I'll call to order the meeting of the Ellisville Board of Zoning Appeals for Wednesday, November 18th, 2026. Caleb, would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Yes. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Okay, the first item on our agenda is approval of the twenty twenty seven meeting dates. Yes, so before you heard the proposed twenty twenty seven. meeting dates. I believe there's only one that's outside of the normal second Wednesdays. And I'll know next year's a week here. So there's not too many outside of our normal dates. So if you review those and if you see anything you want changed, let me know. I make a motion that we accept the Board is owning a field meeting for next year, 2027. Seconded. Okay, we have a motion and a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Hearing none, motion carries. Next item is approval of the minutes from our meeting on October 14th of 2026. So moved. Second. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Hearing none, motion carries. We have no old business. We have two items of new business. The first is a petition for a variance from development standards to reduce the minimum lot area. That's a conflict of interest. The petitioner is Ozzie Lauer. Is there a conflict of interest? Do we want to have any conflict of interest? Do we want an item for tonight? I'll say something in the honor of transparency. I live in Charlestown Manor, so that's first off. Second off, the first petition that was pulled, what was it called exactly? The use variance. I was approached by representatives of Charlestown Manor's HOA. They had general questions about the BZA and the things we do and what we look for and stuff. I answered those questions to the best of my ability. I also had questions pertaining to my normal job as a firefighter. I answered those questions to the best of my ability as well. And then we just had friendly conversation and I shared my own personal opinions on the matter. So just so everyone's aware and they know that I did talk to some of the HOA members, okay? Okay, and so the 500 South Turtle Bay Creek Road. I need to disclose them. Okay. So I have an employee in my office, Mike Burns, and he's a resident of Charlestown Manor in the HOA, and because of that, he was not involved with the file, so I just wanted to disclose that. Now we're ready. Okay, so 500 South Turtle Bay Creek Road is case number BGA 26-8. Thank you. This is a petition by Ozzie Lauer of Bynum-Fanyone Associates for consideration of a variance from development standards to reduce the minimum lot area to 5,662 square feet or 0.13 acres in a residential one zoning district, subject parcels located at 500 South Turtleback Creek Road. The owners of 500 South Turtle Creek Turtleback Creek have given Township Trustee representatives by Nymphianian Associates permission to pursue the variance from development standards. Minimum lot area for low density residential district R1 is 8,000 square feet for single family residential and 10,000 square feet for other uses. Richland Township Trustee owns a parcel adjacent to 500 South Turtleback Creek Road and its use is a ball field. Richland Township Trustee is acquiring a 1.13 acre parcel from 500 Turtleback Creek. Currently the proposed parcel serves has the access route to a ball field owned by the Township Trustee until now the 0.13 acre parcel has been used by the public to reach the ball fields without a recorded ingress slash egress easement or right away. In the absence of a recorded ingress slash egress easement or dedicated right away, the property owner 500 South Turtleback Creek Road was responsible for the access to and from the property and any associated liabilities. In taking action on all variance requests, the Board of Appeals is to consider The following decision decision criteria consistent with Indiana code and unified development ordinance. Number one general welfare the approval of the variances from development standards will not be injurious to the public health safety morals and general welfare the community staff finding approval would not cause any significant problems in relation to public health and safety. Two, adjacent property, the use or value of the area adjacent to the property included in the variance will not be affected in a substantially adverse manner. Staff finding the development standard variances will not affect adjacent properties in a substantially adverse manner. Three, practical difficulty, the strict application of the terms of the ordinance will result in a practical difficulty in the use of the property. Subject property consists of a narrow strip of land that provides access for members of public to reach township owned recreational facilities used for ballgames and other public activities. The requirement of a lot area of 10,000 square feet because it's considered another use. would prohibit the transfer of the property. In addition, the existing access arrangement may limit the property owner's ability to reasonably use or improve the property while accommodating the public's continued access to a township-owned recreational facility. Strict applications of the applicable zoning development standard may therefore create a practical difficulty in the use of the property. Existing public access circumstances create a difficulty that is not self-imposed and provides reasonable relief while protecting the interests of the property owner and the public. The Board of Zoning Appeals action shall be in a form of approval, approval with conditions, denial, or a continuance. The Board of Zoning Appeals takes final action on all variance petitions. The purpose of a variance from development standards is to provide relief from a specific zoning requirement when strict enforcement of that requirement creates practical difficulty for the property owner. Therefore, based on the above analysis, it is a staff opinion that the variance from development standards to reduce the minimum lot area to 5,662 square feet or 0.13 acres meets all requirements and criteria and therefore recommends approval of the request. The board may approve the variances if after testimony and discussion, it finds that the request meets all six of the stated requirements. If the board denies a variance, it shall state which requirements have not been met. And this is the proposed plat. And this is what the parcel will look like. after it's been transferred from 500 South Turtleback and petitioners representative is present if you have any questions. Okay, so basically the township is buying part of this lot to make the access to the ball field legal and nothing else is changing. Correct. The property across the creek. or is it