WEBVTT

00:00:00.610 --> 00:00:08.219
- City of Bloomington Redevelopment Commission meeting for Monday, November 16th, 2026. Let's begin with

00:00:08.219 --> 00:00:15.680
- a roll call. Commissioners? Randy Cassidy, present. John West, present. C. Scambaleri, here. So, and

00:00:15.680 --> 00:00:23.585
- now to staff. I'm sorry. Christina Finley, hand department. Tammy Caswell, hand department. Jeff McCammon,

00:00:23.585 --> 00:00:28.830
- controller. Jane Coopersmith, economic and sustainable development and

00:00:29.122 --> 00:00:38.743
- As you can likely tell Deborah Meyerson cannot be with us tonight, so I'm pinch hitting for her. Let's

00:00:38.743 --> 00:00:48.364
- move into reports. Is there a director's report this evening? Not a formal report. I'm happy to answer

00:00:48.364 --> 00:00:54.622
- any questions that you have. I do want to give you a brief update.

00:00:54.786 --> 00:01:02.199
- Mr. Cassie had asked me at the last meeting about the Evergreen Village maintenance. And we have since

00:01:02.199 --> 00:01:09.468
- tried to reach out again to set up another neighborhood meeting. They have declined. They have asked

00:01:09.468 --> 00:01:16.521
- for more time. So they would be more interested in a neighborhood meeting starting in the spring.

00:01:16.521 --> 00:01:24.510
- So just FYI, we did attempt. Anything else, Ian? No. OK, I'm going to interrupt. I see Lauren McGrady on Zoom.

00:01:24.706 --> 00:01:33.550
- So let's acknowledge that, sorry. Thank you, Laurie. Okay, and is there a legal report? No report tonight.

00:01:33.550 --> 00:01:42.146
- Okay, thank you, Dana. Treasurer's report? No report. Okay, and business development? Not this evening.

00:01:42.146 --> 00:01:51.486
- A quiet evening. Okay, that takes us to minutes for approval from November 2nd, 2026. These are in your packets.

00:01:51.618 --> 00:02:00.433
- Are there any corrections or changes? And if not, may I have a motion? Move for approval. Second. It's

00:02:00.433 --> 00:02:08.992
- been moved and seconded. We'll do a roll call vote with one of our commissioners on Zoom. But Lori,

00:02:08.992 --> 00:02:17.550
- you're muted. I was not present for the mute for the meeting. So I can vote to approve, but maybe I

00:02:17.550 --> 00:02:19.262
- should abstain. OK.

00:02:21.282 --> 00:02:32.182
- Commissioners? Raina Cassidy. Was that a yes? Yes. John West, yes. And Sue Scambler, yes. That passes.

00:02:32.182 --> 00:02:42.871
- So 301. And that takes us to a presentation on proposed project delivery system for 714 South Rogers

00:02:42.871 --> 00:02:46.046
- Street. Would someone like to

00:02:46.594 --> 00:02:56.590
- provide a runway for this and get us oriented? Last meeting, we heard about different delivery methods

00:02:56.590 --> 00:03:06.198
- with the construction manager's agent CMA approach and discussion about the construction manager's

00:03:06.198 --> 00:03:12.894
- constructor CMC approach. We heard from a company called Garmont and

00:03:13.442 --> 00:03:22.869
- their discussion about it. And we also have locally Whittle Brothers who does similar services. And

00:03:22.869 --> 00:03:32.295
- so they also would like an opportunity to express their views on the CMA and CMC process to the RDC

00:03:32.295 --> 00:03:41.910
- and a little bit about their company. And so we have Chris Seeley here. And if they'd like to come up

00:03:41.910 --> 00:03:43.230
- to the chairs

00:03:43.426 --> 00:03:51.864
- introduce here. If you would introduce yourselves for the record. I'm Chris Scioli, Vice President of

00:03:51.864 --> 00:04:00.634
- Water Village Construction here in Bloomington. I have Josh Nagel, our Vice President of Pre-Construction

00:04:00.634 --> 00:04:08.245
- Services, with me as well. And yeah, as Dana mentioned, watched the presentation last week,

00:04:08.245 --> 00:04:13.374
- or last meeting, presented heavily on the CMA side of things.

00:04:13.538 --> 00:04:20.641
- Just reached out and said, hey, you know, I understand that there are two delivery methods, both provide

00:04:20.641 --> 00:04:27.542
- pros and cons. And, you know, I think that was important to highlight, at least maybe go a little bit

00:04:27.542 --> 00:04:34.375
- more depth on the differences and some real life experiences that we've seen. We perform and provide

00:04:34.375 --> 00:04:40.734
- both services, CMA, CMC, and general contractors. So we're very well familiar with all those.

00:04:41.058 --> 00:04:47.172
- and we've done them all for the City of Bloomington. So Josh, with that, do you want to jump in and

00:04:47.172 --> 00:04:53.469
- kind of give your overview of the services? It is to be very, very brief. So if you have questions or,

00:04:53.469 --> 00:04:59.889
- you know, further clarifications, please feel free to jump in and ask. But as Chris mentioned, Weddell's

00:04:59.889 --> 00:05:05.086
- performed both CMA and CMC services for the City of Bloomington on various projects.

00:05:05.250 --> 00:05:15.751
- And it's just hitting on a few things of where neither one of these delivery methods are an owner's

00:05:15.751 --> 00:05:26.672
- rep position. That's something completely different by definition within the industry. So just focusing

00:05:26.672 --> 00:05:33.918
- on CMA and CMC, just a point of note here that the fees that there's

00:05:34.946 --> 00:05:41.874
- there's nothing that says one method is necessarily cheaper than the other right out of the gate. So

00:05:41.874 --> 00:05:48.733
- the fees are set by proposals that are submitted and there's no guarantee of a savings and going in

00:05:48.733 --> 00:05:55.661
- a CMA model. So I guess that doesn't necessarily make a CMC model more expensive. To me, the two key

00:05:55.661 --> 00:06:02.658
- things that separate the two are basically a staffing capacity and a construction understanding under

00:06:02.658 --> 00:06:04.510
- a CMA model that that puts

00:06:04.802 --> 00:06:12.876
- the onus on the city to have resources to manage contracts, to understand, you know, what's happening

00:06:12.876 --> 00:06:20.950
- on their project and to be able to process the information that's provided to them by the CMA in that

00:06:20.950 --> 00:06:29.420
- case. So under CMC, the construction manager holds all the contracts and takes care of that, the paperwork

00:06:29.420 --> 00:06:33.694
- wrangling and things. And so it's, you know, they're,

00:06:34.722 --> 00:06:41.419
- That's one component of it. The other big component is really the appetite for risk that the city has.

00:06:41.419 --> 00:06:47.922
- And cost certainty, that's a term that we like to use in the pre-construction world. The earlier we

00:06:47.922 --> 00:06:54.749
- can establish cost certainty for you as the city, you know what the project is supposed to cost. There's

00:06:54.749 --> 00:07:00.926
- no settling up at the end of, well, it's the cost of the work plus my fee, plus my management.

00:07:01.090 --> 00:07:09.581
- plus whatever I have there. You know the day you sign the contract with the CMC that you have a guaranteed

00:07:09.581 --> 00:07:17.992
- maximum price in play. Granted, there can be instances where the design changes after the fact or there's

00:07:17.992 --> 00:07:26.086
- an unforeseen condition that nobody knew about within the project. So it's not completely a foolproof

00:07:26.086 --> 00:07:31.006
- method, but you do have, like I said, an earlier period where

00:07:31.330 --> 00:07:37.868
- You know, it's your job as the CM to establish the proper contingencies and allowances to put in the

00:07:37.868 --> 00:07:44.600
- project that will cover it. There's various ways to handle that money at the end if you have money left

00:07:44.600 --> 00:07:51.332
- over. Our stance on our projects has been that 100% of the savings goes back to the owner. Like I said,

00:07:51.332 --> 00:07:56.510
- that can be negotiated in different ways by different proposals, but our stance

00:07:56.642 --> 00:08:04.031
- As a local contractor, we want to see that money go back to the local entity. In a lot of ways, it's

00:08:04.031 --> 00:08:11.420
- our tax money, too. So we want to be good stewards through that process. So to me, those are the two

00:08:11.420 --> 00:08:18.808
- biggest differences. And I think you all have heard other presentations of what is included. So yes,

00:08:18.808 --> 00:08:24.734
- at a very basic level, management of the project is included under both delivery

00:08:25.634 --> 00:08:32.121
- It's a similar staffing model. You typically have a project manager, a superintendent, a project engineer

00:08:32.121 --> 00:08:38.241
- or so for that level, regardless of who manages the project, under which method. So I want to focus

00:08:38.241 --> 00:08:44.728
- on the things that I see as the difference, the differentiators in the decision-making process. So Chris,

00:08:44.728 --> 00:08:50.971
- is there anything you want to add to that? The only thing I would say is, as CMA, and I think this is

00:08:50.971 --> 00:08:54.398
- important because it does make a difference in the job,

00:08:54.818 --> 00:09:01.586
- CMA, you can't self-perform any of the work. You cannot jump in and participate. If something comes

00:09:01.586 --> 00:09:08.422
- up, you must rely on your prime contractors or find somebody else to do it. You cannot do any of the

00:09:08.422 --> 00:09:15.393
- work by state statute. So CMC, delivery method, if you get into a situation where there's either a gap

00:09:15.393 --> 00:09:22.161
- or failure or whatever that might be, you can step in and do the work and ensure that it gets done.

