City of Bloomington Redevelopment Commission meeting for Monday, November 16th, 2026. Let's begin with a roll call. Commissioners? Randy Cassidy, present. John West, present. C. Scambaleri, here. So, and now to staff. I'm sorry. Christina Finley, hand department. Tammy Caswell, hand department. Jeff McCammon, controller. Jane Coopersmith, economic and sustainable development and As you can likely tell Deborah Meyerson cannot be with us tonight, so I'm pinch hitting for her. Let's move into reports. Is there a director's report this evening? Not a formal report. I'm happy to answer any questions that you have. I do want to give you a brief update. Mr. Cassie had asked me at the last meeting about the Evergreen Village maintenance. And we have since tried to reach out again to set up another neighborhood meeting. They have declined. They have asked for more time. So they would be more interested in a neighborhood meeting starting in the spring. So just FYI, we did attempt. Anything else, Ian? No. OK, I'm going to interrupt. I see Lauren McGrady on Zoom. So let's acknowledge that, sorry. Thank you, Laurie. Okay, and is there a legal report? No report tonight. Okay, thank you, Dana. Treasurer's report? No report. Okay, and business development? Not this evening. A quiet evening. Okay, that takes us to minutes for approval from November 2nd, 2026. These are in your packets. Are there any corrections or changes? And if not, may I have a motion? Move for approval. Second. It's been moved and seconded. We'll do a roll call vote with one of our commissioners on Zoom. But Lori, you're muted. I was not present for the mute for the meeting. So I can vote to approve, but maybe I should abstain. OK. Commissioners? Raina Cassidy. Was that a yes? Yes. John West, yes. And Sue Scambler, yes. That passes. So 301. And that takes us to a presentation on proposed project delivery system for 714 South Rogers Street. Would someone like to provide a runway for this and get us oriented? Last meeting, we heard about different delivery methods with the construction manager's agent CMA approach and discussion about the construction manager's constructor CMC approach. We heard from a company called Garmont and their discussion about it. And we also have locally Whittle Brothers who does similar services. And so they also would like an opportunity to express their views on the CMA and CMC process to the RDC and a little bit about their company. And so we have Chris Seeley here. And if they'd like to come up to the chairs introduce here. If you would introduce yourselves for the record. I'm Chris Scioli, Vice President of Water Village Construction here in Bloomington. I have Josh Nagel, our Vice President of Pre-Construction Services, with me as well. And yeah, as Dana mentioned, watched the presentation last week, or last meeting, presented heavily on the CMA side of things. Just reached out and said, hey, you know, I understand that there are two delivery methods, both provide pros and cons. And, you know, I think that was important to highlight, at least maybe go a little bit more depth on the differences and some real life experiences that we've seen. We perform and provide both services, CMA, CMC, and general contractors. So we're very well familiar with all those. and we've done them all for the City of Bloomington. So Josh, with that, do you want to jump in and kind of give your overview of the services? It is to be very, very brief. So if you have questions or, you know, further clarifications, please feel free to jump in and ask. But as Chris mentioned, Weddell's performed both CMA and CMC services for the City of Bloomington on various projects. And it's just hitting on a few things of where neither one of these delivery methods are an owner's rep position. That's something completely different by definition within the industry. So just focusing on CMA and CMC, just a point of note here that the fees that there's there's nothing that says one method is necessarily cheaper than the other right out of the gate. So the fees are set by proposals that are submitted and there's no guarantee of a savings and going in a CMA model. So I guess that doesn't necessarily make a CMC model more expensive. To me, the two key things that separate the two are basically a staffing capacity and a construction understanding under a CMA model that that puts the onus on the city to have resources to manage contracts, to understand, you know, what's happening on their project and to be able to process the information that's provided to them by the CMA in that case. So under CMC, the construction manager holds all the contracts and takes care of that, the paperwork wrangling and things. And so it's, you know, they're, That's one component of it. The other big component is really the appetite for risk that the city has. And cost certainty, that's a term that we like to use in the pre-construction world. The earlier we can establish cost certainty for you as the city, you know what the project is supposed to cost. There's no settling up at the end of, well, it's the cost of the work plus my fee, plus my management. plus whatever I have there. You know the day you sign the contract with the CMC that you have a guaranteed maximum price in play. Granted, there can be instances where the design changes after the fact or there's an unforeseen condition that nobody knew about within the project. So it's not completely a foolproof method, but you do have, like I said, an earlier period where You know, it's your job as the CM to establish the proper contingencies and allowances to put in the project that will cover it. There's various ways to handle that money at the end if you have money left over. Our stance on our projects has been that 100% of the savings goes back to the owner. Like I said, that can be negotiated in different ways by different proposals, but our stance As a local contractor, we want to see that money go back to the local entity. In a lot of ways, it's our tax money, too. So we want to be good stewards through that process. So to me, those are the two biggest differences. And I think you all have heard other presentations of what is included. So yes, at a very basic level, management of the project is included under both delivery It's a similar staffing model. You typically have a project manager, a superintendent, a project engineer or so for that level, regardless of who manages the project, under which method. So I want to focus on the things that I see as the difference, the differentiators in the decision-making process. So Chris, is there anything you want to add to that? The only thing I would say is, as CMA, and I think this is important because it does make a difference in the job, CMA, you can't self-perform any of the work. You cannot jump in and participate. If something comes up, you must rely on your prime contractors or find somebody else to do it. You cannot do any of the work by state statute. So CMC, delivery method, if you get into a situation where there's either a gap or failure or whatever