WEBVTT

00:00:01.762 --> 00:00:10.569
- I'll call to order the meeting of the Ellisville Board of Zoning Appeals for Wednesday, November 18th,

00:00:10.569 --> 00:00:19.633
- 2026. Caleb, would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United

00:00:19.633 --> 00:00:28.782
- States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty

00:00:28.782 --> 00:00:31.518
- and justice for all. Thank you.

00:00:34.626 --> 00:00:49.683
- Yes. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Okay, the first item on our agenda is approval of the twenty

00:00:49.683 --> 00:01:02.526
- twenty seven meeting dates. Yes, so before you heard the proposed twenty twenty seven.

00:01:02.882 --> 00:01:13.101
- meeting dates. I believe there's only one that's outside of the normal second Wednesdays. And I'll know

00:01:13.101 --> 00:01:23.026
- next year's a week here. So there's not too many outside of our normal dates. So if you review those

00:01:23.026 --> 00:01:31.870
- and if you see anything you want changed, let me know. I make a motion that we accept the

00:01:32.290 --> 00:01:43.364
- Board is owning a field meeting for next year, 2027. Seconded. Okay, we have a motion and a second.

00:01:43.364 --> 00:01:54.548
- All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Hearing none, motion carries. Next item is approval of the

00:01:54.548 --> 00:02:02.078
- minutes from our meeting on October 14th of 2026. So moved. Second.

00:02:03.042 --> 00:02:10.491
- All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Hearing none, motion carries. We have no old business. We

00:02:10.491 --> 00:02:17.941
- have two items of new business. The first is a petition for a variance from development standards to

00:02:17.941 --> 00:02:25.317
- reduce the minimum lot area. That's a conflict of interest. The petitioner is Ozzie Lauer. Is there

00:02:25.317 --> 00:02:32.766
- a conflict of interest? Do we want to have any conflict of interest? Do we want an item for tonight?

00:02:32.962 --> 00:02:41.531
- I'll say something in the honor of transparency. I live in Charlestown Manor, so that's first off.

00:02:41.531 --> 00:02:50.187
- Second off, the first petition that was pulled, what was it called exactly? The use variance. I was

00:02:50.187 --> 00:02:59.102
- approached by representatives of Charlestown Manor's HOA. They had general questions about the BZA and

00:02:59.682 --> 00:03:06.893
- the things we do and what we look for and stuff. I answered those questions to the best of my ability.

00:03:06.893 --> 00:03:13.964
- I also had questions pertaining to my normal job as a firefighter. I answered those questions to the

00:03:13.964 --> 00:03:20.965
- best of my ability as well. And then we just had friendly conversation and I shared my own personal

00:03:20.965 --> 00:03:28.036
- opinions on the matter. So just so everyone's aware and they know that I did talk to some of the HOA

00:03:28.036 --> 00:03:29.086
- members, okay?

00:03:30.370 --> 00:03:38.988
- Okay, and so the 500 South Turtle Bay Creek Road. I need to disclose them. Okay. So I have an employee

00:03:38.988 --> 00:03:47.356
- in my office, Mike Burns, and he's a resident of Charlestown Manor in the HOA, and because of that,

00:03:47.356 --> 00:03:55.723
- he was not involved with the file, so I just wanted to disclose that. Now we're ready. Okay, so 500

00:03:55.723 --> 00:04:00.158
- South Turtle Bay Creek Road is case number BGA 26-8.

00:04:01.602 --> 00:04:09.955
- Thank you. This is a petition by Ozzie Lauer of Bynum-Fanyone Associates for consideration of a variance

00:04:09.955 --> 00:04:18.706
- from development standards to reduce the minimum lot area to 5,662 square feet or 0.13 acres in a residential

00:04:18.706 --> 00:04:25.150
- one zoning district, subject parcels located at 500 South Turtleback Creek Road.

00:04:25.954 --> 00:04:32.698
- The owners of 500 South Turtle Creek Turtleback Creek have given Township Trustee representatives by

00:04:32.698 --> 00:04:39.509
- Nymphianian Associates permission to pursue the variance from development standards. Minimum lot area

00:04:39.509 --> 00:04:46.320
- for low density residential district R1 is 8,000 square feet for single family residential and 10,000

00:04:46.320 --> 00:04:48.190
- square feet for other uses.

00:04:49.026 --> 00:04:56.746
- Richland Township Trustee owns a parcel adjacent to 500 South Turtleback Creek Road and its use is a

00:04:56.746 --> 00:05:04.925
- ball field. Richland Township Trustee is acquiring a 1.13 acre parcel from 500 Turtleback Creek. Currently

00:05:04.925 --> 00:05:12.569
- the proposed parcel serves has the access route to a ball field owned by the Township Trustee until

00:05:12.569 --> 00:05:15.550
- now the 0.13 acre parcel has been used

00:05:15.682 --> 00:05:22.924
- by the public to reach the ball fields without a recorded ingress slash egress easement or right away.

00:05:22.924 --> 00:05:30.166
- In the absence of a recorded ingress slash egress easement or dedicated right away, the property owner

00:05:30.166 --> 00:05:37.689
- 500 South Turtleback Creek Road was responsible for the access to and from the property and any associated

00:05:37.689 --> 00:05:44.158
- liabilities. In taking action on all variance requests, the Board of Appeals is to consider

00:05:44.258 --> 00:05:50.994
- The following decision decision criteria consistent with Indiana code and unified development ordinance.

00:05:50.994 --> 00:05:57.795
- Number one general welfare the approval of the variances from development standards will not be injurious

00:05:57.795 --> 00:06:04.339
- to the public health safety morals and general welfare the community staff finding approval would not

00:06:04.339 --> 00:06:08.958
- cause any significant problems in relation to public health and safety.

00:06:09.730 --> 00:06:16.097
- Two, adjacent property, the use or value of the area adjacent to the property included in the variance

00:06:16.097 --> 00:06:22.588
- will not be affected in a substantially adverse manner. Staff finding the development standard variances

00:06:22.588 --> 00:06:28.770
- will not affect adjacent properties in a substantially adverse manner. Three, practical difficulty,

00:06:28.770 --> 00:06:35.075
- the strict application of the terms of the ordinance will result in a practical difficulty in the use

00:06:35.075 --> 00:06:36.126
- of the property.

00:06:36.514 --> 00:06:42.895
- Subject property consists of a narrow strip of land that provides access for members of public to reach

00:06:42.895 --> 00:06:49.215
- township owned recreational facilities used for ballgames and other public activities. The requirement

00:06:49.215 --> 00:06:53.694
- of a lot area of 10,000 square feet because it's considered another use.

00:06:53.890 --> 00:07:00.504
- would prohibit the transfer of the property. In addition, the existing access arrangement may limit

00:07:00.504 --> 00:07:07.382
- the property owner's ability to reasonably use or improve the property while accommodating the public's

00:07:07.382 --> 00:07:14.327
- continued access to a township-owned recreational facility. Strict applications of the applicable zoning

00:07:14.327 --> 00:07:20.478
- development standard may therefore create a practical difficulty in the use of the property.

00:07:21.026 --> 00:07:27.854
- Existing public access circumstances create a difficulty that is not self-imposed and provides reasonable

00:07:27.854 --> 00:07:34.553
- relief while protecting the interests of the property owner and the public. The Board of Zoning Appeals

00:07:34.553 --> 00:07:41.059
- action shall be in a form of approval, approval with conditions, denial, or a continuance. The Board

00:07:41.059 --> 00:07:45.182
- of Zoning Appeals takes final action on all variance petitions.

00:07:45.282 --> 00:07:52.420
- The purpose of a variance from development standards is to provide relief from a specific zoning requirement

00:07:52.420 --> 00:07:59.493
- when strict enforcement of that requirement creates practical difficulty for the property owner. Therefore,

00:07:59.493 --> 00:08:06.435
- based on the above analysis, it is a staff opinion that the variance from development standards to reduce

00:08:06.435 --> 00:08:13.376
- the minimum lot area to 5,662 square feet or 0.13 acres meets all requirements and criteria and therefore

00:08:13.376 --> 00:08:14.686
- recommends approval

00:08:14.818 --> 00:08:24.113
- of the request. The board may approve the variances if after testimony and discussion, it finds that

00:08:24.113 --> 00:08:33.407
- the request meets all six of the stated requirements. If the board denies a variance, it shall state

00:08:33.407 --> 00:08:42.794
- which requirements have not been met. And this is the proposed plat. And this is what the parcel will

00:08:42.794 --> 00:08:43.806
- look like.

00:08:44.418 --> 00:08:53.534
- after it's been transferred from 500 South Turtleback and petitioners representative is present if you

00:08:53.534 --> 00:09:02.472
- have any questions. Okay, so basically the township is buying part of this lot to make the access to

00:09:02.472 --> 00:09:10.526
- the ball field legal and nothing else is changing. Correct. The property across the creek.