00:09:22.161 --> 00:09:23.582
- So that's important.

00:09:23.746 --> 00:09:29.779
- to me, a pretty significant difference in the two delivery methods. And that's a good point. So obviously,

00:09:29.779 --> 00:09:35.642
- under public bidding, those packages, even as a CMC, if that's us in that role, you still competitively

00:09:35.642 --> 00:09:41.336
- bid those packages. You still advertise and go through the same exact process that you would for any

00:09:41.336 --> 00:09:47.143
- other prime bidder. So there is a competitive element there. You're not just handing money to somebody

00:09:47.143 --> 00:09:50.526
- who acts as a CMC because they're in that role versus a CMA

00:09:55.714 --> 00:10:10.694
- Any questions? So basically the end result is the construction manager will give you a price that says

00:10:10.694 --> 00:10:22.910
- you will not go above this. We have a design, we have a concept, and it's up to us.

00:10:23.074 --> 00:10:30.628
- to include as a construction manager. Like I said, any contingencies, any allowances, any things that

00:10:30.628 --> 00:10:38.478
- we see in our professional opinion of what it takes to deliver the project. And we always have to contend

00:10:38.478 --> 00:10:45.958
- with the budget too on the owner's side. So working within that framework is our end result. Now how

00:10:45.958 --> 00:10:50.846
- we get there, there's different ways to do it. As a design, well,

00:10:51.106 --> 00:10:57.230
- Now let's go back to the very beginning. The earlier the construction manager is brought on, the better,

00:10:57.230 --> 00:11:03.179
- because you have a chance to review and influence the design to make sure you stay within the owner's

00:11:03.179 --> 00:11:09.419
- budget. So you're guiding this process the entire way through. And like I said, the earlier you're brought

00:11:09.419 --> 00:11:15.252
- in, the better. Whether it's conceptual or whether it's even a schematic design, those are the best

00:11:15.252 --> 00:11:17.118
- times to be brought in. And so,

00:11:17.922 --> 00:11:25.277
- Some owners would like for you to go to a GMP as early as possible in the design phase because there's

00:11:25.277 --> 00:11:32.560
- the risk component that they want you as the contractor to take risk on in the project because that's

00:11:32.560 --> 00:11:39.701
- how the concept of getting to the best value and understanding that as a contractor, you understand

00:11:39.701 --> 00:11:46.270
- exactly what's involved. You're not coming with consistent hands out asking for more money.

00:11:47.170 --> 00:11:53.781
- Within that process, you could wait until you get to a fully designed project and there's really no

00:11:53.781 --> 00:12:00.591
- risk involved and now you're bidding the job and just managing it. Or you can go earlier and say, hey,

00:12:00.591 --> 00:12:07.599
- if we were at 90% drawings or maybe 75% drawings or at some level, you can establish a guaranteed maximum

00:12:07.599 --> 00:12:14.078
- price there. That does a couple things for you. That allows you to get the project started sooner

00:12:14.242 --> 00:12:22.643
- because you're not waiting for the entire design to be complete and then go through a bidding process.

00:12:22.643 --> 00:12:30.880
- So if you're looking to shave time off a schedule, that's a way you can do that. And then, there's a

00:12:30.880 --> 00:12:39.036
- lot of variables involved in it, but that's the high level of when do you want to lock in the risk?

00:12:39.036 --> 00:12:40.830
- And so we've done it,

00:12:41.090 --> 00:12:47.610
- almost all the ways I've just named, where we've locked in a job at 60% drawings, at 90% drawings. And

00:12:47.610 --> 00:12:53.940
- if there's not a high level of confidence among the owner and the design team that it needs to wait

00:12:53.940 --> 00:13:00.397
- until it gets to a final design, that's a decision that the group makes together. So there's a lot of

00:13:00.397 --> 00:13:04.702
- variables in play of when you establish a guaranteed maximum price.

00:13:08.706 --> 00:13:16.688
- What projects for the city have you done performed as a CMA? I'm familiar with your CMC projects. So

00:13:16.688 --> 00:13:24.749
- recently we did Fire Station 1, Fire Station 3, and the Forge. Those are all CMA. I've mentioned this

00:13:24.749 --> 00:13:32.809
- before, either delivery method, they have their pros and cons. I'm not here to say one is superior to

00:13:32.809 --> 00:13:37.630
- the other. It's important just to look at what is the result

00:13:37.762 --> 00:13:47.280
- or what is best for the city, and you look at your management, what do you have on staff to manage the

00:13:47.280 --> 00:13:56.613
- project, what's your ability to handle multiple contracts, and then looking at where do you want the

00:13:56.613 --> 00:14:05.854
- risk to lie. It's preference. All right. Questions for Mr. Stone. So if you were to be awarded as a

00:14:06.146 --> 00:14:21.604
- CMC or a CMA, does that eliminate Wendell Brothers to be a bidder as a contractor? Under the CMC scenario,

00:14:21.604 --> 00:14:34.750
- we could bid packages for work that we typically perform. Up to 30% by state statute, yes.

00:14:35.778 --> 00:14:42.703
- I guess I envision the, I'm not saying what happened, I'm just saying that it opens up the opportunity

00:14:42.703 --> 00:14:49.494
- for a conflict of interest. Because at the end of the day, what the RDC is interested in is somebody

00:14:49.494 --> 00:14:56.621
- representing our interest, which is the public's interest. That's why we're going down this path. Because

00:14:56.621 --> 00:15:03.815
- none of us are in the construction business to the extent that we want to manage this. So we want somebody

00:15:03.815 --> 00:15:05.630
- representing our interest.

00:15:07.042 --> 00:15:19.026
- So with that said, where's our money better spent? Which direction are we better? So as a CMC that does

00:15:19.026 --> 00:15:31.011
- not take away our duty to act as your agent. I mean it just enables us as the CM to potentially perform

00:15:31.011 --> 00:15:36.542
- some of the work and have influence on schedule

00:15:36.802 --> 00:15:44.384
- as we would perform work. But it's... I would go on to say if that's a true concern, you can say we

00:15:44.384 --> 00:15:52.497
- don't want you to do the work. That's also an option to say we don't want you to stop performing anything.

00:15:52.497 --> 00:16:00.155
- You can still serve as CMC and not bid on the packages. You lose some coverage, but that's certainly

00:16:00.155 --> 00:16:02.430
- an option that the owner has.

00:16:03.842 --> 00:16:10.499
- So one thing I didn't, I failed to mention this in the CMA to CMC comparison. So when a job comes out

00:16:10.499 --> 00:16:17.157
- as a CMA, that requires all prime bidders to bond their work, to complete all the city paperwork, all

00:16:17.157 --> 00:16:23.749
- the things that it takes to work for the city, right? That restricts your bidding pool significantly

00:16:23.749 --> 00:16:30.733
- right out of the gate because there are plenty of local qualified subcontractors who, they'll go elsewhere

00:16:30.733 --> 00:16:33.278
- because it's easier to work elsewhere.

00:16:33.634 --> 00:16:40.275
- So under the CMC method, that does help attract local contractors. So I think it helps get, we like

00:16:40.275 --> 00:16:47.581
- to think it helps get better pricing on the back end through the subcontractor community and more competitive

00:16:47.581 --> 00:16:54.222
- bids. But to go back, I know you haven't gotten down to that level yet. You're still focused on how

00:16:54.222 --> 00:17:00.863
- do you know that we are acting in your best interest or whoever the collective we is, right, is the

00:17:00.863 --> 00:17:02.590
- subcontracting community.

00:17:02.690 --> 00:17:11.653
- By the duties required in the state statute, there's still a requirement to act upon your behalf and

00:17:11.653 --> 00:17:20.526
- to give you reporting and to give you visibility within the project and to any of the duties that a

00:17:20.526 --> 00:17:30.110
- CMA would provide in that case. So there's nothing lost there on what's required to, and whatever you want,

00:17:30.754 --> 00:17:36.651
- delivered to you, that gets written in the contract. So if you want a specific report, if you want,

00:17:36.651 --> 00:17:42.666
- like I said, specific visibility into the project, write that into the contract and whoever works for

00:17:42.666 --> 00:17:48.622
- you will owe you that information. I think one thing that goes along with that, I heard mentioned in

00:17:48.622 --> 00:17:54.578
- the previous presentation, there's talk about contingency. I think there's a little skepticism about

00:17:54.578 --> 00:18:00.062
- how contingency is handled and how do you know that it's being represented in the right way.

00:18:00.546 --> 00:18:06.981
- And as Josh mentioned, you can write it however you want, but we have contracts where, well, almost

00:18:06.981 --> 00:18:13.609
- all of them, it's a mutual contingency where if the contingency needs to be used, it requires approval

00:18:13.609 --> 00:18:20.109
- from the owner. You have to go to them and say, this is why we're using it. They sign off and, okay,

00:18:20.109 --> 00:18:26.737
- we understand why it's being used. It's not just a slush fund. It's there for purposes of the project.

00:18:26.737 --> 00:18:29.118
- They monitor it, it's accounted for.

