like to call to order the meeting of Monroe County Public Library Board of Trustees for November 18, 2026. If we could go around and introduce ourselves, and if you'd like to share what you're reading, you may. Hi, everyone. My name is Jennifer Whitley. I am currently reading a book that I just blanked on. So that's OK. We'll just pass on that. That's totally fine. Yeah. Something about bees. Yes, long day, long drive. I'm Becky Hill, and I'm reading Exit Party by Emily St. John Mandel. Whitney Eats, and I had to pull it up. I'm reading Sleeping Beauties by Stephen King and Owen King. Oh, lovely. I'm Jamie Burkhart. I am currently between books, but I want to pick up the new, is it the Booker Prize? Everything ends, and what does anybody know the real title? What is it, Becky? Something like that. But it seems interesting, and that's what I'd like to read. I'm Greer Carson. I'm embarrassed to share what I read sometimes when I hear you all. I'm reading Beethoven impressions by his contemporaries, which I think was written in like 1829. And we're playing Ocarina of Time, the remake on Switch 2. I'm Amy O'Shaughnessy. I'm reading Buckeye by Patrick Ryan. Chris Hall, and I just finished City of Thieves, and I can't remember if I read the last book shop, so I'm re-reading that, or starting to. I'm Nancy Van Allen, and I'm reading Impossible Escape, a true story of survival and heroism in Nazi Europe. Very cool. Fantastic. Are there any public comments? In person? Nope. Zoom? Is there a motion to approve the consent agenda? It includes the minutes from October 21st, monthly financial report, monthly bills for payment, personnel report, and the board meeting calendar. All in favor say aye. Aye. Those opposed say nay. Ayes have it. And next we're going to hear the director's monthly report. So usually I highlight a few things from the report because there are always excellent things in there and this month there's no exception, but given today's agenda and our department update plans and the executive session, I thought I'd just jump to three things that are not actually in the report just to keep you all informed. The first is we are still working with our elevator consultant. on finalizing the chosen bid and specifically in working with our previous elevator contract in actually coming to terms on our legacy agreement before we sign on with our new bid. So we have had the preferred vendor come out and look at our system and give us feedback on whether or not we're going to run into any problems. A lot of our system has some really dated and inconsistent mechanics that have to be addressed. So we wanted to make sure before signing anything what we were in for. We also want in writing from our previous elevator contract that we're good severing the contract. So we're still working on that through our elevator consultant is going to happen. It's just taking a lot longer than expected. The second is our strategic plan. Normally we would bring a draft of that plan to this meeting and then the final version in December. We and by we I mean I am a little behind on that process this month. So we're going to bring the strategic plan to you all next month. I can share that we have finished the community surveys and the staff surveys. We have a pretty good sense for what both community and staff are interested in seeing with our next strategic plan. We are very likely going to renew a lot of what's in the current plan but update the language and possibly combine a few current goals and make room for some finance related goals in the new plan. But we will bring that to you all in December. And then finally I know we shared last month the county council held the public hearings and then Verbally approved our budget for 2027. It has been officially approved and submitted to the Department of Local Government Finance as of a couple of days ago, I think. So we are good to go for 2027. There is a final step where we get that information back around the December 17th mark, but we're very pleased. We thank our partners at County Council and more than anyone. I thank our good Director of Finance, Gary Letley, for getting us through this first year under the new law change in Indiana. Happy to answer any questions, as always. Anyone? OK. Motion to hear the annual employee benefits renewal. Second. OK. Becky, tell us all about it. I have handouts for you guys that I didn't get a chance While Becky's handing those out, I'll remind everyone, last month we brought our insurance brokers from JA Benefits to speak to you all and give you kind of the background on what's going on both within the market overall, so completely independent of MCPL's plan, but also some of the MCPL claims and related specific details that are influencing the significant increase in insurance premiums that we're going to be seeing for next year. And I think as Corey and some others from J.A. had indicated last month, there's a lot of work behind the scenes in negotiating with Anthem in looking at options that we've had to go in with other providers, even marketplace. At the end of the day, our goal is always to make sure we can pass on as little of the increase as possible to our staff while remaining fiscally responsible. And that is the work that has been done over the last, it's been more than a month, but in earnest, the last month has been a lot of number crunching, looking at options. So what Becky's gonna present to you all tonight is what we believe is the wisest approach to staying with our Anthem plan, but with some adjustments. And Becky and also Corey from JA are here to answer any questions you all have. And then following that, we'll be looking for a vote on our proposal for 2027 benefits. And Corey, thanks for coming. OK. So you guys have several papers in front of you. We'll go through those kind of in order as they come up, but I wanna make sure that I go over all the information and then give you guys some time to ask questions. Corey is here to answer any questions that you have specific to insurance that I cannot answer. And then we'll kind of go from there. So as JA presented, Last month our initial renewal from anthem came in at thirty nine point nine eight percent. So just shy of forty percent increase J a since our last meeting has worked really hard on our behalf to get our renewal down The final renewal came in with anthem at thirty five percent, which was not quite the movement we were hoping for and for a number of reasons. And so 35% was our best and final renewal from Anthem on the same plans that we had in 2026. As Corey had mentioned, Corey and Alyssa had mentioned last month, some of the reasons that our increase is what it is. We had some increased usage on prescriptions. So the specialty drug market has not done us any favors. There were about $600,000 in prescription costs on the plan. And then we also had some claim numbers that they look at. So Anthem, again, wants us to run at a loss ratio that they set. We were significantly above that. So they look at what we pay in premium versus what they're paying out. And so that specialty drug, prescription drug cost combined with our actual plan usage got us up over that number, which is part of why we've seen the increase that we've seen. The other part is the insurance industry has just been challenging in general. All of the employers across the nation are seeing challenges with this. So most employers are seeing significant increases. And the insurance companies have not been quite as willing to come down on renewals. JA has been an exceptional partner. in working on options and levers for us to pull. So we meet all year to look at what some of those levers and options are. They prepared us really well with some of those conversations up front. So as soon as we got the renewal, we started looking at what levers we could and couldn't pull and what we were comfortable pulling for staff and for our budgeting. Several of the options that we looked at were some things that we had talked about With J in advance so they did go to market for us to see if we could change to a different carrier Unfortunately, the entire market seems to be frozen And so carriers are not taking on new lines of business. And so that really kind of ran into a dead end for us We looked at some other options on ways to kind of get creative