00:09:11.906 --> 00:09:20.625
- or is it partial of the, on this side of the creek, could be the east side of the creek. This is where

00:09:20.625 --> 00:09:29.174
- you enter the ball field. Yeah, I understand that, but I'm asking if it's a square foot, square feet

00:09:29.174 --> 00:09:37.893
- is just on the west side of the creek or is it on both sides? I don't think it has anything to do with

00:09:37.893 --> 00:09:40.094
- the creek. Well, it does.

00:09:40.482 --> 00:09:50.266
- Can AJ answer that, your question? Are you ready for him? Are you ready for him? Yeah, sure. Okay. I

00:09:50.266 --> 00:10:00.243
- guess that's the creek right there, I suppose. AJ Willis, Spot and Fanion Associates. I'm representing

00:10:00.243 --> 00:10:08.574
- this project tonight. So the new lot line between the two lots will follow the creek.

00:10:08.930 --> 00:10:16.488
- So right now, the creek currently splits that lot at the 500 Turtleback Creek Road. So we're gonna subdivide

00:10:16.488 --> 00:10:23.491
- it along the center line of that creek. Everything on the west side of the creek will be transferred

00:10:23.491 --> 00:10:30.494
- over to the township, and everything on the east side of the creek will remain the same. Will remain

00:10:30.494 --> 00:10:37.982
- the same? Yep. And the other question I have, is there any other lots there as the township got any of the,

00:10:41.666 --> 00:10:49.759
- section feed crossed from the creek. The Creek County does the. Yeah, not that I'm aware of. There may

00:10:49.759 --> 00:10:58.008
- be a few lots down through there that just barely cross over that creek, but this is the only area where

00:10:58.008 --> 00:11:05.865
- that drive crosses another parcel of land. Okay, thank you. Yep. Does anyone have any questions for

00:11:05.865 --> 00:11:08.222
- the petitioner or for Denise?

00:11:10.754 --> 00:11:20.906
- Okay, is there anyone from the public that wants to address this? Seeing none, I think we're ready for

00:11:20.906 --> 00:11:31.157
- a motion. I will then make a motion that we approve case number BZA 26-8 for 500 South Turtleback Creek

00:11:31.157 --> 00:11:40.126
- Road. I'll second it. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call, please. David Drake.

00:11:40.258 --> 00:11:48.775
- Travis Conyer? Yes. Pat Wesolowski? Yes. Caleb Plummer? Yes. Matt Steevo? Yes. Thank you. Okay, motion

00:11:48.775 --> 00:11:57.043
- carries. The next item on our agenda is a petition for a special exception to allow a home business

00:11:57.043 --> 00:12:05.643
- in a residential three zoning district, location 4504 North Triple Crown Drive. Petitioner is Tim Lang.

00:12:05.643 --> 00:12:07.710
- Case number is BZA 26-7.

00:12:15.618 --> 00:12:23.319
- Good evening. Next on the agenda is a petition by Tim Lang for consideration of a special exception

00:12:23.319 --> 00:12:31.175
- to allow home based business in residential three zoning district. Excuse me. Subject parcels located

00:12:31.175 --> 00:12:39.030
- at 4504 North triple crown drive. The unified development ordinance requires home based businesses in

00:12:39.030 --> 00:12:44.190
- an R three zoning district are to be allowed by special exception.

00:12:45.122 --> 00:12:51.736
- Petitioners request for special exception, special exception, it's mouthful, is the only item to be

00:12:51.736 --> 00:12:58.417
- considered by this Board of Zoning Appeals. Charlestown Manor was annexed into the town of Ellsville

00:12:58.417 --> 00:13:05.097
- in 2017 with R3 zoning. At that time, the developer intended to construct apartments, which have not

00:13:05.097 --> 00:13:11.712
- come to be. Building permit application to add the addition of a garage with a vault in the rear to

00:13:11.712 --> 00:13:14.622
- house the home-based business was submitted

00:13:14.786 --> 00:13:23.083
- on July 21st, 2026 by the prior property owner. In discussions with the property owner, it was decided

00:13:23.083 --> 00:13:31.702
- to add that garage has an addition to the home because detached buildings are not allowed for a home-based

00:13:31.702 --> 00:13:39.999
- business. Petitioner purchased 4504 North Triple Count Drive, a single-family dwelling on August 21st,

00:13:39.999 --> 00:13:44.510
- 2026 and is a sole proprietor of TLS Tactical Solutions

00:13:44.770 --> 00:13:52.169
- a firearms dealer, manufacturer and retailer. The garage addition will house the home-based business

00:13:52.169 --> 00:13:59.642
- petitioner and holds a federal firearms license issued by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms

00:13:59.642 --> 00:14:07.114
- and sees clients by appointment only between the hours of 5 p.m. to 7 p.m. The business does not have

00:14:07.114 --> 00:14:13.854
- employees and there will not be any signage. The vault for the business is 160 square feet.

00:14:13.954 --> 00:14:21.419
- The door weighs 1,000 pounds and is 14 inches thick with steel reinforced walls and has a safe lock

00:14:21.419 --> 00:14:29.034
- system. In taking action on all special exception requests, the board is zoning appeals shall use the

00:14:29.034 --> 00:14:35.902
- following decision criteria consistent with Indiana code and unified development ordinance.

00:14:36.898 --> 00:14:43.389
- Number one, the establishment, maintenance, or operation of the special exception will not be detrimental

00:14:43.389 --> 00:14:49.573
- to or endanger the public health, safety, morals, or general welfare, be injurious to public health,

00:14:49.573 --> 00:14:55.819
- safety. Sorry, that's repeating. Staff finding petitioners seeking a special exception for home-based

00:14:55.819 --> 00:15:02.064
- business that will see clients by appointment only during specific hours, which will not be injurious

00:15:02.064 --> 00:15:06.718
- to the public health, safety, morals, and general welfare of the community.

00:15:07.490 --> 00:15:13.771
- Number two, the special exception will not be interest to the use and enjoyment of other property in

00:15:13.771 --> 00:15:20.177
- the immediate vicinity for the purpose is already permitted. The proposed home based firearms business

00:15:20.177 --> 00:15:26.832
- will operate by appointment only and will not employ additional personnel. Client visits will be scheduled

00:15:26.832 --> 00:15:33.486
- in advance, limiting the frequency and concentration of business related traffic to the property. Business

00:15:33.486 --> 00:15:37.342
- transactions and inventory storage will be conducted indoors.

00:15:37.666 --> 00:15:44.045
- and no outdoor sales displays, firearm demonstrations, or discharging to firearms will occur on the

00:15:44.045 --> 00:15:50.870
- premises. Based on the proposed scale and manner of operation, the business is not anticipated to generate

00:15:50.870 --> 00:15:57.440
- excessive traffic, parking demands, noise, lighting, odors, or other disturbances that would adversely

00:15:57.440 --> 00:16:04.010
- affect neighboring residential properties. The limited appointment-based nature of the business allows

00:16:04.010 --> 00:16:07.646
- the property to retain its primary residential character

00:16:07.778 --> 00:16:14.726
- while accommodating the proposed business activity. Subject to compliance with applicable federal, state,

00:16:14.726 --> 00:16:21.280
- and local requirements, their proposed use is not expected to be injurious to the use and enjoyment

00:16:21.280 --> 00:16:28.162
- of surrounding properties for their permitted residential uses. The establishment of a special exception

00:16:28.162 --> 00:16:30.718
- will not impede or substantially alter

00:16:30.850 --> 00:16:37.127
- the normal and orderly development and improvement of surrounding property or uses permitted in the

00:16:37.127 --> 00:16:43.844
- district. The proposed home-based business will operate within the existing residence and will not require

00:16:43.844 --> 00:16:50.372
- substantial structural modification to the property's existing residential character. The business will

00:16:50.372 --> 00:16:57.088
- operate by appointment only with no additional employees and all business activities and inventory storage

00:16:57.088 --> 00:16:58.846
- will be maintained indoors.

00:16:59.426 --> 00:17:06.037
- The limited nature of the proposed business is not anticipated to interfere with the development improvement

00:17:06.037 --> 00:17:12.103
- or continued residential use of surrounding properties. Neighboring property owners will retain the

00:17:12.103 --> 00:17:18.350
- ability to construct, maintain, expand, and improve their properties in accordance with the applicable

00:17:18.350 --> 00:17:19.806
- R3 zoning requirements.

00:17:20.610 --> 00:17:27.482
- Their proposed special exception will not change the zoning classification of the property or alter

00:17:27.482 --> 00:17:34.491
- the permitted residential uses of surrounding properties. Therefore, the proposed use is not expected

00:17:34.491 --> 00:17:41.776
- to impede or substantially alter the normal and oral development and improvement of surrounding property.

00:17:41.776 --> 00:17:48.510
- Four adequate utilities, access road drainage, and other necessary facilities are being provided.