00:18:29.474 --> 00:18:36.003
- And at the end of the job, whatever's remaining is a deduct change or a back to the owner. Now their

00:18:36.003 --> 00:18:42.597
- previous or some contracts, they try to incentivize it by saying, well, we'll do a shared savings and

00:18:42.597 --> 00:18:49.191
- then hope that it doesn't complete the contingency right away. You can have contractor's contingency.

00:18:49.191 --> 00:18:55.656
- There are multiple ways to do it. But I think what we see pretty commonly is the mutual contingency

00:18:55.656 --> 00:18:57.854
- where it's in one purse, requires

00:18:58.082 --> 00:19:04.615
- conversation as to why it has to meet criteria written out in the contract and what it's used for. That

00:19:04.615 --> 00:19:11.337
- way it's just not there for oversight and misuse. It gets controlled. And with that, the base AIA contract

00:19:11.337 --> 00:19:17.745
- document does not get to that level. That needs to be something that whoever you choose to work with,

00:19:17.745 --> 00:19:23.838
- that you work through that and negotiate those terms. Otherwise, it's very vague in those terms.

00:19:26.914 --> 00:19:32.989
- Randy, do you have a question? No, go ahead. When we get down to the basics and when we're starting

00:19:32.989 --> 00:19:39.308
- to look at a GMP in regards to it, because we all know there's a certain pot of money we can work with,

00:19:39.308 --> 00:19:45.505
- what particular percentage, once we have an architect and our engineering team on board, does the CMC

00:19:45.505 --> 00:19:51.823
- get involved in order to make sure the budget is going to stay there? Is that a 20%, 50%, 60%? The next

00:19:51.823 --> 00:19:53.342
- week would be fantastic.

00:19:53.538 --> 00:20:00.698
- Seriously and the sooner the better. Literally that way the engineer and the architects are working

00:20:00.698 --> 00:20:08.288
- with the potential constructor in order to basically make the design also work into the constructability.

00:20:08.288 --> 00:20:15.448
- Okay and then when we get down to a basis of if we have CMA we're going to have multiple primes. We

00:20:15.448 --> 00:20:21.534
- have multiple primes that would occur. With that how does that differentiate between

00:20:21.698 --> 00:20:29.736
- CMA versus CMC as far as where our warranty would run into. So, yeah, at CMA, each prime contractor

00:20:29.736 --> 00:20:37.935
- is responsible for their own warranty. So if you have six prime contractors, you're going to have six

00:20:37.935 --> 00:20:45.973
- different, you know, warranties with them. CMC, it rolls back to your construction manager at risk,

00:20:45.973 --> 00:20:51.358
- who's ultimately responsible. And then they'll have contracts with

00:20:51.714 --> 00:20:58.544
- the subs, but at the end of the day, they're responsible for ensuring it and passing it down, make sure

00:20:58.544 --> 00:21:05.373
- there's representation. Okay, so that way from a longevity standpoint, anything, we would end up coming

00:21:05.373 --> 00:21:12.137
- back to one person as opposed to going to multiples and trying to get them if there's any deficiencies

00:21:12.137 --> 00:21:15.486
- that we see. From a standpoint of working with the

00:21:15.650 --> 00:21:24.553
- engineer, architects, engineers, and the owners that would be utilizing the facilities that we're talking

00:21:24.553 --> 00:21:33.623
- about. How does that play in between the two? Because if we select architects and engineers, or we selected

00:21:33.623 --> 00:21:42.526
- CMA or CMC, at what point are the construction manager as agent or the construction manager as contractor

00:21:43.170 --> 00:21:49.709
- Involving that particular end user is that immediately is that. I think part of that depends on how

00:21:49.709 --> 00:21:56.380
- you write your proposal services you're I mean you're asking when the when the when the user comes in

00:21:56.380 --> 00:22:03.050
- and user actually comes in as we may be the owner, but we would not be the end user of this facility.

00:22:03.050 --> 00:22:09.720
- My being clear. So you're talking about when like operations when you would you bring them in for the

00:22:09.720 --> 00:22:11.486
- conversation. I would say.

00:22:11.938 --> 00:22:18.362
- I would think that starts at the very beginning of the programming. So you start your basis of design

00:22:18.362 --> 00:22:24.913
- off of what their needs are in the assessment. A lot of times that early in that process, the architect

00:22:24.913 --> 00:22:31.337
- and engineering drives that, the programming and the meetings and getting what the owner really wants

00:22:31.337 --> 00:22:37.761
- incorporated in the design. And then so obviously their feedback is you're reviewing constructability

00:22:37.761 --> 00:22:41.918
- of a concept that the owner might want. I mean, there's a lot of,

00:22:42.114 --> 00:22:49.536
- And that step is irrespective of the delivery method. It should be, at least. It doesn't matter. It's

00:22:49.536 --> 00:22:56.885
- just a matter of when you get the team on, then it's going to be utilized on a final basis. And then

00:22:56.885 --> 00:23:04.744
- to John's point, where we really don't want to have to be in. We're not to the point of doing it ourselves.

00:23:04.744 --> 00:23:07.582
- So you're kind of using owner and user

00:23:07.714 --> 00:23:15.797
- interchangeably. Yeah, what I say because we're not the. Yeah, we may be the funding source, but the

00:23:15.797 --> 00:23:23.881
- end user will be the police department. We're paying the bills. Yeah, we don't. We may tour it. I'll

00:23:23.881 --> 00:23:32.605
- be about the only time we. Right, if there's an impasse on I want this, but it's not your budget. Somebody's

00:23:32.605 --> 00:23:35.646
- gonna have to be that decision maker.

00:23:36.130 --> 00:23:42.727
- Yeah, the user will have to come to us. Right, exactly. The job as the contract manager goes through

00:23:42.727 --> 00:23:49.455
- this process is to challenge the design team to meet the budget and hold them. This is the value we're

00:23:49.455 --> 00:23:56.117
- working towards. We'll challenge them. There'll be some tough conversations we have regularly because

00:23:56.117 --> 00:23:58.142
- they're proud of their design.

00:23:58.466 --> 00:24:05.433
- And so we will challenge them to ensure that we're making sure that it's physically responsible because

00:24:05.433 --> 00:24:12.534
- at the end of the day, if it doesn't meet the budget, the project doesn't happen. I would use an example,

00:24:12.534 --> 00:24:19.232
- the three fire department projects. The two were CMA and one was CMC. I would think that process as

00:24:19.232 --> 00:24:22.046
- we went through all the pre-construction,

00:24:22.434 --> 00:24:29.860
- with the fire department and with other, I'm trying to remember who from the city, it was in JD that

00:24:29.860 --> 00:24:37.213
- was part of it. So that process did not go any differently for us, even though it was two different

00:24:37.213 --> 00:24:44.565
- delivery methods. We approached it the same way. That raises a really good question. Why wasn't the

00:24:44.565 --> 00:24:51.550
- same method used throughout? What caused the CMA to pop out when you had success with the CMC?

00:24:52.162 --> 00:24:58.582
- We did the CMA projects first. We switched to CMC for FireOps. So the FireOps Center, the history of

00:24:58.582 --> 00:25:05.193
- it was, it kept getting pushed. It kept getting delayed and delayed and they needed to get out of their

00:25:05.193 --> 00:25:11.740
- building where they were across town because the lease was going to end. So they were trying to figure

00:25:11.740 --> 00:25:18.096
- out how can we expedite this job to move it along. So if you do CMC, there's opportunity to get out

00:25:18.096 --> 00:25:20.702
- there and get started on your site work.

00:25:21.346 --> 00:25:28.527
- do an early, you know, do iterations of GMP and get this thing rolling faster. It allowed us to get

00:25:28.527 --> 00:25:35.852
- the PEMB, the pre-engineered building, ordered sooner. Whereas CMA, you really wait for the design to

00:25:35.852 --> 00:25:43.105
- go, be fully complete, and you go on your bid packages for each respective package. So we waited, or

00:25:43.105 --> 00:25:50.430
- you'd have to wait, in most scenarios. CMC allows you to start a little bit sooner in some scenarios.

00:25:52.290 --> 00:25:59.795
- Were you, when you were at CMC, were you also one of the contractors? We performed one package. We did

00:25:59.795 --> 00:26:07.227
- not get the concrete. We just did general trades. Yeah, so we didn't get all the packages that we bid

00:26:07.227 --> 00:26:14.732
- competitively. So even when you self-performed, you still have to bid? We still have to bid. You still

00:26:14.732 --> 00:26:19.614
- go through the public bid process and it's still a public opening.

00:26:19.746 --> 00:26:27.049
- But you're there to help us select the right contractor, so how, I mean that's just really, I know you're

00:26:27.049 --> 00:26:34.076
- gonna, now on the CMC you select them. Yeah, I mean the contractor with you. We hold the contractors.

00:26:34.076 --> 00:26:39.518
- Hold the contractors. So in a bidding process, we're still involved, I gather.