with the benefits that we offer some different ways that we could potentially offer health insurance to staff those also had kind of some dead ends for various reasons. So the option that we spent the most time looking at was different plan designs within the anthem. sort of suite of plans that we could look at. So if you think of it as a menu, we had three plans that we were offering. Anthem gave us a whole other list of plans that we could look at. So we've spent a lot of time poring over several other options, changes to the type of plan, to the benefits within the plan. JA has been integral in looking at all of that and helping us understand what some of those differences are. What we came down to ultimately and what we're proposing to you all tonight is that we change from three plans. So historically we've offered a PPO and two high deductible health plans. There's a $3,400 deductible and a $5,000 deductible. We're looking to move to two plans for 2027. So this will be a PPO and one high deductible health plan. For a number of reasons that seems to make sense. It makes it a lot easier for our staff with fewer plans to decide between. That does make that an easier decision. And it also helps us to simplify and streamline some of those options. Those two changes do come with several significant changes to the plan design. And so I'll walk through those with you guys and then we can kind of get into some more details. The first thing is the PPO plan. So last year for twenty twenty six we had a five hundred dollar deductible plan for the PPO. That's almost unheard of when we do benchmarking and look at what our peers are offering. We've known for a while that that five hundred dollar deductible plan is kind of a dinosaur and really rare. So one of the things that we're looking at shifting would be to go to a fifteen hundred dollar deductible on the PPO. That is more in line with what other providers and other employers are going with. It still keeps us market competitive on our benefits but it does help to bring down some of that premium cost. So that's the first big change that we're doing or that we're proposing. We did also look at $2,000 deductibles and some other plans. We decided that that $1,500 was the least disruptive and kept the benefits as strong as we could for staff. The high deductible health plan, we're moving from a 3,400 and a $5,000 deductible to a $4,000 deductible plan. The IRS updates the amount for the high deductible plan every year, so it was gonna go from 3,400 to 3,600 anyways, so it makes sense to make that jump to 4,000. And then the difference between 4,000 and 5,000 is pretty minimal, and so that's why we opted to go to just one high deductible health plan. The other big change that we're proposing for this year is on the premium share. So historically the library has covered 100 percent of the premium for employees covering only themselves on health insurance. We know that that's a market leading benefit to offer. A lot of employers do not offer that. And so we did feel that this was the year that we needed to make that change. So we're proposing that the library cover 95 percent of the employee only premium and that employees pay 5 percent. That's a pretty nominal amount for staff. We do understand that's a big change because we haven't had that in my tenure here. I don't know when the last time we had staff pay anything for just simply only. What you'll see in the spreadsheets that I've provided, there's a 2027 benefit breakdown. That does have on the front page, there's the benefit breakdown that shows all of our benefits that we offer to staff. And the second page in that paper clipped packet has the 2027 health premiums. So you can see the per pay amount is $18.19 for employee only per pay and $21.71 for employee only for the PPO. per pay so we did try to keep that as minimal for staff as we could but we felt like that was something that was necessary to do this year. The other piece of the plan design that we looked at was our HSA contribution. So for the high deductible health plan, we do contribute to the HSA. GA benefits had presented last month and shared that we are market leading by almost four times what other employers provide for that. We are proposing that we keep that strong. It does offset the deductible for staff and helps them to save for other things that they might have coming up medically. are keeping that similar to what we've had in the past. It is going to be kind of a middle point between our $3,400 deductible and our $5,000 deductible on what we were contributing to the HSA. So we kind of tried to meet in the middle there on that. So our folks who had the $3,400 deductible plan will have a higher deductible, but they will get more in their HSA. And then our folks who had the $5,000 deductible if they move to the four thousand have a lower deductible and they get a little bit less in the HSA contribution. So we felt like that was the right thing to do and was within our budget. So that's the other piece that we're not making a huge change on. And that's kind of the reasoning behind why we're not proposing cutting that HSA contribution. And then The plan design changes that we've looked at, so I know it's kind of hard to look at those and understand exactly what the big changes are. But between the deductible and the premium, those are kind of the big things. There's some other nuances in there that I'm happy, or Cory is probably happy to talk through. But the big thing that we looked at with that is that the change shifts the increase for the PPO from 35% increase to 28% increase. And then it shifts our increase on the high deductible plans from 39 and 41.5% to 25.7%. So we're bringing that increase down even more than what Anthem had come down on our renewal. So we're going from 35 to about 27% increase across the plan. So it's kind of a way that we can help stair step that down a little bit more. The total budget that we're expecting this increasing, the total amount that we're expecting this to increase our employer budget for health insurance is $255,900. So that does remain within the budget that Gary has put forward. And we're trying to kind of balance those costs as well as the benefits for staff. So before I get into more details, So you guys have the 2027 benefit breakdown that does include all of our health insurance premium split. So that shows the total premium from Anthem for each of the plans. And then it splits it out into per pay amount so that you can see what it costs an employee per pay and what it's costing the library per pay. And again, there's just two plans this year versus three plans last year. And you can easily compare that. The paper clipped pack or the staple packet that you have is our 2026. Insurance benefits so you can look and see what those impacts are for staff across those different plans And then you also have The page that says JA benefits at the top is our current plans and then what we've chosen for renewal so you can see kind of down that side-by-side what those plans look like and then what the total cost increase is and I know it's a lot of information to digest, and I do not expect you to look at all of it and understand it all. And then the final page that you guys have is a spreadsheet that shows the total increase in budget. So we're planning on about $500,000 total increase in budget. That does include the compensation increases for next year and then the insurance increases. So that breaks everything down. by the twenty twenty six what we're currently paying and then what we're projected for twenty twenty seven and shows what the increase is and the total is down at the bottom. So it does break out some different models that we're looking at the compensation increases and then also all of our insurance packages. So you can see we stayed within the budget increase that Gary had budgeted for. And so we just wanted to give you all of that because I know it's a big a big increase and it's something that we've taken very seriously and looked at really in depth. So and then the other benefits that we have in addition to health insurance Marathon Health Clinic is one that we offer to all of our staff. So Marathon gives staff access to preventative care acute care and then prescription refills through the clinic at no cost. That's