00:17:49.986 --> 00:17:57.316
- Staff finding is stated earlier in paragraph five, an application was received at the addition of a

00:17:57.316 --> 00:18:04.866
- garage with a vault in the rear to house the home-based business, and that necessary facility has been

00:18:04.866 --> 00:18:09.118
- completed. Adequate utilities, sorry, just read that one.

00:18:10.146 --> 00:18:17.177
- The special exception will be located in a district where such use is permitted and all other requirements

00:18:17.177 --> 00:18:23.879
- set forth in the UDO that are applicable to such use will be met. Staff finding the town of Ellsville

00:18:23.879 --> 00:18:30.450
- Unified Development Ordinance identifies home-based business has use permitted by special exception

00:18:30.450 --> 00:18:37.219
- in the R3 high-density residential zoning district. Proposed firearm sale business is conducted by the

00:18:37.219 --> 00:18:38.270
- property owner,

00:18:38.882 --> 00:18:45.530
- and as stated earlier, it's within the existing residence, operates by appointment only and does not

00:18:45.530 --> 00:18:52.178
- employ additional personnel. The proposed business will be subject to the applicable development and

00:18:52.178 --> 00:18:59.023
- operational standards established in section 3.6, home-based business of the UDO, including limitations

00:18:59.023 --> 00:19:05.736
- on customer visits, hours of operations, business location, outdoor storage and displays, maintenance

00:19:05.736 --> 00:19:08.830
- of residential character, parking and signage,

00:19:09.666 --> 00:19:16.019
- The business will not require additional driveways, exterior commercial displays, or alterations that

00:19:16.019 --> 00:19:22.433
- would change the residential appearance of the property. Subject to compliance with the applicable UDO

00:19:22.433 --> 00:19:28.973
- requirements and any conditions imposed by the Board of Zoning Appeals, the proposed home-based business

00:19:28.973 --> 00:19:34.142
- is eligible for consideration as a special exception in our three zoning district.

00:19:35.042 --> 00:19:42.328
- The Board of Zoning Appeals action shall be in a form of approval, approval with conditions, denial,

00:19:42.328 --> 00:19:50.119
- or continuance. The Board of Zoning Appeals takes final action on all variance petitions. Special exception

00:19:50.119 --> 00:19:57.406
- use is authorized by the Board of Zoning Appeals after a public hearing and a determination that all

00:19:57.406 --> 00:20:01.662
- applicable special exception criteria have been satisfied.

00:20:02.082 --> 00:20:08.401
- The proposed home-based business has minimal impacts and can be regulated through the same standards

00:20:08.401 --> 00:20:15.159
- used for home-based businesses in single-family districts, which the petitioner already meets. If approved,

00:20:15.159 --> 00:20:21.854
- the proposed use becomes an authorized use of the property subject to any conditions imposed. The property

00:20:21.854 --> 00:20:28.361
- retains its R3 zoning classification. The approval does not rezone the property or change the permitted

00:20:28.361 --> 00:20:30.238
- use of neighboring properties

00:20:30.370 --> 00:20:37.345
- and the applicant must continue complying with all applicable UDO requirements. Therefore, based on

00:20:37.345 --> 00:20:44.600
- the above analysis, it is staff opinion that the special exception to allow a home-based business meets

00:20:44.600 --> 00:20:51.994
- all requirements of the home-based business requirements under the UDO, and therefore recommends approval

00:20:51.994 --> 00:20:57.086
- of the special exception request. And I'll go through photos, excuse me.

00:20:58.114 --> 00:21:08.540
- This is where the parcel is located. So this is looking in the garage, the vaults in the back, and on

00:21:08.540 --> 00:21:19.170
- the right, some measurements of the walls in the vault door. And this is looking out towards the garage

00:21:19.170 --> 00:21:28.062
- door. And then that's the vault door. And that's the front of the home with the garage

00:21:28.450 --> 00:21:36.638
- on the left is noted. And then I tried to get a little closer, but it was hard to get it all in one

00:21:36.638 --> 00:21:44.991
- screen. So and that's all the pictures. Petitioner is here if you have any questions. OK, so my first

00:21:44.991 --> 00:21:53.179
- question of you, Denise, is if this were an R1 zone, is a home based business automatically allowed

00:21:53.179 --> 00:21:58.174
- if it meets those conditions? Yes, it'd be allowed by right.

00:21:58.690 --> 00:22:05.573
- So the only difference here, even though this was zoned as R3, it's been completely developed as R1.

00:22:05.573 --> 00:22:12.591
- Correct. So if it had been zoned correctly, or not correctly is not the right word, but if it had been

00:22:12.591 --> 00:22:19.542
- zoned as it has been constructed, then it would have been allowed by right. And the only reason we're

00:22:19.542 --> 00:22:27.038
- here is because when it was annexed in, it was annexed in as R3, even though it was developed as R1. Correct.

00:22:27.362 --> 00:22:35.092
- It's all single-family residential in the development. Okay. And right now there's 82, if you want to

00:22:35.092 --> 00:22:42.974
- know, 82 single-family homes built or under construction. And are there any other home-based businesses

00:22:42.974 --> 00:22:50.629
- in that neighborhood subdivision? I've been told that there are four. But they don't have to come to

00:22:50.629 --> 00:22:55.934
- us because, well, no, they would because it's in our three. Yeah, but

00:22:56.098 --> 00:23:04.551
- They just didn't, but I can't confirm him. I've just been told that. So does this proposed home based

00:23:04.551 --> 00:23:12.839
- business meet all of the requirements of a home based business according to our code? Yes, it does.

00:23:12.839 --> 00:23:21.209
- The only difference he would be allowed to have signage and there's some parking standards, but it's

00:23:21.209 --> 00:23:23.198
- by appointment only so.

00:23:23.874 --> 00:23:32.726
- He'll probably only have theoretically one car at a time, plus his home, his personal car is parked

00:23:32.726 --> 00:23:41.578
- there. And the signage, he said he doesn't want any signage, which he would be allowed to have. OK,

00:23:41.578 --> 00:23:50.430
- so this next question, I guess, is probably for our attorney. Is this email that was sent to Denise

00:23:50.430 --> 00:23:53.086
- from Tim Lang describing what

00:23:54.818 --> 00:24:03.024
- he's going to do, is that considered a commitment under the? It would be considered an offer on his

00:24:03.024 --> 00:24:11.311
- part to meet certain conditions and you could make those conditions that he's offered a condition of

00:24:11.311 --> 00:24:12.542
- your approval.

00:24:12.930 --> 00:24:19.762
- or you can incorporate by reference his email. If the board's inclined to grant this, I would specifically

00:24:19.762 --> 00:24:26.338
- list the conditions, like the hours by appointment only, no employees, just so it's crystal clear. And

00:24:26.338 --> 00:24:32.914
- the reason I mention that, because it says there will be no signage. Correct. If he's agreeing to give

00:24:32.914 --> 00:24:39.362
- that up, he's negotiated with you in advance on that. So yes, that's a condition that you can impose

00:24:39.362 --> 00:24:41.150
- as a condition of approval.

00:24:41.442 --> 00:24:53.601
- So basically, this is like any other home-based business that would be allowed in an R1 zone. It just

00:24:53.601 --> 00:25:05.760
- involves firearms. Not yet. Not yet. We come to the public term and eventually. Thank you. So Denise,

00:25:05.760 --> 00:25:08.382
- can you answer how we

00:25:09.154 --> 00:25:16.668
- how we basically got the cart before the horse here. In other words, how did we end up with the vault

00:25:16.668 --> 00:25:24.181
- before we get to needing the special exception? Or should the petitioner answer that? Well, he didn't

00:25:24.181 --> 00:25:31.621
- own the property at the time, and plus it's a building issue versus a zoning issue. So we could have

00:25:31.621 --> 00:25:38.398
- kept just his own firearms in there and not had a business. And nobody would ever know. OK.

00:25:39.746 --> 00:25:48.272
- When the prior owner, we talked about it, he was building it, and he needed to sell his property. So

00:25:48.272 --> 00:25:56.545
- I said it had to be an addition to the house to be a home-based business. So he built the garage,

00:25:56.545 --> 00:26:05.325
- and Mr. Lang conveyed he needed additional car storage. I think he has some toys. And so then the vault

00:26:05.325 --> 00:26:09.630
- would be in the back. And so that's how we waited.

00:26:09.922 --> 00:26:18.295
- for the sale to happen and then Mr. Lang contacted us to see how he went about having his home-based

00:26:18.295 --> 00:26:26.916
- business. Okay, so part of the home-based business regulations state that no mechanical equipment shall

00:26:26.916 --> 00:26:35.371
- be used and it's already illegal to discharge a firearm within the town limits. And I would point out

00:26:35.371 --> 00:26:37.278
- that the town does not

00:26:37.698 --> 00:26:46.232
- enforce homeowner association regulations. That's a civil issue and not part of the town's authority.