00:26:39.842 --> 00:26:47.087
- There is a pre-qualification process. There are certain things that all the city requirements that would

00:26:47.087 --> 00:26:54.538
- be on any other project carry through into the CMC bidding documents. So, yeah, picking the most qualified,

00:26:54.538 --> 00:27:01.852
- most responsive contractor is still part of the process. We do not have free reign to just choose whoever

00:27:01.852 --> 00:27:08.062
- we want. So the convention center of CMC, every big package that we put out, up-way open,

00:27:08.226 --> 00:27:14.739
- went back and talked to the CIV. We looked at the pre-calls that they filled out, looked at their financials,

00:27:14.739 --> 00:27:20.838
- looked at their safety records, scoped, did a full review with them, and then they had the opportunity

00:27:20.838 --> 00:27:26.819
- to offer feedback on if they had any reservation about contractor that appeared to be the low bidder

00:27:26.819 --> 00:27:32.858
- or the appropriate contractor. They didn't go with the low on every single one of them. One reason or

00:27:32.858 --> 00:27:35.582
- another, they made some decisions, but it was

00:27:36.130 --> 00:27:44.270
- fully disclosed and what was there, what we were working with. Just to get a clear understanding of

00:27:44.270 --> 00:27:52.409
- that, pre-qualifications occur. So, you know, you've got enough. It's under one contractor, but all

00:27:52.409 --> 00:28:00.793
- bids for all prime trades are publicly opened, and they would be presented to? Correct. We'd come with

00:28:00.793 --> 00:28:05.758
- a recommendation. Recommendation. Fully transparent process.

00:28:06.210 --> 00:28:12.345
- And then one other thing that when we're allowed to bid self-performed packages, we will turn our bids

00:28:12.345 --> 00:28:18.540
- in early to whoever the person is, the designee, just to ensure that nobody's peeking or doing anything

00:28:18.540 --> 00:28:24.615
- unethical. If it's 24 hours in advance, they have to be turned in, whatever. Give them to whoever the

00:28:24.615 --> 00:28:30.750
- representative is that will hold them until the opening, and then they're all opened at the same time.

00:28:37.090 --> 00:28:47.918
- from a delivery timeframe based upon the CMA versus CMC as far as duration of time from start to finish.

00:28:47.918 --> 00:28:58.539
- Well, I'm just curious in regards to where you're going out, where we have to go out. And you. I mean,

00:28:58.539 --> 00:29:05.758
- Josh, correct me if I'm wrong, but really, I think where you're going

00:29:05.890 --> 00:29:12.857
- The only way you would really see a significant difference in duration is if you decide to put out an

00:29:12.857 --> 00:29:19.755
- early package. Maybe put out an early demo package or something to get ahead. Yeah, in this case, or

00:29:19.755 --> 00:29:26.585
- if there's site for this particular project, yeah, if there is a site package or something you want

00:29:26.585 --> 00:29:33.278
- to get out ahead to start underground detention or the work that can be involved in this project.

00:29:34.370 --> 00:29:42.320
- Yeah, it would have to be strategic, not just for the sake of. But that strategy you're talking about

00:29:42.320 --> 00:29:50.270
- is identified quickly. Oh, yeah, yeah. We have the owner's representative or the user, the architect,

00:29:50.270 --> 00:29:58.065
- engineer, and the construction. Right, yeah. But that's in a CMC scenario already, more likely. Not

00:29:58.065 --> 00:30:04.222
- necessarily. That process could be followed. As long as your documents are the

00:30:04.418 --> 00:30:11.740
- level they need to be. Yeah. Sorry, can I make one more comment? So a lot of CMA projects prefer to

00:30:11.740 --> 00:30:19.209
- wait later in the process to where the documents are 100% complete, because if you're starting before

00:30:19.209 --> 00:30:25.726
- the documents are complete, you're taking on risk, which then puts you in a CMA at risk.

00:30:26.242 --> 00:30:33.009
- Or you have to put more contingency or more allowances in, which then can have a negative impact on

00:30:33.009 --> 00:30:39.844
- your overall budget. So that's why that process tends to go that way under a CMA umbrella. Just take

00:30:39.844 --> 00:30:46.408
- water? Yeah. We're at about 20 minutes now on this presentation. Are there more questions? Yeah,

00:30:46.408 --> 00:30:50.942
- one more. Go ahead. Are you recommending one process over another?

00:30:55.586 --> 00:31:03.594
- I mean yeah so I like I said starting out they're both fine delivery methods I think knowing what I

00:31:03.594 --> 00:31:11.762
- know about where the city is with their capacity to manage the project and resources available I lean

00:31:11.762 --> 00:31:19.769
- towards CMC because it gives you one one contractor deal with opposed to multiple and also you know

00:31:19.769 --> 00:31:24.414
- I think it's about where you do with risk and I mentioned

00:31:25.762 --> 00:31:32.781
- If you have a contractor that happens to go out of business or fold shortly after a job is done, that's

00:31:32.781 --> 00:31:39.598
- the owners to figure out. I mean, the CMA can help lead the way and try to guide the process. But at

00:31:39.598 --> 00:31:46.482
- the end of the day, you have to work through the process of getting somebody else to come back in and

00:31:46.482 --> 00:31:52.286
- fix that work. Where in the CMA arrest scenario, you go to your construction manager,

00:31:52.578 --> 00:31:58.248
- your CMC and make them responsible for that other contractor. But they're both fine delivery methods.

00:31:58.248 --> 00:32:03.918
- I'm not saying one is superior to the other. I think it just is unique to what you need and what best

00:32:03.918 --> 00:32:09.532
- fits where you're at. Like I said, I watched the presentation from last meeting, and that was a nice

00:32:09.532 --> 00:32:15.146
- summary of what they are. So probably reiterated a lot of what you've already heard. So I'm not here

00:32:15.146 --> 00:32:21.261
- to contest any of that. I just highlight and answer any questions that we can. I do think for this particular

00:32:21.261 --> 00:32:22.206
- project, though,

00:32:22.498 --> 00:32:31.834
- there is when you go into a renovation or from what we've heard this project is, there's a lot of risk

00:32:31.834 --> 00:32:40.988
- of unknowns and finger pointing and between multiple primes or whatever. So having a CM, a risk with

00:32:40.988 --> 00:32:51.230
- one focal point to work through and let that CM manage the process and will make things go smooth, smoother from

00:32:51.362 --> 00:32:59.825
- what you see as the owner and what you'd be involved in. So that's specific to this project, the one

00:32:59.825 --> 00:33:08.456
- comment I would make. Support between CMA and CMC on the front end before the Indians going, are equal

00:33:08.456 --> 00:33:17.086
- or? Should be. I would say yes. Any additional questions? Okay. Thank you gentlemen. Much appreciated.

00:33:17.086 --> 00:33:18.846
- Dana, do you want to

00:33:20.226 --> 00:33:34.008
- want to do the off ramp for them. So you've had both presentations. There was no action we're asking

00:33:34.008 --> 00:33:47.654
- for this evening. So you've got time to consider this. And then we may be bringing you something at

00:33:47.654 --> 00:33:50.110
- the next meeting.

00:33:50.306 --> 00:34:01.182
- For you to to make a decision on how to move forward We would like to which other direct either direction

00:34:01.182 --> 00:34:11.443
- you go. We would like to get going because the a Proposal have come in and so we do want to get the

00:34:11.443 --> 00:34:20.062
- CM whichever type on sooner than later, so But so I'll send some information out on

00:34:20.322 --> 00:34:29.196
- how that contracting with the CMA goes and CMC and and you know what the next steps are and find out

00:34:29.196 --> 00:34:37.982
- you know you guys can respond to me individually if you know what you your thoughts might be if you

00:34:37.982 --> 00:34:46.768
- want more information of one type or another and I can get that for you. Can you recollect where we

00:34:46.768 --> 00:34:48.350
- are on the actual

00:34:48.930 --> 00:35:01.128
- written responses or proposals from anybody. What do we have in the way of a written proposal from any

00:35:01.128 --> 00:35:13.680
- GM or CM? I believe we sent them to you for the CMAs. And we had how many of those? You had two proposals

00:35:13.680 --> 00:35:17.470
- for CMAs plus the contract that

00:35:17.602 --> 00:35:27.036
- Garmong had sent that, well, I detailed that. I didn't give you the actual contract because that would

00:35:27.036 --> 00:35:36.379
- be under negotiation, but the details of it shortlisted. As far as the CMC, that's a process that has

00:35:36.379 --> 00:35:45.630
- to go out for RFPs by statute. CMAs is professional services and does not require that same process.

00:35:46.050 --> 00:36:06.929
- that the CMC does. So for the purposes of today's discussion, we don't have anything in writing from

00:36:06.929 --> 00:36:15.198
- Wellbrookers? No. That was a while ago.

00:36:16.098 --> 00:36:24.440
- utilize an owner's rep at some point. So that's still an option. Owner's rep, CMA, CMC. So the next

00:36:24.440 --> 00:36:32.281
- time we'll hear from you will be December 7th at our meeting then. That's correct. OK. Great.

00:36:32.281 --> 00:36:41.374
- Thank you. That takes us into new business. We have five resolutions before us this evening to work through.

00:36:41.474 --> 00:36:48.400
- We'll begin with resolution 2691, approval of the fourth amendment to the agreement with Mother Nature

00:36:48.400 --> 00:36:55.259
- Landscaping Inc. for sidewalk and trash container repairs at the trades district. Who'd like to speak

00:36:55.259 --> 00:37:01.983
- to this? I'm more than happy to at least kick you off so that you can understand what the obstacles

00:37:01.983 --> 00:37:04.606
- are. I have some images on the screen.