something that we offer to all staff. So regardless of our status full time or part time everyone has access to that. We did have a rate increase on that for this year. And the library, we're proposing that the library accepts that and just takes the increase on completely. So we continue to offer that benefit to staff. The increase for Marathon is 3.6%, which is really reasonable and kind of what we've seen year over year for that. Dental insurance is going to increase slightly for 2027. but we're holding the same benefits. So that goes up five percent. And then our vision insurance was on a rate hold. So that has no change this year, which is why you don't see that in the paperclip packet, but you see it in the staple packet because there's no rate changes. Guardian life and disability products. We do have an increase on our group term life. So that's the benefit that we offer to all of our full time staff. We pay group term life which is two times your annual salary and benefits if something happens and you pass away. That premium does increase by nine point zero nine percent. And that's something that's paid entirely by the library for our full time folks. And then our short-term disability, which is what pays 60% of your pay if you do fall ill or injured and unable to work for up to 12 weeks. That premium is also increasing by 6.9%. And that's something that the first $150 of that premium is paid by the library. So we anticipate the majority of that increase is going to be absorbed by the library just because of the way we have that one structured. Long-term disability does not increase, and our voluntary life in AD&D does not increase either. So I know that was a lot of information. What questions do you all have? What can I answer? What did I go over too fast? I have a question about what the contribution is to the health savings account for a full-time employee. The health savings account? I'm sorry, what's your question? Like on the benefit breakdown, it says the library contributes to the health savings account for 37.5 hours per week. Do we have a set amount that we do? Do we do a percent of salary? Yeah, so that's on the second page in that packet. I missed it. When you look at the option two, there's the HSA contribution in there. So it's a set amount if you enroll for employee only versus employee plus spouse. or employee plus child and family, those are all the same. So it's $120 per pay for employee plus and then $60 per pay for employee only. And that's only offered to folks who elect the high deductible health plan. It'd be page three. I'm sorry. I didn't realize there were page numbers at the bottom. Yeah, no, that's my bad. I printed them out and pulled something. Great job. Really great job. Thank you. And it's not just me. Mark Bryant is our payroll benefit coordinator. He has been absolutely integral in this. Corey and Alyssa at JA have been amazing. And then Gary has been wonderful on the budgeting and part of our review as well as his career. So it's definitely a team effort. on behalf of the library staff and the organization's wellness, too. Can you answer for me? I want to make sure I understand the total increase in budget of $500,000 was what was budgeted for staff for employee compensation increases as well as other increases that the library might incur over the course of this year. Do I understand that correctly, or is that where does this $500,000 budget come from and increases and what does it include? What is it intended to include? I don't even know if that's necessary, but I guess what I'm wanting to understand as to the effect that these changes in healthcare costs are affecting the library, is it correct in my understanding that if the health insurance increase is about $255,000 for next year, And the other increases to dental and other things like that are relatively nominal that it essentially represents half or a little more than half of the total increase in budget that the library will incur next year. Is that generally correct in my understanding? I'm sure there are other like library or other capital projects that are captured there, but in terms of planned budget increase. wanting to make sure I understand correctly the impact or the percentage of the health care increase and yeah. Okay. Yeah, that makes sense. Okay. Yeah, I don't need a more. There's plenty of detailed analysis here. I was just wanting to understand broad strokes, the scope, if I was understanding that correctly. So thanks. But that's a good question because this health insurance increase has a big impact on our budget. And if we want to just say, well, we'll incur all of the increases, it would push our budget way beyond the limits that we're comfortable with. And so that 500,000 was a good benchmark for us to figure out how much of this can we absorb, how much do we have to push off to staff, and so on. So that was kind of the framework in which we looked at all of this. Yeah. I wanted to just comment, I guess, that the Marathon Health amount that's paid every year, I think that's a great thing for employees. Yeah. I go to Marathon Health through my school It's so convenient, they're so good, and like you said, you get your prescriptions to a lot of your prescriptions right there. Is that, I'm a little ignorant on this, is that just something the library does as kind of like an extra option for those who, are all your employees, they're not all required to have health insurance, I guess, I would assume. I don't know how that works in other organizations besides schools, but wonderful. So we're able to offer health insurance to full time staff. So that's our folks who work 37 and a half hours or more. Our folks who work 25 hours a week, 20 hours a week and 15 to 18 hours a week. We can't offer health insurance just through the ACA. And so offering marathon health clinic as an option for them as a way for us to offer them access to medical care and prescriptions. It's no cost to them. And so it's optional for all of our staff. They're welcome to enroll for themselves and cover family members as well. And so that's a benefit that we've heard really positive things. from staff, we've done a couple of different things over the years where we've done like a rate split or we've asked folks to pay a portion of the cost, but we shifted to the library covering the full cost on that. And we feel like that's a really important benefit for, particularly for our part-time folks, but also our full-time folks who rely on the clinic for preventative care as well as acute care. I would think that's something that makes the library a great place to work, which is one of the goals. I've not heard of that in other organizations just to have that provided. But again, I don't know a lot about that. But I just think it's well worth the money for those people who aren't able to work full time or aren't able to have the health insurance that they really would like to have but can't afford at that point in their life. It's huge to me. I'm glad that the library provides that. Any other questions? Part time employees who have been here for a long time. Do they have the option of doing a health savings account. So we don't have the ability to offer a health savings account. We do offer flexible saving flexible spending accounts on FSA. So, Our folks who are not taking our health insurance and who are qualified for an FSA are eligible to participate in that. They can put money in pre-tax and use that to pay for medical costs. So you can use it for prescriptions, over-the-counter medications, like eyeglasses, contacts, dental care. And so there's a list of things you can use those funds for. And that's a way for us to continue to offer that type of a benefit to folks who aren't on a high deductible health plan. How many people, employees, do we have? do that? The FSA? Yeah. I'd have to look. It's not quite as many as you would think. I think we typically run about a dozen to two dozen folks who take advantage of that. And then we also offer dependent care FSA. So that's for folks who have dependent child or parents who are dependent on them. They can put money in and use that to pay for daycare, after school care, summer camp programs. And we have a number of staff who have really appreciated that and use that. And again, that's not that many. But to the