Welcome to our regularly scheduled council meeting. Would the lovely clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Flaherty? Here. Stossberg? Here. Piedmont-Smith? Here. Zulek? Here. Asari? Here. Daly? Here. Rallo? Here. Ruff? Here. Rosenberger? Here. All right. Thank you very much. And it looks like there are no minutes for approval. Then we'll have our report section for council members, then a presentation on the climate action plan implementation by Sean Mia, council committee report, and our first section of general public comment. Then we will have any appointments to boards and commissions, legislation for first reading, including title 16 amendments to the Bloomington Municipal Code to update the residential rental unit and lodging establishment inspection program and add a new section on short-term rentals, an ordinance to amend Title X of the Bloomington Municipal Code titled Wastewater regarding fats, oils, and grease, and amending Title VI of the Bloomington Municipal Code to update fees and billing and define new requirements for second readings resolutions. We have a resolution to affirm the City of Bloomington as a welcoming and inclusive community for LGBTQ plus residents and visitors and to reinforce local commitments to equal protection, health care access and human rights. We will have an ordinance to fix the salaries of all elected city officials for the City of Bloomington for the year 2027. An ordinance for UDO amendments related to housing attainability and finally an ordinance to vacate an alley on the southwest corner of West 11th Street and North Roger Street. We will conclude with one final section for public comment and council schedule. Okay. Reports from any council members. Council member Stasberg. Thank you. I was originally planning on trying to make a planned comment this evening about this, but I kind of ran out of runway this afternoon with that. So I'm just going to off the cuff say for those of you who may not be aware that last week the US lost its status as having measles eliminated as a society. And that is I feel like it's a little bit shameful in terms of public health, honestly. Really big problem part of I mean it can be a very serious disease and there's a whole host of people who it could impact especially those under one who are not actually eligible to get the vaccine yet, so I guess if you're listening out there and you have a child please vaccinate them and if you have a child that is Unable to be vaccinated because they're too young or because they you know There are some people that have a different set of circumstances which makes them uneligible for different vaccines. And part of the key is having that herd immunity and so that everybody can protect each other and protect those more vulnerable members of our society that are not able to get various vaccines. And I can appreciate the challenges sometimes associated with the overwhelming piece of vaccinations. There are lots of really legitimate educational ways that you can learn about vaccines and about the diseases and that overall the risk of disease is far greater than the risk that might be associated with getting any of those vaccinations. So please vaccinate your kids and if you and if you are one of those more vulnerable members or you have a kid that's too young, like please take precautions and just be aware of who you're around and be aware of that sickness. Thank you. Thank you very much. And now we'll go to council member Rongo online. Thank you. Can you hear me? Can you hear me? OK, thank you. Mr. Rossman, would you put up the slides that I prepared? I want to speak on the accelerating timeline of AI tonight. First, I want to thank my colleagues for the support you offered on ordinance 202629. This is the ordinance to prohibit the deployment of artificial superintelligence, ASI, within Bloomington. First to say that this is a particular AI, so not to cause confusion. in the community. It's characterized by being an autonomous agent that is vastly superior intelligence in all cognitive domains and has the capability to recursively self-improve. That's what makes it so dangerous. This particular AI, ASI, hasn't yet arrived, but it is the stated goal of the Frontier Labs, and it is on the near horizon. It is designed to replace people in the workplace. It is emphatically not what tech businesses are using here or at IU. In fact, IU's AI efforts are human-centered AI, described as a framework focused on ethical deployment, human oversight, and beneficial societal impacts. It's not designed to replace people. Local tech applications, and IU are to be lauded for their approach. ASI, as we have resolved by resolution, has a high probability of existential risk and therefore should be prohibited in every community across the country. However, this will need to happen soon. Estimates have been that its capability has been growing on an exponential. So the first slide I'd like to show is from meter. This is from a report that was released the day after our ordinance was voted on. What it indicates are two major conclusions. One is that the exponential is no longer exponential, but hyper exponential. That is that the doubling time for the capabilities of things like task duration has gone from every seven months to every four months to every 1.7 months. So it is exploding in terms of its capability. The other conclusion in the report is that 80% of this increase is attributable to a recursive self-improvement. That is the most dangerous practice of having the machines design their their successors. The next slide shows on November 9th, Paul Cristiano, who was President Biden's appointment to head the National AI Safety Commission that was essentially eliminated by President Trump, came out with a stark warning. He said, on our trajectory, he predicted a 50-50 chance of an AI takeover within three years. A situation where AI calls the shots, he says, on our destiny, not people. He added that it was possible for an AI to take over the US government within 12 months on our current trajectory. The next slide shows Jeffrey Hinton, who is regarded as the godfather of artificial intelligence using neural networks. This is just several days later on November 12th. He stated that on the the trajectory we are on, the technology could kill everyone within three years. Next slide. Now, for those who doubt that this is possible or wonder how it could happen, MIT came out with this report on existential risk just yesterday and describes the eight domains where this describes what could happen scenarios. So MIT has offered us examples of what an AI takeover would look like. Last slide, please. Yes, this slide is today. It's a general accounting office report that was just issued a few hours ago showing that AI platforms provide terrorist blueprints when prompted. Now, we hope that these models, not ASI, But the point is that the current models are dangerous enough without proceeding to an artificial superintelligence. So in conclusion, as I said before, we need to stop this research on developing ASI as soon as possible. Every day brings greater risks. I'm very proud that Bloomington took the step that other cities could replicate. AI safety luminary Nate Soros contacted me after the vote. and he congratulated us on laying the groundwork for other cities to follow. He said that hopefully this could snowball with other cities taking action that could lead to a national and international cessation on this type of research. Thank you. Thank you very much. Any other council comments or reports? Okay. Now moving on to the presentation on climate action plan implementation. Oh, I'm sorry. Councilmember Asare. I'm so sorry. It's OK if we have to move on. I'll be super fast. But I'm really sorry that I can't be in person today. But I'm here in Nashville this week attending the National League of Cities Summit, speaking on a panel here, and just wanted to share a quick reflection. I think that there's a real opportunity for Bloomington to benefit from membership in the National League of Cities amongst many other organizations that would help us share information with other cities that are facing the type of things that we're facing. that have overcome the type of things that we've overcome or that we're facing. And I'm just really having a great time started today and runs through Friday. And so I think that many of the challenges that we face, whether they're housing affordability, infrastructure, economic development, emerging technologies are all challenges that communities across the country are working to address. And I think that any type of efforts that we can do to increase our networking with other cities, I think will make us more resilient more innovative city. And so I do plan to bring forward a resolution at some point, maybe at one of our, maybe at our last meeting or during the early time in next year, sort of calling, perhaps or proposing the Bloomington Forum Legion, the National League of Cities. So happy to talk a little bit more about that. But again, sorry that I'm not there with you all. And again, welcome back, Kate. I mean, Council Member Rosenberger, it's the most happy day to see you. Okay, bye-bye. Thank you very much. Are there anyone else? I think I have everyone on Zoom, so I can't miss a hand again. OK. Now we are moving on to the presentation on climate action plan implementation with Assistant Director of Sustainability, Sean Mia. Take it away. Or please state your name for the record first. I am Sean Mia, the assistant director of sustainability for the city of Bloomington's economic and sustainable development department. I have provided a lot of slides tonight. I won't be going through all of them, but they are there in the packet. If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them. This is a map of all of the billion dollar weather and climate disasters caused by climate change in 2026. As you can see, the majority of them are in the Midwest. Climate change impacts our public infrastructure, health, economy, quality of life, ecosystem and food security. And so when we invest in our climate action plan, we are investing in all of these things. Since 2023, ESD has successfully helped the city to secure over a million dollars in funding. Here's a list of all of the funding sources. The first section I'm going to talk about is renewable energy. To date we have 35 municipal solar systems installed at various municipal sites throughout the city. To date we have produced over 27 gigawatts of power. We have hired VeriG to maintain all of those systems, and ESD funds any replacement of broken panels, inverters, and optimizers. Our largest grant program is our solar energy efficiency and lighting program. We provide grants up to $25,000 for solar systems to small businesses and nonprofits, and up to $20,000 for nonprofits for battery energy storage systems for nonprofits that provide essential services. And our vendor for this program is Solar Energy Solutions. Each system is approximately eight kilowatts. The lifetime savings of a single system is approximately $56,000, and they will reduce 217 metric tons of CO2 emissions. In 2026, we have approved six solar systems for these sites with two additional installs in the queue for this year at these two sites. In 2026, Bloomington Housing Authority's solar system for the grant that we provided to Bloomington Housing Authority was installed. The total capacity was 85 kilowatts. The 25-year total electric cost savings for these systems is $620,000, and the CO2 emission reductions is over 2,000 metric tons. This year, we launched our Solar Grants for Income Qualified Homeowners program. This system will install five kilowatt systems on 22 houses. The total combined savings for all of these systems over the lifetime of the systems is over 690,000 with reducing over 3000 metric tons of CO2 emissions. So far we have approved 12 installations and we have received over 40 applications. This grant will provide ESD staff with excellent experience if the three million dollar solar for all grant that was allocated to the city of Bloomington is reinstated by the EPA. Federal courts ruled EPA's grant termination was illegal in September of twenty twenty six. So that is making its way through the court systems and hopefully that funding will be provided to the city of Bloomington. One grant applicant. said, saving on energy costs will allow us to use money saved on energy on child care for our nearly one-year-old daughter. The next session I'll talk about is energy efficiency. I wanted to provide an update for all of the work that we've done with Donovan Energy, who is our municipal energy efficiency and decarbonization consultant. In 2025, they completed nine level two ASHRAE energy audits on these buildings. And from those audits, they had a list of recommended energy conservation measures. So far, we have completed numerous LED lighting upgrades. We've installed a high volume, low speed fan at Switchyard Park Maintenance Garage. I'll just highlight on some of these. We have installed heat pumps at Rose Hill Maintenance garage and we will be installing heat pumps at the Allison jukebox community center early next year We will also be installing rooftop solar at the animal shelter early next year and the Allison jukebox community center So here are all the buildings that we have completed LED lighting upgrades We received we were awarded $141,000 reimbursement voucher from the U.S. Department of Energy's Energy Efficiency Conservation Block Grant. We anticipate receiving, hoping to receive that reimbursement by the end of this year. We also received a $508,000 grant from the Indiana Office of Energy Development for the Buskirt-Chumlee Theater. This was part of their Empowering Energy Partnerships in Indiana Communities EPIC grant. So today we have hired HFI to complete the HVAC upgrades. We will be installing a 24 kilowatt solar system on the roof. We were supposed to install a battery energy storage system with this project. We issued the ITP and the bids that we received were too high, so that part has been removed from the scope of work. We anticipate the solar installation and the HVAC upgrades to be completed by April of 2027. And we will be hosting four climate talks at the Buskirt Chumlee Theater in 2027. So now for the energy efficiency and lighting portion of the SEAL program, we provide free energy audits and up to $10,000 grants for energy efficiency projects for LED lighting upgrades, heat pump HVAC systems, air conditioners, heat pump, water heaters, insulation, windows, doors, and cool roofs. IFF completes the energy audits. And this is a list of all of the grant recipients that have been approved in 2026. And here are additional sites that have been approved for energy efficiency upgrades. Our Bloomington Green Home Improvement Program is a program where we provide rebates to Bloomington homeowners. Rebates cover 25 percent of the installation or 40 percent for low income residents up to a maximum amount depending on the project type. So for example for solar panels we provide five thousand dollar rebate for heat pumps twenty five hundred dollars. So we provide rebates for all of these project types. And so in 2025, we approved 32 rebates. In 2026, we approved 43 rebates. Six of those were low-income qualified. In 2026, we completed our Bloomington Energy Works program. We were awarded a $250,000 grant by the Coalition for Green Capital in Ickley, USA. We used this funding to create a robust program to promote energy efficiency and renewable energy across the city. Our goal is to bring low-cost capital to Bloomington for project implementation. And our project partner for this program was the Indiana Energy Independence Fund. So with that funding, we provided free energy audits to nine commercial manufacturing nonprofit building owners and MCCSE to develop a list of energy efficiency and solar projects in need of funding for our volunteer community engagement program. Our hired nonprofit Electrify Indiana, they knocked on 7,000 doors and gave group presentations. And we created a robust public-private partnership plan worth $69 million. So the next section is climate adaptation. Our cool corridors program is where we fund tree plantings next to sidewalks to protect pedestrians from extreme heat and to also cool our city and increase our tree canopy. Canopy Bloomington, their grant agreement is for community engagement activities, tree plantings, and tree maintenance for three years. We collaborate with an IU urban forestry class in Haskell Smith, the city of Bloomington's urban forester. We planted 125 trees in BHA's Crestmont and Walnut Woods neighborhoods. We will plant 100 trees north of College Mall in 2027, and we'll plant 100 trees along Second Street in 2028. Our tree assistance program is where we provide funding to remove hazardous limbs or trees for low to moderate income homeowners. This increases electric grid resilience during severe weather by removing tree hazards in your power lines. It decreases property damage. In 2025, we completed 12 tree removals, 12 trees needing risk mitigation pruning and the planting of 12 new trees. In 2026, we are assisting 17 homeowners with tree removals, risk mitigation pruning, and planting of new trees. In 2026, we completed bus stop shelter installations across the city. We just launched our new residential stormwater grant program in collaboration with CBU. This provides funding for residential grants for rain gardens and bioswales to prevent flooding. on private property. I wanted to give an update of Project 46, the Southern Indiana Regional Climate Alliance. The steering committee is made up of the city of Bloomington, town of Nashville, city of Columbus. Our list of advisory committee members continues to grow every year. So some key milestones. In July 2025, we adopted our bylaws and organizational structure. In May of this year, we hired Lotus Engineering and Sustainability as our regional climate alliance consultant. In July of 2026, Project 46 was awarded $35,000 capacity building grant from the Indianapolis Foundation. And this month we are applying for a grant from the Climate Smart Communities Initiative to fund flood mitigation projects in each of the Project 46 member cities. In September 2026, we held our first strategic planning retreat. We decided on four focus areas, flood and hazard mitigation, energy efficiency, renewable energy, waste and materials management, and EV adoption. The next steps are to do mapping for our partners and stakeholders. We are forming subcommittees for each of the focus areas. With the help of our consultant, we are researching and applying for funding opportunities. And the subcommittees and all of us, we are working on community outreach and education. We are continuing to fund food security grants for Hoosier Hills Food Bank to purchase and distribute locally grown food. Mother Hubbard is covered to support their garden program. Our Earth Day attendance continues to grow every year. And we have our Zero in Bloomington Sustainability Action Platform. It's an online platform that residents can use. So this coming fall winter we are getting ready to launch a new zero heroes group challenge Residents will form groups to complete missions including volunteering We have our climate action dashboard that's still up and running and Finally our climate action plan the five-year anniversary was in April of 2026 we are going to be publishing a five-year implementation report early next year and Our departments have submitted over 220 climate actions that will be in that report. We have hired Kim Lundgren and associates who will be leading an internal staff workshop in January to help us refocus the climate action plan and to help us prioritize actions for the next five years. It's not that we're doing away with the original climate action plan. This is just an internal refocus and it'll be an addendum to the climate action plan. So thank you so much, and I'm happy to answer your questions. Thank you. Are there any questions? Council member Stossberg. I'm just curious real fast on the plan to plant the hundred trees north of College Mall. Like, what is, I mean, north of College Mall could be lots of places. So I just wanted a little bit more detail about. where those trees are going to go? Yep. It'll be east of, what is that, 45? East of, or 46 there? East of 46, north of, what is that, 3rd Street? It's the area there by St. Mark's Church, Best Buy, Need More Coffee. There's a whole area there. OK. So they're not necessarily, like, It's like on the private property, essentially. And the right of way and private property. So we're looking at continuous areas where we can plant trees. Sometimes we don't have enough space in the right of way. And so that's where Canopy Bloomington and the IU Urban Forestry class will engage with the property owners to see if we can plant trees on their property. OK. All right. Great. That's like district three. So I would be interested in hearing more about that. Great. Being around for any of that, if that is appropriate. I know sometimes the canopy Bloomington folks do that. We would appreciate your help. Thanks. Councilmember Piedmont-Smith. Yeah, as far as the Bloomington energy works, what phase are we in now? We received the $250,000 investment fund market building grant. Have we continued with the submission of the $50 million, the list of potential projects up to 50 million? Has that been submitted? Yes. The Bloomington Energy Works program has completed. We have expended all of the funding that was provided. And we provided that public-private partnership plan to the Municipal Investment Fund in Ickley, USA. And they're continuing to engage with us and trying to find funders who are willing to provide low-cost capital in Bloomington for those projects. So I'm just looking at the website. There are different steps here. So are we on step three, apply for a potential $2 million phase two municipal investment fund? That funding, the municipal investment fund in Ickley, USA, they were not able to secure that funding for that additional $2 million grant for each of the cities. Their funding is actually frozen. It's it's sitting in their bank, but the Trump administration has frozen those funds and so it's sitting there It's gaining interest, but they're not actually allowed to distribute that funding at this time Okay, so at this point we're just looking for The coalition is helping us look for funding to implement some of the projects on that big list. Yes All right. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. I Councilmember Rallo. Thank you. That's a very impressive, outstanding volume of work that you've done in finding resources besides too. My question was about, I think of action on climate change from maybe three different angles. One is, Increasing efficiency, so reducing carbon emissions that way. Substituting fossil fuels by using solar wind. And then sequestration. And you're doing a lot of tree planting. Maybe we've done some prairie planting too, which is a really efficient way of sequestering carbon. But I wonder if we keep track of that. Do we quantify the sequestration that these trees contribute to our overall carbon reduction? We haven't done that yet. I believe we were waiting for updated maps of our tree canopy. And so far, that hasn't been included in our greenhouse gas emissions inventory. But that's something that we could look at in the future. Yeah, I just want to say that I think it would be a great idea. But thank you so much for your report. Thank you. Council member Osari. Thank you so much. And I thank you, Director Mia, for all of your incredible work. And I think also the copious amount of work that's being done. But I'm somewhat curious about many targets. I mean, just taking one and sort of maybe building off of Council member Aralo's question. Could you talk a little bit, if you took a sort of step back, about where we are today relative to our 2030 emissions targets, for example? So in terms of our KPIs, how are we doing? Thank you for the question and the opportunity, council members. Sorry. Based on our most recent greenhouse gas inventory report, we are on track to meet our 2030 goal, which is to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions by 25% of our 2018 emission levels. So we are on track to meet that goal. But however, to meet our 2050 goal of carbon neutrality, we need to significantly increase our efforts in reducing our greenhouse gas emissions. So everything they can do. Excellent. And that gets to my follow-up question, which is, have you outlined what increasing our efforts looks like? I mean, obviously, there's some federal elements that are outside of our hands. But within the realm of control that we have, what would you like to see us do in the next couple of years? And I know that there's this asterisk on. We'll also have a better sense of this after the five-year re-strategy. But just from where you stand now, sort of informing the next couple of years, what would you like to see council doing, supporting, advocating for? So if we look at our greenhouse gas inventory, the majority of our emissions come from stationary energy usage, so from our building energy usage. And so everything that we can do to increase energy efficiency in buildings, so all of our municipal buildings trying to make them as energy efficient as possible. And that goes for homes. businesses manufacturers schools all of those buildings every building needs to be more energy efficient and then our second source of greenhouse gas emissions are transportation and so everything that we can do to transfer our municipal fleet to electric vehicles and encouraging EV adoption with our residents providing EV charging stations all over the city encouraging our businesses to provide EV charging stations our manufacturers our schools, wherever people are parking their cars to encourage EV charging stations availability. And then I think just continuing the programs that we already have. So our SEAL program, our BG HIP program, we're providing rebates for EV chargers inside homes. So continuing those programs and wherever we can install solar as well. So encouraging solar, so continuing our seal, BGHIP program, municipal solar installations, encouraging all of our businesses and manufacturers and schools to install solar. All of those things need to happen to really make an impact. Excellent. Thank you. Any other questions? I have a question. OK. Thank you so much for the presentation. And congratulations to you and Miss Jolie Perry, another one of our sustainability staff. for all of your accomplishments over the past year. I was just wondering a little bit about the food security grants. I know that moving into 2027, we're going to see increasing cuts to our SNAP program at the federal level. How are we preparing for that? And in regard to the security grants, how can organizations apply for a food security grant? Thank you. Thank you. So so far we have the same amount budgeted for 2027 that we have all along and So we've been partnering with Hoosier Hills food bank it seems to be a great partnership where they're they're working with a local farmer to Purchase local locally produced food and distribute that and the mother Hubbard's covered their garden program they are providing education to residents about Growing vegetables and all the vegetables that they grow on site they provide to residents So we will continue those programs Thank you so much Okay, any other questions? Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you so much And now we are moving on to reports by council committees do we have any Okay And now we will begin our first section of public comment. Just so everybody is aware, we have three minutes per person. Please state your name for the record, and you will be able to go. And your timer should be up on the screen. Great. Hello. My name is Katherine Corz Rosman. I'm a photographer and artist in the community. And I have been practically run out of the community by two former arts administrators. I tried to speak last night at the Bloomington Arts Commission and while I was speaking the event was hacked with anti-semitic images and penises were put behind my head while I was speaking. This has been a really long and difficult process where I've been searching for an adult in the room who could maybe acknowledge that the retaliation I'm experiencing has gone too far. I have closed my business. I am trying to live and work and function in this community. And the city arts department has made that impossible. I think city arts and the commission has become too political. I think you need to completely disband the Bloomington arts commission at this time. I am not happy with that. I believe in building things up instead of tearing them down. But I believe that a strange brand of political activism has become systemic in our arts in a way that is affecting citizens so they cannot build small creative businesses in our community anymore. Even here tonight, I'm afraid that I'm going to be shot. People have shut down my Instagram all day and my website. And I mean, speaking in front of the Arts Commission last night under the circumstances that I did was one of the most disrespectful experiences of my life. And I cannot believe that my hometown did this to me. I have volunteered hundreds of hours in this community. I have volunteered for marginalized people. I am not fighting the Palestinian cause in any way. I will stand up here and say, free Palestine. I have an incredible amount of empathy for those people. But I am not willing to take that on as if I am the enemy in our community. And that is happening and is happening regularly. and I have spoken to the mayor's office, the legal seemed to think that I was pursuing some kind of liability claim. I don't want to sue the city that I grew up in. I don't want a penny from you. I think that suing a city is taking money away from yourself. That's money I paid for roads and programs for my child and my family. I can't believe I have to come here tonight and ask for help. I don't know what to do to find an adult that will say, this is unacceptable. So I'm asking for help. And last night, the way the meeting was set up, it was set up in a way where there was no comment. No one spoke to my concerns. The meeting was actually established in a way where they weren't able to do that. And public comment was intentionally suppressed. People left. People were not allowed into the meeting. I think it was a failure of governance. Unfortunately the way that the meeting is set up we are not allowed to respond to public comments But thank you, is there anyone else in Chambers who would like to speak? Please state your name. You'll have three minutes Good evening. My name is Kenny Leifert. I am a neighborhood compliance officer for housing neighborhood development I'm here tonight to extend an open invitation to any and all council members before I extend that I'm here with some of my co-workers and I'm on behalf of the ones that aren't here. I just like to give a brief description of what compliance officers do there are 33,000 plus rentals in the city They all have to be inspected All of those inspections have to have a report written Those have to be followed up with the reinspection if those violations are not corrected another report that also includes complaint inspections and It includes BHQA meetings. It includes reports for those meetings. It includes Board of Public Works, if anybody wants to appeal these. We also enforce Title VI of our code. Excessive growth, loose and scattered trash, cans at the curb, snow removal, which I really want to touch on. And that is not just rentals in the city. That is all residents of the city. When we hear some grumblings that we're not doing enough with enforcement, we decided we'd like to kind of stand up and say something on our behalf. There's roughly 243.5 miles of sidewalk in the city. For all of that to be cleared, for seven people to enforce that is quite the job. We know that it's not perfect. We know that it doesn't always get done in a timely manner. We've heard that people would like it to go straight to fines and no warnings be issued. We do not agree with that. We think everyone should get a warning before they get a fine. And one of the things we like to do is we try to enforce around schools first. We try to go to the bus stops and then we try to work from downtown out to make sure, to try to make it safe for everybody. Again, And we receive you report system. I'm sure you're all familiar with that. That is nonstop at every day all day. And that's not just for title six. That is rental complaints, snow complaints, trash complaints, grass complaints. That never stops. So the main reason we came tonight was to extend an open invitation to all members of council that we would like for you, any of you, all of you to come to the hand department and spend a day or a week with a compliance officer. We'd like you to maybe ride with us. We'd like you to go in some of these rentals. We'd like you to see some of the things that we experience on a daily basis. It's not always the greatest. We'd like for you to go into some of them, not some of these nice new shiny builds, but some of these rentals that are a little rough. But we'd also like you to come out especially during snow season. Try and understand just exactly what we are dealing with on a daily basis when there is snow out or In the middle of the summer when people don't want to cut their grass or pick their trash up or pull their trash cans from the curb And we didn't come tonight to make any accusations Obviously, we're just trying to extend an invitation and we would like for everybody on the council to really get a good idea and maybe a first-hand experience of just what we do so again We would really just appreciate if some people, if any of you would just come out and maybe spend a day or a week with us. And it's not a, nobody likes the hand department. I hate to say that, but when we show up, it is either going to cost money or time. Thank you all very much. Thank you. And thank you for your service, Mr. Leifert. I will follow up with you on that. Do we have anyone on zoom? Okay. First person on Zoom, you should be able to unmute and you'll have three minutes. Please state your name. Is that me? Am I the first person? Can you hear me? Yes, we can. Go right ahead. Okay. I wasn't sure there wasn't an indication of who was going to speak, but good evening. My name is Eric Ost and I appreciate this opportunity to offer comments. I want to express my strong support for continued and expanded financial contributions by the city of Bloomington to Bloomington Transit and urge that public transportation receive a greater priority in the allocation of cities, of the city's transportation resources. Public transit is an essential public service. Thousands of residents depend on it to get to work, attend school, obtain medical care, purchase groceries, and participate in community life. For many residents, particularly those with limited incomes, older adults, students, and people with disabilities, public transit is not a single, excuse me, is not simply a transportation preference, it is a necessity. In October alone, Bloomington Transit provided more than 254,000 passenger trips, yet proposed reductions in service threatened to make transportation less accessible and less reliable for the very people who depend upon it. Meanwhile, limiting continues to invest substantial resources in safe streets for all initiatives, traffic calming devices, bicycle lanes, and neighborhood greenways. Some of these investments may provide legitimate safety benefits, but their actual benefits should be objectively measured and compared with alternative uses of those same public funds. The assessment requires open, timely, and ongoing publication of relevant, accurate, and detailed data for access, review, and analysis by your peers, members of the general public. There is a fundamental distinction between bicycle-focused infrastructure serving a limited subset of travelers and public transit serving residents across a broad range of ages, incomes, and physical abilities. Public transit is also a significant traffic safety investment. Reliable public transit can reduce automobile dependence, improve access to employment, and provide essential mobility to those who cannot drive. Transportation investment should therefore be evaluated according to measurable public benefits, actual usage, people served, accessibility, reductions in injuries and fatalities, service reliability, and cost effectiveness. Before committing additional discretionary funding to safe streets for all bicycle focused infrastructure or traffic calming projects, the city should demonstrate that those benefits justify those expenditures relative to investments in public transit. Bloomington's immediate priorities should include competitive driver compensation for bus drivers, reliable operations, adequate service, frequent service, and expanded transit coverage. A safe transportation system is one that residents can actually use. I urge the city to maintain and expand its financial support for Bloomington Transit and make accessible, reliable public transportation a central priority of its transportation and public safety policies. Thank you. Thank you very much. We'll come back in chambers. If you could sign in and state your name, that'd be lovely. You'll have three minutes. Seaforth Breeze, resident of Bloomington for 14-ish years. I wanted to speak today on the subject of seminary point. I know this body is considered it in the past, and we're currently seeing, unfortunately, the end result of a long process with its demolition beginning at this time. I wanted to bring it up as a indication of how You know, today, the UDO will be considered. Short-term rentals, I believe, are also going to be considered. There's a lot of good work that the city council is putting into housing and affordability in this community, which is to be commended. But I just wanted to bring it to the public's attention that, you know, right now, we're seeing the loss of these 29 units that existed, these four commercial spaces that were super affordable as well. at price points that are simply, I mean, they just don't exist in Bloomington in numbers that they need to, right? We see with the Bloomington Housing Authority that right now they're taking concrete steps to try to expand their housing stock, which is good, but that is toward workforce sort of housing, that price point, which is, you know, it's not even in the same ballpark in comparison to the affordable, and then the affordable to the super affordable is another gulf that just so many in our community cannot bridge. So I wanna encourage the city council to continue taking the proactive steps that it's already doing, but also to look into ways that permanent funding can be provided for super affordable housing in this community. That also includes ensuring that it stays that way. It has to be affordable now, so we have to save what it currently exists, and build stuff now when we can, but also has to be affordable forever. I look at Hopewell as an example, and I worry that we will funnel a lot of public money into Hopewell as a project, but if we don't have the right protections in place, it might be affordable for the first people to get their foot in the door, and then that just washes away, which uses up the funds that were set aside in the payments in lieu and things like that. So thank you so much for your time. You all have put in so much work. I've seen you at many of these meetings doing that, but I just, I want to bring it forward again and again, because so many of my coworkers in the union at IU, they are, you know, they used to live in Bloomington and they don't anymore. And, you know, we saw the census number come out with like the, 70% of workers or something ridiculous like that do not live in Bloomington despite working in Bloomington. Anyways, thank you for your time. Thank you. Others in chambers? If you could sign in and state your name, you'll have three minutes. Good evening. Paul Rousseau. It's really nice to see a full council for a while. Two months? I don't know. 10 months ago, I was routinely walking to work for a mile through public sidewalks where every single lot had been unshoveled even 10 weeks. 10 days, excuse me. I'll get it right. 10 days after the snowstorm. But I'm here to talk about something else, which is the plan to redesign College and Walnut. which I think is one of the most significant Bloomington public projects of this century. But from what I've observed, the process for public engagement is weak at best and broken at worst. Last October, public input was solicited by the city. I submitted lengthy comments directly to the Planning and Transportation Department by email. But a review of that department's website today appears to show that only comments constrained by the department's online survey questionnaire have been included in the public record. Two days ago, the public had another nominal opportunity to comment at a special hearing of the Transportation Commission. The only copy of the corridor study available to the public was a draft version from eight months ago on the website of the Planning and Transportation Department, while there were no documents about the study on the commission's web page. I was not the only member of the public who felt insufficiently informed about the current details of the project. Neither were the transportation commissioners satisfied as they voted to continue their deliberations until December 7th. So if the commissioners have three more weeks to make more comments at a separate public meeting, why will members of the public be denied further opportunity to also learn more and participate? Is such a prohibition on public participation even legal? What's happening to our public comments? Another thing that I'm noticing is that I did not see any itemized responses to the comments that were submitted under the constrained process that I mentioned before. So I feel like we're being ignored. But I hope that's not the truth. Thanks. Thank you. Is there still somebody on Zoom with their hand raised? Okay, great. Go right ahead. Zoom. Hello, my name is Alex Lani. I'm currently a PhD researcher at the University of Plymouth in the UK, but I was born and raised in Bloomington for 22 years. And I just kind of wanted to reflect on the previous regular meeting that discussed the ASI ordinance and push maybe the committee and the council members to look towards a different approach, maybe a more practical approach to artificial intelligence, which would be making data centers more eco-friendly. And so I'll talk about these details soon. So just from my background, I'm a pre-doctoral researcher at Moth Quantum, and I've done summer internship work at Argonne National Laboratory for two years. So I have a lot of experience with LLMs and OpenAI. The first time I used Chad GBT, I was one of the first two, three million users in December, 2022. And so I just wanted to kind of give my perspective on it because I think there was some missing components that maybe should be addressed that could help the ordinance. I don't want to sound like I'm completely against it. I watched the whole five-hour meeting last time. You all do great work for the community. I just want to put that out there. So following up on the ordinance, I wanted to talk a bit about the difference between AGI and ASI. I kind of view them as overhyped. both of them, but I think we should delineate between them, right? So we're banning ASI, but like AGI comes before that and we're not even at AGI, right? So right now we're at like ANI, so it's kind of narrowly worse than humans in a lot of ways, but we're not even at AGI, which is AI matching humans, let alone ASI, which is AI exceeding humans. MIT put Uh, an opinion piece about, you know, not being fooled by the summer of AI hype. I think this kind of goes along with that. Yann LeCun is considered a godfather of AI. He's the winner of the Turing Award, which is like the noble prize of computing. And he was in a video about why open AI and LLMs will not lead to AGI, let alone ASI. Um, I thought that should be mentioned. Also, uh, Councilman last session posted. slides talking about a paper that said, advanced AI according to 1,580 researchers, uncertain, unsaved, and sooner than we thought. Now, I know that 1,580, that sounds like a big number, but if you go to page four of that paper, you'll see in section 2.1, it says, we sent emails to 19,874 addresses and received 2,052 complete or partial responses for a response rate of 10%. That's about 90% of researchers who felt that this ASI paper wasn't worth their time. And I think that's the most telling detail about us from people that know a lot about AI to say, hey, this is not the best direction right now. So Bloomington, Illinois, they already have 70 news articles about redesigning data centers. We have one at IU. I know that Monroe County has a ban on making them, but that could change. I think we should be open to that. So I just kind of wanted to pitch an idea of, you know, combining IU's Environmental Resilience Institute, O'Neill, Dillman Wastewater Treatment Plant, Bloomington Environmental Commission, Duke Energy to, you know, try to put more legislation into something more practical related to AI, which is eco-friendly data centers. Thank you very much. I'm sorry. That is your time. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else in chambers who would like to make a comment? Okay. Anyone else on Zoom? Anyone else on Zoom? Thank you. Okay. In that case, we can move on to Section 5, Appointments to Boards and Commissions. Are there any motions? I can make a motion. I'm sorry. Councilmember Flaherty. Thank you. On behalf of Interview Committee B, I'd like to make a few recommendations. I'm just pulling up the page. Sorry, I was on the wrong PDF. So to three different commissions, I'll name them all. If folks want to divide the question or ask questions about them, you're of course welcome to. But again, the committee's recommendations are as follows. For the Utility Service Board, to appoint Patrick Dirks to seat C3. For the Community Advisory and Public Safety Commission, to appoint Amanda Stone to seat C1. Catherine Vasinth to seat C4 and Maya Lukey to seat C7. And for the Environmental Commission, two point Ashish Nambiar to seat C2 and Nathaniel Hand to seat C4. Okay, there has been a motion and a second. Would anyone like to make a comment or ask a question? Council Member Stosberg. Thank you. So we just went through a whole thing about that in some ways boils down to how difficult it might be to ever remove anybody from any of these seats. And so I feel often that we just sort of take the recommendations from the interview team and don't ask any further questions about any of these folks. And I think that it's a really tricky kind of weird piece, because then if we do ask questions, then we're discussing in public. And that just seems weird, too. So I guess I just, you know, anybody from interview team B can can answer this, like, were all of these people interviewed? And, like, were there options in terms of a candidate? Like, were you deciding between candidates and thought that these were like the best candidates in terms of what they added to the board, or were these the only candidates? If anybody could speak to that, it would be great. Councilmember Daley. I'll answer for my part. We did divide up interviews rather than trying to align everybody's schedules. I was responsible for the advisory on Public Safety Commission, community advisory for public caps. Thank you. We had three applicants for four seats, but I did 20 plus phone minute interviews with each of them. And each of these three were extraordinarily qualified. They all had backgrounds that blended nicely into some form of public safety or public care. They gave incredibly thoughtful and committed answers, and they were very excited and eager to be joining. And so I do think that they would have stood out in a crowd anyway. I felt very lucky that we had those applicants and I'm grateful that they applied. Anyone else? Yeah, I could follow up. As Councilmember Daly noted, we were in the interest of time and getting appointments filled, subdividing the tasks to call the best applicants were possible. I had the utility service boards. This was designated by which liaison we were for which commissions we are a liaison. And I guess not the staff liaison, you don't know what I'm talking about, the council lead, yes. So I did talk to Director Zeiger, who's in back of the room, about the applicants. We did have one additional applicant since my conversation with the director. I did call all the applicants. I was only able to speak to two of them. They all seemed like good candidates to me. When it comes to something like screening and trying to keep an eye out for unforeseen circumstances, I think that's probably very difficult to manage, especially with the capacities we have on the council, both as individuals and with our staff, even the clerk's office for that matter. But I think we lean towards the recommendation based on the skills that Mr. Dirk Springs, he's a former city employee actually, an engineer. I worked in the engineering department. and now works in a consulting capacity. And on the Environmental Commission, that was a little bit different. We didn't have our full committee together, but we know the Environmental Commission has been frustrated by kind of the duration of some of the vacancies, understandably, and we were trying to err in the direction of getting those seats filled, especially since they'd been reduced. We had, I would say, four good candidates for two seats on the Environmental Commission. We also try to keep in mind, you know, when there are mayoral appointments or vacancies that might be coming up, there can be opportunities there even when there aren't on the council side. I did speak to a long-serving commissioner about kind of the makeup of the commission right now, what the skill sets are, what would be most helpful to them relative to balancing what's there already or maybe what they've lost recently. And so that was a framework that informed the recommendation we made with the two applicants. Multiple of the applicants we were familiar with through city government in one way or another or community involvement, but we didn't actually conduct phone interviews in the case of the environmental commission specifically. Great. Thank you. I appreciate that additional information about these recommendations. OK, great. Any other questions? Will the clerk please call the roll? member clarity. Yes. Sasberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Sorry. Yes. Daily. Yes. You should offer out. Rallo. Yes. Rough. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. That passes. Are there any other appointments? No. Okay. Then we will move on to legislation for first readings. I move that ordinance 2026-38 be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. Second. Any discussion? Okay. Will the clerk please call the roll? Council member Stasberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Daily? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Thank you. That passes. Will the clerk please read by title and synopsis? Ordinance 2026-38, amending Title 16 of the Bloomington Municipal Code to update the Residential Rental Unit and Lodging Establishment Inspection Program and add a new section on short-term rentals. The synopsis is as follows. This ordinance amending Title 16 includes the following substantive changes. One, the addition of Chapter 16.06 short-term rentals per Indiana Code 36124. Two, an update to the fee schedule in section 16.03.07 fees. Three, inclusion of a vacancy fee for single-family detached homes. Four, removal of sections and references in accordance with Indiana Code 32-31-120. And five, grammatical quality of life and spelling corrections. There are no changes in hands inspections or in the evaluation criteria. The recommended implementation date is July 1, 2027. Your council member's sponsor is Rallo. Thank you very much. I move to discuss ordinance 2026-38. Second. OK. There's been a motion and a second to discuss. Any questions or comments? OK. Will the clerk please call the roll? Piedmont Smith? Yes. Zulek. Yes. Asari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stasberg. Yes. Thank you. Thank you. That passes. Is there anyone here to present? Go right ahead. Please state your name for the record. Good evening council members my name is Taylor Brown I am the assistant city attorney for the housing and neighborhood development code enforcement portion of the code and for the record Kenny I might be biased but I like hand so. This is where you insert the spinning wheel as it's buffering. The buffering, yeah. Appreciate it. All right. So this is the summary of changes. I want to first thank you for your time and attention during the presentation. A special thanks to Council Member Rallo for sponsoring this legislation and to the members of the BHQA for their feedback, which was invaluable as well as their endorsement to this legislation. I will go through a quick summary of changes, is the addition of a chapter requiring the registration of short-term rentals, updating the fee schedule, and inclusion of the vacancy fee for single-family detached homes, removal of certain sections and references under state code, as well as various grammatical readability and spelling corrections. By readability, I mean things like adding in a particular citation for all of the definitions, that way you know exactly which definition. It was a personal pet peeve of mine which I was happy to correct in this legislation. I will go through, because there is a lot, I will go through each of the sections and I will pause after each section for questions and then pause at the end for overarching questions to try to make a little bit of organization. But of course, council members, feel free to interrupt me at any time. So beginning with short-term rentals. So the legislature provided for a program, quick note, the page numbers up top in the titles, reference the specific page in the red line that the legislation is discussing in case you want to follow along or have any questions there. So the legislature provided a program for municipalities to adopt the registration of short-term rentals in 36-1-24. And so the first thing that they input was a definition of short-term rentals. It is defined as a dwelling unit, defined in code. rented for less than 30-day terms through a short-term rental platform. Now a short-term rental platform is also defined basically as a website through unaffiliated third parties can put their dwelling units up for rent. For instance, if you are ABC Rentals, rental company in the city, and you have a website that puts all of your rentals online, that would not qualify as a short-term rental because it is through you are the affiliated party, if that makes sense. For the process, you will register with hand providing a specific set of information. That's outlined in code. It's basic contact information, things like that. There is a one-time $150 fee per dwelling unit. Bless you. And again, that is one time. There is no fee to renew. All that is required, and this is again under state law, all that is required is a notice to hand that they intend to renew for the following year so we can keep our list accurate. And then they are good to go for the next year. Again, by state law, it must be issued within 30 days, the permit for the short-term rental, and then it is, again, good for one-year terms. Restrictions, enforcement, and appeals. So if there are three or more ordinance violations in a calendar year, and that is specifically in this instance, trash, noise, excessive growth, Title VI things, the permit can be revoked for no more than one year. Appeals will go through the BHQA, although the ordinance violations themselves will still go through the Board of Public Works. So hearing appeals for noise violations, abatements, things like that, will still go through the Board of Public Works, but then to go and say, hey, I took care of all of my ordinance violations, please reinstate my short-term rental permit, that will be heard at the BHQA. It also provides for certain restricted uses under state law, such as you can't sell alcohol out of a short-term rental, things like that. And that's it. As far as title 16 goes I think it's pretty straightforward but I also have been reading this day in and day out and so I'm seeing it whenever time I close my eyes. So I will pause for questions here. Okay. Councilmember Ruff thank you for your presentation by the way. How does this compare or do you know how this compares to other communities in Indiana in Indiana that we've heard about that have done taken steps to try and permit or regulate short-term rentals like we hear West Lafayette did this and that. Can you compare this? Of course. The legislation that the state passed specifically grandfathered in certain short-term rental programs that already existed, I believe this was back in 21 or so. They grandfathered in the ones that already existed and then provided a very rigid set of here's how municipalities can regulate going forward. Again, this is just registration, regulation or zoning or anything like that. Does that answer your question. So were there communities that had something in place that was stricter than what the state now allows. I can't speak to any specifics but yes there were a couple that had specific areas that said no. short-term rentals in these particular areas. The state legislature did provide a way to do that, but laid out much more specific requirements. I'm not sure how that previous legislation would have been debated or passed, but the legislature then made it more specific and more criteria to be laid out. Is that clear? Yes, no. Can I ask a clarifying question? You said in some communities have like specific areas where they might have set aside. No. So could covenants and restrictions privately agreed upon covenants restrictions in a certain project or development or subdivision prevent just ex-proc prevent prohibit short-term rentals under state law. Excellent question. There is actually a specific place in state law in that section that says this will not interfere with those private organizations such as HOAs and things. Okay. Thank you. You may have already answered a couple of my clarification questions, but I just want to really make sure. So in terms of the It has to be through a short-term rental platform. That's state law. So somebody could, in theory, have a short-term rental that they don't have to go through this registration process with because they're not advertising it on a third-party website. Theoretically, yes. However, the third-party platform pretty broad. So I think you'd be have you'd be stretching to find something that didn't apply if that makes sense for the most part. Yes. Well if you like hosted your own Web site or something like that if you hosted your own Web site then you're running a rental I'm happy to get back to you on that in writing if I dig into it a little bit. I just wanted to clarify in terms of state law. In terms of state law, yes. Why does it have to be through a rental platform? And it's because of state law. Yes, that was lifted straight from that. And then the no renewal fee? Yes. That's also a state law? That is state law, yes. OK. And then the other, I guess, real Question is so are these short-term rentals going to be inspected by hand? Is this adding to their inspection state legislation? Specifically states that they cannot there cannot be a requirement to have them inspected however hand after I discussed it with them we are providing an opportunity for them to be inspected at a discounted rate. So that way, if they want to say on whatever rental platform they're advertising, we had the hand inspectors come in and they certify that this meets the same standards that normal rental properties do, things like that. So we have it as an option for short-term rental owners, but we cannot acquire it. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? Council Member Rosenberger. Are these full-time rentals or any owner-occupied renting out their home for one weekend? The short-term rental definition means any rental of a single-family home, a dwelling unit within a single-family home, so a room, things like that, a dwelling unit in a two-family or multi-family dwelling, or a dwelling unit in a condominium cooperative or timeshare, and that's Pulled from again state law there is a carve out under title 16 for I think if there is owner occupied they rent to one tenant and They share bathroom facilities and living quarters I think and that is an exemption for title 16 in general and I think that particular carve out is there So it would really depend on the exact Facts of somebody renting out a room in their home I'm sorry to be the lawyer and say it depends, but it depends. Sorry, what was that joke about? Sorry, what was that? What did you just say? I'm sorry. Oh, at the end, I'm sorry to be a lawyer and say it depends, but it depends. Oh, gotcha. OK. What about, I don't know what we call it anymore, but a rooming house, a board? You know, we have a short term option that allows one owner in like four bedrooms. So that would be considered then here as a short term. I'm not quite sure what you're referencing, if you'd like to. We have, I don't know what the definition, do you guys know that? Are you referring to the single room occupancy? No, we have, it's not a rooming house. It's something kind of similar though, where like the owner can live in it and rent out like up to four bedrooms. That is the SRO? Oh, the owner has to live in it. We switched it. Okay, yeah. So an SRO would be under this program? I can double check and make sure that that is where that falls specifically and let you know. I think it's just good to make sure there's only one requirement, I guess, like for an SR to follow, and it's not complicated. Happy to follow up. I think it would be helpful if everyone who has follow-up questions could submit them in writing as well, just so Mr. Brown can keep track of them. Are there any other questions on this part? Councilmember Rallo. Oh, Councilmember Rallo. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Brown. I appreciate your work on this, as well as Director Killian Hanson and the BHQA. I just have a couple of questions related to potential next steps. I realize that we're hamstrung by the state to a large extent. Is there any possibility for putting an absolute number, restricting the number in Bloomington? of short-term rentals? That is a very good and very complicated question, council member. That is one I will absolutely have to get back to you in writing on. There is a plethora of litigation, legislation around short-term rentals. It's a very hot button topic as you well know. I'm happy to research and see what the next steps could be and get back to you on that. I appreciate that. I appreciate your work on this and but I think that we need to explore options because if we have potentially 800 short term rentals and my understanding is the 44 percent occupancy rate and 80 percent of those rentals are not used except on peak weekends. That's a significant impact on potential housing that could be obviously occupied by full-time residents of Bloomington and must account for significant effect on housing and rental rates and so forth. So there is a potential for zoning as well. Is that correct? That's something that could be explored And then since these are occupied primarily on peak weekends, it seems that this is one potential way to address this would be a market approach whereby hotels would become competitive. In other words, when you were looking at this, is part of the problem lack of hotel rooms? During peak weekends I would say that's probably more of a policy question and I would defer to hand on answering that. I can say like the data you just read off I can say that that has been provided and that gives us a way forward. Again I think to first start would be let's see what we're dealing with first and then we can move forward based on the data that we gather the short term rentals that register things like that. Yeah. Yeah that's a great idea. All right. Thank you for your for your work. I really appreciate it. Thank you sir. Are there other questions at this time. Council member Stahlberg. Sorry, I got reminded by, I think, a Wisconsin member, Rosemarger's question. Would the owner occupied short-term rentals? And maybe you can answer this now, or maybe we need to follow up with it later. But it's specifically defined as a term, but then as I was reading through the actual short-term rentals chapter, I was like, I can't tell. It's defined as a term, but I can't tell what it's actually like defined as a term for, because I didn't see it anywhere else. So is it exempted from things? Is it not exempted from things? Is it just like, so I was just kind of like, we defined it, but then we didn't specifically use it anywhere. And so I don't know if I missed where we used it or what, but I would love some clarity on that in general. Would you like me to follow that up? Yes, that would be great. I'll follow up with that right. Thanks. Thank you I'm not sure if this is appropriate question for short-term rentals, but it was brought up By my colleague councilmember Rosenbarger or maybe this isn't even what she meant but the difference between rooming house and single-room occupancy Makes me think that we need to make sure our terminology between Title 20 and Title 16 is compatible, because we do not have rooming house as a defined term in our UDO anymore. So we should use single room occupancy in this case. We can use both, but we definitely need to reference single room occupancy. Yes, and I believe that was in your email list of questions. I did read and start annotating them, but I haven't responded yet. So yes, I did see that. OK, thank you. OK, any other questions on this part? OK. If everyone could submit their questions in writing to Mr. Brown by noon on Tuesday, just as a reminder, next week is Thanksgiving, and I want to give Mr. Brown ample time to answer the questions in a way that they're in the packet so that the public can also read and prepare for our December 2nd meeting. Take it away, Mr. Brown. Thank you very much. I appreciate the lead time. Next up, we have vacancy fees and fee schedules, the update to the fee schedule. Again, the state legislature, they provided a long list of issues with Vacant homes specifically. It's 36-7-9-4.5 for those of you playing along at home And in recognition of those that extra burden this includes a $500 vacancy fee for single-family detached homes that are vacant for longer than one year again, that will be homes that are for one full calendar year vacant. Now, and this is where, again, the BHQA was invaluable. One of the members pointed out in the event that a housing market cools and someone is desperately trying to sell it and they just can't, the last thing we want to do is include an additional financial burden on someone who is already struggling to sell a home. Which is why any appeals will be taken by to the BHQ a Where they will be able to evaluate the good faith efforts to sell provide extensions to? for the fee things like that And then the update to the fee schedule So the current fee is in that first column the second column is the new fee in general I rounded the fees to the nearest $5 increment just for ease of calculation. Um, the single family detached home fee did not change, uh, and neither did the condominium inspection fee. Um, however, there is one significant change, which is the, uh, second, second and subsequent re-inspection fee, um, for a while. And again, I am doing code enforcement for the city. There have been certain, uh, shall we say, bad actors that have merely included this as a cost of business rather than an opportunity to actually make repairs on their properties. And so they would rather pay the extra two or three inspections that are $77 each rather than make the $1,000 repair of a water heater, what have you. So in recognition of that and the extra time that staff takes to do second inspections and things like that, we have raised that fee to $150. Now to clarify what is a second and subsequent re-inspection, so HAND will go out first, do an inspection, they will provide a list of all of the things that they have found that are violations of Title 16, things to fix. They, in general, have 14 days to fix life safety issues and then 60 days to fix everything else. They will come back and make sure that they have fixed everything. That is not the second reinspection, that is the first reinspection. So if they have failed to make the repairs that HAND has asked them to make, the next inspection will be $150 moving forward. Questions on fee schedules and the vacancy fees? Thank you. I have a few questions in this category. Yes. So I guess the first one in terms of the vacancy fee is I am not a tax expert but I have heard over the last few years of sitting in this seat that there are different management companies that specifically would prefer to leave properties vacant in order to get tax break related stuff for income loss as opposed to rent them. So do you know anything in terms of that $500 fee for vacancy like is that going to offset enough in terms of any sort of tax break that somebody might get from or tax loss that somebody might get from deliberately leaving a property vacant? I see you writing something down, so I assume you're going to have to look that up. On my best day in law school, tax law always evaded me. So I will absolutely be looking that up, and I will get back to you. Thank you. That would be great. I have more questions, too, but I saw another hand down there. So do you want me to go on? Councilmember Rosenberger. Hi, yes, thank you. Did you consider vacancy of, well, vacant lots as well as vacant homes? No, that would be outside the scope of this particular title. OK, all right, because I think vacant lots are the most egregious here. And then the second most egregious are vacant homes. One example is that someone in near West Side tore down a house because they didn't want to look at it. And they just own that vacant lot. And I think if we're in the city, we should be building homes on our lot. So what title is that? It doesn't matter. And then with these fees, are they just? I'm sorry that I missed this. I'm just going to be honest. My brain is mush because there's a lot going on. Are we just getting up to this 125 amount like for inflation purposes because we've been at 105 for a long time. Correct. So this was last updated in 2012. The last the fee schedule has been the same since 2015 with one 10 percent increase in 2019. So that so as far as like the increases in twenty twenty eight and twenty twenty nine I followed the exact same pattern that the previous fee schedule did which was a ten dollar increase for single family detached homes and et cetera. With the exception of the second and subsequent fee, which I increased to yes. Okay. And then I mean, we don't see past 2029. Are we mostly sticking to the 125 at that point for a while? You think? Yeah. So again, just like in the previous, the previous time this was made, uh, after 2020. So 2020, 2030, sorry. Yikes. Uh, 2030, um, January one, any increase, uh, will be the board of public works by 10%. Unless a larger one is required then that would of course come to council. Okay, and last question on the fees condos versus multifamily dwellings, so it is Does that mean it's a hundred and five dollars for one condo? unit I Believe so. Yes, but then each building for multifamily is $77 it would be 80 for the new fee and I believe that is so 80 for the building and then each unit in that building is 30 So if you look at the two the line right underneath, so it'd be 80 flat and then add 30 I'm gonna look at I'm getting the nod from director Kelly. So yes. Okay. Thank you Councilmember, sorry Thank you so much. A couple of questions that may be built off of both Councilmember Stosberg's and Councilmember Rosenberger's questions around the fees specifically. And first, just to make sure that I'm understanding correctly, the short term rental permit is capped at 150 by state law. Is that correct? That is correct. Yes. And is that a one time fee or is it recurring every time that they renew? Uh, that is a one-time fee there. Again, by state law, there cannot be a renewal fee. Okay. But then the other fees, so the regular rental inspections, um, the repeat inspections and the vacant properties that we're putting on here, um, those are not capped by state law. We get to set those, right? They are capped, but it is a general ordinance violation cap at $2,500. Okay, okay, that is just for your records state law 36-1-6 Fantastic the but then the inspection fees Are we are recovering and think this is relevant to the public comment we received earlier? But are we recovering the actual cost of inspections I mean or Mean, or is there a different sort of is this cost recovery or is it is it a different sort of theory of change? Yeah, I would defer to Hand to answer that particular question. I believe it is just cost recovery if you want to Hi director Killian Hansen The state does not allow us to recoup our full costs of inspections so at one point they did try to take away the program and Part of that deliberation was that we are not allowed to recoup the full cost of the program. Okay. And then, but then, and so my final question then is, is why, you know, why, why 150 and 200 for repeat? Why 105 for, uh, for the regular rental inspections? So the 105, I wanted to keep the fees the same, uh, for this next, um, cycle. So that way there would know there were no big surprises. Um, basically, and then the implementation date would be July 1, so that we would get through all of the new, the students coming in and out and everything else, and then once the busy season is over, July 1 is when the new fees would kick in. My reasoning for the second and subsequent re-inspection fee, frankly, I doubled it and then went to the nearest $5 increment. That was my rationale. But but then why not make it why not make the reinspection fee a thousand dollars You in your if you would like to do that you're more than welcome to this was my first Passed by and I felt that might be egregious giving the other Inspection fees, but I'm happy to entertain anything else. That makes sense. Okay, those all my questions. Thank you. Yeah I am going to ask a question before we go back to councilmember Stasberg. So in regard to the fee for vacancies, I see that it's $500. I have the Indiana state code pulled up here. It looks like an IC 36-7-9-4.5, legislative findings, vacant or deteriorated structures. It says, in recognition of the problems created in a community by vacant structures, the General Assembly finds that vigorous and disciplined action should be taken to ensure the proper maintenance and repair of vacant structures and encourages local bodies to adopt maintenance and repair standards appropriate for the community in accordance with this chapter and other statutes. That's what it's referring to, is that correct? Correct. Is it possible to increase that? I know that one of our biggest problems that we struggle with in Bloomington is vacancy rates, so I'm just curious if that number is flexible or if state code has laid out a different cost in a different spot. Happy to look into that and get back to you. Thank you very much. I'll follow up in writing. Great. Councilmember Rosen. Oh, Councilmember Ruff. We're going first round. Councilmember Zulek's last question. What councilman was like read from code state code seemed to suggest that the reasoning for having a a vacancy fee or penalty Sounds like the logic is that is associated with concern about deteriorating structures and Resulting negative impacts on the community on the neighborhood by deteriorating structure so in the absence of that any concern about the structure not being maintained or deteriorated but just vacant. Is that the kind of thing that the Board of Zoning Appeals would do you envision or does administration vision that I mean the Housing Quality Authority is a board would approve if someone said hey I've got a sabbatical for a year plus we're going to be in New Zealand and so we're going to stay an extra four months for the summer so we move more than a year and We don't need to rent the house. We don't need the income. We're just gonna leave it vacant It'll be fine. It'll be in great good shape Does that run afoul or are they likely to get this $500? Thank you so much for asking this because this is nestled in title 16 This only applies to vacant rental properties Not for instance someone who owns a home and like for instance leaving for a year on sabbatical other first rounds okay I'm gonna go councilmember Stasberg and then we'll go back to you councilmember Rosenberger thank you so in terms of wait kind of continuing to follow up actually I'm a councilmember rough was talking about with like evaluating that the the exemptions that might be allowed in terms of that $500 fee so it only applies to rental homes I guess I The big question that I have is what kind of guidance is going to be given to the, which board did you say it would be? Board of Housing Quality Appeals. Board of Housing and Quality Appeals to evaluate good faith efforts. And so especially I'm thinking like, I mean, you mentioned a good faith effort to sell a property, but what about a good faith effort to rent the property out, say, for the example of somebody trying to rent a property for well over the standard kind of going rate, or folks that might, or properties that might not necessarily be in good working order, and they are, once again, I've also heard speculation that some property owners sometimes very deliberately let properties decay so that then they have better justification to demo it. And so I guess I just am concerned about those issues and concerned mostly about how to evaluate those exceptions and to do it in a way that is fair to all of the petitioners that might request that and expected and also like goes toward the ultimate goal, which is to have our properties being lived in. So how do you envision, I guess, that process? Is there going to be a rubric? What's the guidance? Where's the guidance? Right. Well, I would say, first off, to kind of go back to what you had said earlier in the meeting, you evaluate these committee members. You evaluate their qualifications, whether or not they're suited for a board, things like that. in their judgment and wisdom, they would be able to make those kinds of determinations. Um, that's the purpose of legislative bodies and things is to come together for those kinds of things. Um, as far as guidance is concerned, more than happy to collaborate on anything that council might think is appropriate. Um, but that they, when I brought this up with them and discussed it with the BHQA members, um, they, brought up the very examples I was giving, which is good faith efforts, trying to sell, trying to rent, things like that. Does that? Well, it answers the question. I guess I would just encourage whoever would need to do that to have some sort of written documentation in place. Right. And I'm not even sure who the best body would be to create that, maybe the BHQA themselves, maybe the hand department, maybe a collaboration. I don't think that that's necessarily the thing that council usually ends up getting in the middle of. But I think that it's generally important in terms of evaluation to make sure that every petition is getting evaluated based on the same standards. And so ideally, then, those standards would be written down somewhere and would be transparent to the community. I'm also the attorney for BHQA advising them. So I'd be more than happy to say, hey, guys, heard this when I was talking to counsel and put something together. Absolutely. Thank you. Hi, thanks. Getting more into the vacancy fee. Okay, so this does not apply to owner-occupied homes, is what you're saying. No, this is nestled in Title 16, so it is only rental properties. Okay, and I see that that is the case, but I see that that is a problem for me because we're basically, it's like an equity problem that if your home is, the policy goal here is to not have homes vacant. any home, I think. And so then we're saying if you are able to leave your home vacant and go rent somewhere else for a year, you don't have to pay a fee. That feels problematic to me. I know that these are separate titles, but it does feel problematic to me. Second, what about second homes that are vacant? So someone has a second home here and they come three weekends out of the year. Does it get a vacancy fee? Well, as you said three weekends out of the year, right it has to be vacant for a full calendar year so vacant second homes here Won't get any kind of fee From according to your example, they would come live in there in the home six days six days out of the year they would need to be vacant for a full year for this fee to kick in and Okay, so also for the policy goal of getting humans living in our houses, that is a problem for me, because second homes are even worse than Airbnbs, because Airbnbs at least house our guests when they come to town, because our hotels are full. I think Councilmember Varallo asked if our hotels were full, but yes, they are all full for our football games and things. Places like Notre Dame have insane problems with blocks of second homes. I don't think, don't get me wrong, Ayu, but I don't know that our football team will ever be that good. But I think that- They won a championship already, Councilmember Rosenberger. I know. And according to people, our team is different. I don't follow. I love it. Thank you. I love everyone doing it. Let's do more football. I think that- I know we're in Title 16, but I think this is a more holistic problem than what we're looking at. And I think this is targeting landlords and renters in a way that feels unfair to me. And I think when we're looking at these fees, most, well, when I did a long-term rental, I almost always had to get a re-inspection because something needed to be updated. So then you update it, and then they come back. And so we're looking at, $325 and like landlords mostly to the best of their ability don't absorb any costs and they pass those on to tenants So I think we have to be thinking about these fees I think councilmember sorry said can it be a thousand dollars? But like I don't think that's a good idea because we're talking about landlords wanting to make money So it's I think it's just more complicated than how much can we charge? I'm sorry. How are you getting the $325? There might be a misunderstanding a Subsequent. All right, they go they do the Well, I'm looking at 2029. So the first fee is 125. They have some things not in compliance. They have to get things into compliance and schedule another inspection. So that would be $325. No. So thank you for the clarification. So the second and subsequent reinspection fee would be hand shows up to inspect. They come back to make sure that all of the things on their list were fixed. That is not the second. Re-inspection that is the first re-inspection. It's Worded strangely and we could perhaps clarify that but then the if there is anything that they failed to fix Beforehand comes back and hand has to return again for a third time That is when the second and subsequent re-inspection fee would begin. Okay, it's cut off I know I have in my packet, but it looks like it says re-inspection fee So maybe that's a little unclear. We can change it by next reading. OK. Another hypothetical. I have a house I'm renting on Airbnb, but I don't accept bookings for one year. Do I get a vacancy fee? Yes. The way this is written. OK. OK. Thank you. That's it. Any other questions? Councilmember Piedmont-Smith. I guess it begs the question, how would you know that this house is vacant for a year? Which is why the fee exists, right? So Hand actually monitors a lot of these things. We discuss with utilities if there is, there are usually signs that the inspectors know if they can, they can usually tell if, you know, cars aren't in the driveway, they don't see lights on, things like that at different times they're going by their neighborhoods. If there is a, if there is suspicion that it is vacant, Um, like for instance, when there are certain rentals, when someone asks, you know, they asked to be exempt from title 16 because a home is vacant. We can usually go to utilities and say, have there any utilities been used in the last however long? Um, so there are, there are methods and ways that, uh, hand does investigate how, if whether or not a home is vacant. If that answers your question. Thank you. Council member Stasberg. Thank you. I think that this is actually my last question about this is it's actually about the the funds that the fees go into and then what gets paid out of those funds. So Director Killian Hansen also already said that like it doesn't fully cover the cost of the programs. But does it just like go into general fund. So like how does that work by state law. All funds received through Title 16 whether they be fines fees etc. are placed in the unsafe building fund. And the unsafe building fund is specifically for and I'm gonna look at you. I believe it's for Any abatements that need to happen? emergency repairs things like that The actual like operating costs of hand come out of it at all so it's so what exactly is this fund used for or what it has been used for in the past and So Title 17 of the Bloomington Municipal Code is related to unsafe buildings so we can issue orders to seal vacate remove. Etc when those buildings that we have declared unsafe do not comply Then we can step in with an abatement and take care of it So you might remember the fire that occurred on Walnut Street a couple of years ago It was gosh. I can't remember the address off the top of my head But it burned pretty rapidly and the owners were unable to step in there was no contact with them And so we ended up stepping in with unsafe funds demolishing removing making the area safe. So and I will say just in relation to the vacant homes some of the biggest problems that we have are related to festering properties that have overgrowth. Nobody's living in them. We have issues with Title 17 specifically. So if you were interested in addressing potentially some of the vacancies with owner occupied, I would direct you to do that through Title 17 changes because that is one of the biggest challenges that we have. There's probably a hundred ish properties in Bloomington that are sitting vacant that are just degradated and failing. Probably a hundred ish. Thank you. How much more presentation do you have? I believe I have one slide. Okay, great. Go for it. So the specific removal of sections and references. So the legislature passed 32-31-1-20, which prohibits regulation of landlord-tenant relationships. The code hasn't been updated since then, so we went through and removed certain sections that were now prohibited and void under state law. Also, this year, the Indiana Fire Prevention and Building Safety Commission was disbanded and absorbed back into the Indiana Department of Homeland Security. And so we removed any references to that specific commission, seeing as it no longer exists. Thank you. Thank you. Any final questions for Mr. Brown? Thank you, you guys. OK. Thank you so much for your presentation. And thank you for your stamina. I know we've kept you up here for quite a minute. Thank you very much. Thank you. We'll try to get those questions into you by noon on Tuesday so that you have enough time to actually get them answered. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. Any final comments from council members? That is for second reading. We do questions, comments, and then public comment during first reading. Are there any comments? Okay, then we'll go to public comment. Would anyone in chambers like to speak on this ordinance in particular? Anyone online? OK. Then I will entertain a motion. I move to send Ordinance 2026-38 to a second reading on December 2nd. Second. OK. There has been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Will the clerk please call the roll? Council Member Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Naly? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stosberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. That passes, and we will continue Ordinance 2026-38 onto our next regularly scheduled meeting on December 2nd. Any other motions? I move that Ordinance 2026-39 be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. Second. OK. There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Will the clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Asari? Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont-Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Thank you. Thank you. That passes. Will the clerk please read. Ordinance 2026-39 to amend Title 10 of the Bloomington Municipal Code titled Wastewater Regarding Fats, Oils, and Grease. The synopsis is as follows. This ordinance amends Title 10 of the Bloomington Municipal Code at Chapter 10.17 to bring the city's FOG program into compliance with recently enacted House Enrolled Act 1348, which established new legislation at Indiana Code 8146.1, for the regulation of fats, oils, and grease. The council sponsor is Flaherty. Thank you very much. I move to discuss ordinance 2026-39. Second. There's been a motion and a second. Any comments? Okay. Thank you. Will the clerk please call the roll? Council Member Daly? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger. Yes, clarity. Yes, Stossberg. Yes, Piedmont Smith. Yes, Azulik. Yes, sorry Yes Thank you. Thank you very much that passes. Is there anyone to present? Go right ahead, please state your name Good evening, I'm Stephen Stanford the pretreatment coordinator for the city of Bloomington utilities and I'm here to tell you a little bit about some recommended revisions to Title X that are intended to make our city ordinance consistent with the new state code. Fats, oils, and grease. These are the regulatory citations. History and background. The city of Bloomington has regulated the fats, oils, and grease discharges since That's under Chapter 10.17 of the Municipal Code. The new state law, HEA 1348, was signed in March of this year, and it became effective in July of this year. So this law already applies and establishes a statewide framework for the regulations of fog discharges that contribute to sewer blockages and overflows. And it also requires the continued acceptance of septage from neighboring jurisdictions from which we were receiving septage on January 1st, 2024. The amendments that we recommend to our city ordinance to make it consistent with the new state law is to adopt certain state definitions require that the Grease control be designed by professional engineers or architects. We've adopted a grease control device sizing equation. We've established procedures for exemptions and alternative service frequencies. And we also intend to adopt a time limitation of 60 days for plan reviews when, say, a developer is coming into town and they want to build a new facility. We have no longer than 60 days to review the fog related sections of the project. In terms of fiscal impact, what we anticipate is that a potential for substantial savings for a developer who is building a commercial property in an area zoned for food service establishments. Currently we require that they install a large fog control device. That blanket mandate is eliminated under the state law. And so if the developer was to build a multi-use building that has retail space, for example, previously we would have required a grease interceptor to be installed as part of the project. We can no longer require that upfront. Another change is that using the sizing equation, the developers and operators of the businesses could propose smaller grease control devices than are customary today. What we anticipate is that the maintenance of smaller devices can fall by the wayside more frequently than the larger devices that have a regular subscription service from a hauler. And so we think that we're going to probably see as a consequence of this more fog discharges into the sewer and possibly more frequent sewer cleaning. It's difficult to project how many additional sewer cleaning events that we would need, but on a case-by-case basis, those things typically cost us about $250. to $2,500 per event depending on the size and severity of the problem. If in the end we find that we're going to need a new jet vac truck and crew for enhanced sewer maintenance as a consequence of these changes, that would increase our operating costs by about $200,000 to $250,000 per year. We thank you for your consideration and I would like to ask That you move forward with the proposed amendments and I will be glad to answer any questions that you might have Thank you very much are there any questions Councilmember Stossberg I just have a question about what you ended with in terms of that fiscal impact. So that's like a theoretical possible fiscal impact kind of depending on how well the the interceptors actually work and That's our best projection based on the experience and what we anticipate based on expected changes in the nature of the devices that could be used and installed. Because the state is saying this has changed the guidelines and so we have to go along with the state's change. That's correct. We're just attempting to meet the state law in this particular instance. Okay. Do you happen to know if this was a consideration that was given at the state legislature when they changed this? I can't speak to their deliberation process. I'm not familiar with the process that went into this. Because I assume this is true for the entire state, so every municipality, every utility, And so every utility would be potentially dealing with this kind of fiscal impact related to maintenance. Yes. Okay. Thanks. Council member Piedmont Smith. Yes. In looking at the ordinance or the the code changes we have different sections for installation requirements for new food service establishments. installation requirements for newly remodeled food service establishments, installation requirements for existing food service establishments. They're all the same as far as I can tell. So why do we need three different sections? Actually, the next one is the same as well. Why do we need all these different sections if the requirements are the same for all the different establishments? I would leave that question to our drafter of those particular regulations. We were working with the old ones to start with, and what we did was we put the new state definitions into our existing definitions. Would that be attorney Chris Wheeler, or who wrote this? Yes, attorney Wheeler helped us with this. Is he online by any chance? I am, yes. Hello. Hello. Did you hear my question? I did. I was listening. So when we drafted the fog ordinance many years ago, we tried to capture all of the different food service establishment, whether they're brand new, whether they're existing, whether they're moving into a new place. And in each one of those instances, we were just trying to capture all of the different possible ways that a food service establishment should get captured by this fog regulation so that we can make sure that they're putting the right, at that time, put in a grease interceptor. When we worked on this update, we didn't get rid of the terms, we just put that same definition into those terms. I think where I can speculate where you might be going is why don't we just consolidate it and say any restaurant has to do this, right? But just for the sake of brevity, or not brevity, but simplicity in making the amendments, we just made it apply to all of those different categories that already had been in place and existing in the current code rather than trying to consolidate it. That's all that happened there. It wasn't anything more than that. Well, I guess this is more of a comment, but since it's first reading, am I allowed to make a comment as well? To me, it seems much easier to consolidate them. Okay. Well, you might be right. So we can talk about that a little later. Related to that, You have section 10, 17.100, installation requirements for food service establishments causing or contributing to a sanitary sewer overflow. So I'm a little puzzled why we need this section, because aren't all food service establishments already covered by the categories above? The new commercial, the remodel commercial, et cetera, et cetera. and this language seems the same, so is this somehow, did I miss something? Is this language harsher for ones that actually caused a sanitary sewer overflow? Yeah, so if they actually are, if in fact there are issues that are causing a congestion in the sanitary lines that's causing it back up, because that's just a specific type of a situation where if in fact they're creating a problem that's causing sanitary sewer to overflow because of the fact that there's all this grease coming into the sanitary sewer and plugging it up. That's what we're trying to get out there with that definitional term. Okay. But again, the actual text underneath the heading is the same. Okay. Again, all of the different definitional terms we just simply applied that one term to all of them. So it works evenly across the board now for every possible type of food service establishment that's out there. OK. Well, I'll email you about consolidating that perhaps. Sure. Thank you. Thank you. And thanks for being here, Mr. Wheeler. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Oh, Council member, sorry. Thank you so much, Madam Chair. And thank you for the work on this, both Mr. Wheeler and the wonderful CBU staff. I had a question about cost shifting. I mean, because I sort of get the tension. I think I get the tension that we have this financial trade-off in the middle of this, that we think that, and I think it's the sort of model that's presented. So if I understand it correctly, Smaller equipment can reduce the cost for private businesses, but we think that that's going to increase maintenance costs for the utility. And so, first, do I understand that correctly? the facilities operating the smaller devices tend to forego maintenance more frequently than the larger facilities. Okay, and so how do we ensure if at all that those, I guess the lead up question to this is do you have some estimate of, because I know a lot of of restaurateurs, a lot of developers. I mean, this has been a pain point for a long time, the huge cost of putting in grease traps and those type of things. And so, do we have any estimates on what uptake is going to be? I mean, I don't, this might be too hypothetical, but really the more pointed question is, you know, one, how do we ensure that any additional costs aren't simply transferred to utility customers, and two, perhaps, More directly and immediately important is is do we currently have sufficient pretreatment inspection, you know enforcement capacity, etc To monitor compliance if there's if there's a sort of more variable equipment and maintenance schedules We do require all of the food service establishments to subscribe to a cloud-based customer portal and to log their cleanouts for us so that we know that they're, number one, they're in business, and number two, how often they're cleaning it out. And the pretreatment team does inspect restaurants in particular that are out of compliance. Do you anticipate needing more staff, more operational capacity in any way to enforce this with these changes? I think we're in pretty good shape, Councilman. In terms of staff to keep up with this because this is not a new Business for us. It's we're just making some adjustments to the existing ordinance Okay, excellent. Excellent. Thank you so much I have a follow-up that I kind of thought of well other council members were asking their questions. Has there been any consideration within utilities to assess fines for those establishments that are slacking, you can say, on some of that maintenance and thus causing backups? Is there a way to really figure out how a backup is caused? I guess I kind of similarly to what Council Member Asari said, I don't want this transferred onto all of our utility customers at large, especially if there's individual establishments that could be doing a better job at maintenance. We have something that's called our enforcement response plan. It's a graduated enforcement approach to customers who are not complying with city ordinance. Starts with things like telephone calls emails works its way to written warnings and then it goes to fines and we we have a history of imposing fines on Food service establishments who are not taking care of business Okay, great. Great. Thank you any Councilmember Piedmont Smith Yes, do I understand correctly that Garbage disposals are not allowed. Is that a new requirement? That requirement's been in place since 2012, to my knowledge. OK. I saw it as read in the text, so maybe it was just moved from one place to another. I believe that's correct. OK. And is that can be exempted if the food service establishment somehow proves that they don't have a lot of grease or something like that? Yes, there is a method for an operator to go through that process. Okay. Thank you. Did I see Mr. Wheeler have his hand up? Yeah, I did. And I was going to just chime in and explain that all of the enforcement procedures are in section 1030 of Title 10. And so if you had been looking through 1017 and didn't see any fine or enforcement provisions, that's because it's in section 1030. Thank you very much. Are there any final questions? Any council comments? Would anyone in the chambers like to make a public comment on this ordinance? Is there anyone on Zoom? Great. At this point in time, I will entertain a motion. I move that we move this item of legislation, ordinance 2026-39, to our regular session on December 2nd for a second reading. Second. Great. There's been a motion and a second. Will the clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stosberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Ann Daly? Yes. Thank you very much. That passes. We will pick this back up on December 2nd. And please, if you have any follow-up questions, please send them in writing again by Tuesday at noon. Thank you so much. for your endurance. I know it's a little bit of a late night. OK. So now that we have completed ordinance 2026-39, do I hear a motion? I move that ordinance 2026-41 be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. Second. OK. There has been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Will the clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Asari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Thank you very much. Will the clerk please read. Ordinance 2026-41 amending Title VI of the Bloomington Municipal Code to increase solid waste cart fees and other sanitation service fees and to establish new requirements for solid waste collection. The synopsis says as follows, Ordinance 2026-41 amends Title VI of the Bloomington Municipal Code to increase fees for waste services, including trash carts, large items, appliances, and yard waste, to establish fees for new carts and for cart exchanges, to require new residential developments, acquire carts for each property prior to the start of city sanitation services, to hold landlords responsible for ensuring the rental property has trash and recycling carts at the start of a tenancy, and to make further updates to billing and other required practices with regards to waste services. The council sponsor is Flaherty. I move to discuss ordinance 2026-40. Well, I'm just wondering if this is that I guess I need to ask our council attorney Mr. Rossman, is this the kind of just a piece of legislation where because it has to do with Finance it has to do with money, you know, we'd raised we did this with the fees. We talked about the fees earlier on the housing Legislation, but it's just the kind of legislation that Folks can't be referred to remote for this is a first reading and we're not taking a vote on it. And so I just want to be sure that they won't have to they won't have to. And so I didn't really think I deserve a look of disdain for that. But I just want to be sure that they don't that we're not running a foul of a law. If it stays on track for first reading there No problem to discuss. Okay. Thank you. Councilmember daily. Go ahead. It's twenty twenty six dash forty one be discussed. Okay. There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion. Will the clerk please call the roll. Councilmember Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stasburg. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. Director Wason. Good evening members of the council Adam Wason public works director for the city of Bloomington It's always an honor and a privilege to be with you and to serve the city of Bloomington Tonight's discussion on rate changes for the sanitation division is not my favorite reason for being in front of you But here we are As you'll recall during the 2027 budget deliberations the the sanitation division budget request was reduced with a request from the council to for staff to bring forward a Rate proposal to eliminate the general fund support for sanitation So tonight we will discuss the rates that we are proposing to do such To do just that and then some additional changes to title six that we would like to implement while we are updating the ordinance So what is in front of you tonight is just that a rate proposal for the next three budget cycles that would eliminate the roughly one point six million dollars that makes up the difference between the revenues brought in compared to the full cost of operating the sanitation division. So a couple of things to point out on our sanitation services and why we are where we're at today. So you will all remember that the sanitation division collects our solid waste, recycling, yard waste, leaves, appliances, large items, and holiday trees. We service approximately 14,000 units any given week. And additionally, sanitation crews respond to the different types of events downtown and service those, whether it's the IU Homecoming Parade, The solid waste from the actual festivals like taste of Bloomington, but all of the crowds that use the pedestrian scale Cart trash cans throughout the downtown the Sanitation's division also services all city facilities. So City Hall the police station facilities fire stations trailheads pools parking lots and garages, et cetera. So that's 23 different parks, 20 buildings, and around 50 downtown pedestrian-scale carts and cans. Overall, we've seen significant costs increase over these last several years, and I can provide some specific examples for you as we go through tonight. You know, where a trash truck, a... So the 25 yard rear load trash trucks that we were buying in 2023 and prior were around $245,000. That same truck now cost $315,000. Additional costs, we have increased costs on a lot of other areas, whether it's just the supplies, the gloves, the bags, the cleaning materials for all the things. One of the biggest things and we've all seen this with fuel costs throughout the year the last year at this time in 20 November of 2025 we were paying about three dollars a gallon for diesel Everyone knows what we're paying what we've been seeing this last year as of November for this year We're at five dollars and 82 cents per gallon for diesel So, you know, we're seeing significant cost increases across the board that have honestly done away with a lot of the cost savings we were hoping to see in the new, more efficient program with what we implemented in 2017. So for a lot of these factors, with increased costs and everything, additionally we have our new collective bargaining agreements with our AFSCME employees, which is increasing our category one costs. After all the discussions with our budget hearings in August September and October We heard from the council that they wanted to see a proposal that would reduce that general fund support amount over From what we bring in with our revenues So what we're proposing is a rate proposal that would cut six hundred thousand dollars in costs for 2027 cut an additional six hundred thousand in costs for and not cost but cut six hundred thousand dollars in general fund support in twenty seven another six hundred thousand dollar reduction of general fund support in twenty twenty eight and then a final cut of four hundred thousand dollars in twenty twenty nine to completely eliminate the general fund support to the sanitation division. What does that look like an actual rate term. So you'll see in the yellow highlighted area of this chart we would be moving the thirty five gallon carts for twenty twenty seven to 1061, the 64-gallon carts to 1940, and the 96-gallon carts to $29.10. Additionally, we are proposing some additional rate changes to yard waste, moving that from $1 to $2, large items to $30, appliances to $40, and cart exchanges to $30. This next chart here shows, so if a resident has an additional pickup need on a week where they had a particularly heavy volume of solid waste in a given week, we will do an extra Friday pickup. We make that cost based on an approximate fourth of the cost of a typical monthly charge to do the additional pickups there. So that was the 2027 rate increase. Proposals for 2028 we would do an additional increase To eliminate that additional six hundred thousand dollars from the general fund support Here that would take rates to 1238 for the 35 gallon 2264 for the 64 gallon and $33.96 for the 96 gallon Again, here's what it would look like in 2029 with the rate increases on that same projected reduction of the general fund support. And again 1374 for the 35 gallon cart and 96 gallon cart would be thirty seven dollars seventy cents. A couple other changes that we're asking for the council to consider as part of this ordinance update includes winter weather collection access. So just clarifying some language last year really showed us with our big 12 inch snowfall that we need to encourage residents to make sure they can get those carts into an area where our staff can accept actually access the carts for collection. We are updating some language about residential rental property container accountability That's a long way of saying that we're asking that landlords confirm that the carts are on their property when residential turnover occurs so in August when Tenants move out that the landlords confirm that the carts are still there for their addresses we also have a Request to the cost of providing carts to new developments. So we have some different new housing developments coming in. This past year, we realized we were carrying the full cost of providing the carts to those new homes. So we're asking that we update the ordinance to capture the full cost of the cart delivery for new residential developments. Just a few minor adjustments on the enforcement procedures, moving that from seven days to seven calendar days. in the language and then the ordinance obviously captures the rate increases again just to kind of wrap up and open it up for questions from the council members you know these rate increases that we're proposing are in line with what was discussed as part of the twenty twenty seven budget process where we heard loud and clear that there We heard loud and clear by action of the council to reduce our budget requests by that $600,000 amount for 2027 Later after those budget hearings, we went to the financial subcommittee Had a good discussion with that team of council members on this proposal and the result is what you see in front of you tonight I'm happy to answer any questions and will Defer to some staff if I don't know the answers and would get back to you on those so Thank you for your time tonight. Thank you for yours. And thank you for the presentation. Any council questions. Councilmember Piedmont Smith. Yeah. The proposal to build the general fund two hundred thousand dollars next year for the services that sanitation provides that are separate from the curbside pickup. It makes sense to me. I'm just wondering how did you arrive at that two hundred thousand dollar. We did some calculation estimates based on the amount of time staff spend servicing all those facilities the number of carts or cans at them. And I can get you kind of more specific information on that. What exactly went into that. But it was our staff doing some estimations on the time and Fuel costs and and such for the teams that do those collections Thank you You recycling every week have we thought about doing every other week Not as part of this proposal, but that could be on the table as we talk about service delivery methods. Thanks Councilmember Stasberg Thank you. In terms of the new cart delivery, $75 delivery fee, should there maybe be some flexibility in there at the discretion of the director as opposed to that strict fee? And I guess my thought is something like if somebody is getting a delivery of both trash and a recycling is that $150 if it's a duplex or a triplex and so it's getting a delivery of a lump to like a single location on a single trip then that would be like multiplied potentially by more and so I guess I'm you know like absolutely want to kind of recoup some of those real costs for those services but also want to leave some kind of flexibility or understanding for that sort of multiple cart delivery at one time sort of situation. OK. Let us think about that in the time we have between tonight and next hearings and discuss that internally. The $75 probably doesn't capture the whole cost of the delivery the whole cost of the cart purchase itself and the delivery. But let me dig into that with the team and see what we think about that. What type of language we might propose to amend the current ordinance to seek some of that flexibility as you were as you were making your comment I was thinking you're probably going more towards the idea of you know, what if we had a Strong affordable housing development and if we wanted to do something there So let me let me rack our brains and public works on how we might want to word that so that we have some discretion I think we Instead of making it at the discretion of the director we might think of something like at the discretion of the Board of Public Works to take it in front of an official body make the case of why and such but We can chew on that and come back a couple weeks with maybe some amended language that we could work with you on okay, I guess I'm also looking at it as Fee is just for the actual delivery of the item not for the cart itself And I think based on what you just said you intend it to be the delivery plus the cart the whole the $75 per cart includes the delivery And the cost okay, so art itself does e cart exchange $30 per cart. Is that correct? of just the delivery then or is that the cart and that's more maybe we just need to clean up that language to clarify that a little bit because I clearly had a different understanding of what that $75 was doing then you did so so let's think of it this way the $75 is more of a capital recovery cost and the $30 is more for a new so let's think of the $75 charge for a new residential unit that needs new carts. That's more of a capital recovery. Whereas the cart exchange fee is more of the labor and fuel to do that. OK. OK. I thought that that that that delivery that seventy five dollars was the labor fee and not the cart fee. We can clarify language. Yep. Clarifying that language would be fantastic. Thanks. Other questions. Councilmember Ruff. I apologize if it was in the materials we've gotten. I just overlooked it. I didn't get an understanding of it. But when there's a damaged card, it's always been a great service that A new lid comes and is put on by our new that continues that's