00:26:46.232 --> 00:26:54.682
- Okay, I think that's all the questions that I have of Denise. Does anybody else have any for Denise?

00:26:54.682 --> 00:27:03.384
- So the structure was built prior to Tim owning the property? Yes. With the intent of running a business

00:27:03.384 --> 00:27:06.814
- out of it? Yes. Thank you. Anybody else?

00:27:08.162 --> 00:27:16.200
- Okay, let's hear from the petitioner. And while he's getting up, I will point out that when we do open

00:27:16.200 --> 00:27:24.004
- the floor for public comment, each speaker is allowed three minutes to speak. You come in, you sign

00:27:24.004 --> 00:27:32.432
- up at the podium on the sign in sheet. You get your three minutes with a maximum of 30 minutes for everyone

00:27:32.432 --> 00:27:36.958
- altogether. If we feel that's not enough, we can add more

00:27:37.570 --> 00:28:00.416
- time for more people, but each person is limited to three minutes. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

00:28:00.416 --> 00:28:03.614
- Good evening.

00:28:05.154 --> 00:28:11.606
- My name is Tim Lang, and I wanted to give you a little bit of background information before we answer

00:28:11.606 --> 00:28:17.994
- or field some of the questions concerning the home business. So I am the owner, sole proprietor, and

00:28:17.994 --> 00:28:24.319
- only operator for this business. I've never had any employees in the five years I've been operating

00:28:24.319 --> 00:28:30.960
- since 2010, October. So I moved to Bloomington, Indiana in 2005 to work at NSWC Crane. I've been married

00:28:30.960 --> 00:28:32.478
- for 27 years to Serena.

00:28:33.186 --> 00:28:39.569
- I have twin 13-year-old boys, sons Christian and Jackson. I've spent most of my professional career

00:28:39.569 --> 00:28:45.952
- serving our country as a U.S. Marine, a duty civilian, GS-15, and now a defense contractor as chief

00:28:45.952 --> 00:28:52.335
- engineer. I've held the top secret clearance at least half of my professional career. I've deployed

00:28:52.335 --> 00:28:58.782
- all over the world to include eight months in Afghanistan 2010. Let's see, I enjoy hunting, fishing,

00:28:58.914 --> 00:29:06.678
- golf and most outdoor activities with my family. I'm very involved with my some sports teams. I've coached

00:29:06.678 --> 00:29:14.152
- them in football, basketball, baseball. I'm also a licensed drone pilot, part 107 certified. So I want

00:29:14.152 --> 00:29:21.408
- to talk about a little bit of how the standard operating practices when I sell a firearm. So number

00:29:21.408 --> 00:29:28.446
- one, I first get a requirement to buy or build a firearm via text message, email, or phone call.

00:29:29.250 --> 00:29:36.374
- I then order the firearm or parts from a wholesale distributor based on availability. The firearm is

00:29:36.374 --> 00:29:43.920
- then shipped to my house via FedEx, UPS, or USPS. A signature is required. Upon receipt, I log the firearm

00:29:43.920 --> 00:29:50.973
- information in my FFL disposition book. Every FFL is required to have a FFL disposition book. Every

00:29:50.973 --> 00:29:58.238
- single transaction that I do has to go in this book. So in the 261 months that I've had this business,

00:29:58.658 --> 00:30:05.889
- I have 242 transactions. So that is less than one transaction a week. You can do the quick math, right?

00:30:05.889 --> 00:30:13.050
- I just wanted to clarify that I have very low volume. So everyone understands that I am not a gun shop

00:30:13.050 --> 00:30:20.628
- that's gonna have high volume. I'm not gonna have increased commercial throughput. That is not my intention.

00:30:20.628 --> 00:30:27.998
- I don't want people at my house. That's not what I'm looking to do, right? This is a small home business.

00:30:28.802 --> 00:30:36.213
- To continue, I notify the customer to come and pick up the firearm again by appointment. When they arrive,

00:30:36.213 --> 00:30:43.347
- I have a customer fill out a standard ATF form 4473. This is the form right here. After they fill this

00:30:43.347 --> 00:30:50.689
- form out, I then conduct a required FBI background check via NICS. Everyone has to pass an FBI background

00:30:50.689 --> 00:30:58.238
- check if you are an FFL license holder. If I do a private to private sale, which I don't because I'm an FFL,

00:30:58.722 --> 00:31:04.102
- But if anyone in here is a private owner, they don't have to do an FBI background check. They simply

00:31:04.102 --> 00:31:09.747
- just sell the weapon to the other person. But me as a licensed FFL, I am required to do an FBI background

00:31:09.747 --> 00:31:15.180
- check and every single one that has been through this book has passed. If they don't pass, they don't

00:31:15.180 --> 00:31:20.879
- get the weapon. So if they didn't pass the background check, I then log the firearm out of the disposition

00:31:20.879 --> 00:31:26.046
- book and the customer leaves my home with the firearm. The whole process takes about 10 minutes.

00:31:26.146 --> 00:31:33.159
- Again, if they do not pass the background check, they do not receive the firearm. To date, this has

00:31:33.159 --> 00:31:40.242
- never happened, given that most of my customers that I work with have security clearances for the US

00:31:40.242 --> 00:31:47.325
- government. Bottom line, I don't sell to criminals. Safety concerns for the neighborhood. I keep all

00:31:47.325 --> 00:31:53.566
- of my guns locked up in a secure safe. No one has access to anyone except my wife and I.

00:31:54.530 --> 00:32:00.483
- And I initially met Chuck and Harvey, and I had them build a secure space with a 1,000-pound vault door

00:32:00.483 --> 00:32:06.206
- to include steel reinforced walls. The room will also have a 24-hour video surveillance camera, ADT

00:32:06.206 --> 00:32:12.216
- professionally installed both inside and out. And I would have this place regardless if I had a business

00:32:12.216 --> 00:32:17.997
- or not for my personal collection. I do not keep an inventory for my business. Every gun in my vault

00:32:17.997 --> 00:32:23.720
- room is my gun. If you look at my disposition book, and I'm willing to pass this around if you want

00:32:23.720 --> 00:32:24.350
- to see it,

00:32:24.738 --> 00:32:30.177
- you'll see that everything out, there's no open dispositions. So that means I don't have any guns from

00:32:30.177 --> 00:32:35.457
- any customers that are sitting in there other than one person who ordered something five months ago

00:32:35.457 --> 00:32:40.843
- and then got deployed for the Navy. So I don't keep inventory for my gun business at all. There'll be

00:32:40.843 --> 00:32:46.124
- no additional traffic tied to my business as I don't have hours of operation. I'm a trained firearm

00:32:46.124 --> 00:32:51.457
- specialist. I've been to countless firearm courses. I've worked as a range safety officer at Bedford

00:32:51.457 --> 00:32:52.830
- Contingent Shooting Range

00:32:53.442 --> 00:32:58.957
- different business, I'm also a Marine Corps veteran. Why did I move to Ellisville? I wanted my boys

00:32:58.957 --> 00:33:04.638
- to live in a smaller, tighter community, and I wanted them to go to Edgewood schools. I wanted a house

00:33:04.638 --> 00:33:10.208
- with nicer finishings, more garage space, and a neighborhood that was good for my kids to play with.

00:33:10.208 --> 00:33:15.723
- Previously, we lived on the south side, about 15 minutes south, and unfortunately, they didn't have

00:33:15.723 --> 00:33:21.403
- the access to ride their bike in different places, so we wanted better schools, and I believe Edgewood

00:33:21.403 --> 00:33:22.782
- provides better schools.

00:33:24.418 --> 00:33:31.076
- Before I bought the house, when touring the home, I asked Chuck Short and Andy if the HOA would have

00:33:31.076 --> 00:33:37.668
- issues with running my business for my home. They said it wouldn't be an issue. Chuck Short is also

00:33:37.668 --> 00:33:44.392
- one of the two signature authorities on the HOA covenant, so I figured he would probably be a knowing

00:33:44.392 --> 00:33:51.445
- authority. That makes sense, right? Lastly, there's a covenant section citing 3.03, and it says commercial

00:33:51.445 --> 00:33:53.950
- uses no lot, residence, or structure.

00:33:54.210 --> 00:34:00.636
- or any partner of erected any lot should be used for industry, business, trade, or commercial purposes.

00:34:00.636 --> 00:34:07.062
- Withstanding the foregoing in-home professional pursuits without employees shall be permissible so long

00:34:07.062 --> 00:34:12.931
- as any such in-home professional pursuit does not generate significant traffic to the division

00:34:12.931 --> 00:34:19.296
- or subdivision. Also withstanding the foregoing declarant may establish and maintain from time to time

00:34:19.296 --> 00:34:23.806
- a model home or model homes in the developmental period. My response is,

00:34:23.970 --> 00:34:32.588
- How am I any different than a cupcake baker, a real estate agent, a professional trainer, or massage

00:34:32.588 --> 00:34:41.376
- therapist? That's my question. So that's all I have. I'm willing to accept questions now. Does anybody

00:34:41.376 --> 00:34:50.249
- from the Planning Commission have questions for Mr. Lang? You're not gonna have any guns? You said like

00:34:50.249 --> 00:34:53.918
- a showroom type of situation? No showroom.