folks that use that, it's something that's very important. OK, thanks. Thank you. Yeah. Any other questions before we take a vote? OK, all in favor of the 2027 proposal for the benefits breakdown and renewal, say aye. Those opposed, say nay. Ayes have it. If I can I just want to say that we really appreciate the board supporting benefits like this for our staff. I know it's a very large budget spend but it's something that really matters to our staff and really makes a difference on retention and just. their ability to utilize benefits and afford them. We also really appreciate J.A. benefits and all the support that they give as well as Gary for budgeting and allowing us to have funds to continue to improve benefits and absorb additional costs. And then also Mark Bryant our payroll benefit coordinator has been integral in this too. So I just want to say thank you for doing that. I know it means a lot to staff and it's something that we really appreciate. And again thanks to all of you. Thank you. Thanks. OK. Do I have a motion to hear the resolution for surplus items? So moved. So we have had a request from the Southwest branch to surplus a play kitchenette. And it's not totally useless. And I think they're looking for someone who can use it. I guess it's slightly damaged. but they're getting a new one. OK. Any questions? All in favor? Say aye. Aye. Those opposed say nay. Ayes have it. Do I have a motion to hear the gift tree sweater? So you may have noticed that out on Kirkwood at certain times of year, the trees are wrapped in lovely handmade sweaters. Well, our friends at Middleway House reached out and would like to give us one of the sweaters that was featured out in front of our Kirkwood entrance. So I'll read a little bit of what they sent us and I'll show you the sweater. Dear Mr. Carson, all of us at Middleway House appreciate the important role our library plays in the lives of families and youth. We want you to have this wrapped in love tree sweater. I've included a one-page description of the artwork and its relevance to the library and our community. We understand if you choose to use it or to alter it. one page. Our library is wrapped in love tree sweater. This tree sweater once adorned the tree in front of the MCPL as part of Bloomington's annual wrapped in love public art exhibit. From October through January each year the display shows fiber art by local volunteers wrapped around trees along Kirkwood Avenue and nearby streets. Through Tree Sweater sponsorships, the exhibit raises awareness and funds for Middle Way House. Middle Way House is a nonprofit organization that supports survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault, and human trafficking and educates the community through outreach and prevention programs. Based in Bloomington, less than a mile from our library, it offers a wide range of services across six Indiana counties, including crisis intervention, emergency shelter, legal advocacy, prevention programming, and youth development initiatives. Wrapped in love goes beyond public art and beyond philanthropy. It symbolizes our community's collective support for survivors of assault and abuse. Each tree sweater represents creativity, strength, and solidarity. And generous sponsors invest in important programs to help individuals and families seeking better lives free of mistreatment. These beautiful creations carry a powerful message of hope and resilience. So they reached out to us to offer the tree sweater, and I will show you that tree sweater now. These are a number of books, classic and otherwise. Here's Winnie the Pooh, Wizard of Oz. Pretty sure The Hobbit's on here somewhere. So we would like to accept this according to our gift policy. All gifts in kind, meaning not financial gifts, need to be reviewed and approved by the board for acceptance. And then we take it and we send an acknowledgment form to the person who gifted it. And then we do what we please. We would like to display this. somewhere in the downtown library. We don't have specific plans for it just yet. At the very least, we will be good stewards of this gift and take good care of it. But we're talking about where we might be able to display it semi-permanently, even perhaps in a glass frame of some kind. Great. Who's the artist? Is that included? Yes. Thank you. Two artists, and I'm going to mispronounce someone's name, so I apologize in advance. Anasazi Shields. and Stevie Sebold, crocheted this tree sweater in 2025. Over 100 volunteer artists ranging in age from 9 to 97 have contributed to the display since 2011. All in favor of accepting the gift tree sweater, say aye. Aye. Those opposed, say nay. Ayes have it. Next up, can I get a motion to hear about the resolution for perf renewal? I'm not going to read through the entire perf agreement just because it's lengthy, but I will pass it around for you guys to sign. Basically perf is our public employee retirement fund. This is the retirement that the library contributes to for full time folks. This is separate from the Hoosier start retirement plan that we offer for all of our staff. That is a voluntary retirement benefit. So those are two separate things. Perf is a specific retirement. plan, every year they update the percentages for the normal and supplemental rate. So the employer contribution is 11.2%. What makes that up is a normal percentage and a supplemental percentage. And then there's a 3% employee rate that goes into that as well. So it's 14.2% total. The library does pay both of those. So we do pay the employer and the employee portion to max that out for staff. So all that we have to do is sign the approval to change the normal and supplemental rates. In twenty twenty six, those rates, the normal was four point four and the supplemental was six point eight this year. The normal is five percent and the supplemental is six point two. And so this is just our adoption of their rate change on how that eleven point two percent is made up. So do we have any questions? In favor of the resolution per annual as presented, say aye. Those opposed say nay. Ayes have it. And Becky's going to continue to speak to us about the NFP compensation review. Sorry, you guys are going to be tired of me by the end of this meeting. So just kind of an informative session before we bring everything to you guys in December. In 2022, the library partnered with NFP for a full compensation and benefits review. We adopted their recommended compensation schedule for 2023, which did include a full market review of our job descriptions compared to market averages. We looked at data from Bloomington the state of Indiana national information as well as public libraries. So those four data points make up what they look out when they make those recommendations. And then we work to ensure that we stay within the 50th percentile. So they look at all of those numbers for each job description across all four data points. And then the 50th percentile means that we sit right in the middle. So we want to remain competitive and stay in that 50th percentile to be right in the middle of the pack. So we've committed to continue this work and perform regular reviews to ensure that our compensation structure remains competitive. Unfortunately, SB1 and the impact that that had on our budget last year did delay this project. But when we ensured that we made no layoffs, and completed the work that was required by SB1, we did engage NFP for the renewal project. And so we've been working with them this fall, well, summer and fall, to come up with a full review of our compensation structure. So pleased to share that the recommendation will be brought to the board in December for our wage and salary schedule to be updated accordingly to remain competitive for all of our staff members. And this project in particular include reviewing a number of specific job descriptions. So we picked 10 across our entire compensation scale that they did a full benchmarking review on. So they looked at the data points for again Bloomington the state of Indiana national as well as public libraries to ensure that our wage and salary schedule remains at the 50th percentile. So we intend to bring that new wage and salary schedule to the board in December along with the annual increases. So that number that you saw earlier includes all of that