partial of the, on this side of the creek, could be the east side of the creek. This is where you enter the ball field. Yeah, I understand that, but I'm asking if it's a square foot, square feet is just on the west side of the creek or is it on both sides? I don't think it has anything to do with the creek. Well, it does. Can AJ answer that, your question? Are you ready for him? Are you ready for him? Yeah, sure. Okay. I guess that's the creek right there, I suppose. AJ Willis, Spot and Fanion Associates. I'm representing this project tonight. So the new lot line between the two lots will follow the creek. So right now, the creek currently splits that lot at the 500 Turtleback Creek Road. So we're gonna subdivide it along the center line of that creek. Everything on the west side of the creek will be transferred over to the township, and everything on the east side of the creek will remain the same. Will remain the same? Yep. And the other question I have, is there any other lots there as the township got any of the, section feed crossed from the creek. The Creek County does the. Yeah, not that I'm aware of. There may be a few lots down through there that just barely cross over that creek, but this is the only area where that drive crosses another parcel of land. Okay, thank you. Yep. Does anyone have any questions for the petitioner or for Denise? Okay, is there anyone from the public that wants to address this? Seeing none, I think we're ready for a motion. I will then make a motion that we approve case number BZA 26-8 for 500 South Turtleback Creek Road. I'll second it. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call, please. David Drake. Travis Conyer? Yes. Pat Wesolowski? Yes. Caleb Plummer? Yes. Matt Steevo? Yes. Thank you. Okay, motion carries. The next item on our agenda is a petition for a special exception to allow a home business in a residential three zoning district, location 4504 North Triple Crown Drive. Petitioner is Tim Lang. Case number is BZA 26-7. Good evening. Next on the agenda is a petition by Tim Lang for consideration of a special exception to allow home based business in residential three zoning district. Excuse me. Subject parcels located at 4504 North triple crown drive. The unified development ordinance requires home based businesses in an R three zoning district are to be allowed by special exception. Petitioners request for special exception, special exception, it's mouthful, is the only item to be considered by this Board of Zoning Appeals. Charlestown Manor was annexed into the town of Ellsville in 2017 with R3 zoning. At that time, the developer intended to construct apartments, which have not come to be. Building permit application to add the addition of a garage with a vault in the rear to house the home-based business was submitted on July 21st, 2026 by the prior property owner. In discussions with the property owner, it was decided to add that garage has an addition to the home because detached buildings are not allowed for a home-based business. Petitioner purchased 4504 North Triple Count Drive, a single-family dwelling on August 21st, 2026 and is a sole proprietor of TLS Tactical Solutions a firearms dealer, manufacturer and retailer. The garage addition will house the home-based business petitioner and holds a federal firearms license issued by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms and sees clients by appointment only between the hours of 5 p.m. to 7 p.m. The business does not have employees and there will not be any signage. The vault for the business is 160 square feet. The door weighs 1,000 pounds and is 14 inches thick with steel reinforced walls and has a safe lock system. In taking action on all special exception requests, the board is zoning appeals shall use the following decision criteria consistent with Indiana code and unified development ordinance. Number one, the establishment, maintenance, or operation of the special exception will not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, morals, or general welfare, be injurious to public health, safety. Sorry, that's repeating. Staff finding petitioners seeking a special exception for home-based business that will see clients by appointment only during specific hours, which will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals, and general welfare of the community. Number two, the special exception will not be interest to the use and enjoyment of other property in the immediate vicinity for the purpose is already permitted. The proposed home based firearms business will operate by appointment only and will not employ additional personnel. Client visits will be scheduled in advance, limiting the frequency and concentration of business related traffic to the property. Business transactions and inventory storage will be conducted indoors. and no outdoor sales displays, firearm demonstrations, or discharging to firearms will occur on the premises. Based on the proposed scale and manner of operation, the business is not anticipated to generate excessive traffic, parking demands, noise, lighting, odors, or other disturbances that would adversely affect neighboring residential properties. The limited appointment-based nature of the business allows the property to retain its primary residential character while accommodating the proposed business activity. Subject to compliance with applicable federal, state, and local requirements, their proposed use is not expected to be injurious to the use and enjoyment of surrounding properties for their permitted residential uses. The establishment of a special exception will not impede or substantially alter the normal and orderly development and improvement of surrounding property or uses permitted in the district. The proposed home-based business will operate within the existing residence and will not require substantial structural modification to the property's existing residential character. The business will operate by appointment only with no additional employees and all business activities and inventory storage will be maintained indoors. The limited nature of the proposed business is not anticipated to interfere with the development improvement or continued residential use of surrounding properties. Neighboring property owners will retain the ability to construct, maintain, expand, and improve their properties in accordance with the applicable R3 zoning requirements. Their proposed special exception will not change the zoning classification of the property or alter the permitted residential uses of surrounding properties. Therefore, the proposed use is not expected to impede or substantially alter the normal and oral development and improvement of