00:34:54.786 --> 00:35:00.693
- No, I have a ballroom and I have guns in my ballroom, but that is not a show up and walk in. That's

00:35:00.693 --> 00:35:06.660
- not a thing. It's not like US defense down the road where you just walk in and look at a gun. That's

00:35:06.660 --> 00:35:12.626
- not the case. The guns in the vault are yours? Correct. Every single one of them. That's wrong, man.

00:35:12.626 --> 00:35:18.770
- Anybody else? It says manufacturing, I assume, because the gun comes in pieces. You putting it together

00:35:18.770 --> 00:35:22.846
- would be considered the manufacturing department? Yeah, for example,

00:35:23.394 --> 00:35:28.753
- If somebody wants a very specific AR build, and they want to use it for hunting hogs down in Texas,

00:35:28.753 --> 00:35:34.111
- and they'll come to me and say, I need a thermal site. I want this particular caliber. I want it to

00:35:34.111 --> 00:35:39.470
- be this color. I want this handle. And I go out and I buy the parts. The parts are shipped to me. I

00:35:39.470 --> 00:35:44.829
- put it together. I have no machining equipment. I'm not a machinist. I'm an engineer, but I'm not a

00:35:44.829 --> 00:35:50.294
- machinist. I don't own the lathe or mill or any of that kind of stuff. That's not the intent. It's me

00:35:50.294 --> 00:35:51.902
- putting together, assembling,

00:35:52.386 --> 00:35:58.450
- And then they, I sell a firearm. And you're not manufacturing or making ammunitions or anything like

00:35:58.450 --> 00:36:04.454
- that either? Not for sale, no. Okay. I have one other question, David. Does any government agencies

00:36:04.454 --> 00:36:10.578
- come in and check you over? ATF does. They had the right to show up at any time and inspect my, so in

00:36:10.578 --> 00:36:16.702
- the five years prior, they never showed up to inspect, but they can literally call me and inspect any

00:36:16.702 --> 00:36:22.046
- time. Okay, thank you. So it's very critical that this book right here is 100% accurate.

00:36:22.402 --> 00:36:29.697
- Because if they show up and they say, hey, where's this firearm? And I say, I don't know. Well,

00:36:29.697 --> 00:36:37.980
- guess what? I'm in trouble at that point. So this is kept extremely, extremely important that it's accurate.

00:36:37.980 --> 00:36:45.883
- OK, any more questions? OK, so what we're going to do next is we're going to allow public comment. Then

00:36:45.883 --> 00:36:52.190
- you can come back up and answer anything that you want to answer after they speak.

00:36:52.322 --> 00:37:09.570
- sounds good okay so we're ready for public comment three minutes maximum come on up and sign in and

00:37:09.570 --> 00:37:15.262
- tell us what you want to tell us

00:37:20.162 --> 00:37:35.799
- Denise, are you keeping time? Is one of you keeping time? OK. You can say a lot in three minutes if

00:37:35.799 --> 00:37:45.182
- you don't repeat yourself a lot. OK. No problem. I'll wait.

00:37:54.818 --> 00:38:04.119
- There we go. There you go. Okay. Good evening. I'm going to. Good evening. I'm Tom Hebdom. I'm speaking

00:38:04.119 --> 00:38:13.420
- on behalf of the Advisory Committee of Charles Style Manor and its 75 concerned homeowners. And I thank

00:38:13.420 --> 00:38:22.453
- you for your attention. I want to address five concerns. The distinction between the home occupation

00:38:22.453 --> 00:38:24.510
- and the home business.

00:38:24.770 --> 00:38:30.551
- Traffic, property values, safety, and compliance. First, home occupation versus home business.

00:38:30.551 --> 00:38:37.184
- The application describes TLS as a home-based business. There is an important distinction. A home occupation

00:38:37.184 --> 00:38:43.756
- typically involves a professional working from his home office, such as an attorney or accountant providing

00:38:43.756 --> 00:38:49.963
- the service. A retail business involves exchanging product or goods. TLS proposed to operate a retail

00:38:49.963 --> 00:38:53.310
- business from a garage, not a traditional home office.

00:38:53.794 --> 00:39:00.013
- Allowing this use would set a precedence for other commercial operations such as furniture repairs,

00:39:00.013 --> 00:39:06.543
- bakery goods, or other similar businesses in our residential neighborhood. Second, traffic. Triple Crown

00:39:06.543 --> 00:39:13.197
- Drive already carries considerable traffic. Adding any customer visits or deliveries increases the traffic

00:39:13.197 --> 00:39:19.602
- in a neighborhood disruption. Third is property values. Homeowners purchase their properties expecting

00:39:19.602 --> 00:39:23.582
- residential community and introducing a retail firearm business

00:39:23.778 --> 00:39:30.202
- or any retail business could affect the desirability and marketability of the surrounding homes. Protecting

00:39:30.202 --> 00:39:36.269
- homeowners' investments and their residential character should be an important consideration for this

00:39:36.269 --> 00:39:42.217
- board. A residential neighborhood should not gradually become a collection of commercial operations

00:39:42.217 --> 00:39:48.640
- through individual exceptions. Fourth is safety and security. A firearm business presents security concerns

00:39:48.640 --> 00:39:51.198
- beyond those of an ordinary home business.

00:39:51.778 --> 00:39:59.067
- The term vault is used loosely. The only secured area of the structure is the vault door and the interior

00:39:59.067 --> 00:40:06.357
- wall. The three exterior walls are normal construction material. Finally, compliance, the most important.

00:40:06.357 --> 00:40:13.784
- If the board approves this petition, what official monitoring will the city provide to ensure that business

00:40:13.784 --> 00:40:20.798
- operates within the limits and conditions presented to this board? Who will verify future compliance?

00:40:21.346 --> 00:40:27.544
- The real issue is not Mr. Lang's business. It's whether any retail business is appropriate within the

00:40:27.544 --> 00:40:33.620
- established residential subdivision. We believe this proposed business, as well as other commercial

00:40:33.620 --> 00:40:39.696
- home businesses, is inconsistent with the residential character of our community. Please understand

00:40:39.696 --> 00:40:43.646
- I'm not speaking as an individual homeowner, which I will later.

00:40:43.778 --> 00:40:51.654
- I am speaking on behalf of the Charles Salmanner Advisory Committee and representing the concern of

00:40:51.654 --> 00:40:59.530
- 75 homeowners who respectfully ask this board to deny the special exception petition. Thank you for

00:40:59.530 --> 00:41:01.342
- your time. Okay, next.

00:41:10.274 --> 00:41:19.074
- Before I start, I just have a question about something that was mentioned previously. Is that OK to?

00:41:19.074 --> 00:41:28.223
- OK. I'm John Spoonmore, and I live in Charleston Manor. But I have a question about the R1 zoning versus

00:41:28.223 --> 00:41:37.023
- the R3 zoning. Could you go back over that, explain that? So single-family residential, such as what

00:41:37.023 --> 00:41:39.550
- your neighborhood is, is R1.

00:41:40.674 --> 00:41:48.934
- When that was annexed, it was annexed as R3 because they wanted to put in apartments. They didn't develop

00:41:48.934 --> 00:41:56.805
- it as R3. They developed it as R1. So really, in reality, it operates as a single-family residential

00:41:56.805 --> 00:42:03.974
- neighborhood, not an apartment complex. An apartment complex is R1 or R3? R3 is apartments.

00:42:03.974 --> 00:42:07.870
- R1 is single-family residential. Okay. Thank you.

00:42:10.242 --> 00:42:17.122
- Okay, my name is John Spoonmore and I live in Charleston Manor. I'm here to oppose the request for an

00:42:17.122 --> 00:42:23.867
- exception that would allow retail business to operate out of our home in our neighborhood, which is

00:42:23.867 --> 00:42:30.814
- zoned residential only. This request is not simply about what the applicant wants to sell. It is about

00:42:30.814 --> 00:42:38.099
- introducing retail activity into a subdivision that was intentionally designed and contractually reinforced

00:42:38.099 --> 00:42:40.190
- to be exclusively residential.