00:37:04.706 --> 00:37:12.862
- that show what we're working against. There are several areas within the trades district where the brick

00:37:12.862 --> 00:37:20.863
- has created a pretty big dip, which causes some accessibility issues. Water appears to be getting down

00:37:20.863 --> 00:37:28.864
- below the brick and kind of washing away some of the dirt. We had talked previously. We had had a site

00:37:28.864 --> 00:37:33.214
- visit to try and figure out exactly what the cause was.

00:37:33.410 --> 00:37:41.226
- I think at that time, John actually was present with us. We felt like there was a lack of compacting

00:37:41.226 --> 00:37:48.964
- of the sand underneath some of the brick. So basically Mother Nature has gone through, taken a look

00:37:48.964 --> 00:37:56.857
- at some of the repairs that are necessary and given us an estimate to try and get that taken care of.

00:37:56.857 --> 00:38:00.958
- Again, there are some accessibility concerns related

00:38:01.154 --> 00:38:11.954
- to the work that's needed at the trades district. The other thing that I would want to highlight are

00:38:11.954 --> 00:38:21.150
- the trash cans. When the trash cans were installed, they were bolted to loose bricks.

00:38:21.826 --> 00:38:31.727
- And there are doors on the front of these trash cans. So when they go to be emptied, they create a situation

00:38:31.727 --> 00:38:40.902
- where they're top heavy, and they try to fall over. So part of this quote is related to bolting them

00:38:40.902 --> 00:38:51.166
- to the curb so that they no longer fall over. Dana, what did I miss? No, that covers it well. So again, we were.

00:38:51.810 --> 00:39:02.460
- those out there as well. There are, I think, three main areas that the brick is doing this in kind of

00:39:02.460 --> 00:39:13.319
- a linear fashion, as you can see from the drawings or the pictures. So this would be to cover all those

00:39:13.319 --> 00:39:21.150
- areas and to secure all the trash containers, recycling receptacles in the

00:39:21.378 --> 00:39:32.813
- district to get for accessibility issues as well as of course aesthetics and prevent falls. Did the

00:39:32.813 --> 00:39:44.362
- original report come with any kind of guarantees against this kind of shifting and sinking or are we

00:39:44.362 --> 00:39:47.678
- out of warranty so to speak?

00:39:49.986 --> 00:39:57.213
- Yeah, what I had understood was we're past that time period. We'll be out of warranty. I can address

00:39:57.213 --> 00:40:04.440
- a little bit of that. Decorative pavers put them in. The Cassidy Electric, my previous employer, was

00:40:04.440 --> 00:40:12.311
- on this project. And decorative paving also just did the forge project around. So those were the individuals.

00:40:12.311 --> 00:40:17.534
- Part of it, I would assume, would still be under warranty at some point.

00:40:18.818 --> 00:40:25.048
- Things that we're seeing here typically have been made by vehicles driving on, because if you look at

00:40:25.048 --> 00:40:31.339
- the compaction of what that is, this is actually part of the stormwater drain for the trades district.

00:40:31.339 --> 00:40:37.629
- So you see the gravel in between that? It's not compacted to a point, and there's a weight-based limit

00:40:37.629 --> 00:40:43.798
- that needs to be put on these in order to not have the equipment that has been drove in their trucks

00:40:43.798 --> 00:40:47.646
- on them, because it is part of the stormwater. I would like to

00:40:47.874 --> 00:40:55.061
- asked to get with utilities to find out where our agreement was because all of this drains into two

00:40:55.061 --> 00:41:02.392
- storm systems that have maintenance that needs to be cleaned out. So while I have no issues with Sean

00:41:02.392 --> 00:41:09.579
- and Mother Nature's ability to do the work, we need to make sure what that substrate needs to be in

00:41:09.579 --> 00:41:16.478
- order for it to be put back because in my estimation, in my experience, this has been caused by

00:41:16.738 --> 00:41:25.245
- equipment being driven on it. And if you see the gravel in there, you can see this is set up as a drainage

00:41:25.245 --> 00:41:33.434
- system. Yeah, well, I want to comment. I'm glad Randy said that, so I'd like to comment on it. I can't

00:41:33.434 --> 00:41:41.703
- deny that, although every one of these surfaces, there's only a it all floats to the middle. So there's

00:41:41.703 --> 00:41:45.758
- there's one single area that's depressed, not like

00:41:46.114 --> 00:41:55.998
- wheels from a vehicle that would have to. But it's pretty clear that the subsurface was not done properly.

00:41:55.998 --> 00:42:05.513
- And that's throughout the whole district. So I think it was done quickly in a little bit of haste, not

00:42:05.513 --> 00:42:14.750
- compacted. And then because they were probably up against the timeline, they threw the pavers down.

00:42:15.138 --> 00:42:23.061
- because it looked nice. And the trash containers, this is not my area of expertise, but I know I'm not

00:42:23.061 --> 00:42:30.984
- going to bolt trash containers to a moving paver, to a floating paver. I can't even answer that. Well,

00:42:30.984 --> 00:42:38.907
- you don't. I mean, it's pretty clear the paver is going to shift, and you're trying to mount something

00:42:38.907 --> 00:42:44.830
- to it permanently. So it should have been mounted to the curb to begin with.

00:42:45.890 --> 00:42:54.182
- I don't think the contractor did us any favors. But we're stuck with this problem. It has to be repaired.

00:42:54.182 --> 00:43:02.084
- My main concern in regards to anything is to make sure that we get the manufacturing what is for the

00:43:02.084 --> 00:43:10.141
- subsurface of the drainage to make sure that that is contiguous. Because while this is an issue that's

00:43:10.141 --> 00:43:15.070
- approximately, what, eight years old? If I remember correctly.

00:43:15.586 --> 00:43:22.871
- We've got the entire same type situation at Hopewell. So that's part of my concern from a long-term

00:43:22.871 --> 00:43:30.447
- maintenance of what we have and how we budget accordingly for that. Because if we're using these pavers

00:43:30.447 --> 00:43:37.804
- and the substrate, there is a maintenance protocol that needs to be maintained on a consistent basis

00:43:37.804 --> 00:43:43.486
- because as we see the grass and such growing up, that shouldn't be occurring.

00:43:44.002 --> 00:43:52.857
- if we want to maintain these long term, that the depression has to be repaired. I think Randy brings

00:43:52.857 --> 00:44:01.624
- up a really good point about driving on it. When I was there, I didn't even think about that. So if

00:44:01.624 --> 00:44:10.478
- these are used as a kind of a vehicle right away, I mean, they're supposed to be sidewalks. We asked

00:44:10.478 --> 00:44:12.670
- that question, actually,

00:44:13.474 --> 00:44:21.479
- visit and at that time we were told that nobody had seen that occur. I have since that time heard from

00:44:21.479 --> 00:44:29.561
- other people that have seen driving occur on some of these papers close to the mill. So I've heard both

00:44:29.561 --> 00:44:37.410
- accounts. No there hasn't been any driving on it and yes there has but I have not. I wasn't privy to

00:44:37.410 --> 00:44:42.462
- that. Well I drive around a lot. I got a video from last week of

00:44:42.562 --> 00:44:53.521
- of a uniloader on Hopewell. So as a follow-up, John Fernandez sent some of us who were on that tour

00:44:53.521 --> 00:45:04.700
- a little schematic of the Tech Park and kind of who owns what. I've not verified this, but are all of

00:45:04.700 --> 00:45:11.166
- the sections that need to be repaired, are they all in the

00:45:11.746 --> 00:45:18.446
- public right-of-way, which is our problem. Unfortunately, that public right-of-way has not been adopted

00:45:18.446 --> 00:45:25.017
- by Public Works, and a lot of that has to do with the condition of the pavers. So the RDC is still...

00:45:25.017 --> 00:45:31.588
- So once we get this through... That is the hope, is to try and make sure that Public Works can adopt.

00:45:31.588 --> 00:45:38.030
- Or the trade, because my main concern is we repair it now, but we go back and repair again, that we

00:45:38.030 --> 00:45:40.414
- have a long-term maintenance program

00:45:40.898 --> 00:45:48.780
- at least cost it in so we know what that overall long-term cost is so we can project for it. I think

00:45:48.780 --> 00:45:56.739
- that if we have to do this, we do it with the understanding that it gets transferred to public works.

00:45:56.739 --> 00:46:03.294
- We don't have to deal with it. Do we need more time to do some additional research?

00:46:04.194 --> 00:46:11.365
- Well, I just want to know that we're bringing that up to a standard where public works will accept it.

00:46:11.365 --> 00:46:18.536
- That's the due diligence I want. Because I don't, to Randy's point, I don't want to do this again next

00:46:18.536 --> 00:46:25.776
- year. I don't know how to guarantee that without having public works. The question, look, as the trades

00:46:25.776 --> 00:46:33.086
- district moves forward, and of course we've got, you know, we've got contracts with the trades district.