surrounding property. Four adequate utilities, access road drainage, and other necessary facilities are being provided. Staff finding is stated earlier in paragraph five, an application was received at the addition of a garage with a vault in the rear to house the home-based business, and that necessary facility has been completed. Adequate utilities, sorry, just read that one. The special exception will be located in a district where such use is permitted and all other requirements set forth in the UDO that are applicable to such use will be met. Staff finding the town of Ellsville Unified Development Ordinance identifies home-based business has use permitted by special exception in the R3 high-density residential zoning district. Proposed firearm sale business is conducted by the property owner, and as stated earlier, it's within the existing residence, operates by appointment only and does not employ additional personnel. The proposed business will be subject to the applicable development and operational standards established in section 3.6, home-based business of the UDO, including limitations on customer visits, hours of operations, business location, outdoor storage and displays, maintenance of residential character, parking and signage, The business will not require additional driveways, exterior commercial displays, or alterations that would change the residential appearance of the property. Subject to compliance with the applicable UDO requirements and any conditions imposed by the Board of Zoning Appeals, the proposed home-based business is eligible for consideration as a special exception in our three zoning district. The Board of Zoning Appeals action shall be in a form of approval, approval with conditions, denial, or continuance. The Board of Zoning Appeals takes final action on all variance petitions. Special exception use is authorized by the Board of Zoning Appeals after a public hearing and a determination that all applicable special exception criteria have been satisfied. The proposed home-based business has minimal impacts and can be regulated through the same standards used for home-based businesses in single-family districts, which the petitioner already meets. If approved, the proposed use becomes an authorized use of the property subject to any conditions imposed. The property retains its R3 zoning classification. The approval does not rezone the property or change the permitted use of neighboring properties and the applicant must continue complying with all applicable UDO requirements. Therefore, based on the above analysis, it is staff opinion that the special exception to allow a home-based business meets all requirements of the home-based business requirements under the UDO, and therefore recommends approval of the special exception request. And I'll go through photos, excuse me. This is where the parcel is located. So this is looking in the garage, the vaults in the back, and on the right, some measurements of the walls in the vault door. And this is looking out towards the garage door. And then that's the vault door. And that's the front of the home with the garage on the left is noted. And then I tried to get a little closer, but it was hard to get it all in one screen. So and that's all the pictures. Petitioner is here if you have any questions. OK, so my first question of you, Denise, is if this were an R1 zone, is a home based business automatically allowed if it meets those conditions? Yes, it'd be allowed by right. So the only difference here, even though this was zoned as R3, it's been completely developed as R1. Correct. So if it had been zoned correctly, or not correctly is not the right word, but if it had been zoned as it has been constructed, then it would have been allowed by right. And the only reason we're here is because when it was annexed in, it was annexed in as R3, even though it was developed as R1. Correct. It's all single-family residential in the development. Okay. And right now there's 82, if you want to know, 82 single-family homes built or under construction. And are there any other home-based businesses in that neighborhood subdivision? I've been told that there are four. But they don't have to come to us because, well, no, they would because it's in our three. Yeah, but They just didn't, but I can't confirm him. I've just been told that. So does this proposed home based business meet all of the requirements of a home based business according to our code? Yes, it does. The only difference he would be allowed to have signage and there's some parking standards, but it's by appointment only so. He'll probably only have theoretically one car at a time, plus his home, his personal car is parked there. And the signage, he said he doesn't want any signage, which he would be allowed to have. OK, so this next question, I guess, is probably for our attorney. Is this email that was sent to Denise from Tim Lang describing what he's going to do, is that considered a commitment under the? It would be considered an offer on his part to meet certain conditions and you could make those conditions that he's offered a condition of your approval. or you can incorporate by reference his email. If the board's inclined to grant this, I would specifically list the conditions, like the hours by appointment only, no employees, just so it's crystal clear. And the reason I mention that, because it says there will be no signage. Correct. If he's agreeing to give that up, he's negotiated with you in advance on that. So yes, that's a condition that you can impose as a condition of approval. So basically, this is like any other home-based business that would be allowed in an R1 zone. It just involves firearms. Not yet. Not yet. We come to the public term and eventually. Thank you. So Denise, can you answer how we how we basically got the cart before the horse here. In other words, how did we end up with the vault before we get to needing the special exception? Or should the petitioner answer that? Well, he didn't own the property at the time, and plus it's a building issue versus a zoning issue. So we could have kept just his own firearms in there and not had a business. And nobody would ever know. OK. When the prior owner, we talked about it, he was building it, and he needed to sell his property. So I said it had to be an addition to the house to be a home-based business. So he built the garage, and Mr. Lang conveyed he needed additional car storage. I think he has some toys. And so then the vault would be in the back. And so that's how we waited. for the sale to happen and then Mr. Lang contacted us to see how he went about having his home-based business. Okay, so part of the home-based business regulations state that no mechanical equipment shall be used and it's already illegal to discharge a firearm within the town limits. And I would point out that the town does not enforce homeowner association regulations. That's a civil issue and not part of the town's authority. Okay, I think that's all the questions that I have of Denise. Does anybody else have any for Denise? So the structure was built prior to Tim owning the property? Yes. With the intent of running a business out of it? Yes. Thank you. Anybody else? Okay, let's hear from the petitioner. And while he's getting up, I will point out that when we do open the floor for public comment, each speaker is allowed three minutes to speak. You come in, you sign up at the podium on the sign in sheet. You get your three minutes with a maximum of 30 minutes for everyone altogether. If we feel that's not enough, we can add more time for more people, but each person is limited to three minutes. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Tim Lang, and I wanted to give you a little bit of background information before we answer or field some of the questions concerning the home business. So I am the owner, sole proprietor, and only operator for this business. I've never had any employees in the five years I've been operating since 2010, October. So I moved to Bloomington, Indiana in 2005 to work at NSWC Crane. I've been married for 27 years to Serena. I have twin 13-year-old boys, sons Christian and Jackson. I've spent most of my professional career serving our country as a U.S. Marine, a duty civilian, GS-15, and now a defense contractor as chief engineer. I've held the top secret clearance at least half of my professional career. I've deployed all over the world to include eight months in Afghanistan 2010. Let's see, I enjoy hunting, fishing, golf and most outdoor activities with my family. I'm very involved with my some sports teams. I've coached them in football, basketball, baseball. I'm also a licensed drone pilot, part 107 certified. So I want to talk about a little bit of how the standard operating practices when I sell a firearm. So number one, I first get a requirement to buy or build a firearm via text message, email, or phone call. I then order the firearm or parts from a wholesale distributor based on availability. The firearm is then shipped to my house via FedEx, UPS, or USPS. A signature is required. Upon receipt, I log the firearm information in my FFL disposition book. Every FFL is required to have a FFL disposition book. Every single transaction that I do has to go in this book. So in the 261 months that I've had this business, I have 242 transactions. So that is less than one transaction a week. You can do the quick math, right? I just wanted to clarify that I have very low volume. So everyone understands that I am not a gun shop that's gonna have high volume. I'm not gonna have increased commercial throughput. That is not my intention. I don't want people at my house. That's not what I'm looking to do, right? This is a small home business. To continue, I notify the customer to come and pick up the firearm again by appointment. When they arrive, I have a customer fill out a standard ATF form 4473. This is the form right here. After they fill this form out, I then conduct a required FBI background check via NICS. Everyone has to pass an FBI background check if you are an FFL license holder. If I do a private to private sale, which I don't because I'm an FFL, But if anyone in here is a private owner, they don't have to do an FBI background check. They simply just sell the weapon to the other person. But me as a licensed FFL, I am required to do an FBI background check and every single one that has been through this book has passed. If they don't pass, they don't get the weapon. So if they didn't pass the background check, I then log the firearm out of the disposition book and the customer leaves my home with the firearm. The whole process takes about 10 minutes. Again, if they do not pass the background check, they do not receive the firearm. To date, this has never happened, given that most of my customers that I work with have security clearances for the US government. Bottom line, I don't sell to criminals. Safety concerns for the neighborhood. I keep all of my guns locked up in a secure safe. No one has access to anyone except my wife and I. And I initially met Chuck and Harvey, and I had them build a secure space with a 1,000-pound vault door to include steel reinforced walls. The room will also have a 24-hour video surveillance camera, ADT professionally installed both inside and out. And I would have this place regardless if I had a business or not for my personal collection. I do not keep an inventory for my business. Every gun in my vault room is my gun. If you look at my disposition book, and I'm willing to pass this around if you want to see it, you'll see that everything out, there's no open dispositions. So that means I don't have any guns from any customers that are sitting in there other than one person who ordered something five months ago and then got deployed for the Navy. So I don't keep inventory for my gun business at all. There'll be no additional traffic tied to my business as I don't have hours of operation. I'm a trained firearm specialist. I've been to countless firearm courses. I've worked as a range safety officer at Bedford Contingent Shooting Range different business, I'm also a Marine Corps veteran. Why did I move to Ellisville? I wanted my boys to live in a smaller, tighter community, and I wanted them to go to Edgewood schools. I wanted a house with nicer finishings, more garage space, and a neighborhood that was good for my kids to play with. Previously, we lived on the south side, about 15 minutes south, and unfortunately, they didn't have the access to ride their bike in different places, so we wanted better schools, and I believe Edgewood provides better schools. Before I bought the house, when touring the home, I asked Chuck Short and Andy if the HOA would have issues with running my business for my home. They said it wouldn't be an issue. Chuck Short is also one of the two signature authorities on the HOA covenant, so I figured he would probably be a knowing authority. That makes sense, right? Lastly, there's a covenant section citing 3.03, and it says commercial uses no lot, residence, or structure. or any partner of erected any lot should be used for industry, business, trade, or commercial purposes. Withstanding the foregoing in-home professional pursuits without employees shall be permissible so long as any such in-home professional pursuit does not generate significant traffic to the division or subdivision. Also