complicate development of the adjoining southern lot.

04:57:27.778 --> 04:57:35.704
- I think I do agree that the arguments, you know, when we think about the long term, you know, 100 years

04:57:35.704 --> 04:57:43.325
- out, certainly, I find that a compelling argument. And, you know, and I don't think that it should,

04:57:43.325 --> 04:57:51.099
- I do think that we should have a high standard of vacating alleys. But I think that one of the things

04:57:51.099 --> 04:57:52.318
- that makes this

04:57:52.514 --> 04:57:59.577
- A particular and different case and I made, I think the same argument when we were looking at the other

04:57:59.577 --> 04:58:05.214
- at the other vacation that we did in the trades district is that you know there's.

04:58:05.602 --> 04:58:14.399
- We're investing and have invested a lot of of our economic development strategy in the success of the

04:58:14.399 --> 04:58:23.454
- trades district and and we're already receiving a huge return on investment. And this is going to enable

04:58:23.586 --> 04:58:31.246
- I think the highest return of all of the investments that have been made in that place and then bring

04:58:31.246 --> 04:58:39.057
- them to the next level that seems to me critical that we get the most, that we complete what it is that

04:58:39.057 --> 04:58:46.793
- we're trying to do in this district and be able in this case to bring ideally more housing, to attract

04:58:46.793 --> 04:58:53.552
- more people to Bloomington, to do the type of things that we wanna see to really activate

04:58:53.552 --> 04:59:04.916
- that sector of our city. And so when I think about that ecosystem, to me, this really advances our existing

04:59:04.916 --> 04:59:11.230
- redevelopment plans there. And so I really would urge us to

04:59:11.362 --> 04:59:18.578
- Aside from the fact that it's late, I do think that this is sort of the right time. And I also understand

04:59:18.578 --> 04:59:25.454
- that there's some time pressures because I know that there are a lot of people looking at this plot,

04:59:25.454 --> 04:59:32.329
- trying to enter into negotiations. So having some clarity about this will help us move forward a lot

04:59:32.329 --> 04:59:39.137
- quicker. So for those and some other reasons that I'm just so tired, but many other reasons I think

04:59:39.137 --> 04:59:40.158
- that we should

04:59:40.226 --> 04:59:49.140
- We should vote for this today. Council member Rollo. Yes, I was going to make a motion, but I think

04:59:49.140 --> 04:59:58.856
- I prefer not to. I think that Council member Stossberg's point is well taken. The L shape has some potential

04:59:58.856 --> 05:00:06.878
- utility, but on balance and decisions are usually made on a basis of sometimes tradeoffs.

05:00:07.362 --> 05:00:15.621
- I think the public good is best served by the vacation. I think that what Mr. Fernandez says is correct.

05:00:15.621 --> 05:00:23.644
- This has been a vacant parcel for a long time. I was part of the original council during the purchase

05:00:23.644 --> 05:00:31.588
- back in 2011. We've been waiting for this to fully materialize and there's been various impediments.

05:00:31.588 --> 05:00:35.678
- I think there has been a lot of good work going on.

05:00:35.874 --> 05:00:45.094
- As I said, it happens to be one of the nodes for most promising area of job creation in the city. I

05:00:45.094 --> 05:00:54.315
- think that on balance, yes, there are good arguments. I was very insistent on maintaining alleyways

05:00:54.315 --> 05:01:03.166
- at Hopewell. I fought very hard for walk paths, for connectivity that the city should maintain.

05:01:03.298 --> 05:01:11.836
- I have more of a record for maintaining alleys than vacating them. But I think in this case, it's justified

05:01:11.836 --> 05:01:20.136
- because I think that flexibility is needed because I can't anticipate what minimum space would be needed

05:01:20.136 --> 05:01:27.646
- for tech purposes. And I would like to provide that flexibility. So I'll be voting in support.

05:01:32.386 --> 05:01:46.630
- I would just like to move to continue this ordinance 202634 to our next regular session on December

05:01:46.630 --> 05:02:02.014
- 2nd. Is this something we can discuss? OK, any discussion? OK, I'll just say I'm not in favor. Anyone else?

05:02:02.370 --> 05:02:25.102
- Okay, will the clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Asari? No. Daly? No. Rallo? No. Ruff?

05:02:25.102 --> 05:02:30.366
- No. Rosenberger? Yes.

05:02:31.778 --> 05:02:42.953
- Clarity. Yes. Stasberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. So like no. Okay. Thank you. That fails for five.