that might be, you can step in and do the work and ensure that it gets done. So that's important. to me, a pretty significant difference in the two delivery methods. And that's a good point. So obviously, under public bidding, those packages, even as a CMC, if that's us in that role, you still competitively bid those packages. You still advertise and go through the same exact process that you would for any other prime bidder. So there is a competitive element there. You're not just handing money to somebody who acts as a CMC because they're in that role versus a CMA Any questions? So basically the end result is the construction manager will give you a price that says you will not go above this. We have a design, we have a concept, and it's up to us. to include as a construction manager. Like I said, any contingencies, any allowances, any things that we see in our professional opinion of what it takes to deliver the project. And we always have to contend with the budget too on the owner's side. So working within that framework is our end result. Now how we get there, there's different ways to do it. As a design, well, Now let's go back to the very beginning. The earlier the construction manager is brought on, the better, because you have a chance to review and influence the design to make sure you stay within the owner's budget. So you're guiding this process the entire way through. And like I said, the earlier you're brought in, the better. Whether it's conceptual or whether it's even a schematic design, those are the best times to be brought in. And so, Some owners would like for you to go to a GMP as early as possible in the design phase because there's the risk component that they want you as the contractor to take risk on in the project because that's how the concept of getting to the best value and understanding that as a contractor, you understand exactly what's involved. You're not coming with consistent hands out asking for more money. Within that process, you could wait until you get to a fully designed project and there's really no risk involved and now you're bidding the job and just managing it. Or you can go earlier and say, hey, if we were at 90% drawings or maybe 75% drawings or at some level, you can establish a guaranteed maximum price there. That does a couple things for you. That allows you to get the project started sooner because you're not waiting for the entire design to be complete and then go through a bidding process. So if you're looking to shave time off a schedule, that's a way you can do that. And then, there's a lot of variables involved in it, but that's the high level of when do you want to lock in the risk? And so we've done it, almost all the ways I've just named, where we've locked in a job at 60% drawings, at 90% drawings. And if there's not a high level of confidence among the owner and the design team that it needs to wait until it gets to a final design, that's a decision that the group makes together. So there's a lot of variables in play of when you establish a guaranteed maximum price. What projects for the city have you done performed as a CMA? I'm familiar with your CMC projects. So recently we did Fire Station 1, Fire Station 3, and the Forge. Those are all CMA. I've mentioned this before, either delivery method, they have their pros and cons. I'm not here to say one is superior to the other. It's important just to look at what is the result or what is best for the city, and you look at your management, what do you have on staff to manage the project, what's your ability to handle multiple contracts, and then looking at where do you want the risk to lie. It's preference. All right. Questions for Mr. Stone. So if you were to be awarded as a CMC or a CMA, does that eliminate Wendell Brothers to be a bidder as a contractor? Under the CMC scenario, we could bid packages for work that we typically perform. Up to 30% by state statute, yes. I guess I envision the, I'm not saying what happened, I'm just saying that it opens up the opportunity for a conflict of interest. Because at the end of the day, what the RDC is interested in is somebody representing our interest, which is the public's interest. That's why we're going down this path. Because none of us are in the construction business to the extent that we want to manage this. So we want somebody representing our interest. So with that said, where's our money better spent? Which direction are we better? So as a CMC that does not take away our duty to act as your agent. I mean it just enables us as the CM to potentially perform some of the work and have influence on schedule as we would perform work. But it's... I would go on to say if that's a true concern, you can say we don't want you to do the work. That's also an option to say we don't want you to stop performing anything. You can still serve as CMC and not bid on the packages. You lose some coverage, but that's certainly an option that the owner has. So one thing I didn't, I failed to mention this in the CMA to CMC comparison. So when a job comes out as a CMA, that requires all prime bidders to bond their work, to complete all the city paperwork, all the things that it takes to work for the city, right? That restricts your bidding pool significantly right out of the gate because there are plenty of local qualified subcontractors who, they'll go elsewhere because it's easier to work elsewhere. So under the CMC method, that does help attract local contractors. So I think it helps get, we like to think it helps get better pricing on the back end through the subcontractor community and more competitive bids. But to go back, I know you haven't gotten down to that level yet. You're still focused on how do you know that we are acting in your best interest or whoever the collective we is, right, is the subcontracting community. By the duties required in the state statute, there's still a requirement to act upon your behalf and to give you reporting and to give you visibility within the project and to any of the duties that a CMA would provide in that case. So there's nothing lost there on what's required to, and whatever you want, delivered to you, that gets written in the contract. So if you want a specific report, if you want, like I said, specific visibility into the project, write that into the contract and whoever works for you will owe you that information. I think one thing that goes along with that, I heard mentioned in the previous presentation, there's talk about contingency. I think there's a little skepticism about how contingency is handled and how do you know that it's being represented in the right way. And as Josh mentioned, you can write it however you want, but we have contracts where, well, almost all of them, it's a mutual contingency where if the contingency needs to be used, it requires approval from the owner. You have to go to them and say, this is why we're using it. They sign off and, okay, we understand why it's being used. It's not just a slush fund. It's there for purposes of the project. They monitor