work. And then we are planning to propose a $0.75 or 3% increase for 2027. So we do whatever the greater of those two figures would be for folks. So we have a plan in place with NFP to ensure that we're continuing to make annual compensation adjustments to align with our peers and continue to stay in the 50th percentile each year. The plan is that this will be minimal increases every year just to ensure our minor increases to make sure that we kind of stay competitive with that entire wage and salary schedule that we have. We select the 50th percentile because that's the average and we do want to make sure we stay competitive with that. And then one of the other things that we looked at was if we were going to need to change jobs from one pay grade to another. And so we won't be proposing that with this wage and salary schedule. It will just be an update really on those pay ranges to move our scale up to make sure we stay at the 50th percentile. Do you have any questions or anything that I can make sure I bring next month when we present this? Thank you. OK. Thanks. Thanks. Next up, can I get a motion to hear the policy update for collection development? Hello. When doing our annual review of the collection development policy, we found that there were a few updates that we would like to bring to you for approval. You have in your packet the current collection development policy, which is also posted to the library's website. And you should also have the proposed update with the changes highlighted. And so I'll just walk through the proposed version and just point out some of the things that we're seeking to change. Under scope, we just reordered and combined sentences in the first paragraph, but the statement that the scope of our collection is as broad as possible to allow for the expression of a wide range of topics and perspectives is not new. And then in the second paragraph under scope, we added a statement about artificial intelligence in order to be clear that materials created with AI are not automatically rejected for consideration and may have a place in our collection. To echo the position statement on AI that Library Director Greer-Carson presented to the board in July of this year, MCPL will continue to evaluate materials being considered for addition to our collection in accordance with the selection criteria outlined in our collection development policy, regardless of the use of AI in the production of an item. And our selection criteria are not changing. And then under the examples of special collections, we revised the description of the Library of Things collection just to better reflect the contents in this collection. Under selection of diverse and inclusive materials, we combined sentences for clarity and emphasis. And this revision also was motivated by interest in removing any implication that marginalized groups don't already have a voice or are dependent upon others to provide them with a voice. And I'd like to acknowledge that this change was pointed out by one of our staff members who felt that it was something that really needed to be improved. And then toward the end, under interlibrary loan, we are just going to add a link to the interlibrary loan form from the website version of the policy. We have a link to our suggestions for purchase form and thought we could just go ahead and add a link to the ILL form as well. And then finally under collection, maintenance and review in the second paragraph there, we just removed the first and last sentence for brevity. Have any questions about anything? Yes. Not necessarily. Some of the online platforms that we subscribe to have started to make an effort to label materials that they have identified as being created in some way with artificial intelligence. But the print collection, the publishing industry is really still working toward figuring out how to establish a standard and at what level of use by an AI tool in the production of an item warrants it being described as created with AI. Once publishing standards are adopted, we would absolutely be eager to implement a way for our patrons to search for and recognize or have a way for themselves to identify something that has been created with AI. Right now, there's just nothing that has been established as a standard to include in a MARC record that would allow us to help our patrons see. And sometimes the information isn't even known. When an author is working with a publisher, more and more publishers are establishing contracts with authors, asking them to identify ways that they may have used AI in the production of their work. But even those contracts vary and from what I'm reading, publishers are really trying to work through the process with authors just to kind of figure out how do we assess use of AI and how do we describe it. Yes? Explain again, what was the purpose or the changes in the first highlight it's a part of the scope change where it says while collections emphasize. Was that added? The statement about the scope of our collection being as broad as possible is not new. It wasn't like a new edition. We just kind of moved a sentence from the second paragraph into the first and just kind of combined it. Yeah. All right. Anything else? Any other questions? vote. All in favor of the policy update to collection development say aye. Aye. Those opposed say nay. Ayes have it. And next we're going to continue to hear from Lisa about collection development. All right, thank you. I always appreciate the opportunity to share information with you about the work of the collection development department, the work that every member of the team does to help make a wide variety of print and digital materials available for our community to use. I'll describe some of the challenges that MCPL, that our department has faced this last year as the publishing and distribution industries continue to evolve at a rapid pace. And I will be brief in order to reserve time for my colleagues' presentations. But please don't hesitate to ask any questions that arise for you. In October of last year, MCPL learned that its primary book vendor, Baker and Taylor, which had served libraries across the country for nearly 200 years, was shutting down. MCPL was fortunate to already have accounts established with our secondary vendor, Ingram, and we were able to move our orders quickly over to Ingram and upgrade our accounts largely due to the fluency our acquisitions associate, Pam White, has with our ordering and invoicing systems and the attentiveness that she possesses for working through all the details. But this shift impacted all of the collection development staff from the selectors to the acquisitions and cataloging teams to our materials processor and our collection maintenance assistant. As we essentially needed to review workflows that had been built in part on the predictability of Baker and Taylor's delivery system. And while Ingram was really remarkably responsive to the needs that libraries across the country were facing unexpectedly, Ingram was confronted with its own learning curve for how to onboard hundreds of libraries at once and update their own staffing and workflow needs as they expanded their services. Understandably, the length of time that it took for us to receive materials from Ingram already processed with barcodes and property stamps and spine labels, that increased a little bit and we understood a need to be patient with this as, you know, they were working through all of the unexpected changes. But in some cases, we found that it was taking three to four months to receive items already in stock in one of their warehouses. And when we learned that it was the spine labels for adult print materials that seemed to be causing most of these delays, we stopped having Ingram apply the spine labels and we started investigating services that other vendors were beginning to offer to help fill the gap left by Baker and Taylor's closing. For years now, we have been ordering materials on a supplementary basis from Amazon. And in June of 2025, Amazon developed a library hub portal for libraries to use to place orders where we can download MARC records for on-order titles and more easily designate orders that are going to go to different locations in our system. This year Amazon announced its intent to start offering processing