00:42:40.962 --> 00:42:48.883
- Our subdivision's HOA covenants clearly prohibit commercial or retail operations. Every homeowner agreed

00:42:48.883 --> 00:42:56.578
- to those covenants when purchasing property. They reflect the expectations we rely on, quiet streets,

00:42:56.578 --> 00:43:04.273
- predictable residential use, and no customer-based activity, while the BZA is not required to enforce

00:43:04.273 --> 00:43:10.686
- HOA rules. Those covenants are strong evidence of the community's intended character

00:43:10.914 --> 00:43:18.381
- and the commitments made by every resident. The applicant, Mr. Lang, and thank you for your service,

00:43:18.381 --> 00:43:25.996
- Mr. Lang, proposes an appointment-based retail business. But appointment-based retail is still retail.

00:43:25.996 --> 00:43:33.463
- It still means customers arriving at the home, transactions occurring on site, inventory stored in a

00:43:33.463 --> 00:43:39.230
- residential structure. This is commercial activity, and it directly conflicts

00:43:39.458 --> 00:43:46.579
- with both the zoning ordinance and the HOA covenants that define our neighborhood. Just as concerning,

00:43:46.579 --> 00:43:53.700
- maybe more so, the residents were not informed of this plan. We learned about it only after the appeal

00:43:53.700 --> 00:43:59.992
- was filed. A zoning exception that affects an entire subdivision should never move forward

00:43:59.992 --> 00:44:05.246
- without transparency and community awareness throughout the entire process.

00:44:07.426 --> 00:44:16.014
- Granting this exception would also set a precedent. If retail activity is allowed once in a residential-only

00:44:16.014 --> 00:44:24.050
- subdivision, especially one with covenants prohibiting it, future applicants will cite this decision.

00:44:24.050 --> 00:44:32.086
- The stability of our zoning depends on consistent enforcement, and the integrity of our HOA covenants

00:44:32.086 --> 00:44:36.734
- depends on not undermining them through zoning exceptions.

00:44:37.794 --> 00:44:45.039
- There are many commercially zoned areas of Monroe County where this business could operate without conflict.

00:44:45.039 --> 00:44:51.620
- There is no hardship here, only convenience for the applicant at the expense of the neighborhood's

00:44:51.620 --> 00:44:58.865
- established residential character. For these reasons, I respectfully ask the board to uphold the residential

00:44:58.865 --> 00:45:03.518
- only zoning and deny this request. Thank you very much for your time.

00:45:11.138 --> 00:45:16.580
- Hello. First, thank you, Mr. Lang, for your service. My name is Adam Mickey. I'm a father of three young

00:45:16.580 --> 00:45:21.815
- children and a resident of the Charlestown Manor subdivision. I'm going to be intentional to explain

00:45:21.815 --> 00:45:27.257
- my opposition to this request with no regard for the nature of the business. Rather, it's based on three

00:45:27.257 --> 00:45:32.700
- critical points. Charlestown Manor consists of single-family homes filled with wonderful families. Under

00:45:32.700 --> 00:45:38.142
- Eldsfield Town Code Chapter 152, R3 zoning exists to protect neighborhoods from commercial encroachment.

00:45:38.242 --> 00:45:43.690
- Introducing any added traffic associated with any commercial business operations out of a home directly

00:45:43.690 --> 00:45:49.086
- compromises the integrity of our zoning laws. Current homeowners moved into this neighborhood with the

00:45:49.086 --> 00:45:54.430
- knowledge that home-based businesses are prohibited. The same is true for Mr. Lang. If there are four

00:45:54.430 --> 00:45:59.773
- businesses operating out of the neighborhood today, I would be here to oppose them just the same. The

00:45:59.773 --> 00:46:05.117
- second critical piece is increased traffic. There are 32 single-family homes between the neighborhood

00:46:05.117 --> 00:46:07.422
- entrance and 4504 North Triple Crown Drive.

00:46:07.586 --> 00:46:13.841
- Triple Crown Drive is a narrow, local residential street built exclusively to handle neighborhood traffic.

00:46:13.841 --> 00:46:19.745
- Forcing business-related traffic past 32 residential doorsteps will cause unnecessary congestion and

00:46:19.745 --> 00:46:25.766
- possible safety issues. The petitioner claims that the business is not anticipated to create excessive

00:46:25.766 --> 00:46:31.670
- traffic. No business can guarantee a permanent cap on any amount of customer traffic. The only thing

00:46:31.670 --> 00:46:36.990
- better than minimal customer traffic is zero. My third critical point is childhood safety.

00:46:37.154 --> 00:46:42.470
- Most concerning of all, there is a designated school bus stop situated along the direct path from the

00:46:42.470 --> 00:46:47.942
- neighborhood entrance to Mr. Lang's house. Charlestown Manor is full of young children who play in their

00:46:47.942 --> 00:46:53.362
- yards, ride bicycles, walk the sidewalks, wait at this bus stop daily, and walk home from this bus stop

00:46:53.362 --> 00:46:58.731
- daily. Introducing foreign traffic directly into the path of our children creates an unacceptable risk

00:46:58.731 --> 00:47:03.838
- to childhood safety that is avoidable simply by upholding the zoning guidelines that exist today.

00:47:04.834 --> 00:47:11.371
- A commercial business belongs in an appropriately zoned commercial district, not deeply embedded in

00:47:11.371 --> 00:47:17.909
- a subdivision. I'd question why any special exception should ever be made for the current R3 zoning

00:47:17.909 --> 00:47:24.642
- guidelines. For these reasons, I urge the board to uphold the existing R3 zoning guidelines and reject

00:47:24.642 --> 00:47:29.022
- the use variance for this petition. Thank you for your time. Next.

00:47:32.386 --> 00:47:38.014
- Good evening. My name is Michael Doherty. I've submitted my statement and questions for already to all

00:47:38.014 --> 00:47:43.587
- three emails from Ms. Line. So I would ask that if my time extends that you take time to answer those

00:47:43.587 --> 00:47:49.216
- questions that are submitted, I believe in the record already. First, I'd like to remind the committee

00:47:49.216 --> 00:47:54.953
- and correct me if I'm wrong, Ms. Attorney, that if this is an R3 zoning, that just because the developer

00:47:54.953 --> 00:48:01.182
- hasn't used the space already for R3 zoning buildings does not mean they cannot use the remaining space to do so.

00:48:03.618 --> 00:48:11.044
- Is that correct? So he could use the additional space to build apartments if he desired, as it is owned

00:48:11.044 --> 00:48:18.255
- for an R3. I think he could. Correct. So I'd like you to keep that in mind. Good evening. My name is

00:48:18.255 --> 00:48:25.681
- Michael Doherty. I live at 4636 North Kelly Met Court in Charlestown Manor. I'm a small business owner,

00:48:25.681 --> 00:48:28.894
- a firearm owner, and a local area physician.

00:48:29.314 --> 00:48:34.932
- I want to be clear, I'm not here to speak against Mr. Lang personally or against lawful firearm ownership.

00:48:34.932 --> 00:48:40.340
- I'm here because the petition asked the board to authorize commercial firearms dealer and manufacturer

00:48:40.340 --> 00:48:45.591
- in a residential neighborhood, and I don't believe the records before you supports the findings the

00:48:45.591 --> 00:48:51.052
- board is required to make. First, the order of events that you brought up. The staff report states that

00:48:51.052 --> 00:48:56.460
- on July 21st, the previous owner, Andy Lynch, whose staff says is employed by the builder, applied for

00:48:56.460 --> 00:48:58.718
- a permit for a garage addition, step back.

00:48:58.882 --> 00:49:03.917
- Sure. Applied for a permit for a garage addition with a vault to house this business. That

00:49:03.917 --> 00:49:09.727
- permit application, number 5037, lists the work as a new construction that does not mention any business

00:49:09.727 --> 00:49:15.592
- use. The addition was built by Bardee Builders, which staff identifies as partly owned by our subdivision

00:49:15.592 --> 00:49:21.180
- developer. The home was then sold to the petitioner a month later. Section 3.1C of the UDO calls for

00:49:21.180 --> 00:49:25.662
- compliance with use standards to be verified before a building permit is issued.

00:49:25.762 --> 00:49:31.476
- Here the structure was permitted and built first and the board is now being asked to approve the use

00:49:31.476 --> 00:49:37.416
- after the fact. You're being hoodwinked. Anybody could come in here and request before the sale of their

00:49:37.416 --> 00:49:43.582
- property to build an addition for a business that you would possibly not want to accept a special exception.

00:49:44.418 --> 00:49:49.794
- Second, the business is described as a dealer and manufacturer, but every staff finding addresses only

00:49:49.794 --> 00:49:55.013
- sales. Section 3.6 prohibits mechanical equipment, though he has stated here today, there's nothing

00:49:55.013 --> 00:50:00.441
- in the staff recommendations or other submission materials that I could find that record what materials

00:50:00.441 --> 00:50:06.078
- are manufactured that would happen on site, what equipment will be used, and what materials will be stored.