it, it's accounted for. And at the end of the job, whatever's remaining is a deduct change or a back to the owner. Now their previous or some contracts, they try to incentivize it by saying, well, we'll do a shared savings and then hope that it doesn't complete the contingency right away. You can have contractor's contingency. There are multiple ways to do it. But I think what we see pretty commonly is the mutual contingency where it's in one purse, requires conversation as to why it has to meet criteria written out in the contract and what it's used for. That way it's just not there for oversight and misuse. It gets controlled. And with that, the base AIA contract document does not get to that level. That needs to be something that whoever you choose to work with, that you work through that and negotiate those terms. Otherwise, it's very vague in those terms. Randy, do you have a question? No, go ahead. When we get down to the basics and when we're starting to look at a GMP in regards to it, because we all know there's a certain pot of money we can work with, what particular percentage, once we have an architect and our engineering team on board, does the CMC get involved in order to make sure the budget is going to stay there? Is that a 20%, 50%, 60%? The next week would be fantastic. Seriously and the sooner the better. Literally that way the engineer and the architects are working with the potential constructor in order to basically make the design also work into the constructability. Okay and then when we get down to a basis of if we have CMA we're going to have multiple primes. We have multiple primes that would occur. With that how does that differentiate between CMA versus CMC as far as where our warranty would run into. So, yeah, at CMA, each prime contractor is responsible for their own warranty. So if you have six prime contractors, you're going to have six different, you know, warranties with them. CMC, it rolls back to your construction manager at risk, who's ultimately responsible. And then they'll have contracts with the subs, but at the end of the day, they're responsible for ensuring it and passing it down, make sure there's representation. Okay, so that way from a longevity standpoint, anything, we would end up coming back to one person as opposed to going to multiples and trying to get them if there's any deficiencies that we see. From a standpoint of working with the engineer, architects, engineers, and the owners that would be utilizing the facilities that we're talking about. How does that play in between the two? Because if we select architects and engineers, or we selected CMA or CMC, at what point are the construction manager as agent or the construction manager as contractor Involving that particular end user is that immediately is that. I think part of that depends on how you write your proposal services you're I mean you're asking when the when the when the user comes in and user actually comes in as we may be the owner, but we would not be the end user of this facility. My being clear. So you're talking about when like operations when you would you bring them in for the conversation. I would say. I would think that starts at the very beginning of the programming. So you start your basis of design off of what their needs are in the assessment. A lot of times that early in that process, the architect and engineering drives that, the programming and the meetings and getting what the owner really wants incorporated in the design. And then so obviously their feedback is you're reviewing constructability of a concept that the owner might want. I mean, there's a lot of, And that step is irrespective of the delivery method. It should be, at least. It doesn't matter. It's just a matter of when you get the team on, then it's going to be utilized on a final basis. And then to John's point, where we really don't want to have to be in. We're not to the point of doing it ourselves. So you're kind of using owner and user interchangeably. Yeah, what I say because we're not the. Yeah, we may be the funding source, but the end user will be the police department. We're paying the bills. Yeah, we don't. We may tour it. I'll be about the only time we. Right, if there's an impasse on I want this, but it's not your budget. Somebody's gonna have to be that decision maker. Yeah, the user will have to come to us. Right, exactly. The job as the contract manager goes through this process is to challenge the design team to meet the budget and hold them. This is the value we're working towards. We'll challenge them. There'll be some tough conversations we have regularly because they're proud of their design. And so we will challenge them to ensure that we're making sure that it's physically responsible because at the end of the day, if it doesn't meet the budget, the project doesn't happen. I would use an example, the three fire department projects. The two were CMA and one was CMC. I would think that process as we went through all the pre-construction, with the fire department and with other, I'm trying to remember who from the city, it was in JD that was part of it. So that process did not go any differently for us, even though it was two different delivery methods. We approached it the same way. That raises a really good question. Why wasn't the same method used throughout? What caused the CMA to pop out when you had success with the CMC? We did the CMA projects first. We switched to CMC for FireOps. So the FireOps Center, the history of it was, it kept getting pushed. It kept getting delayed and delayed and they needed to get out of their building where they were across town because the lease was going to end. So they were trying to figure out how can we expedite this job to move it along. So if you do CMC, there's opportunity to get out there and get started on your site work. do an early, you know, do iterations of GMP and get this thing rolling faster. It allowed us to get the PEMB, the pre-engineered building, ordered sooner. Whereas CMA, you really wait for the design to go, be fully complete, and you go on your bid packages for each respective package. So we waited, or you'd have to wait, in most scenarios. CMC allows you to start a little bit sooner in some scenarios. Were you, when you were at CMC, were you also one of the contractors? We performed one package. We did not get the concrete. We just did general trades. Yeah, so we didn't get all the packages that we bid competitively. So even when you self-performed, you still have to bid? We still have to bid. You still go through the public bid process and it's still a public opening. But you're there to help us select the right contractor, so how, I mean that's just really, I know you're gonna, now on the CMC you select them. Yeah, I mean the contractor with you. We hold the contractors. Hold the contractors. So in a bidding process, we're still involved, I gather. There is a pre-qualification process. There are certain things that all the city requirements that would be on any other project carry through into the