and cataloging services for libraries and in August we agreed to be a beta test library with Amazon for ordering and receiving books with the plastic jacket covers attached. This is one of the more time-consuming tasks for us to complete ourselves. And while we were able to receive some ad copies of popular titles for free, courtesy of being a beta test with Amazon, we found that only certain titles were eligible to receive the jacket covers, and ultimately the process was just not smooth enough for us to feel confident about adopting more processing services within Amazon. We've also been setting up ordering accounts with Follett, a long established book vendor specializing in services to school libraries. As schools moved to using online textbooks, Follett's sales of physical textbooks have decreased and so they find that they now have room in their warehouses for adding stock of adult materials or materials geared for adult audiences. So Fallout is expanding their services to support public libraries with a commitment to providing pre-processed materials to libraries by street date, which is the date at which libraries can make new titles available to the public for borrowing. And I'm sure it's no surprise that it takes time to onboard with a new vendor as we need to describe for them how we want to have our materials labeled and sync their ordering platform with our integrated library system so that we can easily import MARC records and invoices. And the other thing, of course, that takes time is just the familiarity that it takes for the users of a new platform to build so that our collection development librarians is there just having to learn how is this platform different from another? Where do I go to see how many titles are in stock? What is the discount rate that this platform is charging me for delivery to our system? And so they're looking out for those sorts of things in addition to just trying to figure out what is this book about and is it something that is going to appeal to people in our community while keeping all of the selection criteria in mind. Now while MCPL's selector for digital media, Brandon Rome, doesn't have to worry about the processing and delivery rates of materials, he has faced his own set of unique challenges with managing the escalating costs of e-books and digital audiobooks, while patron interest in these formats also has risen. For some time now, libraries have been at the whim of the publishers who set the licensing terms for the works that they publish. And fewer and fewer e-books and e-audiobooks are available for purchase with a permanent license permitting us to own that title into perpetuity. Typical licensing options are metered for either a one to two year time period or a certain amount of checkouts. And often publishers set the cost for e-books at almost four times higher for libraries than what they charge an individual consumer. And in some cases, publishers may decide not to license a title for public libraries to purchase at all. It could be an Amazon exclusive, not eligible to be included on the digital media platforms that we use. Or it may be a title that only can become available on a library platform after a specified time period. For example, an audiobook published by Macmillan isn't eligible for instant borrowing on Hoopla until 13 months after its release date. And similarly, an e-book published by Harlequin won't be available as a Hoopla instant title until a year after its release date. And those are just a couple examples. Each publisher works out with Hoopla the arrangement for when they can make it available as an instant title. And in some instances, publishers change the licensing and purchasing options after a title has already been released. For example, The Calamity Club by Catherine Stockett has been hugely popular and has had a long holds queue in overdrive with hundreds of people waiting to read it. When the title was first released by the publisher in May of this year, Brandon had the option to purchase 100 one-use copies for simultaneous use. And this option helps meet the demand for a blockbuster title at a more affordable and timely rate. But then a few months later, the publisher removed the simultaneous use purchase option. So when the 100 uses expired, it wasn't possible to go back and order more at that same affordable rate. And it had become prohibitively expensive to purchase enough individual copies of that title to try and meet demand. To manage the costs of borrowing digital media on Hoopla, at the start of this year, we decided to reduce the amount of monthly borrows a patron has for instant titles and increased the amount of monthly borrows a patron has for flex titles on Hoopla. While this was disappointing for some patrons seeking to borrow titles that are only offered as instant options, the new limits have helped ensure that we don't hit a daily expense cap for use of Hoopla, and it enables more patrons to have opportunity to use Hoopla. So these are just a few examples of the types of decision-making and ongoing learning that the collection development team embody in their work, and I'd like to commend the team as a whole for their fortitude and tenacity during a year that has been anything but predictable. And I'd also like to acknowledge how MCPL support for professional development truly benefits our ability to learn and adapt to changes in the work of librarianship, which ultimately benefits the community that we serve. As we look ahead to next year, we plan to continue to budget for sustainable use of digital media and development of the print collections that many patrons prefer. We're also trying to balance the high demand we see for popular blockbuster titles like Calamity Club while continuing to purchase a variety of mid-level titles that help our patrons discover new authors and series and provide the representation of subject matter that our community deserves. And we're also paying attention to how intelligent tools may be helping or inhibiting the discovery of library resources and what impact that has on the types of resources that we invest in for our community. And as always, we'll conduct our work with the aim of achieving MCPL's primary strategic goal to facilitate and support intellectual freedom for all patrons through proactive and responsive collection development. That's what happened. Thank you. I recognize the challenges that you have had with vendors and collection and I'm sorry it's been a year. I'm guessing it's going to be your new norm. Yes. Yeah Pam in particular is like boy I really would like to see a normal year but I'm not sure there is a normal year anymore. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Next up we're going to hear from Chris Jackson about outreach services. Hello, I am Chris Jackson, Manager of Outreach Services, and it's always an honor to be able to talk about what we do in the department and catch you up since I last spoke to you a year ago. Outreach is really involved in mitigating barriers to library access for people who can't make easy use of our three branches. We address barriers of language and literacy, mobility, geography, and socioeconomic status, among others. And we do it with a staff of 10 individuals, nine full-time, one part-time, myself included. And I have to say, as Lisa just did, that my staff is absolutely phenomenal. I have the most committed, engaged, and fun group of people I could possibly hope for, and they do outstanding work that I'm glad to represent here. We do this work at really seven different service points. One of them is vital our volunteers and tutoring adult learners, and I am not going to spend any time on vital because Bethany Turrentine is here and we'll do a presentation just on that one segment of outreach. Our other service points are our library van. The van service started in 2004 and is designed to meet the library needs of individuals who reside in senior living or assisted living facilities. It's sometimes confused with the bookmobile, and yes, both are trucks that haul media. The difference with van is that instead of patrons coming onto the vehicle, we take the items off on rolling carts and set them up inside the lobbies or meeting rooms of assisted care facilities and senior living so that individuals with limited mobility can