00:46:33.666 --> 00:46:41.324
- We have this public works transfer and then we have a long-term maintenance aspect portion of it because

00:46:41.324 --> 00:46:48.909
- of what all is going to occur. Who do we need in the room to get that worked out? We've got the utility

00:46:48.909 --> 00:46:56.348
- worked out for the drainage for them to take care of it based upon the costing to each lot owner. Who

00:46:56.348 --> 00:47:02.110
- do we need to get in the room to get that resolved so that we can turn it over

00:47:02.210 --> 00:47:10.543
- but they have adequate understanding from what the manufacturer's specifications are to what the maintenance

00:47:10.543 --> 00:47:18.189
- needs to be, so we don't end up in long-term degradation of a public facility. There's never enough

00:47:18.189 --> 00:47:26.064
- money to maintain all of them if you don't know what the maintenance cost is. Just to clarify, are you

00:47:26.064 --> 00:47:27.134
- talking about

00:47:27.522 --> 00:47:35.090
- Just the paper maintenance, are you talking about it as part of the stormwater? Well, part of the stormwater,

00:47:35.090 --> 00:47:42.245
- these particular drainage things go into storm. There's two storm swirls on that property. I don't know

00:47:42.245 --> 00:47:49.331
- what the maintenance schedule has been with them. And utilities, I'm assuming, has it. Yes, and that's

00:47:49.331 --> 00:47:56.830
- just what I wanted to make sure is clear, is that utilities early on in the planning of the trades district,

00:47:57.378 --> 00:48:03.888
- There was a plan to have there be kind of a condo-ized strategy for maintenance of the storm sewer.

00:48:03.888 --> 00:48:10.398
- CBU is not comfortable with that. They want to make sure that the maintenance is done correctly. So

00:48:10.398 --> 00:48:17.233
- they're doing that. And I believe that this body had some kind of legislation early on. Yeah, I remember

00:48:17.233 --> 00:48:23.288
- this conversation. Yeah. So, OK. Yeah. So we're not managing the underground facilities? No,

00:48:23.288 --> 00:48:25.566
- not the two, not the storm swirls.

00:48:25.986 --> 00:48:32.997
- but the maintenance of keeping these clean because they're specific, you know, you got to blow the organic

00:48:32.997 --> 00:48:39.615
- materials off. And I would just like to see whoever the manufacturer, we had specifications when all

00:48:39.615 --> 00:48:46.495
- this was done, who the manufacturer and decorative pavers put all this in and also did the forge because

00:48:46.495 --> 00:48:51.934
- I was checking back to make sure whether Public Works gets with them or, you know,

00:48:52.546 --> 00:48:58.163
- somebody from the trades district in order to make sure that we know what's going to continue. Because

00:48:58.163 --> 00:49:03.725
- if we see, if Public Works has not taken it over yet, or we don't know what it takes for Public Works

00:49:03.725 --> 00:49:09.397
- to take it over, is that a fair assessment? I wouldn't say that that's a fair assessment, that we don't

00:49:09.397 --> 00:49:14.632
- know exactly what it will take for them to feel comfortable taking on the right of way. I mean,

00:49:14.632 --> 00:49:17.086
- part of it is, I would assume, cost related.

00:49:17.762 --> 00:49:24.100
- There's an increased cost of maintaining the brick pavers, which they may not have the ability to take

00:49:24.100 --> 00:49:30.375
- on. So we really need to figure that out. That's why I'll try it. And I think that we figure that out

00:49:30.375 --> 00:49:36.651
- before we start spending a bunch of money. And this becomes something we're saddled with for years to

00:49:36.651 --> 00:49:43.358
- come. I think that's fine. If you guys want to try and table it and wait for us to come back with additional

00:49:43.358 --> 00:49:44.158
- information.

00:49:45.186 --> 00:49:54.381
- But you are now aware that we have an issue. Yes. So is there a motion to table? I'll make a motion

00:49:54.381 --> 00:50:03.668
- to table. Second. Moved and seconded. We'll do a roll call vote with Lori online. Let's go in person

00:50:03.668 --> 00:50:13.231
- first. So. Randy Cassidy, yes. John West, yes. C. Scambaleri, yes. It says she's joining. She must have

00:50:13.231 --> 00:50:14.334
- fallen off.

00:50:23.330 --> 00:50:32.540
- She's gone. She's gone. She's in the internet. OK. Oh, no. Well, let's treat that as 4-0, or 3-0.

00:50:32.540 --> 00:50:42.125
- You know, it works in Chicago. So let's go ahead and table that until December 7th, or such a time as

00:50:42.125 --> 00:50:51.522
- we have the information. I don't know that you get a resolution by the 7th. You may have to kick it

00:50:51.522 --> 00:50:53.214
- in the next year.

00:50:55.138 --> 00:51:03.208
- OK, that takes us to resolution 2692, approval of on-call services agreement with Thrasher Landscape

00:51:03.208 --> 00:51:11.517
- Inc. for snow removal. Who would like to take us through this? I'll do this one. I've been working with

00:51:11.517 --> 00:51:19.587
- JD Borough on starting to have some of the on-call services contracts directly with the RDC. They've

00:51:19.587 --> 00:51:23.902
- been going through public works and then splitting up

00:51:24.034 --> 00:51:34.703
- the invoices based on the properties. It would just, in my opinion, be cleaner to have the RDC have

00:51:34.703 --> 00:51:45.585
- their own on-call services contracts as well so that they could just be invoiced directly to the RDC.

00:51:45.585 --> 00:51:54.014
- And so this is the first of several that would be coming with snow potentially

00:51:54.338 --> 00:52:06.540
- any time now, never now. This is our first one. Thrasher Landscape is one of the approved contractors

00:52:06.540 --> 00:52:19.579
- that the public works facilities JD's group uses. It's the one that he typically uses for the RDC properties

00:52:19.579 --> 00:52:23.646
- and so we are requesting that the

00:52:23.778 --> 00:52:44.123
- RDC approved not to exceed amount for those on-call services and the amount of would be $25,000 and

00:52:44.123 --> 00:52:53.278
- this would come out of the maintenance fund.

00:52:53.570 --> 00:53:04.331
- has two one-year renewal options if unless of course if the price were to change or something that would

00:53:04.331 --> 00:53:14.580
- have to be agreed to but otherwise everything stayed the same there is two one-year renewal options

00:53:14.580 --> 00:53:19.294
- on it. Again this is just an effort to try to

00:53:21.666 --> 00:53:34.872
- to say clean up, it is to clean up the accounting on, I'm sorry? To plow through. To plow through. She's

00:53:34.872 --> 00:53:47.198
- here all night. Get these running through the RDC system separately. So we request your approval.

00:53:47.746 --> 00:53:55.657
- Sounds pretty straightforward. But are there any questions on 2692, John? Just a quick question. What

00:53:55.657 --> 00:54:03.490
- happens when you try to cap snow and we have more snow than 25,000 cover? We would have to come back

00:54:03.490 --> 00:54:11.478
- for additional. This is basically your appropriation for it, so we'd have to come back. And if we have

00:54:11.478 --> 00:54:16.286
- little snow, then we don't use it. That's fine, too. Correct.

00:54:19.906 --> 00:54:30.293
- personnel based on hourly rate. It's up to them not to exceed. And then looking in here, how many RDCs

00:54:30.293 --> 00:54:40.478
- properties is on this? Was I just missing something or? We can, JD will choose which RDC properties.

00:54:40.478 --> 00:54:49.150
- There has been discussion with like the trades district that possibly agreeing to use

00:54:49.538 --> 00:54:59.606
- work with John Fernandez's group to kind of have the maintenance of that area be consistent with vendors

00:54:59.606 --> 00:55:09.865
- to make it so we didn't want to pin it down to anyone. So it would be whatever properties that JD directed

00:55:09.865 --> 00:55:19.070
- them to. And then that's why I put in there that facilities could direct where they were to go.

00:55:19.266 --> 00:55:25.911
- So it's any RDC properties at all, JD would be able to direct them to take care of it. Yeah, because

00:55:25.911 --> 00:55:32.490
- when I look at something from a public work standpoint, I look specifically at the Hopewell project

00:55:32.490 --> 00:55:39.068
- and what we have up there. What is the level we're going to get to? And I'm bringing that up at one

00:55:39.068 --> 00:55:45.779
- of our other resolutions where we're talking with Centerstone, where we're allowing them to park. And

00:55:45.779 --> 00:55:48.542
- then are we cleaning the parking lot? No.

00:55:48.898 --> 00:55:56.991
- that resolution for Centerstone says that the original agreement which we are not cleaning that parking

00:55:56.991 --> 00:56:04.773
- lot. I just don't want to end up in a liability situation based on the fact that we're not cleaning

00:56:04.773 --> 00:56:12.944
- something we own and we're allowing people to park there. In going back to the mill, they've got several

00:56:12.944 --> 00:56:16.446
- owners and do they have an HOA of some sort?

00:56:17.602 --> 00:56:28.568
- So are they contributing to the maintenance of the overall park? I don't have a problem with thresher

00:56:28.568 --> 00:56:39.856
- and I don't have a problem with the cap. I just thought, because I had this map out, do we have to clear

00:56:39.856 --> 00:56:47.166
- these roadways at the park at our expense when others are using it?

00:56:47.298 --> 00:56:58.318
- properties on it. At this point, we clear what is ours. They have to clear the sidewalks in front of

00:56:58.318 --> 00:57:10.212
- their places of business. So are the streets have not been dedicated either? Public Works is still following

00:57:10.212 --> 00:57:17.086
- the streets to my knowledge. It's not shoveling the sidewalks.