CMC bidding documents. So, yeah, picking the most qualified, most responsive contractor is still part of the process. We do not have free reign to just choose whoever we want. So the convention center of CMC, every big package that we put out, up-way open, went back and talked to the CIV. We looked at the pre-calls that they filled out, looked at their financials, looked at their safety records, scoped, did a full review with them, and then they had the opportunity to offer feedback on if they had any reservation about contractor that appeared to be the low bidder or the appropriate contractor. They didn't go with the low on every single one of them. One reason or another, they made some decisions, but it was fully disclosed and what was there, what we were working with. Just to get a clear understanding of that, pre-qualifications occur. So, you know, you've got enough. It's under one contractor, but all bids for all prime trades are publicly opened, and they would be presented to? Correct. We'd come with a recommendation. Recommendation. Fully transparent process. And then one other thing that when we're allowed to bid self-performed packages, we will turn our bids in early to whoever the person is, the designee, just to ensure that nobody's peeking or doing anything unethical. If it's 24 hours in advance, they have to be turned in, whatever. Give them to whoever the representative is that will hold them until the opening, and then they're all opened at the same time. from a delivery timeframe based upon the CMA versus CMC as far as duration of time from start to finish. Well, I'm just curious in regards to where you're going out, where we have to go out. And you. I mean, Josh, correct me if I'm wrong, but really, I think where you're going The only way you would really see a significant difference in duration is if you decide to put out an early package. Maybe put out an early demo package or something to get ahead. Yeah, in this case, or if there's site for this particular project, yeah, if there is a site package or something you want to get out ahead to start underground detention or the work that can be involved in this project. Yeah, it would have to be strategic, not just for the sake of. But that strategy you're talking about is identified quickly. Oh, yeah, yeah. We have the owner's representative or the user, the architect, engineer, and the construction. Right, yeah. But that's in a CMC scenario already, more likely. Not necessarily. That process could be followed. As long as your documents are the level they need to be. Yeah. Sorry, can I make one more comment? So a lot of CMA projects prefer to wait later in the process to where the documents are 100% complete, because if you're starting before the documents are complete, you're taking on risk, which then puts you in a CMA at risk. Or you have to put more contingency or more allowances in, which then can have a negative impact on your overall budget. So that's why that process tends to go that way under a CMA umbrella. Just take water? Yeah. We're at about 20 minutes now on this presentation. Are there more questions? Yeah, one more. Go ahead. Are you recommending one process over another? I mean yeah so I like I said starting out they're both fine delivery methods I think knowing what I know about where the city is with their capacity to manage the project and resources available I lean towards CMC because it gives you one one contractor deal with opposed to multiple and also you know I think it's about where you do with risk and I mentioned If you have a contractor that happens to go out of business or fold shortly after a job is done, that's the owners to figure out. I mean, the CMA can help lead the way and try to guide the process. But at the end of the day, you have to work through the process of getting somebody else to come back in and fix that work. Where in the CMA arrest scenario, you go to your construction manager, your CMC and make them responsible for that other contractor. But they're both fine delivery methods. I'm not saying one is superior to the other. I think it just is unique to what you need and what best fits where you're at. Like I said, I watched the presentation from last meeting, and that was a nice summary of what they are. So probably reiterated a lot of what you've already heard. So I'm not here to contest any of that. I just highlight and answer any questions that we can. I do think for this particular project, though, there is when you go into a renovation or from what we've heard this project is, there's a lot of risk of unknowns and finger pointing and between multiple primes or whatever. So having a CM, a risk with one focal point to work through and let that CM manage the process and will make things go smooth, smoother from what you see as the owner and what you'd be involved in. So that's specific to this project, the one comment I would make. Support between CMA and CMC on the front end before the Indians going, are equal or? Should be. I would say yes. Any additional questions? Okay. Thank you gentlemen. Much appreciated. Dana, do you want to want to do the off ramp for them. So you've had both presentations. There was no action we're asking for this evening. So you've got time to consider this. And then we may be bringing you something at the next meeting. For you to to make a decision on how to move forward We would like to which other direct either direction you go. We would like to get going because the a Proposal have come in and so we do want to get the CM whichever type on sooner than later, so But so I'll send some information out on how that contracting with the CMA goes and CMC and and you know what the next steps are and find out you know you guys can respond to me individually if you know what you your thoughts might be if you want more information of one type or another and I can get that for you. Can you recollect where we are on the actual written responses or proposals from anybody. What do we have in the way of a written proposal from any GM or CM? I believe we sent them to you for the CMAs. And we had how many of those? You had two proposals for CMAs plus the contract that Garmong had sent that, well, I detailed that. I didn't give you the actual contract because that would be under negotiation, but the details of it shortlisted. As far as the CMC, that's a process that has to go out for RFPs by statute. CMAs is professional services and does not require that same process. that the CMC does. So for the purposes of today's discussion, we don't have anything in writing from Wellbrookers? No. That was a while ago. utilize an owner's rep at some point. So that's still an option. Owner's rep, CMA, CMC. So the next time we'll hear from you will be December 7th at our meeting then. That's correct. OK. Great. Thank you. That takes us into new business. We have five resolutions before us this evening to work through. We'll begin with resolution 2691, approval of the fourth amendment to the agreement with Mother Nature Landscaping Inc. for sidewalk and trash