05:02:42.953 --> 05:02:54.574
- Would anyone else like to make a comment before we vote. Councilmember Rosenberger. I. Is it known that

05:02:54.574 --> 05:03:01.726
- people are trying to develop this right now or is that unknown.

05:03:03.650 --> 05:03:10.411
- We have passed the time for questions. Somebody just asked a question. I mean, it's not in our notes

05:03:10.411 --> 05:03:17.105
- that there is somebody wanting to develop it. But someone has talked to me about wanting this alley

05:03:17.105 --> 05:03:23.933
- vacated to develop it. And I just wanted to know. I kind of thought the message we're getting is just

05:03:23.933 --> 05:03:31.028
- in case. But I think there is someone who wants this. And I just want to know if we have the whole story.

05:03:31.028 --> 05:03:33.438
- Who are you asking the question to?

05:03:34.050 --> 05:03:45.224
- Mister Fernandez. We've had 2 previous proposals that did not move forward. Because of the. Impediments.

05:03:45.224 --> 05:03:55.866
- We've had a couple of other folks who are interested genuinely. But you know no one's ready to pull

05:03:55.866 --> 05:04:03.102
- the trigger because they don't know what the rules are going to be.

05:04:03.362 --> 05:04:11.892
- Yeah, and I know what, you know, I mean, you can say, well, the rules are that the allies are platted.

05:04:11.892 --> 05:04:20.338
- But at the end of the day, it's going to be very difficult from an economic perspective to be able to

05:04:20.338 --> 05:04:28.619
- develop something that takes into the limitations that this site as it's currently platted present.

05:04:28.619 --> 05:04:30.110
- So yes, there are

05:04:30.210 --> 05:04:42.028
- potentially some interest in moving forward. We'd like to move forward, but the folks who are interested

05:04:42.028 --> 05:04:53.959
- can't make it work with these allies because you're limiting the scale. And yes, that's the issue, right?

05:04:53.959 --> 05:04:58.686
- And I think that's a reasonable argument.

05:04:59.202 --> 05:05:06.845
- I know that Councilmember Flaherty said this a lot, and I think that's a reasonable argument to say

05:05:06.845 --> 05:05:14.488
- that alleys limit scale. They do. And in some circumstances that makes a lot of sense, but when you

05:05:14.488 --> 05:05:22.207
- have other kinds of impediments that are on the property, scale matters because you have to overcome

05:05:22.207 --> 05:05:26.334
- some of the other development costs that are related.

05:05:26.754 --> 05:05:33.657
- So yes, there are people interested, but do they want to come forward? And we don't have a deal. We

05:05:33.657 --> 05:05:40.975
- don't have a specific proposal. We have some ideas. We have talked to several people that are interested.

05:05:40.975 --> 05:05:48.154
- But as the property is currently configured, it just won't work. Thank you. Yes, I wanted to know that.

05:05:48.154 --> 05:05:53.470
- I mean, I understand this is going to pass. I think, too, I just want to say

05:05:53.634 --> 05:06:01.824
- It feels like people are talking like either we vacate these alleys or nothing happens here and it is

05:06:01.824 --> 05:06:10.176
- not binary. We can like economic development and we can like alleys. Big cities have alleys everywhere.

05:06:10.176 --> 05:06:18.366
- They're not a detriment to buildings. So I just do want to make sure that's clear. Thanks. Thank you.

05:06:18.498 --> 05:06:27.874
- But big cities do not have Mr. Fernandez. I'm sorry. We're not where we've passed the point of going

05:06:27.874 --> 05:06:37.713
- back and forth. Council member Stossberg. I'm sorry. I think that you have reached your limit of speaking

05:06:37.713 --> 05:06:47.646
- times. Would anyone else like to speak? Okay. Well, the clerk, please call the roll. Council member daily.

05:06:49.890 --> 05:07:01.423
- Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. No. Flaherty. No. Stossberg. No. Piedmont-Smith. No. Zulek.

05:07:01.423 --> 05:07:13.069
- Yes. Asari. Yes. Thank you. That passes 5-4. And now we're moving on to our additional public comment

05:07:13.069 --> 05:07:19.806
- section. Would anyone like to speak during public comment?

05:07:21.538 --> 05:07:30.343
- Okay, thank you. Now matters of council schedule. Does anyone have a council scheduling update? Okay,

05:07:30.343 --> 05:07:33.278
- great. This meeting is adjourned.