going to continue with at no charge at no charge. So if you say with our automated equipment in particular the side loads with 35 gallon carts they tend to cause the most issue for that. But yeah we would continue if we cause the damage. We're going to go ahead and repair that through our as we do today. OK. Thank you. Final questions. OK. Thank you very much Director Wason. Council comments. Council Member Piedmont-Smith. I'm in favor of this proposal. I think it is more equitable to not charge, okay, let me put it this way. Currently, a lot of residents of Bloomington are paying into the general fund, which is providing $1.6 million a year for sanitation services. But they are not benefiting from the curbside services, which is most of what our sanitation division does. So I think it is more equitable to raise the amount of fees that are charged directly to the people who benefit from the services. And I think it's very smart to also carve out that $200,000 to cover the public, of sanitation division that benefit everybody the downtown Trash cans the ones in the parks, etc So I am in favor of the proposal. Thank you Thank you any other comments Okay, Oh councilmember Flaherty I Brother agree with the councilmember Piedmont Smith. I I do think a few things worth noting that I think were in the memo perhaps or have been discussed otherwise. But even after these changes, the city sanitation services are below market rates. So you can't get sanitation service this cheap from a private hauler. So that is true for roughly half of households in Bloomington who don't get service from the city sanitation. And then additionally, I think the incremental nature of it, we're talking about a couple of dollars a month change You know, over the next three years each, I think I'm hopeful that in most circumstances that will not stress people's finances in a way that makes a major difference. You know, again, we're talking one to $4 a month difference for next year, for instance, relative to the baseline, similar in the years to follow. But I'll also note that because we bill in a combined fashion with City of Bloomington Utilities Water Service, There is a program that's been refined and improved over recent years to provide billing assistance for folks that are struggling to pay their utility bills. The trash bill is part of that bill for folks that are struggling that is available and so wanting people to be aware of that and also just if they need it but also aware of it as another effort the city makes to mitigate the inevitable impacts that folks feel from what seem like endlessly rising costs that of course track Costs that do indeed endlessly rise fuel costs and equipment costs and infrastructure and personnel and all the rest So yeah, there's just a couple of things worth noting as well. Thank you Thank you any final comments councilmember Stasberg I guess the thing that I'll tag on to that that I don't think has mentioned yet like nobody really likes to increase fees but the other thing that I think is a Valuable to think about in this context is that this fee is to literally Get rid of our trash and the things that we use and I think that we should all kind of be paying that real cost for disposal and it partly recognizes like and it forces hopefully individuals to recognize the true cost of items because it's not just the price that you pay at the store, it's also you have to get rid of the packaging or dispose of whatever bits and pieces come with it, and that that is a piece of the true cost. And there's been a lot of different environmental-based movements, bulk buying, for example, bulk grocery, filling up your own jar, bringing your own bags to the grocery store. And then, of course, we have things like recycling and trying to purchase things in recyclable containers. Composting to try to reduce that overall load of what it is that we're putting in the in the cans on the curb and so I You know you hate to raise prices on anything but I also have to kind of put some place some value and importance on people actually having to pay the full price for those sorts of disposal and understanding that it costs something to throw something away and That's just reality. So thank you. Councilmember Rosenberger. I just wanted to give my first seven year comment that pay as you throw is the best way to make people aware of actually what they're throwing away. I know we're not doing that right now but what councilmember Stossberg just said as long as you have a monthly rate. You're not thinking about that so much because you're paying the same amount whether you buy all the plastics and things at the grocery store, bring your own containers. But if you were to be charged for every trash bag like we used to, then you might bring your own containers. That's it. Thank you. Thank you. Council member Stossberg. Would advocate that the system that we have does sort of encourage that and say that we are a household of four to five depending on how many teenagers and our household manages to exist on the smallest of the trash bins that the city provides and that That is kind of a choice that we make to be very deliberate about how we're managing our belongings So I would say that there is some element of pay as you throw right now in the choice of which trash bin you get and seeking to reduce down to that lowest amount, which is, I mean, it's like $10 a month, which is quite low in general. Would anyone else like to make a comment? Great. We're going to public comment now? Would anyone in chambers like to make a comment? You'll have three minutes. Anyone online? Great. Person online, please unmute yourself and state your name for the record. You'll have three minutes. Hello, my name is Sarah Wolford and I just wanted to thank Sanitation for all that they do. My mom worked in sanitation for a while. Jane St. John was also involved in, or was in New York during the sanitation strike. So I just think it's good to take a moment to appreciate the dirty work that doesn't always get appreciated. I also think it would be interesting to look into incentives to potentially downsize or a way to incentivize downsizing your units right now. You have to pay a fee in order to swap if you are someone at a rental and you want to like reduce or get a smaller one, you have to kind of coordinate that. potentially looking into some way to incentivize people to downsize their trash, I think could be interesting. And then just because it kind of involves a lot of people and a lot of things that have been under discussion tonight, I just wanted to kind of highlight that Public Works actually owns a vacant house at 2541 West Third Street. and they've owned it since 2008. So I'm just also kind of, this kind of, I guess, references earlier things talked about tonight, but I am just kind of curious how the city will handle vacancy fees for their own properties. And yeah, anyway, that's all, thank you. Thank you very much. Is there anyone else on Zoom who would like to speak? Okay. Second person online, you will have three minutes. Please unmute yourself and state your name. Is that me? Yes, we can hear you. OK, thank you. There's just no indication of the order. So anyway, good evening. My name's Eric Gost, and I appreciate this opportunity to offer public comment on the important topic of the future of city sanitation services. Before approving the proposed sanitation rate increases, which would recommend, I'm recommending that you continue this perhaps to another meeting, but certainly there might be time before the next one. I urge you to consider a more comprehensive and potentially more economical alternative, extending city sanitation services to all residential dwellings in Bloomington. including larger apartment buildings, condominiums, and private street communities. The current proposal would increase sanitation cart rates by approximately 48 percent over three years, principally to eliminate the general fund operating subsidy. But it assumes that the city's existing service boundaries should remain unchanged. There's been no publicly presented comprehensive financial analysis demonstrating that this being the current proposal is the most economical way to provide residential sanitation services. There might be alternatives. The city's registration rental data raises important questions about the fairness and efficiency of the existing system. A preliminary analysis identifies approximately 6,937 unique rental permits representing 29,175 rental units. Of these 6,379 permits representing of these, excuse me, 6379 permits represent 7357 rental units involving properties containing four or fewer units. The remaining 558 permits represent 21,818 units of larger rental properties. That means approximately 25% of registered rental units are in the category of residents currently required to pay the city sanitation services while approximately 75% are in larger rental properties that are by the city's choice intentionally excluded from services. This is important because the suggestion that homeowners receive subsidized city sanitation while renters do not is simply incorrect. Many renters already receive city sanitation services. The real distinction is based largely on building size and location, not on whether residents own or rent their homes. Why should Bloomington continue excluding so much of its residential housing for municipal collection without first determining whether universal service would benefit the entire community. A preliminary financial model suggests that expanding collection from approximately 14,700 existing municipal cart accounts to roughly 33,200 residential dwelling unit equivalents could reduce the average fully allocated costs from approximately $27.85 to $20.87 per month. It's about a 25% reduction. The expansion could support approximately- Thank you very much, Mr. Post. That is unfortunately your time. Okay, I apologize. I will submit the rest of this in writing. Thank you. Thank you. Is there someone in chambers who would like to speak? You'll have three minutes. Please state your name. This is Paul Rousseau. At times like this, I wish that there was more than three minutes for some people. But I'm one of the people who lives in the 75% of renters who do not get to recycle, because the landlord is not going to pay for more than just they're required to do. At least that's my impression, because I live in my neighborhood is in the stadium district, which is almost all large rentals. What I can see day by day all I see are large bins and all that in the parking lots of all the large apartment buildings and I Have a lifetime of experience of doing exactly what two council members here talked about reducing my personal waste stream I Habitually reflexively separate plastic glass put it on the refrigerator and then After a couple weeks, I put it in a plastic bag, take it out to the dump, and dump it into the bin. It doesn't get recycled. About 90% of my waste stream could be recycled. But it's not, because I don't get that option. And you multiply my experience over, well, 20,000 people, something like that. And so I strongly advocate extending the city program to all residents. Other than that, I'm a little bit agnostic on whether pay as you go or the cart fees are more efficient. But I do remember the pay as you go system when we had the stickers. Actually, I guess I'm not agnostic. I think that we should use a pay as you go system that does not use stickers anymore but uses Scannable carts and I think the previous speaker if he had been given more time could have given you more details on that But that's all I have thank you, thank you, is there anyone else who would like to speak on this Online okay. Great. Thank you very much at this time. I'll entertain a motion Ordinance 2026 dash 41 to a second reading on December 2nd. I There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Thank you. Will the clerk please call the roll? clarity. Yes. Stasberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Vasari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. Thank you. Thank you. That passes. We will continue this on December 2nd. Great. Thank you, council members. I will just make a quick note. I likely will not be here on the second, but we'll have other public work staff here with sanitation and our deputy director. So I appreciate you all. Thank you. Y'all heard it here first. If you have questions for director Wason, submit them in writing by Tuesday at 12. Thank you for being here. And now we have moved on to legislation for second readings and resolutions. Do I hear a motion? I move that resolution twenty twenty six dash twenty four be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. Okay. There's been a motion and a second. Do we have any discussion. Great. Will the clerk please call the roll. Yes. Councilmember Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Sorry. Yes. Daily. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. And Flaherty? Yes. All right. Will the clerk please read by title and synopsis? Yes. Sorry. Resolution 2026-24 to affirm the city of Bloomington as a welcoming and inclusive community for LGBTQ plus residents and visitors and to reinforce local commitments to equal protection health care access and human rights. The synopsis is as follows. Sponsored by council members Daly and Piedmont Smith. No, my apologies, Zulek. This resolution affirms the city of Bloomington as a welcoming and inclusive community for LGBTQ plus residents, workers and visitors, and reaffirms the city's commitments to protecting their civil rights, equal protections and dignity. Specifically, it reiterates Bloomington's gender-affirming health care policy, resolution 2024-09, upholds non-discrimination protections across municipal operations, programs, and services, and recommits to annual recognition of Transgender Day of Visibility, LGBTQ Plus Pride Month, and Transgender Day of Remembrance. Oh, and the sponsors were Daley and Zulek. Sorry. All right. Do I hear a motion? Thank you. I move that resolution 2026-24 be adopted. Second. All right. And just to explain, the person presiding shouldn't be sponsoring the legislation, so that's why I have the gavel for now. But council members Daley and Zulek, would you like to present? Yes. Thank you very much. Okay, so in June of 2024, this council unanimously passed resolution 2024-09, declaring Bloomington a safe haven for gender-affirming healthcare. And it was very meaningful, but a lot has changed since then. We've seen more rollbacks and barriers put in place, and frankly, more hate impacting our LGBTQ friends and family members. and our communities. And this is 100% unacceptable. One of the most important things that we can do as a community and as humans is to be a source of unconditional belonging. Everyone deserves a place where they can simply live, thrive, and feel safe without having to constantly defend their rights. So that is this promise that we want to keep alive in Bloomington. So tonight, Councilmembers Zulik and I are proud to introduce a resolution that turns the promise of our 2024 resolution into action. But before I give a quick walkthrough of it, I do want to take a pause to extend a sincere thank you to Liliana Young. She drafted the initial text of this legislation, and she brought it to Councilmembers Zulik and I for passage. So community-driven advocacy like hers is the heartbeat of local government, and I'm greatly deep full deeply grateful, let's just go with it, for her care initiative and her partnership. So tonight's resolution builds directly on that foundation and on the vital proclamations that Mayor Thompson issued for Pride Month of that year as well to meet the broader challenges of this moment though. So specifically, this legislation commits our city to four clear actions. Number one, it reaffirms our unwavering support for the civil rights, equal protections, and dignity of all LGBTQ plus residents, workers, and visitors. It renews our commitment to our 2024 gender affirming healthcare policy and upholds our local human rights ordinance across every municipal operation and service. It locks in annual community visibility, committing the city to officially recognize and support Transgender Day of Visibility, Pride Month, and tomorrow's transgender day of remembrance for every single year moving forward. And it turns our commitment outward, encouraging local schools, businesses, and other organizations to use our Human Rights Commission as an educational resource while sending an unmistakable message to all LGBTQ plus Hoosiers. Bloomington opens its doors, values your presence, and welcomes you home. So in a climate of shifting, state and federal policies, silence can create fear. By passing this resolution, we ensure that Bloomington remains a steady beacon of safety, dignity, and true belonging for everyone who calls our community home. And I'll pass it on over to Councilmember Zulek. Thank you. You covered that so well. I just have a couple extra comments. So this past election cycle, we saw some incredibly upsetting and disrespectful political ads attacking transgender people. Thankfully, we also saw those ads backfire in a very substantial way on election night. And so I believe that now is the time to reaffirm our solidarity with the LGBTQ plus community. We have also as a council spent quite a bit of time over the past few months holding deliberation sessions on the council's role in public safety. And one of the many things that we learned is that community and belonging actually do have a tangible impact on how safe someone feels in our city. And I know that this resolution won't eradicate homophobia or transphobia in our country or even in our city, but it is my hope that by passing this, our LGBTQ plus siblings are reminded that Bloomington wants you here and that when we say public safety, your safety is a part of that. We are happy to answer any questions. Thank you, council sponsors, Daley and Zulek. Are there any questions from colleagues? Council Member Stosberg. I do actually have one little question. Council Member Daley, you were emphasizing in section four, like during your presentation, section four, kind of the official recognition recognition of those different observances does that change anything about how we're currently recognizing those because I kind of feel like they already are official are they not actually official and we just do it as far as I know it's not official part of the city calendar recognition okay thanks sponsors I will just follow up on Council Member Stossberg's question. So what do you envision as the, how would we annually recognize these, the Transgender Day of Visibility and Day of Remembrance? Would that be some kind of a proclamation or what do you have in mind? Proclamation would be great. city activities around any of them, officially recognizing, especially for Pride Month. I know we in Bloomington celebrated in August. Typically, it's celebrated in June. I'd love to do both. I think in a lot of ways, us re-establishing, hey, these are days that we celebrate and or participate in, depending on the type of day. I know we have one day of remembrance. But also, this year, Governor Braun established June as the nuclear family month. And so I know that that is not something that any of us up here agree with. And I also know that not everyone in Bloomington might know that, unless we say it. part of this vote is to say, you know what, actually June is for Pride Month, and in Bloomington so is August, and the rest of the year. Thank you. All right, any other questions or any comments from, oh no, we'll just do questions, sorry. Yes, Council Member Stossberg. I do have a question then in light of some of that answer and realizing that in section four it says, Pride month in August specifically So I assume that that was deliberate or do you I mean do you because August isn't actually pride month, but that's when we celebrate pride So is that phrase the best way that we want to phrase that right now I guess Would you like to bring forward an amendment well I I just want to make sure that we're not locking into something that we don't really want to lock into in terms of that idea of celebrating Pride Month in June and August. So are we saying we definitely want to celebrate in August, and then maybe we'll celebrate in June later? I was also being mindful when we were working through this resolution to not overreach or overextend to create I thought this was a good place to start. Honestly, yeah, I'll leave it at that. OK. As long as everybody else feels good about that language, I'm good. All right. If there are no other questions, we can go to public comment. Is there anybody in the public who would like to comment on resolution 2026-24? we'll start here in council chambers. Please go ahead, state your name for the record and you'll have up to three minutes. Good evening council and for the record, I am Liliana Young. I am the chair of the Bloomington DSA Stonewall Working Group that put this resolution in front of the council. The LGBTQ community has been under cultural and legal assault for decades. Indeed, even after advancements in social acceptance and marriage equality and baseline employment and housing protections and health care access we have still seen in this recent era an erosion of these things or Promises from some of the nation's most powerful people to erode them This council does not have the power to repair that damage and My own immediate community, transgender people, have been facing the brunt of this for the last decade, a sustained campaign to vilify and demonize us and paint us as the nation's most destabilizing force in modern history. funded by arch conservative billionaires and perpetuated by Republican politicians, both nationally and right here in our home state. And this council does not have the wealth to combat that unequal footing. Truly things have deteriorated so heavily and so quickly for trans people that simply being openly trans in this modern era imposes a stress and a danger upon us that the cisgender people in this room are fundamentally incapable of understanding, but know that when we are beaten half to death in public restrooms, that when we are murdered in the supposed safety of our apartment laundry rooms, and when right here in Bloomington, one of our own was seconds away from being physically attacked in a women's locker room, that when I leave my home, To do this kind of advocacy for the basic dignity of my people that might be the last day I see my own wife and my child and This council does not have the power to restore that safety for everyone But what this council does have the power to do is to declare with us? loudly and proudly that here in Bloomington we celebrate curiosity and differences and science that in Bloomington, all members of the LGBTQ community will find dignity and inclusion no matter who's in charge of the state government or federal government, and that this city will help continue to advance queer liberation, not just through pretty words, but also further policy to come. And we invite you to use that power. Thank you. Next speaker here in chambers, please. Hello. My name is Jordan Connor, a relatively recent transplantee into Bloomington. And I felt in my time here that Bloomington feels accepting of all different types of people. And that's one thing that makes me really proud to get so invested into the community. So a resolution like this would really mean a lot to me to see pass. I also think that it would be an excellent first step in the continuing progress of defending our LGBTQ plus populace and would love to see this set the groundwork for future ordinances and activities that would continue to make tangible beneficial change in our community. So thank you very much. One more here in chambers and then we'll check online. Good evening, y'all. My name is Kate Lubbin. I'm a social worker. I'm transgender. I'm speaking in favor of the resolution tonight. I just want to thank Council Member Daley and Zulik for sponsoring this. Now, a little bit of history about me. I first moved to Bloomington 10 years ago. Before that, I was living in rural Texas, and it wasn't long after moving here that I realized that a certain weight had been lifted off of my chest. Now, I realized that the dread and fear that I had been living with, the fear that someone would follow me home to attack me or that I would be suddenly fired just for being myself was lifted. That is to say, in short, I felt a sense of belonging. In short order, Bloomington became my home. And that is a beautiful feeling to feel a sense of belonging and a sense of being at home. But more and more each day, people like me see the communities in which they live become less and less like home. They see ads on TV. They see statements from politicians vilifying their existence. They see assemblies trying to make their existence illegal. That is, until one day these people decide that they have had enough and they pack their things, they leave, just like I did from my community in Texas. I recognize that this city council's options are limited when it comes to pushing back against a state and federal government who would like to remove people like me from society. But what this council can do is to make it clear to all that Bloomington is a safe place, a community where everyone is welcome. Let us remember that inclusion benefits everyone. When people are driven out, as council member Daley mentioned, these are our family members, these are our friends, these are our community members, these are our neighbors. These are real people who could otherwise help us create a beautiful and vibrant community together. Let us ensure that there is no doubt in anyone's mind, all are welcome here in Bloomington. I urge you all to vote in favor of this resolution. Thank you. Is there anybody on Zoom who has their hand raised? No? Okay. Well, we can continue here in council chambers. There's another person who would like to comment. Hi, Paul Russo. I'll just make it brief. If I had seen a resolution like this a year ago, I thought maybe it would be gilding the lily, because it seems to me that Bloomington, of course, is the oasis that we all think it is. In July, a woman at the First United Church was attacked while she was gardening. And it was covered in the B Square bulletin. She was attacked for her color and for being lesbian. And it kind of reminded us that you can't let your guard down. So if nothing else, a resolution like this reminds us of who we really are. And it's important. While I'm at it, I'd like to give a plug for the Coriolan Men's Chorus. They're having their 25th anniversary this year, one of the largest, longest-standing gay men's choruses. And their concert will be the weekend before Christmas, 19th and 20th. Thank you. Would anybody else in chambers like to comment? Hi, Joshua Stockton. I would just like to start off by saying I want to thank everyone for showing up today, especially my queer siblings. I did want to comment specifically on the policy itself. I think it would be perfectly fine to have Pride in August. I gave it some thought while sitting there, and I was like, I think it'll get more attention. I frankly think it would get more attention broadly, if we have it in Pride Month. And I think it also makes sense for our community, too, because August is a welcoming time in Bloomington. Historically, June has been Pride Month because of queer liberation in New York City. But I think having it in August would also make a statement about who we are. It doesn't really matter what time of the year we do it. It just matters that we do it. And I think more importantly, it's important that we have transgender day of remembrance and trans visibility day even more than we have pride month because those are the people who have really fought for my rights and for everyone else's rights too. So I also have to say the city needs to follow up with it. If we are going to do this as a thing we need to be sending out those emails. We need to be printing out the papers and posting them in the staff lounge and out where the public is. We need to also have events like we need to have a meeting, a gathering, something where we can actually remember, we can actually see visibility. Because since moving here in 2020, I've seen the visibility diminish. I've watched it. The way people interact, the clothes they wear, the way they cut their hair or dye it, it truly has changed. And it has diminished. And that's what we're fighting for today is against that. We will be out here. We will be ourselves. And we will be queer. Thank you, guys. Anybody else in council chambers, please come to the microphone. Hello, my name is Kip Reedlove. I've lived in Bloomington for about eight years since 2019, and I fell in love with the community and with Indiana, but I'm not really in love with the hate that is enshrined an hour north in Indianapolis every day at the Capitol. So I just want to urge you to please vote yes on this ordinance. I don't want my queer friends such as Kate who spoke tonight to have to leave Bloomington