still and still have quality FaceTime with library staff for readers advisory and holds and also FaceTime with each other. It's great to see the exchange of recommended books and this movie stunk. You should never watch this that goes on at our various van stops. We have 11 stops on the service and we visit each one of those every other week. Another service for people with mobility restrictions is house calls. This is often for individuals still residing at home, but no longer able to drive sometimes due to a disability or chronic illness or a variety of factors. Most of them are elderly, but not all. For these individuals, if they live anywhere in the county and can't get to one of our other service points, we will make a monthly delivery to them in their home, bringing them anything that checks out from the library and extending the due dates for that month-long period. A lot of these individuals are also pretty socially isolated, and although we don't advertise it, a friendly face, spending time even though it's just once a month and even though it may only be 10 to 20 minutes is often a very welcome quality of life enhancing engagement for some of these individuals. We currently have about 75 people on the service and we visit one fourth of them each Friday so over the course of a month we visit everybody on the service once. We also spend a lot of time on the phone with them. I was just noticing on the phone tree here that Caitlin Doherty, one of our House Calls folks, has her own line because because she's getting constant phone calls. Just thought that was a little curiosity there. Next up, I'd like to talk about our jail service. This is a... partnership with the Monroe County Correctional Center. They provide us with a budget of $8,000 a year that we spend on their behalf to stock and do collection development on their library. And in addition to stocking the library, we also do circulation from it three days a week. So a member of our staff is over there Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday afternoons for two hours each day, circulating the materials, providing readers advisory, and taking requests for future visits. We also supplement the collection that they purchased with a lot of donations given to us by the Friends of the Library Bookstore for which we're really grateful. Not surprisingly, this service is extremely popular among the incarcerated population. If you can imagine being under lock and key for hours and hours, having a way to spend that time with a good quality book, whether it's recreational or educational or self-improvement, is greatly appreciated. The staff and the jail administration are also really grateful. I don't think they can spend $8,000 more effectively to improve the safety and security, their main priorities by giving the incarcerated a way to spend their time. We also have a variety of programming services that we do in my department. At the bottom end of the age range spectrum, we have preschool services. We have an early literacy librarian, Libby Pennington, who visits each of the Head Start classrooms in the county, and there are currently, I think, 17. She visits each of those as well as The Nest at New Hope on a monthly basis to do early literacy story times and other early literacy activities to turn these young preschoolers into engaged readers by the time they get to school. and she also drops off a collection of materials that stays in that classroom for a month until her visit the following month where she rotates in a new set. We also offer that that collection drop off to the larger daycares in the county and as her time permits she does one-off programs at those daycares upon request. At the other end of the H spectrum, in addition to our van service and house call service, we do have an adult programming librarian, Jen Hoffman, who visits many of the same locations and indeed more than where the van goes to do book clubs and book talks and a variety of craft activities for our older residents who aren't able to come and enjoy the great programs that we offer here at our branches. And then one other program we do with both the jail and Jen Hoffman is Read to Me. This is a partnership with New Leaf New Life where we record incarcerated parents reading aloud from a book that they choose and then we share a copy of that recording and a free copy of the book that we give to the child of the incarcerated parent for them to keep. We do the distribution of that and the collection development of those giveaway books and New Leaf New Life does the actual recordings. And then finally, I want to talk about Bookmobile, which is, other than Vital, our most visible program. Also the hardest for me to talk about because I told you last year that we would have a new bookmobile by I think I was saying May at the latest of last year. Unfortunately, we do not yet have a new bookmobile. We still have a 16-year-old vehicle that for the last two years has had no heat or air conditioning, making it very trying for both staff and patrons to provide the service. Unfortunately, there is no bookmobile dealer who has vehicles on the lot where you pick out your color and options and drive it off. They're all custom made. It is a long process. We started it well over a year ago by coming up with our own specs. working with a consultant, going out to bid, selecting the best vendor. The vendor we chose is a fairly new player who was not in the market last time we bought a bookmobile 16 years ago, but they are very well respected and we are glad to be working with them. There have been a number of holdups that are not really their fault, matters mostly beyond their control, and they are still waiting to get the body that has been attached to the chassis to their shop so they can put in the shelves. power systems in the HVAC, which we desperately need, and all the other things that turn basically a UPS truck into a bookmobile, they do assure us that they will take delivery of it as far as they know the day after tomorrow, in which case they need six weeks to turn a truck shell into a book truck. But with the holidays, I'm now expecting January is the earliest that we can accept delivery. And having had so many delays, I can't say it's not impossible that we will have even more. We're stocked up on hand warmers, and we might want that tree wrap as a blanket to carry with us. I can't say enough for how hardy my staff have been under really trying working conditions. We have had to cancel when temperatures have been up in the 90s. We will cancel when temperatures get really frigid, but we try to do that as little as possible because we have people who are really dependent on us for library services that really mean a lot to them, and it means a lot for us to deliver it. So I have to, again, commend my staff for putting up with some really trying conditions. And we can't wait until the new Bookmobile is here. And when it is, we'll have various promotional activities and tours. So if you're not able to get on any of those contact me I'll be happy to show it off either here in the garage or out on one of the routes we're super excited about it finally finally coming so that's all I have any questions I'd be happy to answer hoping for a mild December and next up we're gonna hear from Bethany Turrentine for vital services I think somewhere I have some slides. Oh, right there. Thanks, Mara. There it is. All right. Thank you so much for having me. Tonight I'm going to be sharing some information from our 2025 annual report. Since we do this update so late in the year that does feel a little bit dated. So I'll give some current context as well. So you have a real time feel for where things are standing. So in terms of services, VITAL continues to provide educational opportunities for adult basic literacy, as well as English as a new language, including adults who are studying for the driver's license, citizenship, and high school equivalency tests. Of those services, English as a New Language continues by far to be the most requested service with about 95% of students participating in that program and about 5% of students who are native English speakers working on reading skills ranging from basic phonics skills up to high school reading and writing skills. In 2025, we served about 287 students. That is