withstanding the foregoing declarant may establish and maintain from time to time a model home or model homes in the developmental period. My response is, How am I any different than a cupcake baker, a real estate agent, a professional trainer, or massage therapist? That's my question. So that's all I have. I'm willing to accept questions now. Does anybody from the Planning Commission have questions for Mr. Lang? You're not gonna have any guns? You said like a showroom type of situation? No showroom. No, I have a ballroom and I have guns in my ballroom, but that is not a show up and walk in. That's not a thing. It's not like US defense down the road where you just walk in and look at a gun. That's not the case. The guns in the vault are yours? Correct. Every single one of them. That's wrong, man. Anybody else? It says manufacturing, I assume, because the gun comes in pieces. You putting it together would be considered the manufacturing department? Yeah, for example, If somebody wants a very specific AR build, and they want to use it for hunting hogs down in Texas, and they'll come to me and say, I need a thermal site. I want this particular caliber. I want it to be this color. I want this handle. And I go out and I buy the parts. The parts are shipped to me. I put it together. I have no machining equipment. I'm not a machinist. I'm an engineer, but I'm not a machinist. I don't own the lathe or mill or any of that kind of stuff. That's not the intent. It's me putting together, assembling, And then they, I sell a firearm. And you're not manufacturing or making ammunitions or anything like that either? Not for sale, no. Okay. I have one other question, David. Does any government agencies come in and check you over? ATF does. They had the right to show up at any time and inspect my, so in the five years prior, they never showed up to inspect, but they can literally call me and inspect any time. Okay, thank you. So it's very critical that this book right here is 100% accurate. Because if they show up and they say, hey, where's this firearm? And I say, I don't know. Well, guess what? I'm in trouble at that point. So this is kept extremely, extremely important that it's accurate. OK, any more questions? OK, so what we're going to do next is we're going to allow public comment. Then you can come back up and answer anything that you want to answer after they speak. sounds good okay so we're ready for public comment three minutes maximum come on up and sign in and tell us what you want to tell us Denise, are you keeping time? Is one of you keeping time? OK. You can say a lot in three minutes if you don't repeat yourself a lot. OK. No problem. I'll wait. There we go. There you go. Okay. Good evening. I'm going to. Good evening. I'm Tom Hebdom. I'm speaking on behalf of the Advisory Committee of Charles Style Manor and its 75 concerned homeowners. And I thank you for your attention. I want to address five concerns. The distinction between the home occupation and the home business. Traffic, property values, safety, and compliance. First, home occupation versus home business. The application describes TLS as a home-based business. There is an important distinction. A home occupation typically involves a professional working from his home office, such as an attorney or accountant providing the service. A retail business involves exchanging product or goods. TLS proposed to operate a retail business from a garage, not a traditional home office. Allowing this use would set a precedence for other commercial operations such as furniture repairs, bakery goods, or other similar businesses in our residential neighborhood. Second, traffic. Triple Crown Drive already carries considerable traffic. Adding any customer visits or deliveries increases the traffic in a neighborhood disruption. Third is property values. Homeowners purchase their properties expecting residential community and introducing a retail firearm business or any retail business could affect the desirability and marketability of the surrounding homes. Protecting homeowners' investments and their residential character should be an important consideration for this board. A residential neighborhood should not gradually become a collection of commercial operations through individual exceptions. Fourth is safety and security. A firearm business presents security concerns beyond those of an ordinary home business. The term vault is used loosely. The only secured area of the structure is the vault door and the interior wall. The three exterior walls are normal construction material. Finally, compliance, the most important. If the board approves this petition, what official monitoring will the city provide to ensure that business operates within the limits and conditions presented to this board? Who will verify future compliance? The real issue is not Mr. Lang's business. It's whether any retail business is appropriate within the established residential subdivision. We believe this proposed business, as well as other commercial home businesses, is inconsistent with the residential character of our community. Please understand I'm not speaking as an individual homeowner, which I will later. I am speaking on behalf of the Charles Salmanner Advisory Committee and representing the concern of 75 homeowners who respectfully ask this board to deny the special exception petition. Thank you for your time. Okay, next. Before I start, I just have a question about something that was mentioned previously. Is that OK to? OK. I'm John Spoonmore, and I live in Charleston Manor. But I have a question about the R1 zoning versus the R3 zoning. Could you go back over that, explain that? So single-family residential, such as what your neighborhood is, is R1. When that was annexed, it was annexed as R3 because they wanted to put in apartments. They didn't develop it as R3. They developed it as R1. So really, in reality, it operates as a single-family residential neighborhood, not an apartment complex. An apartment complex is R1 or R3? R3 is apartments. R1 is single-family residential. Okay. Thank you. Okay, my name is John Spoonmore and I live in Charleston Manor. I'm here to oppose the request for an exception that would allow retail business to operate out of our home in our neighborhood, which is zoned residential only. This request is not simply about what the applicant wants to sell. It is about introducing retail activity into a subdivision that was intentionally designed and contractually reinforced to be exclusively residential. Our subdivision's HOA covenants clearly prohibit commercial or retail operations. Every homeowner agreed to those covenants when purchasing property. They reflect the