00:50:06.818 --> 00:50:13.210
- The third, the staff report itself has gaps. The criteria listed states use variance, though this is

00:50:13.210 --> 00:50:19.729
- a special exception. Criteria four and five are identical. The reports claim six criteria are met, but

00:50:19.729 --> 00:50:26.185
- list five. I'm gonna get to the base of what I'm asking. I'm asking at minimum you give a continuance

00:50:26.185 --> 00:50:32.830
- because the petitioner has the burden of providing, approving compliance, not the town or the neighbors.

00:50:32.930 --> 00:50:38.841
- However, if you do so, decline. I have a specific that I did submit conditions of approval that I would

00:50:38.841 --> 00:50:44.581
- ask that you consider. I have a copy that are spelled out that I'd like to, if it wasn't printed out

00:50:44.581 --> 00:50:50.321
- for you, that you consider those conditions. If you'd like, feel free to read. I don't wanna take up

00:50:50.321 --> 00:50:56.118
- more of my time, but those are the conditions I suggest, mostly of which are already submitted by the

00:50:56.118 --> 00:50:58.846
- petitioner. The last one would be that this is,

00:50:59.234 --> 00:51:08.365
- if you make these conditions of your approval, that they be subject to annual review. Thank you very

00:51:08.365 --> 00:51:17.677
- much. Next. Thank you. Is there a way to put that map up at this house? The what? The map. The old map

00:51:17.677 --> 00:51:26.718
- you had up there. This? No, the whole overhead map. Oh. Yeah, right there. My name's Dwayne Bishop.

00:51:28.706 --> 00:51:38.616
- This is where this garage is at. That's where I live at. Closest to that vault than anyone. Dwayne,

00:51:38.616 --> 00:51:49.021
- D-W-A-Y-N-E. And I only met him once. I walked over after I heard about all this. I looked at his garage

00:51:49.021 --> 00:51:57.246
- and vault. I didn't even know what was going on. To me, I have no problem with it.

00:51:58.658 --> 00:52:05.103
- I know when you assemble firearms, you don't need machinery. A screwdriver is about the most you need.

00:52:05.103 --> 00:52:11.359
- And from what I see, it looked safe and secure, probably more than would be if it wasn't there with

00:52:11.359 --> 00:52:17.616
- video cameras and stuff. I mean, it's a vault. About the traffic area, I've known people who's done

00:52:17.616 --> 00:52:23.998
- this before. If you're worried about the traffic area, there's these no parking signs all up and down

00:52:23.998 --> 00:52:26.814
- the street with cars parked underneath them.

00:52:27.394 --> 00:52:34.270
- And I drive in the morning and swerve around them. I don't care. I don't care that kids drive out or

00:52:34.270 --> 00:52:41.146
- people have their quad runners. There's a lot of exceptions made in this. Is this because it's guns?

00:52:41.146 --> 00:52:47.953
- Would they do this if they were selling Mary Kay? I don't know. But to me, it ain't gonna affect my

00:52:47.953 --> 00:52:51.902
- value. And I have no problem with it. That's all I'd say.

00:52:54.978 --> 00:53:01.818
- okay now i'm not sure we've never had this come up before but you've already spoken you've already spoken

00:53:01.818 --> 00:53:08.271
- once as the advisory committee i'm speaking as a resident okay well make it quick i'll just make it

00:53:08.271 --> 00:53:14.852
- really short i'm sure you realize i've been involved in commissions before and this is a rather large

00:53:14.852 --> 00:53:21.886
- turnout i think i'm not familiar with ellisville i was in my original hometown but i would just like to know

00:53:22.050 --> 00:53:28.285
- How many of the people who may not be comfortable to speak in the audience now might be from Charlestown

00:53:28.285 --> 00:53:34.341
- Manor, and if they might raise their hands so that we have an idea. Okay, so I think even though only

00:53:34.341 --> 00:53:40.279
- five of us spoke, it could be possibly some of these people are concerned about the introduction of

00:53:40.279 --> 00:53:46.395
- any kind, and not Mr. DeWine's, but any kind of commercial or retail business to be established in the

00:53:46.395 --> 00:53:48.830
- community that they've chose to live in.

00:53:49.090 --> 00:53:57.893
- I appreciate the second opportunity to speak to the board. My name is Rick Johnson. I'm a resident of

00:53:57.893 --> 00:54:07.300
- Charleston Manor. I have a family, five kids. We did so under the impression of everything in that covenants

00:54:07.300 --> 00:54:16.621
- and under good faith that there wouldn't be businesses and I didn't even think that that would be something

00:54:16.621 --> 00:54:18.174
- that we'd have to

00:54:19.074 --> 00:54:31.635
- consider, I believe you, I believe that Chuck did tell you that it would be fine. Dude lied to you,

00:54:31.635 --> 00:54:44.195
- he lied to a lot of us. Sorry man, honestly, no issue with guns or just not in my neighborhood with

00:54:44.195 --> 00:54:47.838
- five kids, okay? That's all.

00:54:48.034 --> 00:54:57.739
- I serve too, I respect you serving too. I really hope, I don't know what your purview is as far as if

00:54:57.739 --> 00:55:07.824
- it's just by the law or if our opinions actually hold sway. We live there, I respect the staff's opinion.

00:55:07.824 --> 00:55:16.958
- I'm not willing to bet my kids' wellbeing or my family's wellbeing on it, because I live there.

00:55:17.954 --> 00:55:32.089
- And that's what I have to say. Mr. Lang, did you want to say anything else? Sure. So I heard a lot about

00:55:32.089 --> 00:55:46.494
- increased traffic to the neighborhood, right? And I understand that being concerned. A lot of little kids.

00:55:46.722 --> 00:55:53.729
- Again, I've got kids too, so I understand that. But the previous five years that I've operated from

00:55:53.729 --> 00:56:01.087
- my home and my prior residence shows a very low volume, less than one per week. I don't intend to change

00:56:01.087 --> 00:56:08.585
- any of that. Again, I have a full-time job. I work 50 hours a week at my regular job. This is not intended

00:56:08.585 --> 00:56:15.102
- for me to be a full-time business. It's by appointment only, the additional proposed traffic

00:56:15.234 --> 00:56:23.126
- will be non-existent, you will not, you'll probably see more Amazon deliveries to other houses than

00:56:23.126 --> 00:56:31.017
- you would at my house. And that's the honest truth, right? I really don't anticipate the additional

00:56:31.017 --> 00:56:39.303
- traffic that you wouldn't probably even notice, honestly. Okay, thank you. Okay, seeing. Is there anyone

00:56:39.303 --> 00:56:43.486
- from joining remotely who has an interview to speak?

00:56:50.530 --> 00:57:02.411
- They're going to ask if anyone remotely has anything to speak. Just a minute. I was having technical

00:57:02.411 --> 00:57:14.292
- difficulties earlier. So you can ask if anybody remotely would like to speak. Do any of their people

00:57:14.292 --> 00:57:18.174
- want to speak for three minutes?

00:57:20.514 --> 00:57:41.745
- I don't know what. I'm OK. I'm OK. I'm just listening. Thank you. OK. I don't hear anybody. Good evening.

00:57:41.745 --> 00:57:45.150
- I'm Serena Lang.

00:57:45.890 --> 00:57:53.762
- I will address a couple of things that I've heard here tonight. I know it's not about the HOA, but this

00:57:53.762 --> 00:58:01.936
- HOA covenant is not as strict as I've heard it made out to be. I did not sign or even see the HOA covenants

00:58:01.936 --> 00:58:09.732
- until several weeks, maybe even a month after we purchased the home when my neighbor emailed it to me.

00:58:09.732 --> 00:58:14.046
- So that is that. There are also many exceptions to that.

00:58:14.530 --> 00:58:22.626
- I've asked twice to be given an account to this HOA so I could pay dues and read the covenants for myself

00:58:22.626 --> 00:58:30.416
- and get information to which I have heard nothing in about three months. The second thing is traffic.

00:58:30.416 --> 00:58:38.130
- My neighbors have nannies, house cleaners, Amazon, Domino's at least four times a week. I mean, they

00:58:38.130 --> 00:58:42.942
- have significantly more traffic than my house would ever have.

00:58:43.426 --> 00:58:52.514
- Live here. I don't want strange men in my house. I don't want people Driving up my driveway that I don't

00:58:52.514 --> 00:59:01.342
- know. That's a strict That's a hard line for me and my family. Okay, this is not something that we've

00:59:01.342 --> 00:59:06.622
- ever done more than a hobby for Tim and like he said he is a

00:59:07.330 --> 00:59:16.899
- Trained, he is experienced. My children are hunter, firearm, safety, whatever. They've taken the hunter

00:59:16.899 --> 00:59:26.193
- safety class. We do not play with guns at our home. We respect them. I'm also a Marine. So we've had

00:59:26.193 --> 00:59:34.750
- a wealth of firearms practice and handling. They're not toys to us. So that's another thing.