container repairs at the trades district. Who'd like to speak to this? I'm more than happy to at least kick you off so that you can understand what the obstacles are. I have some images on the screen. that show what we're working against. There are several areas within the trades district where the brick has created a pretty big dip, which causes some accessibility issues. Water appears to be getting down below the brick and kind of washing away some of the dirt. We had talked previously. We had had a site visit to try and figure out exactly what the cause was. I think at that time, John actually was present with us. We felt like there was a lack of compacting of the sand underneath some of the brick. So basically Mother Nature has gone through, taken a look at some of the repairs that are necessary and given us an estimate to try and get that taken care of. Again, there are some accessibility concerns related to the work that's needed at the trades district. The other thing that I would want to highlight are the trash cans. When the trash cans were installed, they were bolted to loose bricks. And there are doors on the front of these trash cans. So when they go to be emptied, they create a situation where they're top heavy, and they try to fall over. So part of this quote is related to bolting them to the curb so that they no longer fall over. Dana, what did I miss? No, that covers it well. So again, we were. those out there as well. There are, I think, three main areas that the brick is doing this in kind of a linear fashion, as you can see from the drawings or the pictures. So this would be to cover all those areas and to secure all the trash containers, recycling receptacles in the district to get for accessibility issues as well as of course aesthetics and prevent falls. Did the original report come with any kind of guarantees against this kind of shifting and sinking or are we out of warranty so to speak? Yeah, what I had understood was we're past that time period. We'll be out of warranty. I can address a little bit of that. Decorative pavers put them in. The Cassidy Electric, my previous employer, was on this project. And decorative paving also just did the forge project around. So those were the individuals. Part of it, I would assume, would still be under warranty at some point. Things that we're seeing here typically have been made by vehicles driving on, because if you look at the compaction of what that is, this is actually part of the stormwater drain for the trades district. So you see the gravel in between that? It's not compacted to a point, and there's a weight-based limit that needs to be put on these in order to not have the equipment that has been drove in their trucks on them, because it is part of the stormwater. I would like to asked to get with utilities to find out where our agreement was because all of this drains into two storm systems that have maintenance that needs to be cleaned out. So while I have no issues with Sean and Mother Nature's ability to do the work, we need to make sure what that substrate needs to be in order for it to be put back because in my estimation, in my experience, this has been caused by equipment being driven on it. And if you see the gravel in there, you can see this is set up as a drainage system. Yeah, well, I want to comment. I'm glad Randy said that, so I'd like to comment on it. I can't deny that, although every one of these surfaces, there's only a it all floats to the middle. So there's there's one single area that's depressed, not like wheels from a vehicle that would have to. But it's pretty clear that the subsurface was not done properly. And that's throughout the whole district. So I think it was done quickly in a little bit of haste, not compacted. And then because they were probably up against the timeline, they threw the pavers down. because it looked nice. And the trash containers, this is not my area of expertise, but I know I'm not going to bolt trash containers to a moving paver, to a floating paver. I can't even answer that. Well, you don't. I mean, it's pretty clear the paver is going to shift, and you're trying to mount something to it permanently. So it should have been mounted to the curb to begin with. I don't think the contractor did us any favors. But we're stuck with this problem. It has to be repaired. My main concern in regards to anything is to make sure that we get the manufacturing what is for the subsurface of the drainage to make sure that that is contiguous. Because while this is an issue that's approximately, what, eight years old? If I remember correctly. We've got the entire same type situation at Hopewell. So that's part of my concern from a long-term maintenance of what we have and how we budget accordingly for that. Because if we're using these pavers and the substrate, there is a maintenance protocol that needs to be maintained on a consistent basis because as we see the grass and such growing up, that shouldn't be occurring. if we want to maintain these long term, that the depression has to be repaired. I think Randy brings up a really good point about driving on it. When I was there, I didn't even think about that. So if these are used as a kind of a vehicle right away, I mean, they're supposed to be sidewalks. We asked that question, actually, visit and at that time we were told that nobody had seen that occur. I have since that time heard from other people that have seen driving occur on some of these papers close to the mill. So I've heard both accounts. No there hasn't been any driving on it and yes there has but I have not. I wasn't privy to that. Well I drive around a lot. I got a video from last week of of a uniloader on Hopewell. So as a follow-up, John Fernandez sent some of us who were on that tour a little schematic of the Tech Park and kind of who owns what. I've not verified this, but are all of the sections that need to be repaired, are they all in the public right-of-way, which is our problem. Unfortunately, that public right-of-way has not been adopted by Public Works, and a lot of that has to do with the condition of the pavers. So the RDC is still... So once we get this through... That is the hope, is to try and make sure that Public Works can adopt. Or the trade, because my main concern is we repair it now, but we go back and repair again, that we have a long-term maintenance program at least cost it in so we know what that overall long-term cost is so we can project for it. I think that if we have to do this, we do it with the understanding that it gets transferred to public works. We don't have to deal with it. Do we need more time to do some additional research? Well, I just want to know that we're bringing that up to a standard where public works will accept it. That's the due diligence I want. Because I don't, to Randy's point, I don't want to do this again next year. I don't know how to guarantee that without having public works. The question, look, as the trades district moves forward, and of course we've got, you know, we've got contracts with the trades