expectations we rely on, quiet streets, predictable residential use, and no customer-based activity, while the BZA is not required to enforce HOA rules. Those covenants are strong evidence of the community's intended character and the commitments made by every resident. The applicant, Mr. Lang, and thank you for your service, Mr. Lang, proposes an appointment-based retail business. But appointment-based retail is still retail. It still means customers arriving at the home, transactions occurring on site, inventory stored in a residential structure. This is commercial activity, and it directly conflicts with both the zoning ordinance and the HOA covenants that define our neighborhood. Just as concerning, maybe more so, the residents were not informed of this plan. We learned about it only after the appeal was filed. A zoning exception that affects an entire subdivision should never move forward without transparency and community awareness throughout the entire process. Granting this exception would also set a precedent. If retail activity is allowed once in a residential-only subdivision, especially one with covenants prohibiting it, future applicants will cite this decision. The stability of our zoning depends on consistent enforcement, and the integrity of our HOA covenants depends on not undermining them through zoning exceptions. There are many commercially zoned areas of Monroe County where this business could operate without conflict. There is no hardship here, only convenience for the applicant at the expense of the neighborhood's established residential character. For these reasons, I respectfully ask the board to uphold the residential only zoning and deny this request. Thank you very much for your time. Hello. First, thank you, Mr. Lang, for your service. My name is Adam Mickey. I'm a father of three young children and a resident of the Charlestown Manor subdivision. I'm going to be intentional to explain my opposition to this request with no regard for the nature of the business. Rather, it's based on three critical points. Charlestown Manor consists of single-family homes filled with wonderful families. Under Eldsfield Town Code Chapter 152, R3 zoning exists to protect neighborhoods from commercial encroachment. Introducing any added traffic associated with any commercial business operations out of a home directly compromises the integrity of our zoning laws. Current homeowners moved into this neighborhood with the knowledge that home-based businesses are prohibited. The same is true for Mr. Lang. If there are four businesses operating out of the neighborhood today, I would be here to oppose them just the same. The second critical piece is increased traffic. There are 32 single-family homes between the neighborhood entrance and 4504 North Triple Crown Drive. Triple Crown Drive is a narrow, local residential street built exclusively to handle neighborhood traffic. Forcing business-related traffic past 32 residential doorsteps will cause unnecessary congestion and possible safety issues. The petitioner claims that the business is not anticipated to create excessive traffic. No business can guarantee a permanent cap on any amount of customer traffic. The only thing better than minimal customer traffic is zero. My third critical point is childhood safety. Most concerning of all, there is a designated school bus stop situated along the direct path from the neighborhood entrance to Mr. Lang's house. Charlestown Manor is full of young children who play in their yards, ride bicycles, walk the sidewalks, wait at this bus stop daily, and walk home from this bus stop daily. Introducing foreign traffic directly into the path of our children creates an unacceptable risk to childhood safety that is avoidable simply by upholding the zoning guidelines that exist today. A commercial business belongs in an appropriately zoned commercial district, not deeply embedded in a subdivision. I'd question why any special exception should ever be made for the current R3 zoning guidelines. For these reasons, I urge the board to uphold the existing R3 zoning guidelines and reject the use variance for this petition. Thank you for your time. Next. Good evening. My name is Michael Doherty. I've submitted my statement and questions for already to all three emails from Ms. Line. So I would ask that if my time extends that you take time to answer those questions that are submitted, I believe in the record already. First, I'd like to remind the committee and correct me if I'm wrong, Ms. Attorney, that if this is an R3 zoning, that just because the developer hasn't used the space already for R3 zoning buildings does not mean they cannot use the remaining space to do so. Is that correct? So he could use the additional space to build apartments if he desired, as it is owned for an R3. I think he could. Correct. So I'd like you to keep that in mind. Good evening. My name is Michael Doherty. I live at 4636 North Kelly Met Court in Charlestown Manor. I'm a small business owner, a firearm owner, and a local area physician. I want to be clear, I'm not here to speak against Mr. Lang personally or against lawful firearm ownership. I'm here because the petition asked the board to authorize commercial firearms dealer and manufacturer in a residential neighborhood, and I don't believe the records before you supports the findings the board is required to make. First, the order of events that you brought up. The staff report states that on July 21st, the previous owner, Andy Lynch, whose staff says is employed by the builder, applied for a permit for a garage addition, step back. Sure. Applied for a permit for a garage addition with a vault to house this business. That permit application, number 5037, lists the work as a new construction that does not mention any business use. The addition was built by Bardee Builders, which staff identifies as partly owned by our subdivision developer. The home was then sold to the petitioner a month later. Section 3.1C of the UDO calls for compliance with use standards to be verified before a building permit is issued. Here the structure was permitted and built first and the board is now being asked to approve the use after the fact. You're being hoodwinked. Anybody could come in here and request before the sale of their property to build an addition for a business that you would possibly not want to accept a special exception. Second, the business is described as a dealer and manufacturer, but every staff finding addresses only sales. Section 3.6 prohibits mechanical equipment, though he has stated here today, there's nothing in the staff recommendations or other submission materials that I could find that record what materials are