down a little bit from the previous year, which was 303 students, and we are continuing to see that number trend down slightly this year. It's pretty likely that that is a result of changes at the federal level to immigration policy. That impacts not only the number of people who are able to come into the country, but also people who are currently here having limited access to workforce authorization. So with those challenges, it just makes it much more difficult for adults to participate in educational opportunities. So given those circumstances, we are always looking for ways to decrease barriers and increase opportunities. And that's why the one-on-one tutoring continues to be such a really important option for students who want to participate. It is by far the most flexible opportunity in terms of location and timing, really allowing students who might not have an opportunity elsewhere. A brief example, a student recently contacted us. She has been in the US for about two years. She's never studied English, just picked up from daily life. She works as a nail tech and she works from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. every day including Sundays 12 to 6. She cannot get to the library during open hours. So I said we'll see what we can do. And we did, we figured out there's a cafe nearby, there's a tutor who's got a car, and they're gonna meet there after hours. So this option truly does make a difference for folks. Which is why I'm really, really excited to see this number from last year. This is a massive increase. The 167 students participating in one-on-one tutoring. The previous year, it was 96. So that is something we put a lot of energy into. I think that change can really be attributed to continuing to fine tune our volunteer training, getting volunteers in quickly, and reducing student wait list time. So we are hoping that that does continue in the next year, that increase in students participating in tutoring. We also offer the option for English language groups. We run five eight-week sessions throughout the year. These are drop-in programs that are hosted by nine of our most seasoned vital volunteers who have been with us for over 10 years, as well as hosted by vital staff. So far, the English language groups have offered over 300 hours of free conversational practice, while also creating a safe space for social connection and exploration of different cultures and cultural norms and language. In terms of volunteers, we did see an increase of volunteers last year, up from 93 the previous year to 115 in 2025. That number also includes 41 new volunteers trained, which is actually a rather heroic accomplishment. In May of this year, our Canvas site went down in the big data breach. And most K-12 and university programs got their Canvas back. Our free for teachers was gone. So we had to very quickly pivot, figure out a new platform. We've moved all of our training content to a WordPress site. It's actually a better option for us. It offers more flexibility and creativity in terms of how we process that. But I really want to give a huge thank you to the vital team of Mick Breeze and Kyla Wargle, who worked so quickly and efficiently to get that up and running. The training went down in May, and we were back up and running in the WordPress site in July. So minimal disruption is possible to keep things moving. We continue to keep an eye on the reading level of all of our students. And looking big picture, in the previous year about 45% of students who are participating in tutoring were reading at or below a kindergarten or first grade level. On the other side of things, only about 20% of students were reading at or above a fifth grade level. This is where the vital collection continues to be such an important part of the work we do. It's an incredible treasure. We will host library programs who are interested in starting their own literacy programs, and they'll take a tour. Rather overwhelmed by the options that we have and have to remind them like you can start small. We are coming into our 50th year. This is vitals 49th year of service. So we've had a long time to develop and maintain and support that collection. And it really is important when students are struggling with limitations of time that they do have opportunities for practice outside of the classroom. So having those high-low books, having those read-alongs, we also recently added circulating flashcards to the collection so people can study those at home. It's a huge part of the services that we offer. We were also really pleased to add on a new service this year. If you go to the public service desk, there are, available on an iPad, Fire Lingo translation services. So Fire Lingo, this is a partnership with a local startup company. We've just completed our one year of service with them, and you can kind of see our interactions throughout the year. This translation tech is more sophisticated than something like a Google Translate. The translation is more nuanced and also the interface is very easy to use. And our hope is that by offering this proactively, patrons don't have to ask, it's just there for them, that it really sends the message that we see you, we are glad you are here, and that we want to help. Translation tablets support 12 different languages, including the ones most commonly seen in our community. The highest used are Spanish and Chinese. So far this year it's been used 230 times. That's about 18 conversations every month. And it really is a huge conversation booster or confidence booster for both the staff and the patron to really feel like we can provide an in-depth discussion about services, answer questions, and really feel like we've provided limited English speakers with the same level of service that we do our native English speakers. So it's currently available at all the desks downtown as well as Southwest. There was previously a tablet at Ellitsville that wasn't getting as much use, so we've transitioned it to Southwest thinking there will be a greater usage at that location. It offers 12 languages, yeah, yeah. And parallel, yeah, so those, Spanish and Chinese are the highest ones. And they're actually adding languages continually, so it's currently 12, but they will continue to add throughout the year. Is there signage in the library or at information desk that these are available? There's a door cling on the door that says welcome in the languages that are all represented on the tablets. Yeah, yeah. And parallel to that, we've actually just developed. These are hot off the press. This is a new multilingual flyer that we are hoping to share with our students with the idea being that people who are already familiar with VITAL, who understand that the library is a safe space, will share these out with their families, friends, and communities, encouraging additional folks to enjoy the space that the library offers. And lastly, I do have some pictures to share with you and also a huge thank you to our facilities team who gave us a much needed renovation to the vital office this summer. I don't think the space had been touched much since we moved in there in the 90s. And it showed. These were looking a little bit dated. So we've got a fresh coat of paint that really features the beautiful vital blue palette. We've got new furniture, new chairs in the meeting rooms, as well as new tables that are on wheels and can be moved around to different configurations for different service styles. Storage, both for staff, so we're not climbing up on ladders, but also a beautiful hutch for our volunteers, so all the materials they need for tutoring are well organized. and some additional new signage. We now have a digital screen that takes the place of what we had previously in terms of print flyers, providing some welcoming photos about people doing vital activities, as well as some visual imagery to depict the work that we do in that space. The space is really well used. We average about 163 meetings every month. So you're welcome to come in and visit us any time. And we are looking forward to sharing news about our 50th celebration with you next year. Do you have any questions for me? Glad to do it. Thanks so much. Okay, any additional comments from the board? All right, is there a motion to adjourn? Second. Motion approved, meeting adjourned.