because that would only make the community worse. And also I'd like to note for the record that Trans Remembrance Day is not tomorrow, it's Friday. Anyway, thank you for your time. Thank you. I apologize. It's the 20th. You're absolutely right. I thought today was the 19th. Not bad. Is there anybody online now? Yes. And Clerk Bolden. OK, let's go to the person online, and then we'll go to Clerk Bolden. So individual who has raised their hand online, you should be unmuted and ready to give us your name. Hello, this is Sarah Wilford again. I just wanted to thank members of council for putting this forward and I lend my support and also kind of echo earlier comments on how I think this is a great. Oh, Sarah, are you there? accepting values, but I also think we need to continue. You are going in and out. Oh, it's the zoom. The moment that we think that it's okay to kind of take a pause or take a break is when our adversaries take advantage of that and start to work to limit limit our freedoms. So I think this is a great first step, but I also look forward to further measures to help protect our LGBTQ family and community. Thanks. Thank you. Clerk Polden, did you want to make a statement? Thank you. I wanted to say thank you to council members Daley and Zulek for taking the language that had been proposed by Liliana and putting forth a resolution. I do appreciate it. This is Loomington. We're a town of extremes at times. And being in a community that tries to affirm and recognize our marginalized communities is something I'm grateful for as a black LGBTQ plus community member. I am fully aware of the hostility and discrimination and high rates of violence towards our community, particularly our black trans community. And so I say thank you for this resolution. I think it's a very good step. I would love to see the city actually pursue further measures, including gender neutral bathrooms and other things that we could do, at least in our city buildings, if not citywide for all businesses. And to those who showed up tonight and spoke, I say thank you. Again, it's nice to see you in the room. I hope you show up more. And that is all. Thank you. Thank you. Last call, would anybody else in the council chambers like to make a comment? Is there anybody else online? All right. Thank you. We'll come back to council members. Would any council member like to make a comment? Council member Zulek. Thank you. I just want to thank Liliana, who we've had the pleasure of working with on this resolution, and also thank everyone who came to speak today. I know it's no small thing to come up here and put your name on the public record and say what you need to say about your own safety. Advocating for yourself is probably one of the scariest things you can do, especially as a young person. And so thank you. I hope that you pat yourself on the back when you go home. Councilmember Daly. I had a whole bunch more that I had written up that I was going to say, but you guys don't need more flowery words. I already said some. But I do just want to make sure that I thank everybody who did show up tonight and echo Councilmember Zulek's comments and Clerk Bolden's comments about showing up and making comment that is incredibly impactful and very valuable. And I just wanted to say that Bloomington sees you, we value you, and we welcome you home. Thank you. Any other council member comments? I will just say that I appreciate my colleagues bringing this forward. I appreciate Ms. Young for working on it and the whole working group that she's part of. And I agree with Clerk Bolden that one important step we could take is gender neutral restrooms, at least in City Hall, all city buildings. This is something that I've been thinking about for a while. In addition, we need to make sure that all of our ordinances have gender neutral language. One of the ordinances we had tonight for first reading, I think it was the one about Title VI, had some phrase about how the masculine language shall also refer to the feminine and the plural shall also refer to the singular or something like this. I'm like, no, that is not sufficient, and I will be authoring an amendment to change that. That's just lazy. I mean, we can change the language to they, them. It's just a matter of common sense and being inclusive, and that's what we need to do. We represent everybody in the community, and we value everybody's voice. So with that, There are no other comments. I'm looking up there. We can go for a roll call vote, please. Well, Councilmember Piedmont-Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Daly. Oh, no. I'm sorry. Sorry. First. Yes. Thank you. Daly. Yes. Morello. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger yes clarity yes and Stasberg yes thank you that passes unanimously thank you all right on to our next piece of legislation do I hear any word I'm sorry do I hear it Yes. Council member Stasberg. I would like to make a motion to suspend the rules and amend the agenda and move ordinance twenty twenty six thirty one which is item C under second readings resolutions up so that we hear it right now. So basically switching B and C. OK. There's been a motion. Is there a second second. OK. Any discussion. Councilmember Stasberg, can you send that to me in writing, please? I love it. I'm sorry, what? Will you please send that to me in writing? Oh, yeah. Thank you. OK. And no discussion, so will the clerk please call the roll? Yes, one moment, please. That's not going to work. I'm sorry? Yes. Daily? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stosberg? Yes. And Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. That passes. And so now, ordinance 2026-31 will come before ordinance 2026-27. Any motions? Sorry. Oh, yes. I move that ordinance 2026-31 be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. Second. OK. There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion? OK. Thank you. Will the clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Asari? Yes. Daly? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? Yes. Clarity. Stasberg. Yes. Piedmont-Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Thank you. Passes. Will the clerk please read? This is 2026-31, correct? Yes. Thank you. Ordinance 2026-31, UDO amendments related to housing attainability. The synopsis is as follows. This ordinance contains amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance to amend the use specific standards regulating the use dwelling accessory unit, dwelling cottage home, dwelling duplex, dwelling triplex, and dwelling fourplex. The council sponsor is Stasburg. Thank you. Since twenty twenty six dash thirty one be adopted second Okay, who is here to present please state your name and go ahead Thank you very much Eric Grulick development services manager so I'm here to present or just kind of give a brief overview of what we Discussed about two weeks ago regarding this series of amendments to the UDO. So this is the third series of amendments that the department kind of brought forward starting several months ago. Some of these were just following up on items within the UDO that we had highlighted a while ago earlier in the last year actually. Um, look at what we can do to improve housing attainability within the community. Um, some of these were also then, um, or we're also folded into some changes that the state brought forward in a house bill 10 0 1 directing communities to look at certain aspects of their zoning codes that are, um, possibly holding back housing, um, looking at, Diversifying the use table. So we had identified a couple things within the UDO related to accessory dwelling units cottage homes and duplexes and triplexes So we brought forward some amendments these were heard at the Playing Commission So when House Bill 1001 was coming forward and moving through the legislation last year there were some broad series of initiatives within there that were going to possibly come forward. Some of those played out some of those didn't. One of the things that was incorporated within there was a definition a new definition for accessory dwelling units that gave a certain size as the department had looked at and considered modifying some of the accessory dwelling unit standards. We saw this as a good opportunity to sink our definition of an ADU with the state's definition and also give a slight increase with the size of the accessory dwelling unit. So the legislation that came forward with HB 10 0 1 as I mentioned give that no definition that said 80 use could be no more than a thousand square feet or 75 percent of a dwelling unit. So we're sinking our language with that with this as I mentioned we had highlighted some things with a use within the UDL called cottage home developments. So cottage home development is something that doesn't get used very much. In fact, we've only had one petition come forward with that and so some of the restrictions within those density standards were certainly seen as a hindrance some of the other standards regarding buffering and setbacks also kind of created challenges with use utilizing those incentives within the UDO so we've proposed modifying those density allowances to give a greater likelihood of those being implemented And then for duplexes and triplexes We had identified a couple things within there that that we could look at Loosening or removing to help try to make these a little bit more attainable as well some of the things that are in the UDO that regulate those are the use specific standards and then also a number a maximum number of accessory of Duplexes that can be approved within a year and then there is a 150 foot buffer that is created around any approved duplexes for two years So we had highlighted the last two there The maximum number that could be done per calendar year and then also the buffer as two possible things that we could remove And then in regards to the use specific standards as we have gone through several Petitions of those one of the the key elements that we do always make sure to evaluate when they there are four elements Let me rephrase that back up a little bit. There are four you specific standards that govern duplexes Those are roof pitch front porch width and depth front building setback and vehicular access that the you specific standards say that those elements should be Similar to a majority of the structures on a block face in regards to the the roof pitch. We have also always Interpreted that to mean roof orientation. So roof pitch and orientation are very intrinsically designed and so we we are adding language to the roof pitch to just supplement to say that Orientation is also an element of that as well. So that's just kind of following up with our our common practice and so as I mentioned we also proposing to remove the cap, the maximum number 15 that are allowed per year and the 150 foot buffer. And then also there was a standard associated with triplexes and fourplexes That restricted those to only one or I'm sorry two entrances for the building as a whole And then it did create challenges in situations where somebody wanted to town Turn those into townhomes and couldn't have a door for every unit that was in there So we saw that as a hindrance as well. And so we're proposing to remove that So the Planning Commission did hear this in their septum September meeting sorry, it's been a while and voted to send this to you Five oh, I believe so with that I'm here to have any happy to answer any questions. Thank you I think there are two amendments. Would it make more sense to propose those first? Councilmember Piedmont Smith Yes So I move amendment one to ordinance 2026-31 There's been a, so this is brought forward by myself and council members Rallo and Ruff and it basically eliminates two paragraphs that are proposed to be changed by the ordinance. So it eliminates those changes and they are about the maximum number of approved duplex dwellings in R1, R2 and R3. shall be 15 per year. We want to keep that in there. The 150-foot buffer shall be created around the approved duplex dwelling in R1, R2, and R3 zoning districts. We want to keep that in there as well. My rationale, and I welcome my co-sponsors, of course, to talk as well, but my main rationale is that The main argument in favor of allowing duplexes in R1, R2, and R3 zoning districts in 2021 was that higher density housing in these districts would bring down housing prices. But what I've actually seen occurring in my district is that old affordable rental homes have been torn down and replaced with new duplexes with much higher lease rates. In addition, the replacement of single-family homes with duplexes has led to a shortage of on-street parking in some neighborhoods that has not been adequately addressed through changes in city policy. So that's my presentation. Councilmembers Ruffin, Rollo? If there's anything to add. I don't have anything to add, but I want to thank Councilmember Piemont-Smith for taking the initiative to bring this amendment forward. Yeah, I just would like to thank my colleague, too, for bringing it forward. I feared what I've seen happen, which is conversion of small single-family homes, including ones that are rental, that have been perplexed, which increases density, but it doesn't address affordability. And so the affordability is has not manifested. And so I would be, I think it's consistent to say that that number of approvals shouldn't change because we would just expedite the process. That's all. Thank you. And I do just want to let everyone know that an amendment could possibly send the ordinance back to Plan Commission for an automatic 45-day kickback. And I'm hoping that Attorney Rossman can provide a little more detail. I'd be happy to. Thank you. This is an openly good question tonight. Here's why. Under the traditional planning law, Indiana Code 36-7-4-607, amending a favorably certified zoning proposal requires a mandatory 45-day return to plan commission. However, recent state statutory updates have created some ambiguity. Our code hasn't been updated, and our code references the old Indiana code is my understanding. Also our UDO is a question as well. I'm not able to provide a formal opinion tonight on how the latest state statute reconciles with our local code. Uh, I couldn't guarantee that adopting amendment one will allow final passage tonight. Okay. Thank you. The sponsors of the amendment like to respond to that and or do you have any thoughts? Well, it's my understanding that it's always been the case. If we amend something that plan commission brings to us, they have a certain time period to accept it or override it. So I don't see that this is any different. Okay. Are there any questions for sponsors for Amendment 1? Okay. We'll go to public comment. Would any member of the public like to comment in chambers? Go right ahead. Please state your name. Is there anyone online? Because I'm the only one left at 10 o'clock. Yes. Yes strongly support the amendment for the reasons cited I Talked to the people at 614 grant the end of the spring semester and they were four students renting a four-bedroom house for $2,200 that's five hundred and fifty dollars a piece and then in this fall in August or September I talked to the Students across the street and they thought they have a good deal because they're renting at $1,200 a bedroom new construction and And their neighbors are paying $1,600 a month. It's anecdotal, I know. But I support this. Thank you. Thank you. Looks like we have one more person in chambers. Anybody online? OK, great. Thank you. Go ahead. Hi, Joshua Stockton again. I would say I do support this, a personal testimony. Lot across the street from me a home was just demolished. It was a two bedroom home. I was older in the community built 1930s. The units were about five to six hundred dollars a month per bedroom. So about twelve hundred dollars a month. But in my neighborhood this is a lot of what we're seeing is homes being torn down that were affordable for students many of whom are Hoosiers. That's one thing specifically in my neighborhood and at the university right now is that a lot of Hoosiers are being priced out from just living here and being able to go to school here. So this would help a lot of that. And I would say this can help retain the housing in my neighborhood, because now you wouldn't be able to build around it. And also, I will say the on-street parking issue in my neighborhood, which is something I recently found out about, how I can't get a parking pass, even though there's no one that parks in front of the building. There's going to be 12 new residents across the street that are going to have no place to put their cars. So I don't know where they're going to put them. They're probably going to put them in my parking lot eventually. And then I'm not going to have a place to park. So that's also something that needs to be addressed in the future. But I think this is a step in the right direction. So thank you. Thank you. Anybody else? We have one more member of the public in here. Nobody on Zoom? OK. We'll come back to Council comment. Council member Stasberg. Thank you. I wanted to comment on this in terms of my representation to the Planning Commission. At Planning Commission, we did talk about these two sections. And the argument that was generally given toward keeping keeping these sections in as opposed to eliminating them had to do actually with something slightly different, which is the fact that plexes are conditional right now. And so then everything has to go to the BZA, the Board of Zoning Appeals. And so if suddenly we remove the restrictions around that, then are we going to suddenly get a lot more cases in front of the the BZA. The numbers that were shared by staff when we were considering this was that over the last few years, the number approved or before the BZA has not approached this maximum of 15 and there hasn't been an issue with the buffer. That was why we left it in, figuring that anything else like as the body, figuring than anything else, was more of a political decision as opposed to something land use based. I'm agnostic about it in a lot of ways because I think that my real concern with duplexes does lie in the fact that they're conditional. And this doesn't change that, whether this is in or whether it's not in. They're still conditional, and they've got to go before the Board of Zoning Appeals. And there are just numerous challenges within that process for everybody involved, I think, including community members, neighbors of potential projects, the developers themselves, the Board of Zoning Appeals, volunteers, and what they're being asked to do in their capacity. I'm fine supporting this tonight to leave these in. Yeah. I'm agnostic either way. Go either way. Thanks. Councilmember Rosa Parker. I agree. I think if the first step had been making them permitted I would have liked that a little more. But I think that allowing more duplexes that end up staying in the BZA for months and slowing down projects and increasing costs will just force that issue, so I'm okay with this right now. I did have a question about the ADUs, I think. Oh, where is the amendment? Okay, so that's what I think. So I wouldn't approve the amendment and I would be okay with just going with the UDO, the update as is. Thank you. Any final Councilmember Flaherty? Yeah, I'm not going to support the amendment. I understand the logical chain that's in the rationale. I did want to share my different perspective from what's reflected there. One is that, and I've said this in other contexts, I think parking issues of all kinds are appropriately regulated through parking policy and not housing policy. So if we are having overly parked streets, it means we need to price them or permit them differently, not, you know, avoid having certain types of housing. I think my perspective, I guess, on the rationale outline for the amendment is that it takes a very narrow lens over a very short time scale that leads to a sort of misunderstanding of how housing affordability works in the community. First of all new construction is more expensive than older homes like full stop of any type And so that's true of new single-family homes. It's true of any type of new homes and we're not here to crying You know the the homes being torn down for new single-family homes being built. We just sort of like target it on a small multifamily and missing middle housing for some reason and if it's because they're more likely to house renters or students or what but it We tend to be inconsistent in the application of that logic about the expense of new housing and the housing loss that we're experiencing From you know older homes which you know Just just to be frank like aren't always in great shape and often, you know are maybe not needing to be preserved They might entail 150 or 200 thousand dollars of work to be made, you know livable so having experienced the rental market here myself for some time like I know that is the case and So while people are paying more, they're also getting a higher quality home in many instances. That doesn't address the one-to-one affordability question of the exact lot or property where that's happening, of course, but again, that kind of misses the forest for the trees. Broadly, I believe we need much more housing than we have because we are a desirable community with a massive net in commute and people who want to live here who can't. There's a dire need for affordable housing solutions of all kinds through various forms of subsidies and there's a need for much greater housing availability of all types. We can't just do extremely large apartment complexes and detached single family homes. I believe strongly having a range of housing types that reflects the historical nature of our community housing and There's good imperial research on all this from cities that have done this better than we have of the actual broader affordability benefits at the system. Again, not at the lot looking at that single question about a single lot and what happened there, but looking at the rents and home prices across the whole system. So, you know, we talk about these things ad nauseam. That's nothing new exactly. Just sharing a different perspective on the questions we should be asking when it comes to something like Duplexes and triplexes their role in the community and what we should be expecting of them. So that's why I'm not supporting it. Thank you Yeah, I certainly understand the arguments that councilmember Flaherty is making and those are the arguments I made in 2021 when You know, I actually wanted to to make it easier to build duplexes this 15 per year and 150 foot buffer was a compromise then. But what I've seen happen in the neighborhoods I represent is not single family homes being torn down to build new single family homes. It's single family homes being torn down to build duplexes. And they are more expensive. And I also have seen Uh, that the city has not done the pricing of parking. Um, so I'm just looking at the reality on the ground and not trying to make it any worse. And, and, you know, as others have said, this is not a big change either way. It's not going to make much of a difference. Um, but I, I just don't want to make a problem that I'm seeing, um, for my residents, uh, worse, even if it's just a tiny bit. Thank you. Thank you. Final comments? OK. Will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 1? Yes. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? No. Flaherty? No. Stosberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Zulik? Yes. Sorry? Yes. Okay, that passes of 6-2. 7-2. Wow, all of us are here tonight. Would anyone like to introduce a second amendment? Yeah, I'll move amendment two. Okay, there's been a motion in a second. Take it away, council member Piedmont-Smith. This is just correcting some typos. Are there any questions? Okay. No questions? Would any member of the public like to make comment on typos? Anyone on Zoom? Great. Thank you. Back to council for council comment. Council member Stasberg. Terms to term and plan commission. So maybe this is a second terms to term, but I Don't know if it's the same one or not. I'll have to look at that Thank thank thank you for catching these as usual careful reader Piedmont Smith Okay, any other comments Great. Well the clerk, please call the roll Councilmember Allah Yes breath yes Rosenberger Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stasberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Daly? Yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. Amendment two passes. And now we will go back to ordinance 2026-27 as amended. So questions. Council member Rosenberger, did you want to ask your question? Yep, it's so late, you know, I'm just, I can't, okay, I have a question about the ADUs. I was trying to find it in the UDO, like in, okay, I'm sorry, so they're getting changed to 1,000 square feet or 75% of the primary residents. In some cases, is that smaller than what's allowed now? No, because the minimum would be a thousand, whichever is less. So let's say that, you know, the house was was really big, then they could go seventy five percent of that. Yeah. But if your house is a thousand square feet, yes, then you get six seventy five maybe in places that it would normally be eight hundred right now. Is that right? I mean, it would have to be a really, really small house. I think, you know, I'd have to do the math of what. I mean, Prospect Hill has a lot of a thousand square foot homes. I'm sorry, say that again. Prospect Hill has a lot of a thousand square foot homes. So is this? Yeah, but every two, I mean, if it's a two story, then both of those would, would count. Both of those floors would count for that. If what's the two story? If the, you're talking about a thousand square foot home. If it was a one story then sure it would just be a thousand if it was a two story then it obviously would be a two thousand square foot home that we would take that seventy five percent from. I'm sorry I feel confused that I thought it was saying that started over the ADU can be either a thousand square feet or seventy five percent of the primary residents whichever is less. Is the lesser of the two, yes. So if your primary residence is 1,000 square feet, why are you talking about 2,000 square feet? Yeah, so in that case, it would be 750. If it was 1,000 square feet, it would be 750. So in that case now, I mean, right now in Prospect Hill, it would be 580. That's what it's limited to right now. Is it getting smaller or bigger? OK, so it's still getting bigger? Yes. OK, thank you. Other questions? Okay, we'll go to public comment on ordinance 2026-27 at, or I'm sorry, ordinance 2026-31 as amended. Anyone in chambers? Okay, anyone online? Okay, great. Person online, you'll be able to unmute yourself. Please state your name and you'll have three minutes. is Audrey Smith. I apologize. I am also feeling the time of night it is. So my thoughts are not very put together. But I just want to encourage the council to support density. And I think that allowing ADUs and duplexes is a good way to do that. People have raised concerns about parking. And earlier in the evening, there was discussion of public transportation and what we can do to support public transportation. And I think that that is one way of addressing parking concerns that hadn't been brought into the conversation yet. There are lots of ways that we can make it so that people don't need cars as much. And that will make it so that we don't need as much space devoted to parking. I think that's all I have. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anyone else? Okay. Second person on Zoom, take it away. Please state your name. Hello, this is Sarah Wolford. I just wanted to also say that I encourage council to continue to look at ways that we can increase density. both from a sustainability perspective and also from a housing affordability standpoint. I think I live in Isabel Piedmont Smith's district. And so I appreciate her concerns over parking and the demolition of some houses or the planned demolition of homes in our district. I think that there are other ways to potentially address some of the concerns around parking and around demolition delays that can happen. And that's not necessarily my area of expertise. I'll leave that to the politicians. But I just want to say that the, The need to be creative and to use all the tools in our toolbox during this housing crisis is really important. And I appreciate council taking steps to address density and just encourage to kind of be moving in that direction. I'd love to see more about potential alley frontage in areas as well. And yeah. Thank you. Thank you very much. In chambers. Evening, Paul Rousseau again. In my opinion, density alone does not create a walkable and bicyclable neighborhood. Just increasing the density will bring in more cars. And that's what we're saying. I've said this before. I'm like a broken record. I think this is the cart before the horse. If we have a mass transit system, if we have college and Walnut redesigned, if we have a lot of things to encourage bicycling and walking that we don't have now, and then you add the density, well, yeah, maybe that would work. But if you just add the density in a car-centric city, you're going to get more cars. And it's not good. So I oppose this. It's just growth by other means. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else in chambers online? Great. We'll come back for final council comment. Anybody? Council members Stasberg and then Flaherty. I just want to address that adding density in a car centric city is going to add more cars concept because I think that one of our challenges with with cars in Bloomington is that we have a really large student population. And students sometimes bring cars, right? And I think that one of the things, societally, that we don't necessarily think about when we own a car is where we're going to put the car. And so I think a piece of it is educational and collaborating with IU to make sure that in their literature and understanding they're saying to their students when they come, hey, you've got to have a plan for where you're going to put your car. Where are you going to store your car? And it's not something that societally I think we've typically thought about. The United States is really big, right? There's all this space in the United States to put stuff. But in cities, that's not necessarily true. you know, thinking about New York City, thinking about Chicago, thinking about some of those really big urban areas. I mean, you know, my kid wanted to drive to visit New York over the summer, and you know, she's 18 now, I can only control so much. But my question to her was, are you actually gonna bring your car into New York City? Because that is a thing. And she hadn't fully thought about that. even though she's like my kid and we talk about that kind of thing all the time. So if that's not part of the culture of, well, where are you going to park? You can't necessarily assume there's a place to park. I mean, we have to somehow make that part of the culture for not only the people who live here full-time, year-round for years and years and years, but also our more temporary student population coming in, and we need to say, hey, you need to make a plan for where you're going to put your car. Here are some options for how that works. And that's communication, that's collaboration, that's education. Thanks. Councilmember Flaherty. Yeah, I also just wanted to talk about some of the sustainability things, because a few members of the public brought it up. There's multiple benefits to allowing more people to live here. It's not that allowing more folks to live in neighborhoods that are close to campus when there are students there or staff there. It's not that they're going to necessarily get rid of cars, though some might. It's that they're going to have to drive a whole heck of a lot less than they would if they were living in Bedford or out in the county somewhere. And so increased density, a big part of it is just allowing people to live close to where they you know, work and playing and shop such that the trips are shorter. More trips can be made by foot and bike, even if it's not, you know, where we ideally like to see it. Also just noting that multifamily housing has shared walls that reduces energy costs substantially. These things do pay big dividends over time. Like it's, again, I'm just a fundamental believer in missing middle housing as a role, and I think we lose sight of that sometimes because new housing isn't affordable, like full stop. Market rate new housing isn't affordable. of almost any type, whether it's massive multi-family buildings or single-family homes. If we wanted to get really serious about trying to control prices, we would set maximum sizes for the homes that can be built. We wouldn't let anything be bigger than 1,500 square feet, because that's going to cut the cost of a new home in half. So that's pretty aggressive. We're not going to do that. I get it. People would call us communists or something. But just noting that there's a lot of sustainability benefits to small-scale multi-family housing. Understand that the trade-offs that folks folks have in mind and the concerns around it When when we see an older home that might be pretty affordable now disappear for something newer that's not affordable right now So I get it, but just wanted to talk to those sustainability aspects as well. Thanks Thank you. Any other final comments? Okay Councilmember Rosenberger, I'll just go a little bit about parking. It's fun, you know, I Lived in Denver and I lived in a an apartment across from a restaurant bar, and if I moved my car after 5 p.m., I couldn't find a spot anywhere near me. It changed how I lived, and it changed the decisions I was making about driving. It's a good thing. I didn't have a car when I went to school here, and my parents didn't either. And I think it's sad how many cars are here now. If students need them to go home, I think that's OK. You can park at the stadium. So students get to park at the stadium and pay, I think, $77 or something like that. Our city also has garages that you can do seven days a week, non-reserved. You can do five days a week. You can do reserved. They're not sold out. So there's places to put your car if you need to come here. And it doesn't necessarily need to be right in front of your house. I think it's a neat way to live, right? And the fact that we have so many people who come here and say, oh my gosh, you live here. I can't believe it. I could never afford to live here. I think we need to make big changes. And I think we're making some. And I think rents are starting to look a little better. I'm in Prospect Hill and looking at what to rent seems like It's not going up as much as it used to, I think, which is really neat. And it's showing that maybe we're building housing and folks are choosing to live. Students maybe are living in bigger spaces. I'm not quite sure. But what we're not allowing still is missing middle housing. And it's so controversial here. I think it's a real bummer that we're saying that we have so many duplexes and we're not allowed to make more, even though they work fine in neighborhoods. Like new ones, old ones, Prospect Hill has a lot of duplexes. But no, we can't make any more. It's just kind of wild to me. We can't build what's right across the street from us. Like, why is that? We've regulated housing prices to be so expensive. And it is just a supply and demand. And then in terms of climate change, it really matters where we're putting these homes. So I hope this is going to be a tiny little thing again that we change. And I guess I just hope this council can still do more than this. Thanks. Any other comments? OK, will the clerk please call the roll on ordinance 2026 31 as amended? Yes. Councilmember Ruff? No. Rosenberger? Yes. Flaherty? Yes. Stossberg? Yes. Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Zulek? Yes. Sorry. Yes. Daily. Yes. Bravo. Yes. Okay thank you that passes eight one. And now we are back to ordinance twenty twenty six dash twenty seven. Twenty six dash twenty seven be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. Any discussion. Will the clerk please call the roll. Councilmember Rosenberger. Yes. Flaherty. Yes. Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Asari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Thank you very much. Will the clerk please read. ordinance twenty twenty six twenty seven to fix the salaries of all elected city officials for the city of bloomington for the year twenty twenty seven the synopsis is as follows this ordinance recommended by the special fiscal committee sets the twenty twenty seven salaries for all elected city officials for the city of bloomington thank you very much six dash twenty seven be adopted I don't have very much to present. I talked about it a little bit at first reading this and there's a memo in there that I wrote in terms of the recommendation coming from the fiscal committee with a 2-1 vote with Councilmember Flaherty being absent that day and I voted against it. I included two amendments in there that are sponsored by myself. I don't know if you guys want me to pick an amendment and introduce that first or just have any questions about the ordinance as it's presented. Well, I think in this case because amendments one and two contradict each other, it might be worth a motion to suspend the rules to discuss both amendments simultaneously. I guess my thought on that immediately is that at first reading, I kind of brought that up as a, you know, can we discuss it and there was very little discussion, I felt like, from colleagues. So I don't know if people have more opinions on it now or whether it would be more instrumental to pick one. That is up to you, Councilmember Stosberg. I guess I'll go ahead and introduce Amendment 1 then. I'll move Amendment 1. second. All right, go right ahead council member Stossberg. So basically, you know this this discussion in general this year the resounding conclusion from fiscal committee was that we're essentially going to do a COLA increase and one of the other issues is that you know the the overall like cost of the COLA increase is what is currently in our city budget and so exceeding that in general would just not be good. So What amendment one does is it addresses my ongoing issue that I have with COLA increases, that a standard COLA increase across all positions just exacerbates the salary gap. This idea actually came from Controller McKim, he said it publicly, so I think it's okay in a meeting. What the county had done, because the county had dealt with this too, right, in terms of that idea of the exacerbating the salary gap between high and low wage workers. When he was on county council, what he said was that they took that overall cost of the COLA increase and just divided it by the number of positions. And so then everybody got a flat increase, which meant that the lower end of the salaries got a higher percentage and the higher end of the salaries got a lower percentage, but they all got the same flat amount. That was just a way to counteract that kind of increasing wage gap. And so amendment one is just taking that concept across these positions, these three positions. And I can appreciate the concept that we're only doing this with these three salaries as opposed to all of civil city salaries, because it's an issue with all of civil city salaries as well. You know, these are the wages that we really control. These are the salaries that we control as the elected salaries. And it also is just a really interesting example of how that works. I also wanted to address, Clerk Bolden mentioned when we did it for first reading, this idea like, well, if it does this, she kind of broke it down to hourly. And I do want to make clear that we can't really, by law, think about hourly with our salaries with the elected salaries. But I did because it's an interesting exercise and I'm a math person. And so Clerk Bolden's comment was like, ooh, if council works 20 hours a week, say, on that 26,827 proposed salary with Amendment 1, then that's $25 an hour, and that's true. But if we take the mayor's hourly rate based on $40 an hour and that same in Amendment 1, it's over $70 an hour. And even at 60 hours a week, because I've heard the mayor say that she works way more than 40 hours, and whether or not that's advisable or good, it's still over $47 an hour, and the clerk You know, at 40 hours is almost $45 an hour, and at 50 hours is almost $36 an hour. So there's still a huge differential there in terms of what elected officials are getting paid versus our, we can say the lowest wage workers in the city are getting paid, which the living wage is something like 16 something an hour, maybe 22 this year. Um, so I'm not sure that that was necessarily relevant in this situation, but I thought it was an interesting thought exercise. Um, and as I said, we can't really base it on hours anyway, because we can't go by hours. So anyway, in some ways, this is a thought exercise on amendment one. Councilmember Rosenberger. Sorry I just popped back in the bathrooms were closed I had to go and couldn't find one blah blah blah. Did you say we can't go on ours but the real narrative is we were like we could but we're choosing not to. My understanding from when we were doing this salary stuff over the last couple of years is that state law actually says that we can't be paid based on an hourly wage. Oh, be paid hourly. Yes, but we should, like, create a salary based on hours. Yes. Yes. Yeah. OK. Yeah. And so, like, they said roughly on a part-to-half-time job. Right. Right. OK, yes. Right. Yeah. Clerk Bolden? Oh, I was just going to clarify. My point was not about your hours worked. My point was, looking at the COLA increase that you were proposing by splitting it up, which was if you did that, you'd be getting a larger COLA increase than some of our lowest paid employees who are making significantly less. And that's where I brought in the hourly rate as a point of comparison. Because depending, there are some council members who are working over 30 hours a week and some who are working with much more constraint on their time availability due to other positions and responsibilities. So I didn't want to lock it into the hourly rate. And yeah, I was having fun with math as well. So I did want to clarify that. Thank you. Are there any other questions? I want to respond to that if I could. I just want to appreciate that clarification and also kind of say, I think that across the the city in terms of, I mean, I think that there needs to be a flat increase, essentially, to help compensate, essentially, for our lower wage workers having that lower COLA increase. Like, I think that it's problematic across the city. Are there any other questions? OK, let's go to public comment. Would anyone in chambers like to speak on Amendment 1? OK, is there anyone online? Okay, we're coming back to council member comments. Council member Piedmont Smith. I agree with council member Stossberg that wage compression is a problem in the city, but I don't think that applying it just to the elected positions is equitable or really worthwhile at this point. So I would encourage increase in ongoing conversations with HR and with the mayor about Addressing wage compression across the board next year Other councilmember comments Okay, I will just second councilmember Piedmont Smith's point and one last call for comments before we council member Stasberg I Just want to say it's that very concern is why I had amendment to as well as another option Okay, so yeah, thank you other comments Okay, will the clerk please call the roll and amendment one? Councilmember clarity Stossberg. Yes. Piedmont-Smith. No. Zulek. No. Massari. No. Daly. No. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. Yes. OK. I got to do math. I think that fails four or five. Yes. OK. Okay. Well, would anyone like to introduce another amendment and or we could discuss it just as is? Go ahead. I'll go ahead and move Amendment 2. Second. Okay. Go ahead. So Amendment 2 keeps our wages the same across the board with no COLA increase. kind of on a principle, honestly, that I think that there are problems with straight COLA increases, and it has some equity issues, and I don't want to exacerbate that by making it worse, that elected salaries can only go up, they can never go down, and similarly, we can say that the fiscal committee as a body still had a real struggle with figuring this out and trying to get a good framework and do all of that work this year. And so kind of on the principle that I would rather keep things the way they are than continue to maybe make things worse in terms of equity, especially when thinking about if I don't have it in here, but a couple years ago when we had that ad hoc committee and we were looking at the rate of increases across these positions, and just mathematically at some point when you think about that increase, there's exponential growth at some point. When the salary gets so high that that 2% or 3% all of a sudden You know, it really shoots up in a curve. And the mayor's salary is starting to do that. The clerk's salary hasn't quite done it. Council salary is nowhere close to doing it. But it's like investment. It's like you think that you're not building very much interest until all of a sudden your principal is so big that you're building a lot of interest. And so it's the same kind of concept. So this amendment, too, is more like, well, if we're not actually going to fix it and make it better, then let's just not make it worse. So another thought exercise you could say okay questions on amendment two Okay, we'll go to public comment on amendment two would anyone in chambers like to speak Okay, is there anyone online? Great. Thank you One last call for public comment. Okay, and we'll go back Oh clerk pulled in I know that public comment is not a time to go back in a back and forth. So I don't know if this is the appropriate place for me to do it or if I'm doing it as a member of staff or however you want to put it. But if you haven't done the framework, you're saying to just keep it the way it is, but you're not keeping it the way it is because elected officials have traditionally gotten the same COLA increase that other staff have done. So you are changing it significantly by this. And you're also giving everybody who holds elected office a pay cut. Because while you are keeping everything flat, and I understand that perspective, you're not addressing the fact that costs of living have gone up across the board. And I cannot tell you how upset I was that I couldn't get my overpriced eggs today. But there it is. So looking at what's going to happen over the next year or two with increasing costs, but a decrease in salary, which is what you're talking about, that does have a pain point. And while for some positions or for some people who hold elected office, that may or may not be a big deal, at least for myself and for future clerks, I look at that as problematic because this is a full-time position. Some people will be able to hold the position with additional income and some people will not. But that does create issues for people. And that is a different type of equity that you're looking at. Council, sorry, didn't mean to make it at one person. Thank you. Anyone else for public comment? OK, one person online. You'll have the opportunity to unmute yourself. Please state your name for the record. You'll have three minutes. Hi, this is Mayor Thompson. I also don't know how to engage with this as a member of public or elected official. I'll just say that I think that the work that was started two years ago to look at the principles behind elected salaries was a good start and that work was supposed to continue. But every year we talk about how we're going to structure elected salaries. We talk about pay compression, et cetera, et cetera. And I think at the very least we should be as elected officials compensated in similar ways to the way the rest of the city staff is compensated and on similar principles. And so I would just say that until we get an understanding of how we would like to operate differently, I would recommend that we go with a straight COLA increase. I agree with the clerk. It is essentially a pay cut. We all come from different places and can't presume hardship or otherwise, but salary is compensation for a job. And there are many factors to determining compensation. I know that our consultants two years ago gave recommendations for how to determine that to the subcommittee that was working. And I would expect that those recommendations are still valid. Thank you. Any other member of the public? OK. You'll have three minutes. Please state your name. Hello, this is Sarah Wolford again. And as someone who has been lucky enough to work at an organization who historically and continues to give COLA, I do appreciate the concern with COLA, but I also think that without without a recommendation for how to address how to adjust for the incredible increase in cost of living that people have seen over the last year. I feel like it is I think unfair to punish the employees of our city government who help it run to not give them to basically not provide them with adjustment because that adjustment is problematic. So I would urge that if another amendment can't be put forward that to address the issues with COLA, that COLA just continues to move forward as it stands. Thank you. Is there anyone else online? Great. Anyone in chambers? Last call? OK. We will come back to council comment. Council member Stosberg. I want to start off, I think, by responding to the last public commenter that I put forth that amendment that I thought would fix Colomor and it failed. So there's that. But secondly, more generally, It's not as though the city that elected officials have always had COLA increases. And in fact, in the chart that Clerk Bolden made a couple of years ago when we were first looking at this and the history of salaries for these three positions in 2005 and in 2013, there were no COLA increases. They were flat. salaries that are the same in 2012 as 2013, same in 2004 as 2005. So the idea of not giving the elected a COLA increase is not this crazy new thing. It has happened a couple of times. But that was citywide. Well, still, it's happened a couple of times. And I appreciate that idea. well, we need to do the same thing with our electeds as we're doing with all of the rest of our employees. But I also agree with Mayor Thompson, we've been talking about this for a couple of years and nothing changed about COLA this year for city staff either. So who is going to actually drop the hammer and say, okay, something different has to happen. And so both of these amendments were my way of saying something different really has to happen. And like whether they get approved or not. I mean, something different has to happen. And sometimes I think it's dramatic. I liked Amendment 1 way better than Amendment 2. But I think that sometimes you just have to put it out there and have the conversation and see what happens. OK. Is there other council members? Dave, excuse me. I'm so sorry. Council Member Aralo. Thank you. And thank you, Council Member Stasberg. I think this has been a good discussion and I appreciate it as a thought experiment. I too favored Amendment 1. I voted for it. I understand your meaning of supporting a set of principle. You don't want to worsen the differential. However, I think that We should go with the COLA this time around and concentrate on addressing this wage compression problem in the next year, because I think you're absolutely right. I think that we do need to focus on raising the wage floor. It would be really unjust or it is unjust for people who work full time for the city that they can't afford to live in. So I think that needs to be addressed by us. And I appreciate this, your effort in bringing this to our attention and for consideration. But I won't be supporting this amendment. Thanks. Thank you. Final council comments. Okay. Clerk Bolton, would you please call the roll on Amendment 2? Council Member Stasberg. Yes. Piedmont-Smith? No. Zulek? No. Daly? I'm so sorry. I keep doing this today. I'm so sorry, Council Member. Sorry, I'm not trying to leave you out. Is it me? No. Okay. Thank you. Daily? No. Rallo? No. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? No. And Flaherty? No. Thank you. Thank you. That fails to seven. And now we will come back to ordinance 2026-27. Are there any questions? OK. Would anybody in the public like to speak? OK. OK. If you would like to speak, if you could unmute yourself and state your name for the record, that would be great. Or if you could put your hand down, that would also be great. Great. Thank you very much. If no other takers, that concludes our comment period for the ordinance itself. Back to final council comment. Council member Piedmont-Smith. It's been very difficult to find a rational principled basis from which to calculate appropriate salaries for council members, clerk, and mayor. I still think it's something we need to try to do. But as I think Mayor Thompson said, we haven't gotten very far in two years since the initial proposal came forward. So I don't think this is ideal that we just do a COLA increase. I think that there needs to be some principled way that we arrive at fair salaries instead of just perpetuating the salaries that somehow have historically trickled down to us because there was no rational basis for those really to begin with. And it's particularly tricky because I think that most communities don't really think through this and just kind of keep with the COLA increases or other increases that regular staff of the city get. I think in 2027 we have an opportunity as it being the last year of this council term to make some difficult decisions and know that we may not necessarily benefit from them as some of us will be stepping off council and nobody is guaranteed to stay on. So I think we should do it and I encourage all members and not just those members of the fiscal committee to think about this and give the fiscal committee your ideas. And really engage in this and not wait until we have legislation in front of us that nobody is thrilled about. Thank you. Any Councilmember Stasberg? I want to thank my colleagues and the public for going along with my thought experiments this evening. I know that it is late, but I appreciate it. I do think that it's important. And as Councilmember Piedmont Smith said, It has been a struggle. It has been a struggle. And I think that I'm actually maybe the only council member up here who was on the ad hoc committee working with the consultants, also on fiscal committee last year and then on fiscal committee again this year. So it's like every year and it's kind of the same frustrations I do have. hopes of a better calendar related to it next year in terms of having the conversation sooner, being able to engage more with the Office of the Controller around increases, because one of the other things is if there are potentially larger increases, those have to be worked into budget numbers that get decided much earlier than now. And so then either way, we kind of get locked into different corners. And this isn't a decision that should be made because we get blocked into a corner, this should be a decision that we're making deliberately. Whether it's a decision to not give any increase at all or whether it's a decision to give increases here or there or whatever it is, it should be with deliberation and intent. So I think that it's a good goal and I will carry forth in the next year to continue trying to meet that goal of being able to do this with Consistency and transparency and deliberation because our community deserves that. Thanks councilmember Rosenberger No on this I just wanted to respond to the mayor's comments that I kind of I think she said something about like why haven't you all figured this out yet? One reason we haven't figured it out is because for every year she has said she will support no more than a cola increase It says right here in the packet Both the mayor and the clerk gave feedback that they would support no more than the 2.7% COLA increase, but neither were able to attend the meeting on October 2nd. So I think council hasn't gotten a lot of help in figuring this out. the mayor thinks there is anything to figure out. I think it's unfortunate that we're going into an election year with the same salary and that people have to forfeit making a living wage should do this job. So I think it's a missed opportunity again, and I'm going to vote no on these salaries because I think council needs to be compensated fairly for the hours that they're putting in. Any final comments? Will the clerk please call the roll? Council member Piedmont-Smith. Yes. Zulek. Yes. Vasari. Yes. Daly. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. No. Flaherty. No. Stosberg. No. Okay. Thank you. That passes 6-3. Is there a motion? I move that ordinance 2026-34 be introduced and read by the clerk by title and synopsis only. There's been a motion and a second. Any discussion? Will the clerk please call the roll? Council member Zulek? Yes. Asari? Yes. Daly? All right, that time. Rallo? Yes. Ruff? Yes. Rosenberger? No. Flaherty? Yes. Stosberg? Yes. And Piedmont-Smith? Yes. Thank you. That passes 8-1. Will the clerk please read by title and synopsis? Ordinance 2026-34, to vacate public parcels regarding two 12-foot wide alley segments located in the southwest corner of West 11th Street and North Rogers Street, Trades District Community Development LLC petitioner-owner. The synopsis is as follows. The petitioner-owner Trades District Community Development LLC, operated by Dimension Mill, requests vacation of two alleys that are in the southwest corner of West 11th Street and North Rogers Street. These parcels are part of the trades district west phase and are being prepared for redevelopment. The council sponsor is Council Member Asari. Thank you. The board needs 2026-34 be adopted. Second. Okay. Who is here to present? I think Director Coopersmith is online. Okay, Director Coopersmith, I'm hoping you're still with us. Please take it away if you are here. In some ways, this feels like talking to a ghost. She's here. I just don't know. And she's unmuted, so she just needs to be given access, I guess, or something. Council staff? Is Director Coopersmith able to unmute? Okay. Okay. Director Coopersmith, are you with us? A chat perhaps? Hey. Unfortunately, if you are trying to speak, we can't hear you. If you aren't trying to speak, you should be unmuted. And please try again. I have to admit, you guys, I don't know what to do here. did right and she said that she was speaking and she was questioning whether why we couldn't hear her oh so okay yes unfortunately director Gruber Smith we cannot hear you I can just read what she wrote. She said, my audio isn't working. I didn't have a formal presentation this evening. Ms. Fernanda has been in communication and submitted formal materials. I'm supportive of this hourly vacation in order to facilitate this economic development project in the Trade District. Thank you very much. Does anyone have any questions? I recognize that this is not conventional, Sometimes you do what you can with what you have. Does anyone have any questions? Okay. Would anybody like to speak in terms of public comment? I'm not seeing anyone get up. Anyone on Zoom? Okay. Council comments? Council Member Piedmont-Smith and then Council Member Flaherty. Well, just for the public in case Anybody is still paying attention aside from the few people here in the room. But this is about two alley segments north of the Beeline Heights apartment building at the corner roughly of Rogers and West 11th Street. So just so you know what we're talking about here. And Mr. Fernandez, the director of, what's it called? Amplify. Sorry, I changed its name. Presented this at our last regular session. And the reasoning, I believe, was because they want to maintain maximum flexibility for proposals from developers to develop that land. So anyway, I'm just saying that because there was really no context for people online. Thank you. Any other final comments? Councilmember Rosen, pardon, oh, I'm so sorry. Councilmember Flaherty, I forgot about you. Thank you. When we heard this at first reading, I indicated that would probably be a no vote, and I in fact will be. I mentioned that it's just a pretty tall bar for me to vacate public land. It's a decision that has, you know, lasts in perpetuity, could have impacts a century from now that we don't know about Whatever gets built there next is long gone. We might wish we had the alley. Also, I think there are near-term benefits to alleys that are multiple. They help with utilities, where you put trash and dumpsters, where you put vehicles to load instead of, say, blocking college or Walnut, which can lead to its own problems, or any other street for that matter. They help control building massing and keep things at a human scale. There's just lots of reasons. There are cases to be made, give the Convention Center as an example. I'm not a big fan of the public money we spent on that project. Sure, a building that size for the purpose of a convention needs to be the size of a city block. I get it. Let's vacate an alley for that. But here, there's really no pitch being made. The planning memo says, well, they're not currently being used as alleys, and they're not currently improved. But again, that's really not the question we should be asking about when we're vacating public land forever. And then the ordinance itself, there's a whereas clause that says this is essentially the case being made. Amplify is interested in furthering development of the land and existing alleys would negatively impact the potential sale and development of the real estate. That's just sort of like a true statement for anyone trying to sell land, like giving away public land for private development will make that private developer happier. That's just a given. There's no strong case being made. I just don't really see it. I understand why it would be more attractive for somebody to not have to deal with the public allies. So I understand the rationale, but I just don't think, to me, it's aligned with the public interest more broadly. Thank you. Thank you very much. And I'm very sorry, but I have to open up public comment again because I forgot to read my script that attorney Rossman so graciously provided me. I note for the record that public hearing notice ran in the Herald Times on October 23rd, 2026 and went by certified mail to all three abutting owners at the notice November 4th regular session hearing. No public objections were offered. Public comment will also be taken tonight. And if anyone has public comment, Please approach the podium and state your name, if you would. Very well. Very well stated. Once it's gone, it's gone. And right now there's no obvious reason for why it has to be vacated. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anyone else in public comment? Online? OK. Then that concludes. the public hearing. Council Member Rosenberger and then Ruff. I got a little something I would like to first say hard ditto to what Council Member Flaherty said. Although I would like to say, I don't think vacating an alley is always super profitable for a developer. For instance, you can park in an alley for 15 minutes, I think, in our city code without parking and finding a spot, paying a meter. I'm just saying, not everyone do it, but I think it's allowed a little bit. I mean, the access that alleys give us are pretty cool, and that's why they exist. And I just, again, hard ditto that we shouldn't be giving away public land like this. Thanks. Council Member Ruff and then Rollo. I agree that Council Member Flaherty put it very eloquently and very effectively. So over the years, I served on council, we've vacated alleys, spaces for various times and for various reasons. Sometimes I felt strongly one way or the other. In this case, I'm leaning towards going ahead and approving it, I guess, at this point. When we say once it's gone, once we have an easement or an alleyway or something like this, it's gone forever. I mean, arguably, yeah, but government has the power of eminent domain that most other entities don't. So, and though I'm loathe to use it, and I hate to see it, It is an option if there was a dramatic need in a given situation, even something that spun off of something like this. But I don't really foresee anything like that. So I really appreciate the way it was articulated by Council Member Flaherty. But at this point, I think I'm going to be voting. Go ahead and support it. Thank you. Council Member Rallo. I generally agree with my colleagues who are loath to give up private land, especially alleys that could be utilized for transportation and connectivity and so forth. I've generally been very judicious about doing it. As Council Member Ruff said, I think in this case with no apparent use of these alleys, but with an apparent public good, to provide flexibility because this happens to be a node for one of the most promising areas for job creation. I trend towards approving this. So on balance, I think this serves a public good and I'll be supporting it. Thank you. Any final comments? Council Member Stosberg. I have a question first, I guess. The problem I'm struggling with right now is which person should I ask this to? Because I'm not sure if Director Cooper-Smith is going to know the answer, or I don't know if council members, sorry, might be able to address it. But one of the things that- I'm happy to answer, but also John's on line. Oh, wonderful. OK, so maybe Mr. Fernandez can address this. But one of the things that I remember being mentioned was the idea that essentially, These alleys essentially form a cross, right? And the south end and the west end, essentially dead end and other properties. And so to me, it makes complete sense to vacate the alleys that are essentially alleys to nowhere. We talk about sidewalks to nowhere sometimes. These are alleys to nowhere. But it makes less sense for me to think about vacating north section and the east section, because they would kind of form an L, which is sort of how we have the alley on the other side in the trades district. We vacated part of the alley, so then it would form an L around, I can't remember which building, the forge, no, the mill. I can't remember which building that is anymore, the forge. And so I guess the question is whether there was consideration of that vacation and whether that would potentially compromise with the Amplify Bloomington and the Trades District plan to make it easier to build there, but also maybe kind of a compromise with my colleagues who are reluctant to vacate public land because those two sections of alley, they're just not going anywhere. They're not gonna be good for anything ever. I'm happy to jump in, President Esau, because that's OK. I'm not sharing. Oh, sorry. It's totally fine. I apologize for joining like I'm on the road here. But I hear what you're saying on that question. But I think the issue is that these are at least to nowhere. They've never been really improved. They're platted. They're impediments to kind of thinking about how someone might want to build on these properties. The alley that runs to the south does not even go all the way through the land that we owned. It stops halfway through the property, so it doesn't even continue to the south. where the apartments are, so it would run into that parking lot if it was continued all the way to the south. The east-west, as it goes towards the Bender property, even if the Bender property was developed on the west end of the Bender property, is one of those major utility poles that has the high power lines for electric that you cannot build under. So you cannot run an alley to the west all the way to Fairview. At the end of the day, the whole issue in my view is that alleys are supposed to provide access for, historically, for deliveries and other kinds of egress into a property. They weren't originally designed to be pedestrian ways or even access for vehicles. They were mainly for deliveries. If you look at the site as a whole, As it develops, anything that happens on this property is going to have to go through the planning department. If it's a site plan, it's going to go to the planning commission. So the whole issue of like access and whether it's pedestrian, whether it's deliveries, whether it's vehicles is going to require a substantial amount of review. And so I, you know, we're talking about theoretical things about what could happen or not happen. And at the end of the day, nothing has happened on this property for a very long time. And so I would hope that we would trust the planning staff, trust the planning commission and others to ensure that any development plan that goes forward on this property is going to be sufficiently reviewed and all these issues of access and Yeah, connectivity are gonna be addressed in a meaningful way. Thank you. If I could, I think, Mr. Fernandez, I appreciate your response, but I think that you missed what I was asking in terms of, right now, it's a cross-shape alley, so I'm asking about the consideration of whether you considered only requesting vacating part of that to make it an L-shaped alley, and then it would connect 11th Street to Rogers Street. And so the two pieces that you mentioned that are kind of going to nowhere, those would be vacated. And public property would be maintained in that L-shape. And that's, I think, what the debate or the concern was by a couple of my colleagues and by the public commenters, this idea of vacating public right of way forever and that it's kind of a giveaway to private enterprise. Yeah, no, I did not misinterpret the question. I may not have answered it sufficiently. I just think that those alleys were never developed. The city had them on a map. And so we're not giving up anything. I think that the notion, the way it works is that you've got these impediments to people bringing forward plans because they can't develop anything with any kind of certainty because they don't know what the rules are. And at the end of the day, that's the issue we have. This property has been undeveloped for a long time. It has other impediments. It has the recorded environmental conditions. It has unbelievably old infrastructure. The water lines on it are from 1920. There are a bunch of impediments to anyone being able to bring forward a plan because they don't know what they can or can't do. And so the premise here is that let's trust the process that if we're interested in having adequate planning for pedestrians, for vehicles, for other kinds of access at piece of property, that we have so many layers of review and consideration that are going to bring those kinds of conditions and considerations Uh, into the public process for review and, and, and ultimately for decision-making that we've got place. We've got a lot of processes here that can ensure that we're going to address those kinds of issues. But right now, I mean, there's just so much uncertainty. Nobody wants to, you know, take the risk and make commitments and design plans because they don't know what the rules are. I think that. all these issues, whether it's an L-shaped, it might be a different shape. But Council Member Strouser, I think that at the end of the day, anybody who's gonna make this kind of investment is going to want to ensure that you have the right kind of ingress, egress, that's gonna serve their needs and the public need. And whether it's a T-shape, or some other shape, I don't know. But I think we have plenty of guardrails in place to ensure that we address those kind of public considerations. Thank you. Are there any final comments? Council Member Flaherty. First of all, just noting again that in this case and in many cases, The idea of pedestrian access or something is quite minimal or ancillary and so is connectivity. Like those are not the primary benefits of alleys in my mind, which kind of became a little bit of a focus in the discussion. I also don't, with respect to Mr. Fernandez, don't quite understand the idea that there's uncertainty about the rules. Alleys are alleys. They're public right of way. You can't build them full stop. Like those are the rules. We're considering changing the rules tonight. and creating a new set of rules, and that benefits a private developer who will have more land and more flexibility in the size of things they can build and what they can do with it. I get that, but I just, I'm gonna have to disagree that having alleys, you know, creates uncertainty. I think a good, I don't know, analog to consider is Hopewell, where the council fought very hard last term to get planted alleys into the Hopewell site. the administration didn't want to. They wanted a giant blank slate with no alleys there. And I think, again, for value engineering and other purposes, what most likely is going to happen when you don't set the basic urban form in a pattern that has worked very well for us for a very, very long time is that you're not going to use it. And I really don't think that the plan commission or planning staff process is up to the task of administering that. It's not that I don't trust their processes. It's about what they're suited for and what they're not suited for. So when it comes to the basic urban fabric and rules of the game, I just think and have always thought that, you know, public alleys are an important piece of that fabric. I still think that, again, it's not that they can never be vacated, but I'm just really not seeing the case here. even though I understand that the folks at Amfly Bloomington feel strongly about it. Again, I appreciate Mr. Fernandez being here with us very late and the petition itself. So thank you. Council Member Rosenberger. Things written down, we do know the rules. They're very clear. We don't build on public roads. The parcels are smaller across the street. I mean, I assume this is going to pass. I would urge my colleagues stop using alley connectivity as a big test for whether or not we should vacate an alley. We have a lot of alleys that don't connect. And I think vacating them in the life of a city over centuries is short-sighted. I live in Prospects Hill. Our alleys don't connect. People use them. We've had somebody here come and ask to vacate an alley. I just don't want us to start doing that. I think there are barriers. There can be barriers to building. The public realm and the pedestrian realm doesn't do well with massive buildings. It does better with smaller buildings. So I think that is fine. I think there are a lot of creative ways. I don't know why the building has to be so big, I guess. Also, the RDC is into giving land away at the expense of taxpayers. So if there are a lot of barriers on this property, I feel like it could be given away to developers, I guess. I think I feel very strongly that we should keep City's public land and we should be good stewards of that. Thanks Their final comments councilmember Stasberg I'm at this point pretty Well convinced as I'm looking at this picture that I would much prefer to keep an L shaped alley here and if we I would be open to continuing that and working on an amendment if That is something that would be of interest to a majority of my colleagues. But I think that it would be much more interesting for that whole area to have it kind of mirror that other block, which also has an L-shaped alley around the forge and that hotel. I don't think that it's ideal in that space, just thinking about how that space is, to just have one big building there. If it's not one big building, then why do we need to vacate the alleys? I agree with Councilmember Flaherty, the planning commission and that whole process, they don't deal with road access as much as they deal with building design. And then if something kind of checks all the boxes, then it's, You know, yeah, it goes to your plan commission, but it's almost like a rubber stamp. Like, oh, they met all the requirements, so we just have to say yes at this point. So I'm gonna vote no, I guess, tonight on this unless there is a motion to continue and look at amending to make it an L instead of that cross. Thanks. Councilmember Piedmont-Smith. Yeah, I like the idea of keeping the north and east portions of this alley network that would be a connection, and it's kind of a compromise. And I do think there's value in alleys. I agree with what Councilmembers Flaherty and Rosenberger have said. That's really the only thing that would prevent one Building, well, we may have some rules about building with, no we don't, okay. We have building variation in the facade, but it could still be one building, which I think would not be very pedestrian friendly or very, well, it's just not a good fit for the city. So I would be in favor of postponing and working on amending this, because if we vote this down now, I think they cannot bring back a new proposal for just part of the alleys. I think it's a no for forever, at least for a significant period of time. So that's where I'm standing now. I think I would vote no tonight, but if we could pare down the request, I would probably vote yes. I see Mr. Fernandez has his hand up. I was prepared to make a motion. Mr. Fernandez, do you? Let's go with Mr. Fernandez first then. Yeah, you know, I mean, I understand what people are saying. I appreciate it. But, you know, I mean, there's so many conflicting objectives that I hear from the city as it relates to how we want to Uh, see our city evolve. Um, and you know, when, when you have things like recorded environmental conditions that increases the complexity and the cost, uh, that anybody who wants to bring forward a proposal that might be exactly, um, aligned with the ambitions of the city council. that at the end of the day, sometimes form is not going to be able to meet this kind of historic shape of blocks. You require a little bit of density to be able to offset the infrastructure costs, and the remediation costs. This is a brownfield that has been vacant for a very long time and you know it's a trade-off and I appreciate that but at the end of the day it's like the objective of the trades district is to try and bring if you read the your own plans it's about bringing a more Mitch use urban development to increase economic activity for our city. And, you know, maybe it's a leap of faith and I appreciate if you don't want to make that, but at some point, you know, we have to work together to try and bring forward some ideas that might actually take this undeveloped land that's not producing a single dime of benefit to the public into some kind of activity that delivers value. And we can have a platted alley that has never been improved, never been developed and maintained by the city of Bloomington and have it on a map and have vacant property. Or we can remove these impediments. Let's work together to bring forward something that might actually deliver some real value to the community. And I'm just asking you that I think we've tried to deliver benefit to the community. Let's move forward. I know there's a lot of mistrust and all of that when it comes to development. But I think the people who are working here are trying to do things that are for our collective benefit. And if you don't do this and you say, well, we've got to impose some development model that may or may not be relevant to the market, you may have vacant property for another who knows how long. You know, I don't think that's going to serve our interest. Thank you. Council member, sorry. Thanks so much. And I'm happy to vote on this tonight. I mean, just I mean, guess being the sponsor doesn't necessarily mean that one is in favor of it. In this case, I am. I'll be as brief as possible because I know it's very late. But, you know, I think we have, as I understand it, arguments on both sides here. As I see it, the arguments in support of vacating the alley are one that it's not currently being used. This two notion that as currently plated, they don't connect to any existing network. That three They are obstructing or at least presenting a challenge to redevelopment and I think that that point we have. evidence for in our packet, not just in the arguments of the person requesting it of Amplified Bloomington, our trades district more specifically. But the planning department says they agree that the existing right of ways make adequate construction space along the 11th Street extremely difficult and that they complicate development of the adjoining southern lot. I think I do agree that the arguments, you know, when we think about the long term, you know, 100 years out, certainly, I find that a compelling argument. And, you know, and I don't think that it should, I do think that we should have a high standard of vacating alleys. But I think that one of the things that makes this A particular and different case and I made, I think the same argument when we were looking at the other at the other vacation that we did in the trades district is that you know there's. We're investing and have invested a lot of of our economic development strategy in the success of the trades district and and we're already receiving a huge return on investment. And this is going to enable I think the highest return of all of the investments that have been made in that place and then bring them to the next level that seems to me critical that we get the most, that we complete what it is that we're trying to do in this district and be able in this case to bring ideally more housing, to attract more people to Bloomington, to do the type of things that we wanna see to really activate that sector of our city. And so when I think about that ecosystem, to me, this really advances our existing redevelopment plans there. And so I really would urge us to Aside from the fact that it's late, I do think that this is sort of the right time. And I also understand that there's some time pressures because I know that there are a lot of people looking at this plot, trying to enter into negotiations. So having some clarity about this will help us move forward a lot quicker. So for those and some other reasons that I'm just so tired, but many other reasons I think that we should We should vote for this today. Council member Rollo. Yes, I was going to make a motion, but I think I prefer not to. I think that Council member Stossberg's point is well taken. The L shape has some potential utility, but on balance and decisions are usually made on a basis of sometimes tradeoffs. I think the public good is best served by the vacation. I think that what Mr. Fernandez says is correct. This has been a vacant parcel for a long time. I was part of the original council during the purchase back in 2011. We've been waiting for this to fully materialize and there's been various impediments. I think there has been a lot of good work going on. As I said, it happens to be one of the nodes for most promising area of job creation in the city. I think that on balance, yes, there are good arguments. I was very insistent on maintaining alleyways at Hopewell. I fought very hard for walk paths, for connectivity that the city should maintain. I have more of a record for maintaining alleys than vacating them. But I think in this case, it's justified because I think that flexibility is needed because I can't anticipate what minimum space would be needed for tech purposes. And I would like to provide that flexibility. So I'll be voting in support. I would just like to move to continue this ordinance 202634 to our next regular session on December 2nd. Is this something we can discuss? OK, any discussion? OK, I'll just say I'm not in favor. Anyone else? Okay, will the clerk please call the roll? Councilmember Asari? No. Daly? No. Rallo? No. Ruff? No. Rosenberger? Yes. Clarity. Yes. Stasberg. Yes. Piedmont Smith. Yes. So like no. Okay. Thank you. That fails for five. Would anyone else like to make a comment before we vote. Councilmember Rosenberger. I. Is it known that people are trying to develop this right now or is that unknown. We have passed the time for questions. Somebody just asked a question. I mean, it's not in our notes that there is somebody wanting to develop it. But someone has talked to me about wanting this alley vacated to develop it. And I just wanted to know. I kind of thought the message we're getting is just in case. But I think there is someone who wants this. And I just want to know if we have the whole story. Who are you asking the question to? Mister Fernandez. We've had 2 previous proposals that did not move forward. Because of the. Impediments. We've had a couple of other folks who are interested genuinely. But you know no one's ready to pull the trigger because they don't know what the rules are going to be. Yeah, and I know what, you know, I mean, you can say, well, the rules are that the allies are platted. But at the end of the day, it's going to be very difficult from an economic perspective to be able to develop something that takes into the limitations that this site as it's currently platted present. So yes, there are potentially some interest in moving forward. We'd like to move forward, but the folks who are interested can't make it work with these allies because you're limiting the scale. And yes, that's the issue, right? And I think that's a reasonable argument. I know that Councilmember Flaherty said this a lot, and I think that's a reasonable argument to say that alleys limit scale. They do. And in some circumstances that makes a lot of sense, but when you have other kinds of impediments that are on the property, scale matters because you have to overcome some of the other development costs that are related. So yes, there are people interested, but do they want to come forward? And we don't have a deal. We don't have a specific proposal. We have some ideas. We have talked to several people that are interested. But as the property is currently configured, it just won't work. Thank you. Yes, I wanted to know that. I mean, I understand this is going to pass. I think, too, I just want to say It feels like people are talking like either we vacate these alleys or nothing happens here and it is not binary. We can like economic development and we can like alleys. Big cities have alleys everywhere. They're not a detriment to buildings. So I just do want to make sure that's clear. Thanks. Thank you. But big cities do not have Mr. Fernandez. I'm sorry. We're not where we've passed the point of going back and forth. Council member Stossberg. I'm sorry. I think that you have reached your limit of speaking times. Would anyone else like to speak? Okay. Well, the clerk, please call the roll. Council member daily. Yes. Rallo. Yes. Ruff. Yes. Rosenberger. No. Flaherty. No. Stossberg. No. Piedmont-Smith. No. Zulek. Yes. Asari. Yes. Thank you. That passes 5-4. And now we're moving on to our additional public comment section. Would anyone like to speak during public comment? Okay, thank you. Now matters of council schedule. Does anyone have a council scheduling update? Okay, great. This meeting is adjourned.