district. We have this public works transfer and then we have a long-term maintenance aspect portion of it because of what all is going to occur. Who do we need in the room to get that worked out? We've got the utility worked out for the drainage for them to take care of it based upon the costing to each lot owner. Who do we need to get in the room to get that resolved so that we can turn it over but they have adequate understanding from what the manufacturer's specifications are to what the maintenance needs to be, so we don't end up in long-term degradation of a public facility. There's never enough money to maintain all of them if you don't know what the maintenance cost is. Just to clarify, are you talking about Just the paper maintenance, are you talking about it as part of the stormwater? Well, part of the stormwater, these particular drainage things go into storm. There's two storm swirls on that property. I don't know what the maintenance schedule has been with them. And utilities, I'm assuming, has it. Yes, and that's just what I wanted to make sure is clear, is that utilities early on in the planning of the trades district, There was a plan to have there be kind of a condo-ized strategy for maintenance of the storm sewer. CBU is not comfortable with that. They want to make sure that the maintenance is done correctly. So they're doing that. And I believe that this body had some kind of legislation early on. Yeah, I remember this conversation. Yeah. So, OK. Yeah. So we're not managing the underground facilities? No, not the two, not the storm swirls. but the maintenance of keeping these clean because they're specific, you know, you got to blow the organic materials off. And I would just like to see whoever the manufacturer, we had specifications when all this was done, who the manufacturer and decorative pavers put all this in and also did the forge because I was checking back to make sure whether Public Works gets with them or, you know, somebody from the trades district in order to make sure that we know what's going to continue. Because if we see, if Public Works has not taken it over yet, or we don't know what it takes for Public Works to take it over, is that a fair assessment? I wouldn't say that that's a fair assessment, that we don't know exactly what it will take for them to feel comfortable taking on the right of way. I mean, part of it is, I would assume, cost related. There's an increased cost of maintaining the brick pavers, which they may not have the ability to take on. So we really need to figure that out. That's why I'll try it. And I think that we figure that out before we start spending a bunch of money. And this becomes something we're saddled with for years to come. I think that's fine. If you guys want to try and table it and wait for us to come back with additional information. But you are now aware that we have an issue. Yes. So is there a motion to table? I'll make a motion to table. Second. Moved and seconded. We'll do a roll call vote with Lori online. Let's go in person first. So. Randy Cassidy, yes. John West, yes. C. Scambaleri, yes. It says she's joining. She must have fallen off. She's gone. She's gone. She's in the internet. OK. Oh, no. Well, let's treat that as 4-0, or 3-0. You know, it works in Chicago. So let's go ahead and table that until December 7th, or such a time as we have the information. I don't know that you get a resolution by the 7th. You may have to kick it in the next year. OK, that takes us to resolution 2692, approval of on-call services agreement with Thrasher Landscape Inc. for snow removal. Who would like to take us through this? I'll do this one. I've been working with JD Borough on starting to have some of the on-call services contracts directly with the RDC. They've been going through public works and then splitting up the invoices based on the properties. It would just, in my opinion, be cleaner to have the RDC have their own on-call services contracts as well so that they could just be invoiced directly to the RDC. And so this is the first of several that would be coming with snow potentially any time now, never now. This is our first one. Thrasher Landscape is one of the approved contractors that the public works facilities JD's group uses. It's the one that he typically uses for the RDC properties and so we are requesting that the RDC approved not to exceed amount for those on-call services and the amount of would be $25,000 and this would come out of the maintenance fund. has two one-year renewal options if unless of course if the price were to change or something that would have to be agreed to but otherwise everything stayed the same there is two one-year renewal options on it. Again this is just an effort to try to to say clean up, it is to clean up the accounting on, I'm sorry? To plow through. To plow through. She's here all night. Get these running through the RDC system separately. So we request your approval. Sounds pretty straightforward. But are there any questions on 2692, John? Just a quick question. What happens when you try to cap snow and we have more snow than 25,000 cover? We would have to come back for additional. This is basically your appropriation for it, so we'd have to come back. And if we have little snow, then we don't use it. That's fine, too. Correct. personnel based on hourly rate. It's up to them not to exceed. And then looking in here, how many RDCs properties is on this? Was I just missing something or? We can, JD will choose which RDC properties. There has been discussion with like the trades district that possibly agreeing to use work with John Fernandez's group to kind of have the maintenance of that area be consistent with vendors to make it so we didn't want to pin it down to anyone. So it would be whatever properties that JD directed them to. And then that's why I put in there that facilities could direct where they were to go. So it's any RDC properties at all, JD would be able to direct them to take care of it. Yeah, because when I look at something from a public work standpoint, I look specifically at the Hopewell project and what we have up there. What is the level we're going to get to? And I'm bringing that up at one of our other resolutions where we're talking with Centerstone, where we're allowing them to park. And then are we cleaning the parking lot? No. that resolution for Centerstone says that the original agreement which we are not cleaning that parking lot. I just don't want to end up in a liability situation based on the fact that we're not cleaning something we own and we're allowing people to park there. In going back to the mill, they've got several owners and do they have an HOA of some sort? So are they contributing to the maintenance of the overall park? I don't have a problem with thresher and I don't have a problem with the cap. I just thought, because I had this map out, do we have to clear these roadways at the park at our expense when others are using it? properties on it. At this point, we clear what is ours. They have to clear the sidewalks