00:57:17.218 --> 00:57:25.849
- But the mills lease puts them in charge of that in front of their building. I need to look at the forges

00:57:25.849 --> 00:57:33.329
- lease. So the $25,000 goes to other properties that we have, not the mill. That's not part

00:57:33.329 --> 00:57:41.713
- of this discussion. Unless they're sent to clean sidewalks and things there as well. Well, not on our

00:57:41.713 --> 00:57:46.974
- behalf, though. Well, there's part of the sidewalks that aren't

00:57:47.266 --> 00:58:04.174
- adjacent to any other properties correct yes that's my understanding we also typically have had somebody

00:58:04.174 --> 00:58:16.574
- like Thrasher taking care of the area surrounding the trades district garage

00:58:16.770 --> 00:58:24.667
- commercial space because that's ours, not necessarily the garage itself. So there is some challenges

00:58:24.667 --> 00:58:32.486
- there, which is why we had discussed potentially having one contractor for that entire area so that

00:58:32.486 --> 00:58:34.910
- it's not piecemealed together.

00:58:36.546 --> 00:58:42.375
- So we're working on that. We're supposed to receive it. I just want to be sure that we're not invoiced

00:58:42.375 --> 00:58:48.034
- for things that we're not responsible for because it's just easy to send it to the RDC because they

00:58:48.034 --> 00:58:53.806
- have deep pockets and they'll pay for it. Well, we've been criticized pretty heavily for not clearing

00:58:53.806 --> 00:58:59.918
- sidewalks on properties that we own, such as College Square not getting shoveled. It was the responsibility

00:58:59.918 --> 00:59:03.710
- of Weddle for their lease. So I don't think that that's occurring.

00:59:05.154 --> 00:59:11.322
- The issue we come into, at least from my perspective, is that we should set the example of what the

00:59:11.322 --> 00:59:17.490
- right thing to do. For properties that we are responsible for. Exactly, that we're responsible for.

00:59:17.490 --> 00:59:23.720
- That's what we're fighting. I'm not saying we should not take responsibility. It's just easy to say,

00:59:23.720 --> 00:59:30.074
- well, let the RDC do it. Like the trades district garage portion that we have a lease on, is that part

00:59:30.074 --> 00:59:35.070
- of the lease holding? There's multiple little things that have to be worked out.

00:59:37.954 --> 00:59:45.736
- Any additional questions on 2692 before we go to public comment? Okay, seeing none, let's open it for

00:59:45.736 --> 00:59:53.824
- public comment, either online or sort of in person. There is no in person. There is no in person, really.

00:59:53.824 --> 01:00:01.606
- Okay, seeing none, let's come back. Are there any more questions? And if not, may I have a motion for

01:00:01.606 --> 01:00:06.718
- resolution 2692? I'll make a motion for 2692 as presented. Second.

01:00:07.394 --> 01:00:14.749
- It's been moved and seconded. We'll do a roll call vote. Let's start here in person. Randy Cassidy,

01:00:14.749 --> 01:00:22.398
- yes. John West, yes. Sue Scambaleri, yes. Laurie McRobbie, yes. Thank you. That's 4-0. And that passes.

01:00:22.398 --> 01:00:29.974
- That takes us to resolution 2693, approval of an agreement with McAllister Machinery Company, Inc. for

01:00:29.974 --> 01:00:37.182
- the repair of the Trades District garage generator. Who would like to take us through this? Dana?

01:00:37.474 --> 01:00:49.707
- The motherboard on the generator at the Traces District garage has sustained some damage. It was believed

01:00:49.707 --> 01:01:01.593
- to be possibly due to a lightning strike at some point, and facilities had determined that it was down

01:01:01.593 --> 01:01:04.478
- an issue. McAllister had

01:01:04.738 --> 01:01:22.657
- given a proposal to come out and replace the motherboard and program it and it is an item again that

01:01:22.657 --> 01:01:34.366
- is an expense of the RDC and so it's just one of you know it just

01:01:34.466 --> 01:01:41.632
- I'm not sure what more to say about that. JD brought it to us. The JD board brought it to us from facilities

01:01:41.632 --> 01:01:48.404
- again. We've got to get this repaired, and it requires a new motherboard. OK. Are there any questions?

01:01:48.404 --> 01:01:55.044
- Randy? Well, two. A question and a comment. One, has it already been done? No. It has not been done.

01:01:55.044 --> 01:02:02.079
- OK, that's why I wanted to see if it was a retroactive situation. And you're sure it's the trades district

01:02:02.079 --> 01:02:03.262
- garage generator?

01:02:04.418 --> 01:02:13.312
- And the reason I say that, the trades district garage manager, which we didn't put in, it's a collar.

01:02:13.312 --> 01:02:22.381
- It's a collar. What does that mean, Randy? It's a manufacturer. It's a manufacturer. And our resolution

01:02:22.381 --> 01:02:31.188
- says it's a Cummins, which is the manufacturer. And the Cummins generator is on the forge. So that's

01:02:31.188 --> 01:02:33.630
- why I'm specifically asking

01:02:34.210 --> 01:02:42.135
- Because that's the Cummins, and it's on the Forge, and that is the Kohler that's in the trades district.

01:02:42.135 --> 01:02:49.833
- So I just want to clarify what we're actually. So we're at Cummins. No, I see that. No, no, no. Where

01:02:49.833 --> 01:02:57.380
- it says da-da-da-da-da. Wait, are you saying that the Kohler is at the Forge, and Cummins is at the

01:02:57.380 --> 01:03:02.814
- garage, or vice versa? No, no. Because the quote does say Cummins. Yes.

01:03:03.202 --> 01:03:11.331
- The Cummins generator, which we did not put in, Cassidy didn't do. The Cummins generator was moved from

01:03:11.331 --> 01:03:19.226
- the Bloomington Police Department, or from the old 714, to the Forge. And it is the backup generator

01:03:19.226 --> 01:03:27.198
- for the Forge. The trades district garage, when it was installed, which again, we did not do that, it

01:03:27.198 --> 01:03:32.670
- is a Kohler manufactured generator. So I'm trying to identify, was it

01:03:32.770 --> 01:03:41.347
- at the forge that needs a Cummins motherboard, or was it a Kohler motherboard? And is it under warning?

01:03:41.347 --> 01:03:49.594
- Which in my professional opinion, very doubtful. But it never hurts to ask. JD's email from Lisa is

01:03:49.594 --> 01:03:57.758
- attached as a quote from the Callister for repairs to the trades garage generator transfer switch.

01:03:57.954 --> 01:04:04.592
- They believe at some time was experienced a surge, most likely from a lightning strike that damaged

01:04:04.592 --> 01:04:11.230
- the transfer switch that controls the generator. This unit is out of warranty. A warranty would not

01:04:11.230 --> 01:04:17.867
- cover something like this, even if it was still in the warranty period. We are seeking RDC funds to

01:04:17.867 --> 01:04:24.704
- complete this repair, since the garage is an RDC facility. Please let us know if there's something the

01:04:24.704 --> 01:04:26.430
- RDC, if this could cover.

01:04:27.170 --> 01:04:39.659
- Reading that email just made sense because it could be a Cummins transfer switch that Controls the generator.

01:04:39.659 --> 01:04:51.127
- So now that makes sense. Okay, so It does specify that that is on One other question Jeff based upon

01:04:51.127 --> 01:04:52.830
- parking garage

01:04:53.378 --> 01:05:00.569
- bond money that like 4th Street, would there be a possibility that that could fall under utilization

01:05:00.569 --> 01:05:07.689
- of the trades district garage to repair as opposed to coming out of the 2519? That I would have to,

01:05:07.689 --> 01:05:15.165
- that's a legal question. I mean... I consider this a repair. What was happening at the 4th Street garage

01:05:15.165 --> 01:05:18.654
- is there was issues with how it was constructed.

01:05:19.298 --> 01:05:29.170
- And so that goes to the original construction. Here, there's no issue with how it was constructed. There

01:05:29.170 --> 01:05:38.666
- was a surge. And so it's simply a repair. So bond funds can't be used for repairs. If the bond funds

01:05:38.666 --> 01:05:45.342
- were for constructing the garage, no, it couldn't be used for repairs.

01:05:45.922 --> 01:05:53.015
- Fourth Street garage bond ordinance. I don't know that we looked well. I didn't know if there was any

01:05:53.015 --> 01:06:00.039
- money left over in the trade sister garage Just from a fiscal standpoint Because we did we didn't we

01:06:00.039 --> 01:06:07.063
- not on the fourth Street garage utilize revenues to fix the plumbing issue or the drainage issues It

01:06:07.063 --> 01:06:14.017
- was defect wasn't the repairs was fixing the construction Okay, it was a defect that wasn't covered

01:06:14.017 --> 01:06:14.782
- by warning

01:06:16.002 --> 01:06:22.870
- I didn't install it. That's a problem. OK. That answers the questions. Thank you. Yeah, I don't think

01:06:22.870 --> 01:06:29.603
- there's any money left in that bond anyway. OK. That clears it up. Any additional questions on 2693

01:06:29.603 --> 01:06:36.538
- before we go to public comment? Seeing none, let's go to public comment, either online or sort of here

01:06:36.538 --> 01:06:42.867
- in person. Seeing none, let's come back to commissioners. Are there any additional questions?

01:06:42.867 --> 01:06:45.022
- Or if not, may I have a motion?

01:06:45.410 --> 01:06:53.047
- I move approval of Resolution 2693. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. We'll vote by roll call

01:06:53.047 --> 01:07:00.907
- starting here in person. Randy Casta, yes. John West, yes. Sue Scambaleri, yes. Lori McGrady, yes. Great.