00:59:34.850 --> 00:59:44.950
- my top concern with my children. They do not have access to any firearms, any ammo, nothing. So your

00:59:44.950 --> 00:59:55.550
- kids would never either, unless they break into the back of my vault. Yes, so that's it. Traffic, safety,

00:59:55.550 --> 00:59:57.150
- HOA. Thank you.

01:00:05.666 --> 01:00:15.061
- Good evening. My name is Robert Thomas. I do not live in Charleston. I live in Centennial Park. I'm

01:00:15.061 --> 01:00:24.738
- currently under contract with Chuck to build a home. It will be my retirement home in the subdivision.

01:00:24.738 --> 01:00:35.166
- So my biggest concern is about property values. The house that I'm under contract to build is not inexpensive.

01:00:35.458 --> 01:00:45.507
- And I'm just curious about what type of analysis you used to conclude that this business would have

01:00:45.507 --> 01:00:55.557
- no impact on property values. I found Mr. Lane's statement to be very persuasive. I believe that he

01:00:55.557 --> 01:01:04.702
- is an honorable man, he's a serviceman, and his business description does sound very mild.

01:01:05.058 --> 01:01:13.368
- But my problem is I see very little criteria for deciding what is acceptable use for retail and what

01:01:13.368 --> 01:01:21.677
- isn't acceptable. I haven't heard any analysis, maybe the staff will provide some analysis about why

01:01:21.677 --> 01:01:29.905
- this business or any retail business in this residential area will have no impact on property value

01:01:29.905 --> 01:01:35.006
- safety, in particular property values. So my big concern here

01:01:35.362 --> 01:01:45.721
- is not just Mr. Lang, but what future individuals will come in and perhaps get an exception to provide

01:01:45.721 --> 01:01:56.382
- maybe a retail business that is not as not so innocuous as the one that Mr. Lang is proposing. Thank you.

01:02:11.394 --> 01:02:21.560
- Okay, well we're back to the commission. I'll make a few comments to the other commission members. As

01:02:21.560 --> 01:02:31.626
- we noted before, it's not our responsibility nor do we have the authority to enforce whatever may or

01:02:31.626 --> 01:02:39.998
- may not be the HOA covenants. If this was zoned R1 as it probably should have been,

01:02:40.130 --> 01:02:48.617
- And as it's used, this would be allowed by right and would not even require any action by us. I don't

01:02:48.617 --> 01:02:57.104
- see any significant traffic increase from this any more than anybody else's residence has. It appears

01:02:57.104 --> 01:03:06.007
- to meet all the conditions that are required for a home-based business according to our coded regulations.

01:03:06.007 --> 01:03:09.918
- If we deny it, we have to specify exactly what

01:03:10.370 --> 01:03:21.832
- those requirements have are not being met besides just feelings we have to have specific criteria and

01:03:21.832 --> 01:03:33.068
- put that in writing if we deny it so I have some when we're ready for a vote I have some conditions

01:03:33.068 --> 01:03:38.462
- of approval that I would propose which would be

01:03:39.554 --> 01:03:48.348
- reiterating what was already said in that email, mainly by appointment only Monday through Friday, maximum

01:03:48.348 --> 01:03:56.732
- of three per day, no other employees on the premises and no signage or any indication that a business

01:03:56.732 --> 01:04:05.197
- is being operated in the home. So does anybody else have any comments? He said three per day, it's one

01:04:05.197 --> 01:04:06.430
- transactional.

01:04:07.746 --> 01:04:14.052
- Okay, so you want to go with one transaction a week? I'm good with one transaction. Okay. I don't need

01:04:14.052 --> 01:04:20.359
- three days. That's not how I operate. Okay, one transaction per week. That's been my average that I've

01:04:20.359 --> 01:04:26.482
- been operating under for the past five years. Are you are you all right with the other requirements

01:04:26.482 --> 01:04:33.278
- with the other conditions? The ADT security system 24 hour surveillance? No, no, I mean, are you okay with the

01:04:33.762 --> 01:04:42.177
- By appointment only, no other employees on premises, and no signage. 100%. Between 5 PM and 7 PM. Is

01:04:42.177 --> 01:04:50.592
- that what you said, 5 PM and 7 PM? No one will show up to my house unannounced. You said no signage.

01:04:50.592 --> 01:04:59.006
- I'm curious, will there be online signage, like on Google Maps or anything like that? No, I actually

01:04:59.006 --> 01:05:03.422
- tried to do the website thing to have online orders.

01:05:03.522 --> 01:05:11.039
- It was too costly, and I didn't pay any business, so I canceled that about six months ago. OK, anybody

01:05:11.039 --> 01:05:18.410
- else from the? I have one last thing to address. There was a concern. Google searched on Master FFL.

01:05:18.410 --> 01:05:26.073
- Because when you Google my business name, Master FFL pops up with a description, and that's a nationwide

01:05:26.073 --> 01:05:31.838
- database for FFLs. And in there, there's an AI profile in there that calls out

01:05:32.802 --> 01:05:39.026
- employees, it calls out business hours, it calls out training offerings. None of that is true. I've

01:05:39.026 --> 01:05:45.624
- since then removed myself from that database, and it doesn't exist anymore. So just be aware that anybody

01:05:45.624 --> 01:05:51.849
- that Google searched Master FFL and saw that I had a profile in there, that is not real, and that's

01:05:51.849 --> 01:05:58.446
- invalid since. OK, let's get back to the board. I've got just one comment, David. Many of you have talked

01:05:58.446 --> 01:06:02.430
- about traffic. If I'm not mistaken, when I drove through there,

01:06:03.362 --> 01:06:12.842
- that development has just been opened up to another neighborhood. Yes. So your traffic is going to come

01:06:12.842 --> 01:06:22.323
- just because of having a home business there. So that's something to think about. Evidently, you people

01:06:22.323 --> 01:06:32.350
- didn't care about having more traffic coming through your neighborhood with going into the other development.

01:06:33.666 --> 01:06:43.767
- Okay, so I seriously doubt that one transaction per week is going to add an unbearable amount of traffic

01:06:43.767 --> 01:06:53.771
- in the neighborhood. So we're still with us. Anybody else have any comments, questions? Okay, well then

01:06:53.771 --> 01:07:02.814
- I'll make a motion that we approve the special exception for 4504 North Triple Crown Drive as

01:07:03.106 --> 01:07:15.738
- requested in incorporating the staff findings into the approval and noting that the business is subject

01:07:15.738 --> 01:07:29.342
- to all of our home-based business requirements. And with the addition that any activity be by appointment only,

01:07:30.242 --> 01:07:39.728
- A maximum of one transaction per week from 5 to 7 PM. No other employees on the premises and that there

01:07:39.728 --> 01:07:48.939
- be no signage or any indication that a business is being operated. In the home. I'll send it. OK, we

01:07:48.939 --> 01:07:58.334
- have a motion in a second roll call, please. David Drake, yes. Travis Conyer, yes. Pat Weslowski, yes.

01:07:58.334 --> 01:08:00.158
- Kayla Plummer, yes.

01:08:00.706 --> 01:08:11.678
- That's the vote. Yes. Okay, motion carries. Thank you. Next item on our agenda is planning department

01:08:11.678 --> 01:08:22.757
- update. Our next meeting will be December 3rd. And I'm working on third or ninth. Third. It says ninth

01:08:22.757 --> 01:08:24.478
- on here. Sorry.

01:08:31.298 --> 01:08:51.006
- wait just a minute. Let me check my calendar while they're moving to be sure. Thank you.

01:08:51.266 --> 01:09:10.167
- It's the third. Okay. No, that's plan commission on the door. Oh, yeah, this is the BCA. Well, I didn't

01:09:10.167 --> 01:09:17.982
- question it. Did I question it? Hey, guys.

01:09:18.178 --> 01:09:30.271
- It's not over yet here. We're still working. Thank you. They're in your hood. So anyway, so anyway,

01:09:30.271 --> 01:09:42.728
- I was working. I've been working on Plan Commission BZA both so I'm working on something that can come

01:09:42.728 --> 01:09:45.630
- before you for the BZA.

01:09:46.274 --> 01:09:54.698
- Um, in December, Darla's helping me with it a little bit. And, um, but right now you'll have, I anticipate

01:09:54.698 --> 01:10:02.727
- something for you. Is December 9th BZA meeting or the? BZA. BZA. Okay. Plan commission is the second,

01:10:02.727 --> 01:10:10.915
- third? Yeah. Okay. Are you putting that on your calendar, David? I already did, but I couldn't remember

01:10:10.915 --> 01:10:15.166
- what I wrote. Because he didn't come do the last one.

01:10:15.490 --> 01:10:23.922
- Yeah, I had it written down as the next Thursday for some reason. So that's all I have. Do you guys

01:10:23.922 --> 01:10:32.606
- have anything or Darla and want to thank Darla for being here? Yeah. Thank you. Oh my gosh. Planning's

01:10:32.606 --> 01:10:37.918
- the third. December 3rd? Yes. Okay, well we're adjourned then.