in front of their places of business. So are the streets have not been dedicated either? Public Works is still following the streets to my knowledge. It's not shoveling the sidewalks. But the mills lease puts them in charge of that in front of their building. I need to look at the forges lease. So the $25,000 goes to other properties that we have, not the mill. That's not part of this discussion. Unless they're sent to clean sidewalks and things there as well. Well, not on our behalf, though. Well, there's part of the sidewalks that aren't adjacent to any other properties correct yes that's my understanding we also typically have had somebody like Thrasher taking care of the area surrounding the trades district garage commercial space because that's ours, not necessarily the garage itself. So there is some challenges there, which is why we had discussed potentially having one contractor for that entire area so that it's not piecemealed together. So we're working on that. We're supposed to receive it. I just want to be sure that we're not invoiced for things that we're not responsible for because it's just easy to send it to the RDC because they have deep pockets and they'll pay for it. Well, we've been criticized pretty heavily for not clearing sidewalks on properties that we own, such as College Square not getting shoveled. It was the responsibility of Weddle for their lease. So I don't think that that's occurring. The issue we come into, at least from my perspective, is that we should set the example of what the right thing to do. For properties that we are responsible for. Exactly, that we're responsible for. That's what we're fighting. I'm not saying we should not take responsibility. It's just easy to say, well, let the RDC do it. Like the trades district garage portion that we have a lease on, is that part of the lease holding? There's multiple little things that have to be worked out. Any additional questions on 2692 before we go to public comment? Okay, seeing none, let's open it for public comment, either online or sort of in person. There is no in person. There is no in person, really. Okay, seeing none, let's come back. Are there any more questions? And if not, may I have a motion for resolution 2692? I'll make a motion for 2692 as presented. Second. It's been moved and seconded. We'll do a roll call vote. Let's start here in person. Randy Cassidy, yes. John West, yes. Sue Scambaleri, yes. Laurie McRobbie, yes. Thank you. That's 4-0. And that passes. That takes us to resolution 2693, approval of an agreement with McAllister Machinery Company, Inc. for the repair of the Trades District garage generator. Who would like to take us through this? Dana? The motherboard on the generator at the Traces District garage has sustained some damage. It was believed to be possibly due to a lightning strike at some point, and facilities had determined that it was down an issue. McAllister had given a proposal to come out and replace the motherboard and program it and it is an item again that is an expense of the RDC and so it's just one of you know it just I'm not sure what more to say about that. JD brought it to us. The JD board brought it to us from facilities again. We've got to get this repaired, and it requires a new motherboard. OK. Are there any questions? Randy? Well, two. A question and a comment. One, has it already been done? No. It has not been done. OK, that's why I wanted to see if it was a retroactive situation. And you're sure it's the trades district garage generator? And the reason I say that, the trades district garage manager, which we didn't put in, it's a collar. It's a collar. What does that mean, Randy? It's a manufacturer. It's a manufacturer. And our resolution says it's a Cummins, which is the manufacturer. And the Cummins generator is on the forge. So that's why I'm specifically asking Because that's the Cummins, and it's on the Forge, and that is the Kohler that's in the trades district. So I just want to clarify what we're actually. So we're at Cummins. No, I see that. No, no, no. Where it says da-da-da-da-da. Wait, are you saying that the Kohler is at the Forge, and Cummins is at the garage, or vice versa? No, no. Because the quote does say Cummins. Yes. The Cummins generator, which we did not put in, Cassidy didn't do. The Cummins generator was moved from the Bloomington Police Department, or from the old 714, to the Forge. And it is the backup generator for the Forge. The trades district garage, when it was installed, which again, we did not do that, it is a Kohler manufactured generator. So I'm trying to identify, was it at the forge that needs a Cummins motherboard, or was it a Kohler motherboard? And is it under warning? Which in my professional opinion, very doubtful. But it never hurts to ask. JD's email from Lisa is attached as a quote from the Callister for repairs to the trades garage generator transfer switch. They believe at some time was experienced a surge, most likely from a lightning strike that damaged the transfer switch that controls the generator. This unit is out of warranty. A warranty would not cover something like this, even if it was still in the warranty period. We are seeking RDC funds to complete this repair, since the garage is an RDC facility. Please let us know if there's something the RDC, if this could cover. Reading that email just made sense because it could be a Cummins transfer switch that Controls the generator. So now that makes sense. Okay, so It does specify that that is on One other question Jeff based upon parking garage bond money that like 4th Street, would there be a possibility that that could fall under utilization of the trades district garage to repair as opposed to coming out of the 2519? That I would have to, that's a legal question. I mean... I consider this a repair. What was happening at the 4th Street garage is there was issues with how it was constructed. And so that goes to the original construction. Here, there's no issue with how it was constructed. There was a surge. And so it's simply a repair. So bond funds can't be used for repairs. If the bond funds were for constructing the garage, no, it couldn't be used for repairs. Fourth Street garage bond ordinance. I don't know that we looked well. I didn't know if there was any money left over in the trade sister garage Just from a fiscal standpoint Because we did we didn't we not on the fourth Street garage utilize revenues to fix the plumbing issue or the drainage issues It was defect wasn't the repairs was fixing the construction Okay, it was a defect that wasn't covered by warning I didn't install it. That's a problem. OK. That answers the questions. Thank you. Yeah, I don't think there's any money left in that bond anyway. OK. That clears it up. Any additional questions on 2693 before we go to public comment? Seeing none, let's go to public comment, either online or sort of here in person. Seeing none, let's come back to commissioners. Are there any additional questions? Or if not, may I have a motion? I move approval of Resolution 2693. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. We'll vote by roll call starting here in person. Randy Casta, yes. John West, yes. Sue Scambaleri, yes. Lori McGrady, yes. Great. Thank you. That passes 4-0. That takes us to Resolution 2694, approval of First Amendment to the agreement with Centerstone of Indiana, Inc. for temporary parking at 714 South Rogers Street. Anna? So earlier this year, the RDC passed 2615, which allowed Centerstone to use the 714 South Rogers Street surface lot, also located at the southwest corner of First and Rogers, for their employees and clients to park their vehicles. 2615 expires December 31 of this year, so 2694 is an extension of that agreement. and that extends to June 30th, 2027. Of course, there's also in there that that could be ended earlier with a seven-day notice to Center Stronghold. That's it. That's the gist. Are we satisfied with the seven days? Will that meet our needs? Are we pretty confident? Well, it's pretty short, so yeah. OK. I think they generally know that It will need to be vacated eventually. So they're kind of on notice. Perpetually anyway. Questions? Randy? Brings me to the question that we need to ask. Jeff, we're Centerstone? I mean, I happened to drive by today and look and all the parking lots were full. So the question I've got as far as we have, well, garage and such, does Centerstone have a plan? Because if we ask them for seven days to leave, they're still going to have the same employees and they've since they've merged with brightly I don't and this is a regional thing there may be more people so I'm just I'm concerned about seven days we know we're gonna do a police station if at all possible you know God willing Creek Bed and Rise but trying to give them a heads up a plan that says where are we gonna because you know Centerstone is a vital part of our community they provide excellent services but they have staff I mean, yeah, I don't know what their plan is. I just know that they are well aware of the parking situation. I just want to be able to fix it if we can ahead of time without having to be reactionary and then next thing we know. Hopefully they are working on a plan knowing that this is going to happen. I would hope that they would be working on a plan. And of course, we would likely have more than seven days notice to give them, and we would give them as much notice as we possibly could. Just as we move forward with our housing and Hopewell, Centerstone, and the police station, we just collectively try to be proactive in regards to it. I know we are. As long as we want to just let it terminate, we want it to be extended because We know that there's at least a few months in there that they could still use it, and we didn't want to shut the doors on it too soon. Just bring it to everyone's attention that there will come a point. It's better to be proactive with, because they're a fairly substantial employer downtown. Any additional questions on 2694 before we go to public comment? Seeing none. Public comment online or in person? Seeing none, let's come back to the commission. If there are no further questions, may I have a motion on 2694? I'll make a motion to approve 2694 as presented. Second. It's been moved and seconded. We'll vote by roll call starting here in person. Randy Cassidy, yes. John West, yes. Sue Scambalur, yes. Cory McCready, yes. Thank you. That passes 4-0. That takes us to resolution 2695, approval of notice of offering for West Dodd Street properties. Thank you, Commissioner. So this resolution authorizes a public offering of the four residential lots that you had purchased in I believe 2022 from Habitat for Humanity 813, 819, 825, and 831 West Dodd Street. Statutorily, we're required to issue them for the average of two appraisals. We did lump them together in the in the offering for a total of 164,000 for the four lots, but individual lots are available. We will be evaluating proposals based on the number and type of housing units proposed, affordability and anticipated sales prices or rents, development quality and feasibility, developer experience and financial capacity and the ability to meet a construction deadline and deliver the project promptly. I think we can also add some language into any agreement that gets executed to make sure that if there's any market conditions that change that we could potentially make sure that there are some contingencies there. So we are in the offering saying that they would be required to begin construction within nine months of conveyance and complete the project within 15 months of construction commencement. So this is here before you. These are just four vacant parcels that are sitting otherwise not collecting tax base and could be homes for people. So we would really like to get these on the market. Thank you. Questions? John? Since we're offering them, as a package or individually, should we not price them individually? In the offering and the under notice of offering under the second paragraph, we have added language that says single lot price shall be 41,000. Public edification. Additional questions? Okay, let's go to public comment. Is there any comment either here or online? Seeing none, let's come back to the commission. Are there any further questions? If not, may I have a motion on 2695? I'll make a motion to approve 2695 as presented. Second. It's been moved and seconded. We'll vote by roll call starting here in person. Randy Cassidy, yes. John West, yes. Steve Scambaleri, yes. And Lauren Nefrabi, yes. Thank you. That passes 4-0. I would like to thank Anna Killian-Hanson for getting this put forth and putting it back to productive use. I greatly appreciate that. Done. Is there any further business? Are there any quorum checks we need to do? Can I just make one brief comment? Yeah, please. I had said earlier that we had no money left in the Troyes District Bond Fund. I checked that. We actually do have $16,000. Dana's comments about the usage still stand. So it's not appropriate to use for ongoing maintenance. But I just wanted to say there is $16,000 rather than zero. So it's right there. We just got to figure out how to use it. So if you find a defect, which one could certainly come up, and we can help develop them. Hopefully there are enough. Are there any quorum checks we need to do for anything, Anna? Quorum checks. I said quorum checks. For our snack menu. Our next regularly scheduled meeting is going to be Monday, December 7 at 5 PM. Will we have a quorum for that date? Yes. I'll be here in person. OK, perfect. I'll be there in person. Wonderful. We probably need to have an executive session prior to that meeting, if at all possible, at 4 PM, if you will be available. Yes. Yes. Yes. OK, perfect. Then I believe that's all I need, and then you won't have to see me for the rest of the year. See you never. You'll be in our memory. We'll miss you. Seeing no further business, is there a motion to adjourn? Some of them moved. Been moved and seconded. All those in favor? Aye. Thank you everyone. Thank you so much. Bye bye.