01:07:00.907 --> 01:07:08.841
- Thank you. That passes 4-0. That takes us to Resolution 2694, approval of First Amendment to the agreement

01:07:08.841 --> 01:07:15.070
- with Centerstone of Indiana, Inc. for temporary parking at 714 South Rogers Street.

01:07:16.226 --> 01:07:25.400
- Anna? So earlier this year, the RDC passed 2615, which allowed Centerstone to use the 714 South Rogers

01:07:25.400 --> 01:07:34.484
- Street surface lot, also located at the southwest corner of First and Rogers, for their employees and

01:07:34.484 --> 01:07:43.658
- clients to park their vehicles. 2615 expires December 31 of this year, so 2694 is an extension of that

01:07:43.658 --> 01:07:44.638
- agreement.

01:07:44.802 --> 01:07:53.515
- and that extends to June 30th, 2027. Of course, there's also in there that that could be ended earlier

01:07:53.515 --> 01:08:01.974
- with a seven-day notice to Center Stronghold. That's it. That's the gist. Are we satisfied with the

01:08:01.974 --> 01:08:10.518
- seven days? Will that meet our needs? Are we pretty confident? Well, it's pretty short, so yeah. OK.

01:08:10.518 --> 01:08:13.310
- I think they generally know that

01:08:13.698 --> 01:08:20.373
- It will need to be vacated eventually. So they're kind of on notice. Perpetually anyway. Questions?

01:08:20.373 --> 01:08:27.115
- Randy? Brings me to the question that we need to ask. Jeff, we're Centerstone? I mean, I happened to

01:08:27.115 --> 01:08:34.056
- drive by today and look and all the parking lots were full. So the question I've got as far as we have,

01:08:34.056 --> 01:08:40.798
- well, garage and such, does Centerstone have a plan? Because if we ask them for seven days to leave,

01:08:41.410 --> 01:08:47.106
- they're still going to have the same employees and they've since they've merged with brightly I don't

01:08:47.106 --> 01:08:52.690
- and this is a regional thing there may be more people so I'm just I'm concerned about seven days we

01:08:52.690 --> 01:08:58.274
- know we're gonna do a police station if at all possible you know God willing Creek Bed and Rise but

01:08:58.274 --> 01:09:03.915
- trying to give them a heads up a plan that says where are we gonna because you know Centerstone is a

01:09:03.915 --> 01:09:08.382
- vital part of our community they provide excellent services but they have staff

01:09:09.218 --> 01:09:16.526
- I mean, yeah, I don't know what their plan is. I just know that they are well aware of the parking situation.

01:09:16.526 --> 01:09:23.436
- I just want to be able to fix it if we can ahead of time without having to be reactionary and then next

01:09:23.436 --> 01:09:30.279
- thing we know. Hopefully they are working on a plan knowing that this is going to happen. I would hope

01:09:30.279 --> 01:09:34.398
- that they would be working on a plan. And of course, we would

01:09:34.530 --> 01:09:42.655
- likely have more than seven days notice to give them, and we would give them as much notice as we possibly

01:09:42.655 --> 01:09:50.400
- could. Just as we move forward with our housing and Hopewell, Centerstone, and the police station, we

01:09:50.400 --> 01:09:58.145
- just collectively try to be proactive in regards to it. I know we are. As long as we want to just let

01:09:58.145 --> 01:10:01.790
- it terminate, we want it to be extended because

01:10:01.922 --> 01:10:08.916
- We know that there's at least a few months in there that they could still use it, and we didn't want

01:10:08.916 --> 01:10:15.980
- to shut the doors on it too soon. Just bring it to everyone's attention that there will come a point.

01:10:15.980 --> 01:10:23.251
- It's better to be proactive with, because they're a fairly substantial employer downtown. Any additional

01:10:23.251 --> 01:10:27.614
- questions on 2694 before we go to public comment? Seeing none.

01:10:28.898 --> 01:10:35.244
- Public comment online or in person? Seeing none, let's come back to the commission. If there are no

01:10:35.244 --> 01:10:41.906
- further questions, may I have a motion on 2694? I'll make a motion to approve 2694 as presented. Second.

01:10:41.906 --> 01:10:48.188
- It's been moved and seconded. We'll vote by roll call starting here in person. Randy Cassidy, yes.

01:10:48.188 --> 01:10:51.742
- John West, yes. Sue Scambalur, yes. Cory McCready, yes.

01:10:52.066 --> 01:11:00.377
- Thank you. That passes 4-0. That takes us to resolution 2695, approval of notice of offering for West

01:11:00.377 --> 01:11:06.814
- Dodd Street properties. Thank you, Commissioner. So this resolution authorizes

01:11:06.946 --> 01:11:16.079
- a public offering of the four residential lots that you had purchased in I believe 2022 from Habitat

01:11:16.079 --> 01:11:25.122
- for Humanity 813, 819, 825, and 831 West Dodd Street. Statutorily, we're required to issue them for

01:11:25.122 --> 01:11:30.910
- the average of two appraisals. We did lump them together in the

01:11:31.202 --> 01:11:38.941
- in the offering for a total of 164,000 for the four lots, but individual lots are available. We will

01:11:38.941 --> 01:11:47.369
- be evaluating proposals based on the number and type of housing units proposed, affordability and anticipated

01:11:47.369 --> 01:11:51.966
- sales prices or rents, development quality and feasibility,

01:11:52.194 --> 01:11:58.849
- developer experience and financial capacity and the ability to meet a construction deadline and deliver

01:11:58.849 --> 01:12:05.312
- the project promptly. I think we can also add some language into any agreement that gets executed to

01:12:05.312 --> 01:12:11.775
- make sure that if there's any market conditions that change that we could potentially make sure that

01:12:11.775 --> 01:12:15.742
- there are some contingencies there. So we are in the offering

01:12:16.194 --> 01:12:23.470
- saying that they would be required to begin construction within nine months of conveyance and complete

01:12:23.470 --> 01:12:30.675
- the project within 15 months of construction commencement. So this is here before you. These are just

01:12:30.675 --> 01:12:37.880
- four vacant parcels that are sitting otherwise not collecting tax base and could be homes for people.

01:12:37.880 --> 01:12:45.438
- So we would really like to get these on the market. Thank you. Questions? John? Since we're offering them,

01:12:45.570 --> 01:12:59.200
- as a package or individually, should we not price them individually? In the offering and the under notice

01:12:59.200 --> 01:13:12.958
- of offering under the second paragraph, we have added language that says single lot price shall be 41,000.

01:13:14.274 --> 01:13:22.308
- Public edification. Additional questions? Okay, let's go to public comment. Is there any comment either

01:13:22.308 --> 01:13:29.802
- here or online? Seeing none, let's come back to the commission. Are there any further questions?

01:13:29.802 --> 01:13:37.836
- If not, may I have a motion on 2695? I'll make a motion to approve 2695 as presented. Second. It's been

01:13:37.836 --> 01:13:43.166
- moved and seconded. We'll vote by roll call starting here in person.

01:13:43.362 --> 01:13:49.627
- Randy Cassidy, yes. John West, yes. Steve Scambaleri, yes. And Lauren Nefrabi, yes. Thank you. That

01:13:49.627 --> 01:13:55.956
- passes 4-0. I would like to thank Anna Killian-Hanson for getting this put forth and putting it back

01:13:55.956 --> 01:14:02.472
- to productive use. I greatly appreciate that. Done. Is there any further business? Are there any quorum

01:14:02.472 --> 01:14:08.863
- checks we need to do? Can I just make one brief comment? Yeah, please. I had said earlier that we had

01:14:08.863 --> 01:14:11.870
- no money left in the Troyes District Bond Fund.

01:14:12.034 --> 01:14:19.609
- I checked that. We actually do have $16,000. Dana's comments about the usage still stand. So it's not

01:14:19.609 --> 01:14:27.334
- appropriate to use for ongoing maintenance. But I just wanted to say there is $16,000 rather than zero.

01:14:27.334 --> 01:14:34.983
- So it's right there. We just got to figure out how to use it. So if you find a defect, which one could

01:14:34.983 --> 01:14:40.702
- certainly come up, and we can help develop them. Hopefully there are enough.

01:14:42.146 --> 01:14:52.250
- Are there any quorum checks we need to do for anything, Anna? Quorum checks. I said quorum checks. For

01:14:52.250 --> 01:15:02.158
- our snack menu. Our next regularly scheduled meeting is going to be Monday, December 7 at 5 PM. Will

01:15:02.158 --> 01:15:11.870
- we have a quorum for that date? Yes. I'll be here in person. OK, perfect. I'll be there in person.

01:15:12.034 --> 01:15:21.033
- Wonderful. We probably need to have an executive session prior to that meeting, if at all possible,

01:15:21.033 --> 01:15:30.121
- at 4 PM, if you will be available. Yes. Yes. Yes. OK, perfect. Then I believe that's all I need, and

01:15:30.121 --> 01:15:36.510
- then you won't have to see me for the rest of the year. See you never.

01:15:36.994 --> 01:15:44.246
- You'll be in our memory. We'll miss you. Seeing no further business, is there a motion to adjourn? Some

01:15:44.246 --> 01:15:52.126
- of them moved. Been moved and seconded. All those in favor? Aye. Thank you everyone. Thank you so much. Bye bye.