manufactured that would happen on site, what equipment will be used, and what materials will be stored. The third, the staff report itself has gaps. The criteria listed states use variance, though this is a special exception. Criteria four and five are identical. The reports claim six criteria are met, but list five. I'm gonna get to the base of what I'm asking. I'm asking at minimum you give a continuance because the petitioner has the burden of providing, approving compliance, not the town or the neighbors. However, if you do so, decline. I have a specific that I did submit conditions of approval that I would ask that you consider. I have a copy that are spelled out that I'd like to, if it wasn't printed out for you, that you consider those conditions. If you'd like, feel free to read. I don't wanna take up more of my time, but those are the conditions I suggest, mostly of which are already submitted by the petitioner. The last one would be that this is, if you make these conditions of your approval, that they be subject to annual review. Thank you very much. Next. Thank you. Is there a way to put that map up at this house? The what? The map. The old map you had up there. This? No, the whole overhead map. Oh. Yeah, right there. My name's Dwayne Bishop. This is where this garage is at. That's where I live at. Closest to that vault than anyone. Dwayne, D-W-A-Y-N-E. And I only met him once. I walked over after I heard about all this. I looked at his garage and vault. I didn't even know what was going on. To me, I have no problem with it. I know when you assemble firearms, you don't need machinery. A screwdriver is about the most you need. And from what I see, it looked safe and secure, probably more than would be if it wasn't there with video cameras and stuff. I mean, it's a vault. About the traffic area, I've known people who's done this before. If you're worried about the traffic area, there's these no parking signs all up and down the street with cars parked underneath them. And I drive in the morning and swerve around them. I don't care. I don't care that kids drive out or people have their quad runners. There's a lot of exceptions made in this. Is this because it's guns? Would they do this if they were selling Mary Kay? I don't know. But to me, it ain't gonna affect my value. And I have no problem with it. That's all I'd say. okay now i'm not sure we've never had this come up before but you've already spoken you've already spoken once as the advisory committee i'm speaking as a resident okay well make it quick i'll just make it really short i'm sure you realize i've been involved in commissions before and this is a rather large turnout i think i'm not familiar with ellisville i was in my original hometown but i would just like to know How many of the people who may not be comfortable to speak in the audience now might be from Charlestown Manor, and if they might raise their hands so that we have an idea. Okay, so I think even though only five of us spoke, it could be possibly some of these people are concerned about the introduction of any kind, and not Mr. DeWine's, but any kind of commercial or retail business to be established in the community that they've chose to live in. I appreciate the second opportunity to speak to the board. My name is Rick Johnson. I'm a resident of Charleston Manor. I have a family, five kids. We did so under the impression of everything in that covenants and under good faith that there wouldn't be businesses and I didn't even think that that would be something that we'd have to consider, I believe you, I believe that Chuck did tell you that it would be fine. Dude lied to you, he lied to a lot of us. Sorry man, honestly, no issue with guns or just not in my neighborhood with five kids, okay? That's all. I serve too, I respect you serving too. I really hope, I don't know what your purview is as far as if it's just by the law or if our opinions actually hold sway. We live there, I respect the staff's opinion. I'm not willing to bet my kids' wellbeing or my family's wellbeing on it, because I live there. And that's what I have to say. Mr. Lang, did you want to say anything else? Sure. So I heard a lot about increased traffic to the neighborhood, right? And I understand that being concerned. A lot of little kids. Again, I've got kids too, so I understand that. But the previous five years that I've operated from my home and my prior residence shows a very low volume, less than one per week. I don't intend to change any of that. Again, I have a full-time job. I work 50 hours a week at my regular job. This is not intended for me to be a full-time business. It's by appointment only, the additional proposed traffic will be non-existent, you will not, you'll probably see more Amazon deliveries to other houses than you would at my house. And that's the honest truth, right? I really don't anticipate the additional traffic that you wouldn't probably even notice, honestly. Okay, thank you. Okay, seeing. Is there anyone from joining remotely who has an interview to speak? They're going to ask if anyone remotely has anything to speak. Just a minute. I was having technical difficulties earlier. So you can ask if anybody remotely would like to speak. Do any of their people want to speak for three minutes? I don't know what. I'm OK. I'm OK. I'm just listening. Thank you. OK. I don't hear anybody. Good evening. I'm Serena Lang. I will address a couple of things that I've heard here tonight. I know it's not about the HOA, but this HOA covenant is not as strict as I've heard it made out to be. I did not sign or even see the HOA covenants until several weeks, maybe even a month after we purchased the home when my neighbor emailed it to me. So that is that. There are also many exceptions to that. I've asked twice to be given an account to this HOA so I could pay dues and read the covenants for myself and get information to which I have heard nothing in about three months. The second thing is traffic. My neighbors have nannies, house cleaners, Amazon, Domino's at least four times a week. I mean, they have significantly more traffic than my house would ever have. Live here. I don't want strange men in my house. I don't want people Driving up my driveway that I don't know. That's a strict That's a hard line for me and my family. Okay, this is not something that we've ever done more than a hobby for Tim and like he said he is a Trained, he is experienced. My children are hunter, firearm, safety, whatever. They've taken the hunter safety class. We do not play with guns at our home. We respect them. I'm also a Marine. So we've had a wealth of firearms practice and handling. They're not toys to us. So that's another thing. my top concern with my children. They do not have access to any firearms, any ammo, nothing. So your kids would never either, unless they break into the back of my vault. Yes, so that's it. Traffic, safety, HOA. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Robert Thomas. I do not live in Charleston. I live in Centennial Park. I'm currently under contract with Chuck to build a home. It will be my retirement home in the subdivision. So my biggest concern is about property values. The house that I'm under contract to build is not inexpensive. And I'm just curious about what type of analysis you used to conclude that this business would have no impact on property values. I found Mr. Lane's statement to be very persuasive. I believe that he is an honorable man, he's a serviceman, and his business description does sound very mild. But my problem is I see very little criteria for deciding what is acceptable use for retail and what isn't acceptable. I haven't heard any analysis, maybe the staff will provide some analysis about why this business or any retail business in this residential area will have no impact on property value safety, in particular property values. So my big concern here is not just Mr. Lang, but what future individuals will come in and perhaps get an exception to provide maybe a retail business that is not as not so innocuous as the one that Mr. Lang is proposing. Thank you. Okay, well we're back to the commission. I'll make a few comments to the other commission members. As we noted before, it's not our responsibility nor do we have the authority to enforce whatever may or may not be the HOA covenants. If this was zoned R1 as it probably should have been, And as it's used, this would be allowed by right and would not even require any action by us. I don't see any significant traffic increase from this any more than anybody else's residence has. It appears to meet all the conditions that are required for a home-based business according to our coded regulations. If we deny it, we have to specify exactly what those requirements have are not being met besides just feelings we have to have specific criteria and put that in writing if we deny it so I have some when we're ready for a vote I have some conditions of approval that I would propose which would be reiterating what was already said in that email, mainly by appointment only Monday through Friday, maximum of three per day, no other employees on the premises and no signage or any indication that a business is being operated in the home. So does anybody else have any comments? He said three per day, it's one transactional. Okay, so you want to go with one transaction a week? I'm good with one transaction. Okay. I don't need three days. That's not how I operate. Okay, one transaction per week. That's been my average that I've been operating under for the past five years. Are you are you all right with the other requirements with the other conditions? The ADT security system 24 hour surveillance? No, no, I mean, are you okay with the By appointment only, no other employees on premises, and no signage. 100%. Between 5 PM and 7 PM. Is that what you said, 5 PM and 7 PM? No one will show up to my house unannounced. You said no signage. I'm curious, will there be online signage, like on Google Maps or anything like that? No, I actually tried to do the website thing to have online orders. It was too costly, and I didn't pay any business, so I canceled that about six months ago. OK, anybody else from the? I have one last thing to address. There was a concern. Google searched on Master FFL. Because when you Google my business name, Master FFL pops up with a description, and that's a nationwide database for FFLs. And in there, there's an AI profile in there that calls out employees, it calls out business hours, it calls out training offerings. None of that is true. I've since then removed myself from that database, and it doesn't exist anymore. So just be aware that anybody that Google searched Master FFL and saw that I had a profile in there, that is not real, and that's invalid since. OK, let's get back to the board. I've got just one comment, David. Many of you have talked about traffic. If I'm not mistaken, when I drove through there, that development has just been opened up to another neighborhood. Yes. So your traffic is going to come just because of having a home business there. So that's something to think about. Evidently, you people didn't care about having more traffic coming through your neighborhood with going into the other development. Okay, so I seriously doubt that one transaction per week is going to add an unbearable amount of traffic in the neighborhood. So we're still with us. Anybody else have any comments, questions? Okay, well then I'll make a motion that we approve the special exception for 4504 North Triple Crown Drive as requested in incorporating the staff findings into the approval and noting that the business is subject to all of our home-based business requirements. And with the addition that any activity be by appointment only, A maximum of one transaction per week from 5 to 7 PM. No other employees on the premises and that there be no signage or any indication that a business is being operated. In the home. I'll send it. OK, we have a motion in a second roll call, please. David Drake, yes. Travis Conyer, yes. Pat Weslowski, yes. Kayla Plummer, yes. That's the vote. Yes. Okay, motion carries. Thank you. Next item on our agenda is planning department update. Our next meeting will be December 3rd. And I'm working on third or ninth. Third. It says ninth on here. Sorry. wait just a minute. Let me check my calendar while they're moving to be sure. Thank you. It's the third. Okay. No, that's plan commission on the door. Oh, yeah, this is the BCA. Well, I didn't question it. Did I question it? Hey, guys. It's not over yet here. We're still working. Thank you. They're in your hood. So anyway, so anyway, I was working. I've been working on Plan Commission BZA both so I'm working on something that can come before you for the BZA. Um, in December, Darla's helping me with it a little bit. And, um, but right now you'll have, I anticipate something for you. Is December 9th BZA meeting or the? BZA. BZA. Okay. Plan commission is the second, third? Yeah. Okay. Are you putting that on your calendar, David? I already did, but I couldn't remember what I wrote. Because he didn't come do the last one. Yeah, I had it written down as the next Thursday for some reason. So that's all I have. Do you guys have anything or Darla and want to thank Darla for being here? Yeah. Thank you. Oh my gosh. Planning's the third. December 3rd? Yes. Okay, well we're adjourned then.